Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 18.03.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 04.05.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 04.05.2026
+
W.P.(C) 4705/2018 & CM APPL. 20533/2023, CM APPL.
47780/2023, CM APPL. 10838/2024, CM APPL. 16042/2024
GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI & ORS
.....Petitioners
Through: Ms. Avnish Ahlawat, SC along
with Mr. Nitesh Kumar Singh,
Ms. Aliza Alam and Mr.
Mohnish Sehrawat, Advs.
versus
DR. H.C GUPTA
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Kirtiman Singh, Sr. Adv.
along with Mr. Ritwik Saha,
Mr. Shaurya Shyam and Mr.
Maulik Khurana, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J. :
1.
Through the present Writ Petition, the Government of NCT of
Delhi [hereinafter referred to as „GNCTD‟] has invoked jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, seeking to quash orders
dated 16.02.2016 and 19.03.2018 [hereinafter referred to as
„Impugned Orders‟] passed by the learned Central Administrative
Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi [hereinafter referred to as „the
Tribunal‟] in O.A. No.4303/2014 and C.P. No.89/2017, respectively.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
2.
The Tribunal, while passing the Impugned Orders, proceeded
on the premise that the Respondent was entitled to regularization from
the date of initial appointment, i.e., 1998, and consequently held that
the grant of regularisation with effect from 07.10.2008 did not amount
to full compliance of its earlier directions, thereby directing GNCTD
to effect complete compliance in those terms.
3.
During the course of hearing, learned Counsel representing
GNCTD has raised a short and crisp question for adjudication,
namely, whether an ad hoc employee, in the absence of applicable
statutory rules and regulations, can claim regularization from the date
of his initial ad hoc appointment.
FACTUAL MATRIX:
4.
In order to appreciate the controversy involved in the present
case, it is necessary to briefly advert to the relevant facts.
5.
The Tibbia College Act, 1952 [hereinafter referred to as „TC
Act‟] was enacted and regulations were framed under the TC Act,
whereunder the College was managed by an autonomous body with its
own service conditions, including provisions relating to confirmation
of temporary employees. The TC Act was subsequently repealed by
the Tibbia College (Takeover) Act, 1997 [hereinafter referred to as
„Takeover Act‟], pursuant to which the management of the College
stood vested in GNCTD with effect from 30.04.1998, and the
Ayurveda and Unani Tibbia College was formally taken over in May
1998.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
6.
Thereafter, a recruitment notice dated 07.07.1998 was issued
inviting applications for the post of Lecturer in various streams,
including Kaya Chikitsa (Ayurvedic Medicine), on ad hoc basis in the
regular pay scale, pursuant to which the Respondent applied, was
selected, and came to be appointed on ad hoc basis on 21.09.1998.
7.
In the year 2002, the Recruitment Rules, 2002 [hereinafter
referred to as „2002 RR‟] were notified. Thereafter, the Respondent
filed O.A. No.1479/2003 before the Tribunal seeking regularization
on the basis of the Recruitment Rules of 1985 [hereinafter referred to
as „1985 RR‟], which came to be dismissed on 01.04.2004. Aggrieved
thereby, the Respondent preferred W.P.(C) No.10920/2004, wherein
this Court, while issuing notice, granted a stay on the operation of the
Tribunal‟s order vide order dated 13.07.2004.
8.
In October 2005, the Union Public Service Commission
[hereinafter referred to as „UPSC‟] issued a recruitment notice for 18
posts of Lecturer (Ayurveda) under the Directorate of Indian System
of Medicine & Homeopathy („ISM&H‟) for Tibbia College, to be
filled through direct recruitment. Pursuant thereto, the Petitioners
forwarded a requisition to UPSC for making recommendations against
18 posts of Ayurveda Lecturers and 16 posts of Unani Lecturers.
9.
Thereafter, vide Cabinet Decision No.1139 dated 20.11.2006,
approval was accorded for the constitution of the Delhi Health Service
[hereinafter referred to as „DHS‟]. In furtherance thereof, an Office
Memorandum („OM‟) dated 18.12.2006 was issued providing for the
constitution of DHS for practitioners of the Allopathy system,
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
envisaging creation of Public Health sub-cadres with initial
constitution to be drawn from two sources, namely: (a) officers of the
Central Health Service („CHS‟) stream serving in Delhi who opted to
be part of the new service; and (b) those appointed on the advice of
the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare („MoHFW‟) on ad
hoc/contract basis from 1995–96 onwards against ex-cadre posts.
10.
Subsequently, on 06.05.2008, a Cabinet Note was prepared
proposing regularization of ad hoc/contract teachers as part of the
initial constitution of the service, subject to (i) satisfactory work and
conduct, (ii) vigilance clearance, and (iii) satisfactory assessment by
UPSC. The said proposal was approved vide Cabinet Decision
No.1403 dated 12.05.2008, whereby it was decided to recommend the
cases of 20 ad hoc/contract teachers of the Indian System of Medicine
(„ISM‟) stream, including the Respondent, to UPSC for regularization
on the aforesaid terms.
11.
Pursuant thereto, an OM dated 07.10.2008 was issued by the
Department of Health and Family Welfare („DoHFW‟) stipulating that
such regularization would form part of the initial constitution of the
service and would be subject to approval by UPSC. In view of the said
development, the Respondent withdrew W.P.(C) No.10920/2004 with
liberty to seek appropriate remedies in the event the decision dated
07.10.2008 was not taken to its logical conclusion.
12.
On 08.09.2011, the Respondent was re-designated as Associate
Professor in his existing pay scale as a stop-gap arrangement, with a
specific stipulation that such re-designation would not confer any right
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
to promotion or regular appointment. A similar order came to be
issued on 27.09.2012.
13.
Thereafter, on 03.05.2013, the Delhi Health Service – Teaching
Cadre of Indian System of Medicine (Ayurveda and Unani) Rules,
2013 [hereinafter referred to as „2013 DHS Rules‟] were notified.
Rule 6 and Rule 9 thereof read as under:
“6. Initial Constitution of the Service.(i) All the officers appointed on regular basis in the Ayurvedic and
Unani Tibbia College, Delhi on or before the commencement of these
rules will be deemed to have been appointed under these rules and
they will be members of the service at the entry grade.
(ii) The regular continuous service of officers referred to in sub-rule
(1) before the commencement of these rules will count for the purpose
of promotion, qualifying service for promotion confirmation and
pension in the service.
(iii) The suitability of all the officers who are appointed on adhoc
/contract basis upto 2003 in Ayurveda and Unani Tibbia College and
are continuing in service till day and possess requisite educational
qualifications and experience prescribed for the post of lecturer
(Ayurveda/ Unani) now re-designated as Assistant Professor
(Ayurveda/Unani) as per CCIM norms shall be assessed by the
commission and being found fit, they shall be deemed to have been
appointed under these rules and they shall be members of the service
at the entry level at initial constitution stage from the date of the
issuance of Office Memorandum No. F. DISMH/1/07/79/AY/553-566
dated 07-10-2008.
***
9. Seniority.The seniority of members of the service appointed to a grade at the
time of initial constitution of the service under Rule 6, will be as
obtaining on the date of commencement of these rules in the following
manner:(i) For the members appointed under Rule 6 (i) if the seniority of any
such member had not been specifically determined: on the said date,
the same will be determined on the basis of the rules governing the
fixation of seniority as were applicable to the members of the service
prior to the commencement of these rules
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
(ii) The seniority of officers recruited to, other than those appointed
under Rule 6(i) will be determined in accordance with the orders
issued by the Government in the matter from time to time.
(iii) The seniority of persons recruited to the service in accordance
with sub rule (v) of Rule 4 will be fixed in the manner provided
therein.
(iv) In cases not covered by the above provisions, seniority will be
determined by the Government in consultation with the commission.
(v) The protection, if any accorded in towards increments drawn by
doctors who worked on contract/adhoc basis prior to placement at the
initial constitution stage shall not be taken into account for
determining the length of service or seniority for consideration, for
promotion on time scale basis subsequent to their placement at the
initial constitution stage.”
14.
After making various representations, the Respondent filed
O.A. No.4303/2014 before the Tribunal seeking regularization in
terms of the Cabinet decision dated 12.05.2008 and the 2013 DHS
Rules, along with grant of seniority from the date of his initial
appointment in the year 1998. In the said OA, the Respondent, inter
alia, prayed for the following reliefs:
“6. The applicant, therefore, prayed for the following reliefs:(a) Direct the respondents to regularize the applicant in view of
the Cabinet decision dated 12.05.2008 and office order dated
07.10.2008 and grant seniority from the date of initial
appointment and to take necessary steps for the same.
(b) Direct the respondents to include and consider the case of
the applicant in the list sent for DPC for the post of Associate
Professor.
(c) Hold and declare that no promotion that no promotion to the
post of Associate Professor can be made without considering the
case of the applicant for the post of Associate Professor
reckoning his seniority from September, 1998.
(d) Direct respondents to take immediate steps in terms of the
Recruitment Rules, 2013 for constitution of initial cadre to
regularize applicant from initial date of appointment and also to
grant all benefits including seniority from initial date of
appointment being September 1998.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
(e) To pass any other order and/or direction as this Hon'ble
Tribunal may deem fit and appropriate.”
15.
In
response,
GNCTD
submitted
that
the
process
of
regularization was underway and that the UPSC would complete the
requisite assessment. Vide order dated 16.02.2016, the Tribunal
allowed O.A. No.4303/2014 and directed convening of a Department
Promotion Committee („DPC‟) to consider regularization of the
applicants in service from the date of their initial appointment within a
period of three months. However, the said directions were not
complied with. Consequently, the Respondents initiated the contempt
proceedings.
16.
Thereafter, on 15.06.2017, an Assessment Board convened by
UPSC considered the case of the Respondent along with other
candidates for regularization under Rule 6(iii) of the 2013 DHS Rules,
and vide recommendation dated 20.06.2017, found the Respondent
suitable for appointment as a member of the service at the entry level
from the stage of initial constitution. The said recommendation was
accepted by the Lieutenant Governor of GNCTD, and accordingly,
vide order dated 16.10.2017, the services of the Respondent were
regularized with effect from 07.10.2008.
17.
In the contempt proceedings instituted by the Respondent, the
Tribunal, vide order dated 19.03.2018, held that its earlier direction
required regularization from the date of initial appointment (1998),
whereas GNCTD had granted regularization only with effect from
07.10.2008, and consequently directed compliance within a period of
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
four weeks. Aggrieved thereby, the present Writ Petition has been
filed.
18.
Counter Affidavit and Rejoinder have been filed by the
Respondent and the Petitioner, respectively.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES:
19.
This Court has heard learned Counsel for the parties at length
and, with their assistance, perused the material placed on record.
20.
Learned Counsel representing the Petitioner, placing reliance on
Rule 6(iii) of the 2013 DHS Rules, submits that the Respondent has
been rightly regularized with effect from 07.10.2008 as part of the
initial constitution of the service, and that no claim for regularization
or seniority can be sustained from the date of his ad hoc appointment.
21.
Per contra, learned Counsel representing the Respondent
submits that:
i.
The Respondent was appointed in 1998 pursuant to a
recruitment notice and recommendation of the Staff Selection
Commission („SSC‟) through an open and transparent selection
process.
ii.
Even the Cabinet Note dated 06.05.2008 acknowledges that the
Respondent was selected by a duly constituted committee in
accordance with the recruitment rules prevailing at the time, and thus
cannot be termed a backdoor entrant. Reliance is placed upon the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
judgments in Jaggo v. Union of India & Ors.1; Vinod Kumar & Ors.
v. Union of India & Ors.2; and Dharam Singh & Ors. v. State of
Uttar Pradesh & Anr.3.
iii.
The services of the Respondent were governed by valid
recruitment rules, namely the 1985 RR and subsequently the 2002 RR.
Since the Respondent underwent a selection process and was
appointed in terms of the Recruitment Rules in vogue at the time of
his appointment, his appointment shall be regular as on the date of his
appointment. Reliance is placed upon the judgment rendered in K.
Raghupathi v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors.4
iv.
The Respondent is, therefore, entitled to seniority from the date
of his initial appointment on ad hoc basis, the same being substantive
in nature. Reliance is placed upon the judgment of the Supreme Court
in G.P. Doval & Ors. v. Chief Secretary, Govt. of Uttar Pradesh &
Ors.5.
v.
Where substantive posts are filled in accordance with the
procedure known to law, the length of service ought to be reckoned
from the date of initial appointment, including for the purposes of
pensionary benefits, particularly as the Respondent has since
superannuated on 30.11.2020. Reliance is placed upon the judgments
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826
(2024) 9 SCC 327
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1735
(2022) 6 SCC 346
(1984) 4 SCC 329
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
in Baleshwar Dass & Ors. v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors.6; and
Ramesh K. Sharma & Anr. v. Rajasthan Civil Services & Ors.7
vi.
The Respondent is entitled to pensionary benefits for a
qualifying service to be calculated from his initial appointment.
Reliance is placed upon the judgment of this Court in Govt. of NCT of
Delhi & Anr. v. Dr. Yoginder Gupta & Anr. in W.P.(C)
No.1265/2018 and other connected matters.
22.
No other submissions have been made on behalf of the learned
Counsel representing the parties.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
23.
The short question that arises for consideration in the present
case is whether an employee appointed on ad hoc basis can claim
regularization from the date of his initial appointment, in the absence
of any statutory rules or provisions permitting such retrospective
regularization.
24.
From a reading of the Impugned Order dated 16.02.2016 passed
by the Tribunal, it becomes evident that the Tribunal has not given
any reason for issuing a direction to convene a DPC to consider the
process of regularization of the Respondent from the date of his initial
appointment. The Tribunal has neither examined the Rule 6(iii) nor
referred to any rule or regulation in support of such a direction. Such
an approach of the Tribunal is not in accordance with law. Once the
Respondent had specifically relied upon the service rules, the Tribunal
(1980) 4 SCC 226
(2001) 1 SCC 637
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
was expected to examine the matter in the light of the applicable
statutory framework.
25.
At the outset, it is necessary to examine the appointment letter
issued to the Respondent on 21.09.1998. It is specifically provided
therein that the Respondent was appointed to the post of Lecturer
(Ayurveda) in Kaya Chikitsa on a purely temporary and ad hoc basis.
Clause 1 of the appointment letter provides that the appointment was
purely on ad hoc basis for a period of six months or till a regular
appointment is made, whichever is earlier.
26.
The said appointment letter was issued pursuant to the
recruitment notice dated 07.07.1998, which specifically invited
applications for various teaching posts on ad hoc basis in the regular
pay scale. Once the recruitment notice as well as the appointment
letter clearly provided that the Respondent was appointed on ad hoc
basis, it was not appropriate for the Tribunal to hold that he would be
treated as having been appointed on a regular basis from the date of
his appointment in the absence of any rules, regulations, or
instructions to that effect.
27.
The concept of regularization of service is to regularize
irregular appointments in accordance with the applicable rules. The
Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Secretary, State of
Karnataka & Ors. v. Uma Devi & Ors.8 has clearly held that
regularization must be strictly governed by rules, regulations, or
instructions issued by the Government, as any such regularization
(2006) 4 SCC 1
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
otherwise would deprive eligible candidates of the opportunity to
compete for appointment.
28.
In the present case, the Respondent was admittedly appointed
on ad hoc basis pursuant to a recruitment notice which itself
contemplated only a temporary engagement. In the absence of any
statutory rules at the relevant time permitting regularization from the
date of initial appointment, the Respondent cannot claim retrospective
regularization dehors the subsequently framed statutory scheme.
29.
When a recruitment notice is issued for filling up posts on ad
hoc basis, many interested candidates may not choose to apply
because of the uncertainty with regard to the tenure of appointment.
Hence, the submission of learned Counsel for the Respondent that the
appointment was made against a substantive post after following the
procedure known to law cannot be accepted.
30.
Further, learned Counsel for the Respondent has placed reliance
upon the judgments rendered in Jaggo (supra), Vinod Kumar (supra),
and Dharam Singh (supra) to contend that the Respondent was
appointed through a valid selection process and cannot be treated as a
backdoor entrant.
31.
This Court has considered the aforesaid judgments. The same
do not advance the case of the Respondent. The said decisions were
rendered in the context of appointments where, despite the initial
nature of engagement, the incumbents were appointed pursuant to a
recognized selection process and continued in service under
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
circumstances where the Courts found it appropriate to extend certain
protections in the absence of a governing statutory bar.
32.
In the present case, however, the Respondent was appointed
pursuant to a recruitment notice which itself contemplated only an ad
hoc engagement for a limited duration, and the appointment letter
expressly stipulated that the engagement was purely temporary and ad
hoc, for a period of six months or till a regular appointment was made,
whichever was earlier.
33.
More importantly, the present case is governed by a specific
statutory framework, namely the 2013 DHS Rules, which provide for
regularization only as part of the initial constitution of the service and
from a specified date, i.e., 07.10.2008. The aforesaid judgments do not
deal with a situation where a statutory rule expressly governs the
manner and date of regularization. The mere fact that a selection
process was undertaken would not, by itself, alter the expressly ad hoc
nature of the appointment in the face of a governing statutory scheme.
Accordingly, the reliance placed thereon is misplaced.
34.
This Court now turns to the Cabinet Note dated 06.05.2008. A
careful reading thereof shows that regularization was proposed only as
a part of the initial constitution of the service and that too subject to
certain conditions, namely: (i) satisfactory work and conduct, (ii)
vigilance clearance, and (iii) assessment by UPSC. The said proposal
was approved on 12.05.2008.
35.
Thereafter, in exercise of powers under Article 309 of the
Constitution of India, the 2013 DHS Rules were notified. The
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
expression “initial constitution of the service” has been specifically
explained in Rule 6, which has already been extracted hereinabove.
36.
The case of the Respondent clearly falls under Rule 6(iii),
which provides that candidates appointed on ad hoc basis up to the
specified period, who are continuing in service and possess the
requisite educational qualifications and experience, shall have their
suitability assessed by UPSC and, on being found fit, shall be deemed
to have been appointed under the Rules and shall become members of
the service at the entry level from the date of issuance of the OM
dated 07.10.2008.
37.
A plain reading of Rule 6(iii) makes it clear that the statutory
scheme itself creates a legal fiction whereby such ad hoc appointees,
upon being found suitable, are deemed to have been appointed under
the Rules only from the date of initial constitution, i.e., 07.10.2008.
The Rule consciously does not provide for regularization from the
date of initial appointment. Therefore, any claim for regularization
from an earlier date would run contrary to the express mandate of the
statutory rules.
38.
Thus, the service rules clearly mandate that regularization
would take effect from 07.10.2008 and not from the date of initial
appointment on ad hoc basis. The Respondent has not challenged the
constitutional validity of Rule 6(iii), and in the absence of any such
challenge, the Tribunal could not have issued a direction contrary to
the statutory rules.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
39.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent has further placed reliance
upon K. Raghupathi (supra) to contend that since the Respondent was
appointed in accordance with the recruitment rules prevailing at the
relevant time, his appointment ought to be treated as regular from the
date of initial appointment. This Court has considered the aforesaid
judgment. The same does not advance the case of the Respondent, as
it pertains to a situation where, despite the nomenclature of the
appointment being contractual, the candidates were subjected to a fullfledged selection process and were extended benefits and service
conditions akin to those applicable to regularly appointed employees.
The appointments in the said case, therefore, were not purely ad hoc
in nature. In contrast, the Respondent in the present case was
appointed on a purely ad hoc basis, as is evident from both the
recruitment notice and the appointment letter, which clearly stipulated
the temporary nature of the engagement.
40.
More importantly, as already noted, the field in the present case
is governed by the 2013 DHS Rules. In view of this statutory scheme,
any claim for regularization from an earlier date cannot be sustained
on the basis of general principles laid down in the aforesaid judgment,
which is therefore distinguishable on facts as well as in law.
41.
It is also relevant to note that the Respondent had earlier filed
O.A. No.1479/2003 before the Tribunal seeking regularization under
the 1985 RR, which came to be dismissed on 01.04.2004. Though the
Respondent had filed a Writ Petition against the said order, the same
was subsequently withdrawn. Consequently, the decision of the
Tribunal declining regularization under the 1985 RR attained finality.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
At the cost of repetition, the Tribunal has not adverted to these crucial
aspects.
42.
The Tribunal has also erred in observing that the Respondent
was appointed prior to the takeover of the College. The record clearly
shows that the College was taken over in May 1998 pursuant to the
decision dated 30.04.1998 under the provisions of the Takeover Act.
The recruitment notice dated 07.07.1998 was issued by GNCTD itself,
and the Respondent was selected only in September 1998. The finding
recorded by the Tribunal, therefore, suffers from a factual error.
43.
It is also pertinent to note that, as per Clause (d) contained in
the prayer portion of the O.A., the Respondent himself had prayed for
regularization in terms of the 2013 DHS Rules, though he
simultaneously sought regularization from the date of initial
appointment. Such a relief is not envisaged under the 2013 DHS
Rules.
44.
While filing the O.A., the Respondent had also prayed for grant
of seniority from the date of his initial appointment. This aspect has
not been specifically examined by the Tribunal. This Court has
examined the relevant service rules. Rule 9 of the 2013 DHS Rule
governs the seniority of members of the service. The same has been
reproduced hereinabove.
45.
The case of the Respondent would fall under Rule 9(ii), as he is
not covered under Rule 6(i) and has entered the service as part of the
initial constitution under Rule 6(iii). Rule 9(ii) provides that the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
seniority of such officers shall be determined in accordance with the
orders issued by the Government from time to time.
46.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent has placed reliance upon
G.P. Doval (supra) to contend that the Respondent is entitled to
seniority from the date of his initial appointment. The said judgment is
distinguishable, as it pertains to appointments made against
substantive vacancies where the incumbents were treated as members
of the service. In the present case, however, the Respondent was
appointed on a purely ad hoc basis. Further, seniority is specifically
governed by Rule 9 of the 2013 DHS Rules, and the Respondent,
being covered under Rule 6(iii), cannot claim seniority from the date
of his initial ad hoc appointment.
47.
Additionally, learned Counsel has also relied upon Baleshwar
Dass (supra) and Ramesh K. Sharma (supra) to contend that the
entire length of service ought to be reckoned from the date of initial
appointment. The said judgments, however, relate to appointments
against substantive posts and do not deal with a statutory framework
such as the 2013 DHS Rules. In the present case, Rule 6(iii) creates a
legal fiction whereby regularization takes effect only from
07.10.2008. In view thereof, the reliance placed upon the aforesaid
judgments is misplaced.
48.
Further, in the facts of the present case, it would be appropriate
to direct the Government to determine the Respondent‟s seniority in
accordance with Rule 9(ii), while leaving it open to the Respondent to
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
challenge the same in accordance with law, if so advised. Such a
decision shall be taken within a period of two (02) months.
49.
The last submission of learned Counsel for the Respondent
relates to counting the entire length of service from the date of initial
appointment for the purpose of pensionary benefits. It has been
contended that the issue stands covered by the judgment in Dr.
Yoginder Gupta (supra).
CONCLUSION:
50.
As already noticed, when the O.A. was filed, the Respondent
was still in service and has since superannuated during the pendency
of the present Writ Petition.
51.
It would not be appropriate for this Court to adjudicate this
issue in the present Writ Petition arising out of the order of the
Tribunal. However, GNCTD is directed to take an appropriate
decision regarding the Respondent‟s entitlement to pensionary
benefits in accordance with law, within a period of three months after
the issue of regularization and seniority is decided. Needless to note,
such consideration shall be uninfluenced by any observations made
herein on the issue of regularization.
52.
Consequently, the present Writ Petition is partly allowed. The
directions issued by the Tribunal with regard to regularization of the
Respondent from the date of his initial appointment on ad hoc basis
are set aside.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
53.
The present Writ Petition is disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
All pending applications stand closed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
MAY 04, 2026
s.godara/shah
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
12:33:32
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review