Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:31509
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
COPC No.
: 525 of 2025
a/w COPCs No. 916 of 2024;
344, 378, 524 & 527 of 2025
Reserved on
:
14.07.2026
Decided on
:
30.07.2026
Uploaded on
:
30.07.2026
1. COPC No. 525 of 2025
Upma Handa and others
…Petitioners
Versus
Sharwan Manta
…Respondent
…………………………………………………………………………….
2. COPC No. 916 of 2024
Gopal Singh Kanwar and others
…Petitioners
Versus
Sharwan Manta
…Respondent
…………………………………………………………………………….
3. COPC No. 344 of 2025
Chain Singh Kanwar and others
…Petitioners
Versus
Sharwan Manta
…Respondent
…………………………………………………………………………….
4. COPC No. 378 of 2025
Diwan Chand and others
…Petitioners
Versus
2026:HHC:31509
Sharwan Manta
…Respondent
…………………………………………………………………………….
5. COPC No. 524 of 2025
Pushpa Sharma and others
…Petitioners
Versus
Sharwan Manta
…Respondent
…………………………………………………………………………….
6. COPC No. 527 of 2025
Lajender Singh Tomar and others
…Petitioners
Versus
Sharwan Manta
…Respondent
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioner(s) :
Mr. Onkar Jairath, Senior
Advocate, assisted by Dr. Lalit
Kumar Sharma, Mr. Nitin
Thakur, Mr. Anshul Jairath,
and Mr. Vanshaj Sharma,
Advocates.
For the respondent(s) :
Mr. Dilip Sharma, Senior
Advocate, assisted by Mr.
Munish Sharma, Advocate.
Virender Singh, Judge.
The above-titled contempt petitions are being
decided by this common order, as, all these contempt
Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2026:HHC:31509
petitions have been filed in CWPs No. 660 of 2018, 76 of
2020, 321 of 2020 and 860 of 2020, decided by this Court,
on 28th March, 2024.
2.
By way of judgment, dated 28th March, 2024,
this Court has decided a bunch of petitions, alongwith the
above-named writ petitions.
3.
As per the record, the judgment, dated 28 th
March, 2024, had been assailed before the Division Bench
of this Court, by way of LPA No. 242 of 2024, which was
dismissed, on 4th October, 2024.
4.
By way of the contempt petitions in hand, a
prayer has been made to initiate contempt proceedings,
against the respondent, for willful disobedience of the
judgment, passed by this Court.
5.
While deciding the above-noted writ petitions,
vide judgment, dated 28th March, 2024, this Court has
granted the following relief, to the petitioners therein:
“19. Consequently in view of the detailed
discussion made hereinabove as well as law
taken into consideration, this Court finds
merit in the present petitions and accordingly
same are allowed and impugned order dated
12.12.2017 passed by respondent No. 2, in
all the petitions, is quashed and set-aside
and amount, if any, recovered on account of
the recovery proceedings, shall be refunded
2026:HHC:31509
to the petitioners alongwith upto date
interest. Pending applications, if any, also
stands disposed of.”
6.
It is not in dispute that this Court, vide
judgment, dated 28th March, 2024, has quashed the order,
dated 12th December, 2017, passed by respondent No. 2
and directed the respondents to refund the amount, if any,
recovered,
on
account
of
the
recovery
proceedings.
However, by way of the above-titled contempt petitions, a
prayer has been made that by virtue of judgment, dated
28th March, 2024, the order, dated 12th December, 2017,
passed by respondent No. 2, has been quashed, as such,
their pay is required to be re-fixed, which has not been
done by the respondent.
7.
The
prayer
for
initiating
the
contempt
proceedings has been made, on the ground, that despite
the judgment, passed by this Court, quashing the order,
dated 12th December, 2017, when the salary for the month
of September was credited into the accounts of the
petitioners, they realized that their salary has been
reduced. The said act of the respondent is stated to be not
2026:HHC:31509
only contrary to the orders, passed by this Court, but, also
contemptuous.
8.
On the basis of the above facts, a prayer has
been made to punish the respondent, for contempt of the
Court.
9.
Reply has been filed, in COPCs No. 916 of 2024
and 344 of 2025, in which, the factual position has not
been disputed, but, it has been prayed that all the
directions of this Court have been complied with and by
way of filing the Contempt Petitions, the petitioners cannot
claim the relief, which has not been granted to them, by
the Court.
10.
According to the respondent, there was no
order, with respect to re-fixation of the pay of the
petitioners, nor, there was any direction to restore their
pay.
11.
As such, a prayer has been made to dismiss the
contempt petitions.
12.
Rejoinder to the reply has been filed in COPC
No. 916 of 2024, denying the stand, as taken by the
2026:HHC:31509
respondent, in the reply and it has been prayed that the
respondents are guilty of contempt of the Court.
13.
In the lead case, i.e. CWP No. 660 of 2018, the
petitioners had made the following prayer:
“(i) That the impugned order dated 24.3.2018
(Annexure P-10) passed by respondent No. 2,
may kindly be quashed and set-aside.
(ii) That the impugned order dated 12.12.2017
(Annexure
P-8),
letter
dated
9.2.2018
(Annexure P-6) and recovery notice dated
15.2.2018
(Annexure
P-7)
passed
by
respondents No. 2 and 3 respectively, may
kindly be set-aside and quashed.
(iii) That after setting aside the orders dated
12.12.2017 (Annexure P-8), letter dated
9.2.2018 (Annexure P-6) and recovery notice
dated 15.2.2018 (Annexure P-7), respondent
No. 3 may kindly be directed to restore the
salary of the petitioners as drawn in February,
2018 prior to the issuance of the recovery
notice.
(iv) That the respondent No. 3 may further be
directed to release the less paid salary for the
month of February, 2018 onwards to the
petitioners.”
14.
After considering the rival contentions of the
parties, this Court, has passed the order, dated 28 th March,
2024, operative portion of which, has been reproduced
hereinabove.
15.
In
this
backdrop,
considering
the
limited
jurisdiction of this Court, under the Contempt of Courts
2026:HHC:31509
Act, the material question, which arises for determination,
before this Court, is as to whether any action can be taken
against the respondent, for willful disobedience of the
orders, passed by this Court, whereas, it is not in dispute
that the directions, as contained in para 19 of the
judgment, dated 28th March, 2024, have been complied
with.
16.
In this regard, it would be profitable for this
Court to make reference to the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, in Sudhir Vasudeva, Chairman and
Managing Director, Oil and Natural Gas Corporation
Limited and others versus M. George Ravishekaran and
others, reported in (2014) 3 Supreme Court Cases 373,
wherein, it has been held that the power to punish for
contempt is a special and rare power and the very nature
of the power, casts a sacred duty, in the Courts, to exercise
the same with great care and caution and the Courts must
not travel beyond the four corners of the order, which is
alleged to have been flouted.
Relevant para-19 of the
judgment, is reproduced, as under:
“19. The power vested in the High Courts as
well as this Court to punish for contempt is a
2026:HHC:31509
special and rare power available both under
the Constitution as well as the Contempt of
Courts Act, 1971. It is a drastic power which,
if misdirected, could even curb the liberty of
the individual charged with commission of
contempt. The very nature of the power casts a
sacred duty in the Courts to exercise the same
with the greatest of care and caution. This is
also necessary as, more often than not,
adjudication of a contempt plea involves a
process of self-determination of the sweep,
meaning and effect of the order in respect of
which disobedience is alleged. The Courts
must not, therefore, travel beyond the four
corners of the order which is alleged to have
been flouted or enter into questions that have
not been dealt with or decided in the judgment
or the order violation of which is alleged. Only
such directions which are explicit in a
judgment or order or are plainly self-evident
ought to be taken into account for the purpose
of consideration as to whether there has been
any disobedience or wilful violation of the
same. Decided issues cannot be reopened; nor
can the plea of equities be considered. The
Courts must also ensure that while
considering a contempt plea the power
available to the Court in other corrective
jurisdictions like review or appeal is not
trenched upon. No order or direction
supplemental to what has been already
expressed should be issued by the Court while
exercising jurisdiction in the domain of the
contempt law; such an exercise is more
appropriate in other jurisdictions vested in the
Court, as noticed above. The above principles
would appear to be the cumulative outcome of
the precedents cited at the Bar, namely,
Jhareswar Prasad Paul v. Tarak Nath
Ganguly, (2002) 5 SCC 352, V.M. Manohar
Prasad v. N. Ratnam Raju, (2004) 13 SCC 610,
Bihar Finance Service House Construction
Coop. Society Ltd. v. Gautam Goswami, (2008)
5 SCC 339; and Union of India v. Subedar
Devassy PV, (2006) 1 SCC 613.”
(self emphasis supplied)
17.
2026:HHC:31509
Being guided by the above decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, this Court is of the view that the
petitioners have miserably failed to make out a case to
initiate
the
proceedings,
as
prayed,
in
the
present
petitions.
18.
The
contempt
petitions
are
disposed
of,
accordingly, with liberty to the petitioners to approach the
Court, in case, their grievances still remain to be
redressed, by taking recourse to appropriate proceedings.
An attested copy of this order be placed on the
all the connected files.
( Virender Singh )
Judge
July 30, 2026
( rajni )
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review