Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: 13.01.2026
FAO 300/2018
+
GOPAL SINGH
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Varun Sarin and Ms. Parul Dutta,
Advocates.
versus
MAHESH LOCHI & ANR (THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE
COMPANY LTD)
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. J.P.N. Shahi, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
CM APPL. 25508/2018 (Delay of 136 days in filing)
1.
This is an application filed by the applicant/appellant seeking
condonation of delay of 136 days in filing the instant appeal.
2.
For the reasons stated in the application, the same is allowed, and the
delay of 136 days in filing the appeal is condoned.
3.
The present application is disposed of in the above terms.
FAO 300/2018
1.
The present appeal has been filed under Section 30 of the Employee's
Compensation Act, 1923 (hereinafter referred to as the “EC Act”) seeking
setting aside of the order dated 22.11.2017 passed by the Commissioner
under the Employee's Compensation Act, 1923 in the matter of Sh. Gopal
Singh Vs. Sh. Mahesh Lochib & Ors. in Case No. CEC/SD/l/22/17, and
remanding back of the matter to the concerned Trial Court.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:51:47
FAO 300/2018
2.
Vide the impugned order, the appellant’s claim application was
dismissed as non-maintainable for the reason that his claim application filed
before the Motor Accidents Claim Tribunal (“MACT”) had already been
dismissed vide judgment dated 15.12.2016.
3.
The only question which arises for consideration is whether, with his
claim application having been dismissed by the MACT, the applicant would
be estopped from filing a claim application under Section 3 of the EC Act.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellant contends that despite the appellant’s
claim being rejected by the MACT, there is no bar to entertaining an
application under the EC Act.
5.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent contends that in
terms of Section 167 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (“MV Act”), there is a
complete bar once a claim under the MV Act has been entertained and
dismissed. He submits that the finding recorded in Paragraph 10 of the
judgment dated 15.12.2016 rendered by the MACT, whereby the appellant
was held to be negligent and liable for having caused the accident, would
stop him from instituting a claim under the EC Act.
6.
Before proceeding further, it is apposite to note that the EC Act is a
beneficial piece of legislation and has been enacted to protect
workmen/employees as far as possible from hardships arising from
accidents. The factual narration available on record shows that the
claimant/injured suffered a road accident on 14.04.2013, which involved
vehicle number HR-38P-0235 owned by respondent no. 1 insured by
respondent no. 2.
7.
The claim petition came to be filed before the MACT being Suit No.
220/14. On summons being issued to respondent no. 1, being the employer
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:51:47
FAO 300/2018
of the appellant and the owner of the car involved in the accident, he filed
his written statement admitting that his vehicle was involved in the accident
and that the accident was not caused due to his fault. The insurance
company, i.e., respondent no. 2, also filed its written statement and
questioned the maintainability of the appellant’s claim, but admitted that the
concerned vehicle was insured vide a policy that was valid and subsisting on
the date of accident. The MACT, while considering the claim petition, came
to the conclusion that no substantial proof of the accident had been placed
on record and that the petitioner himself had been negligent.
8.
In the present proceedings, the stand of respondent no. 2/insurance
company is that the said finding bars the claimant from raising any claim
under the EC Act. To deal with the said contention, it would be pertinent to
extract Section 3(1) of the EC Act. The same reads as under:
“3. Employer's liability for compensation.—(1) If personal injury is
caused to a employee by accident arising out of and in the course of his
employment, his employer shall be liable to pay compensation in accordance with
the provisions of this Chapter:
Provided that the employer shall not be so liable —
(a) in respect of any injury which does not result in the total or
partial disablement of the employee for a period exceeding three days;
(b)in respect of any injury, not resulting in death or permanent
total disablement caused by an accident which is directly attributable
to—
(i) the employee having been at the time thereof under the
influence of drink or drugs, or
(ii) the wilful disobedience of the employee to an order
expressly given, or to a rule expressly framed, for the purpose of
securing the safety of employees, or
(iii) the wilful removal or disregard by the employee of any
safety guard or other device which he knew to have been provided
for the purpose of securing the safety of employee.”
9.
A perusal of the aforesaid shows that exceptions to liability are
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:51:47
FAO 300/2018
entailed in the proviso itself. In the considered opinion on this Court, the
considerations before the two Authorities under the MV Act and the EC Act
are different. Even if the claimant/injured is negligent, the same would not
debar him from filing a claim under the EC Act. In this regard, a gainful
reference may also be made to the decision of the Coordinate Bench of this
Court in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Virender Singh1, which
observes:“7. Liability under the Employee’s Compensation Act, 1923 arises if an
accident arises out of and in the course of employment. Liability can only
be avoided if evidence is led before the Commissioner that either the
employee was under the influence of liquor or drugs or the employee had
willfully disobeyed an express order given to him. Negligence of an
employee is not a ground to dispute or deny the compensation under
Section 3. …
***
9. The first argument urged on behalf of the appellant is completely
misconceived as I have already referred above Section 3 of the Act which
shows that there is no provision in the said section that an employee
cannot claim compensation if there is negligence. All that Section 3
requires is that accident must arise out of and in the course of employment
and the employee should not be under the influence of liquor or drugs or
that he should have disobeyed an express order. …”
10.
Coming now to the aspect of whether Section 167 of the MV Act
debars a claimant from instituting a claim under the EC Act. Section 167 of
MV Act reads as under:
“167. Option regarding claims for compensation in certain
cases.—Notwithstanding anything contained in the Workmen’s
Compensation Act, 1923 (8 of 1923), where the death of, or bodily injury
to, any person gives rise to a claim for compensation under this Act and
also under the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923, the person entitled to
compensation may without prejudice to the provisions of Chapter X claim
such compensation under either of those Acts but not under both.”
It is worth noting that Section 167 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
2014 SCC OnLine Del 1372
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:51:47
FAO 300/2018
(reproduced above) is in pari materia with Section 110-AA of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1939. With that in mind, another gainful reference may be
made to the decision of the Bombay High Court in Neelabai Mahadeo
Salunkhe & Ors. Vs. Shamrao Tatoba Pawar & Ors.2, which holds as
follows:“6. Section 110-AA was inserted in the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939,
by Amending Act 56 of 1969. The said section is applicable only where the
death or bodily injury caused to a person gives rise to a valid claim for
compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, as well as a claim for
compensation under Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923. The said section
prohibits the applicants from making double recovery of compensation by
invoking both the Acts. If the application for compensation made before
the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal is rejected on the ground that the
deceased himself was negligently driving the tractor in question it can
hardly be said that the death of the deceased gave rise to a valid claim for
compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939. If the claim for
compensation made under Motor Vehicles Act could not be entertained by
the Claims Tribunal for want of valid cause of action or for want of proof
in respect of negligence of the driver causing the accident as alleged,
section 110-AA of Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, can never be applied so as to
bar the claim for compensation under Workmen’s Compensation Act,
1923. Even if the deceased was himself negligently driving the tractor
leading to the accident in question, the claim for compensation
under Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923, may be still maintainable
against the employer concerned or against the insurance company if the
deceased died as a result of an accident which took place during the
course of employment of the deceased. Section 3, Workmen’s
Compensation Act provides for statutory liability of the employer to pay
compensation to the workman or his dependants if the death or personal
injury is caused by accident arising out of and in the course of
employment of the workman concerned. The criterion to be applied for
determination of an application for compensation under the Workmen’s
Compensation Act, 1923, is somewhat different from the criterion to be
applied for determination of a claim for compensation under section 110A of Motor Vehicles Act, 1939.
***
8. The learned counsel for the respondent No. 2 has submitted that
Motor Accident Claim No. 35 of 1980 was not rejected for lack of
jurisdiction but was rejected on merits. The learned counsel for
1994 SCC OnLine Bom 205
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:51:47
FAO 300/2018
respondent No. 2 has submitted that the bar created by section 110-AA of
the above-referred Act was thus clearly attracted. The language of section
110-AA of the Act is clear and specific on this aspect. In this case, the
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal held that the death of the deceased
Arjun Mahadeo Salunkhe did not give rise to a claim for compensation
under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, as the deceased was himself
negligently driving the tractor. In substance, the Tribunal held that the
appellants had no cause of action for making the claim for compensation
under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939. In view of the above, I have no
hesitation in rejecting this submission of the learned counsel for the
respondent No. 2.
9. The learned Commissioner for Workmen’s Compensation held
that the party had a choice to make a claim before either of the two forums
and once the claim was made before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal,
no claim could be made for compensation in respect of the same accident
invoking Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923. The proposition formulated
by the trial court is too wide and is incorrect. In my opinion, the learned
Commissioner for Workmen’s Compensation was clearly in error.”
11.
This Court concurs the afore-extracted opinion rendered by the
Bombay High Court. In view of the above discussion, this Court is of the
considered view that the learned Commissioner erred in dismissing the
appellant’s claim as not maintainable. Accordingly, the impugned order is
set aside, and the matter is remanded back to the Trial Court for adjudication
of the appellant’s claim on merits.
12.
The matter be listed at the first instance before the concerned
Principal District and Sessions Judge on 28.01.2026, for directions.
13.
Considering that the matter has been pending for considerable time,
the Trial Court is requested to make an endeavour to dispose of the matter as
expeditiously as possible.
MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 13, 2026/pmc
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:51:47
FAO 300/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review