Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRM-M-1323-20
2026 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH
H
COURT OF PUNJAB
JAB A
AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
ARH
CRM-M-1323-2026 (O&M)
GOLDI @ GOLD
GOLDI PALIWAL
... Petitioner
oner
Versus
STATE OF PUNJAB
PUNJ
...Respondent
dent
The
he date
dat when the judgment is reserved
served
The
he date
dat when the judgment is pronoun
onounced
The
he date
dat when the judgment is uploaded
loaded on the
website
ebsite
Whethe
hether only operative part of thee judg
judgment is
pronoun
ronounced or whether the full judgmen
dgment is
pronoun
ronounced
The
he delay,
del if any, of the pronouncement
cement of full
judgme
dgment and reasons thereof.
05.05.2026
08.05.2026
08.05.2026
Full
Not applicable
CORAM: HON'BLE
HON
MRS. JUSTICE MANIS
ANISHA BATRA
Present:
Mr. Satnam Singh Gill, Advocate
ate for the petitioner
Mr. Roshandeep
R
Singh, AAG, Punjab for respondent
****
MANISHA BATR
BATRA, J.
1.
The instant one is the sixth petition
etition filed by the petitioner under
nder
Section 483 of Bharatiya
Bh
Nagarik Suraksha Sanh
Sanhita, 2023 (for short “BNSS”)
SS”)
for grant of regular
regul bail in case arising out
ut of F
FIR No.248 dated 19.10.2022
registered under
nder Section
S
22 of Narcotic Drugs
gs and Psychotropic Substances Act,,
1985 (for short
ort “N
“NDPS Act”) at Police Station
on City Rajpura, District Patiala.
2.
As per
pe the allegations on 19.10.2022
0.2022, the petitioner was found
d in
conscious possess
ossession of 34,000 intoxicant tablets of Alprazolam and Tramadol
adol
HCL. The previo
previous petitions as filed by the
he pet
petitioner had been dismissed
d on
AMIT SHARMA
2026.05.08 14:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-1323-20
2026 (O&M)
different dates.
tes.
The last petition had been dismissed on 23.09.2025
5 by
observing that
hat o
out of 13 only 03 prosecution
ecution witnesses remained to
o be
examined.
3.
The main
m thrust of argument off learn
learned counsel for the petitioner
er is
that even after
ter dis
dismissal of his previous petition,
tition, a period of 08 months and
d 15
days has elapsed
lapsed, however, there has been
en no progress in the trial as 03
prosecution witnesses
witne
still remain to be examin
xamined. He has already suffered
fered
incarceration
n for a period of 03 years, 06 months
onths and 15 days. His prolonged
nged
incarceration
n mil
militates against his fundamenta
mental rights of personal liberty
berty
guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution
ution of India. His antecedentss are
clean. Each
h day spent by him in custody has fu
furnished him a new ground
d to
move bail afresh
fresh ffor seeking concession of bail. It is, therefore, urged thatt the
petition deserves
erves to
t be allowed.
4.
Per contra,
c
learned State counsel
nsel hhas argued that this one is a
successive petition
etition without there being any subst
substantial or drastic change in
n the
circumstances
es and hence, the petition doess not deserve to be allowed. It is,
therefore, urged
rged th
that the petition is liable to be dism
dismissed.
5.
This Court
C
has heard the rival submis
ubmissions made by learned counsel
unsel
for the parties
es at co
considerable length.
6.
Undis
Undisputedly
this is the sixth petition
etition for grant of regular bail. Two
petitions as filed by the petitioner had been dism
ismissed as withdrawn, whereas
ereas
others petitions
ons w
were dismissed on differentt dates
dates. However, for the last more
than 08 months,
nths, tthe trial has not proceededd furth
further at all as 03 witnesses still
AMIT SHARMA
2026.05.08 14:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-1323-20
2026 (O&M)
remain to bee exam
examined. The petitioner has alread
already spent a period of more than
03 years, 06 months
mont and 15 days in custody. The allegations against him prima
ma
facie make out a case
c
for commission of thee subj
subject offences by the petitioner.
oner.
So far as thee ques
question of maintainability of this ppetition being successive one
ne is
concerned, it may be mentioned that, an accused
cused hhas a right to move successive
ssive
bail application
tion ffor grant of bail and itt is th
the duty of the Court, while
hile
entertaining such a subsequent bail application,
ion, to consider that any fresh ground
ound
which persuade
ade it to take a view differentt from the one taken in the earlier
arlier
application is made
mad out or not. It is also require
required to be noted that every day
spent by an accus
accused in custody provides a new ccause of action for filing a bail
application under certain circumstances. He ca
cannot be kept in custody for
indefinite period
eriod and
a the bail application can
an be considered even if it is filed
repeatedly. The denial
d
of bail comes with a cond
condition that the prosecution must
press for early
rly completion
com
of the trial. No recove
recovery has been effected from the
petitioner. He has
ha clean antecedents. He is in ccustody since long. It is well
settled proposition
osition of law that grant of bail on acc
account of delay in trial and long
period of incarcera
carceration is to be considered in the li
light of Section 37 of the NDPS
DPS
Act. Reliance
ce in this regard can be placed
ed upo
upon the observations madee by
Hon’ble Apex
x Co
Court in Mohd. Muslim @ Huss
Hussain v. State (NCT of Delhi),
hi),
2023 SCC OnLin
Line SC 352, wherein it was held tthat grant of bail on account
nt of
undue delay in tria
trial cannot be said to be fettered
ttered uunder Section 37 of the NDPS
DPS
Act, given the imperative
im
of Section 436-A
A of C
Cr.P.C. which is applicable
le to
offence under
er the Act. It was also observed that jjails are overcrowded and their
living conditions
itions aare, more often than not, appall
appalling. The danger of unjustified
tified
AMIT SHARMA
2026.05.08 14:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-1323-20
2026 (O&M)
imprisonment
nt is that inmates are more likely to be hardened rather than
reformed. Relianc
eliance can also be placed upon Man
Manmandal and Another v. State
tate
of West Bengal,
al, S
Special Leave Petition (Criminal
inal) No.8656 of 2023 decided on
14.09.2023 and
nd Rabi
R
Prakash v. State of Odis
Odisha, 2023 LiveLaw (SC) 533,
33,
wherein the Hon’ble
Hon’b Supreme Court had extended
tended benefit of bail to the accused
used
who had been
een incarcerated
in
for a long period
eriod by observing that prolonged
nged
incarceration
n milit
militated against the most precious
ecious fundamental right guaranteed
teed
under Article
le 21 o
of the Constitution and in such a situation, the constitutional
ional
principles must
ust ov
override the statutory embargo
argo ccontained under Section 37
7 of
the NDPS Act.
7.
Relia
Reliance
can also be placed upon Santosh Pawar Vs. State of
Chhattishgarh
h & Anr., Criminal Appeal No.48
o.4883/2025, which is a recently
ently
pronounced verdic
verdict of Hon’ble Supreme Court
ourt ob
observing that rigors of Section
ction
37 of NDPS Act will
w not be a bar for considering
ering the case of an accused forr bail
as it comes with a condition that the prosecuti
osecution would press for an early
completion of trial.
tria In the above-mentionedd case
case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
ourt
held that appella
lant who was being prosecuted
ecuted for being in possession
n of
commercial quantity
quant of narcotic substance, was eentitled for bail in view off her
incarceration
n for a period of 19 months.
8.
Simil
Similarly
in another case i.e. inn the ccase of Satender Kumar Antil
ntil
v. Central Bureau
reau of Investigation, (2022) 100 SC
SCC 51 prolonged incarceration
ation
and inordinate
te delay
del engaged the attention off the H
Hon’ble Supreme Court, which
hich
considered the
he cor
correct approach towards bail,
l, with respect to several enactments,
ents,
including Section
ection 37 NDPS Act. The courtt expre
expressed the opinion that Section
ction
AMIT SHARMA
2026.05.08 14:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-1323-20
2026 (O&M)
436A (which
h requires
requ
inter alia the accused to be enlarged on bail if the trial
ial is
not concluded
ed wit
within specified periods) of the Cr
Criminal Procedure Code, 1973
would apply.
9.
In the
th case of Ismail Khan @ Pa
Pathan vs. State of Rajasthan
an
Crminal Appeal
eal No.4911 of 2025 with regard to recovery of commercial
rcial
quantity of narcotic
narcoti substance, the Hon’ble Supre
Supreme Court accorded the benefit
nefit
of bail to thee accused
accus in view of prolonged incarce
incarceration for a period of 02 years
and 08 months
ths of the
t accused.
10.
Simil benefit has been extended
Similar
ended in another appeal i.e. SLP
LP
No.15699-2025
25 titled
tit
as Ebrahim @ Ibrahim SK vs. The State of West Bengal
gal
and in the case
ase of Pamesh Arora vs. UT Chandig
ndigarh Criminal Appeal No.4872
of 2025.
11.
Even in a recent order dated 05.05
05.05.2026 passed by the Hon’ble
ble
Apex Court in Special
Sp
Leave to Appeal (Crimin
riminal) No.4729 of 2026 titled
ed as
Rajadurai vs.. The
Th State of Tamil Nadu, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
extended benefit
enefit of bail to an accused involve
volved in recovery of commercial
rcial
quantity of ganja
nja after a period of one year on acco
account of his prolonged custody.
12.
On analyzing
an
the peculiar facts
ts and circumstances of the present
esent
case in the light o
of the aforementioned principle
nciples of law, it transpires thatt the
petitioner has
as suffered
suf
prolonged incarceration
ration for a period of 01 year,
r, 11
months and 27 days.
da
The trial is not likely
ly to bbe concluded in near future
re as
only 01 outt of 13
1 prosecution witnesses have been examined so far. The
continued detentio
etention of the petitioner is not likely to serve any fruitful purpose.
pose.
AMIT SHARMA
2026.05.08 14:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-1323-20
2026 (O&M)
There is nothing
hing on
o record to show that if released
leased on bail, the petitioner will
ll not
participate in
n the trial
t
or will abscond.
13.
In view
vie of the above discussion,
n, this Court is of the opinion that
hat a
case is madee out ffor grant of bail to the petitioner
itioner at this stage. Accordingly,, the
petition is allowed
llowed and the petitioner is ordered
ered to be released on bail subject
ct to
his furnishing
g personal
pers
as well as surety bonds
nds to the satisfaction of the learned
rned
trial Court/Chief
hief Judicial
J
Magistrate/Duty Magistr
agistrate concerned.
14.
It is, however, clarified that thee obse
observations made above shalll not
be construed
d as an expression of opinion of this
is C
Court on the merits of the case
and shall nott influ
influence the outcome of the trial
ial in aany manner.
15.
Since the main petition has been all
allowed, pending application,
n, if
any, is rendered
ered in
infructuous.
(MAN
(MANISHA BATRA)
JUDGE
08.05.2026
Amit Sharma
AMIT SHARMA
2026.05.08 14:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
Whether speaking/reasoned:- Yes
Yes/No
Whether reportable:- Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review