Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 09th December, 2025
Pronounced on: 09th February, 2026
%
CRL.A. 1688/2025
+
GANGADHARAN.C
Through:
.....Petitioner
Petitioner in person
versus
1.
STATE (NCT OF DELHI)
2.
SH. PANKAJ MEHROTRA
S/o Late Sh. KK Mehrotra
R/o B-304 Navin CGHS, Sector-5,
Plot No 13, Dwarka, New Delhi-110075
Through:
.....Respondents
Ms. Kiran Bairwa, APP for the State
Ms. Sunanda Nimisha, Advocate
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Appeal under Section 378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
(hereinafter referred to as “Cr.P.C.”) has been filed against the judgment
dated 05.07.2018 whereby the learned MM dismissed the Complaint under
Section 500 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as
“IPC”) filed by the Petitioner/Gangadharan C. against Accused persons,
i.e. Accused No. 1/Sh. Pankaj Mehrotra, the President, Accused No. 2/Sh. S.
Chandrasekhar, the Secretary, and Accused No. 3/Sh. HS Bhandari and
4/Smt. Anjana Bhandari are the members of the Society, Accused No. 5/Sh.
Swaminathan is the Advisor to the President of the Management Committee,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
CRL.A.1688 /2025
Accused Nos. 6 to 10 (Sh. M Arshad Khan, Smt. Shanti Bhardwaj, Sh. CM
Bhardwaj, Smt. Surender Kaur, Inderjeet Singh, respectively) who were the
members of the Management Committee.
2.
The Complainant/Petitioner had filed a Complaint under Section 500
IPC wherein he narrated that he is a member of a Society, i.e. Naveen
Cooperative Group Housing Society Limited, in which he resides with his
wife and family. He had been allotted a car parking in the Society in a
lottery on 03.05.2009, in regard to which there was a dispute, about which
he had made the Complaint to the President of the Society wherein he stated
that Accused No. 3 and 4 had occupied his car parking. They had erased the
allotted parking number and had started using it by affixing their own house
number.
3.
The Accused No. 4 had written a Letter dated 06.05.2009 to Sh.
Pankaj Mehrotra, Accused No. 1, President of the Society. He also made a
Complaint against the Accused person in P.S. Dwarka on 06.06.2009.
However, no action was taken. Thereafter, the Accused person started
threatening the Complainant to kill him and also started calling him as a
“mental case”. Because of these kinds of threats, the Complainant was
unable to come to his house for a few days. His wife also made a Complaint
dated 13.06.2009 to PS Dwarka.
4.
The
Complainant
also
filed
a
Complaint
against
the
Respondents/Accused persons, in the Office of Deputy Registrar
(Arbitration ground). A Reply was filed by the Society through the
Managing Committee wherein it was stated that the Complainant is a case of
mental disorder and it was requested that he be referred to a mental hospital
or to his Department in order to avoid day-to-day quarrelling and to prevent
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
CRL.A.1688 /2025
the trouble being created in the society compound and to the residents at
large in the Society.
5.
The Complainant asserted that he is not a person suffering from
mental disorder and has filed his medical prescription dated 26.11.2010 in
support thereof.
6.
The Accused persons also called the Complainant a cheater, fraud,
thug, and a case of mental disorder, without any provocation. They had
failed to restrict themselves from such expressions against the Complainant.
Their intentions are quite clear to damage the reputation and to lower his
social and personal image in the eyes of society and public.
7.
It was further asserted that such words were used on 03.05.2009 in the
presence of the public persons in the public place and to the Policeman. He
was similarly abused on 14.03.2010 and on 23.06.2010 openly in the
presence of many persons. The Complainant thus, filed the Complaint under
Section 500 IPC against the accused persons, the Respondent.
8.
The Complainant examined himself as CW1 wherein he reiterated
the contents of his Complaint.
9.
The Accused persons were summoned on 21.10.2013 for the offence
under Section 500 IPC. Thereafter, post-summoning evidence was led
wherein the Complainant adopted his pre-summoning evidence. The witness
was extensively cross-examined by the accused persons.
10.
The learned MM considered the testimony of the Complainant and
referred to his cross-examination wherein he admitted that he had made
about 40 Complaints. He also admitted using the words such as, “mard ke
bacche aur asli maa baap ke hain” in his Complaint. He also admitted
having written Letters dated 17.07.2013 and 10.07.2013 to the Accused
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
CRL.A.1688 /2025
persons and about pasting those letters on the notice board. The
Complainant himself admitted using the word B**** in the Letter. The
Complainant further admitted that when the Accused persons called him
names on 03.05.2009, no other public person was present.
11.
The learned MM thus, concluded that there was no publication of the
imputation, which was a necessary requisite for making out an offence of
defamation and consequently, acquitted the accused persons vide
judgment dated 05.07.2018.
12.
Aggrieved by the said judgment, the Appellant has preferred the
present Appeal on the grounds that the learned Trial Court had erred in not
appreciating the facts in correct perspective. It had not been considered that
the car parking space of the Complainant had been criminally trespassed by
the Accused persons despite it being duly allotted, earmarked and
demarcated by the Society Management in his favour.
13.
The allegation that he was being threatened to be killed and of dire
consequences about which the Complainant had specifically stated in his
Complaint, have been overlooked. The Accused persons have been
exonerated, despite having violated the DCS Act and DCS Rules.
14.
The learned Trial Court has justified the forgery and cheating
committed by the Respondents, in order to nullify 24 vigilance inquiries and
24 letters from Registrar from CMO and GNCTD against several offences.
15.
The Status Report was concocted and fabricated on the directions of
the Accused persons. It has also not been considered that the Accused No. 1
had become illegal and illegitimate because of forging the documents and
entering into a conspiracy. The Complainant had been called “mental”
without there being any medical ground. Many forged and cheating Letters
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
CRL.A.1688 /2025
had been sent to various authorities against the Complainant, while hiding
their own offences of cheating, forgery, bribery and misuse of society funds,
being concealed.
16.
The Complainant has been writing to ARB Court, who nullified 40
Complaints to Police, 40 Complaints to RCS, 24 vigilance inquiries, two
crime branch inquiries, two anti-corruption inquiries and several
Applications to various highest Officers of the Government of India and
Delhi.
17.
The Respondents No. 1 and 2, had forged a Letter dated 12.04.2008
against entry fee refund, forged report to Crime Branch by calling the
Complainant a man of unsound mind, and had forged various other
complaints and reports.
18.
The Petitioner/Complainant filed his Medical Fitness Certificate
before the Court to disprove the baseless defamation, but those documents
have not been considered. The defamatory replies of the Respondents, Ex.
CW-1/1 and CW-2/3, were duly proved but has not been considered.
19.
In the impugned judgment, reference has been made to two time
barred Letters, Ex. CW1/D1 and CW1/D2 dated 26.02.2010 and 10.07.2010,
for which a separate Complaint No. 2790/1/14 has already been filed by
Accused No. 1, 3 and 4, wherein the wife of the Complainant has also been
made an Accused. It has not been considered that learned MM through the
Petition in a deep gorge, jeopardised further harassment, torture, and tragedy
as the Accused compelled the Petitioner to file Court cases by giving bribes
to the Police Vigilance, PGCs, RCS, Crime Branch, CIC and AntiCorruption Department.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
CRL.A.1688 /2025
20.
The Complainant had filed an Application dated 23.04.2009 to the
President and Secretary of the Society, against the criminal trespass of his
demarcated car parking by erasing his house number and re-allocating it to
Accused Nos. 3 and 4, thereby committing the offence of criminal trespass.
21.
The Complainant further asserted that he had never closed his pre-
summoning evidence, but the Counsel for the Complainant and the Accused
and the Court, in conspiracy with each-other, converted the pre-summoning
evidence as the Complainant’s evidence. The statements of 04 Accused were
recorded and 03 accused denied the allegations and stated that a settlement
and compromise was arrived at with the Complainant in the presence of
Police for parking space, but the date of 10.03.2010 has not been given
deliberately.
22.
The Accused, Anjana Bhandari, Chandrasekhar and Pankaj
Mehrotra, too similarly had denied the allegations levelled by the
Complainant, as not correct. Instead, the Accused No. 2, 3 and 4 recorded
that they had not signed the reply dated 22.05.2010, and recorded that they
had not defamed the Complainant.
23.
In regard to not summoning the officials from PS Dwarka to prove the
Complaints, it is explained that it was not required as the Complaints had
already been filed in the Court and was marked “C”. The certified copy of
Ex. CW1/1 was from RCS and has also been filed along with the Reply.
24.
It is claimed that the impugned Order has been based on the forged
complainant’s evidence, which could not have been considered. The Letters
of the Complainant to the Accused persons, had been written in good faith
and for public good. The Complainant has been termed as a master of fraud.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
CRL.A.1688 /2025
25.
The forged Complainant’s evidence has been imposed on the
Complainant, because of the fraudulent act of the Counsel for the Accused
who had bribed the Counsel for the Complainant, who did not bring the true
facts on record.
26.
It is asserted that the learned MM has wrongly concluded that there
was no evidence to prove the offence of defamation and the Complaint has
been wrongly dismissed.
Submissions heard and record perused.
27.
The averments made in the Complaint and the testimony of the
Complainant discloses that the genesis of the acrimony between the
Complainant and the Respondent/other accused persons was in regard to
allotment of a car parking along with the flat.
28.
The Complainant alleged that there was an earmarked car parking
space in the Society, for him. However, he admitted in his statement that he
had purchased the flat from the allottee and that there was no mention of the
number of the parking in the documents of allotment. He did not have any
Parking Allotment Letter there. He further explained that there was no
provision for issuance of Allotment Letter of parking in the Society to any
member.
29.
Accused Bhandari had a car and he had two parkings allotted in his
name, while he was allotted one parking. The Complainant stated that there
was a fight between him and Bhandari, but again stated that there was no
fight. The Police had not come at that time but he had complained to the
Police. He admitted that there was a Settlement between them before the
Police, but that the same was after one year. His first Complaint to the
Police was on 04.06.2009 where he mentioned that the Accused had been
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
CRL.A.1688 /2025
repeatedly threatening him. He admitted he did not mention that the
Accused had been calling him names. He admitted having made 40
Complaints.
30.
He further admitted that in a Letter dated 26.09.2010 wherein he had
used the words such as “mard ke bacche aur asli maa baap ke hain” and
that he had written the Letters dated 17.07.2013 and 10.07.2013 to the
Accused persons and also admitted that he had pasted those letters on the
notice board.
31.
He further admitted using the abusive words B**** in the certain
letter. He further admitted that while the alleged names were called to him
by the Accused persons, there were no persons found present around on
03.05.2009.
32.
From his testimony, it clearly emerges that essentially the
Complainant has disputes with the Respondent and the members of the
Society in which he lives, in regard to the car parking. There has been
admittedly almost 40 Complaints had been written by to various agencies
and has even gone to pasting some of his letters on the notice board wherein
derogatory words had been written.
33.
He, himself has admitted that there were no persons present at the
time the accused persons had called him names.
34.
It is pertinent to understand that to constitute an offence under of
defamation under Section 500 IPC, the most important and essential
ingredient is the lowering of the estimation and self-respect in the public
eye.
35.
Section 499 IPC reads as under:
“499. Defamation.—
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
CRL.A.1688 /2025
Whoever, by words either spoken or intended to be read, or by signs
or by visible representations, makes or publishes any imputation
concerning any person intending to harm, or knowing or having
reason to believe that such imputation will harm, the reputation of
such person, is said, except in the cases hereinafter expected, to
defame that person.
Explanation 1.— …
Explanation 2.— …
Explanation 3.— An imputation in the form of an alternative or
expressed ironically, may amount to defamation.
Explanation 4.— No imputation is said to harm a person’s reputation,
unless that imputation directly or indirectly, in the estimation of
others, lowers the moral or intellectual character of that person, or
lowers the character of that person in respect of his caste or of his
calling, or lowers the credit of that person, or causes it to be believed
that the body of that person is in a loathsome state, or in a state
generally considered as disgraceful.”
36.
The intrinsic facet of “Defamation” is harm to “reputation”
or lowering the estimation of a person in public domain. This makes it
pertinent to understand what constitutes “reputation”. It is reputation alone
that is vulnerable; character needs no adventitious support. In essence, any
statement which has a tendency to injure the reputation of the person or
lower him in the estimation of members of the society, results in loss of
reputation and is defamatory.
37.
In Subramanian Swamy vs. Union of India, 2016 SCC OnLine SC 550
the Apex Court has observed that the law relating to defamation protects the
reputation of each individual in the perception of the public at large. It
matters to an individual in the eyes of the society. Protection of individual
right is imperative for social stability in a body polity and that is why the
State makes laws relating to crimes.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
CRL.A.1688 /2025
38.
The Calcutta High Court in Dipankar Bagchi vs. State of West
Bengal, 2009 SCC OnLine Cal 1877, has succinctly observed that for an
offence of defamation, evidence to show that the reputation has been
lowered in the estimation of others is essential.
39.
On similar lines, another bench of Calcutta High Court in Aveek
Sarkar vs. State of West Bengal, 2025 SCC OnLine Cal 6942 has observed
as under:
20. Moreover it is settled law that no one can be defamed in his
own eyes. In the present case admittedly no witness was examined
before issuance of process, in whose eyes the complainant was
defamed. It may be that a large number of people is the reader of the
said newspaper but that does not mean that in the eyes of all those
readers, the complainant/organization has been defamed, unless any
such reader comes before the court and disclose that in their eyes, the
reporting has defamed the complainant/organization.
40.
In essence, any statement which has a tendency to injure the
reputation of the person or lower him in the estimation of members of the
society, results in loss of reputation and is defamatory.
41.
In the light of the aforesaid proposition of law, it is evident that the
essential pre-requisite to establish that the alleged imputation had in fact,
lowered his reputation in the estimation of others, was not satisfied. Afterall,
reputation is not what you think about yourself; it is what others think about
you. Therefore, publication of such derogatory words is of primary
significance.
42.
In the present case, admittedly, the Complainant himself has
admitted that when such derogatory words were said and when he was
called with names, there were no public persons present. The mandatory
requirement of establishing loss or harm to reputation in public estimation,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
CRL.A.1688 /2025
has not been fulfilled. There is not an iota of evidence to show that there
was any lowering of reputation in the public estimation.
43.
The learned MM has rightly concluded that no case of defamation
was made out from the Complaint and the evidence of the Complainant and
thereby, has rightly dismissed the Complaint.
Conclusion:
44.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby dismissed.
45.
Pending Applications are also disposed of accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 09, 2026
N
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:16:12
CRL.A.1688 /2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review