Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present :-
Hon’ble Justice Amrita Sinha
WPA 22939 of 2022
Goutam Hari
Vs.
Coal India Limited & Ors.
For the writ petitioner
:-
Mr. Samiran Mandal, Adv.
Mr. Abhinaba Dan, Adv.
Mr. Nitish Samanta, Adv.
Ms. Shreyashree Mitra, Adv.
For the respondent nos. 2-4 & 6
:-
Mr. Manik Das, Adv.
Heard on
:-
24.03.2026
Judgment on
:-
02.04.2026
Amrita Sinha, J.:1.
The matter relates to compassionate appointment in the died in
harness category. The petitioner’s father was serving as Safai
Karmachari in Kalla Central Hospital. He died in harness while on
duty on 14th January, 2021. On his death, the petitioner applied for
compassionate appointment. At the time of making application
seeking compassionate appointment the petitioner disclosed his age
as 33 years. The petitioner was provisionally issued an appointment
letter with effect from 15th January, 2021. He was advised to submit
requisite documents for verification.
2.
The petitioner submitted all his documents before the respondent
authority. Initial Medical Examination of the petitioner was
conducted on 25th May, 2021 when his age was assessed between
33 to 38 years. As per the National Coal Wages Agreement- VI
(NCWA), which is prevailing at present, the upper age limit for
appointment is 35 years. The petitioner was declared medically unfit
for employment due to overage and low vision. The provisional
employment of the petitioner was terminated with effect from 10th
July, 2021.
3.
Being aggrieved by the findings of the Initial Medical Examination
relying on which his engagement stood terminated, the petitioner
approached
the
Apex
Medical
Board
of
the
authority
for
reassessment of his age and vision. Simultaneously, the petitioner
got himself tested before the State Government hospital on 31st
July, 2021 where he was declared fit for joining. The Apex Medical
Board report dated 19th November, 2021 assessed the age of the
petitioner to be between 35 and 40 years and found his vision to be
normal.
4.
During the course of consideration of the instant writ petition, the
Hon’ble Court directed the Superintendent of SSKM hospital and
IPGMER to constitute a Board for assessment of age of the
petitioner by way of ossification test. The test report has been
placed before this Court which mentions that the age of the
petitioner will be between 30 and 40 years.
5.
According to the petitioner, he is within the prescribed age limit
eligible for appointment and his vision is normal. He alleges that he
has been illegally terminated from service. Prayer has been made to
set aside the impugned order of termination and direct the Eastern
Coalfields Ltd. to reinstate the petitioner in service.
6.
Learned advocate representing the respondent authorities opposes
the submission of the petitioner. The report filed by the Chief
Medical Officer (Administration) is relied upon. It has been
mentioned therein that the father of the petitioner died while on
duty. Due to tremendous pressure of all the unions in the Central
Hospital,
the
appointment
authority
to
the
was
petitioner
compelled
on
the
to
give
self-same
immediate
day.
The
appointment was provisional, subject to compliance of the rules for
appointment including medical check-up.
7.
At the time of Initial Medical Examination, the age of the petitioner
was assessed between 33 and 38 years. Taking the midpoint of the
age bracket, the age of the petitioner was considered as 37 ½ years.
The age limit for providing appointment on compassionate ground
by the respondents is 35 years. Apart from being overaged, the
petitioner was also found to be suffering from low vision.
8.
According to the respondents, The Mines Rules, 1955 restricts
appointment to persons with low vision. It has been submitted that
it is extremely dangerous to give appointment to a person with low
vision to work in the mines.
9.
As the petitioner failed on two counts, i.e., (i) overage and (ii) low
vision, the provisional appointment letter which was issued in his
favour stood terminated.
10.
Learned advocate for the respondents relies upon the judgment
delivered by the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court on 25th April,
2023 in MAT 1582 of 2022 in the matter of M/s. Eastern
Coalfields Limited and Others vs Sujala Ankure @ Sujala
Akuria wherein the Court was pleased to direct SSKM Hospital to
constitute medical board for conduct of ossification test and to
provide the report with the range of five years instead of ten years. It
has been contended by the respondents that ten years is a long
bracket for ascertaining the proper age of a person who will be
employed in the mines.
11.
The respondents pray for dismissal of the writ petition or
alternatively a direction for conducting ossification test of the
petitioner once again before AIIMS, Kalyani and for furnishing a
report within the bracket of five years.
12.
I have heard and considered the rival submissions made on behalf
of both the parties and have perused the materials on record.
13.
It appears that at the initial stage of consideration of the instant
writ petition, the Court directed the petitioner’s age to be assessed
by way of an ossification test to be conducted by the Board
specifically constituted by the Superintendent of SSKM hospital. An
application was filed by the respondents seeking recall of the order
directing ossification test to be carried out. The said application for
recalling stood dismissed. An appeal being MAT 1434/2023 carried
from the said order by the respondents also stood dismissed by the
Hon’ble Division Bench on 30th January, 2024.
14.
The ossification test report of SSKM hospital has been perused
wherefrom it appears that the age of the petitioner has been
assessed within 30 to 40 years. The mean age of the petitioner as
per the said report will be 35 years, which is the prescribed age
limit for being appointed by the respondent authorities.
15.
From the documents annexed to the writ petition it appears that,
though initially the petitioner was disqualified for engagement on
two counts, but thereafter, it is only the age that is standing in the
way of providing appointment to the petitioner. The vision of the
petitioner has been recorded as normal in the medical report of the
Apex Medical Board.
16.
It appears that the age of the petitioner was assessed by three
different authorities; namely, the Initial Medical Examination Board
who found the petitioner’s age to be between 33 to 38 years, the
Apex Medical Board found the petitioner to be within 35 to 40 years
and the SSKM hospital found the petitioner to be within 30 to 40
years.
17.
When the age of the candidate is uncertain, the respondent
authorities assess the age of the candidate by taking the midpoint of
the bracket within which the age of the candidate has been
assessed. Applying the aforesaid formula, the midpoint of the
petitioner’s age as per the Initial Medical Examination will be 35 ½
years, as per the Apex Medical Board report it will be 37 ½ years
and as per the SSKM report the petitioner is 35 years.
18.
The direction passed by the learned single Judge for conducting
ossification test of the petitioner to ascertain his age was
unsuccessfully challenged by the respondent authority. The order of
the Division Bench was, however, not tested before any other
superior forum. The same implies that the order of the Division
Bench is final and the authority would be bound to comply with the
same.
19.
After the report of the SSKM hospital has arrived, the authority
ought to follow the opinion given by its expert Board. It has to be
kept in mind that the ossification test of the petitioner was
conducted by SSKM hospital in the year 2024. The petitioner was
provided appointment in the year 2021. Had the ossification test of
the petitioner been conducted in the year 2021 by SSKM hospital,
the age bracket of the petitioner would certainly have been lower
than that has been currently found.
20.
The prayer of the respondent authority for conducting fresh
ossification test cannot be allowed because of the reason that the
petitioner is claiming appointment on compassionate ground. His
father died while on duty in the year 2021. Though the petitioner
was provisionally appointed for a brief period of time, but thereafter
the said appointment stood terminated. The petitioner has filed the
instant writ petition in the year 2022.
21.
Appointment on compassionate ground is considered only when the
family of the deceased employee is suffering from acute financial
crisis and is not in a position to have two square meals a day.
Prayer for compassionate appointment ought not to be kept pending
for an indefinite period of time. It will be nearly five years that the
petitioner lost his father and he is still now running from pillar to
post to get back his job which stood terminated.
22.
Passing order for conducting further ossification test of the
petitioner will result in more delay in consideration of the
petitioner’s prayer for compassionate appointment. The same will
cause not only injustice but severe prejudice to the petitioner.
23.
Moreover, as the petitioner was engaged as a Safai Karamchari in a
hospital, minor age difference at the time of providing appointment
will not cause much harm to the respondent authorities vis-a-vis
the suffering that the petitioner is facing for losing the job that he
got on compassionate ground. It is not at all suggested that the
prescribed age limit for providing appointment has to be given a go
by; but at the same time, as the ossification test report of the
petitioner, as per the method of calculation of the respondent
authorities, will suggest that he was approximately 35 years of age
when the test was conducted in the year 2024, it can be safely
concluded that the petitioner was certainly under 35 years of age in
the year 2021, when compassionate appointment on provisional
basis was provided to him.
24.
The facts of the case in Sujala Ankure (supra) do not match with the
facts and circumstances of the instant case. In the said case,
ossification test of a female was conducted. By taking into
consideration the age of the child of the said female, the age of the
incumbent, assessed after the ossification test, was found to be
improper. It was under such doubtful circumstances that the Court
directed further ossification test to be conducted and the report to
be furnished within a bracket of five years. Such is not the case at
hand. Here the age of the petitioner, as assessed by the medical
boards of the authority and the medical board of SSKM hospital,
does not differ much.
25.
In view of the above, the Court is of the considered opinion that the
impugned order of termination of the provisional appointment of the
petitioner is liable to be set aside and is, accordingly, set aside. The
respondent authorities are directed to reinstate the petitioner in
service by taking into consideration the report of the ossification
test conducted by SSKM hospital at the earliest but positively within
a period of four weeks from the date of communication of this order.
26.
No direction can be passed for grant of back wages as the
respondent authorities could not have engaged the petitioner relying
on the age assessed by their medical boards. The provisional
appointment
letter
issued
to
the petitioner
was
subject
to
compliance of the rules of appointment including medical check-up.
As the age of the petitioner has been determined by the ossification
test conducted as per the direction of the Court, accordingly, the
authority cannot be held to be responsible for the delay in
ascertaining the proper age of the petitioner.
27.
The writ petition stands disposed of.
28.
No costs.
29.
Urgent certified photocopy of this judgment, if applied for, be supplied
to the parties or their advocates on record expeditiously on compliance
of usual legal formalities.
(Amrita Sinha, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review