Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 7TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.REV.PET NO. 890 OF 2023
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 26.08.2023 IN CRL.MP NO.1546 OF
2023 OF COURT OF ENQUIRY COMMISSIONER & SPECIAL JUDGE
(VIGILANCE), MUVATTUPUZHA
REVISION PETITIONER/COMPLAINANT:
GIREESH BABU,*(EXPIRED)
AGED 47 YEARS,
S/O. GOPALAKRISHNAN,PUNNAKKADAN-HOUSE,
KALAMASSERY, CUSAT- POST, COCHIN,
ERNAKULAM-DISTRICT, PIN – 682022
BY ADVS.
SRI.AKHIL VIJAY, AMICUS CURIAEA
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY PRINCIPAL SECRETARY),
DEPARTMENT OF HOME & VIGILANCES,
ROOM NO. 357(a) & 358, MAIN BLOCK,
GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
VIGILANCE & ANTI-CORRUPTION BUREAU
(REP BY THE DIRECTOR),
REPRESENTED BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM,
PIN - 682018
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
* VEENA THAIKANDIYIL,
AGED 39, D/O VIJAYAN, PRAVIK, PINARAYI P.O,
KANNUR;
FOUNDER AND OWNER OF EXALOGIC SOLUTIONS PVT.
LTD., 1051, 7TH MAIN,
80FT ROAD, KORMANGALA,
BANGALORE.
* PINARAYI VIJAYAN,
AGED 78 YEARS, CHIEF MINISTER,
CLIFF HOUSE, NANTHANCODE,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
* RAMESH CHENNITHALA,
AGED 67, EX. HOME MINISTER AND EX. OPPOSITION
LEADER, KOTTOOR KIZHAKETHIL,
TRIPPERUNTHURA P.O., CHENNITHALA,
MAVELIKKARA, ALAPPUZHA.
* KUNJALI KUTTY,
AGED 72, PANDIKADAVATH HOUSE, PATTARKADAVU P.O.,
PANAKKAD(VIA), MALAPPURAM-676519.
* V.K. IBRAHIM KUNJU,
AGED 71, C.C 12/1515, GRACE GARDEN,
PANAYAPILLI, KOCHI.
* SHRI. SATHIVILAS NARAYAN KARTHA SASIDHARAN
KARTHA,
MANAGING DIRECTOR,
M/S COCHIN MINERALS AND RUTILE LTD,
MARKET ROAD, ALWAYE,
ERNAKULAM, KERALA- 683101.
* K.S. SURESH KUMAR,
CFO, M/S COCHIN MINERALS AND RUTILE LTD,
MARKET ROAD, ALWAYE, ERNAKULAM, KERALA-683101,
RESIDING AT SREELAKSHMI HOUSE, KUNNUKARA P.O,
NEAR AHANA AUDITORIUM, NORTH PARAVUR.
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
* P. SURESH KUMAR,
CGM, FINANCE AND COMPANY SECRETARY,
M/S COCHIN MINERALS AND RUTILE LTD,
MARKET ROAD, ALWAYE,
ERNAKULAM, KERALA-683101
* K.M. VASUDEVAN,
CASHIER, M/S COCHIN MINERALS AND RUTILE LTD,
MARKET ROAD, ALWAYE, ERNAKULAM, KERALA-683101.
*(ADDL. R3 TO R11 ARE SUO-MOTO IMPLEADED AS PER
ORDER DATED 8-12-2023 IN CRL.R.P. 890/2023)
BY ADVS.
GILBERT GEORGE CORREYA
NISHA GEORGE
P.A.MOHAMMED SHAH
S.RAJEEV
RAFIQ P.M.
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PROSECUTION(AG-10)
P.NARAYANAN, SENIOR G.P. AND ADDL.PUBLIC
PROSECUTOR()
SHRI.SAJJU.S., SENIOR G.P.
NIKITA J. MENDEZ(K/2364/2022)
SRUTHY N. BHAT(K/000579/2017)
P.VIJAYA BHANU (SR.)(K/421/1984)
V.VINAY(K/355/2009)
M.S.ANEER(K/644/2013)
SARATH K.P.(K/001467/2021)
PRERITH PHILIP JOSEPH(K/000736/2015)
ANILKUMAR C.R.(K/001190/2020)
K.S.KIRAN KRISHNAN(K/3514/2022)
GEORGE POONTHOTTAM (SR.)(K/000570/1979)
RENOY VINCENT(K/000580/2017)
SHAHIR SHOWKATH ALI(K/000584/2019)
CHELSON CHEMBARATHY(K/001483/2019)
ABEE SHEJIRIK FASLA N.K(K/345/2018)
MUHAMED JUNAID V.(K/680/2020)
ADITH KRISHNAN.U.(K/001385/2023)
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
SHERIN SHERIYAR(K/4033/2023)
AFEEFA NAFEESA C.C.(K/001768/2024)
NANDA SURENDRAN(K/1367/2020)
THANUSHREE DAMODARAN(K/1566/2022)
SRI.T.A.SHAJI (DGP)
SRI.RAJESH.A, SP.GP (VIGILANCE)
SMT.REKHA.S (SR.PP)
THIS CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY
HEARD ON 28.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED
THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
K.BABU, J.
-------------------------------------Criminal.R.P No.890 of 2023
--------------------------------------Dated this the 28th day of March, 2025
ORDER
The Revision Petitioner is the complainant in a private
complaint filed before the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge
(Vigilance), Moovattupuzha. The learned Special Judge, by order
dated 26.08.2023, rejected the complaint. The said order is under
challenge in this Criminal Revision Petition.
2. In the complaint, the revision petitioner alleged as follows:
M/s. Cochin Minerals and Rutile Ltd., (‘CMRL’ for short),
respondent No.8 in the complaint, is a company engaged in mining
and other business activities. Additional respondent No.4 is the
Chief Minister of Kerala. Additional Respondent Nos.5 to 7 were
public servants at the relevant time.
Respondent No.3 is the
daughter of additional respondent No.4. She received money from
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
CMRL under the cover of respondent No.4. Thereby, the company
obtained undue privileges and advantages. Respondent Nos.4 to 7
misused their official position and caused loss to the public
exchequer. Due to the silence and inaction of the public servants in
return
for
the
illegal
gratification
they
received,
severe
environmental problems arose in the State, especially pollution of
the River Periyar by way of the activities of the CMRL company.
The actions of the additional respondents attract the offences under
the Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988.
The Interim Board for
Settlement under the Income Tax Act, New Delhi, found that the
acts alleged reveal the offences under the Prevention of Corruption
Act. M/s. Exalogic Solutions Pvt. Ltd., a one-person company, the
Managing Director of which is additional respondent No.3, received
a sum of Rs.3,00,000/- and she received another sum of
Rs.5,00,000/- every month based on an alleged agreement for
giving software service whereas, there was no such legal or valid
agreement.
The revision petitioner had made a petition to the
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
Director
of
Vigilance
and
Anti-Corruption
Bureau,
Thiruvananthapuram, on 14.08.2023, but no action was taken on it.
3.
Based on the above allegations, the revision petitioner
prayed for ordering a quick verification by the Vigilance and AntiCorruption Bureau and to proceed in accordance with law. The
learned Special Judge, as per the impugned order, rejected the
complaint at the threshold.
4. During the course of proceedings, the revision petitioner
died. The learned counsel who appeared for the revision petitioner
submitted that as nobody turned up to prosecute the matter, he is
not in a position to proceed with the revision petition. Even in the
absence of a party or his counsel, a Criminal Revision Petition falls
for consideration on merits.
Therefore, this Court appointed
Advocate Shri. Akhil Vijay, as Amicus Curiae to assist the Court.
5.
The complaint is essentially based on the entries
maintained in a diary by a representative of CMRL and the decision
of the Interim Board for Settlement, New Delhi, that as M/s Exalogic
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
Solutions Pvt. Ltd. has not provided any services to the company,
the payment of Rs.1,72,00,000/- does not qualify as a business
expenditure.
6. I have heard Sri.Akhil Vijay, the learned Amicus Curiae,
Sri.T.A. Shaji, the learned Director General of Prosecution,
Sri.Gilbert George Correya, the learned counsel for additional
respondent Nos.3 and 4, Sri.George Poonthottam, the learned
Senior Counsel appearing for respondent No.5, Sri.P.A Mohammed
Shah, the learned counsel appearing for respondent No.6,
Sri.S.Rajeev, the learned counsel appearing for respondent No.7,
and Sri.P.Vijaya Bhanu, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for
respondent Nos.8 to 11.
7. The learned Amicus Curiae submitted that as the complaint
revealed cognizable offences on the face of it, the learned Special
Judge ought to have taken cognizance of the offences alleged. The
learned Amicus Curiae submitted that the findings of the Interim
Board for Settlement that M/s. Exalogic Solutions Pvt. Ltd has
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
received payments from CMRL without providing any services to
the company project a suspicion on the role of additional
respondent No.4 in giving undue favour to CMRL. The learned
Amicus Curiae submitted that the allegations prima facie establish
the offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act.
8. Sri.Gilbert George Correya, the learned counsel appearing
for additional respondent Nos.3 and 4, submitted that there is no
presumption as to the essential ingredients of the offences alleged
under the criminal law. The learned Special Judge cannot interpret
the documents relied on by the complainant to assume the
existence of certain facts constituting an offence.
The learned
counsel submitted that the order of the Interim Board for
Settlement is confidential and cannot be relied upon and used
against any person in view of Section 245-I of the Income Tax Act.
9.
Sri.George Poonthottam, the learned Senior Counsel
appearing for respondent No.5, submitted that the rejection of the
complaint against respondent No.5 is justified as the complaint is
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
based on the entries on loose papers with no evidentiary value.
The learned Senior Counsel submitted that insofar as additional
respondent No.5 is concerned, there is no material to connect him
with any of the offences alleged.
However, the learned Senior
Counsel submitted that as far as the allegations against additional
respondent Nos.3, 4 and 8 to 11 are concerned, the finding of the
Interim Board for Settlement, a quasi-judicial authority, is a
relevant fact to proceed against them.
10. Sri.P.Vijaya Bhanu, the learned Senior Counsel appearing
for respondent Nos.8 to 11, submitted that the confession alleged to
have been given by the Chief Financial Officer of CMRL before the
Interim Board for Settlement has no evidentiary value and the same
cannot be relied upon to set the criminal law in motion.
11. Sri.P.A.Mohammed Shah, the learned counsel appearing
for respondent No.6, submitted that based on an inadmissible entry
on a diary, which is not a 'book of account' as provided in Section 34
of the Indian Evidence Act, it could not be concluded that there is
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
any prima facie material to show that respondent No.6 had
accepted bribe from CMRL abusing his official position. The learned
counsel submitted that when the complaint does not reveal any
offence, the course open to the learned Special Judge was only to
reject the complaint at the threshold.
12.
Sri.S.Rajeev, the learned counsel for respondent No.7,
submitted that the entries in the diary maintained by the authorised
representative of CMRL have no evidentiary value and hence, no
prosecution can be initiated based on them. The learned counsel
submitted that there is no prima facie material to show that
respondent No.7 accepted bribe from CMRL. The learned counsel
relied on CBI v. V.C. Shukla [(1998) 3 SCC 410] and Manohar Lal
Sharma v. Union of India [(2017) 11 SCC 731] to support his
contentions.
13. Sri.T.A. Shaji, the learned Director General of Prosecution,
submitted that the entries in the loose papers relied on by the
defacto complainant have no evidentiary value, and no prosecution
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
can be initiated based on the same. The learned Director General
of Prosecution further submitted that even the entries in the books
of account cannot alone be sufficient evidence to charge any
person with liability.
14. I shall first consider the evidentiary value of the loose
papers relied on by the revision petitioner to fasten criminal
liability. The relevant provision dealing with the matter is Section
34 of the Indian Evidence Act.
15. Section 34 of the Evidence Act reads thus:
“34. Entries in books of account including those
maintained in an electronic form when relevant
Entries in books of accounts, including those maintained
in an electronic form, regularly kept in the course of
business, are relevant whenever they refer to a matter
into which the Court has to inquire, but such statements
shall not alone be sufficient evidence to charge any
person with liability.”
16. As per Section 34 of the Evidence Act, entries in the books
of accounts regularly kept in the course of business are relevant
whenever they refer to a matter under enquiry.
However, the
Section cautions that such a statement shall not alone be sufficient
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
evidence to fasten a person with criminal liability. What is relevant
under Section 34 of the Evidence Act is the entries in the books of
account. A 'Book' ordinarily means a collection of sheets of paper
or other material, blank, written or printed, fastened or bound
together to form a material whole.
Loose sheets or scraps of
paper cannot be termed as 'book' as they can be easily detached
and replaced. The term 'book' in the context of Section 34 of the
Evidence Act signifies a collection of sheets of paper bound
together with the intention that such binding shall be permanent
and the papers used collectively in one volume.
17. In CBI v. V.C. Shukla [(1998) 3 SCC 410], the Apex Court
had considered the relevance of the entries in Jain Hawala diaries,
notebooks and files containing loose sheets of papers not in the
form of “books of account” and held that such entries in loose
papers/sheets are irrelevant and not admissible under Section 34
of the Indian Evidence Act, and that only the entries that are made
in the books of accounts regularly kept, depending on the nature of
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
occupation, are admissible.
18. In V.C. Shukla (supra), the Apex Court observed that from
a plain reading of the Section 34 of the Evidence Act, it is manifest
that to make an entry relevant thereunder, it must be shown that it
has been made in a book, that book is a book of account and that
book of account has been regularly kept in the course of business.
From the above section, it is also manifest that even if the above
requirements are fulfilled and the entry becomes admissible as
relevant evidence, still the statement made therein shall not alone
be sufficient evidence to charge any person with liability. It is thus
seen that while the first part of the section speaks of the relevancy
of the entry as evidence, the second part speaks, in a negative way,
of its evidentiary value for charging a person with a liability. It will,
therefore, be necessary to ascertain first whether the entries in
the documents relied on by the petitioner fulfil the requirements of
the above section so as to be admissible in evidence and if this
question is answered in the affirmative, then only its probative
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
value need be assessed. The Apex Court further held therein that
meaning of the account book under Section 34 of the Evidence Act
would be spiral notebook/pad, but not loose sheets.
19. In Manohar Lal Sharma v. Union of India [(2017) 11 SCC
731], following the principles declared in V.C. Shukla (supra) the
Supreme Court held that loose sheets of paper are wholly
irrelevant as evidence, not admissible under Section 34 of the
Evidence Act, so as to constitute evidence with respect to the
transactions mentioned therein and having no evidentiary value.
20. It is to be noted that the entries made in the loose sheets
were stated to have been done at the back of the persons whose
names have been indicated therein to whom the payments were
allegedly made. It is important to note that the petitioner has not
placed any material to connect the additional respondents, against
whom the allegations have been levelled, in fact, had any nexus
with the matter or has done some act during the relevant period
which may correlate with the entries in the loose papers.
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
21. The learned Special Judge, in the impugned order, dealt
with the allegations in the complaint as follows:
“3. Heard the complainant. Perused complaint and
documents produced along with the complaint. The entire
complaint is based on the order in the proceedings before
the Interim Board for Settlement, New Delhi. The order is
dated 12 June 2023. That order was passed on an
application by 8th respondent company herein and 9th
respondent who is the managing director of the said
company. It was an application under the Income-tax Act. In
the petition the respondents 8 and 9 had sought for some
reliefs under the Income-tax Act on the assessment made
by the income tax authorities. The proceedings related to
income for the assessment years 2013-2014 to 2019-2020.
The respondent had sought for treating huge amounts
towards business expenditure which was rejected by the
Department.
4. Following search, and seizure of some documents,
the income tax department had found that 8 th respondent
had shown Rs.99.31 crores towards fictitious expenses
under the heads of transportation etc. Rs.34.51 crores were
found to be inflated payments to vendors. 1.72 crores were
claimed to be towards software expenses. Thus Rs.135.549
crores had been assessed by the Department. It had come
out in the enquiry that the company had made payments in
cash to various persons. The 10th respondent herein who
was the chief financial officer of 8th respondent company
had made some entries in loose pages allegedly using
short forms. Those notes were seized in the search made
by the Department. In the enquiry he said that the following
letters stand for the corresponding names:
KK- Kunjali Kutty
AG- A Govindan
0C- Oommen Chandy
PV- Pinarayi Vijayan
IK-Ibrahim Kunju
RC- Ramesh Chennithala
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
5. The 10th respondent in his statement before the
authorities had said that payments were made to
functionaries/members of various political parties, temples,
media houses, Police etc cetera for smooth functioning of
their business. Their business was having environmental
impact as a result of which they receive large number of
threats to obstruct their business or hinder smooth
functioning of their day-to-day activities. In order to
overcome those threats and to obtain cooperation, they
were making payments to members/functionaries of
various political parties, state Police, media houses,
temples etc., so as to ensure smooth functioning of their
day-to-day activities. Those payments were made as
demanded by them.
6. The interim Board of settlement held that 1.72
crores paid to respondents 1 and 7 during the assessment
years 2017-2018 to 2019-2020 did not qualify as business
expenditure. It is based on the stated ground that evidence
gathered during search did not show any service rendered
to 8th respondent by 7th respondent.
7. The above payments to respondents 1 and 7 are
made through accounts. For other payments to various
political parties/individuals, temples, media houses, Police
etc., there is nothing to indicate that they had received the
amount except the alleged entries in loose papers
maintained by 10th respondent or other officers of 8 th
respondent. Section 34 of the Evidence Act while treating
such entries as relevant says that such statements alone
shall not be sufficient evidence to charge any person with
liability. Such entries may be ground for inquiry or
investigation if there are materials to show that
respondents 2 to 6 had given any favours to 8th respondent
by abusing their official position as public servants.
8. This court has jurisdiction to inquire into or try
only the offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act,
1988. The conspiracy to commit an offence under above Act
also can be tried by this court. When offence under
Prevention of Corruption Act is committed, other offences
which can be jointly tried with that offence also can be tried
by Special Judge under Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
This petition is lodged on the premise that the very
functioning of 8th respondent company is illegal. The
purport of the first paragraph of the complaint is that the
alleged payments to respondents 2 to 6 by respondents 8 to
12 are In consideration of 'such mining and other business'
of 8th respondent. What is revealed In the enquiry conducted
by Interim Board for Settlement is that there had been a
general funding including political funding to various
political parties/functionaries of political parties, media
houses, temples etc. as usually done by business groups.
There is only a mere allegation that this is in return for
favors given to 8th respondent company. Such general
allegations are insufficient to initiate criminal proceedings
especially under Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. In
order to initiate proceedings for an offence under the
Prevention of Corruption Act 1988 against a public servant,
the complainant should reveal or disclose material facts
which will show the commission of such offence by the
public servants concerned. In this petition, apart from the
general allegations made, complainant has not furnished
any material facts which will show that respondents 2 to 6
had given any favors to 8 th respondent in their capacity as
public servants in return for the alleged payments. There is
no case for the petitioner that any of the respondents had
officially dealt with any matters pertaining to 8th
respondent. Apart from making a general statement that
the payments are bribery for consideration, the complaint
does not disclose the material particulars which will show
a prima facie case of commission of offences under
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The Complaint also does
not say which offence under the Prevention of Corruption
Act 1988 is committed by respondents.
9. There is no allegation in the complaint nor any
facts disclosed in the complaint that the payment to
respondents 1 and 7 by 8th respondent was towards any
particular favors or benefits received by 8 th respondent
from second respondent. There is no allegation that 2 nd
respondent had dealt with any matters pertaining to 8 th
respondent and had shown any favors to 8 th respondent by
abusing his official position.
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
10. The complaint or the order of the Interim Board
for Settlement dated 12 June 2023 do not show a prima
facie case of commission of any offences punishable under
provisions of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 by any
respondents herein….”
22.
Based on the above-referred materials, the revision
petitioner sought a direction to the special court to take cognizance
of the offences alleged in the complaint.
23. The revision petitioner seeks to take cognizance of the
offences alleged under Section 190 of the Cr.PC.
24. Section 190 of the Cr.PC reads thus:
“190. Cognizance of offences by Magistrates.(1)
Subject to the provisions of this Chapter, any
Magistrate of the first class, and any Magistrate of the
second class specially empowered in this behalf under
sub-section (2), may take cognizance of any offence (a)
upon receiving a complaint of facts which
constitute such offence;
(b)
upon a police report of such facts;
(c)
upon information received from any person
other than a police officer, or upon his own
knowledge, that such offence has been
committed.
(2) The Chief Judicial Magistrate may empower any
Magistrate of the second class to take cognizance under
Sub-Section (1) of such offences as are within his
competence to inquire into or try.”
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
25.
A competent court under Section 190 Cr.PC may take
cognizance of any offence upon receiving a complaint as per Section
2(d), but such complaint shall be a complaint of facts which
constitute such offence.
26. It is relevant to note that the words ‘or suspicion’ in the old
Section 190 have been omitted in the corresponding Section in the
Code of 1973. Section 190 of the old Code had enabled the Magistrate
to take cognizance of an offence not only on his knowledge but also
'on suspicion' that an offence has been committed.
The Law
Commission, in its 41st Report observed;
“We recognize that a police officer can, in certain
circumstances, act on suspicion-(reasonable of course) that an
offence has been committed, but we do not think it wise to place
such a responsibility on a Judicial Officer, and we therefore,
propose to delete that provision from the clause.”
27. Based on the Law Commission Report the legislature had
intentionally removed the words “or suspicion” from Section 190 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. Under Section 190 of the Code
of 1973 and under Section 210 of the BNSS, a Magistrate may take
cognizance of an offence upon receiving a complaint of “facts” which
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
constitute an offence or upon knowledge that such offence has been
committed and not on “suspicion”.
28. A Magistrate is not bound to take cognizance of an offence
merely because a complaint is filed before him. The complaint shall
contain necessary facts constituting the offence alleged.
He is
required to carefully apply his mind to the contents of the complaint
to see if the facts disclosed the offence alleged before taking
cognizance of the offence alleged therein {Vide: Delhi Race Club
(1940) Ltd. v. State of U.P. [(2024) 10 SCC 690] and Usha Chakraborty
v. State of West Bengal (2023 KHC 6085) : (AIR 2023 SC 688) : [(2023)
15 SCC 135]}.
29. In the present case, the revision petitioner could place
materials highlighting the suspicion that the public servants arrayed
as respondents were involved in doubtful financial transactions. The
suspicion so highlighted cannot be substituted for facts constituting
the offences alleged.
30. It is trite that the prosecution brought or initiated under
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
the Prevention of Corruption Act cannot be casually approached by
Courts. This Court in Manoj Abraham, IPS v. P.P.Chandrasekharan
Nair and Another [2017 (3) KHC 983] : [2017 SCC Online Ker 9094] :
[(2018) 1 KLT 174] has considered this question, wherein it was held
thus:
“21...............A prosecution brought or initiated under
the P.C. Act cannot be casually approached by
Courts. It is quite unlike a prosecution alleging
assault or some other offences. Even an
unnecessary investigation may cause blemish, on
the career of a public servant. Once such a blemish
is caused, it would be very difficult to erase it.
Before ordering investigation on a complaint under
Section 156(3) Cr. P.C. the Special Court must
examine not only the complaint, but also the other
materials substantiating the allegations in the
complaint. Such orders cannot be mechanically
passed by the Special Courts. This Court has come
across many such complaints mechanically
forwarded by Courts under Section 156(3) Cr. P.C. for
investigation...................”
31. On a careful analysis of the materials placed before this
Court, I am of the view that the revision petitioner failed to place
any credible material to fasten criminal liability on the additional
respondents.
32. Unless the order passed by the Magistrate is perverse, or
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
the view taken by the court is wholly unreasonable or there is
nonconsideration of any relevant material, or there is palpable
misreading of records, the Revisional Court is not justified in
setting aside the order, merely because another view is possible.
The Revisional Court is not meant to act as an appellate court. The
whole purpose of the revisional jurisdiction is to preserve the
power in the court to do justice in accordance with the principles of
criminal jurisprudence. The revisional power of the court under
Sections 397 to 401 Cr.P.C is not to be equated with that of an
appeal. Unless the finding of the court, whose decision is sought to
be revised, is shown to be perverse or untenable in law or is
grossly erroneous or glaringly unreasonable or where the decision
is based on no material or where the material facts are wholly
ignored or where the judicial discretion is exercised arbitrarily or
capriciously, the courts may not interfere with the decision in
exercise of their revisional jurisdiction. {Vide: Sanjaysinh Ramrao
Chavan v. Dattatray Gulabrao Phalke [(2015) 3 SCC 123], Munna Devi
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
v. State of Rajasthan & Anr [(2001) 9 SCC 631)] and Asian
Resurfacing of Road Agency Pvt. Ltd. v. Central Bureau of
Investigation [(2018) 16 SCC 299)]}.
33. The Criminal Revision Petition, therefore, lacks merits,
and it stands dismissed.
34. It is made clear that the rejection of the complaint does
not stand in the way of filing a fresh complaint or initiating
prosecution against additional respondents 3 to 11 with adequate
materials in future.
Before parting with the matter, this Court places on record its
profound appreciation to the learned counsel Sri.Akhil Vijay, for his
valuable assistance as Amicus Curiae.
Sd/-
K.BABU,
JUDGE
KAS
2025:KER:26645
Crl.R.P NO.890 OF 2023
APPENDIX OF CRL.REV.PET 890/2023
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure 1
CERTIFIED COPY OF ORDER IN CRL MP
NO.1546/2023 DATED 26/08/2023
Annexure 2
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF SETTLEMENT
DATED 12/06/2023.
Annexure 3
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION WITH
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT DATED 16/08/2023
Annexure 4
TRUE COPY OF COMPLAINT U/VIDE CRL. M P
NO.1546/2023 DATED 23/08/2023.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review