Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 14.05.2026
Judgment pronounced on:01.07.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 01.07.2026
+
W.P.(C) 18124/2025, CM APPL. 74988/2025
GAURAV ENTERPRISES
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Ramesh Singh, Sr. Adv.
along with Mr. Harshit Singh
and Ms. Hage Nanya, Advs.
versus
LADY HARDINGE MEDICAL COLLEGE & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Shashank Bajpai, CGSC
along with Ms. Aandrita Deb,
GP, Ms. Aashna Mehra, Mr.
Vatsal Tripathi and Mr. Govind
Singh Chauhan, Advs. for R-1
& 2.
Mr. Hanu Bhaskar and Mr.
Harish Saini, Advs. for R-3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
Through the present Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, the Petitioner assails GeM Bid No.
GEM/2024/B/5021037 dated 16.07.2024, floated by Lady Hardinge
Medical College and Smt. Sucheta Kriplani Hospital, New Delhi, for
outsourcing security manpower services. The Petitioner also assails
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
the consequential GeM Contract dated 03.11.2025 and the Letter of
Award issued in favour of Respondent No. 3.
2.
The challenge, as ultimately pressed, rests on two principal
grounds. The first is that the Letter of Award was issued by the
Tendering Authority after expiry of the original bid-offer validity
period. The second is that the bid and the contract, as originally
framed, did not provide the requisite number of security supervisors
under Rule 10 of the Delhi Private Security Agencies (Regulation)
Rules, 2023.
3.
The bid was issued on 16.07.2024 for a period of one year. The
manpower requisitioned under the bid comprised 449 security
personnel, namely, 18 security supervisors, 369 male unarmed
security guards and 62 female unarmed security guards. The bid
document provided the bid-offer validity as 180 days from the bid end
date.
4.
As per the stand of Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘Official Respondents’), the bid-offer validity was
up to 25.01.2025. The technical bids were opened on 31.07.2024. It is
stated that 190 bidders participated in the tender process. Upon
technical evaluation, 16 bidders were found technically qualified.
5.
The financial bids were opened on 02.01.2025. All 16
technically qualified bidders, including the Petitioner and Respondent
No.3, were found to be L-1 bidders, having regard to the same total
bid value of Rs. 2021 Lakhs (Rs. 20.21 Crores). In view thereof, the
Financial Evaluation Committee used the Auto Run L-1/Run L-1
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
Selection functionality on the GeM portal, whereupon Respondent
No.3, M/s Isha Protectional Security Guard Pvt. Ltd., was selected by
the GeM system.
6.
Since the estimated value of the procurement was above Rs. 20
crores, Respondent No.1 forwarded the proposal to the Ministry of
Health and Family Welfare on 29.01.2025 for approval of the
competent authority. The approval was conveyed on 24.10.2025.
7.
Thereafter, on 03.11.2025, the GeM contract was generated in
favour of Respondent No.3. The contract was accepted by Respondent
No.3 on the same date. Thereafter, a Letter of Award dated
08.11.2025 was issued by the Official Respondents in favour of
Respondent No.3, M/s Isha Protectional Security Guard Pvt. Ltd, and
the contract period was fixed from 01.12.2025 to 30.11.2026.
8.
During the pendency of the present Petition, the Official
Respondents have filed an affidavit placing on record a subsequent
work order dated 11.05.2026. By the said work order, the manpower
was redistributed so as to provide 35 security supervisors for 524
security guards. The said redistribution was stated to have been
undertaken to bring the deployment in conformity with Rule 10 of the
2023 Rules.
9.
In this backdrop, the controversy which survives for
consideration is whether, in the facts of the present case, this Court
ought to interfere with an ongoing hospital-security contract on the
ground that the formal contract was generated after expiry of the
original bid-offer validity period of 180 days, and on the further
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
ground that the original supervisor deployment was deficient, though
subsequently corrected.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
10.
Learned Senior counsel appearing for the Petitioner submits
that the bid-offer validity expired on 25.01.2025, whereas the GeM
contract was generated only on 03.11.2025 and the Letter of Award
was issued on 08.11.2025. It is urged that a bidder’s offer remains
open only during the period of bid validity, and therefore, the
Tendering Authority was required to conclude the award within that
period.
11.
It is further submitted that the selection of Respondent No.3
through the GeM Auto Run mechanism on 02.01.2025 cannot be
equated with award of contract. According to the Petitioner, the actual
contract came into existence only on 03.11.2025, long after the bid
had lapsed.
12.
Learned Senior counsel also relies on the GeM Helpdesk
clarification dated 01.12.2025 to submit that the Authority is required
to award the order within the bid-offer validity period. It is submitted
that the subsequent acceptance by Respondent No.3 on 03.11.2025
cannot revive a bid which had already expired several months earlier.
13.
The second part of challenge by the Petitioner is founded on
Rule 10 of the Delhi Private Security Agencies (Regulation) Rules,
2023. It is submitted that the original bid and contract contemplated
only 18 supervisors for 431 security guards. According to the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
Petitioner, this was contrary even to the ratio of one supervisor for
every fifteen guards under Rule 10(1), and a fortiori contrary to Rule
10(2), which requires one supervisor for every six guards where
guards are deployed in different premises.
14.
Learned senior counsel for the Petitioner submits that the
subsequent work order dated 11.05.2026, whereby the manpower was
redistributed, is itself an admission that the original bid and contract
were not compliant with the statutory requirement. It is urged that the
defect was not merely operational, but went to the legality of the bid
and the Award itself.
15.
Learned Senior counsel further relies on the judgment in
Gaurav Enterprises v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi, W.P.(C)
18585/2025, decided on 02.02.2026, which was also rendered at the
instance of the present Petitioner. It is submitted that this Court, while
considering Rule 10 of the 2023 Rules, directed the procuring
authority to ensure, prior to awarding the contract, that the mandatory
number of security supervisors is requisitioned for deployment. On
this basis, it is urged that the present bid and Award, which were
originally deficient in the number of supervisors, are liable to be set
aside.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS
16.
Per contra, learned counsel for the Official Respondents
submits that the Petitioner participated in the tender process and was
one of the sixteen (16) L-1 bidders. It is submitted that the Petitioner
cannot, after participating in the process, challenge the tender
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
conditions merely because the contract was ultimately not awarded in
its favour.
17.
Learned counsel further submits that Respondent No.3 was not
manually selected by the procuring authority. All 16 financially
qualified bidders had the same total bid price and were ranked L-1. In
such circumstances, the GeM Auto Run L-1 functionality was used,
and Respondent No.3 was selected by the GeM system on 02.01.2025,
within the original bid validity period.
18.
On the issue of bid validity, learned counsel for the Official
Respondents submits that Clause 4(xiii)(f) of the General Terms and
Conditions on GeM permits bid validity to be extended with mutual
consent between the buyer and seller. It is submitted that after
approval was received from the competent authority, the process was
undertaken on the GeM portal on 03.11.2025, and Respondent No.3
accepted the order on the same date.
19.
It is further submitted that the delay after 02.01.2025 was not
attributable to favouritism or mala fides. Since the procurement value
exceeded Rs. 20 crores, approval of the Ministry of Health and Family
Welfare was required. The proposal was sent for approval and, after
approval was conveyed on 24.10.2025, the contract was generated
through the GeM portal.
20.
On the issue of supervisors, learned counsel submits that the
security personnel are deployed within the same hospital premises
and, therefore, Rule 10(1), and not Rule 10(2), would apply. It is
further submitted that, in any event, the manpower has now been
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
redistributed and 35 supervisors are deployed for 524 security guards,
thereby satisfying the statutory requirement.
21.
Respondent No.3 adopts the submissions advanced on behalf of
the Official Respondents. It is additionally submitted that Respondent
No.3 has been performing the contract since 01.12.2025 and has
deployed manpower and resources at the hospital. The allegations
regarding alleged agents or persons collecting money in the name of
Respondent No.3 are denied. It is submitted that no disqualification,
blacklisting, or cancellation of licence has been placed on record
against Respondent No.3.
22.
The Respondents rely on the decisions in Tata Motors Ltd. v.
Brihan Mumbai Electric Supply and Transport Undertaking1,
Agmatel India Pvt. Ltd. v. Resoursys Telecom 2, Well Protect
Manpower Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Baba Sahab Ambedkar Hospital &
Ors.3 to submit that this Court ought not to interdict an ongoing public
contract, particularly when the selection was GeM system-driven, no
mala fides are established, and statutory compliance has now been
ensured.
23.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and having perused
the record, the following issues arise for consideration:
i.
Whether the generation of the GeM contract on
03.11.2025, after expiry of the original bid-offer validity period,
warrants interference under Article 226 of the Constitution, and
2023 SCC OnLine SC 671
(2022) 5 SCC 362
2024:DHC:8653-DB
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
ii.
Whether the initial deficiency in the number of
supervisors under Rule 10 of the Delhi Private Security Agencies
(Regulation) Rules, 2023 requires quashing of the bid or contract
despite subsequent compliance.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
24.
At the outset, it may be noticed that all 16 technically qualified
bidders, including the Petitioner and Respondent No.3, were found to
be L-1 bidders. Thereafter, Respondent No.3 came to be selected
through the Auto Run L-1/Run L-1 Selection functionality on the
GeM portal on 02.01.2025. The Petitioner’s surviving grievance,
therefore, is not directed against any manual choice between
competing L-1 bidders, but against the subsequent generation of the
contract after expiry of bid validity and the non-compliance with Rule
10 of the 2023 Rules.
25.
The principal challenge of the Petitioner concerns the date on
which the GeM contract came to be generated. The bid-offer validity,
even as per the Official Respondents, was up to 25.01.2025. The GeM
Contract, however, was generated only on 03.11.2025 and accepted by
Respondent No.3 on the same date. The contract period was thereafter
fixed from 01.12.2025 to 30.11.2026.
26.
Since the issue turns on bid validity under the GeM framework,
it would be apposite to reproduce the relevant portion of Clause
4(xiii)(f) of the General Terms and Conditions on GeM 4.0, which
reads as under:
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
“4. Enabling provisions of Rule 149 of General Financial Rules2017
xiii. e-Bidding and Reverse Auction (RA) on GeM
(f) The Seller participating in the e-bidding/RA may offer any one of
their product(s) already listed on GeM. The bid submitted under:
i) e-Bidding shall remain valid for 15 days (or as stipulated by the
Buyer in the bid document) from the Bid Opening Date (till 24.00
Hrs IST).
ii) RA in Bid to RA case, where the bid offer validity is less than 30
days, will be extended to 30 days including the RA initiation date.
Bid Validity can be further extended with mutual consent between
Buyer and Seller. The products offered in e-Bidding/RA cannot be
withdrawn by the Sellers from GeM during the bid validity period.
However, in case there has been some technical issues in extending
bid validity online on GeM portal and the buyer has in compliance
with Clause 3(B)(b)(ix) communicated its intention to award the
contract or awarded the contract to the successful bidder in writing,
through any means and mode, outside GeM portal before the expiry
of the bid validity, then in such circumstances, for the purposes of
resolution of any such technical issues and/or necessary
regularization, the bid validity shall be deemed to be extended until
such issue is resolved/regularized by GeM.”
(Emphasis supplied)
27.
The clause contains two parts which are relevant for the present
case. The first part states that bid validity can be further extended with
mutual consent between the buyer and the seller. The second part
deals with a specific situation where there is some technical issue in
extending bid validity online on the GeM portal, but the buyer has,
before expiry of bid validity, communicated its intention to award the
contract or has awarded the contract to the successful bidder in
writing. In that situation, the bid validity is deemed to be extended
until the issue is resolved or regularised by GeM.
28.
The Petitioner is right in submitting that bid validity is not an
empty formality. It represents the period during which the seller’s
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
offer remains open for acceptance by the buyer. The GeM Helpdesk
Email clarification dated 01.12.2025 clarified that bid-offer validity is
the period during which the seller’s offer is valid from the bid end
date, and that the buyer needs to award the order within the bid-offer
validity period.
29.
The said clarification also explained the process for seeking
offer-validity extension at the bid stage or demand stage. However, it
did not, in express terms, answer whether a bid whose original validity
had expired on 25.01.2025 could be acted upon after approval of the
competent authority was received several months later.
30.
The Official Respondents
have also relied upon the
communication dated 12.12.2025 issued by the Director, Category
Management (Health), GeM. The said communication refers to Clause
4(xiii)(f) and states that bid validity can be further extended with
mutual consent between the buyer and seller. However, the said
communication also does not expressly certify the validity of the
contract in question.
31.
Thus, neither the Helpdesk clarification dated 01.12.2025 nor
the communication dated 12.12.2025 can be treated as a conclusive
adjudication of the present controversy. The former emphasized that
the order should ordinarily be awarded within the bid-offer validity
period. The latter referred to the power of extension by mutual
consent.
32.
The Court must, therefore, look at the entire factual setting.
Respondent No.3 was selected through the GeM Auto Run L-1
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
mechanism on 02.01.2025, i.e. within the original bid-offer validity
period.
33.
The delay thereafter arose because the procurement value
exceeded Rs. 20 crores and the proposal had to be placed before the
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare for approval of the competent
authority. The proposal was sent on 29.01.2025. Approval was
conveyed on 24.10.2025. Thereafter, the GeM process for contract
generation was undertaken on 03.11.2025 and the contract was
accepted by Respondent No.3 on the same date.
34.
This Court is conscious that the course adopted by the Official
Respondents is not one which should be treated as a model
procurement practice. Public procurement authorities are expected to
act with sufficient expedition and must ordinarily ensure that the
award is concluded within the bid-offer validity period, or within a
validity duly extended at the appropriate stage.
35.
However, the present case does not disclose a manual
preference in favour of Respondent No.3. Nor does it disclose that the
delay was engineered to favour Respondent No.3. The selection was
made through the GeM system within the original validity period, the
delay thereafter was referable to the process of obtaining approval
from the competent authority, the contract was thereafter generated on
the GeM portal and Respondent No.3 accepted the order.
36.
At this stage, the contract has already been in operation since
01.12.2025 and is to remain in force till 30.11.2026. It is a contract
concerning deployment of security personnel in public medical
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
college for women and its associated hospital. Interfering with the
contract midway would have consequences not merely for the
contracting parties, but also for continuity of security services at the
institution.
37.
Having regard to the above circumstances, this Court is not
persuaded to annul the ongoing contract merely on the ground that the
formal contract was generated after expiry of the original bid-offer
validity period. Given the peculiar facts of the present case,
particularly when Respondent No. 3 is not objecting and is continuing
to perform. It is not the case of the Petitioner that rates for the supply
of manpower, security personnel have come down. Therefore, it
would not be in the public interest to interdict the ongoing contract
already under performance.
38.
It is clarified that this Court is not laying down any general
proposition that an expired bid can be revived after lapse of time as a
matter of course. Bid validity serves a definite public procurement
purpose, and future procurement processes must be conducted with
due regard to the time limits prescribed under the bid and the GeM
framework.
39.
The next objection concerns the number of supervisors
contemplated under the bid and the contract. The GeM contract dated
03.11.2025 records the deployment of 18 security supervisors, 369
male unarmed security guards and 62 female unarmed security guards.
Thus, originally, the contract provided 18 supervisors for 431 security
guards.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
40.
Since the objection is founded on Rule 10 of the Delhi Private
Security Agencies (Regulation) Rules, 2023, the same may be
reproduced:
“10. Provision for Supervisors (1) There shall be one supervisor to supervise the work of not more
than fifteen private security guards.
(2) In case the private security guards are on security duty in different
premises and it is not practical to supervise their work by one
supervisor, the agency shall depute more number of supervisors so
that at least for every six private security guards there is one
supervisor available for assistance, advice and supervision.”
41.
The structure of the rule is plain. Sub-rule (1) prescribes the
ordinary ratio of one supervisor for not more than fifteen private
security guards. Sub-rule (2) applies where the security guards are
deployed in different premises and it is not practical for one
supervisor to supervise their work. In that situation, the stricter ratio of
one supervisor for every six private security guards is attracted.
42.
The Official Respondents have taken the stand that the security
personnel are deployed within the same hospital premises and,
therefore, Rule 10(1) applies. The Petitioner disputes this position and
contends that Lady Hardinge Medical College and its associated
hospitals comprise a large institutional establishment with distinct
units/premises and, therefore, cannot be treated as one compact
premises for the purpose of Rule 10.
43.
Even if the stand of the Official Respondents is accepted and
Rule 10 (1) alone is applied, the original contract was deficient.
Eighteen supervisors for 431 security guards did not satisfy the ratio
of one supervisor for not more than fifteen guards.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
44.
The shortage of supervisors became more apparent when
additional security guards were deployed under the 25% tolerance
clause. The work order dated 11.05.2026 records that the then existing
deployment comprised 561 personnel, namely, 18 supervisors and 543
security guards. This was plainly below the requirement under Rule
10(1).
45.
During the pendency of the present Petition, the Respondents
issued the aforesaid work order dated 11.05.2026, by which the
manpower was redistributed. Through the said work order, 17
additional supervisors were to be deployed, and 19 security guards
were to be withdrawn, resulting in 35 supervisors and 524 security
guards.
46.
On the ratio prescribed under Rule 10(1), 35 supervisors for 524
security guards satisfy the requirement of one supervisor for not more
than fifteen guards. The subsequent affidavit filed by the Official
Respondents, therefore, shows that the statutory deficiency, at least on
the application of Rule 10(1), has been corrected during the pendency
of the present Writ Petition.
47.
The submission of the Petitioner that the subsequent work order
cannot retrospectively validate the original deficiency deserves
consideration. However, it is also required to consider the subsequent
developments, the nature of the deficiency, the stage of performance
of the contract, and whether cancellation of the contract at this stage
would serve the larger public interest.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
48.
In exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226, the Court is
entitled to mould relief having regard to subsequent development,
particularly where the deficiency pertains to the operational
deployment of manpower, has been brought in line with the statutory
ratio, and where cancellation of the contract at this stage would cause
greater disruption than the defect now surviving for adjudication.
49.
In Well Protect Manpower Services Pvt. Ltd. (Supra), W.P.(C)
14441/2024, decided on 06.11.2024, this Court dealt with a similar
objection that the tender had provided for fewer supervisors than what
Rule 10 required. The Court accepted that where a contractual term is
inconsistent with a statutory requirement, the statutory requirement
must prevail. However, since the contract had already been awarded
and compliance with Rule 10 had been undertaken by the successful
bidder, the Court declined to interfere with the awarded contract.
50.
The reliance placed by the Petitioner on Gaurav Enterprises
(Supra) also requires consideration. The said judgment was rendered
at the instance of the present Petitioner itself. In that case, this Court
accepted that Rule 10 of the 2023 Rules had to be complied with and
directed the procuring authority to ensure, prior to awarding the
contract, that the mandatory number of security supervisors was
requisitioned for deployment. However, the said judgment did not
quash the bid. Rather, the Petition was disposed of by binding the
Respondent therein to its stand and to the directions issued by the
Court.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
51.
In the present case, at least on the application of Rule 10(1) of
the 2023 Rules, the deficiency has been addressed by the subsequent
redistribution. The Court is, therefore, not persuaded to quash the bid
or contract on this ground.
52.
The Petitioner has also urged that the bid and the contract
record Bonus and ESI as nil. The Official Respondents have explained
that the wages payable to the security guards and supervisors are
above Rs. 21,000/- and, therefore, the provisions relating to Bonus
and ESI are not attracted in the manner asserted by the Petitioner. The
GeM contract, in any event, contains provisions requiring compliance
with applicable labour laws, including minimum wages, statutory
wage revisions, EPF/ESI requirements wherever applicable, and other
statutory obligations. No ground for quashing of the bid or contract is,
therefore, made out on this score.
53.
The Petitioner has also referred to allegations concerning
persons who are stated to have collected money from job-seekers in
the name of Respondent No.3. Respondent No.3 denies that such
persons were its agents, representatives or employees. In the absence
of any adjudicated disqualification, blacklisting, cancellation of
licence, or established violation of any tender condition attributable to
Respondent No.3, such disputed allegations cannot form the basis for
setting aside an ongoing public contract in proceedings under Article
226.
54.
The scope of judicial review in tender and contractual matters is
well settled. The Court is not concerned with substituting its own
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
commercial assessment for that of the procuring authority. The
inquiry is whether the decision-making process is vitiated by
arbitrariness, mala fides, bias, irrationality, perversity, or procedural
impropriety of a degree warranting interference.
55.
In Tata Motors Ltd. (Supra), the Supreme Court reiterated that
courts should exercise restraint in contractual matters and should not
interfere unless a clear case of arbitrariness, mala fides, bias or
irrationality is made out. The Supreme Court also cautioned that
setting aside an ongoing contract or requiring a fresh tender may not
be in public interest where it would result in avoidable delay or loss to
the public exchequer.
56.
In Agmatel India Pvt. Ltd. (Supra), the Supreme Court
similarly held that the tendering authority is ordinarily best placed to
understand and appreciate its requirements, and that interference by
the writ court would arise only where the decision suffers from
illegality, irrationality, mala fides, perversity, bias or procedural
impropriety.
57.
Tested on the aforesaid principles, this Court is not persuaded to
quash the bid or the contract. The Petitioner has raised concerns which
required examination, particularly on the issue of bid validity and the
initial shortfall in the number of supervisors. At the same time,
Respondent No. 3 was selected through the GeM Auto Run
mechanism within the original validity period, the contract has been
under performance for a substantial part of its term, the supervisor
deployment has since been brought in conformity with Rule 10(1),
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
and no circumstance has been shown which would justify unsettling
the ongoing contract at this stage.
58.
In view of the above discussion, the Writ Petition is dismissed.
The pending applications shall stand closed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
JULY 01, 2026
sp/ad
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 18124/2025
15:16:08
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review