The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. Now, coming to the question of sentence, the appellant has already suffered 2.5 years of jail sentence and the maximum sentence is provided upto seven years under the provision of Section 325 of IPC. The appellant has already suffered the ordeal of this case since 04 years, hence, looking the nature of injury, sentence of three years would meet the ends of justice. Resultantly, the appeal is partly allowed and the appellant is convicted under Section 325 of IPC and sentenced for 3 years R.I. with fine of Rs.10000/-. In case of failure to deposit the fine amount, he shall further to undergo for 3 months S.I.
28. The appellant is in jail, he be set at liberty forthwith if not required in jail in any case after completion of the aforesaid jail sentence and thereafter, his bail bond shall be discharged thereafter, subject to deposit the fine amount.
29. The order of the learned trial Court regarding disposal of the seized property stands confirmed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PREM NARAYAN SINGH
ON THE 31st OF JANUARY, 2024
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 8751 of 2023
BETWEEN:GHANSHYAM @ PUSHKARLAL S/O ISHWARLAL
PATIDAR, AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURIST VILLAGE RAJAKHEDI P.S. NAI ABADI
DISTRICT MANDSAUR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI SANTOSH KUMAR MEEN, ADVOCATE )
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH STATION HOUSE
OFFICER THROUGH POLICE STATION NAI ABADI
DISTRICT MANDSAUR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI RAJESH JOSHI, GA FOR THE STATE )
Heard On:21.12.2023
Delivered on 31.01.2024
This appeal was heard and the Court has pronounced the following:
JUDGMENT
Appellant has preferred this appeal under Section 374 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short 'the Code') against the judgment dated
14.06.2023 passed by Sessions Judge, District Mandsaur in S.T. No.148/2021,
whereby the appellant has been convicted for the offence punishable under
Section 304 (2) of I.P.C. and sentenced to undergo 07 years R.I. with a fine of
Rs.5000/- and in default of payment of fine, to further undergo one months
R.I.
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/31/2024
6:47:32 PM
2. Briefly stated facts of the case are that, the deceased Bhanwarlal and
his brother Ishwarlal lived in their Tapris (huts) and their field are adjacent to
each other. There was a boundary line between fields of both the parties.
Ishwarlal used to tamper such boundary line and on account of that there was a
dispute between them. On 16.05.2021 at around 7PM, Ishwarlal and his son
Ghanshyam (accused) were making some change in the boundary line by
removing stone pieces put thereon. As per the further case of the prosecution,
Bhanwarlal objected Ishwarlal and Ghanshyam to replace the stone pieces and
due to that both brought sticks from their Tapri and assaulted Bhanwarlals with
intention to kill him. Both the accused have caused injury on head to
Bhanwarlal, resulted him falling on the ground. Gopal Patidar and Govind
Patidar intervened them and thereafter, the appellant and co-accused ran away
from the spot. The injured was hospitalized to the District hospital Mandsaur
and the offence was registered against the appellant under Section 307 of IPC.
But during treatment, the injured expired, therefore, the offence under Section
302 of IPC was converted.
3..The police party, after following due procedure, arrested the accused
person and registered the case against the appellant. After due investigation,
charge-sheet was filed against the appellant/accused under Section 302 of IPC.
4 . In turn, the case was committed to the Court of Session and
thereafter, appellant was charged for offence under Section Section 302 of IPC.
He abjured his guilt and took a plea that he had been falsely implicated in the
present crime and prayed for trial.
5. In support of the case, the prosecution has examined as many as 08
witnesses namely Gopal Patidar (PW-1), Dr. Anil Patidar
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/31/2024
6:47:32 PM
(PW-2), Rajula
Patidar (PW-3), Govind Patidar (PW-4), Rahul Patidar (PW-5), Dr.
Mohammad Irfan (PW-6), B.S. Gore (PW-7) & Lal Singh Dodiya (PW-8). No
witness has been adduced by the appellant in his defence.
06. Learned trial Court, on appreciation of the evidence and argument
adduced by the parties, pronounced the impugned judgment on 14.06.2023 and
finally concluded the case and convicted the appellant for commission of the
said offence under the provisions of Section 304-II of IPC.
7 . Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the the appellant is
innocent and the learned trial Court has convicted the appellant wrongly without
considering the evidence available on record. Counsel for the appellant further
submits that the appellant has not caused any fatal injury to the deceased
because there is nothing on record to show that the deceased was died due to
the injury caused by the appellant. It is further submitted that there are material
contradictions and omissions in the statements of the prosecution witnesses but
the learned trial Court has erred in ignoring the same and in convicting the
appellant. The offence was committed in the heated spur of moment and the
incident was ocurred without any specific intention or knowledge. It is further
submitted that PW-3, Rajula Patidar son of the deceased has turned hostile and
has not supported the case of the prosecution and as per the statement made by
this witnesses, the injury has been received by his father by slipping over a
stone. There is no independent witness in the present case and all the witnesses
are almost relatives of the deceased.
8. It is also submitted that as per the MLC report, the doctor has opinion
only single injury on the head whereas the allegations against two accused
persons are to cause injury by stick only. It is submitted that if the case of the
prosecution is received in its face value, the same shall not be traveled beyond
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/31/2024
6:47:32 PM
the provisions of Section 325 of IPC.
9 . It is further submitted that learned Court below has failed to
appreciate the prosecution evidence and has also erred in convicting the
appellant. Hence, prays for acquittal of the appellant.
10. In alternate, learned counsel for the appellant Submits that the learned
trial Court has convicted the appellant under Section 304(II) of IPC and
sentenced for 07 years R.I. which is on higher side as per the provisions of law.
The appellant has already undergone approximately 2 years and 8 months of his
incarceration period and prays that if the appellant is awarded sentence of jail to
the period of the imprisonment already undergone under the provisions of
Section 304(II) of IPC then the ends of justice will be met.
11 . Learned Public Prosecutor has opposed the prayer. Inviting my
attention towards the conclusive paragraphs of the impugned judgement,
learned public prosecutor has submitted that the deceased had died due to the
injury caused by the appellant and the learned trial Court has rightly convicted
the appellant by sentencing him appropriately. Hence, prays for dismissal of the
appeal.
12. I have considered rival contentions of the parties and perused the
record.
13. In view of the evidence available on record and the contentions
advanced by counsel for both the parties, this Court has to decide the question
as to whether the findings of learned trial Court regarding conviction under
Section 304-II of IPC, are correct in the eyes of law and facts or not?
14. In this case, the prosecution has relied upon the testimony of witness
Gopal Patidar, PW-1. the witness has stated in his examiation in chief that when
the deceased has intervened the accused persons not to remove the boundaries
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/31/2024
6:47:32 PM
of the filed, they assaulted Bhanwarlal with wooden sticks, when he went there
to intervene, they fled away from the spot after causing injury to Bhanwarlal. At
that time, the injured was fallen down and there was a head injury and blood
was oozing out. Testimony of this witness has not been controverted in his
cross-examination. Certainly, other eye-witnesses Rajulal Patidar PW-3, Govind
Patidar PW-4 and Rahul Patidar PW-5 have not supported the case of
prosecution.
15. Now, the question is as to whether without support of another eyewitness on the basis of sole testimony of Gopal Patidar, the findings of the
learned trial Court regarding conviction and sentence can be affirmed. It is
paramount principle that even number of witnesses have not supported the
prosecution case, the conviction can be based on the sole testimony of single
witness. It is quality not the quantity of evidence, to be considered while
appreciating the available evidence.
16. Section 134 of the Evidence Act, specifically mandates that no
particular number of witnesses shall in any case be required for the proof of any
fact. On this aspect, the law laid down by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Vithal Pundalik Zendge Vs. State of Maharashtra reported, AIR 2009
SC 1110 is worth referring to the context of the case. Relevant para 6 and 7 of
the said judgment is reproduced below :6. On a consideration of the relevant authorities and
the provisions of the IndianEvidence Act, 1872 (in short
the 'Evidence Act') the following propositions may be
safely stated as firmly established:
(i) As a general rule, a court can and may
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/31/2024
6:47:32 PM
act on the testimony of a single witness though
uncorroborated.
One
credible
witness
outweighs the testimony of a number of other
witnesses of indifferent character.
(ii) Unless corroboration is insisted upon
by
statute,
courts
should
not insist on
corroboration except in cases where the nature
of the testimony of the single witness itself
requires
as
a
rule
of
prudence, that
corroboration should be insisted upon, for
example in the case of a child witness, or of a
witness
whose evidence is
that of an
accomplice or of an analogous character.
( i i i ) Whether
corroboration
of
the
testimony of a single witness is or is not
necessary, must depend upon facts and
circumstances of each case and no general rule
can be laid down in a matter like this and much
depends upon the judicial discretion of the
Judge before whom the case comes.
7 . Therefore, there is no hesitation in
holding that the contention that in a murder
case the court should insist upon plurality of
witnesses, is much too broadly stated.
17. In view of the aforesaid principle of law, the statement of Gopal
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/31/2024
6:47:32 PM
Patidar would be accepted even it does not find support from other eyewitnesses. On this point, the view of Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of
Vinayak Singh vs. State of Bihar [1997 (1) SCC 2083] is worth referring
here where the maximum "evidence has to be weighed and not to be counted"
is well recognized.
18. That apart, the testimony of Gopal Patidar find support from the
statement of Dr. Ail Patidar who has initial examined the injured and found one
injury, which was right side on the head measuring 8x1cm. In this case, Dr.
Mohd. Irfan PW-6 has conducted the post mortem examination and given post
mortem report as Ex.P/9 and the report has supported the fact that there was
only single injury on the right perital region of the deceased. This doctor has
also opined that this injury is sufficient to endanger the life.
19. So far as the arguments regarding non-availability of independent
witnesses is concerned, it is well settled that no criminal case can be
overboarded due to non-availability of independent prosecution witnesses. In
this regard, the following verdict of landmark judgment of the Hon'ble Apex
Court rendered in the case of Appa Bhai vs. State of Gujarat AIR 1988 SC
696 is worth referring here as under:
"10.......Experience reminds us that civilized people are
generally insensitive when a crime is committed even in their
presence. They withdraw both from the victim and the vigilante.
They keep themselves away from the Court unless it is inevitable.
They think that crime like civil dispute is between two individuals
or parties and they should not involve themselves. This kind of
apathy of the general public is indeed unfortunate, but it is there
everywhere whether in village life, towns or cities. One cannot
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/31/2024
6:47:32 PM
ignore this handicap with which the investigating agency has to
discharge its duties. The court, therefore, instead of doubting the
prosecution case for want of independent witness must consider the
broad spectrum of the prosecution version and then search for the
nugget of truth with due regard to probability if any, suggested by
the accused......"
20. In view of the aforesaid principle, if the witnesses have not supported
the prosecution case regarding injury and the incident, it does not create any
surprise because virtually, most of the public persons did not want to be
intricated between the others dispute because they have no sympathy or apathy
with the deceased. However, only on that basis, the case of the prosecution
could not be overboarded because they are well supported by the statements of
other witnesses and medical testimony.
21. Now, coming to the next limb of argument, learned counsel for the
appellant vehemently contended that this is a case of single blow, therefore, it
cannot be assumed against the appellant that he has caused injury to the injured
with intention to kill the deceased. Had he had such type of intention, he would
cause cause repeated blow upon the deceased.
22. On this aspect, the law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the
case of Mohd. Ishaq Mohammad vs. State of Maharashtra [1979 Law
Suit (SC) 212] is worth referring here as under:"We have heard learned Counsel for the parties and have gone
through the judgment of the High Court and of the Sessions Judge.
The occurrence in the course of which the deceased was assaulted,
took place suddenly and after hot exchange of abuses, which took
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/31/2024
6:47:32 PM
place between the deceased and the appellants. The appellants are
said to have assaulted the deceased with sticks. There is no evidence
to show as to which of the appellants struck the fatal blow on the
deceased. Having regard therefore to the circumstances of the
present case and the nature of injuries sustained by the appellants, we
are unable to agree with the High Court that the case falls under
Section 302. There is no evidence of any intention on the part of the
appellant either to cause death of the deceased or cause such injuries
of which the appellant could have the knowledge that it was likely to
cause death although it cannot be doubted that the appellant had the
common intention to cause grievous hurt to the deceased by lathis.
Thus the offence falls under Section 325/34 and not under Section
302 or 304(1). It appears that the appellants have already served their
sentences or at any rate a substantial part of it. For these reasons,
therefore, we would allow this appeal to this extent that the
conviction of the appellants are altered from that under Section
302/34 to one under Section 325/34 and the sentences are reduced to
five years in each case.".
23. On the same point, Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Ratan Singh,
Ran Singh & Anr. vs. State of Punjab [1988 Law Suit (SC) 214] has
observed as under:"2. Admittedly according to the prosecution's own case Ran
Singh and Rattan Singh were carrying lathis which could be
described as hard and blunt object. Such injuries on the person of
the deceased were either on hands or on feet and at best what could
be attributed to them could be injuries resulting in fractures. None of
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/31/2024
6:47:32 PM
these two appellants could be convicted for causing injuries
individually which could make out an offence under Section 302. At
best they could only be convicted under Section 325 of IPC only."
24. In Mahendra Singh vs. State of Dehli Administration [AIR 1986
SC 309], it is held that grievous heart caused by blunt weapon like lathi, can fall
within section 325 of IPC and not under Section 326 of IPC. Likewise, in
another case, Halke vs. State of M.P. [AIR 1994 SC 951], wherein it is held
that the accused caused death of deceased by inflicting blows on him with
stick. Head injury proved to be fatal and deceased died after a week. In this
case, the accused was held liable and punished under Section 325 of IPC. The
following excerpts of the aforesaid judgement is worth to refer here:"9....................No doubt the injury on the head
proved to be fatal after lapse of one week but from that
alone it cannot be said that the offence committed by the
two appellants was one punishable under Section 304
Part II IPC. The injuries found on the witnesses are also
of the same nature and for the same they are convicted
under Section 325 of IPC."
25. Having gone through the evidence available on record, the case of the
appellant came under "Eighthly" of Section 320 of IPC which defines
"Grievous Hurt". Since the deceased had suffered a head injury which
endangers his life as suggested under the clause. It is established that the
deceased was conscious throughout the treatment and he expired after five days
of the incident i.e. on 21.05.2021. The medical evidence also does not bring out
that the injury which was caused, was fatal fatal injury in ordinary course of
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/31/2024
6:47:32 PM
nature to cause death. Admittedly, a single blow was used, hence, in the
considered opinion of this Court, the appellant can only be attributed for
committing the offence punishable under Section 325 of IPC.
26. On substratum of the aforesaid analysis in entirety, the appellant
cannot be convicted under section 304-II of IPC but rather the appellant would
be convicted only under Section 325 of IPC. As such, the impugned judgment
passed by learned trial court qua the conviction of the appellant under Section
304-II of IPC, is hereby set aside and the appellant is convicted under Section
325 of IPC.
27. Now, coming to the question of sentence, the appellant has already
suffered 2.5 years of jail sentence and the maximum sentence is provided upto
seven years under the provision of Section 325 of IPC. The appellant has
already suffered the ordeal of this case since 04 years, hence, looking the nature
of injury, sentence of three years would meet the ends of justice. Resultantly,
the appeal is partly allowed and the appellant is convicted under Section 325 of
IPC and sentenced for 3 years R.I. with fine of Rs.10000/-. In case of failure to
deposit the fine amount, he shall further to undergo for 3 months S.I.
28. The appellant is in jail, he be set at liberty forthwith if not required in
jail in any case after completion of the aforesaid jail sentence and thereafter, his
bail bond shall be discharged thereafter, subject to deposit the fine amount.
29. The order of the learned trial Court regarding disposal of the seized
property stands confirmed.
30. A copy of this order be sent to the learned trial Court concerned for
information.
Certified copy, as per rules.
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/31/2024
6:47:32 PM
(PREM NARAYAN SINGH)
JUDGE
AMIT
Signed by: AMIT KUMAR
Signing time: 1/31/2024
6:47:32 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review