Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
"
"
!
"
$
%&' % (
)*
'%
)
+
!
""
!
""
!
""
!
""
"
Digitally signed
by
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
#
$
%
%
#
$
&
#
$
-2-
'
'
#
!
% " $
(%
!
"
&
#
'
'
'
$
#
%
$
'
#
)
$
'
"
'
#%$
"
"
*
#*
$
''
# $ '
# $
'
'
* '
'
+
*
*
,-. /0-1-234 567-7-82 -. 9-46: ;2:60
'
,3037-<3
3=30->
-2
0-16
;0B-,34
84-/6
6/7-82.
#%$
;03>.,3
"
6/7-82
32,-73
"
78 ?;3., 7,6
:376: "@ "
"
06=-.7606: A<
737-82 980 7,6 89962/6. 5;2-.,3A46 ;2:60
"
# $ 063: C-7,
6/7-82
# $
-3-
,3037-<3
"
FG
D980 .,807
E7,6
506.6274< 562:-2= 82 7,6 9-46 89 7,6
::4
*;:=6 #*0
<3<3
32,-73
2 $ 32: * '
"
-B-4
-2:,32;0
,6 93/7;34 1370-H 89 7,6 /3.6 -. 7,37 7,6
/81543-2327 ! 06.582:627
,3. 7C8 A087,60. 23164<
-I3<
,606-2
3. 32: 567-7-8260
06.-:627 89
;0B-,34 78C2
-I3<
,6 .3-:
-I3<
A3/,6480 32: C3. 0;22-2= 3 567084 A;2>
3. C3.
3. C3. 3
67-7-8260
J
85->0-.,23 -. 3287,60 A087,60 89 /81543-2327 C,8 -. 3
627034
8B6021627 61548<66 -2
3-4C3<
653071627 32:
,6 -. 06.-:-2= 3482= C-7, ,-. 931-4< 37
;A4-
% "(
3. C627 78
"
7,6 /81543-2327F. A087,60
1667 3//;.6:
"(
"
7,6 .3-:
;A4-
-I3<
2 7,6 26H7 :3< - 6
3. :-6: 37
7,6 :63: A8:< C3. A08;=,7 78
K "(
"
-I3<
;A4-
,60639760
;0B-,34 78C2 32: 82
7,6 9;26034 /606182< C3. /82:;/76: 37
;0B-,34 78C2
3760 82 "( "
"
0-7;34 # 60,B-2$ C3. 56098016: 37
7,
:3<
;0B-,34 78C2
7,6
-6
7,6
/81543-2327 32: ,60 .-.760 37762:6: 7,6 .3-: /606182<
-4-
32: 7,6< ,3: A08;=,7 =84: 32: .-4B60 307-/46. 32: /3.,
C807,
. K" """ ! 9081 ,60 ,;.A32:F. ,8;.6 32: 7,8.6
307-/46. C606 >657 -2 3 .7664 A8H -2 7,6 >-7/,62 89 ,8;.6 89
:6/63.6:
-I3<
3.
2 "
"
"
37 3A8;7 @
" 31
/81543-2327 32: ,60 .-.760 48/>6: 7,6 :880 89 7,6 ,8;.6
32: C627 78
-2:,32;0 78C2 980 5;0/,3.-2= .816 =08/60<
,62 7,6< 067;026: 37 3A8;7
"" 5 1 7,6< 98;2: 7,6
48/> 437/, 89 7,6 ,8;.6 C3. A08>62 32: 7,6 :880 C3.
,62 7,6 /81543-2327 32: ,60 .-.760 0;.,6: 78 7,6
>-7/,62 7,6< 98;2: 7,6 .7664 A8H C,-/, C3. /8273-2-2=
I6C640< 32: /3., C3. 82 7,6 94880 32: 7,6 =84: 32: .-4B60
307-/46. 32: /3., C606 1-..-2=
;4>302- 32:
3=303I
2 62?;-0<
0-:,30
;4>302- C,8 C606 2630 7,6 567084
A;2> 32: 34.8 7,6 C80>60. 89 567084 A;2>
C,-/, -.
.-7;376: 2630 78 7,6 ,8;.6 -298016: 7,6 /81543-2327 7,37
37 3A8;7
"" 5 1 3//;.6:
8.
78 % A08>62 7,6 48/> 89
7,6 :880 32: 706.53..6: -278 7,6 ,8;.6 32: 7,606A< 7,6<
/811-776: 7,6 7,697 89 =84: 32: .-4B60 307-/46. 32: /3., -2
7,6 ,8;.6
-5-
2 62?;-0< C-7, 7,6 3//;.6: 7,6< 7,0637626:
7,6 /81543-2327 C-7, :-06 /82.6?;62/6
62/6 .,6 48:=6:
7,6 /81543-27 3=3-2.7 7,6 567-7-8260. 3//;.6: A69806 7,6
06.582:627!584-/6 82 "@ "
"
3446=-2= 7,37 ,60
89 =84: - 6 % 7843. 89 3B343>>- .303
7843. 89 /,3-2 C807, 89
C807, 89
7843. 89 =84: 0-2= 32:
. " """ ! 32: L >= .-4B60
. % """ ! 32: /3.,
7,6 3//;.6:
7843.
. K" """ ! C606 .78462 A<
7 -. 34.8 3446=6: 7,37 7,6 3//;.6: ,3B6 73>62
7,6 :8/;1627. 06437-2= 78 7,6 -118B3A46 5085607< 89
:6/63.6:! -I3<
3. >657 -2 7,6 .3-: ,8;.6
.7062=7, 89 .3-: /81543-27 '
0-16
3==0-6B6:
A<
/316 78 A6 06=-.7606: -2
"
3=3-2.7 7,6 567-7-8260. 3//;.6:
6-2=
7,6
.3-:
7,6
06=-.7037-82
/81543-27 7,6 567-7-8260. 306 A69806 7,-.
7,6 '
'
32:
8;07 78 ?;3.,
32: /81543-27
%
7,6
2 7,6
630: 463026: /8;2.64 980 7,6 567-7-8260. 32:
463026:
06.582:627! 7376
-=,
8;07
8B6021627
463:60
-6-
5307 9081 ;0=-2= .6B6034 /827627-82.
7,6
463026: /8;2.64 980 7,6 567-7-8260. 50-130-4< /8276276: 7,37
.-2/6 7,6 89962/6. 3446=6: -2 7,-. /3.6 306 5;2-.,3A46
A648C ( <630. 89 -150-.821627 7,6 2B6.7-=37-2=
,3. C082=4< 06=-.7606: 7,6 '
5064-1-230< 62?;-0< ;2:60
.;/,
99-/60
C-7,8;7 /82:;/7-2= 32<
6/7-82
( # $ 89
.
7,6 .316 -. 287 .;.73-26: ;2:60 43C
6 34.8
.;A1-776: 7,37 6B62 -9 7,6 3446=37-82. 13:6 -2 7,6
/81543-27 306 73>62 82 -7. 627-067< 6B62 7,62 3
/3.6 -. 287 9807,/81-2= 980 7,6 3446=6: 89962/6.
3=3-2.7 7,6 567-7-8260.
2 80:60 78 A;7706.. ,-. 30=;1627.
,6 064-6: 82 7,6 I;:=1627 89 7,6
82+A46
56H
8;07 -2 7,6
/3.6 89
!" #$ %
//80:-2=4< ,6 503<.
78 3448C 7,6 567-7-82
K
463026:
-=,
8;07
8B6021627
463:60 /8276276: 7,37 A3.6: 82 7,6 /81543-27 48:=6: A<
7,6 /81543-2327 7,6 '
"
/316 78 A6 06=-.7606: -2
0-16
39760 /82:;/7-2= 5064-1-230< 62?;-0< A< 7,6
-7-
2B6.7-=37-2=
99-/60
';07,60
7,6 -2B6.7-=37-82 -. ;2:60
508=06.. 32: 7,6 06.582:627!584-/6 <67 78 /8446/7 7,6
13760-34. A< 06/80:-2= 7,6 .73761627. 89 7,6 C-726..6.
32: 34.8 06/8B60 7,6 3446=6: .78462 307-/46. 89 =84: .-4B60
/3., 32: 34.8 7,6 :8/;1627. 06437-2= 78 7,6 5085607< 89
:6/63.6:! -I3<
3.
. .;/, 37 7,-. .73=6 7,6 '
/32287
A6 ?;3.,6:
//80:-2=4< ,6 503<. 78 :-.1-.. 7,6 567-7-82
(
,3B6 =-B62 1< 32H-8;. /82.-:6037-82 A87, 82
7,6 .;A1-..-82. 13:6 A< 7,6 463026: /8;2.64 980 7,6
06.56/7-B6 5307-6. 32: 34.8 7,6 :8/;1627. 3B3-43A46 82
06/80:
2 /3069;4 063:-2= 89 7,6 /81543-27 3B601627.
-7 -. .7376: 7,37 7,6 :6/63.6:! -I3<
3. C3. 3 A3/,6480
32: ,6 C3. 06.-:-2= 34826 -2 ,-. ,8;.6 37
;0B-,34
/81543-2327 -2 7,-. /3.6 -. ,-. .-.760 32: 3//;.6:
,6
-.
,-. A087,60 32: 3//;.6:
8.
161A60. 89 3//;.6:
//80:-2= 78 7,6 /81543-2327
39760 7,6 :637, 89 :6/63.6:! -I3<
78 % 306 7,6 931-4<
3. .,6 /316 78 7,6
-8-
,8;.6 89 :6/63.6:! -I3<
3. 78 5609801 ,-. 43.7 0-7;34. 32:
>657 ,60 =84: 32: .-4B60 80231627. 32: /3., -2 7,6 ,8;.6
89 :6/63.6:! -I3<
@
2 "
.-.760 C627 78
3.
"
"
C,62 7,6 /81543-2327 32: ,60
-2:,32;0 78 5;0/,3.6 =08/60< A< 48/>-2=
7,6 :880 89 7,6 ,8;.6 C,62 .,6 067;026: 78 7,6 ,8;.6
.,6 98;2: 7,37 7,6 :880 89 7,6 ,8;.6 C3. A08>62 32: ,60
=84: 32: .-4B60 307-/46. 32: /3., C606 1-..-2=
2 62?;-0<
.,6 /316 78 >28C 7,37 7,6 3//;.6:!567-7-8260. ,3B6
980/69;44< 627606: 7,6 ,8;.6 A< A063>-2= 8562 7,6 :880
32: 7,60639760 .78462 7,8.6 307-/46. 32: /3., 3482= C-7,
7,6 :8/;1627. 06437-2= 78 7,6 5085607< 89 4376
62/6 7,6 /81543-27 C3. 48:=6: 82 "@ "
5 1 32: .;A.6?;6274< '
"
-I3<
"
3.
37 K ""
/316 78 A6 06=-.7606:
,6 /827627-82 89 7,6 463026: /8;2.64 980 7,6
567-7-8260. -. 7,37 7,6 89962/6. -2B84B6: -2 7,-. /3.6 306
5;2-.,3A46 ;5 78 ( <630.
. .;/,
7,6
2B6.7-=37-2=
99-/60 8;=,7 78 ,3B6 /82:;/76: 3 5064-1-230< 62?;-0<
-9-
A69806 48:=-2= 7,6 '
( # $ 89
3. /8276154376: ;2:60
6/7-82
78 508/66: C-7, 7,6 -2B6.7-=37-82
6/7-82 ( # $ 89
&'#
(
063:. 3. ;2:60
) *+
(
! "
#
"
"
"
%
#
#
$
&
'
(
#
#
#
)
#
*
+
2 /3069;4 063:-2= 89 7,6 3A8B6 508B-.-82 7,6
.316 :65-/7. 7,37
/8273-26: ;2:60
C-7,8;7 506I;:-/6 78 7,6 508B-.-82
6/7-82
(
84-/6
99-/60 ,3. 58C60 78
-2B6.7-=376 7,6 /8=2-M3A46 /3.6 7,6 89962/6 5;2-.,3A46 980
- 10 -
<630. 80 1806 A;7 46.. 7,32 ( <630. 7,6 584-/6 899-/60
N13<O C-7, 50-80 5601-..-82 9081 32
032> 89
65;7<
99-/60 287 A648C 7,6
;560-2762:627 89
84-/6 508/66: 78
/82:;/7 7,6 5064-1-230< 62?;-0< 78 3./6073-2 7,6 6H-.762/6
/3.6 980 508/66:-2= -2 7,6 137760 C-7,-2 3
560-8: 89
% :3<. 32: 34.8 508/66: C-7, 7,6 -2B6.7-=37-82
C,62 7,606 6H-.7. 3
/3.6
2 A306 063:-2= 89
7,6 .316 7,-. 508B-.-82 -. C-7,8;7 506I;:-/6 78 508B-.-82.
6/7-82
C-7, 7,6
(
6/7-82
(
2B6.7-=37-2=
-. 7,6 58C60 B6.76:
99-/60 -2!/,30=6 89 7,6 584-/6
.737-82 78 -2B6.7-=376 3 /8=2-M32/6 /3.6 82 06/6-57 89 7,6
/81543-27
-2/6 7,6 /81543-27 3446=37-82.
13:6 8;7 3 /3.6 89 ,8;.6 4;0>-2= 32: ,8;.6 706.53.. 32:
34.8 /811-..-82 89 7,697 89 =84: 32: .-4B60 307-/46. C807, 89
43>,. 78=67,60 32: 34.8 3 /3., 32: 34.8 7,6 5085607<
:8/;1627. 7,6
2B6.7-=37-2=
B6.76: ;2:60
6/7-82
-2B6.7-=37-82
A<
(
99-/60 A< B-07;6 89 58C60
06=-.760-2=
508/66:6: C-7, 7,6
7,6
'
8C6B60
7,6
- 11 -
-2B6.7-=37-82 -. .7-44 ;2:60 508=06..
,6 I;:=1627 064-6:
A< 7,6 463026: /8;2.64 980 7,6 567-7-8260. 3.
-. 287
3554-/3A46 78 7,6 93/7. 32: /-0/;1.732/6. 89 7,-. /3.6
%
2 7,6 -2.7327 /3.6 7,6 89962/6. 3446=6: 306
,6-28;. -2 237;06
7 -. .67746: 58.-7-82 89 43C C,-46 :634-2=
C-7, 7,6 567-7-82 980 ?;3.,-2= 508/66:-2=.
C,62 7,6
137760 -. 37 506137;06 .73=6 32: 7,6 -2B6.7-=37-82 ,3. 287
508/66:6: C-7, -7 6H/657 .816 5064-1-230< 699807 73>62 82
7,6 :376 89 06=-.7037-82 89 /3.6 7,6 6B-:62/6 ,3. 78 A6
=37,606: 39760 3 7,808;=, -2B6.7-=37-82 32: 543/6 A69806
7,6
8;07 82 7,6 A3.-. 89 C,-/, 34826 7,6
8;07 /32 /816
78 -7. /82/4;.-82 826 C3< 80 7,6 87,60 82 7,6 5463 89
13439-:6 80 934.6 -154-/37-82.
9 7,6 3446=37-82. 306 A60697 89 70;7, 32: 13< A6
134-/-8;. 7,6 -2B6.7-=37-82 C-44 .3< .8
7 7,-. .73=6 C,62
7,606 306 824< 3446=37-82. 32: 06/43137-82.
6B-:62/6
7,-.
A;7 28
8;07 /32287 327-/-5376 7,6 06.;47 89 7,6
-2B6.7-=37-82 32: 062:60 9-2:-2=. 82 7,6 ?;6.7-82 89 934.6
- 12 -
-154-/37-82
13439-:6
7,6
13760-34.
506.6274<
3B3-43A46
. .;/, -7 /32287 A6 .3-: 7,37 7,6 /81543-27
.,8;4: A6 7,08C2 8B60A830: 82 7,6 1606 5463 89 934.6
-154-/37-82
B62 3..;1-2= 7,37 7,6 /81543-27 ,3. A662
9-46: 82 3//8;27 89 560.8234 32-18.-7< A< 7,6 /81543-2327
7,37 -7.649 C-44 287 A6 3 =08;2: 78 :-./30: 7,6 /81543-27
/8273-26: -2 3 .60-8;. 3446=37-82 89 7,697 A< ,8;.6 4;0>-2=
C,-/,
,3.
A6
76.76:
32:
C6-=,6:
39760
6B-:62/6 13760-34. /8446/76: A< 7,6 2B6.7-=37-2=
K
7,6
99-/60
7 -. .67746: 58.-7-82 89 43C -2 /37623 89
I;:=1627. A< 7,6
82+A46
56H
8;07 7,37 3 /0-1-234
508/66:-2=. /32 A6 ?;3.,6: C,62 -7 132-96.74< 355630.
7,37 7,606 -. 3 46=34 A30 3=3-2.7 7,6 -2.7-7;7-82 80
/827-2;37-82 89 7,6 508/66:-2=. 32: 7,6 3446=37-82. 78 7,6
'-0.7
2980137-82
65807 80 /81543-27 73>62 82 -7. 93/6
B34;6 32: 3//6576: -2 7,6-0 627-067< :8 287 /82.7-7;76 7,6
89962/6 3446=6: 80 C,606 7,6 3446=37-82 /82.7-7;76: 7,6
89962/6
A;7 7,606 -. 28 46=34 6B-:62/6 3::;/6: 80 7,6
6B-:62/6 3::;/6: /46304< 80 132-96.74< 93-4. 78 508B6 7,6
- 13 -
/,30=6
2 7,6 /3.6 82 ,32:
7,6 /81543-27 :-./48.6.
/8=2-M3A46 89962/6 89 7,697 89 ,8;.6 4;0>-2= 80 ,8;.6
706.53.. 37 7,-. 506137;06 .73=6 '
(
//80:-2=4<
/32287 A6 ?;3.,6:
567-7-82 43/>. 160-7 32: .316 -.
,*
%
"
)
"
@
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review