Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:16591
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016
-------Geeta Kumari, S/o. Late Triloki Prasad Singh, R/o. Boaria, P.O.Yasoda Math, P.S.- Motipur, Dist.- Muzaffarpur, Bihar, Presently
R/o.- Vill.- Bhikhanpura, P.O.- Ramna, P.S.- Sadar, Dist.Muzaffarpur, Bihar. (Legal Heirs)
... ... Petitioner
Versus
…… Opp. Party
The State of Jharkhand
-------PRESENT
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP KUMAR SRIVASTAVA
For the Petitioner
For the State
-------: Ms. Sneha Rani, Advocate
: Mr. Abhishek Verma, Advocate
: Mr. Abhay Kr. Tiwari, A.P.P.
C.A.V. On: 05th May,2026
1.
Pronounced On: 09/06/2026
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner as well as learned
A.P.P.
2.
It is pertinent to mention at the very outset here that original
petitioner, namely, Triloki Prasad Singh has challenged his conviction
and sentence passed by the learned Trial Court and upheld by the
learned Appellate Court for the offence under Section 409 of the I.P.C.
and directed to undergo R.I. for 3 years alongwith the fine of Rs.
1,000/-. The revisionist Triloki Prasad Singh died during the pendency
of this revision and substituted by his wife Geeta Kumari for
contesting this revision on merits.
Factual Matrix:-
3.
Factual matrix giving rise to this revision is that Triloki Prasad
Singh (since deceased) was posted as Assistant Manager Burmamines
(Oxygen) godown of Bihar Stated Food and Supply Corporation from
08.04.1994. In the physical verification of the godown from
13.04.1995 to 26.04.1995 by the Child Development Officer,
Jamshedpur, on the basis of confidential information about some
irregularities, the Child Development Officer, Jamshedpur conducted
an enquiry in the said godown but Assistant Manager Triloki Prasad
Singh was absent and absconded after taking all the important register
and documents from the said godown since 15.03.1995 and he was
continuously absent since then. It is further alleged that after physical
verification, the account was prepared by then District Manager, T. N.
Sharma and Assistant Account Officer, Shanti Ratan Bhatacharjee
from 08.04.1994 to 24.04.1995 on the basis of available documents
with assistance of the then accountant Sri Phulan Prasad but after
preparation of the aforesaid account description, Sri Phulan Prasad did
not sign over it for reason based known to him. It is further alleged
that from the statement of account prepared, it transpired that Triloki
Prasad Singh Assistant Manager had misappropriated 10-14.500
quintals of wheat and 266.500 quintals of rice, worth Rs. 1,38,118.83
(rupees one lakh thirty eight thousand one hundred eighteen and
eighty three paisa). Therefore, the then District Manager, T. N.
Sharma through his confidential Letter No. 39 dated 28.04.1995
informed the Managing Director, State Food Corporation and the
Chief Administrator of Bihar Food Corporation vide confidential
Letter No. 89 dated 06.06.1995 respectively recommending for
institution of F.I.R. against Sri T. P. Singh. It is further alleged by the
informant that the then District Manager T. N. Sharma has shown
affection to Triloki Prasad Singh and the said godown used to have
2|Page
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
got all allotment of food grains under JRY Scheme, even if, the
capacity of the godown was much less. It is further alleged that since
all the documents of this period has been removed, there may be
possibility of larger defalcation.
4.
On the basis of aforesaid typed information by the informant,
Golmuri (Burmamines) P.S. Case No. 95 of 1995 was registered
against accused Triloki Prasad Singh and others for the offence under
Section 409, 420, 467, 468 & 471 of the I.P.C.
5.
After conclusion of investigation, two charge-sheets were
submitted vide Charge-sheet No. 7097 dated 23.06.1997 against
Triloki Prasad Singh and Janki Ram Rajak and Charge-sheet No. 17
dated 29.02.2000 against Tarak Nath Sharma.
6.
The accused persons denied from the charges levelled against
them and claimed to be tried.
7.
The Trial Court after evaluating the evidence available on
record, found that the food grains involved in this case were entrusted
to thee accused Triloki Prasad Singh and the prosecution has not been
able to prove direct involvement of other accused persons, namely,
Janki Ram Rajak and Tarak Nath Sharma. Accordingly, convicted
Triloki Prasad Singh alone was held guilty for the offence under
Section 409 of the I.P.C. and other accused persons were acquitted.
8.
The convict Triloki Prasad Singh preferred an Appeal being
Criminal Appeal No. 139 of 2012 before the Court of learned Sessions
Judge, Jamshedpur which was decided by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge-VIII, Jamshedpur vide judgment dated 07.04.2016, the
3|Page
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
conviction and sentence of the petitioner Triloki Prasad Singh was
upheld and confirmed, which has been assailed in this Revision.
Submission on behalf of the Petitioner:9.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that in this
case, by the order of Hon’ble Patna High Court, authorities were
directed to constitute a committee to make an enquiry and fix the
responsibility and liability for the purpose of realizing the defalcated
amount. Therefore, a Money Suit No. 22 of 1998 was filed and a
Committee of high officials was constituted.
The Committee submitted its report as under:“समीक्षा के क्रम में पाया गया कक प्रभार के आदान प्रदान के समय
श्री रजक ने ककसी प्रकार की क्षकि की किकायि नही ीं ककया और न
ही बाद में श्री रजक द्वारा कजला प्रबींधक को क्षकि की सूचना दी गई।
भौकिक सत्यापन में खाद्यान की क्षकि प्रकाि में आई एवीं मुख्यालय
ज्ाींपक 1399, कदनाींक 02.03.2001 एवीं स्मार ज्ाींपक 2016 कदनाींक
04.04.2001द्वारा पू छे जाने पर श्री रजक का आवेदन कदनाींक
21.04.2001 को प्राप्त हुआ, कजसमें उन्ोींने क्षकि राकि के कलए, उन्ें
कजम्मेदार ठहराये जाने पर आपकि प्रकट की है ।
सकमकि यह महसूस करिी है की जब प्रभार के आदान प्रदान के
समय ककसी प्रकार की क्षकि प्रकाि में नही ीं आई और न ही बाद में,
उसकी जानकारी श्री रजक द्वारा दी गई िब यकद प्रभार के बाद
ककसी प्रकार की क्षकि होिी है िो उसके कलए ग्रहण करने वाले
काकमिक ही कजम्मेदार होींगे, न कक प्रभार सौपने वाले काकमिक।“
10.
It is further submitted that when the Committee found the
petitioner to be innocent and the liability was attributed to Janki Ram
Rajak (co-accused) as responsible for defalcation. A departmental
proceeding was also initiated against him and ultimately decision was
taken in the proceeding awarding following punishments to him:-
4|Page
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
I.
Except suspension allowance said Rajak would get nothing.
II.
Rs. 1,38,110/- would be realized from Sri Rajak.
III.
One increment with cumulative effect be stopped.
IV.
He was censored
All the four punishment were given by Bihar State Food
Supplies and Corporation Limited.
11.
It is further submitted that during interregnum period, it is
further relevant to state her that the department requested the District
Magistrate, Chaibasa to withdraw the Money Suit as well as
criminalcase filed/pending against the petitioner. As a result, the
charge-sheet prepared against the petitioner remained ineffective.
However, the Court did not allow withdrawal and directed the
proceeding to proceed in accordance with law. In pursuance of the
recommendation of higher Committee, the Deputy Commissioner,
Singhbuum, Jamshedpur issued Letter directing the Additional Public
Prosecutor in-charge to withdraw both civil and criminal case pending
against the petitioner and to inform the authority. As a result, Civil
Suit filed before the Court of Sub-Judge was withdrawn and
subsequently, a petition was filed on behalf of the accused for his
discharge and/or dropping the criminal case which was pending
against him.
12.
The learned Trial Court on such petition for withdrawal filed on
07.08.2006 directed to keep it on record and put up on date fixed. The
petition was put up on 16.07.2008, on which dated the learned
Magistrate rejected the petition for withdrawal on the ground that the
5|Page
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
petition was filed on 07.05.2006 and it was moved on 25.06.2008
approximately after two years.
13.
It is further submitted that in the course of enquiry, it was found
that the petitioner was deputed on election duty and co-accused Janki
Ram Rajak was in-charge and after return, the petitioner had gone on
leave and Sri Rajak was in-charge and thereby, he was the person
responsible for defalcation.
14.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has further submitted that out
of 16 charge-sheeted witnesses examined during the trial by the
prosecution, PW-3 Mohd. Sultan, Assistant in B.S.F.C. J.S.R at
Kadma has specifically testified that “त्रिलोकी प्रसाद से सारा मामला
त्रिभाग ने सेटल कर त्रलया है उसका आिेदन DC Sir को त्रदया गया था त्रिसमें
उन्ोोंने कोटट से मामला बोंद करने एिों अत्रभयोिन िापस लेने का दरखास्त भी
त्रदया है । त्रिभाग के पि के अनु सार उनके त्रिरुद्ध कोई मामला लोंत्रबत नहीों है ।“
PW-4 has also stated that at the relevant time of alleged defalcation,
the godown in-charge was Janki Ram Rajak in absence of Triloki
Prasad Singh. He has also stated that high level Committee has also
reported for withdrawal of the case against Triloki Prasad Singh.
Likewise, PW-9 and PW-10 have also not supported the
prosecution case rather it was stated that documents were not seized
from Burmamines godown rather from Sakchi Godown.
PW-5 has stated nothing against the petitioner.
PW-6 was hostile.
PW-7 is a formal witness.
6|Page
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
PW-1 states that his statement was not recorded by the police
and similarly PW-2 and PW-3 have also not supported any allegation
against the petitioner.
Other witnesses on whose testimony, the Court has placed
reliance, namely,PW-11, PW-12, PW-13, PW-15 & PW-16 have also
stated nothing showing involvement of the petitioner in the alleged
defalcation.
15.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, in support of his arguments,
has also relied upon the following judgments:I.
Radha Pisharassiar Amma Vs. State of Kerala as report
in (2007) 13 SCC 410.
II.
Prabhat @ Bhai Narayan Wagh & Ors. Vs. State of
Maharashtra as reported in (2013) 10 SCC 391, wherein
it has been held as under:-“ some of the accused persons
acquitted giving benefit of doubt and conviction of only
one, on the basis of same set of evidence, suffering from
contradiction and discrepancies can’t be justified.”
16.
It is further submitted that the learned Trial Court has miserably
failed to consider the aforesaid materials as pointed out and ignoring
the same, simply observed that the petitioner was Assistant Manager
and was temporarily absent from duty makes no difference. Similarly,
application for withdrawal of prosecution was rejected in absurd
manner without recording any sound reasons. Since, the petitioner
was afforded opportunity to raise all the matters during trial, hence,
the said order was not challenged. The present scenario before the
learned Trial Court and the learned Appellate Court was to the effect
7|Page
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
that the defalcated money was already realized from accused Janki
Ram Rajak and Civil Suit was also withdrawn. Therefore, once
liability has been fixed and money has already been realized then
criminal liability only on the petitioner and acquitting the main
accused Janki Ram Rajak is absolutely illegal and beyond the weight
of the evidence available on record. Therefore, impugned judgment of
conviction and sentence of the petitioner is fit to be set aside which
suffers from perversity and serious error of law and the petitioner
(deceased) may be acquitted from the charges levelled against him.
Accordingly, this revision may be allowed.
Submission on behalf of the State:17.
On the other hand, learned A.P.P. has opposed the aforesaid
contentions raised on behalf of the petitioner and has submitted that
the learned Trial Court as well as the learned Appellate Court has
considered all the above points during trial and at the appellate stage
and decided against the petitioner. There is concurrent finding about
the guilt of the petitioner. The learned counsel for the petitioner has
failed to point out any glaring infirmity in the impugned judgment and
order calling for any interference in this revision. The finding of facts
against petitioner has become final by the concurrent finding recorded
by the learned Court below. Therefore, this revision is devoid of merit
and fit to be dismissed.
Analysis, discussion and reasons:-
18.
I have gone through the record of the case alongwith the
impugned judgment passed by the learned Trial Court as well as the
8|Page
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
learned Appellate Court in the light of contentions raised on behalf of
both the parties.
The only point for determination in this revision is that “as to
19.
whether the impugned judgment of conviction and sentence of
petitioner suffers from serious error of law calling for any interference
in this revision?
20.
Before adverting to the above points, I have to take brief
resume of the evidence adduced during trial in this case. In the course
of trial, it appears that altogether 15 witnesses have been examined by
the prosecution.
Apart from oral testimony, following documentary evidence
has been adduced on behalf of the prosecution:I.
Exhibit-1 &Exhibit-1/1 : Consolidated statement of rice of
Burmamines (Oxygen) godown for the period of
08.04.1994 to 26.04.1995 and signature of PW-8 over the
same.
II.
Exhibit-2:
Consolidated
statement
of
wheat
of
Burmamines (Oxygen) godown for the period from
08.04.1994 to 26.04.1995 and signature of PW-8 over the
same.
III.
Exhibit- 3: Original letter of District Manager dated
17.05.2007.
IV.
Exhibit- 4: Typed information report.
V.
Exhibit-5: Seizure list of goods inward register of Sakchi
godown.
9|Page
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
21.
PW-1 Aseem Kumar Biswas, Assistant in the Office of Food
Corporation at Chaibasa. According to his evidence, in the year 1995,
he was posted as Assistant in the Food Corporation office,
Jamshedpur. At that time, some defalcation took place in S.F.C.,
Burmamines godown but he does not know who was in charge of the
godown at that time. He has no knowledge about any inquiry
conducted in the matter. Although, he has stated that Assistant
Manager was Triloki Prasad Singh, who was in-charge prior to the
date of occurrence, but who was in-charge Assistant Manager at the
time of occurrence, he has no knowledge. Therefore, this witness has
not supported the prosecution case as alleged.
PW-2 Kumar Nawal Kishore is the Accountant cum in-charge
Assistant Account Officer, (AAO). According to his evidence, since
July, 1994 to April, 1995, he was posted as Assistant Accountant
Officer in Bihar State Food and Civil Supply Corporation Limited,
Jamshedpur Branch. He has further deposed that since February, 1994
to 24.04.1995, he has prepared grains dispatch statement and
produced the xerox copy of statement containing in two pages.
According to him, original is lying in the office. According to his
statement in the foresaid period, 10 quintals of wheat and 226 quintal
of rice was found short. He further states that this report was prepared
against then Assistant Manager, In-charge Triloki Prasad Singh and
District Manager was Tarak Nath Sharma. According to him, Triloki
Prasad Singh joined in April, 1994 and on that time, he was in election
duty and his diversion order was for three days.
10 | P a g e
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
In the meantime, District Manager ordered to shift the grains
from Burmamines(Oxygen) godown to Sakchi godown and food grains
were transferred to Sakchi godown. At that basis, physical verification
report was submitted by the constituted team appointed by Magistrate.
The aforesaid shortage of food grains happened in the period of
Assistant Manager In-charge of the godown whose liability was fixed.
He has specifically stated that diversion order of food grain from
Burmamines godown to Sakchi godown was made by the order of
the then District Manager Shri T.N. Sharma. Since, he has not
produced original report prepared by him, hence, xerox copy
submitted by him was marked as Exhibit- X for identification. This
witness clearly states, what happened after submitting of report, he
does not know.
PW- 3 Mohd. Sultan was also dealing Assistant in B.S.F.C.,
Jamshedpur. He has produced the report for the year 08.04.1994 to
26.04.1995 prepared by PW-1 A.K. Biswas. He has produced the
carbon copy of the report which shows shortage of 10 quintals of
wheat and 226 quintals of rice in the above period and this document
was marked as Exhibit-1. He has further proved the carbon copy of
statement prepared from original register by A. K. Biswas in respect
on 10 quintal of wheat, its carbon copy of the said report is marked as
Exhibit-2. He has further proved letter issued by the District Manager,
Sri Narendra Dev Jha to produce these documents before the Court.
The letter is marked as Exhibit-3.
This witness clearly admits that in the year 1994-1996, he was
not posted in any capacity at Burmamines godown of B.S.F.C.
11 | P a g e
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
In his cross-examination, he admits that neither Exhibit-1 nor
Exhibit-2 was prepared in his presence. He has no personal
knowledge about the said report and Exhibit-3 is also in his
handwriting which was scribed on instruction of District Manager,
Shri Narendra Dev Jha. Therefore, this witness, even having no
personal knowledge about the report, simply produced the said report.
The veracity of which has to be proved by PW-1, who had prepared
the same and what about the original register, which has not been
explained.
PW-4 Rameshwar Prasad Das has deposed that a team was
constituted in Patna for inquiry of defalcation in this case. He was also
member of the inquiry team, who approached to the concerned
godown and from the available office record, some paper work and
documents were prepared. He has further deposed that at that time,
District Manager was T.N. Sharma when the physical verification of
Burmamines godown was conducted at that time Janki Ram Rajak
was operating the godown. In transportation of food grains some
irregularities were found but to what amount of irregularities was
found he could not recollect. After inquiry, report was prepared and
submitted as he recollect that the irregularities were to the extent of
more than one lakh. According to him, whatever record was found in
the godown at that basis the inquiry report was submitted.
In his cross-examination, he admits that in the mean period of
defalcation, Assistant Manager was Triloki Prasad Singh, District
Manager was T.N. Sharma and Janki Ram Rajak was working as a
salesman.
12 | P a g e
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
PW-5 Sushil Kumar Lal Karn & PW-6 Surendar Rajak have
stated nothing and having no personal knowledge.
PW-7 Om Prakash Vermahas deposed that in the year 1989 to
October, 1996, he was posted in Bihar State Food Civil Supply
Corporation Limited, Jamshedpur as Assistant Accountant. At that
time, Shri Ravindra Prasad Singh was District Manager. He has
further proved that written report of this case was typed by official
typist Shri Shiv Pujan Prasad against this Assistant Godown Manager,
Triloki Prasad Singh which was signed by the District Manager and
marked Exhibit-4.
In his cross-examination, he clearly states that recording
regarding the facts in this case, he has no personal knowledge.
PW-8 Shanti Brat Bhatacharya, this witness has proved
consolidated statement of rice short in Burmamines godown for the
period of 08.04.1994 to 26.04.1995 on the basis of available papers
submitted by Shri Triloki Prasad Singh, then Assistant Manager of
B.S.F.C., Jamshedpur at that time the stock was fall short of 266.64
quintals of rice. He has further proved the signature on said report as
Exhibit 1/1. He has further stated that on the same day, wheat stock
was also inquired and it was short fall of 10-14.5 quintals of wheat
and the report was prepared which bears his signature and marked as
Exhibit- 2/1.
In his cross-examination, he clearly states that available
documents were not produced by accused Triloki Prasad Singh
because he was absent on the relevant time rather, the stock man
13 | P a g e
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
searched out the relevant registers and other documents. Accordingly,
inquiry was conducted and report was prepared.
PW-9 Laxman Lal was posted in B.S.F.C., Jamshedpur from 1993 to
1996 on different posts. He was in-charge of lifting food grains as per
direction of District Manager. He used to supply the food grains
allotted to the concerned godown and deliver to the transport agent.
There is nothing else in his evidence as regards what quantity of
wheat and rice was transported to the Burmamines godown.
PW-10 Ashok Kumar was also posted in B.S.F.C., Jamshedpur from
05.08.1996. At that day, police arrived at the office in presence of
another Assistant, Mukteshwar Prasad Verma at Sakchi godown and
asked for registers of the relevant periods. He submitted Bhandar
Panji (stock register) from page 01 to 49 out of which, page number
12 was torn. Similarly, Sakchi godown goods inward (Agman Panji)
page number 25 to 29 out of which page number 24 carbon copy of
page number 24 seized by police and seizure list was prepared by S.I.
Shailesh Kumar Singh, which was also signed by him marked
Exhibit- 5. He further states that in that period, Triloki Prasad Singh
was godown in-charge.
PW-11 Amrendra Narayan Singh, this witness was posted as Head
Clerk in B.S.FC., Head Office, Jamshedpur. But at the time of
occurrence, he was deputed in the office of Civil S.D.O., Jamshedpur.
He has further stated that in the said period, A.G.M. of Burmamines
godown was Triloki Prasad Singh and Janki Ram Rajak was also sales
agent. He has heard about some defalcation of wheat and rice in that
14 | P a g e
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
matter. Therefore, this witness is also a hearsay witness having no
personal knowledge about the fact of this case.
PW-12 Manoranjan Prasad is the partial Investigating Officer of
this case. This witness was officer in-charge of Burmamines Police
Station on 08.06.1997 and assumed the charge of investigation of this
case. After taking charge of investigation, he recorded the statement of
Jagatanand Sharma who was Transport Agent. He also looked into the
previous investigation and submitted first charge sheet against the
named accused Triloki Prasad Singh, continuing investigation against
T.N. Sharma and Vishram Ram. After completion of supplementary
investigation, during which witness Asim Kumar Biswas, Kumar
Naval Kishore, Sri R. P. Das, Sri Remand Mishra, Sri R.D. Tiwari, Sri
L.K. Dubey were recorded by him. Thereafter, he was transferred on
15.05.1998 and handed over the charge to the then Officer In-charge
Shri Ratan Kumar.
PW- 13 Shailesh Kumar Sinha is the third I.O. of this case. He was
entrusted with the charge of investigation by the then Officer Incharge Burmamines Manoranjan Prasad on 01.03.1996. He raided the
house of accused Triloki Prasad Singh but he was absconding. He also
recorded the statement of witness Harish Chandra Tiwari, Ashok
Kumar and arrested the accused Triloki Prasad Singh. He further
recorded the statement of witness Rafeek Ansari. He also arrested the
accused Janki Ram Rajak. He has further recorded the statement of
witness Asim Kumar Biswas. Thereafter, he was transferred on
26.05.1997 and handed over further charge of investigation to the
Officer In-charge Manoranjan Prasad.
15 | P a g e
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
In his cross-examination, this witness suggests that on
06.08.1996 he has recorded the statement of Janki Ram Rajak as a
witness because till that time there was no evidence against him.
Therefore, he was not arrested in this case. Janki Ram Rajak was
arrested in this case on the instruction of Superintendent of Police. He
has further admitted that he has not conducted any investigation, due
to election duty deputation of the godown in-charge who was involved
in food grains loading and distribution in that period. He also admits
that witness Lakshaman Lal has stated before him that godown incharge Triloki Prasad Singh was on leave due to election dutyand in
that period, Lakshaman Lal was sending food grains to different
godowns as per their allotment. He also admits that witness Ashok
Kumar Singh has not stated before him that at the time of occurrence
Triloki Prasad Singh was on duty or he was on leave.
PW-14 Ravindra Nath Tiwari is the first investigating officer of this
case, who took charge of investigation on 07.10.1995 by the then
Officer In-charge of Burmamines Police Station and after finding
sufficient evidence submitted charge sheet. After assuming the charge
of investigation, he has gone through the record. There was
supervision note of Deputy S.P. directing to arrest the accused Triloki
Prasad Singh and in respect of other accused persons direction was to
collect further evidence. In the course of investigation, he went to
State Food Corporation Office, Jamshedpur and attempted to receive
concerned documents. He also got attachment order against accused
Triloki Prasad Singh. Thereafter, he was transferred and handed over
16 | P a g e
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
charge of investigation to Officer In-charge. He has not recorded
statement of any of the witnesses.
PW-15 Mukteshwar Prasad Verma has proved his signature on
seizure list dated 05.08.1996. At that time, he was posted in Bihar
State Food and Civil Supplies Corporation, District Office, Kadma,
Jamshedpur. Police arrived at the office and two registers were seized
by the police from Sakchi godown. One register of JRY in connection
with Jawahar Rozgar Yojana and second register was of stock register.
From page 01 to page 50 out of which page number 12 was torn. No
other registers were available. The second register, inward register,
(Agman Panji) was containing page 25 to 29 in original but page
number 24 was in carbon copy. The police seized both the registers
and prepared seizure list and on the basis of which, he signed over it
which is marked Exhibit- 5.
22.
From the aforesaid discussion of ocular testimony of witnesses
and the documents of accounts prepared after detection of alleged
defalcation, it appears that PW-2 Kumar Nawal Kishore who was
AAO (Assistant Account Officer) since July, 1994 to April, 1995 at
Jamshedpur Branch has clearly proved that he has prepared grain
dispatch statement since February, 1994 to 24th April, 1995 containing
in two pages, which reveals shortage of 10-14 quintals of wheat and
226 quintals of rice in the aforesaid period. Although, report was
prepared against then Assistant Manager in-charge Triloki Prasad
Singh (Since deceased), who had joined in the month of April, 1994
but at that time, he was in election duty and his diversion order was
for three days. The evidence of this witness further shows that in the
17 | P a g e
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
meantime, the then District Manager, Sri Tarak Nath Sharma ordered
to shift food grains from Burmamines (oxygen) godown to Sakchi
godown and food grains were transferred to Sakchi godown. The
carbon copy of report prepared by PW-2 has been proved as Exhibit-1
by PW-3 Mohd. Sultan. Admittedly, PW-3 was not posted at
Burmamines godown at the relevant year 1994 to 1996. The evidence
of PW-4 Rameshwar Prasad Das also shows that at time of physical
verification of Burmamines godown, Janki Ram Rajak was operating
the godown. PW-8 Shanti Brat Bhatacharya has prepared a report
from stock register on the relevant period from 08.04.1994 to
26.04.1995 (Exhibit-1/1) but clearly admits that available documents
were not produced by accused Triloki Prasad Singh because he was
absent on the relevant time rather the stock man searched out the
register and other documents. PW-9 was in-charge of lifting food
grains as per direction of District Manager and was posted at B.S.F.C.,
Jamshedpur from 1993 to 1996 on different posts but has stated
nothing concerning to Burmamines godown. Similarly, PW-10 Ashok
Kumar has simply produced the stock register at the time of
inspection by police and out of which some pages were torn. PW-11
Amrendra Narayan Singh was also posted at head office as head clerk,
therefore, having no personal knowledge about defalcation of wheat
and rice from Burmamines godown. PW-12 Manoranjan Prasad, PW13 Shailesh Kumar Sinha and PW-14 Ravindra Nath Tewary were
simply investigating officers.
23.
It appears that all the inventories and statement of accounts
prepared either from Burmamines godown or from Sakchi godown are
18 | P a g e
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
alleged to be made from original registers but neither during
investigation nor during trial, the original registers were produced to
prove the authenticity of the report submitted.
24.
From perusal of the record, it is also quite obvious that when
the incident came into lime light and order was passed in writ petition
by the Hon’ble Patna High Court for fixing the liability of erring
official and realizing of defalcated amount in respect of shortfall of
wheat and rice involved in this case, the inquiry was conducted and a
Civil Suit was also filed for realization of money. It appears that at the
relevant time, Janki Ram Rajak was operating the Burmamines
godown and the then District Manager was Sri Tarak Nath Sharma
(Sri T. N. Sharma). It is also revealed that when petitioner Triloki
Prasad Singh was on election duty for three days, all the food grains
were transferred to Sakchi godown by the order of District Manager,
Sri T. N. Sharma. No record is produced showing as to what quantity
of wheat and rice was transported from Burmamines godown to
Sakchi godown in the interregnum period. It also appears that Title
Suit for realization of money filed against Triloki Prasad Singh (since
deceased) was withdrawn. An application for withdrawal of
prosecution was also filed before the learned Trial Court but the same
was rejected because it was placed after two years of filing of the
application. It is also revealed that price of defalcated wheat and rice
was got deposited fixing liability on co-accused Janki Ram Rajak and
the then District Manager by whose order the food grains were
transferred from Burmamines godown to Sakchi godown in absence
of the then Assistant Manager Triloki Prasad Singh, were also accused
19 | P a g e
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
in this case, but they have been extended benefit of doubt and
acquitted from the charges. It appears that the petitioner Triloki Prasad
Singh was convicted in this case simply because he was Assistant
Manager in the relevant period posted at Burmamines godown,
Jamshedpur. His temporary absence from duty was found to be not
sufficient to negate his liability. Mere this fact, ignoring intervening
conduct of the then in-charge who was operating the godown, namely,
Janki Ram Rajak and the District Manager, Sri T. N. Sharma, who
shifted the food grains from Burmamines to Sakchi godown has been
completely ignored from consideration by the learned Trial Court. The
inventories of food grains were also prepared from the register
available at Sakchi godown within the charge of District Manager, Sri
T. N. Sharma. Therefore, the material evidence adduced in this case
which clearly inculcate the liability of other co-accused persons have
been acquitted on the basis of same evidence, giving benefit of doubt.
Hence, petitioner Triloki Prasad Singh was also deserving the same
benefit because defalcated amount was deposited by co-accused Janki
Ram Rajak and Civil Suit was also withdrawn against the petitioner
and an application for withdrawal of prosecution was also filed before
the learned Trial Court in accordance with law. Moreover, no
documentary evidence has been adduced against the petitioner
showing any defalcation of food grains in his period at Burmamines
godown rather the statement prepared from register maintained at
District godown, Sakchi has been relied upon by prosecution.
25.
In view of the above discussion and reasons, I find that both the
learned Trial Court as well as learned Appellate Court has committed
20 | P a g e
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
serious error of law in ignoring the relevant evidence exculpating the
petitioner from any criminal liability of this case. The benefit of doubt
given to other co-accused persons was also extendable to the
petitioner Triloki Prasad Singh (since deceased).
26.
In view of the aforesaid discussion and reasons, the impugned
judgment of conviction and sentence of the petitioner, although he is
no more in this world, is set aside and petitioner is also acquitted from
the charges levelled against him.
27.
Accordingly, this revision is Allowed.
28.
Pending I.A., if any, also stands disposed of.
29.
Let a copy of this order be sent through FAX to the concerned
TrialCourt for informationand needful.
30.
Let the trial court records also be sent back to the concerned
Trial Court.
(Pradeep Kumar Srivastava, J.)
Jharkhand High Court, Ranchi
Dated:09/06/2026
Rahul/NAFR
Uploaded on 10/06/2026
21 | P a g e
( Cr. Revision No. 570 of 2016)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review