Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 30th January, 2026
Pronounced on: 21st April, 2026
%
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
+
GANESH JEE PATHAK
S/o Late Sant Bilas Pathak
R/o A-70, Arya Nagar Apartment
Plot No. 91, I.P. Extension (Patparganj)
Delhi-110092
…..Petitioner
Through: Mr. Sanjeet Trivedi, Mr. Rajesh
Pathak, Mr. Ishank Gupta, Ms. Prachi
Patwal, Advocates.
versus
1.
2.
3.
4.
RESIDENT COMMISSIONER
Govt. of Jharkhand, Jharkhand Bhavan,
Kusumpur Pahari, Vasant Vihar
New Delhi
…Respondent No.1
STATE OF JHARKHAND
Through Chief Secretary
Project building, Dhurva
Ranchi, Jharkhand
….Respondent No. 2
LAW SECRETARY
Government of Jharkhand
Department of Law, Project Building,
Dhurva, Ranchi, Jharkhand
….Respondent No.3
FINANCE SECRETARY
Government of Jharkhand
Department of finance
Project Building
Dhurva, Ranchi, Jharkhand
….Respondent No.4
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
5.
SECRETARY (PERSONNEL AND
ADMINSITRATIVE REFORM AND RAJBHASHA)
Government of Jharkhand
Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms & Rajbhasha,
Project Building,
Dhurva, Ranchi, Jharkhand.
……Respondent No. 5
Through: Mr. Jayesh Garurav, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India has been
filed on behalf of the Petitioner for directing the Respondents to pay the
pension and other retiral benefits along with the interest @18% p.a.
2.
The Petitioner stated that he was appointed on 02.09.1974, as Steno
Typist with the erstwhile State of Bihar and was posted at New Delhi with
the Standing Counsel, Government of Jharkhand, Sampark Karyalaya,
Bihar Bhawan, New Delhi. He completed his entire service tenure and
retired on 31.03.2009 from Delhi only. The Petitioner was granted time
bound promotion in the year 1984 and was given the pay scale of 730-15820-980.
3.
As per the policy decision of the Government, to upgrade the post of
Steno Typist to Personal Assistant, Petitioner was upgraded/re-designated as
Personal Assistant vide Office Order No.356 dated 23.06.1995, passed by
the undivided State of Bihar, Department of Personnel, which had given list
of 23 upgraded Personal Assistant as per their seniority. The posting of the
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
Petitioner remained the same in the Law Department, Government of Bihar,
New Delhi.
4.
In pursuance of the Reorganisation Act, 2000, the State of Bihar was
re-organized into two successor State, namely Bihar and Jharkhand, which
came into effect from 15.11.2000. The Central Government had been
empowered to allocate employees to both the States under Section 72 of the
Bihar Re-organisation Act, 2000. The Petitioner was allocated to the State
of Jharkhand. He remained posted in New Delhi even after he was
allocated to the Government of Jharkhand, till the date of his retirement.
5.
The Respondent had prepared a Provisional Seniority List of Personal
Assistants. The Petitioner found several discrepancies in the said list, i.e.,
details against his name were left blank in all columns and, further, his
juniors were shown above him.
6.
Aggrieved by the discrepancies, the Petitioner submitted a
representation in July, 2006 to the Standing Counsel as well as to the
Respondents; however, no action was taken. The Petitioner thereafter, made
another representation, in response to which the Respondents, vide Letter
dated 30.08.2006, directed the Standing Counsel of the State of Jharkhand,
with whom the Petitioner was attached, to furnish relevant details and
documents, including the Confidential Reports (CRs), for consideration of
his case for promotion/ACP by the Departmental Promotion Committee
(DPC).
7.
All the required information and documents were duly sent to the
Respondents by the Standing Counsel, Government of Jharkhand, Sampark
Karyalaya, New Delhi, vide Letters dated 12.12.2006, 26.11.2007 and
15.01.2008. Despite receipt of the requisite documents and information, the
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
Petitioner was neither considered for promotion nor informed about the
status of processing of his pension papers.
8.
Thereafter, the Petitioner made a representation dated 03.01.2009,
followed by a reminder dated 21.02.2009, seeking processing of his pension
papers and completion of formalities for release of post-retiral benefits. A
similar Representation dated 29.03.2009 was also made for processing of his
service book and related documents.
9.
Meanwhile, the Standing Counsel addressed a Letter dated
07.03.2009, regarding non-grant of promotion and subsequently forwarded
the Confidential Reports of the Petitioner vide Letter dated 13.03.2009.
10.
The Petitioner claimed that since he remained in Delhi for his entire
service period, work condition, leave and salary were granted from New
Delhi. The control and superintendence were exercised by Standing
Counsel/Respondent No. 1 i.e. Resident Commissioner/Chief Administrative
Officer, Jharkhand Bhawan, New Delhi. The Petitioner had received his
Form 16 under Rule 31(1) (a) of the Income Tax Rules from the Respondent
No. 1.
11.
After completing 34 years of service with the Respondents, the
Petitioner retired on 31.03.2009. No action was, however, taken by the
Respondents, for release of his retiral benefits, as well as, arrears of salary
after 6th Pay Commission, much less the grant of regular promotion to the
post of Private Secretary.
12.
The Petitioner visited the Office of the Respondent No. 3 multiple
times for his pension and post retiral benefits and completed all the
formalities.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
13.
On 27.06.2009, the Petitioner was directed by Respondent No. 3 to
approach Respondent No. 4 for completion of further formalities such as
verification. Upon approaching Respondent No. 4, the Petitioner was again
required to complete additional formalities for release of pension, postretiral benefits and arrears. The Petitioner also requested Respondent Nos. 1
and 3 in June, 2009 to grant provisional pension till finalisation of pension;
however, no action was taken.
14.
Despite several representations, the Respondent No. 1 eventually
released certain retiral dues, namely GPF in September, 2009, leave
encashment in October, 2009, and GIS along with arrears of salary in
December, 2009, by way of cheque, after a delay of about 6–9 months, and
without payment of any interest for the said delay.
15.
The Petitioner continued to make repeated representations and also
personally approached the Respondents; however, no effective action was
taken. In response to his reminder letters, the Petitioner received a Letter
dated 23.09.2010 from Respondent No. 4 addressed to Respondent No. 1,
wherein the responsibility for grant of post-retiral benefits and processing of
pension papers was shifted upon Respondent No. 1, clearly reflecting that
the Respondents were evading responsibility and passing the onus upon each
other.
16.
The Petitioner received copy of the Office Order dated 03.12.2010
from the Respondent No. 5 granting him Promotion under Scheme of ACP
from 26.06.2007, instead of Regular promotion to the post of Private
Secretary but even thereafter, no arrears of difference in salary due to
promotion, were granted to him.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
17.
As per the Order issued by the Government of Bihar, vide Memo No.
Pen-1032/67-8739 F dated 13.07.1967, for provisional pension, gratuity and
D.C.R. Gratuities @75% with regard to simplification of Bihar Pension
Rules and procedure for grant of pension and same was enhanced to 90% by
Finance Department No. 3014 dated 31.07.1980. The Petitioner asserted
that there was delay in release of pension without any sufficient cause.
18.
Reliance is placed on State of Kerala vs. V.M. Padmanabhan, 1985
SCC (1) 429, wherein, “it was held that pension and gratuity are no longer
any bounty to be distributed by the Government to its employees but is a
valuable right of property in their hands and any culpable delay in
settlement and disbursement would be visited with the penalty of payment of
interest at the current market till actual payment is made.=
19.
The Petitioner sought the grant of payment of pension, arrears of
pension along with gratuity and computation of pension with interest
@18% p.a. on the said amounts, which had become due w.e.f. 31.03.2009.
He also sought directions for being granted regular promotion to the post
of Private Secretary and for arrears in the difference in salary. He also
sought directions for payment of interest @18% for delayed payment of his
retiral benefits.
20.
The Respondent No. 3 in his Counter-Affidavit explained that except
the claim of retiral benefits and pension, no other claim of the Petitioner, is
admissible. The D.P.C was convened and the Petitioner was granted A.C.P.
All other averments made in the Petition, were denied except that the
Petitioner retired on 31.03.2009.
21.
It was explained that post his retirement, the retiral benefit could not
be finalized due to non-availability of Service Book, which was procured
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
from Department of Personnel, Government of Bihar vide Letter dated
03.02.2010. The File related to confirmation of A.C.P. was sent to the
Department
of
Personnel,
Administrative
Reforms
and
Rajbhasa,
Government of Jharkhand, which was returned to Law (Judicial)
Department on 11.11.2011 along with Office Memo No. 334 dated
03.12.2010. Law (Judicial) Department passed an Order regarding
confirmation of ACP within seven days, vide Memo No. 3129 dated
18.11.2011. There was no delay on the part of Law (Judicial) Department.
22.
The Memo No. 346/J dated 08.02.2013 regarding grant of provisional
pension from 01.04.2009, had also been issued by Law (Judicial)
Department to the Accountant General, Jharkhand. Respondent No. 3 had
taken all efforts for finalisation and fixation of pension of the Petitioner and
in this connection, it was found that the pension papers submitted by the
Petitioner, were defected and this fact was duly communicated to the
Petitioner.
23.
The Additional Affidavit was filed on behalf of the Petitioner
wherein he affirmed that despite an undertaking of the Respondent No. 1 on
05.07.2012, to comply with the Order dated 03.07.2012, to release the
pension, arrears of pension, gratuity and computation of pension along with
interest @18%, it had not been complied by the Respondents.
24.
In compliance of the Order dated 05.07.2012, the Respondent No. 1
had filed an Affidavit in compliance of the Order of the Court and stated that
pension and gratuity, have been sanctioned. However, the perusal of the
documents, reflects that no such order or sanction with regard to
computation of pension @40% and arrears of pension, had been sanctioned.
The Respondent No. 2 had forwarded the pension papers of the Petitioner to
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
Accountant General with a covering Letter dated 19.07.2012, of Law
Department wherein it was requested that pension and Gratuity be granted to
the Petitioner but it has not issued any directions regarding computation of
pension.
25.
It was claimed that the Respondents had been unnecessarily harassing
the Petitioner and there was a delay in processing of pension papers without
any justification or explanation. The last Pay Certificate was issued in the
year 2012. The Respondent had requested for No Objection Certificate from
other Departments only in the month of July, 2012. It shows that the apathy
of the Respondents towards the responsibility to process the pension papers
and issue these documents in time despite the Petitioner having submitted all
the papers in advance and also after retirement.
26.
The plea of the Respondents in regard to defect in pension papers, it is
stated that Respondents first time pointed out the defects on 11.06.2012 i.e.
after five years of submission of the pension papers. The Petitioner had
mentioned the name of SBI with Account Number for receiving the payment
of pension instead of the name of treasury. This was duly replied by the
Petitioner on 23.06.2012.
27.
Moreover, Bihar Treasury Code Sub Section II for place of payment
of pension in Clause 203 (adopted by the Government of Jharkhand)
provides for service pension payable in India, may be drawn from any
treasury/public sector Bank in India. The Petitioner thus reiterated the relief
as stated in the Petition.
28.
The Additional Affidavit wasp submitted on behalf of the
Department of Law, Government of Jharkhand. It was clarified that the
Petitioner had to present himself physically for proper identification for
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
receiving the pension for the first time in terms of Section 345 (1) of the
Treasury Code. The Treasury Officer has already, vide Letter dated
31.08.2012 communicated that the entire calculation has been done by the
Treasury and the amount shall be released once comparison of signature is
made.
29.
Furthermore, the perusal of the Petitioner’s Application for
computation, would show that he had not stated the percentage of pension to
be commuted. Moreover, the date, which is mandatory, was also missing
from the Application. The objections were taken in this regard. As per
Section 250, Jharkhand Pension Rules, the Petitioner had to present himself
before the Medical Board and after which, the commutation of the pension
could be done.
30.
Neither the Land Secretary nor Resident Commissioner, has the
Authority to waive the compliance of Section of 345 of the Treasury Code
and Section 205 of the Pension Rules. Furthermore, the commutation of
pension is a matter between the Petitioner and the Accountant General and
the answering Respondents do not have any authority in this regard. The rest
of the averments as contained in the Affidavit, were reiterated.
31.
Written Submissions were filed on behalf of the Petitioner.
32.
The Plaintiff in her Written Submissions, has clearly flagged two
aspects on which, he is seeking a relief. The first is in regard to the payment
of interest on the delayed release of his pension, gratuity and terminal
benefits. The second is that his 15 years of computed pension has ended and
that his regular pension may be restored, in accordance with rules.
I. Payment of Interest on Delayed release of Pension:
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
33.
The first aspect is whether the Plaintiff is entitled to grant of interest
for the delay in releasing his benefits.
34.
This aspect had been considered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in the Case of Prem Kumar vs. Indian Road Constructions Committee
and Anr., (2007) 98 DRJ 546 and Roshan Lal and Ors. vs. DTC, (2007) 140
DLT 49, held that whenever an amount is illegally withheld by a party,
interest is payable thereon, to the other side, on the simple logic that the
person is entitled to receive the said amount of which he has been
wrongfully deprived, to his detriment. In case of such wrongful withholding
of money, the party must be restituted by payment of interest on the
principal sum, due and payable
35.
Likewise, Apex Court in the case of Uma Agrawal (Dr) vs. State of
U.P., (1999) 3 SCC 438, observed that:
“The grant of pension is not a bounty, but the right of the retired
Government employee and delay in settlement of retiral benefits is
frustrating and must be avoided, at all cost. It was further observed in that
case that the Petitioner retired on 30.04.1993, though the arrears were
released only after Interim Order was passed by Supreme Court on
12.02.1996, in the Writ Petition. Respondents woke up only then and started
sending messages to various places, where the Petitioner had worked. Such
an exercise should have been started two years before the retirement=
36.
Similarly, in the case of State of Kerala vs. M. Padmanabhan Nair,
(1985) 1 SCC 429, Supreme Court granted interest @ 6% per annum on the
pension and gratuity due to the Respondent by observing that:
<…duty was cast on the District Treasury Officer to
grant every retiring Government employee, Last Pay
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
Certificate, which had been delayed by the concerned
Officer, for which there was no justification of
explanation.=
37.
In the present case, it is not denied that the petitioner retired on
31.3.2009 and his retiral benefits should have been released within three
months i.e. by 30.06.2009. Article 65(5)(a) states that where a Government
servant retires on superannuation, interest shall be paid from the date
following the date of expiry of a period of three months from the date of
retirement upto the date of payment of arrears of pension or gratuity or both.
38.
The Petitioner was granted Promotion under scheme of ACP from
26.6.2007. The retiral dues, namely GPF in September, 2009, leave
encashment in October, 2009, and GIS along with arrears of salary in
December, 2009. There had been a delay in release of pension and other
terminal benefits by six to nine months.
39.
Though, the Respondent had tried to explain the same by claiming
procedural challenges, but this can be no reason or explanation for delay
especially when it comes to pensionary and retirement benefits. It was for
the Respondents to have initiated the process for calculation of pension and
other benefits, at least three months in advance of the date of retirement of a
person.
40.
It cannot be over-emphasized that the pension and other benefits, is a
lifeline for the survival of the person, who retires from the service.
Moreover, delay in release of terminal benefits is deprivation of the right of
life and liberty as enshrined in Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India.
The Petitioner is, therefore, had entitled to interest on the delayed
payments, beyond 30.06.2009 till the date of payment.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
41.
The last question for consideration is the rate at which interest be
granted to the Petitioner.
42.
Article 65(1) of the Central Service (Pension) Rules, 2021, provides
for interest on delayed payment of gratuity, pension and family pension. It
provides that in case, family pension, provisional gratuity are delayed
beyond the date when its payment becomes due and the delay is attributable
to the administrative reasons or lapses, interest shall be paid as applicable to
General Provident Fund amount, in accordance with the instructions issued
from time to time.
43.
Further, Article 65(5)(a) states that where a Government servant
retires on superannuation, interest shall be paid from the date following the
date of expiry of a period of three months from the date of retirement upto
the date of payment of arrears of pension or gratuity or both.
44.
From these Rules, it is evident that any delay beyond the period of
three months in payment of pension, gratuity or arrears of pension, the
interest as may be notified, is payable.
45.
The GPF Rate of Interest since 2008 till 2023 has varied between
8.8% to 7.1%. Thus, on an average, the rate of interest which would be
equitable, is calculated @8% p.a. simple interest, which is hereby,
awarded to the Petitioner.
II. Grant of Regular pension on expiry of period of Commuted Pension
in 2024:
46.
The second relief, which the Plaintiff/Petitioner has sought, is that he
had commuted his pension at the time of retirement, which has got over on
31.03.2024 and he has now become entitled to full pension. The directions
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
may be given to the Respondents, to promptly process his case and restore
his full pension.
47.
It is pertinent to observe that the Petition got filed in 2011 wherein the
prayer was for arrears on delayed payments. The commuting of his pension,
had got over during the pendency of the present Petition on 31.03.2024. In
order to get the same restored, the Petitioner is required to move an
application and follow the procedure thereof. There can be no directions
given in this Petition. However, in case, the Application has been filed or is
filed by the Petitioner, for complete pension, the same may be process
expeditiously and preferably within three months from the filing of the
Application or from the date of this Order, as the case may be.
Conclusion:
48.
The petition is partly allowed and the respondents are directed that the
said calculation be made of interest @ 8% for the delayed period in release
of the pension, and the amount be released to the Petitioner, within eight
weeks. Writ Petition is disposed of accordingly. Pending applications, if
any, also stand disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
APRIL 21st, 2026/RS
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
16:37:28
W.P.(C) 7421/2011
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review