Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment reserved on: 12.05.2026
Judgment delivered on: 11.08.2026
%
+
LPA 554/2025 & CM APPLs. 54807-10/2025
GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Sameer Vashisht, SC, Civil,
GNCTD with Ms. Harshita Nathrani
and Mr. Aryaman Vachher, Advs.
Versus
NORTH EAST TRIBAL WELFARE
SOCIETY (REGD.)
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Sumit Bansal, Sr. Adv. with Mr.
Omprakash, Mr. Rajeev Pathak, Ms.
Tulna Rampal and Ms. Nikita Gupta,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
JUDGMENT
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, C.J.
1.
This instant intra-court appeal seeks to assail the validity of the order
dated 26.05.2023 passed by learned Single Judge, whereby W.P.(C)
2257/2018 instituted by the respondent, has been allowed and a direction has
been issued that the land in question, i.e. 1/5 th share of the land situated in
Khasra no. 24/6/1/2 (0-18), 24/15/2 (1-12), 13/29 (0-3), 25/10/2 (0-15),
25/11 (4-16), 25/12 (1-14), 25/20/1 (0-8) and 25/20/2 (3-18) in the Revenue
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
Estate of Village Goela Khurd, South-West District, New Delhi, be handed
over to the respondent.
2.
Heard the learned Counsel for the parties and perused the records
available before us on this appeal. So far as the legal issues which arise in
this appeal are concerned, the same has been decided by us vide judgment
and order dated 11.08.2026 delivered by us today in LPA 34/2024,
Government of NCT of Delhi v. Ruksana Bano & Ors. The relevant issues
framed in Ruksana Bano (supra) are extracted herein below:
“I. When does “Land” defined in Section 3(13) of the DLR Act, 1954 get
urbanized;
(a) Whether on publication of notification under Section 507(a) of
the DMC Act, 1957;
or
(b) On publication under Section 11 of DD Act, 1957 of the Master
and Zonal Development Plans prepared under Section 7 and 8
respectively of the said Act;
II. What are the consequences of notification issued under Section 507(a)
of the DMC Act, 1957 which ensue by operation of Section 150(3) of the
DLR Act, 1954;”
3.
After a detailed discussion, the conclusions drawn on the aforesaid
issues in Ruksana Bano (supra) are as under:
“52. …. ….. ….. ….. Thus, our conclusion in respect of Issue I is as
follows:A. Land defined under Section 3 (13) of the DLR Act, 1954 gets
urbanized on publication of a notification under Section 507 (a) of DMC
Act, 1957 with further consequences as per Section 507(b) and (c) of
DMC Act, 1957 and Section 150 (3) of the DLR Act, 1954.
B.
Once any notification under Section 507 (a) of DMC Act is issued
the Gaon Sabha stands dissolved, and all properties movable and
immovable, which include land comprised in dissolved Gaon Sabha, get
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
vested in the Government, and further the Government steps into the
shoes of the dissolved Gaon Sabha in relation to duties, obligations,
rights, interests and liabilities of the dissolved Gaon Sabha.
C.
All taxes and fees and other charges due to Gaon Sabha
immediately before its dissolution on notification under Section 507 of
DMC Act shall be deemed to be due to the Central Government.
D. The provisions of the DLR Act cease to operate in relation to lands
vested in the Government on dissolution of Gaon Sabha as a
consequence of notification under Section 507 (a) of the DMC Act, 1957.
E.
Master and Zonal Plans prepared under Section 7 & 8 of DD Act,
1957, respectively become operative on publication of notification issued
under Section 11 of the said Act as a result of which no development can
take place in the „development area‟ notified under Section 12 of the DD
Act without permission of the Development Authority and so far as area
other than „development area‟ is concerned, development can take place
only on approval or sanction for such development which is to be
obtained from the Local Authority concerned.
F.
On publication of notification under Section 11 of the DD Act,
1957 of Master and Zonal Plan prepared under Section 7 & 8 of the said
Act respectively, operation of provisions of DLR Act including Section 81
& 82 does not come to a halt. Operation of the DLR Act ceases only on
issuance of notification under Section 507(a) of the DMC Act, 1957, as a
consequence of which the land defined under Section 3(13) of the DLR
Act gets vested in the Government. Section 150(3)(e) of the DLR Act,
1954 makes it unambiguously clear that provisions of DLR Act shall
apply only in relation to lands in Gaon Sabha, which is not vested in the
Government under clause „a‟ of sub-Section (3) of Section 150 of DLR
Act and accordingly in our opinion notification under Section 11 of the
DD Act of the Master and Zonal Plans prepared under Section 7 & 8
respectively of the said Act does not have any bearing on the operation of
DLR Act. The provisions of the DLR Act cease to operate only in respect
of land which gets vested in the Government as per consequence flowing
from Section 150(a) of the DLR Act.
Issue II
53. Discussion so far as Issue II as culled out above, has already been
made in the preceding paragraphs. We may, at the cost of repetition,
remind ourselves of the consequences flowing from operation of Section
150(3)(e) of the DLR Act, on issuance of a notification under Section
507(a) of the DMC Act. As already concluded above, the consequence of
vesting of land in the Government by operation of Section 150(3)(a) of
the DLR Act results in cessation of operation of the DLR Act in relation
to land vested in the Government, as per Section 150(3)(e) of the DLR
Act. This is the most vital consequence for the purposes of resolution of
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
the dispute in this appeal that ensures on issuance of notification under
Section 507(a) of the DMC Act, 1957 by operation of Section 150(3) of
the DLR Act, 1954.”
4.
The LPA 34/2024 has been allowed by quashing the order passed by
the learned Single Judge, dated 07.03.2023, which was under challenge
therein, and the validity of the order dated 24.06.2010, passed by Revenue
Assistant/SDM, Najafgarh, Delhi ((hereinafter referred to as the
“RA/SDM”), vesting the land in question in the said matter, has been
upheld.
5.
However, so far as the facts available on the instant appeal are
concerned, they are some what different from the facts in Ruksana Bano
(supra). The main distinguishing feature of the facts in the instant case is
that in Ruksana Bano (supra), the order of vesting was not challenged
before the year 2018 by taking recourse to the statutory remedies available
under section 185(3) of the Delhi Land Reforms Act, 1954 (hereinafter
referred to as the “DLR Act, 1954”), and the said order was challenged for
the first time straight away by filing W.P.(C) 5517/2020, after a lapse of 8
years in the year 2018, whereas in the instant case the order of vesting dated
24.06.2010 was first challenged by moving an application for recall before
the RA/SDM, which was dismissed by order dated 08.04.2013. Whereafter,
the order of vesting and the order dismissing the recall application passed on
24.06.2010 and 08.04.2013 respectively were challenged in an appeal under
section 185(3) of the DLR Act, 1954, before the District Magistrate, which,
too, was dismissed on 05.12.2017.
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
6.
The respondent, thus, instituted the underlying W.P.(C) 2257/2018
challenging the aforesaid three orders, namely the order of vesting dated
24.06.2010, the order dismissing the recall application dated 08.04.2013 and
the order dated 05.12.2017 by which the appeal was dismissed. It is also
relevant to point out that while filing the underlying W.P.(C) 2257/2018, the
respondent had also challenged the order dated 13/14.10.2015 issued by the
Director (Panchayat), GNCTD, allotting the land to the Director, Directorate
of Education, Govt. of NCT of Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the “DoE,
GNCTD”).
Thus, unlike the facts of LPA 34/2024 [Ruksana Bano
(supra)], in the instant case, the respondent has continuously been
prosecuting its case against the order of vesting dated 24.06.2010 passed
under section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954. The case put forth by the respondent
all through in different proceedings was that the land in question was not
used for non-agricultural purpose; rather, it was lying vacant and therefore
vesting of land in Gaon Sabha under section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954, was
illegal.
7.
We may also note that the respondent has been challenging the order
of vesting dated 24.06.2010 also on the ground that the same was passed in
violation of principles of natural justice and further that the final order of
vesting dated 24.06.2010 was passed, preponing the date in the proceeding
under section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954, from 16.07.2010 without any notice
or information of such preponement to the respondent. Therefore, the instant
LPA, in our opinion, needs to be decided on its facts as narrated above while
reiterating the law enunciated by us in the judgment and order delivered by
us today in LPA 34/2024, which we have already extracted hereinabove.
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
8.
Thus, the question which falls for our consideration and decision in
this appeal is as to whether the order of vesting dated 24.06.2010 was passed
by the RA/SDM in violation of principles of natural justice in as much as the
date 16.07.2010, which was fixed in the proceedings under section 81 of the
DLR Act, 1954, was preponed and a final order was passed 24.06.2010
without any information/intimation or notice to the respondent.
9.
The said issue assumes relevance and therefore needs consideration
by us for the reasons that an order of vesting under section 81 of the DLR
Act, 1954 can be passed only if it is found on the basis of material and
evidence on record that the land in question was being used for nonagricultural purposes. Section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954, is extracted herein
below:
“81. Ejectment for use of land in contravention of the provisions of this
Act. [(1)] A Bhumidhar or an Asami shall be liable to ejectment on the
suit of the Gaon Sabha or the landholder, as the case may be, for using
land for any purpose other than a purpose connected with agriculture,
horticulture or animal husbandry, which includes pisciculture and
poultry farming, and also pay [damages] equivalent to the cost of works
which may be required to render the land capable of use for the said
purposes.
[(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), the Revenue
Assistant also may, on receiving information or on his own motion, eject
the Bhumidhar or Asami, as the case may be, and also recover the
damages referred to in sub-section (1), after following such procedure as
may be prescribed.]
10.
Accordingly, if the holder of any land as defined in Section 3(13) of
the DLR Act, 1954, is found to have been using the land for non-agricultural
purposes, only in that eventuality the land can be ordered to be vested in
Gaon Sabha, and further the order of eviction of the land holder can be
passed. In this view, if the holder of the land is denied adequate opportunity
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
to contest its case under section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954, in our opinion the
order of vesting and eviction will be vitiated.
11.
We now proceed to note the facts in respect of the aforesaid factual
issue:
a.
A notice under section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954 was issued by the
RA/SDM in L.R. FORM-48 which stated therein that it was brought to the
notice that the land described in the schedule of the notice has been used for
non-agricultural purposes and in contravention of chapter III-D of the DLR
Act, 1954, and therefore action under section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954 was
proposed to be taken against the respondent, and accordingly the respondent
was required to appear in person before the court of RA/SDM by the said
notice on 18.01.2010 to show cause why action should not be taken under
section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954.
b.
By another order dated 14.01.2010 itself, the RA/SDM concerned
passed a restrain order, restraining the respondent or any other person from
making any construction on the land in question with a further direction that
the status quo shall be maintained till further orders.
c.
The proceedings under section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954, were
adjourned from 18.01.2010 to 12.02.2010 as the presiding officer was busy
in administrative work. On 12.02.2010, the proceedings were again
adjourned to 26.04.2010, for the same reason. In the meantime, the
respondent filed a reply dated 26.03.2010 in the said proceedings denying
the allegations as mentioned in the restrained order and further stating that
no such activity as “construction of boundary wall and any other
construction work,” had been undertaken.
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
d.
On 26.04.2010, the proceedings were again adjourned to 16.07.2010
for the reason that the presiding officer was busy in administrative work.
These order sheets are on record.
e.
It is apparent from a perusal of the order sheets available on record
that the proceedings under section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954, which were
fixed on 26.04.2010, were adjourned for 16.07.2010; however, before the
next date, i.e., 16.07.2010, the order of eviction and vesting was passed by
the RA/SDM of 24.06.2010.
f.
The RA/SDM also issued a warrant to give possession of the land in
question vide order dated 24.06.2010; this warrant of possession is available
on page 136 of the instant LPA. On the warrant of possession, in fact, two
dates are inscribed i.e., 24.06.2010 and 22.06.2010. The learned counsel of
respondent has taken strong exception to this document and submitted that
though the proceedings were fixed for 16.07.2010; however, before the said
date the order of eviction and vesting was passed on 24.06.2010 itself, and it
appears that warrant of possession was prepared prior to the date of order of
vesting and eviction i.e. on 22.06.2010.
g.
Against the order dated 24.06.2010, the respondent preferred an
application seeking recall of the said order; however, the said application
was dismissed by the RA/SDM vide order dated 08.04.2013, whereafter the
respondent filed an appeal under section 185(3) of the DLR Act, 1954,
before the District Magistrate, challenging the orders dated 24.06.2010 and
08.04.2013. The said appeal was also dismissed by order dated 05.12.2017.
During pendency of the appeal, the Director (Panchayat), GNCTD, issued an
order dated 13/14.10.2015 allotting/transferring the subject land to the DoE,
GNCTD, with the approval of the Hon’ble Lieutenant Governor, Delhi.
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
h.
The respondent thus filed the underlying W.P. (C) 2257/2018 before
this Court, challenging the order of vesting and eviction dated 24.06.2010,
the order dismissing the recall application dated 08.04.2013, the order dated
05.12.2017 by means of which the appeal was dismissed by the District
Magistrate and the order 13/14.10.2015 passed by the Director (Panchayat),
GNCTD allotting the land to DoE, GNCTD.
i.
The learned Single Judge vide order dated 26.05.2023 held that
handing over the possession of land to the DoE, GNCTD, was illegal, and
therefore further directed that the land be handed over back to the
respondent. It is this order dated 26.05.2023 passed by the learned Single
Judge which is under challenge herein.
j.
On noticing the aforesaid facts, what is clear is that the proceedings
drawn and conducted by the RA/SDM under section 81 of the DLR Act,
1954, were in flagrant violation of the principles of natural justice. Nonobservance of principles of natural justice would thus vitiate the order of
vesting/ eviction.
k.
The order sheets of the proceedings under section 81 of the DLR Act,
1954, which are on record, reveal that the proceedings, after issuance of
notice on 14.01.2010, were adjourned firstly to 12.02.2010, and thereafter to
26.04.2010. The proceedings were again adjourned from 26.04.2010 to
16.07.2010. On all these occasions, the proceedings were adjourned on
account of the fact that the presiding officer was busy with administrative
work.
l.
However, despite the proceedings being fixed on 16.07.2010, the date
was preponed without any notice to the respondent, and the order of eviction
and vesting was passed by the RA/SDM on 24.06.2010. Thus, the
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
respondent was clearly denied the adequate opportunity of putting forth its
case and participate in the said proceedings. These aspects do not appear to
have been considered appropriately by the RA/SDM while he passed the
order dated 08.04.2013 dismissing the recall application and also by the
appellate authority while he passed the order 05.12.2017. In view of the
aforesaid, the order of vesting and eviction passed by the RA/SDM, dated
24.06.2010, is vitiated and thus not sustainable.
12.
In the aforesaid facts, we are of the opinion that the matter needs to be
remitted to the RA/SDM to decide the proceedings initiated under section 81
of the DLR Act, 1954, afresh after affording adequate opportunity to the
respondent to put forth his case and defence as may be available under law.
For this reason, the order dated 24.06.2010, 08.04.2013 passed by RA/SDM
and the appellate order dated 05.12.2017 are liable to be set aside.
13.
We may further note that in view of what has been held by us in the
judgment and order pronounced today in LPA 34/2024, urbanization in
respect of the land in question took place on issuance of notification under
section 507(a) of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 (hereinafter
referred to as the “DMC Act, 1957”), which was issued on 16.05.2017. The
consequence of the notification of section 507(a) of the DMC Act, 1957,
flows from the operation of the provisions contained in section 150(3) of the
DLR Act, 1954. Section 150(3)(d) of the DLR Act, 1954, clearly provides
that all suits, prosecutions and other legal proceedings instituted or which
might have been instituted by or against Gaon Sabha on dissolution of Gaon
Sabha in terms of section 150(3) of the DLR Act, 1954, may be continued or
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
instituted by or against the Union of India. Section 150(3) of the DLR Act,
1954, is extracted herein below:
“150 (3) If the whole of a Gaon Sabha Area ceases to be included in
rural areas as and defined in the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act,
1957, by virtue of a notification under section 507 of that Act, the Gaon
Sabha constituted for that area shall thereupon stand dissolved and on
such dissolution,(a) all properties, movable and immovable, and all interests of
whatsoever nature and kind therein, including moneys held in
Gaon Sabha Area Fund, vested in the Gaon Sabha immediately
before such dissolution, shall, with all rights of whatsoever
description, used, enjoyed or possessed by Gaon Sabha, vest in the
Central Government;
(b) all duties, obligations and liabilities incurred, all contracts
entered into and all matters and things engaged to be done by, with
or for the Gaon Sabha before such dissolution shall be deemed to
have been incurred, entered into or engaged to be done with or for
the Central Government;
(c) all rates, taxes, fees rents and other charges due to the Gaon
Sabha immediately before such dissolution shall be deemed to be
due to the Central Government;
(d) all suits, prosecutions and other legal proceedings instituted
or which might have been instituted by or against the Gaon
Sabha may be continued or instituted by or against the Union of
India;
(e) the provisions of this Act shall apply in relation to lands in such
Gaon Sabha Area, not being lands vested in the Central
Government under clause (a), subject to the codification that
references therein to Gaon Sabha and Gaon Panchayat shall be
construed as references to the Central Government;
(f) notwithstanding anything contained in clause (b) of sub-section
(2) of section 1, the provisions of sections 84, 85, 86A and 87 and
any other provision of this Act relating to ejectment of persons
shall apply in relation to lands vested in the Central Government
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
under clause (a) subject to the modification that references therein
to Gaon Sabha and Gaon Panchayat shall be construed as
references to the Central Government.”
14.
Thus, on the matter being remitted under this order, the RA/SDM
shall be well within his jurisdiction and power to continue the proceedings
initiated against the respondent by issuing the notice under section 81 of the
DLR Act, 1954 on 14.01.2010.
15.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the impugned order passed by the
learned Single Judge dated 26.05.2023 is set aside, and the appeal is
disposed of in the following terms:
a.
The order of vesting/eviction passed by the RA/SDM on 24.06.2010
under section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954, is quashed.
b.
The order dated 08.04.2013 passed by the RA/SDM as well as the
order dated 05.12.2017 passed by the appellate authority are also quashed.
c.
The proceedings initiated on issuance of notice dated 14.01.2010
under section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954, shall be revived and decided afresh
by the RA/SDM with expedition, say within a period of 6 months from
today.
d.
Parties shall maintain status quo as it exists on the spot today till the
disposal of the proceedings under Section 81 of DLR Act, 1954 to be
conducted afresh under this order by the RA/SDM.
e.
Parties to the proceeding under section 81 of the DLR Act, 1954, shall
appear before RA/SDM on 17.08.2026 at 11 a.m., for which no other/further
notice will be required to be served on the parties.
f.
Adjournment in the proceedings which are to be revived and decided
afresh by the RA/SDM shall ordinarily not be sought by the parties, which
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
shall, however, be permissible only in exceptional circumstances, that too
with the express and specific leave of the presiding officer.
16.
The appeal along with pending applications thus stands disposed of
finally.
17.
Costs made easy.
(DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA)
CHIEF JUSTICE
(TEJAS KARIA)
JUDGE
AUGUST 11, 2026
‘shailndra’
LPA 554/2025
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
14:02:37
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review