Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC (EP) No. No. 19 of 2023 in
El. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
Date of Decision: 31.10.2023
Shri Gavin Miguel Mylliem & Ors. Vs.
Shri Titosstar Well Chyne
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)/Applicant(s) : Mr. S. Sahay, Adv. with
Ms. Y. Pallavi, Adv.
Ms. S.K. Nongrum, Adv.
Mr. A.M. Pala, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)/Opp. Party: Mr. N. Jotendra Singh, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. B. Khyriem, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Yes/No
1.
The instant application has been filed by the respondent No. 1
under Section 86 of the Representation of People Act read with Order 7
Rule 11 CPC and the Gauhati High Court Rules (as adopted by the High
Court of Meghalaya).
MC(EP) No. 19 of 2023 in
EL. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
2.
The grounds taken in the instant application are that the
Election Petition is ex-facie barred by Section 86 of the Representation of
People Act, being filed in violation of Section 81, 82 & 83 of the said Act,
the High Court of Meghalaya Rules, and also barred by law within the
meaning of Order 7 Rule 11 CPC.
3.
It has been submitted by Mr. S. Sahay, learned counsel for
the applicant/respondent, that the election petition is liable to be dismissed
as it failed to meet the requirement of filing of an election petition as
stipulated by law. Reference has been made to Article 329 (b) of the
Constitution of India that prescribes that (i) election can only be
challenged by way of election petition; (ii) and such election petition must
be presented to the authorized authority (iii) and such presentation must
be done in the manner prescribed under the law. In this regard it has been
submitted that the law as framed for presentation, is contained in Section
81 of the RP Act, the contravention of which, entails outright dismissal as
provided in Section 86 of the said Act.
4.
Further contention has been raised that as the Meghalaya High
Court Rules, 2013 has adopted the procedure with regard to the
presentation of election petitions from the Gauhati High Court Rules,
which in this case is to be before the Stamp Reporter, the non-compliance
thereof, would be violative of Section 81 (1) of the RP Act, read with Rule
MC(EP) No. 19 of 2023 in
EL. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
1 under Chapter VIII A of the High Court Rules. In the instant case, it is
argued that the election petitioner has not controverted the allegations that
the petitioner had not presented the election petition before the Stamp
Reporter personally, and that the reply to the instant application is silent
on material particulars regarding the details of such presentation. It has
been further submitted that there is no endorsement of the Stamp Reporter
in the petition and that the report of the Stamp Reporter does not show that
the petition was personally presented by the election petitioner. In support
of these arguments, reliance has been placed on the following cases:-
5.
i)
G.V. Sreerama Reddy vs. Returning Officer (2009) 8 SCC 736
ii)
Abdul Jabbar vs. Syeda Anwara Taimur & Ors. (1986) 1 GLR
iii)
Jamal Uddin Ahmed vs. Abu Saleh Najmuddin & Anr. (2003)
4 SCC 257
It has been submitted that as the petition has not been
presented personally by the election petitioner, and that in reply to the
instant application, only bald averments have been made without any
material particulars, there is no necessity that evidence be led to
substantiate this contention. It is also submitted that evidence can be led
only if there is a pleading to this effect, and the same not being present,
apart from the Stamp Reporter’s report not indicating that the petition was
MC(EP) No. 19 of 2023 in
EL. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
presented by the election petitioner, the argument that at the time of
presentation, the election petitioner was only present in the campus, will
not come to the aid of the election petitioner in any manner.
6.
It has further been contended that Section 81 (3) of the RP Act
has been breached, inasmuch as, the requirement that each and every copy
of the election petition to be attested by the election petitioner under his
own signature has not been met, while filing the election petition. To the
arguments raised by the election petitioner, that this Court by order dated
11.08.2023 passed in MC (EP) No. 27 of 2023, had allowed the furnishing
of attested copies of the election petition signed by the election petitioner
to all respondents and as such there has been substantial compliance
thereof, it has been countered by the learned counsel for the applicant, that
the order was only with regard to furnishing of fresh copies before hearing
of the objections. The issue of non-compliance of Section 81, it is
submitted has no bearing as far as the instant application is concerned, and
the election petitioner having not presented the election petition
personally, the election petition by virtue of Section 86 of the RP Act is
therefore liable to be dismissed.
7.
Mr. N. Jotendra Singh, learned Senior counsel assisted by
Mr. B. Khyriem, learned counsel for the election petitioner (respondent
herein) has at the outset submitted that dismissing of the election petition,
MC(EP) No. 19 of 2023 in
EL. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
on the ground of there being no cause of action is untenable, inasmuch as,
in the election petition, material facts and particulars have been pleaded in
detail, as is seen by the statements made in Para-3.5, 4, 9 & 14. With
regard to the presentation of petitions and the relevant law governing the
same i.e. Section 81, 82 of the RP Act read with Rule 1 to Chapter VIII A
of the Gauhati High Court Rules as adopted by the High Court of
Meghalaya, the learned counsel has taken this Court through the said
provisions, and submitted that the election petitioner has complied with
the stipulation as contained in Chapter VIII A of the High Court Rules,
especially Note I and Note II to the said Rule, which mandates that noncompliance of the same, an election petition should be returned forthwith
by the Stamp Reporter. There being no objection by the Stamp Reporter,
he therefore contends that the election petition is to be treated as correct
and in proper form. It is further submitted that since the Registry of the
High Court has accepted the election petition, the controversy raised by
the applicant/respondent is not available any longer for consideration
before this Court in the instant proceedings under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC.
The learned counsel has laid great emphasis on the order dated 11.08.2023
passed in MC (EP) No. 27 of 2023, to advance his argument that this Court
having ruled in favour of the election petitioner, and allowed the curing of
the defect of non-furnishing of signed petitions, which was thereafter
MC(EP) No. 19 of 2023 in
EL. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
never challenged by the applicant/respondent, the objections in the
application which touches upon the order dated 11.08.2023 cannot be
sustained. Learned Senior counsel, then submits that the issues raised by
the applicant are all triable issues which are to be decided at the time of
trial of the election petition, and as such this Misc. application is liable to
be rejected as being without any merit.
8.
Heard learned counsels for the parties.
9.
As noted from the submissions, the question to be decided in
the instant application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC is whether the
presentation of the election petition was in accordance with Section 81 (1)
of the RP Act 1951 read with Chapter VIII A of the Gauhati High Court
Rules as adopted by the High Court of Meghalaya. The point in issue
therefore crystallizes only on the examination as to whether the election
petition was presented personally before the authorized officer of the High
Court, in this case as per the Rules, the Stamp Reporter.
10.
It is a settled law that the proper presentation of an election
petition as per Section 81 (1) of the RP Act requires strict compliance as
held in the case of G.V. Sreerama Reddy vs. Returning Officer (supra),
wherein Paras-15 to 19, 24 & 25, reads as follows:“15. This Court, on previous occasions, had the chance to
interpret Section 81(1). It must be noted that
the Representation of the People Act, 1951 is a special
MC(EP) No. 19 of 2023 in
EL. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
statute, and a self-contained regime. In K. Venkateswara
Rao. v. Bekkam Narasimha Reddi a question arose whether
45 days’ period provided under Section 81(1) could be
condoned through the application of the Limitation Act?
After examining the relevant provisions of the Act, this
Court held: (AIR p. 877, para 14)
"14. ... the Limitation Act cannot apply to
proceedings like an election petition inasmuch as
the Representation of the People Act is a complete
and self-contained code which does not admit of the
introduction of the principles or the provisions of law
contained in the Indian Limitation Act."
(emphasis supplied)
This has been reiterated in Hukumdev Narain Yadav v.
Lalit Narain Mishra wherein this Court has again read the
requirements under Section 81 strictly, while stating that
the Act is a self- contained special statute.
16. While interpreting a special statute, which is a selfcontained code, the court must consider the intention of the
legislature. The reason for this fidelity towards the
legislative intent is that the statute has been enacted with a
specific purpose which must be measured from the wording
of the statute strictly construed.
17. The preamble of the Representation of the People
Act makes it clear that for the conduct of elections of the
Houses of Parliament or the legislature of each State, the
qualification and disqualification for membership of those
Houses, the corrupt practice and other offences in
connection with such allegations the Act was enacted by
Parliament.
18. In spite of existence of adequate provisions in the Code
of Civil Procedure relating to institution of a suit, the
present Act contains elaborate provisions as to disputes
regarding elections. It not only prescribes how election
petitions are to be presented but it also mandates what are
MC(EP) No. 19 of 2023 in
EL. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
the materials to be accompanied with the election petition,
details regarding parties, contents of the same, relief that
may be claimed in the petition. How trials of election
petitions are to be conducted has been specifically provided
in Chapter III of Part VI. In such circumstances, we are of
the view that the provisions have to be interpreted as
mentioned by the legislature.
19. One can discern the reason why the petition is required
to be presented by the petitioner personally. An election
petition is a serious matter with a variety of consequences.
Since such a petition may lead to the vitiation of a
democratic process, any procedure provided by an election
statute must be read strictly. Therefore, the legislature has
provided that the petition must be presented "by" the
petitioner himself, so that at the time of presentation, the
High Court may make preliminary verification which
ensure that the petition is neither frivolous nor vexatious.
24. The challenge to an election is a serious matter. The
object of presenting an election petition by a candidate or
elector is to ensure genuineness and to curtail vexatious
litigations. If we consider sub-section (1) along with the
other provisions in Chapters II and III, the object and
intent of the legislature is that this provision i.e. Section
81(1) is to be strictly adhered to and complied with.
25. In view of the endorsement by the Registrar (Judicial)
on 7-7-2008 that the election petition was presented only by
an advocate and not by the election petitioners, we accept
the reasoning of the High Court in dismissing the election
petition. We further hold that as per sub- section (1)
of Section 81, an election petition is to be presented by any
candidate or elector relating to the election personally to the
authorized officer of the High Court and failure to adhere
to such course would be contrary to the said provision and
MC(EP) No. 19 of 2023 in
EL. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
in that event the election petition is liable to be dismissed on
the ground of improper presentation.”
11.
Further, with regard to the constitutionality of the High Court
Rules, requiring the election petition to be presented before the Stamp
Reporter, the same has been upheld in the case of Abdul Jabbar vs. Syeda
Anwara Taimur & Ors. (supra), wherein the erstwhile jurisdictional High
Court, had held that the election petition is said to be filed only when it is
presented to the proper officer for acceptance for record in the office. The
relevant paragraph (at para-14), is quoted hereunder: “14. The next question which arises for consideration is
whether the election petition was presented in terms of the
expression “presentation” used in Section 81. The word
‘presentation’ has many different significations in the
context and circumstances in which it is used. The
dictionary meaning of ‘presentation’ is delivering; filing;
showing. A mere depositing of the petition and marking of
filing by the clerk is not a filing. The paper is said to be filed
when it is delivered or deposited to the proper office or
custodian for keeping it on file. A file mark or endorsement
on the petition is merely an evidence of filing and not actual
filing since filing is delivery to the proper officer or clerk
for his acceptance for record in his office.”
12.
A perusal of the above noted judgments therefore, leaves no
doubt as to the stringent requirements that are to be followed in filing and
presentation of an election petition, inasmuch as, as observed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, an election petition is a serious matter with a
variety of consequences. In the instant case, though pointed arguments
MC(EP) No. 19 of 2023 in
EL. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
have been raised by the applicant/respondent that the election petition was
not presented in the manner prescribed, certain doubts had arisen which
occasioned this Court by order dated 15.09.2023, to call for a report from
the Stamp Reporter, which was furnished on 27.09.2023. However, in the
said report, the Stamp Reporter only verified that the Stamp report of the
main election petition was affixed at the first page of the petition as a
check slip as per practice of the Registry. The report when perused
together with the check slip dated 12.04.2023 bearing Filing Serial No.
189 of 2023, apart from indicating that the case was ready, does not
disclose as to whether the presentation of the same was made personally
by the election petitioner. Compounded with the inconclusive report of the
Stamp Reporter, is the submission of the counsel of the election petitioner
during arguments of the instant application that the election petitioner was
present at the time of presentation in the campus. The fact therefore, as to
whether the election petitioner was present or not, cannot be conclusively
ascertained at this stage from the materials on record, to warrant the
application Section 86 of the RP Act to dismiss the election petition out
rightly.
13.
Another issue which has been raised by the election petitioner
in his defense, i.e. the implication of the order dated 11.08.2023 passed in
MC (EP) No. 27 of 2023, in the opinion of this Court does not deserve any
MC(EP) No. 19 of 2023 in
EL. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
consideration or can be taken to be a ground for not entertaining the instant
application. This is due to the fact that in the said order, it has been clearly
indicated at Para-7 thereof, that the instant application under Order 7 Rule
11 CPC was pending consideration at that time, when MC (EP) No. 27 of
2023 was filed, which was limited only to a prayer for granting leave to
allow furnishing of attested copies of the election petition to the
respondent, which was allowed by this Court.
14.
In consideration of the facts and circumstances as discussed,
and in light of the judgment rendered in the case of Abdul Jabbar vs.
Syeda Anwara Taimur & Ors. (supra), this Court being unable to arrive
at a conclusive finding as to the presence of the election petitioner at the
time of presentation, and in view of the cryptic report furnished by the
Stamp Reporter, deems it fit to take up the issues raised in the instant
application as to the presentation, as preliminary issues for consideration.
15.
Accordingly, the instant application stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
31.10.2023
“V. Lyndem PS”
MC(EP) No. 19 of 2023 in
EL. Pet. No. 2 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review