Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 02.02.2026
Judgment delivered on: 19.02.2026
+
LPA 785/2023
GEETA DEVI & ORS.
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Parveen Kumar, Adv.
versus
EXPORT INSPECTION COUNCIL & ORS.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. L.R. Khatana, Adv. for R-1 to R5.
Mr. Vijay Joshi, CGSC for R-6.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
JUDGMENT
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, C.J.
1.
This intra-court appeal has been instituted by the employees or their
(legal representatives) of the Export Inspection Council (hereinafter referred
to as the ‘Council’), a statutory body created under an Act of Parliament,
namely, Export (Quality Control and Inspection) Act, 1963 (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘Act, 1963’), assailing the judgment and order dated
21.09.2023 passed by the learned Single Judge whereby, W.P.(C)
11407/2021 filed by the appellants, has been dismissed and their claim
relating to their entitlement to be paid pension in terms of Central Civil
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
Service (Pension) Rules, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Rules, 1972’)
which is commonly known as Old Pension Scheme, (hereinafter referred to
as the ‘OPS’) has not been acceded to.
2.
The following chart gives the details of initial joining/engagement of
the appellants, date of completion of 240 days/1 year, date of granting
contractual status, date of their alleged regularisation and date of
superannuation.
S.No. Name
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
3.
Ms. Geeta
Devi
W/o Late
Sh.
Man Singh,
under his
late
husband
Sh. Godhan
Singh Bist
Sh. Yuvraj
Vikas
Sh. V.J.
Methews
Sh.M.
Sreekumar
Sh. K.V.
Rajendran
Date
of
Joining on
Daily/Casual
Basis (3)
07.02.1986
Date of
completing
240 days / 1
year(4)
07.10.1986/
06.02.1986
Date of
Granting
Contract
Status (5)
25.09.1991
Date of
Regularization
(6)
Date of
Superannuation
12.03.2007
Died on
job on 21.07.16
26.11.1985
01.08.1986
25.11.1986
20.12.1992
19.03.1993
10.11.1986
09.03.1987
16.03.1987
15.07.1987
08.12.1986
25.09.1991
20.02.2007
Working
01.09.1993
06.01.2009
[Temporary]
29.10.1992
04.11.2008
Working
29.10.1992
04.11.2008
31.03.2015
31.10.1992
15.03.2007
29.11.2019
20.04.1992
10.03.1986
16.07.1986
08.04.1986
30.04.2020
The appellants case as set up by them is that though, they were
regularised on different dates between the period from 20.02.2007 to
06.01.2009, however, they ought to have been regularised under the Casual
Labourers (Grant of Temporary Status and Regularisation) Scheme, 1993
(hereinafter referred to as the ‘Scheme 1993’), notified by the Department
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
of Personnel and Training, Government on India (hereinafter referred to as
the ‘DoPT’), promulgated vide circular dated 10.09.1993, and accordingly,
they ought to have been given the benefit of pension under the OPS and not
under the New Pension Scheme (hereinafter referred to as the ‘NPS’),
which was introduced with effect from 01.01.2004.
4.
Relying on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of
H.P. v. Sheela Devi, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1272, it has been contended by
the learned counsel for the appellants that since initial appointment of the
appellants was made as casual employees and later on, they were given
contractual status which was followed by their regularisation without any
interruption, and therefore, they are entitled to the benefit of Rule 17 of
Rules, 1972.
5.
Heavy reliance has been placed on behalf of the appellants on a
Division Bench judgment of this Court in the case of Vasudev vs. Union of
India, W.P.(C) 1004/2018, and it has been contended that facts of the instant
case are akin to the facts in the case of Vasudev (supra) where the
employees of the Central Public Works Department, who were initially
engaged on casual basis and subsequently regularised, were given the
benefit of regularisation of their services with retrospective date, as a result
of which, they were brought within the purview of OPS. The contention,
thus, is that in view of the law laid down by the Coordinate Bench of this
Court in Vasudev (supra), the appellants are also entitled to the benefit of
regularisation in service with retrospective effect and thereby, they are
eligible for the grant of pension in terms of OPS. Reliance has also been
placed on behalf of the appellants on a judgment of the High Court of
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
Himachal Pradesh in the case of State of Himachal Pradesh & Others v.
Sh. Matwar Singh & Another, CWP No.2384/2018.
6.
Per contra, the appeal has vehemently been opposed by the learned
counsel representing the respondent-Council stating that it is not a case
where casual employment or employment on contractual basis was followed
by regularisation of the services of the appellants, without any interruption
rather, it is a case where initially, the appellants were appointed on casual
basis whereupon, they were subsequently given the contractual status and
then they were given a fresh appointment between 20.02.2007 and
06.01.2009 on different dates. It has further been stated that the letter of
offer of fresh appointment, pursuant to which the appellants were appointed,
clearly stipulated therein that the appellants shall be governed by the NPS as
applicable to Central Government Employees. It is further contended that
pursuant to these fresh appointments, since the appellants had submitted
their joining after accepting the offer without any protest or demur, they are
estopped from claiming any benefit of the OPS.
7.
We have heard learned counsel for the respective parties at length and
have also perused the records available before us on this letter patent appeal.
8.
As already observed above, respondent-Council is a statutory body
created under the Act, 1963. The employees of the respondent-Council, thus,
are not employees of the Central Government rather, they are the employees
of a statutory body, and therefore, their conditions of service and other
service related aspects are to be governed by either the Act under which the
Council has been created or under the Rules made by the Council under
Section 17 of the said Act.
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
9.
So far as the applicability of the Rules, 1972, on the employees of the
respondent-Council is concerned, the respondent-Council has made Rules
which were notified vide notification dated 24.10.1981, and the said Rules
are called Export Inspection Council, Pension and General Provident Fund
Rules, 1981 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Rules, 1981’). According to
Rule 3 of the said Rules, as notified on 24.10.1981 by the respondentCouncil, the benefit of the Rules, 1972 as amended from time to time, have
been extended to all the whole time and regular employees of the
respondent-Council. Thus, the applicability of the Rules, 1972, in the case of
the employees of the respondent-Council is not doubted.
10.
We, now, need to examine as to whether, in terms of Rule 17 of the
Rules, 1972, the service rendered by the appellants on a contractual basis, is
on a casual capacity, is to be taken into account for the purposes of pension
or not. Rule 17 of the Rules, 1972 is extracted herein below:
“17. Counting of service on contract (1) A person who is initially engaged by the Government on a contract
for a specified period and is subsequently appointed to the same or
another post in a substantive capacity in a pensionable establishment
without interruption of duty, may opt either :(a) to retain the Government contribution in the Contributory
Provident Fund with interest thereon including any other
compensation for that service ; or
(b) to agree to refund to the Government the monetary benefits
referred to in Clause (a) or to forgo the same if they have not been
paid to him and count in lieu thereof the service for which the
aforesaid monetary benefits may have been payable.
(2) The option under sub-rule (1) shall be communicated to the Head
of Office under intimation to the Accounts Officer within a period of
three months from the date of issue of the order of permanent transfer
to pensionable service, or if the Government servant is on leave on
that day, within three months of his return from leave, whichever is
later.
(3) If no communication is received by the Head of Office within the
period referred to in sub-rule (2), the Government servant shall be
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
deemed to have opted for the retention of the monetary benefits
payable or paid to him on account of service rendered on contract.”
11.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sheela Devi (supra) has considered
the said provision and has held that notwithstanding the provisions of Rule
2(g), Rule 17 will be applicable in case a person who is initially engaged on
contract for a specified period, and is subsequently appointed to the same or
another post in a substantive capacity in a pensionable establishment without
interruption of duty. It may be noticed that Rule 2(g) of the Rules, 1972,
provides for the applicability of the said Rules and sub-clause (g) of Rule 2
states that the Rules will not apply to persons employed on contract except
where the contract provides otherwise. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has
considered Rule 2(g) together with the provisions of Rule 17 and has come
to the conclusion that Rule 2(g) saves the application of other provisions of
Rules 1972, and therefore, if the opening phrase of Rule 2 is to be
understood correctly, inference about non-applicability of Rule 17 to the
contractual employees, who are regularised at a later stage, will be incorrect.
12.
Rule 2 of the Rules, 1972 is extracted herein below:
“2. Application
Save as otherwise provided in these rules, [these rules shall apply to
Government servants appointed on or before 31st day of December, 2003]
including civilian Government servants in the Defence Services appointed
substantively to civil services and posts in connection with the affairs of the
Union which are borne on pensionable establishments, but shall not apply to
–
(a) railway servants;
(b) persons in casual and daily rated employment;
(c) persons paid from contingencies;
(d) persons entitled to the benefit of a Contributory Provident Fund;
(e) members of the All India Services;
(f) persons locally recruited for service in diplomatic, consular or other
Indian establishments in foreign countries;
(g) persons employed on contract except when the contract provides
otherwise; and
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
(h) persons whose terms and conditions of service are regulated by or under
the provisions of the Constitution or any other law for the time being in
force.”
13.
Thus, applicability of Rule 17 of the Rules 1972, even in case of
persons employed on a contractual basis is already settled; however, what is
to be noticed, in the facts of the instant case, is as to whether, the initial;
appointment of the appellants on casual and contractual basis was followed
by their appointment in substantive capacity without any interruption of
duty.
14.
It is not the case set up by the respondent-Council that the
appointment of the appellants made between 20.02.2007 and 06.01.2009
was with any interruption of duty from the initial engagement of the
appellants on casual/contractual basis. In fact, the case set up by the
respondent-Council is that the offer of appointments issued to the appellants
between
20.02.2007
and
06.01.2009
was
in
respect
of
direct
recruitment/direct appointment and that it was not regularisation of their
services and, therefore, appellants will not be entitled to the services
rendered by them in casual/contractual capacity for the purposes of bringing
them within the purview of the OPS.
15.
As already noticed above, by means of the notification dated
24.10.1981, the respondent-Council has made applicable the provisions of
Rules 1972, upon its employees and therefore, in our considered opinion,
Rule 17 of the Rules 1972, will be applicable in the instant case as well with
full force.
16.
What Rule 17 of the Rules 1972, envisages is that in case any
appointment on contractual basis is followed by appointment in a
substantive capacity without any interruption of duty, such an employee
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
shall be given an option to opt either (i) to retain the Government
contribution in the Contributory Provident Fund with interest thereon,
including any other compensation for that service or; (ii) to agree to refund
to the Government the monetary benefits or to forgo the same if they have
not been paid to him and count in lieu thereof the service for which the
monetary benefits have been payable.
17.
Thus, it is crystal clear that for attracting Rule 17 of the Rules 1972,
the initial appointment on a casual/contractual basis need not be followed by
appointment in a substantive capacity. For extending the benefit of Rule 17,
the only requirement is that the initial appointment on casual/contractual
basis should be followed by an appointment in substantive capacity without
interruption of duty. The appointment orders issued to the appellants
between the period 20.02.2007 to 06.01.2009 indicate that the appointments
of the appellants was made in substantive capacity and therefore, even if the
appointments of the appellants is treated to be fresh appointments made
during the said period, in our considered opinion, since such appointments
were made in substantive capacity, as such, there is no reason why these
appellants should be denied the benefit of Rule 17 of the Rules 1972.
18.
The reliance by the appellants has been placed on Vasudev (supra),
however, the said judgment does not have any application to the facts of the
instant case for the reason that in the said case, the employees who were
initially engaged on a casual/contractual basis were denied the benefit of the
Scheme, 1993. It is to be noticed that the Scheme, 1993 applies on all casual
labourers who are in employment on the date of issue of the said Scheme
and who have rendered a continuous service of at least one year, which
means that they must have been engaged for a period of at least 240 days,
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
and thus, will be conferred with the temporary status and upon conferment
of the temporary status, certain benefits would accrue to them such as (i)
they shall be paid wages with reference to minimum of the pay scale for a
corresponding Group ‘D’ Employee including, Dearness Allowance, House
Rent Allowance and City Compensatory Allowance. The other benefit on
conferment of the temporary status, as per the said Scheme, was that (ii)
such employees shall also get the benefit of increments as applicable to a
Group ‘D’ Employee and (iii) further they shall also be entitled to leave on
pro-rata basis at the rate of one day for every ten days, (iv) such employees
are also entitled to maternity leave and (v) for the benefit of 50% of service
rendered under temporary status to be counted for the purpose of retirement
benefits after their regularisation. This Scheme further provides that after
rendering three years continuous service after conferment of temporary
status, the casual labourer would be treated at par with the Group ‘D’
Employee for the purposes of contribution to the General Provident Fund
and further that they shall also be eligible for certain other benefits as are
applicable to temporary Group ‘D’ Employees.
19.
Thus, as per Scheme 1993, the eligible casual labourers were to be
granted, firstly, the temporary status and, thereafter, they were to be
regularised. The judgment in Vasudev (supra) is based on the fact that
despite the employees therein being eligible for the grant of temporary status
and subsequent regularisation, they were denied the benefit of the Scheme,
1993 and thereafter, they were regularised with effect from a particular date
in terms of the directions issued by the Central Administrative
Tribunal/Court. The reasoning given in Vasudev (supra), by the Division
Bench of this Court, is that since the employees therein ought to have been
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
given the benefit of consideration for their respective cases for regularisation
under the Scheme, 1993 and had they been given the said benefit, they
would have been regularised prior to the date of their regularisation as
determined by the employer. It is in these circumstances that the Court in
Vasudev (supra) held that employees were entitled to be regularised in their
service with retrospective date and for consequential benefits, including the
benefit of pension.
20.
However, so far as the instant case is concerned, there is nothing on
record that shows that the Scheme 1993, promulgated by the DoPT is
applicable to the employees of the respondent-Council for the reason that
there is no document which establishes either the adoption of such Scheme
by the respondent-Council to its employees or any other such similar
Scheme. Accordingly, the reliance placed by the learned counsel for the
appellant on Vasudev (supra) is misconceived.
21.
Having said that, so far as the applicability of Rule 17 of the Rules,
1972 is concerned, in view of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Sheela Devi (supra), in our considered opinion, the appellants are
entitled to claim the said benefits.
22.
We have already dealt with the submissions made on behalf of the
respondent-Council that since the appointments of appellants were made on
different dates between 20.02.2007 to 06.01.2009, and these appointments
were not by way of regularisation, but rather, they were appointments by
way of direct recruitment and fresh appointments, therefore, the benefit of
Rule 17 will not be available to them. As already discussed, the precondition of the benefit of Rule 17 of the Rules, 1972 is not that the
contractual engagement of an employee shall be followed by regularisation
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
rather, the pre-condition is that such a contractual appointment should be
followed by an appointment in substantive capacity to the same or another
post, without interruption of duty.
23.
The appointment orders, as discussed above, issued to the appellants,
between 20.02.2007 to 06.01.2009 are indicative of the fact that such
appointments were made in substantive capacity and since the appellants’
initial engagement on casual/contractual basis was followed by appointment
in substantive capacity without any interruption of duty, it cannot be
doubted that Rules 1972, will apply to the appellants.
24.
If we examine the impugned judgment rendered by the learned Single
Judge in view of the discussions made above, what we find is that the
substantive case set up by the appellant regarding the applicability and
benefit of Rule 17 of the Rules, 1972, appears to have been lost sight of. The
learned Single Judge instead, proceeded on the premise that in the light of
the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Secretary State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi, (2006) 4 SCC 1, the appellants did not have any
right to be regularised and, therefore, in that view of the matter, their
regularisation could not be dated back and that they would be treated to have
been regularised on different dates on which their appointment orders were
issued between 20.02.2007 and 06.01.2009.
25.
It is, however, not a case where appellants were regularised in service
under any scheme or rule promulgated or notified by the respondentCouncil. It has already been admitted by the respondent-Council that these
appellants were appointed afresh and since their appointment letters clearly
stipulated therein that they shall be governed by the NPS, the benefit of the
OPS cannot be given. The admission to the effect that appointment of the
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
appellants was made afresh by way of direct recruitment on various dates as
indicated above, makes it abundantly clear that it was an appointment in
substantive capacity and not by way of regularisation of services and,
therefore, law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Umadevi (supra) is
not attracted to the facts of the present case. As a matter of fact, the
appointment of the appellants being in substantive capacity, Rule 17 of the
Rules, 1972 will be attracted, as laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Sheela Devi (supra).
26.
For the aforesaid reasons, we are unable to agree with the impugned
judgment and order passed by the learned Single Judge. Resultantly, the
appeal is allowed and the judgment and order dated 21.09.2023 passed by
the learned Single Judge in W.P.(C) 11407/2021 is hereby set aside.
27.
Consequently, the following directions are also issued:
(i)
The respondent-Council shall take immediate steps to invite options
from the appellants (who comprise of the employees working presently and,
in some cases, the legal heirs of the employees), indicating their option in
terms of Rule 17 of the Rules, 1972 within ten weeks’ from today.
(ii)
After receiving the options to be indicated in the notice as aforesaid,
the concerned employees or their legal heirs who may exercise the relevant
option shall be notified about the amounts required to be remitted in case
any amount towards contribution is required.
(iii)
The options so exercised shall be processed and completed within
eight weeks’ thereafter,
(iv)
The entire process under this order shall be completed, fixing pension
or family pension, as the case may be, within a period of five months from
today.
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
28.
There will be no order as to costs.
(DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA)
CHIEF JUSTICE
(TEJAS KARIA)
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 19, 2026/MJ
LPA 785/2023
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
16:11:54
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review