The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. For all the reasons discussed hereinabove, the bail petition is thus allowed. As a sequel, the petitioner is ordered to be released on bail subject to his furnishing bail bonds to the tune of Rs.50,000/- with one surety of the like amount, to the satisfaction of the learned trial Court subject to the following conditions:i) That the petitioner shall not tamper with the prosecution evidence nor intimidate, threaten or coerce the witnesses conversant with the facts of the case; ii) That the petitioner shall put in appearance before the Investigating Officer or the Court as and -9( 2026:HHC:39632 ) when directed; iii) That the petitioner shall not leave the territory of India without the express permission of the Court, he shall surrender passport, if any, before the investigating agency; iv) If the bail petitioner is found to be indulging in similar cases in the future and an FIR is registered against him under the NDPS Act, his bail shall be liable to be cancelled forthwith.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:39632 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
Cr.MP(M) No. 1622 of 2026
Decided on 17th September, 2026
_____________________________________________________
Gaurav Kaundal
…Petitioner
Versus
State of HP
…..Respondent
_____________________________________________________
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Chirag Bhanu Singh, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? Yes
_____________________________________________________
For the petitioner
: Mr. Nishant Khidtta, Advocate,
vice Mr. Ashok Kumar, Advocate.
For the respondent/State
: Mr. Rajpal Thakur, Additional
Advocate General.
_____________________________________________________
Chirag Bhanu Singh, Judge
The petitioner has preferred an application
under Section 483 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suyraksha Sanhita, 2023
(for short “BNSS”) seeking post-arrest bail in Case FIR No. 66 of
2026, dated 01.05.2026 registered at Police Station Sarkaghat,
District Mandi, under Sections 21, 27-A & 29 of the Narcotic
Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (hereinafter referred to
as “the Act”).
2.
The facts which emerge from the status report,
-2( 2026:HHC:39632 )
so filed by the State is that on 01.05.2026, a police party headed
by HC Narender Barwal had left for patrolling in the official vehicle
bearing registration No. HP-89-2049. At about 10:00 am when the
police patrol was at Navahi, a secret information had been
received that one Vishal, son of Sh. Hardev Singh, R/O Village
Kothi, Post Office Cholthara, Tehsil Sarkaghat, District Mandi,
who was wearing a check shirt, grey jeans and a red cap, was on
his way from Jahu to Sarkaghat. He was carrying a consignment
of heroin (Chitta). In case he is apprehended, a huge cache of
drugs can be made.
3.
Acting swiftly, the Investigating Officer, HC
Narender Barwal had prepared the reasons of belief under
Section 42(2) of the Act and had sent the same to the SDPO,
Sarkaghat through HHC Ashwani Kumar. The rest of the party
had proceeded towards Fatehpur to set up a naka. When the
Police patrol had reached near Shani Dev Mandir, they had
noticed a person with the same description coming from Fatehpur
side at about 10:20 AM. On seeing the Police patrol, he tried
running towards Sarkaghat. In the process he had also thrown
something from the right pocket of his pants towards the railing
near the Peepal tree. The members of the Police patrol had
-3( 2026:HHC:39632 )
apprehended the person after a short chase. The Investigating
Officer had tried to stop the vehicle to associate some
independent witness, but to no avail. Eventually, he had
telephonically called Mr. Narender Kumar Gautam, Former
Panchayat Pradhan and requested him to reach the spot. In the
meanwhile, one Rahamuddin, son of Shri Jalaluddin, had reached
the spot on foot. After some time, Sh. Narender Kumar Gautam,
Former Pradhan had also reached the spot. After associating both
of them as independent witnesses, the Investigating Officer had
asked the person to disclose his name. He had disclosed his
name as Vishal S/o Sh. Hardev Singh. The Investigating Officer
had thereupon given the search of the police team and thereafter
checked the packet thrown by the accused. It turned out to be a
packet of a Four Square cigarette. Inside the cigarette packet,
one transparent polythene was found, which was tied with a knot.
On opening the polythene packet, light brown granular substance
was found inside. Over and apart, three small packets made of
silver foil, along with five round brown substance wrapped in
plastic was also recovered.
4.
On the basis of experience and the disclosure
of the accused, it was found to be heroin (Chitta). On weighing,
-4( 2026:HHC:39632 )
the contraband was found to be 6 grams. After following the codal
formalities, the Investigating Officer had taken the contraband into
possession. The said accused Vishal also came to be arrested at
the spot.
5.
During the course of investigation, the said
accused Vishal is stated to have made a disclosure statement
that he had procured the contraband from co-accused Arun
Kumar @ Monu and the payment in respect of the contraband
had been made to co-accused Gaurav Kaundal (the present
petitioner) which had been pay through UPI. He had even earlier
procured contraband from co-accused Arun Kumar. As per him
co-accused Arun Kumar used an ATM card and deposited money
in the account of the present petitioner i.e. accused Gaurav
Kaundal, who belongs to Hamirpur. On 28/29 April, he had
deposited Rs. 16,000/- in the account of Gaurav Kaundal i.e. the
petitioner. The ATM card of Gaurav Kaundal is with the coaccused Arun Kumar. He had also made a payment to the
petitioner on phone bearing No. 82198-04288.
6.
Based on the aforesaid information, the present
petitioner had come to be arrested on 04.05.2026. He is presently
in Judicial custody.
-5( 2026:HHC:39632 )
7.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
gone through the records meticulously.
8.
The learned counsel for the petitioner would
contend that no contraband had been recovered from the
conscious and exclusive possession of the petitioner and his
name had surfaced in pursuance to a disclosure made by one of
the co-accused and there is no material on record to show the
active participation of the present petitioner in the crime. No case
is made out against the petitioner. Even otherwise, the
investigation in the case are complete and no recoveries have to
be effected from the petitioner. He is innocent and has been
falsely implicated at the instance of the others co-accuseds. The
prosecution has already filed a challan and the trial has also
commenced.
9.
Per
contra
Sh.
Rajpal
Thakur,
learned
Additional Advocate General for the State has vociferously urged
that keeping in view the gravity of the offence alleged, and the
fact that the petitioner was a part of an organized racket and
sufficient material had been collected against the accused during
investigation, the discretion of bail cannot be exercised in his
favour. There are chances that the petitioner may again indulge in
-6( 2026:HHC:39632 )
same and similar activities in the future too.
10.
It however transpires from record that the
contraband, indeed, was not recovered from the conscious and
exclusive possession of the petitioner. Admittedly, the contraband
and that too only 6 grams had come to be recovered from one of
the co-accused-Vishal.
11.
The petitioner came to be arrested on the basis
of a disclosure statement made by the said co-accused Vishal,
and that too that he had procured the contraband from another
co-accused, Arun Kumar alias Monu, and on whose asking he
had deposited the sale consideration in the account of the
petitioner/accused Gaurav Kaundal through UPI.
12.
By now, it is fairly settled that a statement made
by the co-accused is inadmissible in law.
13.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Tofan
Singh vs. State of Tamil Nadu 2021 (4) SCC 1 has in uncertain
terms held that any disclosure made under Section 67 (or even
under Section 23 of BNS) is inadmissible and cannot be used as
a confessional statement in the trial. In a case titled as State By
(NCB) Banguluru vs. Pallulabid Ahmad Arimutta and Anr.
-7( 2026:HHC:39632 )
[SLP (Crl.) No. 242 of 2022, decided on 10.1.2022] the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has further reiterated the aforesaid proposition of
law regarding inadmissibility of the confessional statement and
has further gone on to hold that even the Bank details collected in
this respect will have to be examined at the stage of trial.
14.
Even otherwise, merely the existence of the
Bank Statement details of the accused cannot be said to be a
circumstance, which alone may suffice to hold that the petitioner
was complicit in the crime. Suspicion howsoever strong cannot
take the place of proof.
15.
It further emerges on record that admittedly the
quantity of contraband recovered from the co-accused Vishal is
only 6 grams of heroin (Chitta) and in that sense, the quantity of
contraband having been recovered in the present case being less
than commercial, the
rigours of Section 37 may not stricto
sensu apply in the facts and circumstances of the present case.
Over and apart, there is nothing on record to remotely suggest
that any case under the Act stands registered against the
petitioner. The apprehension of the State that the petitioner may
indulge in similar activities thus also seems to be unfounded. The
trial is also stated to have commenced. It is thus likely to take
-8( 2026:HHC:39632 )
substantial time. Pre-trial detention is also otherwise generally
loathed by the Courts.
16.
Thus, seeing to the totality of circumstances
discussed above, the petitioner could be granted the discretion of
bail, though subject to strict terms.
17.
As a sequel, while allowing the present petition,
it is directed that in case the petitioner is henceforth found
indulging in any similar activity and an FIR is registered against
the petitioner under the provisions of the Act, even the present
bail granted shall stand forfeited.
18.
For all the reasons discussed hereinabove, the
bail petition is thus allowed. As a sequel, the petitioner is ordered
to be released on bail subject to his furnishing bail bonds to the
tune of Rs.50,000/- with one surety of the like amount, to the
satisfaction of the learned trial Court subject to the following
conditions:i)
That the petitioner shall not tamper with the
prosecution evidence nor intimidate, threaten or
coerce the witnesses conversant with the facts of the
case;
ii)
That the petitioner shall put in appearance
before the Investigating Officer or the Court as and
-9( 2026:HHC:39632 )
when directed;
iii)
That the petitioner shall not leave the territory of
India without the express permission of the Court, he
shall
surrender
passport,
if
any,
before
the
investigating agency;
iv)
If the bail petitioner is found to be indulging in
similar cases in the future and an FIR is registered
against him under the NDPS Act, his bail shall be
liable to be cancelled forthwith.
19.
The observations, made hereinabove, shall not be
taken, as an expression of opinion, on the merits of the case, as
these observations are confined only for the purposes of the
disposal of the present petition.
20.
Petition stands disposed off in the aforesaid terms, so
also the pending miscellaneous applications, if any.
17th September, 2026
(Ritu)
(Chirag Bhanu Singh)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review