Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on
Pronounced on
Uploaded on
#
CNR No. DLHC010567692022
+
FAO 2/2023
: 16.09.2026
: 07.10.2026
: 07.10.2026
GITANJALI RINGOLA @ GITANJALI VIRENDRA PRASAD
RINGOLA & ORS.
.....Appellants
Through: Mr. Rajan Sood, Ms. Ashima
Sood and Ms. Megha Sood,
Advocates
versus
UNION OF INDIA
Through:
.....Respondent
Ms. Pratima N. Lakra, CGSC
with Mr. Shailendra Kumar and
Ms. Upanita S., Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
1.
By way of the present appeal filed under Section 23 of the
Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987, the appellant seeks to assail the
judgment dated 28.07.2022 passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal,
Principal Bench, Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the “Tribunal”) in
OA(IIu)/DLI/447/2020 whereby the claim application preferred by the
appellant seeking compensation on account of the death of her
husband, Virendra Prasad Ringola (hereinafter referred to as the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
17:49:55
FAO 2/2023
“deceased”) came to be dismissed.
2.
The facts in a nutshell are that on 09.06.2019, the deceased was
travelling from Mehsana Junction to New Delhi by Train
No.12957(Ahmedabad-New Delhi Swarn Jayanti Rajdhani Express)
on the strength of a valid journey ticket bearing PNR No.8619762953.
During the course of the said journey, while the train reached near
Rewari Railway Station, the deceased fell from the train and sustained
injuries. He was taken to Government Hospital, Rewari and thereafter
shifted to Pushpanjali Hospital, where he died during treatment.
3.
The Tribunal, while decidingthe question as to whether the
occurrence constituted an “untoward incident” as defined in the
Railways Act, 1989 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”), returned a
finding against the appellants. The Tribunal noticed that the train had
no scheduled stoppage at Rewari and that the deceased was working at
Milk Dairy, Dharuheda. Relying principally upon the statements
contained in the DRM report, the Tribunal inferred that the deceased
had attempted to get down from the moving train at Rewari.
4.
Before this Court, Mr. Sood, learned counsel for the appellants
submits that the finding returned by the Tribunal is not borne out from
the evidence. It is submitted that there is admittedly no eyewitness to
the occurrence and that none of the RPF officials whose statements
have been relied upon by the Tribunal had witnessed the deceased
falling from the train. It is further submitted that the respondent did not
lead any oral evidence before the Tribunal. The statements recorded
during the DRM inquiry, therefore, could not have been treated as
establishing that the deceased had consciously attempted to alight from
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
17:49:55
FAO 2/2023
the moving train.
5.
On the contrary, learned counsel for the respondent contended
that the train was an Express Train and had no scheduled stoppage at
Rewari. It is further submitted that the evidence collected and placed
during the DRM inquiry supports the conclusion that the deceased had
attempted to alight from the moving train and, consequently, the case
would fall within the exception of self-inflicted injury under Section
124-A of the Act.
6.
At the outset, it may be noted that the Tribunal has already
returned a categorical finding that the deceased was a bona fide
passenger. The said finding has not been challenged by the respondent
in the present appeal and has, therefore, attained finality. The
controversy in the present appeal is consequently confined to the
question whether the fall of the deceased from the train was an
“untoward incident” within the meaning of Section 123(c)(2) of the
Act.
7.
Notably, Section 123(c)(2) of the Act specifically includes the
accidental falling of a passenger from a train carrying passengers
within the expression “untoward incident”. The liability under Section
124-A is subject to the exceptions contained in its proviso. In “Union
of India v. Prabhakaran Vijaya Kumar”1, the Supreme Court has
emphasised the beneficial nature of the provision. In “Union of India
v. Rina Devi”2, the Supreme Court has also explained that an injury
can be treated as self-inflicted only where the circumstances establish
(2008) 9 SCC 527
(2019) 3 SCC 572
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
17:49:55
FAO 2/2023
an intention on the part of the passenger to inflict such injury upon
himself; mere negligence cannot be equated with such intention.
8.
In the present case, the Tribunal itself has recorded that “there is
no eye witness of this incident”. The absence of an eyewitness is not,
by itself, fatal to a claim of this nature, however, where the Railway
seeks to bring the case within the exception of self-inflicted injury, the
material relied upon must establish a particular kind of act attributed to
the deceased. The question that needs to be examined, therefore, is
whether the material relied upon by the Tribunal establishes that the
deceased had in fact attempted to get down from the moving train.
9.
A perusal of the DRM report shows that oneRavindra Kumar,
RPF Constable, had reached the spot after the occurrence. In his
statement, he stated that the deceased tried to get down from a slow
moving train.He personally did not witness the occurrence and his
statement, therefore, cannot be treated as an account of the deceased
actually falling from the train or attempting to get down from it.
Similarly, the statement of Karmveer Singh, ASI/RPF, also does not
provide an eyewitness account of the deceased making such an
attempt. More importantly, insofar as the statement of Dhanpal
Meena, Head Constable, is concerned, the information regarding the
deceased having jumped from the train was attributed to another
person and that person has neither been identified nor examined.
10.
Thus, none of the statements relied upon by the Tribunal
establishes that any particular person had actually seen the deceased
attempting to alight from the train. The distinction is material. The fact
that an RPF official subsequently reached the spot and recorded what
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
17:49:55
FAO 2/2023
he was told cannot convert that information into direct evidence of the
manner in which the deceased fell.This aspect assumes further
significance because the respondent/Railways did not lead any oral
evidence before the Tribunal and the order sheet dated 24.05.2022
records that after the appellants closed their evidence, the respondent
opted not to lead any evidence and its evidence was closed.
Consequently, there is no testimony of the Guard, Loco Pilot or any
other railway official who had seen the deceased at the relevant time
or could state that he had attempted to alight from the moving train.
11.
The Tribunal also appears to have drawn an inference from the
fact that the deceased was travelling in an enclosed AC coach and
questioned why he would come to the door of the coach when the train
was not scheduled to stop at Rewari. This, however, remains an
inference as the record does not disclose what the deceased was doing
immediately before the occurrence or where exactly he was standing
when he fell. The contemporaneous material also does not establish a
deliberate act on the part of the deceased. The MLC records that the
injured was brought to the hospital by one Ashok Rao, stated to be his
friend. The GRP proceedings also record the death as having occurred
on account of the fall from the train.
12.
It is also apposite to note that in “Ramesh Suneja v. Union of
India”3, the Tribunal had similarly proceeded on the basis that the train
had no scheduled stoppage at the station in question and had inferred
an attempt to deboard from the surrounding circumstances. This Court,
however, found that the Guard, who had been examined as a witness,
2025 SCC OnLine Del 2539
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
17:49:55
FAO 2/2023
had not stated that he had actually seen the appellant attempting to get
down from the moving train. His version in that regard was found to
be based on assumptions.
13.
Here, there is no evidence from any member of the Railway
Staff. Indisputably, Ravindra Kumar, an RPF Constable, had reached
the spot after the occurrence and, therefore, could not have witnessed
the deceased attempting to get down from the train. Likewise, the
statement of Dhanpal Meena, insofar as it refers to the deceased
having jumped from the train, is based on information allegedly
received from another person, whose identity has remained unknown
and no independent statement of that person was ever recorded. Thus,
while the record establishes that the deceased fell from the train, it
does not establish that he had attempted to alight from the moving
train. The fact that he was working at Dharuheda may indicate a
possible reason for reaching that area, but cannot, in the absence of
any evidence regarding the actual occurrence, establish the act
attributed to him.
14.
The exception of self-inflicted injury under the proviso to
Section 124-A of the Act, therefore, could not have been invoked on
the basis of such inference. The occurrence is consequently required to
be treated as an “untoward incident” within the meaning of Section
123(c)(2) of the Act.
15.
Accordingly, the impugned judgment is set aside and the matter
is remanded back to the Tribunal, which is requested to assess the
amount of compensation payable to the appellants in accordance with
law and direct the authorities concerned to disburse the same within
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
17:49:55
FAO 2/2023
two months from the receipt of a copy of this order. For this purpose,
the matter be listed before the Tribunal at the first instance on
30.11.2026.
16.
The appeal is allowed and disposed of in the above terms.
17.
A copy of this judgment be communicated to the learned
Tribunal.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
OCTOBER 07, 2026
na
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
17:49:55
FAO 2/2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review