Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment Reserved on: 27.01.2026
Judgment delivered on: 02.02.2026
Judgment uploaded on: As per digital signature
+
W.P.(C) 18585/2025 and CM APPL. 77276/2025, CM APPL.
78566/2025
GAURAV ENTERPRISES
.....Petitioner
Versus
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI
.....Respondent
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Ramesh Singh, Sr. Adv. with Mr.
Harshit Singh, Mr. Anant Dev & Mr. Hage
Nanya, Advocate.
For the Respondent
:
Mr. Tushar Sannu, SC for MCD with Mr.
Priyankar Tiwari, Advocate and Mr. K.K.
Barman, ADC/HQ, Mr. Gaurav Chaturvedi,
Administrative Officer, Mr. Anil Kumar,
SO/HQ, Mr. Rajesh Kumar, ASO/HQ,
MCD
Mr. Rajesh Gogna, Ms. Rebina Rai,
Advocates for R-2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
JUDGMENT
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J.
Digitally Signed
By:MOHIT
17:11:03
W.P.(C) 18585/2025
CM APPL. 81246/2025
1.
This is an application filed on behalf of M/s MI2C Business Private
Limited, seeking impleadment as a respondent in the array of parties.
2.
It is stated in the application that the applicant is not challenging the
tender conditions and only seeks impleadment for safeguarding its interest.
It is stated that the applicant, along with the other seven (7) bidders, has
technically qualified and is awaiting the opening of the financial bids, which
is scheduled for 31.01.2026.
3.
In the considered opinion of this court, the rights of the said parties
are not in contest in the present petition. The applicant is not a necessary
party, and accordingly, the application is dismissed.
W.P.(C) 18585/2025 and CM APPL. 77276/2025, CM APPL. 78566/2025
4.
The
present
petition
lays
a
challenge
to
bid
number
GeM/2025/B/6901498 dated 17.11.2025 (‘the Bid’) for the work of supply
of unarmed security guards, security manpower services, security
supervisors for a period of three (3) years and one (1) day, with an estimated
bid value of Rs. 34,53,79,633/-.
5.
The tender stipulates manpower requirements of 260 unarmed
security guards, 12 armed security guards (total-272) and 16 security
supervisors.
5.1.
The petitioner contends that the tender is contrary to the provisions of
the Private Security Agencies (Regulation) Act, 2005 (‘PSARA’) and Rule
10 of the Delhi Private Security Agencies (Regulation) Rules, 2023 (‘2023
Rules’), which mandate the deployment of one (1) security supervisor for
every six (6) security guards where the guards are deputed at different
premises, and one (1) security supervisor for every fifteen (15) security
Digitally Signed
By:MOHIT
17:11:03
W.P.(C) 18585/2025
guards where they are deputed at the same premises. Rule 10 reads as
follows: 10. Provision for Supervisors. — (1) There shall be one supervisor to
supervise the work of not more than fifteen private security guards.
(2) In case the private security guards are on security duty in different
premises and it is not practical to supervise their work by one supervisor,
the agency shall depute more number of supervisors so that at least for
every six private security guards there is one supervisor available for
assistance, advice and supervision.
(Emphasis Supplied)
5.2.
The petitioner also challenges the tender on the ground that, under the
Additional Terms and Conditions (‘ATC’), the respondent has prescribed
parameters for evaluation of technical and financial bids at Annexure-III,
stipulating that only those firms securing more than 60% of the total 100
marks would be considered as technically qualified. However, it further
provides that where more than one (1) L-1 agency secures identical marks in
the technical bid, the work shall be awarded to the bidder with the highest
turnover during the preceding five (5) years. It is contended that this
condition for awarding work to the bidder with the highest turnover is
arbitrary and unreasonable.
6.
Mr. Ramesh Singh, learned senior counsel for the petitioner states that
the stipulation in Annexure-III of the Bid with respect to award of the
contract to the L-1 bidder with the highest turnover is contrary to Clause
4(xiii)(h) of the General Terms and Conditions of GeM 4.0 dated
06.11.2025 (‘GeM GTC’), which stipulates that in case of multiple L-1
bidders against a service bid, buyer shall place the contract by selection of a
bidder amongst the L1 bidders through a random algorithm executed by the
GeM system.
Digitally Signed
By:MOHIT
17:11:03
W.P.(C) 18585/2025
6.1.
In this regard, he also places reliance on Clause 15 of the Disclaimer
section of the Bid1, which reiterates the overriding effect of Clause 4(xiii)(h)
of the GeM GTC. It expressly provides that any ATC in contravention
thereof shall be invalid.
7.
In reply, learned counsel for the respondent/Municipal Corporation of
Delhi states that the respondent is conscious of the applicability of Rule 10
of the 2023 Rules.
7.1.
He states that, according to the respondent, the applicable criterion is
one (1) supervisor for every fifteen (15) guards and not one (1) supervisor
for every six (6) guards as claimed by the petitioner, thereby rendering Rule
10(1) of the 2023 Rules applicable rather than Rule 10(2) as relied upon by
the petitioner.
7.2.
He states that this is for the reason that the premises in question, i.e.
Dr S.P.M. Civic Centre, for which the services are being procured, is a
single, centralized premises. He states that the respondent has already
requisitioned 16 security supervisors, and as per Rule 10(1), there may be a
shortfall of 2 to 3 supervisors, and this shortfall will be made good before
awarding the contract.
7.3.
He states that any deficiency in security supervisors will be rectified
by increasing the number of required supervisors. In this regard, he relies
upon the Notes in ATC2 stipulated in the Bid, to ensure compliance with
Rule 10(1) of the 2023 Rules.
7.4.
In response to the petitioner’s submission regarding the alleged
inconsistency between Clause 4(xiii)(h) of the GeM GTC and the clause
Page 25 of the paper-book.
Page 40 of the paper-book.
Digitally Signed
By:MOHIT
17:11:03
W.P.(C) 18585/2025
prescribed in the ATC by the respondent3, he states that where multiple
bidders quote the lowest price, the selection amongst the L-1 bidders will be
carried out in accordance with the mechanism prescribed by the GeM
system. Reliance is placed on the stand taken by the respondent in paragraph
24 of the affidavit dated 08.01.2026.
7.5.
He further states that the petitioner has not participated in the bidding
process and, therefore, lacks locus standi to maintain the present petition.
COURT’S FINDINGS
8.
This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused
the records.
9.
The petitioner has challenged the Bid document on the following two
(2) grounds:
(i)
Non-compliance with Rule 10 of the 2023 Rules.
(ii)
Conflict between the GeM GTC Clause 4(xiii)(h) and the
respondent’s prescribed ATC Clause4 for the award of the contract in case of
more than one L-1 qualified bidder.
I.
NON-COMPLIANCE WITH RULE 10 OF THE 2023 RULES
10.
With respect to non-compliance with Rule 10 of the 2023 Rules, the
factual controversy is that though the respondent has called the tender for
deployment of 272 security guards, it has requisitioned deployment of only
16 security supervisors. Whereas, as per Rule 10(1) of the 2023 Rules, the
respondent would be required to deploy 18-19 security supervisors for 272
security guards and as per Rule 10(2), the respondent would be required to
deploy 43-44 security supervisors for 272 security guards.
Page 48 of the paper-book.
Page 48 of the paper-book.
Digitally Signed
By:MOHIT
17:11:03
W.P.(C) 18585/2025
11.
The respondent has contended that Rule 10(1) is applicable to the
facts of the present case and has disputed the applicability of Rule 10(2).
The respondent has, in its affidavit dated 08.01.2026, as well as during the
course of arguments, fairly acknowledged that the shortfall in the number of
security supervisors would be rectified prior to the award of the contract to
the successful bidder, in terms of the clauses appearing as Notes 5. It has
further contended that the tender already provides for 16 security
supervisors, and that the shortfall of 2-3 security supervisors would be made
good by exercising the increase option under Note (a).
12.
This Court, therefore, deems it appropriate to reproduce the Notes6 in
ATC relied upon by the respondent, which reads as follows:
“iii. Physical number of Manpower Required:
S.No.
1.
Designation
Security Guard
Number of
manpower
required
Remarks
Under Semi Skilled
Category
2.
Armed Security Guards
Under Skilled Category
3.
Security Supervisor
Under Skilled Category
Grand Total
Notes :
a) The number of manpower required shown above is indicative/tentative.
The actual quantum may vary. The number of Supervisor/Armed GuardsGunman/Security Guards can also be increased/decreased, subject to future
requirement, if any. However the total strength will remain intact. In case
of any change, the Bidder will be informed at least 07 (Seven) days in
advance.
b) The total strength can be decreased or increased as per proposal made
Page 40 of the paper-book.
Page 40 of the paper-book.
Digitally Signed
By:MOHIT
17:11:03
W.P.(C) 18585/2025
by the bidder and on the decision taken by the department based on actual
requirement, considering the financial viability.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
13.
The Notes (a) and (b) undoubtedly enable the respondent and the
successful bidder to place a proposal for an increase or decrease in the
number of security guards as well as the security supervisors. Since both the
respondent and the successful bidder are bound in law to comply with Rule
10 of the 2023 Rules, this Court is satisfied that the aforesaid Notes (a) and
(b) enable the respondent and the successful contractor to suitably increase
the number of security supervisors to be deployed for the 272 security
guards in compliance with the 2023 Rules.
14.
This Court also notes that Clause (1) of the Buyer Added Bid Specific
Terms and Conditions (at internal page 8 of the Bid document) inter alia
permits/enables the respondent to increase or decrease the contract quantity
or contract duration by up to 25%, at the time of issuance of the contract.
The respondent is entitled to exercise such variation prior to awarding the
contract to the successful bidder. The said Clause corresponds to Note (a)
referred to hereinabove. The Clause (1) reads as follows: “Generic
OPTION CLAUSE: The buyer can increase or decrease the contract
quantity or contract duration up to 25 percent at the time of issue of the
contract. However, once the contract is issued, contract quantity or contract
duration can only be increased up to 25 percent. Bidders are bound to
accept the revised quantity or duration”
(Emphasis Supplied)
15.
The respondent has stated that since it is a single premises, Rule10(1)
of the 2023 Rules is applicable to this bid and not Rule10(2).
The said submission of a single premises was disputed by the petitioner
during oral arguments, contending that the precincts in question are spread
Digitally Signed
By:MOHIT
17:11:03
W.P.(C) 18585/2025
over a vast area comprising the deployment of personnel over several
buildings. This Court is, however, not inclined to accept the submission of
the petitioner. The respondent is the buyer and has taken its stand on oath
with respect to the premises in question being a single unit, and this Court
would rather rely upon the stand of the respondent, which is the municipal
authority, an instrumentality of the State.
16.
In any event, the respondent has acknowledged its statutory obligation
to comply with the 2023 Rules, including Rule 10, in both letter and spirit
prior to awarding the contract to the successful bidder. Accordingly, the
ground alleging a deficiency in the Bid document does not survive for the
purpose of challenging the Bid. The respondent is therefore directed to
ensure that, prior to awarding the contract; it will ensure that the mandatory
number of security supervisors is requisitioned for deployment.
II.
INCONSISTENCY BETWEEN GEM GTC CLAUSE 4(XIII)(H) AND THE
RESPONDENT’S PRESCRIBED ATC CLAUSE WITH RESPECT TO AWARD
OF CONTRACT TO THE L1 BIDDER
17.
With regard to the conflict between GeM GTC Clause 4(xiii)(h) and
the ATC clause prescribed by the respondent7, this Court notes the
respondent’s submission that the GeM GTC Clause 4(xiii)(h) will supersede
the said ATC clause.
18.
However, for the sake of clarity, this Court takes note of the relevant
clauses. Clause 4(xiii)(h)8 of the GeM GTC is reproduced as under:
“(h) In case, two or more acceptable bidders are found to have quoted
identical lowest bid price, forced Reverse Auction shall be conducted for the
required Goods among all technically qualified bidders with 50%
elimination rule as per clause 13(u)(1) in case of bids for Goods.
Whereas in case of Service bids, if the multiple L-1 bidders have quoted the
Page 48 of the paper-book.
Page 131 of the paper-book.
Digitally Signed
By:MOHIT
17:11:03
W.P.(C) 18585/2025
lowest allowed price for that service, Buyer shall place the Contract by
selection of a bidder amongst the L-1 bidders through a Random Algorithm
executed by GeM system.”
(Emphasis supplied)
The second part of the clause pertaining to service bids is relevant to
the issue at hand.
19.
The aspect that the second part of Clause 4(xiii)(h) will supersede any
contravening clause prescribed by the buyer/respondent in the ATC is also
categorically stipulated in the Disclaimer section at Clause 15 of the Bid9,
which reads as follows:
“DISCLAIMER
The additional terms and conditions have been incorporated by the Buyer
after approval of the Competent Authority in Buyer Organization, whereby
Buyer Organization is solely responsible for the impact of these clauses on
the bidding process, its outcome, and consequences thereof including any
eccentricity/restriction arising in the bidding process due to these ATCs and
due to modification of technical specifications and/or terms and conditions
governing the bid. If any clause(s) is/are incorporated by the Buyer
regarding following, the bid and resultant contracts shall be treated as null
and void and such bids may be cancelled by GeM at any stage of bidding
process without any notice: ….
15. Any ATC clause in contravention with GeM GTC Clause 4 (xiii)(h) will
be invalid. In case of multiple L1 bidders against a service bid, the buyer
shall place the Contract by selection of a bidder amongst the L-1 bidders
through a Random Algorithm executed by GeM system.”
(Emphasis supplied)
20.
A conjoint reading of Clause 4(xiii)(h) of GeM GTC and Clause 15 of
the Disclaimer section of the Bid makes it unequivocal that the said Clause
4(xiii)(h) will have an overriding effect on any contrary term prescribed by
the buyer/respondent in the ATC.
Page 25 of the paper-book.
Digitally Signed
By:MOHIT
17:11:03
W.P.(C) 18585/2025
21.
The ATC Clause10 prescribed by the respondent in Annexure-III to
the ATC, which, as per the petitioner, is contrary to GTC Clause 4(xiii)(h),
reads as under:
“The work will be awarded to the responsive L-1 agency. In case, the
financial bid of more than one firm / agency / bidder is same as responsive L1, then the work will be awarded to the firm/agency/bidder, who amongst
them, secures maximum marks in Technical Evaluation. Further, in case
more than one agency have similar marks in technical bid, the bidder having
highest turnover during last 5 financial years (aggregate of all three years),
shall be treated as successful L-1 bidder and the work shall be awarded to
that firm/agency/bidder,”
(Emphasis supplied)
22.
It is contended by the petitioner that due to the nature of the Bid (i.e.,
security services), empirical data show that there is almost always more than
one (1) L-1 bidder, as parties submit competitive bids with the price
components objectively broken down. It is stated that, in these facts,
awarding the contract to the L-1 bidder, who has a higher turnover is
arbitrary and would lead to a monopoly. The petitioner contends that the
award of the contract should instead be as per Clause 4(xiii)(h) prescribed
by the GeM GTC, which is fair and reasonable.
23.
This Court has perused the ATC Clause in Annexure-III as prescribed
by the respondent and finds that the same is ex facie inconsistent with
Clause 4(xiii)(h) of the GeM GTC. Such inconsistency cannot be sustained
in view of the express bar contained in the Disclaimer section of the Bid by
GeM, which, as noted above, explicitly provides that Clause 4(xiii)(h) of the
GeM GTC shall prevail over and supersede any contrary or inconsistent
clause. In fact, if the respondent awards the contract in contravention of
Clause 4(xiii)(h), it shall lead to the resultant contract being treated as null
Page 48 of the paper-book.
Digitally Signed
By:MOHIT
17:11:03
W.P.(C) 18585/2025
and void. We also find merit in the submission of the petitioner that the
criteria in the ATC clause of awarding the contract to the bidder, who has
the highest turnover, is arbitrary, as once all the L-1 bidders have technically
qualified, the criteria of turnover loses relevance. The GeM GTC clause is
far more reasonable.
24.
We, therefore, observe that in case there is more than one (1) qualified
L-1 bidder, the respondent shall award the contract strictly in accordance
with Clause 4(xiii)(h) of the GeM GTC only, and it will not award the
contract as per the process contemplated in Annexure III (referred to above).
This direction also accords with and is reinforced by the stand taken by the
respondent in its affidavit at paragraph 24.
III.
OBJECTION TO MAINTAINABILITY OF THE WRIT PETITION
25.
The respondent has raised an objection to the maintainability of this
writ by the petitioner on the ground that the petitioner himself has not
participated in this Bid and, therefore, has no locus.
26.
This Court, however, notes that the two (2) issues raised by the
petitioner concerning the deficiencies in the Bid stand duly substantiated.
The raising of such issues by the petitioner in this writ petition does not
undermine the tender process; rather, it facilitates strict compliance with the
applicable 2023 Rules, conditions, and the GeM framework governing the
Bid. It thereby ultimately operates in aid of the respondent as it ensures
conformity with law, thereby reducing the scope for ambiguity and averting
potential disputes or litigation at a later stage with both the contractor and
the GeM portal.
27.
In these circumstances, the present petition, along with pending
Digitally Signed
By:MOHIT
17:11:03
W.P.(C) 18585/2025
applications (if any) are disposed of by binding the respondent to the stand
taken in its affidavit, as well as to the directions issued by this Court.
28.
No order as to costs.
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
FEBRUARY 02, 2026/tg/aa
Digitally Signed
By:MOHIT
17:11:03
W.P.(C) 18585/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review