Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.20584 of 2025
======================================================
Gopal Kumar s/o Kedar Prasad Sharma, R/o Walipur, P.S. Pipariya, DistrictLakhisarai, Bihar 811311.
... ... Petitioner
Versus
1.
The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Rural Works Department,
Government of Bihar, Patna.
2.
Secretary, Rural Works Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
3.
The Engineer-in-Chief, Rural Works Department, Patna, Bihar.
4.
The Chief Engineer (Technical), Rural Works Department.
5.
The Chief Engineer- 3, Rural Works Department, Patna, Bihar.
6.
Nodal Officer, Sulabh Samparkta Yojana Scheme, Rural Works Department.
7.
The Superintending Engineer, work Zone, Ara, Rural Works Department.
8.
The Superintending Engineer, Work Zone, Munger, Rural Works
Department.
9.
Techinal Bid Review Committee, Rural Works Department, Patna.
10. Patliputra Infra Construction Private Limted, Gola Road Bailey Road, Patna801503.
11. S.B. Engicon Private Limited, Royal City, West Judges Colony, Saguna
Patna, 801503.
... ... Respondents
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner
:
For the Respondent No.10 :
For the Respondent No.11 :
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Shekhar Singh, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Kumar Anjaney Sharma, Advocate
Mr. Shubham, Advocate
Mr. Ranvir Pratap Singh, Advocate
Ms. Shambhavi Singh, Advocate
Mr. Anand Kumar Ojha-1, Advocate
Mr. Bachan Jee Ojha, Advocate
Mr. Amish Kumar, AC to AG
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR SINGH
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SHAILENDRA SINGH
ORAL JUDGMENT
(Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR SINGH)
Date : 02-04-2026
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
2/17
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2. In the present petition, the petitioner has prayed for the
following relief(s):"i. Issuance of an appropriate writ/s, order/s or
direction/s, particularly in the nature of writ of
Certiorari for quashing and setting aside the
impugned
decision/order
dated
06.10.2025
and
02.12.2025 passed by the Technical Evaluation
Committee, Rural Works Department whereby the
Petitioner's technical bid submitted under Notice
Inviting Tender Bearing No. RWD/SSY/HQ/ET/202526 Dated 28.07.2025 for construction and six year
operation & management including surface renewal
for rural road/bridge under component of Sulabh
Samparakta Yojana (SSY) described as 'Konipar Baba
Sthan se Variyarpur Tak aur Gopalpari ka Konipur
PWD Sadak tak Path Nirman(Tender ID-143842) has
been arbitrarily, illegally and without authority of law
disqualified from the technical bid stage.
ii. Issuance of an appropriate writ/s, order/s or
direction/s, particularly in the nature of writ of
Mandamus to Declare the Petitioner, technically
qualified for participation in the tender process under
Notice
Inviting
Tender
RWD/SSY/HQ/ET/2025-26
Dated
Bearing
No.
28.07.2025
for
construction and six year operation & management
including surface renewal for rural road/bridge under
component of Sulabh Samparakta Yojana (SSY)
described as 'Konipar Baba Sthan se Variyarpur Tak
aur Gopalpari ka Konipur PWD Sadak tak Path
Nirman (Tender ID-143842) and to include the
Petitioner's bid in the financial bid evaluation stage of
the tender process without any further delay.
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
3/17
iii. Issuance of an appropriate writ/s, order/s or
direction/s, particularly in the nature of writ of
Mandamus, for declaration of respondent no.11 to be
the lowest bidder Notice Inviting Tender Bearing No.
RWD/SSY/HQ/ET/2025-26
Dated
28.07.2025
for
construction and six year operation & management
including surface renewal for rural road/bridge under
component
of
Sulabh
Samparakta
Yojana(SSY)
described as 'Konipar Baba Sthan se Variyarpur Tak
aur Gopalpari ka Konipur PWD Sadak tak Path
Nirman'(Tender ID-143842) to be illegal, arbitrary,
malafide, and void ab initio, being the outcome of a
tainted and procedurally defective evaluation process.
iv. Issuance of an appropriate writ/s, order/s or
direction/s, particularly in the nature of writ of
Mandamus to direct the respondent authorities to
reconsider the Petitioner's bid by declaring the
Petitioner technically qualified, open the Petitioner's
financial bid, and thereafter award the tender in
favour of the Petitioner.
v. To direct the Respondents restraining them from
giving effect to or executing any work order/contract
agreement pending final adjudication of the present
writ petition.
vi. Any other relief/reliefs as Your Lordships may think
fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the
case."
3. The brief facts of the case are that the Rural Works
Department, Government of Bihar, issued a Notice Inviting Tender dated
28.07.2025 bearing No. RWD/SSY/HQ/ET/2025-26 for construction and
six-year operation and maintenance of a rural road/bridge project under
the Sulabh Samparakta Yojana (SSY). Pursuant thereto, the petitioner
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
4/17
participated in the tender process and submitted its bid within the
stipulated time. Upon evaluation of technical bids, the Technical Bid
Evaluation Committee, in its meeting dated 08.09.2025, declared the
petitioner technically qualified.
4. Subsequently, a complaint dated 13.09.2025 was
submitted by another bidder alleging non-disclosure of certain prior work
by the petitioner. On the basis of the said complaint, a show cause notice
dated 16.09.2025 was issued to the petitioner, to which the petitioner
submitted a detailed reply on 18.09.2025 along with supporting materials,
stating inter alia that the work referred to in the complaint had already
been proposed to be dropped by the competent authority and did not
constitute an existing or ongoing commitment as on the date of bid
submission. However, upon re-evaluation of the technical bid
on
06.10.2025, the petitioner was technically disqualified by invoking Clause
4.6(3) of the CMBD on the ground of alleged non-disclosure of ongoing
work. Further, in a subsequent re-evaluation held on 02.12.2025, the
petitioner continued to be technically disqualified, and financial bid was
opened.
5. Vide order dated 29.01.2026, notice was issued to
respondent Nos. 10 and 11. In pursuance thereof, learned counsels have
entered appearance on behalf of respondent Nos. 10 and 11 by filing
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
5/17
Vakalatnama, which is taken on record. However, till date, no counter
affidavit has been filed on behalf of the private respondents.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
contention of the respondent-Department that there was alleged nondisclosure of work under Agreement No. 23/SBD/2020-21 is wholly
misconceived, inasmuch as the said work, namely Sharma PMGSY Road
to Godh Tola Harijan Tola Tak under Lakhisarai Division, had already
been proposed to be dropped by the concerned Executive Engineer vide
letter dated 18.06.2024, prior to the last date of submission of the bid.
Agreement No. 23/SBD/2020-21, the details whereof are reproduced as
under:SI. Name of Road
No.
2.
Lenth Constru Maintanance
(KM) ction
Cost
Cost
Sharma PMGSY 1.500 87,73,06 11,79,687
Road to Gadh Tola
Harizan Tola Tak
Agreement
Value
Block
99,52,748
Barahiya
7. It is further submitted that the Executive Engineer, Rural
Works Department, Lakhisarai Division, vide Letter No. 1876 dated
29.08.2025 reiterated the letter dated 18.06.2024 and, had recommended
dropping of the said work. As such, no subsisting obligation remained
upon the petitioner. Extract of letter dated 18.06.2024 is reproduced
hereinbelow:
dk;Zikyd vfHk;ark dk dk;kZy;
xzkeh.k dk;Z foHkkx] dk;Z izeaMy] y[khljk;
____________________________________________________________
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
6/17
i=kad 1125¼vuq0½
y[khljk;@fnukad%& 18@06@24
izs"kd]
bZ0 vk'kqrks"k dqekj
dk;Zikyd vfHk;ark
xzkeh.k dk;Z foHkkx]
dk;Z izeaMy y[khljk;
lsok esa]
v/kh{k.k vfHk;ark
xzkeh.k dk;Z foHkkx]
dk;Z vapy] eqx
a sjA
fo"k;%& MMGSY-NDB BRICS ;kstukUrxZr iFkksa dks Drop djus ds laca/k esAa
egk'k;]
mi;qZDr fo"k; ds laca/k esa dguk gS fd dk;Z izeaMy y[khljk; vUrxZr MMGSY-NDB
BRICS ds fuEu iFkksa dks Drop izLrko izfrosnu fofgr izi= esa rS;kj dj vko';d dkjZokbZ gsrq
lefiZr dh tkrh gSA iFkksa dh lwph fuEu gS%&
dz0
iFk dk uke
iSdst la[;k
Jaitpur Khutha Road to Dhobi Tola Dhaanuk Tola Tirasali
Tola Primary School Tak
MMSGY-NDB-BRRP-113
L028 Nahar Path to Mandal Tola (Behrama)
MMSGY-NDB-BRRP-113
T01 to Koriya Dayal Tola
MMSGY-NDB-BRRP-113
T012 ODR to Ofapur Mushari
MMSGY-NDB-BRRP-113
L091 to Mankatha
MMSGY-NDB-BRRP-113
Sharma PMGSY Road to Gadh Tola Harizan Tola Tak
MMSGY-NDB-BRRP-192
PMGSY Jankidih to North Yadav Tola Basathpul
MMSGY-NDB-BRRP-193
vuq0&;FkksDRkA
fo'oklHkktu
g0@&18@06@24
dk;Zikyd vfHk;ark
xzkeh.k dk;Z foHkkx]
dk;Z izeaMy y[khljk;
To be Dropped Road List of MMGSY-NDB (BRICS)
SI.No.
Name of Roads
Division
Project ID
Administrati
ve Approval
Cost
(In
lakh)
Administrati Length
ve Approval Km)
Reference
i.e.
Letter
No./Date of
Serial no
Jaitpur
Khutha Lakhisarai
Road to Dhobi
Tola
Dharmuk
Tola Tiresali Tola
Lakhisarai
20804001902
58.215
1054/04.12. 0.917
2018 & Sr
No-24
0.000
Constructed
By
Panchayat
Scheme
L028 Nahar Path Lakhisarai
to Mandal Tola
(Behrama)
Lakhisarai
20804001911
117.00
1054/04.12. 2.035
2018 & Sr
No-33
0.000
Habitation
Already
Connected
T01 to Koriya Lakhisarai
Dayal Tola
Lakhisarai
20804001912
69.950
1054/04.12. 1.007
2018 & Sr
No-34
0.000
Habitation
Already
Connected
T012
Lakhisarai
20804001913
42.030
1054/04.12.
0.000
Constructed
ODR
District
to Lakhisarai
0.569
(In Expenditure If Reasons for Remarks
Any
dropping
(in lakh)
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
7/17
Ofapur Mushari
2018 & Sr
No-35
By
Panchayat
Scheme
T019 Mankatha
Lakhisarai
Lakhisarai
20804001914
66.020
1054/04.12. 1.359
2018 & Sr
No-36
0.000
Railway
Land
Allignment
Not
Available
Sharma PMGSY Lakhisarai
Road to Gadh Tola
Harizan Tola Tak
Lakhisarai
2080400190023 100.667
101/24.01.2 1.500
020 & Sr
No-32
0.000
Constructed
By
Other
Scheme
PMGSY Jankidih Lakhisarai
to North Yadav
Tola Basathpul
Lakhisarai
2080400190025 103.843
101/24.01.2 1.377
020 & Sr
No-34
0.000
Constructed
By
Other
Scheme
1. Certified that the following works sanctioned by Rural Works
Department under MMGSY-NDB (BRICS) are proposed to be dropped by division
for reasons indicated in each case.
2. If Any expenditure already incurred on these roads from the funds
released by department for any activity has been recouped by the division. This has
been reflected on the MIS also (If no expenditure has been incurred the same may be
stated).
3. It is further certified that fresh proposals for sanction of these roads
will not be sought by the division under MMGSY-NDB (BRICS)
4. It is also certified that the amount incurred in respect of the roads
already dropped by the Ministry has been recouped from the division and credited to
MMGSY funds and is reflected on MIS.
Sd/-
Sd/-
Sd/-
RWD (WD), Lakhisarai
EE
RWD (WD), LAKHISARAI"
S.E.
8. Further, extract of letter no. 1876 dated 29.08.2025 is
reproduced hereinbelow:
“dk;Zikyd vfHk;ark dk dk;kZy;
xzkeh.k dk;Z foHkkx] dk;Z izeaMy] y[khljk;
i=kad 1876¼vuq0½------ @ y[khljk;@fnukad%& 29-08-25 @
izs"kd]
bZ0 vk'kqrks"k dqekj
dk;Zikyd vfHk;ark]
xzkeh.k dk;Z foHkkx]
dk;Z izeaMy y[khljk;
lsok esa]
v/kh{k.k vfHk;ark
xzkeh.k dk;Z foHkkx]
dk;Z vapy] eqxa sjA
fo"k;%& MMGSY-NDB (BRICS) ;kstuk vUrxZr vkB ¼8½ iFkksa dks Drop djus ds laca/k esaA
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
8/17
egk'k;]
mi;qZDr fo"k;d izklafxd i= ds }kjk MMGSY-NDB (BRICS) ;kstuk vUrxZr fuEu vkB ¼8½ iFkksa dks Drop
djus gsrq fofgr izi= esa okafNr lwpuk vxzrsj dkjZokbZ gsrq lefiZr dh tkrh gSA
1. Jaitpur Khutha Road to Dhobi Tola Dhaanuk Tola Tirasali Tola Primary School Tak
2. L028 Nahar Path to Mandal Tola (Behrama)
3. T01 to Koriya Dayal Tola
4. T012 ODR to Ofapur Mushari
5. L091 to Mankatha
6. L041 Pathua to Kanharpur
7. PMGSY PMGSY JANKIDIH to NORTH YADAV TOLA BASTHPUL
8. Sharma PMGSY Road to Gadh Tola Harizan Tola Tak
vr% vuqjks/k gS fd mijksDRk iFk dks Drop djus dh d`ik dh tk,A
vuq0&;FkksDRkA
fo'oklHkktu
g0@&29@08@25
dk;Zikyd vfHk;ark
xzkeh.k dk;Z foHkkx]
dk;Z izeaMy y[khljk;
9. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that once
the department itself had taken a conscious decision to drop the work, the
same could not have been treated as an ‘existing commitment’ or
‘ongoing work’ requiring disclosure. The disqualification on such ground
is, therefore, arbitrary and unsustainable, particularly when the alleged
omission does not constitute a material deviation that would affect the bid
capacity of the petitioner.
10. Learned counsel for the respondent-State submits that the
disqualification is in strict conformity with the terms and conditions of the
Notice Inviting Tender and the provisions of the CMBD. It is submitted
that Clause 4.2(m) of the CMBD mandates disclosure of existing
commitments and ongoing construction works, which reads as under:
"4.2(m) Existing commitments and ongoing construction work
being undertaken by the bidder shall be submitted in
prescribed format as described in qualification criteria."
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
9/17
11. It is further submitted that Clause 4.6 of the CMBD
provides for determination of available bid capacity, wherein the value of
existing commitments and ongoing works is a crucial component, and
Explanation 3 thereto specifically requires disclosure even of such works
which are pending. Clause 4.6 of the CMBD, reads as under:"4.6 Bidders who meet the minimum qualification criteria will
be qualified only if their available bid capacity is more than
the total bid value. The available bid capacity will be
calculated as under :
Assessed Available Bid capacity = (A*N*M – B)
Where
A = Maximum value of civil engineering works executed in
any one year during the last five financial years {updated
@8% per year to the price level of the preceding financial year
in which bids are invited as specified in NIT} taking into
account the completed as well as works in progress.
N = Number of years prescribed for completion of Initial
Rectification,
Minor
improvement,
Surface
renewal,
Construction of bridge/drainage /protection for which bids are
invited (period up to 6 months to be taken as half-year and
more than 6 months as one year).
M =3
B = Value, at the current price level, of existing commitments
and on- going works to be completed during the period of
completion of Initial Rectification, Minor improvement,
Surface renewal, Construction of bridge/drainage /protection
for which bids are invited.
Explanation1. The Existing Commitment shall be the value of the
remaining work, which has already been awarded to the bidder
as on the date of submission of bid.
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
10/17
2. The value of the remaining work should be calculated on
the basis of the value of work as recorded in measurement
book till the date of submission of bid, by bidder.
3. In case of Land dispute, Forest Land issue, pending for
Foreclosure or drop etc., the bidder must mention such work
in the remarks column of the Existing commitments and
ongoing construction work related format in clause 1.3.2(A) of
Section III Qualification Information. However, In this regard,
if the bidders attach any request letter in bid regarding not
subtracting the remaining amount to calculate the available bid
capacity, the same may be considered after due verification.
4. Further the value of any work awarded to the bidder in the
period between the submission of bid and award of the present
work shall also be counted as existing commitment.
5. In case of EPC and similar nature Contracts, the existing
commitment shall be counted from the appointment date or as
mentioned in respective contract document. Construction of
road/bridge for which bids are invited."
12. Learned counsel for the respondents further submits that
the State Government has also issued a clarification dated 20.05.2025
explaining the scope of ‘existing commitments/ ongoing construction
work’, wherein it has been clarified that bidders are required to disclose
not only works in progress but also such works which, for any reason
including land disputes or other impediments, are not being executed,
along with reasons for pendency. The contents of the said letter dated
20.05.2025 are reproduced as under:
"xzkeh.k dk;Z foHkkx
fcgkj ljdkj
izsl foKfIr
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
11/17
,rn~ lacaf/kr laosndksa dks xzkeh.k dk;Z foHkkx] fcgkj }kjk fuxZr Combined Model
Bidding Document (CMBD) dh dafMdk 4-2(m) dks fuEu :i ls Li"V fd;k tkrk gS%&
"Existing Commitments and ongoing construction work being
undertaken by the bidder shall be submitted in prescribed format as
described in qualification Criteria"
bl laca/k esa ;g Li"V fd;k tkrk gS fd foHkkxh; fufonkvksa esa Hkkx ysus okys
fufonkdkj fufonk esa Existing Commitments and ongoing construction work esa
Work in Progress okys dk;kZsa ds vfrfjDr mu lHkh dk;ksZa tks fdlh Hkh dkj.k ;Fkk Hkwfe
fookn] ou foHkkx ,oa vU; dkj.kksa ls izxfr esa ugha gS ,oa yfEcr gS mu dk;ksZa dks yfEcr j[kus
ds dkj.kksa dks Li"V djrs gq, vius Existing Commitments and ongoing
construction work esa foLr`r :i ls mYys[k vfuok;Zr% djsaxsA
g0@&
20@05@2025
vfHk;ark izeq[k&lg&
vij vk;qDr&lg&fo'ks"k lfpo
xzkeh.k dk;Z foHkkx
13. It is, therefore, submitted by the learned counsel for the
respondents that the action of the respondents is fair, reasonable, and in
consonance with the tender conditions, leaving no scope for judicial
interference in a contractual matter of this nature.
14. Learned counsel for the private respondents adopts the
arguments advanced by the counsel for the respondent-State.
15. The limited issue which arises for consideration before this
Court is as to whether the respondents were justified in disqualifying the
petitioner on the ground of non-disclosure of a work under Agreement
No. 23/SBD/2020-21, which had already been proposed to be dropped by
the competent authority prior to the date of submission of the bid, and
whether such work could be treated as an ‘existing commitment/ongoing
work’ within the meaning of the relevant clauses of the CMBD.
16. The issue in the present case relates to the interpretation of
the expression ‘existing commitments/ongoing construction work’ as
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
12/17
stated in Clause 4.2(m) and Clause 4.6 of the Combined Model Bidding
Document (CMBD). Clause 4.2(m) requires a bidder to disclose ‘existing
commitments and ongoing construction work being undertaken’, whereas
Clause 4.6 provides for determination of ‘available bid capacity’,
wherein the value of ‘existing commitments and ongoing works to be
completed’ is to be taken into account. Explanation 1 to Clause 4.6
further clarifies that ‘existing commitment’ means the value of the
remaining work already awarded to the bidder as on the date of
submission of the bid.
17. From a combined reading of the aforesaid provisions, it is
clear that the expression ‘existing commitment’ refers to a subsisting and
enforceable obligation which has a direct bearing on the bidder’s capacity
to execute the work for which tender has been issued. The emphasis is on
the value of work ‘to be completed’, thereby indicating that only such
works which are ongoing and capable of execution fall within its scope.
18. Explanation 3 to Clause 4.6 provides that works pending
for foreclosure or proposed to be dropped in case of land dispute or forest
land issue, are also to be mentioned in the remarks column. Further a
clarification had been issued dated 20.05.2025, which seemingly expands
the meaning of ‘existing commitments’. Such press release cannot
supplant the conditions of CMBD, and at best it can clarify the conditions
of the CMBD.
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
13/17
19. Further, Explanation 3 to Clause 4.6 anticipates only two
situations, i.e., in case of land dispute or forest land issue, where there is
a necessity of the work to be done. However, in case, where the work has
already been completed by another scheme, it cannot be said to be
included within the meaning of ‘existing commitment/ongoing work’.
The letter dated 18.06.2024 clearly stipulates that the said work was not
necessary to be done, as the work was already done under another
scheme.
20. Additionally, the purpose of Explanation 3 read with
clarification dated 20.05.2025 is to ensure proper disclosure and
transparency. The disclosure is for all such works, which are presently
being executed, along with reasons for pendency, if any. A work which
has already been constructed by another scheme cannot be said to
included in such disclosure.
21. In the present case, it is not in dispute that the work under
Agreement No. 23/SBD/2020-21, namely Sharma PMGSY Road to Godh
Tola Harijan Tola Tak under Lakhisarai Division, was proposed to be
dropped by the Executive Engineer vide letter dated 18.06.2024, which
was subsequently accepted by the respondent-State on 04.12.2025. It is
also an admitted position that as on the date of submission of the bid, i.e.,
14.08.2025, no work was to be executed pursuant to the said agreement
as per the letter of the Executive Engineer dated 18.06.2024.
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
14/17
22. It is further significant that though the proposal to drop the
said work was sent in the year 2024, the same was formally approved
only on 04.12.2025. The delay in approval is attributable to the
respondent authorities and cannot be put against the petitioner. In such
circumstances, the petitioner cannot be penalized for such non-disclosure
of a work which had already been proposed to be dropped and in respect
of which no subsisting obligation remained in practical terms.
23. In matters relating to award of contracts, the scope of
judicial review is limited. However, it is well settled that the decisionmaking process must be fair, reasonable, and free from arbitrariness. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Montecarlo Ltd. v. NTPC Ltd. reported in
(2016) 15 SCC 272, has held that though the employer is the best judge
of the interpretation of tender conditions, such interpretation must be
reasonable and not arbitrary, and the Court can interfere where the
decision is irrational. The relevant part of the judgment reads as follows:
“26. We respectfully concur with the aforesaid statement of
law. We have reasons to do so. In the present scenario, tenders
are floated and offers are invited for highly complex technical
subjects. It requires understanding and appreciation of the
nature of work and the purpose it is going to serve. It is
common knowledge in the competitive commercial field that
technical bids pursuant to the notice inviting tenders are
scrutinised by the technical experts and sometimes third-party
assistance
from
those
unconnected
with
the
owner's
organisation is taken. This ensures objectivity. Bidder's
expertise and technical capability and capacity must be
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
15/17
assessed by the experts. In the matters of financial assessment,
consultants are appointed. It is because to check and ascertain
that technical ability and the financial feasibility have
sanguinity and are workable and realistic. There is a multiprong complex approach; highly technical in nature. The
tenders where public largesse is put to auction stand on a
different compartment. Tender with which we are concerned, is
not comparable to any scheme for allotment. This arena which
we have referred requires technical expertise. Parameters
applied are different. Its aim is to achieve high degree of
perfection in execution and adherence to the time schedule.
But, that does not mean, these tenders will escape scrutiny of
judicial review. Exercise of power of judicial review would be
called for if the approach is arbitrary or mala fide or
procedure adopted is meant to favour one. The decisionmaking process should clearly show that the said maladies are
kept at bay...”
24. In the present case, the interpretation adopted by the
respondents treats even a work which had been proposed to be dropped
and was not being executed as an ‘existing commitment’. Such an
interpretation, in the opinion of this Court, is unreasonable and contrary
to the object of Clause 4.6, which is to assess the actual capacity of a
bidder. The purpose of disclosure of existing commitments is to assess
the real workload of the bidder. A work which is not being executed and
in respect of which the department itself has initiated steps for dropping
(as being constructed by another scheme) cannot be equated with an
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
16/17
ongoing and subsisting commitment where there is necessity of work to
be done.
25. In such circumstances, this Court is of the considered view
that the said work cannot be treated as an ‘existing commitment’ or
‘ongoing work’ within the meaning of Clause 4.6. Mere existence of an
agreement, without any subsisting or enforceable obligation, would not
attract the requirement of disclosure so as to entail disqualification.
26. It is further noted that in the impugned decision after reevaluation of the technical bid of the petitioner, dated 06.10.2025, there is
no consideration on the plea taken by the petitioner, nor they have
assigned any reason to reject the contention of the petitioner. Therefore,
the impugned decision is also in violation of the principles of natural
justice.
27. The action of the respondents in treating the said work as
an ‘existing commitment’ and disqualifying the petitioner on such ground
is, therefore, arbitrary and not in consonance with the terms of the
bidding document.
28. In view of the discussions made herein above, this Court is
of the view that the non-disclosure of the said work does not amount to a
material lapse affecting the petitioner’s bid, and consequently, the
impugned decisions dated 06.10.2025 as contained in Annexure – P/6,
Patna High Court CWJC No.20584 of 2025 dt.02-04-2026
17/17
and 02.12.2025 as contained in Annexure – P/8 series, cannot be
sustained in law and are, hereby, set aside.
29. Accordingly, this writ petition stands allowed.
30. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(Sudhir Singh, J.)
(Shailendra Singh, J.)
Gaurav Kumar/AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE
Uploading Date
Transmission Date
A.F.R.
N.A.
07.04.2026
N.A.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review