Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: 14.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010432872026
+
LPA 717/2026 & CM APPL. 62155-56/2026, CM APPL.
62158/2026
GEETA CHAURASIA
.....Appellant
Through:
Mr. Ram Anugrah Singh and Ms.
Alpana Kiran, Advocates.
Versus
UCO BANK AND OTHERS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Sarfaraz Khan, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
TEJAS KARIA, J. (Oral)
CM APPL. 62157/2026 (Exemption)
1.
Exemption allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2.
The Application stands disposed of.
LPA 717/2026
3.
The present intra court Appeal assails the order dated 03.09.2026
(“Impugned Order”) passed in W.P.(C) 12854/2026 titled ‘Geeta
Chaurasia v. UCO Bank and Others’ (“Writ Petition”).
4.
Pursuant to the appointment letter dated 07.05.2007, the Appellant
joined Respondent No. 1 – UCO Bank (“Bank”) as an Officer in Scale-I.
Thereafter, the Appellant was posted at various branches and offices of the
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:54:06
LPA 717/2026
Bank and was promoted to the positions of Manager (Scale-II), Senior
Manager (Scale-III), and, with effect from 01.02.2019, Chief Manager
(Scale-IV).
5.
In December 2018, while posted at the Kirti Nagar Branch of the
Bank, the Appellant was diagnosed with Hypothyroidism, Polycystic
Ovarian Syndrome (PCOS), and Dermographic Urticaria. Thereafter, the
Appellant continued to receive treatment for her medical conditions and
availed sabbatical leave from 07.01.2023 to 06.01.2025.
6.
On 24.06.2025, the Appellant was posted as Chief Manager (Executive
Scale-IV) at the New Delhi Zonal Office of the Bank. During 2026, the
Appellant availed medical and casual leave on various occasions, which was
duly approved by the Bank.
7.
Vide order dated 13.05.2026 (“Transfer Order”), the Bank transferred
the Appellant from the New Delhi Zonal Office to the Staff Training Centre,
Jaipur, Rajasthan, in the capacity of Chief Manager. Thereafter, the
Appellant submitted representations to the Bank seeking cancellation of the
Transfer Order and requested her retention or posting at the New Delhi Field
Inspection Department on medical grounds. On 16.05.2026, the Bank issued
a relieving order (“Relieving Order”), directing the Appellant to join the
Staff Training Centre, Jaipur, Rajasthan, on or before 18.05.2026.
8.
As the Appellant allegedly remained absent from duty with effect from
18.05.2026, the Bank issued a Show Cause Notice dated 08.07.2026
(“SCN”) to the Appellant for failing to report to the Staff Training Centre,
Jaipur, Rajasthan, pursuant to the Transfer Order.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:54:06
LPA 717/2026
9.
The Appellant challenged the Transfer Order, the Relieving Order, and
the SCN before this Court in W.P.(C) 9461/2026. The learned Single Judge,
vide order dated 16.07.2026, dismissed W.P.(C) 9461/2026. Aggrieved
thereby, the Appellant preferred LPA 606/2026.
10.
On 20.07.2026, pursuant to the SCN, the Bank issued a chargesheet,
together with a statement of allegations and articles of charge, to the
Appellant. Vide order dated 05.08.2026 passed in LPA 606/2026 (“LPA
Order”), this Court declined to interfere with the order dated 16.07.2026
passed in W.P.(C) 9461/2026 but permitted the Appellant to submit a
representation seeking cancellation of the Transfer Order on medical
grounds, setting out the particulars of her medical condition and enclosing
supporting medical prescriptions. The LPA Order further directed the
competent authority of the Bank (“Competent Authority”) to consider the
said representation, having regard to the nature of the Appellant’s ailments
and medical condition, and to adopt a sympathetic view of the matter on
medical grounds.
11.
Pursuant to the LPA Order, the Appellant submitted a representation
dated 07.08.2026 (“Representation”). However, the Competent Authority
declined the Representation vide communication dated 21.08.2026
(“Rejection Order”). Thereafter, the Appellant submitted a reply-cumrepresentation dated 23.08.2026, seeking a fresh, independent, and reasoned
reconsideration of her request for cancellation of the Transfer Order in
compliance with the LPA Order. Vide communication dated 24.08.2026, the
Bank informed the Appellant that the Rejection Order was final and that no
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:54:06
LPA 717/2026
further correspondence or representation concerning the Transfer Order
would be entertained.
12.
Aggrieved by the Rejection Order and the communication dated
24.08.2026, the Appellant preferred the Writ Petition. The learned Single
Judge dismissed the Writ Petition vide the Impugned Order. Aggrieved
thereby, the Appellant has preferred the present Appeal.
13.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant submitted that the learned Single
Judge failed to appreciate that the Rejection Order did not consider the
Appellant’s serious and chronic medical conditions in the manner
contemplated by the LPA Order. It was further submitted that the
Representation was rejected mechanically, notwithstanding the specific
direction in the LPA Order that the request for cancellation of the Transfer
Order be considered sympathetically.
14.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant further submitted that the medical
opinion dated 20.08.2026, obtained by the Bank from its empanelled Medical
Officer, did not assess the cumulative effect of the Appellant’s medical
conditions and did not adequately address her neuropsychiatric condition and
functional capacity. It was submitted that the Appellant had been undergoing
treatment for anxiety, panic attacks, and other psychiatric difficulties, and
had been advised to have family or caregiver support and a less stressful
environment.
15.
It was further submitted on behalf of the Appellant that the Bank ought
to have constituted an independent Medical Board, comprising, inter alia, an
appropriate specialist in neuropsychiatry or mental health, to undertake a
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:54:06
LPA 717/2026
comprehensive assessment of the Appellant’s medical condition. Learned
Counsel for the Appellant relied upon Clause 13.1 of the Transfer Policy
dated 16.10.2025 issued by the Bank (“Transfer Policy”) to contend that the
Competent Authority ought to have allowed the Representation on
compassionate grounds.
16.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents submitted that, pursuant to the
liberty granted by the LPA Order, the Representation was duly considered by
the Competent Authority. In doing so, the Competent Authority took into
account the Appellant’s tenure in the New Delhi Zone; her posting at the
Staff Training Centre, Jaipur, in a non-customer-facing administrative
assignment, having regard to her medical condition; Jaipur’s proximity to
Delhi; the availability of medical facilities and support systems in Jaipur; the
opinion dated 20.08.2026 obtained from the Bank’s empanelled Medical
Officer; and the administrative requirements of the Bank.
17.
It was further submitted on behalf of the Respondents that, of the
Appellant’s approximately 19 years of service with the Bank, she had served
for more than 15 years in New Delhi and for only three and a half years
outside New Delhi, at Chandigarh. With regard to the Appellant’s reliance on
the Transfer Policy for retention in New Delhi on compassionate grounds, it
was submitted that the medical conditions relied upon by the Appellant did
not fall within the scope of the Transfer Policy.
18.
We have considered the submissions advanced by learned Counsel for
the Parties and have perused the material placed on record.
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:54:06
LPA 717/2026
19.
The Appellant’s challenge to the Transfer Order was dismissed by the
learned Single Judge of this Court vide order dated 16.07.2026 passed in
W.P.(C) 9461/2026, against which the Appellant preferred LPA 606/2026.
Vide the LPA Order, this Court found no ground to interfere with the order
dated 16.07.2026 passed in W.P.(C) 9461/2026 and further observed that no
illegality could be attributed to the Transfer Order.
20.
The LPA Order, however, permitted the Appellant to submit the
Representation and required the Competent Authority to consider it, having
regard to the nature of the Appellant’s ailments and medical condition, and to
adopt a sympathetic view of her request for cancellation of the Transfer
Order.
21.
In the Rejection Order, the Competent Authority referred to the
Appellant’s tenure in the New Delhi Zone and the medical conditions relied
upon by her. It further recorded that, having regard to the Appellant’s
medical condition, she had been posted at the Staff Training Centre, Jaipur,
in a non-customer-facing administrative assignment. The Rejection Order
also records that the proximity of Jaipur to Delhi, the availability of medical
facilities and support systems in Jaipur, the opinion dated 20.08.2026 of the
Bank’s empanelled Medical Officer, and the administrative requirements of
the Bank were taken into account while declining the Appellant’s request for
cancellation of the Transfer Order. The relevant observations in the Rejection
Order are reproduced below:
“6. Considering your medical issues, Bank has already taken a
compassionate view and transferred you as administrative office
staff at Staff Training Centre Jaipur. This posting does not require
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:54:06
LPA 717/2026
customer dealing and is considered suitable in view of the medical
conditions represented by you.
7. You have been transferred to Jaipur city which is nearby to
New Delhi and has availability of medical facilities and support
systems which may be required by you in view of the medical
conditions cited in your representation.
8. As regard to your medical conditions, Bank has appropriately
obtained an independent opinion from its empanelled Medical
Officer, who, vide his opinion letter dated 20-08-2026, has stated
that the aliments cited by you require strict diet and medications,
if and when necessary and that the treatment for same is possible
in any major city of India. We have also noted that Jaipur is a
major metropolitan city of India with availability of world class
medical facilities.
The Bank has duly considered the medical grounds cited by you
and has also taken a sympathetic view by posting you to a noncustomer-facing administrative assignment at Staff Training
Centre, Jaipur. The fact that Jaipur is geographically proximate
to New Delhi and has adequate medical facilities has also been
considered. At the same time, the Bank is required to balance the
individual circumstances of an employee with its administrative
and organizational requirement. Transfer and posting of
employee are matters falling within the administrative domain of
the Bank, subject to the applicable policies/guidelines and
administrative exigencies.”
22.
It is, therefore, evident that the Rejection Order was not founded solely
on the premise that treatment for the Appellant’s ailments was available in
Jaipur. In deciding the Representation, the Competent Authority also
considered the nature of the posting assigned to the Appellant, Jaipur’s
proximity to Delhi, and the availability of support systems in Jaipur.
23.
The Competent Authority thus considered the difficulty expressed by
the Appellant in residing at Jaipur while declining her request for
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:54:06
LPA 717/2026
cancellation of the Transfer Order. The direction in the LPA Order to adopt a
sympathetic view of the Representation required due consideration of the
Appellant’s medical condition and the hardship expressed by her in residing
at Jaipur, which cannot be construed as a mandate to allow the
Representation.
24.
The Appellant’s reliance on the Transfer Policy is equally untenable.
This Court, vide the LPA Order, had already concluded that no illegality
could be attributed to the Transfer Order. The learned Single Judge rightly
observed that the scope of the proceedings in the Writ Petition was limited
and that the legality of the Transfer Order was no longer open to
examination, the challenge thereto having attained finality in the earlier
round of proceedings.
25.
Accordingly, the legality of the Transfer Order cannot be reopened in
the present proceedings under the guise of examining the Rejection Order.
Once the Rejection Order records the considerations that weighed with the
Competent Authority in declining the Appellant’s request for cancellation of
the Transfer Order, those considerations cannot be characterised as arbitrary
or perverse. The Court cannot substitute its own assessment of the
Appellant’s medical condition or the hardship expressed by her in residing at
Jaipur for that of the Competent Authority merely because another view may
be possible. The learned Single Judge rightly declined to undertake such an
exercise in the Impugned Order.
26.
We, therefore, conclude that the Competent Authority considered the
Representation within the scope of the LPA Order and that the Appellant has
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:54:06
LPA 717/2026
failed to establish any ground warranting interference with either the
Impugned Order or the Rejection Order in the present Appeal.
27.
It is clarified that the observations made in this Order shall not
prejudice the rights and contentions of the Parties in any disciplinary
proceedings arising from the Appellant’s alleged absence from duty. Any
such proceedings shall be adjudicated on their own merits and in accordance
with law.
28.
Accordingly, the Appeal is dismissed. All pending applications also
stand disposed of. No costs.
TEJAS KARIA, J
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026
HK
Signed By:NEELAM
SHARMA
15:54:06
LPA 717/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review