Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P. (C) No. 4283 of 2021
--Godfam Investment & Finance Co. Ltd., having its registered office
at 1/42, Azad Garh, Ground Floor, P.O.-Regent Park, P.S.-Jadavpur,
District-Kolkata (West Bengal), through one of its Directors, Sri
Subeg Singh, S/o Late Govind Singh, R/o Shastri Nagar East,
Dhanbad, P.O., P.S. & District-Dhanbad
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. Secretary, Department of Mines and Geology, Government of
Jharkhand, Ranchi
3. District Mining Officer, Dhanbad
4. Assistant Mining Officer, Dhanbad
5. Deputy Commissioner, Dhanbad
6. The State Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority,
Jharkhand, through its Member Secretary, Ranchi
….
.…
Respondents
----CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
----For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Shailesh Kumar Singh, Advocate
For the Res.-State :
Mr. Sachin Kumar, A.A.G.-II
Mr. Srikant Swaroop, A.C. to A.A.G.-II
For the Res. No. 6 :
Mr. Bhanu Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Anuj Sarwesh, Advocate
Mr. Prabhakaran Munda, Advocate
----Reserved on 10.06.2026
Pronounced on 18.06.2026
Per : Rajesh Shankar, J. :
1.
The present writ petition has been filed for quashing the order
dated 16.07.2020 passed by the Secretary, Department of Mines
and Geology, Government of Jharkhand (respondent no. 2)
whereby the request of the petitioner regarding release of the
proportionate bid amount along with the proportionate amount
of royalty, registration fee and stamp duty for the period it was
restrained from operating five (5) sand ghats allotted to it i.e. for
the period between 04.06.2012 to 31.03.2014, has been
rejected. Further prayer has been made for release of the
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
aforesaid proportionate amount in favour of the petitioner
including suitable interest for delayed payment.
2.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that a notice was
published from the office of the Deputy Commissioner, Dhanbad
(respondent no. 5) on 14.07.2011 inviting prospective bidders to
participate in an auction for settlement of right with respect to
twelve (12) sand ghats situated in different circles of the
Dhanbad district for three financial years i.e. 2011-2012, 20122013 and 2013-2014.
3.
The petitioner participated in the aforesaid auction and was
declared successful in respect of five (5) sand ghats situated in
different Panchayats of Tundi circle namely Kolhar, Lukaiya,
Chururiya, Ukma and Mairnwatand.
4.
On 9.8.2011, the Assistant Mining Officer, Dhanbad informed the
petitioner about acceptance of its bid in respect of aforesaid five
sand ghats at the price quoted by it and five separate Letters of
Acceptance were issued showing allotment of the aforesaid sand
ghats in its favour. The said Letters of Acceptance did not contain
any
term
and
condition
about
requirement
of
taking
environmental clearance from the Ministry of Environment and
Forest, Govt. of India (MoEF) or from the State Level
Environment Impact Assessment Authority, Jharkhand (SEIAA).
5.
The petitioner deposited 40% of the bid amount as the first
installment and 10% of the bid price as the earnest money and
commenced its operation from 9.8.2011.
6.
Thereafter, five separate registered mining lease agreements, all
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
dated 05.10.2011 were executed between the petitioner and the
respondent no. 5 in respect of the five sand ghats which also did
not contain any term and condition regarding the petitioner’s
obligation to obtain environmental clearance from MoEF or
SEIAA.
7.
The petitioner paid the second installment of 30% of the bid
amount by February, 2012 as per the terms and conditions of the
agreements. Thus, altogether 80% of the bid amount was
deposited by the petitioner and the remaining 20% of the bid
amount was due to be paid in March, 2013.
8.
It is further contended that the petitioner submitted the monthly
returns of the minor minerals excavated by it till June, 2012 and
accordingly transit challans were issued by the Department of
Mines and Geology, Government of Jharkhand. However, from
July, 2012, the respondents stopped issuing transit challans,
which resulted in stoppage of mining operation from the sand
ghats allotted to the petitioner.
9.
It is also submitted that vide letter no. 883 dated 4.6.2012
addressed to the Director, Mines, Department of Mines and
Geology, Government of Jharkhand (a copy of which was also
communicated to the petitioner), the Assistant Mining Officer,
Dhanbad (respondent no. 4) sought necessary instructions
mentioning inter-alia that the petitioner was demanded the
environmental clearance from MoEF and the consent to operate
from Jharkhand State Pollution Control Board with respect to the
said five sand ghats allotted to it, however it failed to submit the
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
same, which resulted in non-issuance of transit challan.
10. It is asserted that the petitioner vide its letter dated 19.7.2012
replied letter no. 883 dated 4.6.2012 and requested the
Additional Chief Secretary-cum-Mines Commissioner, Jharkhand
to issue transit challans, but the respondents did not issue any
transit challan to it which ultimately resulted in stoppage of its
mining activities.
11. The petitioner preferred writ petition being W.P. (C) No. 5235 of
2012 and during pendency of the said writ petition, the
petitioner, vide letter dated 15.10.2012, surrendered all the five
sand ghats allotted to it requesting the respondent no. 5 to
refund the proportionate bid amount for the period it was not
allowed to carry out the mining activities on the allotted sand
ghats. The petitioner also claimed for refund of the proportionate
amount pertaining to royalty, registration fee and stamp duty
incurred by it in course of allotment of the said sand ghats.
12. The said writ petition was disposed of by learned Single Judge of
this Court vide order dated 6.3.2020 with a direction to the
petitioner to make a fresh representation before the Principal
Secretary, Department of Mines and Geology, Government of
Jharkhand within a period of four weeks and the said respondent
was in turn directed to take a final decision within a period of
eight weeks thereafter. It was further directed that if the said
authority came to a finding that the petitioner was entitled for
refund, necessary benefit would be extended to it within a period
of six weeks thereafter.
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
13. The petitioner submitted detailed representation on 16.3.2020
before the respondent no. 2, however the same was rejected by
the respondent no. 2 vide impugned order dated 16.07.2020
observing that in spite of the notice given to the petitioner, it
failed to produce the environmental clearance of the concerned
five sand ghats allotted to it before the respondent no. 3.
Moreover, the claim of the petitioner for refund of the
proportionate bid amount, royalty, registration fee and stamp
duty was also rejected.
14. It is further argued that the petitioner has suffered huge loss due
to stoppage of its mining activities and as such it is required to
be suitably compensated by the respondents.
15. It is also submitted that the petitioner had fulfilled all the terms
and conditions mentioned in the auction notice, the mining lease
agreements as well as the letters of acceptance and had made
timely payments of installments of the bid amount.
16. It is further urged that during the entire mining operation, the
petitioner was never served any show cause notice for any kind
of violation of the terms and conditions of mining lease
agreements or auction notice or the letters of acceptance.
17. It is emphatically contended that since there was no requirement
under the terms and conditions of the auction notice, the Letters
of acceptance and the mining lease agreements for taking
environmental clearance to operate the sand ghats, the
petitioner did not apply for the same.
18. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
excavation of sand from the allotted sand ghats was stopped by
the respondents due to wrong interpretation of the judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered in the case of Deepak
Kumar and Others Vs. State of Jharkhand & Others
reported in (2012) 4 SCC 629. In the said judgment the
Hon’ble Supreme Court had only restrained grant of fresh lease
and/or renewal of lease by the State of Jharkhand without
environmental clearance and the said judgment was not
applicable to the existing lease agreements.
19. It is further argued that the National Green Tribunal, Principal
Bench, New Delhi vide its order dated 05.08.2013 passed in
Original Application No. 171 of 2013 (National Green
Tribunal Bar Association Vs. Ministry of Environment &
Forest
&
Others)
had
directed
all
the
Deputy
Commissioners/Superintendents of Police/Mining Authorities of
all the respective States to restrain all the existing mining
activities
without
obtaining
environmental
clearance
from
MoEF/SEIAA and license from the competent authorities.
However, the said order was stayed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court vide order dated 31.10.2013 passed in Civil Appeal Nos.
9703-9706 of 2013.
20. On the contrary, the learned counsel for the respondents submits
that in spite of the direction issued to the petitioner, it never
submitted the environment clearance of MoEF/SEIAA and the
consent to operate by the Jharkhand State Pollution Control
Board for the settled sand ghats and accordingly, the issuance of
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
transport challan was stopped.
21. It is further submitted that environment clearance from State
Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority (constituted by
the MoEF, Government of India) was demanded from the
petitioner against the concerned five (05) settled sand ghats vide
letter no 869/M, 870/M, 871/M, 872/M, 873/M all dated
20.08.2013
and due to non-submission of the
same,
the
transport challans were not issued by District Mining Office,
Dhanbad.
22. It is also submitted that the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
rendered in the case of Deepak Kumar (Supra.) mandates the
requirement of environment clearance for the leases having area
less than 05 Hectares. Moreover, as per order dated 05.08.2013
passed by National Green Tribunal, Delhi in O.A No. 171 of 2013,
environment clearance
of
MOEF/SEIAA
is
necessary
for
sand mining throughout the country.
23. It is next contended that Part VII (2) of the registered lease
agreements executed on 05.10.2011 in Model Form-C clearly
states that all central as well as state laws will be applicable to
“bandobastidhari”/”bandobastidharigan” to work on mines and
minerals. Therefore, the law regarding obtaining environment
clearance from MoEF/SEIAA for the settled ghats was also
applicable to the petitioner.
24. It is lastly argued that clause 10 of the terms and conditions of
auction notice and Part III (2) of the lease deed agreements
executed
in
Model
Form-C
clearly
states
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
that “bandobastidhari”/”bandobastidharigan” cannot claim any
compensation from the State Government towards loss occurred
due to hurdle in transportation or due to unavailability of
minerals.
25. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
materials placed on record.
26. Thrust of the argument of the learned counsel for the petitioner
is that neither in the terms and conditions of the auction notice
nor in the letters of acceptance or the mining lease agreements,
there was any requirement of obtaining environmental clearance
from SEIAA to do the mining activities over the settled sand
ghats. Despite that, the petitioner was restrained from extracting
sand from the settled sand ghats without any fault on its part
which forced it to surrender all the lease agreements. Thus, the
petitioner is entitled to refund of the proportionate bid amount,
royalty, registration fee and stamp duty etc. including suitable
interest for delayed payment.
27. It is evident from the record that the petitioner was allotted five
(5) sand ghats for a period of three financial years starting from
01.04.2011 to 31.03.2014. The petitioner commenced extraction
of sand from 09.08.2011 and continued till June, 2012.
28. In the meantime, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Deepak Kumar (Supra). held that leases of minor minerals
including their renewal pertaining to an area less than five
hectares have to be granted by the States/Union Territories only
after getting environmental clearance from the MoEF.
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
29. In compliance of the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
rendered in the case of Deepak Kumar (Supra.), the MoEF,
Govt.
of
India
issued
an
Office
Memorandum
No.
L-11011/47/2011-IA.II(M), dated 18.05.2012 stating inter alia
that all mining projects of minor minerals including their renewal,
irrespective of the size of the lease would henceforth require
prior environment clearance and that the projects of minor
minerals with lease area less than 5 hectares, would be treated
as category ‘B’ as defined in Environment Impact Assessment
(EIA) Notification, 2006 and will be considered by the respective
State Environment Impact Assessment Authorities (SEIAAs)
notified by MoEF and following the procedure prescribed under
the EIA Notification, 2006.
30. From July, 2012, the respondents stopped issuing transit challan
in favour of the petitioner for want of environmental clearance
due to which operation of the sand ghats settled to the petitioner
was stopped. Moreover, the claim for refund of the proportionate
bid amount, royalty, registration fee and stamp duty deposited by
the petitioner has been declined by the respondent no. 2 vide
impugned order dated 16.07.2020.
31. The learned counsel for the petitioner puts reliance on the
judgment of Raj Kumar Gupta Vs. The State of Jharkhand
& Others reported in 2018 SCC OnLine Jhar 954 which has
been delivered by one of us (Rajesh Shankar, J). In the said
case, ‘Niktha Sand ghat’ located on Ajay river situated in ‘Soatar
Panchayat’ of Deoghar district, was allotted to the petitioner of
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
that case. The said sand ghat was situated within 500 meters of
High Level Bridge and in view of Clause 8 of the environment
clearance, the mining operation was prohibited in the said area.
The Bench held that the respondent authorities were duty bound
to refund the amount which was received from the petitioner in
lieu of allotment of the sand ghat, since the agreement itself was
illegal in view of the stipulation made in the environment
clearance and the settlement agreement. The Bench further
observed that it was not in dispute that the sand ghats were
selected and put to public auction by the respondent authorities
themselves. Thus, if subsequently it was found that the lifting of
sand from a particular sand ghat was not permissible due to such
stipulation
in
the
environment
clearance
and
settlement
agreement, the settlee/lessee couldn’t be subjected to adverse
consequences arising therefrom.
32. In the case of Manoj Kumar Vs. The State of Jharkhand &
Others reported in 2020 SCC OnLine Jhar 1760, one of the
sand ghats notified in a public auction popularly known as ‘Amma
Sand Mining Project’ was allotted to the petitioner of the said
case which was found situated within the distance of less than
250 meters from the forest area and thus the environmental
clearance for the said mining operation was cancelled. In that
case, one of us (Rajesh Shankar, J.) held that in spite of the
information given by the Divisional Forest Officer, Khunti Forest
Division that certain area of the said sand ghat was within the
distance of 250 meters from the nearest forest area, the
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
respondent Nos. 2, 3 & 4 of the said case proceeded to execute
the lease deed in favour of the petitioner for the said project and
thus they acted in contravention of the decision of the State
Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority, Jharkhand
taken in its meeting dated 07.05.2013. The petitioner was
nowhere involved in selection of the place of the said project,
rather the same was put to public auction by the respondent
Nos. 2, 3 & 4 of the said case. As such, it was observed that the
petitioner couldn’t be punished for no fault on his part. It was
further held that a person cannot be compelled to do what he
cannot possibly perform. The Bench finally held that the
petitioner was entitled for refund of the proportionate amount of
the bid value as well as the security amount deposited by him in
relation to the said project.
33. The learned counsel for the petitioner also puts reliance on the
judgment of a Co-ordinate Bench of this court rendered in the
case of Mahadev Enclave Pvt. Ltd. Vs. The State of
Jharkhand & Others reported in 2023 SCC OnLine Jhar
3936. In the said case, the petitioner was declared successful
bidder pertaining to ‘Narottampur Sand Ghat Mining Project’
situated on ‘Sundar river’ in Godda district and it deposited the
full security amount as well as 40% of the bid amount, however
it could not operate the said sand ghat because of delay in
obtaining environmental clearance. The Co-ordinate Bench
observed that the petitioner should be refunded the amount
deposited with the respondents. It was further observed that the
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
State of Jharkhand being a welfare State should not derive
unreasonable benefit at the risk of rendering financial losses to
the public or the companies operating within its jurisdiction. It
was also observed that unreasonable gain on the part of the
State Government is not within the compass of the constitutional
Scheme. Finally, the Bench directed the Directors of Mines &
Geology, Jharkhand (the respondent no. 2 therein) to refund the
security deposit and 40% of the bid amount deposited by the
petitioner with simple interest at the rate of 6 % per annum to
be calculated from 14.08.2015, till the actual payment.
34. In the case of Sanjeev Kumar Vs. the State of Jharkhand
[W.P.(C) No. 3387 of 2022] with other analogous cases, a
Coordinate Bench of this court directed the Director of Mines and
Geology, Jharkhand to refund the security deposit and bid
amount deposited by the common petitioner in all the three
cases with simple interest @ 6% per annum, to be calculated
from the date of deposit till the date of actual payment by
putting reliance on the judgment of Mahadev Enclave Pvt.
Ltd. (Supra.).
35. Now, the question falls for consideration of this Court is as to
whether the petitioner is entitled for refund of the proportionate
bid amount as well as royalty, registration fee and stamp duty
from the respondents w.e.f. July, 2012 in view of the fact that it
was restrained from carrying out mining activities on the allotted
sand ghats without its fault?
36. In the present case, there was no condition either in the auction
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
notice or in the letters of acceptance or the mining lease
agreements that the allotee shall have to get environmental
clearance for carrying out mining operation over the concerned
allotted sand ghats. The petitioner was allowed to continue the
mining operation without environmental clearance till June 2012.
However, pursuant to the order passed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Deepak Kumar (Supra.), the respondent authorities
decided to stop issuing transit challan to the petitioner and other
mining lease holders who had not obtained environmental
clearance and started demanding environmental clearance of the
respondent no. 6 for operating the settled sand ghats. Due to
the said subsequent development, the petitioner surrendered all
the settled sand ghats to the respondents and demanded for
refund of the proportionate bid amount, royalty, registration fee
and stamp duty etc.
37. We are of the considered view that the respondent authorities
are under legal obligation to refund the proportionate bid
amount for the period the petitioner was not allowed to carry out
the mining operation in the allotted sand ghats, since at the time
of allotment of the sand ghats, the petitioner was not informed
that it had to obtain environmental clearance from SEIAA for
operating the sand ghats.
38. The respondents cannot be permitted to be unjustly enriched at
the cost of the petitioner. Since the condition for operating the
sand ghats allotted to the petitioner was subsequently changed
after the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
2026:JHHC:17663-DB
the case of Deepak Kumar (Supra.), the petitioner was left
with the option either to surrender the sand ghats or to get the
environmental clearance for operating the same. In the present
case, the petitioner chose the first option and as such it is
entitled for refund of the proportionate bid amount for the period
it could not operate the sand ghats.
39. For the reasons as aforesaid, the respondents are directed to
refund the proportionate bid amount to the petitioner for the
period it was not allowed to carry out the mining activities on the
concerned five allotted sand ghats. The petitioner is also entitled
to get simple interest over the said amount @ 6% per annum
from the date it formally surrendered the mining leases to the
respondent no. 5 vide its letter dated 15.10.2012 till the date of
actual payment. However, we decline to order refund of royalty,
registration fee and stamp duty paid by the petitioner for
registration of the lease deed agreements.
40. The writ petition is, accordingly, disposed of with the aforesaid
directions.
41. Pending interlocutory application, if any, also stands disposed of.
(M.S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
18.06.2026
Vikas/A.F.R.
Uploaded on 19.06.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review