Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 22ND DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE E.S.INDIRESH
WRIT PETITION NO.35121 OF 2025 (LR)
BETWEEN:
1.
GIRIJAMMA SHEDTHI
D/O LATE CHANDAMMA SHEDTHI,
AGED ABOUT 85 YEARS,
R/AT GANTI HOLE,
BIJOOR VILLAGE AND POST,
KUNDAPUR TALUK,
UDUPI DISTRICT – 576 201.
2.
AKKAYYA SHEDTHI,
D/O LATE MOOKAMMA SHEDTHI,
AGED 68 ABOUT YEARS,
R/AT BIJOOR VILLAGE AND POST,
KUNDAPUR TALUK,
UDUPI DISTRICT – 576 201.
CHAYA S A
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. K. SHRIHARI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
HERIYAKKA
D/O LATE SUBBA,
-2HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
AGED: MAJOR.
2.
CHANDRASHEKAR,
S/O LATE MAHABALA SHETTY,
AGE NOT KNOWN.
3.
SPECIAL ASSISTANT COMMISSONER,
LAND REFORMS TRIBUNAL,
KUNDAPUR TALUK,
UDUPI DISTRICT-576201.
4.
SUKRA POJARI
S/O SUBBA POOJARY
AGED: MAJOR.
5.
NARAYAN POOJARY
S/O SUBBA POOJARY
AGED: MAJOR
RESPONDENTS NO.1, 2, 4 & 5 ARE
R/AT HOLETHOTA, MELTHUR
KUNDAPUR TALU ,
UDUPI DISTRICT -576 201.
6.
KRISHNA S. POOJARY
HOTEL SAI SNACKS
MOPADA RASINE POST
KALAPURA TALUK
RAIGAD DISTRICT – 410207.
7.
MOODOOR POOJARY
S/O SUBBA POOJARY
AGED: MAJOR.
-3HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
8.
MANJUNATH POOJARY
S/O SUBBA POOJARY
AGED: MAJOR.
9.
SHIVANANDA POOJARY
S/O SUBBA POOJARY
AGED: MAJOR.
10. GOWRI POOJARI
W/O ANAND POOJARI
AGED: MAJOR.
11. VIAJY POOJARI
S/ O ANAND POOJARI
AGED: MAJOR.
12. DHANANJAYA POOJARI
S/O ANAND POOJARI
AGED: MAJOR.
RESPONDENTS NO.7 TO 12 ARE
R/AT HOLETHOTA
MELTHUR, KUNDAPURA TALUK
UDUPI DISTRICT.
13. MUTTHU POOJARY
W/O RAMA POOJARY
AGED: MAJOR.
14. SHANKAR POOJARY
S/O RAMA POOJARY
AGED: MAJOR.
-4HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
15. CHANDRA POOJARY
S/O RAMA POOJARY
AGED: MAJOR.
16. GOPAL POOJARY
S/O RAMA POOJARY
AGED: MAJOR.
17. RAJU POOJARY
S/O RAMA POOJARY
AGED: MAJOR.
18. NAGARATHNA POOJARY
D/O RAMA POOJARY
AGED: MAJOR.
RESPONDENTS NO.13 TO 18 ARE
R/AT GUDIMANE HEROOR
POST RAGIHIKL, HEROOR VILLAGE
BYNDOOR TALUK – 576 224.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. DHANANJAY JOSHI, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI. PURNA CHANDRA M. PURANIK, ADVOCATE
FOR R1, R4 TO R18;
SMT. SHARADA H.V., AGA FOR R3;
SRI. BALAKRISHNA, ADVOCATE FOR R2)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND
227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO QUASH THE
ORDER
PASSED
BY
LAND
TRIBUNAL
AT
KUNDAPUR,
RESPONDENTS NO.3 IN TRI 2272/77-78 DATED
18.09.2025
FILED AS ANNEXURE - A OR MAY BE PLEASED TO ISSUE SUCH
-5HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
OTHER WRIT OR ORDER ON THE FACTS AND CIRCUMSTANCES
OF THE CASE IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS WRIT PETITION HAVING BEEN RESERVED FOR
ORDERS,
COMING
ON
FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT
THIS
DAY,
E.S. INDIRESH J., MADE THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE E.S.INDIRESH
CAV ORDER
1.
In this writ petition, the petitioners are assailing the order
dated 18.09.2025 passed by respondent-Land Tribunal, Byndoor,
Udupi Taluk, (Annexure-A) granting occupancy rights in favour of
private respondents herein.
2.
Facts in nutshell for the purpose of adjudication of the writ
petition are that, one Venkappa Shetty was the original owner in
possession of the Punja Land bearing Sy.No.312/3, measuring 1
acres, 33 guntas and land bearing Sy.No.183/4, measuring 49
cents in Bijoor Village, Kundapur Taluk. The petitioners are the
grand children of late Venkappa Shetty. It is further stated in the
writ petition that, one Subba, had purchased, the portion of the
land from Mahabala Shetty, (son of Venkappa Shetty), and
Mahabala Shetty had allowed him to reside in the house for few
-6HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
months. It is further stated that, no land was granted on lease
by the petitioners in favour of Subba, who in turn filed Form
No.7, seeking grant of occupancy rights and same was registered
as TRI 2272 of 1977-78. After the death of said Subba, his legal
representative was impleaded in the proceedings. The Tribunal,
by order dated 29.01.1979, granted occupancy rights, in favour
of the Nagi Hengsu (wife of Subba) and the said order was
challenged before this Court in W.P.No.4423 of 1979 and this
court vide order dated 11.08.1983 (Annexure-C), remanded the
matter to the Land Tribunal for fresh consideration. Thereafter,
the matter was heard by the Land Tribunal, and passed an order
dated 12.10.2010 (Annexure- F) and same was questioned
before this court in W.P.No.46643 of 2011 and this court vide
order dated 06.06.2012 (Annexure-H) remanded the matter to
the Tribunal for fresh consideration. It is further stated that,
after remand made by this court, the Tribunal has passed the
impugned order dated 18.09.2025 (Annexure-A) and feeling
aggrieved by the same, the petitioners have presented this writ
petition.
-7HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
3.
Heard Sri. K. Srihari, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners;
Sri.
Dhananjay
Joshi,
learned
Senior
Counsel
appearing on behalf of Sri. M. Puranik, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent, Nos. 1, 4 to 18; Smt. Sharada H.V., learned
Additional Government Advocate appearing for the respondentState and Sri. Balakrishna, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent No.2.
4.
Sri.
K.
Srihari,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioners, by referring to impugned order at Annexure-A
contended that, one of the members of the Tribunal-Tahsildar,
Byndoor has not signed the final order and therefore, it is clear
violation of Rule 17 of the Karnataka Land Reforms Rules, 1974
(for short, ‘Rules, 1974’). He further contended that, after filing
of the writ petition, the Tahsildar, Byndoor has signed the
original order, behind the back of the parties, and same is
contrary to law and therefore, sought for interference of this
Court.
5.
Sri. Srihari, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners,
further contended that land in question is a punja land, and not
-8HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
feasible for cultivation and therefore, contended that, as the land
in question is not cultivable in nature, grant of occupancy rights
does not arise.
6.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners further
contended that, no documents have been produced by the
private respondents to establish that they were in cultivation of
the land in question as a tenant nor chit / receipt has been
produced to establish their cultivation of the land under the
landlord and therefore, it is submitted that, the impugned order
passed by respondent-Land Tribunal requires to be set aside. In
this regard, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, refers
to the judgment of this Court in the case of Vijaya Bank, by its
Chief Manager vs. The Secretary to the Government of
Karnataka, Revenue Department and others reported in ILR
2008 KAR 1481 and in the case of Balasaheb Patil, vs. State
of Karnataka in W.P.No. 7293 of 2005 disposed of on
26.06.2018 and argued that, even if the Tahsildar, Byndoor,
being a Secretary of the Tribunal, failed to affix the signature on
the final order and such order has to be declared as nullity in law
and accordingly, sought for interference of this Court.
-9HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
7.
Per
contra,
Government
Smt.
Advocate
H.V.
Sharada,
appearing
for
learned
the
Additional
respondent-State
produced the original records and further contended that there
are three copies, of the original order issued by the Land
Tribunal and the Tahsildar, Byndoor has signed two copies of the
order, however, by inadvertence, failed to affix the signature on
the third copy which has been given to the petitioner and
therefore, submitted that it is only a procedural irregularity and
same has to be ignored. Accordingly, sought for dismissal of the
writ petition.
8.
Sri. Dhananjay Joshi, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
respondent No.1, 4 to 18 contended by referring to the earlier
orders passed by this court in the aforementioned writ petitions
that, the matter has been remitted to the Land Tribunal, on
technical ground, and further contended that, non affixing of the
signature by the Tahsildar, Byndoor does not invalidate the order
passed by the Land Tribunal as majority members of the Land
Tribunal have signed the order of Tribunal, and as such, no
prejudice has been caused to the petitioners and therefore,
sought for dismissal of the petition.
- 10 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
9.
It is further argued by the learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the respondent Nos. 1, 4 to 18 that the land in
question is cultivable in nature and though the land has been
classified as Punja, however, same has been brought into
cultivation and therefore, contended that the argument advanced
by the learned counsel for the
for the petitioners cannot be
accepted.
10.
Finally, it is argued by the learned Senior Counsel that this
court is having limited jurisdiction to interfere with the finding
recorded by the Land Tribunal on facts on record, and therefore,
sought to justify his arguments by referring to the judgment of
this court in the case of Gudde Ningappa since (D.) by LR.
vs. State of Karnataka and others in W.A. No.1131 of 2025
disposed of on 16.10.2025 and in the case of Subhakar and
others vs. The Land Tribunal, Karkala Taluk, and others
reported in 1999 SCC OnLine KAR 101.
11.
Sri.
Balakrishna,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondent No.2 argued on the similar lines as that of learned
Senior Counsel appearing for other private respondents.
- 11 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
12.
In the light of the arguments advanced by the learned
counsel appearing for the parties, the grand father of the
petitioners herein claim to be the landlord of the subject land
and
private
predecessors
respondents
of
the
claims
to
be
tenant
petitioners.
It
is
the
under
case
of
the
the
applicants/private respondents that, one Subba, has filed, Form
No.7, claiming occupancy rights in respect of the land bearing
Sy.No.183/4, to an extent of 49 cents and land bearing
Sy.No.312/3, to an extent of 1 acre, 33 guntas of Bijoor Village.
The Land Tribunal recorded their finding and pass an order,
granting occupancy rights in favour of the legal representative of
the said Subba (i.e. wife of Subba), on 29.01.1979, and same
was challenged before this court in W.P.No.4423 of 1979
(Annexure- C) and the matter was remanded to the Tribunal for
fresh consideration. Again, the Tribunal passed an order dated
12.10.2010, (Annexure-F), and same was challenged before this
court in W.P.No.46643 of 2011 and this court vide order dated
06.06.2012, (Annexure-H) remanded the matter to the Tribunal
for fresh consideration and thereafter, the impugned order dated
- 12 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
18.09.2025
(Annexure-A)
is
passed
by
respondent-Land
of
impugned
Tribunal.
13.
On
careful
consideration
the
order
at
Annexure-A would indicate that, the Tahsildar, Byndoor, being a
Secretary of the Tribunal has not signed the impugned order at
Annexure-A, however, in the records produced by the learned
Additional Government Advocate, signature of the Tahsildar,
Byndoor is found. It is the contention of the learned Additional
Government Advocate that, by oversight signature of the
Tahsildar
is
missing in
the
certified copy served to
the
petitioners. Taking into consideration the argument advanced by
the learned counsel for the parties, and by referring to Rule 17 of
Rules, 1974, it is the duty of the Secretary of the Tribunal, to
affix, his/her signature on the order passed by respondent-Land
Tribunal. In this regard, it is relevant to extract paragraphs 14 to
26 of the order dated 29.07.2026 in W.A.No.100221 of 2023,
which reads as under:
“ 14. Legal point has been raised in this appeal as the
Land Tribunal has violated Sub-Rule (8) of Rule 17 of
the KLR Rules. The Rule 17 of the KLR Rules deals
with the procedure to be followed by the Tribunal.
- 13 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
15. Sub-Rule (8) of Rule 17 of the KLR Rules, reads
as follows:
17. Procedure to be followed by the Tribunal :(1) The tribunal shall in respect of applications made
to it follow the same procedure as specified for a
summary enquiry under Section 34 of the Karnataka
Land Revenue Act, 1964 subject to the condition that
the records of the proceedings shall be maintained in a
language understood by all its members.
(2) Order sheet shall be maintained by the Chairman
in respect of each case heard by the tribunal, noting in
it the day-to-day proceedings of the tribunal relating
to the conduct of the case.
(3) When a meeting is adjourned, the date, time and
place of hearing of adjourned meeting shall be made
known to the parties present and their signature
obtained on the order sheet.
(4) The progress in the enquiry of each case shall be
noted by the Chairman immediately after hearing or
the holding of spot inspection by the tribunal.
(5)
The
opposite
party
shall
be
allowed
to
crossexamine the witness and if it does not wish to so
- 14 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
cross-examine, a note shall be made accordingly. A
brief summary of the evidence given by each witness
shall be recorded by the Chairman.
(6) If there are more applications than one for
registration of occupancy rights by different persons in
respect of the same land, those cases shall be clubbed
together and a common order passed.
(7) Prayer on an interlocutory application has to be
considered by the tribunal strictly in relation to the
reliefs sought for.
(8) The order shall be signed, in addition to the
Chairman, by the other members of the tribunal
who heard the case.
(9) All orders shall be speaking orders, namely, the
points for decision, the decisions themselves and the
reasons for the decisions shall be mentioned. The
orders shall be pronounced in the open court.
(10) No member of the tribunal shall participate in the
deliberations or decision of a case in which he is
personally interested.
(emphasis supplied)
16. Rule 16 of the KLR Rules, provides for a quorum
for a meeting of the Tribunal, which reads as follows:
- 15 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
“16. Quorum for meeting of the Tribunal.- The
quorum for every meeting of the tribunal (including or
adjourned meeting) shall be three members including
the Chairman. If within half-an-hour of the time fixed
for the meeting there is no quorum, the meeting shall
be adjourned. The notice of the date and time of the
adjourned meeting shall be communicated to all the
members of the tribunal.”
17. Quorum in a Tribunal is the minimum number of
Member’s required to be present to legally conduct the
hearing and proceedings. So the quorum is the
minimum number of members, whose presence is
necessary to enable transact business and perform
lawful acts, such quorum is prescribed under Rule 16.
18. In the present case in hand Tribunal has been
constituted with Chairman and four members. Once
the Tribunal has been constituted and there is quorum
for
the
meeting,
the
Tribunal
can
conduct
its
proceedings. However, the further requirement is that
under Rule 17(8) once an order is passed after
adjudication, it is required to be signed by the
Chairman and its members. The fulfilment of quorum
is a prerequisite for commencing a meeting under Rule
16 which does not do away with the requirement of
signing the order under Rule 17(8). Both are distinct
and
require
separate
compliance.
So
once,
the
- 16 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
Chairman and members of the Tribunal hear the
matter and they come to the conclusion or form an
opinion, such being the case, if any one of the
members do not sign the requirement of Rule 17(8) is
not fulfilled.
19. On perusal of the Annexure-F, i.e., the order of
the Tribunal bearing No.TEN/OCP/SR:9+72/2012-13
dated
30.01.2013,
indicates
that
the
Tribunal
constituted with quorum of a Chairman with four
members. The operative portion of the said order at
page No.4 reads as follows:
¥Àæ¸ÁÛªÀ£ÉAiÀÄ°è «ªÀj¹zÀ CA±ÀUÀ¼À ªÉÄðAzÀ £ÁåAiÀiÁ¢üÃPÀgÀtªÀÅ CfðzÁgÀ£À£ÀÄß
PÀ£ÁðlPÀ ¨sÀƸÀÄzsÁgÀuÉ PÁAiÉÄÝ 1961/74gÀ ¥ÀæPÀgÀt 48(PÀ) ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 45gÀ ªÉÄÃgÉUÉ
CfðzÁgÀgÀ CfðAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ¥ÀÅgÀ¸ÌÀ j¹ ºÁªÉÃj vÁ®ÆPÀ zÉêÀVj UÁæªÀÄzÀ j¸À£ÀA
259/2 PÉëÃvÀæ 11J-00UÀÄA ²æÃ §®gÁªÀĹAUï ºÀ£ÄÀ ªÀÄAvÀ¹AUï CªÀÄgÀUÆ
É Ã¼À
¸Á/zÉêÀVj ¥ÉÇÃwªÁgÀ¸ÁzÁgÀgÀÄ ²æÃªÀÄw »ÃgÁ¨Á¬Ä PÉÆÃA §®gÁªÀiï ¹AUï
CªÀÄgÀUÉÆÃ¼À ¸Á/zÉêÀVj ºÁUÀÆ zÉêÀVj UÁæªÄÀ zÀ j¸À£ÀA 259/1 PÉëÃvÀæ 10J34 UÀÄAd«ÄäUÉ ²æÃ UÀ¢UÉ¥àÀ §¸À¥àÀ ºÀƽPÀn Ö ¸Á/ zÉêÀVj EªÀgÀ£ÀÄß
UÉÃtÂzÁgÀ£ÉAzÀÄ ¸ÀªÁð£ÀĪÀÄvÀ¢AzÀ wêÀiÁ𤹠DzÉñÀªÀ£ÀÄß F ¢£À ¢£ÁAPÀ:
30- 1-2013 gÀAzÀÄ §»gÀAUÀ £ÁåAiÀiÁ®AiÀÄzÀ°è WÉÆÃ¶¸À¯Á¬ÄvÀÄ.
CzsÀåPÀëgÀÄ
¨sÀÆ£ÁåAiÀĪÀÄAqÀ½
ºÁªÉÃj
1) ²æÃ ZÀAzÀÄæ E½UÉÃgÀ ¸Á/ºÉƸÀjwÛ :not signed the order
2) ²æÃ §¸ÀªÀAvÀ¥Àà ºÉrAiÀiÁ® ¸Á/ ºÁªÉÃj : ¸À»/-
- 17 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
3) ²æÃ ºÀĸÉãÀ¸Á§ zÉëºÉƸÀÆgÀ ¸Á/ ºÁªÉÃj : ¸À»/4) ² æÃ ZÀAzÀæ±ÉÃRgÀ zÉÆqÀØvÀ¼ÀªÁgÀ ¸Á/ PÀ£ÀPÁ¥ÀÅgÀ : ¸À»/20. On perusal of the said order, it reflects that
Member No.1 Sri Chandru Iliger R/o Hosaritti not
signed on the order. On the other hand, the Chairman
and Member nos. 2, 3 and 4 have signed on the order.
21. Section 17(8) is very clear that the order shall be
signed by the Chairman and other members of the
Tribunal who heard the case. But in the present case
in hand, the member at Sl.No.No.1 has not signed the
order, though his name have is mentioned in the
cause title that he was present on the date of hearing
the matter.
22. Learned counsel for the appellants placed reliance
on the Judgments of learned Single Judge of this Court
as follows:
1) M.Lakappa Bhandari since dead by LRs. and others
Vs. State of Karnataka, by its Secretary, Revenue
Department and others,
2) Siddaiah and others Vs. The State of Karnataka and
others (WP.No.4451/2019(LR) and
3) Vishwanath and others Vs. The State of Karnataka
and others (W.P.No.46938/2004(LR).
- 18 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
23. In the case of Vijaya Bank Founders Branch
this Court has held at paragraph No.4 as follows:
“4. After carefully going through the impugned order
passed by the learned Single Judge in review and the
provisions of Rule 17(8) of the Karnataka Land
Reforms Rules 1974, we are of the opinion that the
failure of the members to sign the order is not merely
a technical lapse but it goes to the very root of the
matter. The judicial discipline requires that in a multi
member judicial/quasi judicial adjudicatory body, all
the adjudicators who have heard the matter should
pronounce their written opinion at the same time and
place and all of them should sign the order. The said
salutary object of law is effectively manifested in Rule
17(8) of the Karnataka Land Reforms Rules. It is
evident that five members have heard the matter.
Only three members have signed the order and two of
them have not signed the order. The Chairman and
one of the members who have signed the order have
expressed note of dissent for grant of occupancy rights
in favour of fourth respondent. Only one of the
members who have signed the order has opined that
occupancy rights to be granted in favour of fourth
respondent. On totality of the consideration of facts
and the material, we are of the view that the
impugned order of the Tribunal which is not signed by
- 19 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
the all the members who have heard the 20 matter is
a nullity and the said order cannot be considered as a
valid juridical adjudication.”
24. Learned Single Judge in the case of Vishwanath
and others Vs. The State of Karnataka and others
(W.P.No.46938/2004(LR) dated 29.07.2019, has held
as follows:
“4. On going through the impugned order, it is found
that the order of the Land Tribunal has been signed by
the Chairman of the Land Tribunal and two other
members have not appended their signature to the
said order. In light of the requirement under Rule
17(8) of the Karnataka Land Reforms Act, the order of
the Land Tribunal is required to be signed by all the
members.
The
said
procedure
is
held
to
be
a
mandatory procedure as per the judgment passed in
the case of Vijaya Bank Founders Branch, Mangalore
Vs.
Secretary
to
the
Government
of
Karnataka,
Revenue Department decided on 20.06.2007 reported
in
ILR
KARNATAKA
1481.
This
Court
at
paragraph 4 of the four of the said judgment has held
that non compliance of Rule 17(8) is not a technical
lapse but goes to the root of the matter. Court has set
aside the impugned order observing that the said
order was a nullity in light of the non-compliance to
Rule 17(8). Without going into the merits as regards
- 20 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
other contentions, in view of the law laid down above
and noticing the present order is not signed by two of
the members of the Land Tribunal, the impugned
order is liable to be set aside as being a violation of
the
procedure
stipulated
under
Rule
17(8)
of
Karnataka Land Reforms Rules. Matter to be decided
afresh by the Tribunal by taking note of all contentions
raised
by
the
petitioners
and
respondents
in
accordance with law. Contentions of all the contesting
parties are kept open.”
25. Learned Single Judge in the case of Pundalik S/o
Dattatraya Havaldhar since dead by his LRs.
Smt.Sudha Pundalik hawaldhar and others Vs.
the
State
of
Karnataka
and
others
(W.P.No.12383/2007(LR) dated 07.12.2021, has
held as follows:
“6.
A
perusal
of
the
impugned
order
dated
26.08.2006, at Annexure-B, indicates that though all
the members of the Tribunal were present, however,
the impugned order has been signed by four members
instead of all the members of the Tribunal which is in
violation of Rule 17(8) of the Karnataka Land Reform
Rules. Hence, the impugned order passed by the Land
Tribunal, Hukkeri, at Annexure-B requires to be set
aside on this ground alone.”
- 21 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
26. Annexure-F the order of the Land Tribunal dated
30.01.2013 was not signed by one of the members of
the Tribunal. Further the records are called by the
Court, but which has not been produced. So there is a
legal presumption that the original order has not
signed and there is no reason to disbelieve the
contention raised by the appellant herein.”
14. It is also relevant to extract paragraphs 11 to 13 of
order passed in the case of Balasaheb Patil, (supra),
reads as under:
“11. As far as the order passed by this Court in the
case of V irupakshappa is concerned, it is noted that in
the said case , the contention was with regard to the
opinion of the Tribunal not being unanimous one,
there was no decision in the eye of law and therefore,
was liable to be
quashed. That contention was
negatived by a learned Single Judge of this Court and
it was held that where there is a dissent amongst the
Members o f the Tribunal, the ma jority view would
prevail and that should be the decision of the Tribunal.
A dissent would imply that there is an order which
would be signed by the Members and Chairman who
have dissented.
- 22 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
12. But, in the instant case , there is no view
expressed by one of the Members. Merely because he
has not expressed any view, it cannot be a con jecture
that even if his view was a dissent, it would have
resulted in a ma jority opinion by the other persons
who had signed the order. That is not the way of
considering a judicial order or a quasi-judicial order,
as in the instant case.
13. The Rule expressly uses the expression ‘shall’
which means a mandatory requirement to be applied.
Therefore,
reliance
placed
in
the
case
of
Virupakshappa by the learned counsel for respondent
Nos.2 to 8 is of no assistance at all.”
(Emphasis supplied)
15.
Following the declaration of law made by this Court, and
the judgment referred to by the learned Senior Counsel for the
respondent Nos.1, 4 to 18 that this court, is having limited scope
to interfere with the finding of fact, however, as there is
procedural irregularity by the members of the Tribunal, as the
Tahsildar of the Byndoor fails to sign one of the copies of the
original order, and same would amounts to nullity in law. In that
view of the matter, as there is procedural irregularity in the
- 23 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
impugned order passed by respondent - Land Tribunal, I find
force in the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the
petitioners.
16.
At this stage it is relevant to cite the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Nadakerappa (D) by
LRs., and others vs. Pillamma (D) by LRs., and others
reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC 387 wherein it is held that, if
the material on record is sufficient, for Appellate Authority to
arriving at a conclusion and under such circumstances, the
matter has to be heard on merits and pass orders without
therebeing remanding the matter to the Land Tribunal for further
consideration. In that view of the matter, in the present
proceedings as there is absence of the signature of the one of
the members of the Tribunal and as the impugned order is nullity
in law, I am constrained to remand the matter to the Tribunal for
fresh
consideration
and
to
pass
appropriate
orders
after
providing an opportunity of hearing to all the parties concerned
and to pass orders in accordance with law.
- 24 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:52286
WP No. 35121 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010746832025
17.
It is made clear that, the Land Tribunal should be serious
in conducting the proceedings and to pass appropriate orders by
following declaration of law by this court, and the Hon'ble
Supreme Court by following the procedural aspects and on
merits of the case. Hence, I pass the following:
ORDER
i.
The writ petition is allowed.
ii.
The order dated 18.09.2025 (Annexure-A) passed
by respondent-Land Tribunal is hereby set aside.
iii.
In order to avoid further delay in the matter, the
parties are directed to appear before the Land
Tribunal, Byndoor on 30.10.2026 at 3.00 pm. It is
open for the parties to lead evidence, if need arises,
in the circumstances of the case.
SD/(E.S.INDIRESH)
JUDGE
SB
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 66
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review