Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision : 21.01.2026
W.P.(C) 16917/2025 & CM APPL. 69553/2025
GAJE SINGH
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Ankur Chhibber and Mr. Arjun
Panwar, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mrs. Anubha Bhardwaj, CGSC with
Ms. Neha Mishra, GP with Ms.
Ananya Shamshery and Mr. Vijay
Misra, Advs
Mr. Vinod Sawant, Law Officer, Mr.
Ajay Pal, A/C Law and Insp. Athurv,
CRPF
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J. (ORAL)
1.
The present petition has been filed for seeking quashing of medical
reports of the Detailed Medical Examination dated 22.10.2025 and the
Review Medical Examination dated 24.10.2025, which was carried out as
part of the Limited Departmental Competitive Examination 2024 and 2025
[‘L.D.C.E. 2024-2025’] for appointment to the post of Assistant
Commandant (General Duty) whereby the Petitioner has been declared as
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
16:12:49
W.P.(C) 16917/2025
medically unfit by the Respondents on the sole ground of Iris pigmentation
in capsule of lens in right eye.
1.1.
The Petitioner also seeks leave to appear for a fresh medical
examination before an independent board in consonance with the Detailed
Medical Guidelines vide OM dated 20.05.2015 read with guidelines for
Review Medical Board as provided under OM dated 31.05.2021 and if
found fit, then his candidature should be restored for further consideration
for promotion to the post of Assistant Commandant against the vacancies
notified in that regard.
2.
The case set up by the learned counsel for the Petitioner in the petition
is as follows:
2.1
Petitioner was recruited on 23.04.2018 is serving personnel of the
Sashastra Seema Bal [‘SSB’] currently at the rank of Sub-Inspector (general
duty). He was posted to Sector Headquarter, SSB, Gangtok w.e.f.
05.07.2024, where he remains posted till date.
2.2
In February 2025, Respondents issued a Notification for filing up
vacancies in the post of Assistant Commandant (General Duty) in Border
Security Force [‘BSF’], Central Reserve Police Force [‘CRPF’], IndoTibetan Border Police Force [‘ITBP’] and SSB by way of the L.D.C.E.
2024-2025. The L.D.C.E. 2024-2025 consists of 5 stages which is
mentioned at paragraph ‘5’ of the petition.
2.3
Petitioner being eligible for the said examination, applied for
candidature, and was duly accepted and he was issued with an admit card
and assigned the Roll No. 22320226.
2.4
Petitioner appeared for the written examination and vide results dated
18.09.2025 the Petitioner was declared as passed. Subsequently, Petitioner
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
16:12:49
W.P.(C) 16917/2025
appeared for Physical Standard Test [‘PST’] and Physical Eligibility Test
[‘PET’] wherein again he had passed. He also appeared for interview which
was conducted on 15.09.2025.
2.5
In the next stage, that is the Detailed Medical Examination [‘DME’]
held at Referral Hospital, ITBP, Greater Noida on 21.10.2025 Petitioner was
rejected on two grounds, (i) Surgical Scar left inguinal region (left
Varicocele operated) and (ii) cluster of cells in anterior capsule of the lens of
the right eye.
Thereafter, Petitioner applied for a Review Medical Examination
[‘RME’] which was conducted on 23.10.2025 wherein the Petitioner was
again held as unfit on the ‘sole’ ground of Iris pigment present over lens
capsule in the right eye but vision is 6/6 in the right eye.
Hence, on account of being declared unfit in the RME, Petitioner was
disqualified from LDCE 2024-2025.
2.6
Aggrieved by the aforementioned medical reports, Petitioner
underwent detailed eye tests in Dr. Rajendra Prasad Eye Centre, AIIMS
wherein vide medical report dated 25.10.2025, the Senior Resident Doctor
opined that Iris pigments are an incidental finding, without any pathology in
right eye. If further recorded that the Petitioner was fit for duty in CAPFs.
2.7
It is stated that Petitioner again got his eyes medically examined in
Central Referral Hospital, Sikkim Manipal University, wherein a detailed
examination of different parts of eye such as cornea, retina, pupil, lens,
conjunctive, lids and fundus was conducted and the results vide medical
report dated 28.10.2025 was that all of such parts were found to be perfectly
normal.
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
16:12:49
W.P.(C) 16917/2025
2.8
It is stated that the conduct of medical examination, is governed by
the MHAs OM dated 20.05.2014 and whereas the RME does not state the
relevant provision under which the Petitioner has been held as unfit, upon an
independent inquiry, the Petitioner believes that the provision relevant to the
subject of Iris pigmentation, is paragraph 62 of the MHAs OM dated
20.05.2014, which reads us under:
"62. Ophthalmoscopic Examination: Ophthalmoscopic examination is carried
out to exclude any abnormality in the fundi and media. Examination must be
carried out in a systematic manner starting from the cornea, anterior chamber,
pupil, iris, lens, posterior chamber and retina. Note will be taken of reaction
of the pupil to the light, abnormality of the papillary edge, any evidence of
inflammation of the iris and lenticular opacity. Vitreous floaters are usually
of no significance. Any abnormal vascular pattern, muscular scarring,
haemorrhages or exudates in the fundi will be noted. The normality of the
disc and the vascular pattern in the disc and its edges, AV ratio, papillary
oedema or color change in and around the disc and pigmentary changes
elsewhere provide valuable clues to various systemic diseases and must be
carefully noted. Indirect ophthalmoscopy is indicated at the discretion of the
ophthalmologist and must be carried out when there is a concern about the
health of the peripheral retina. Recruits will not be examined by
ophthalmoscopy at the initial examination. They will undergo this procedure
only upon appeal and if the ophthalmologist feels it is necessary.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
2.9
It is contended; however, perusal of the above-mentioned paragraph
62 would show that Iris pigment over lens capsule [RE] per se is not a
disqualification.
2.10 It is contended that Petitioner is currently serving at SSB and has a
Shape-I medical fitness certificate as per the last review and, therefore, his
disqualification on the grounds mentioned in the RME are untenable.
2.11 Learned counsel for the Petitioner states that, though the ground of
Surgical Scar left inguinal region (left Varicocele operated) was raised in the
DME report dated 22.10.2025, this was not the ground cited for unfitness in
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
16:12:49
W.P.(C) 16917/2025
the RME report dated 24.10.2025. The RME report only sites, unfit d/t Iris
pigment present over lens capsule [RE] as the ‘sole’ ground for marking the
Petitioner unfit and no other reasoning for the ground for unfitness for
Surgical Scar left inguinal region (left Varicocele operated) was pressed by
the Respondents in the RME report dated 24.10.2025. Therefore, the ground
of post operation surgical scar did not survive for consideration.
3.
In reply, learned counsel for the Respondents relies upon the stand
taken in the counter affidavit, and more specifically, paragraph 10 of its
reply on merits, which reads as under:
“In reply to the Para No. 10 (a) and (b) of the Petition, it is submitted that the
contention of the Para is not true and disagreed. The Detailed Medical
Examination has been carried out as per MHA UO No. A. VI-1/2014-Rectt
(SSB) dated 20.05.2015. There is no misinterpretation of relevant provisions
of MHA guidelines supra. As per Para-62 of MHA guidelines dated
20.05.2015, the Opthalmoscopic examination was done to exclude any
abnormality in the eyes and its different parts. Examination was carried out in
a
systematic
manner
starting
from
the
cornea
anterior
chamber/pupil/iris/lenses/posterior chamber and retina. Reaction of the pupil
to the light also examined by the torch/slit lamp an retina and vitreous was
examined by 90 D lens, by DME Board during the examination it is found
that lens of his right eye which is his dominant eye was having extensive
clusters of iris pigments cells on anterior capsule of lens, which is usually
found as an evidence of inflammation of the iris (an sign of inflammation of
iris provide valuable clues to various systemic and eye diseases mostly found
in chronic uveitis of eyes) clusters of pigment cells on lens may also progress
in future and may cause lenticular opacity, glaucoma in future. Hence,
further exists examination was not required at the stage of DME in ibid Para
of Guidelines. It is also mentioned that recruits will not be examined by
Ophthalmoscopy at the initial examination. They will undergo this procedure
only upon appeal and if the ophthalmologist feels it is necessary. Further. the
Review Medical Examination Board convened at Referral Hospital, ITBP,
Gr. Noida on 23.12.2025- 24.10.2025 was duly conducted strictly in
accordance to the prescribed norms and included Specialists from the
relevant clinical disciplines. Accordingly, the requirement for referring the
Petitioner to any external Specialist under judicial directions does not arise.
The Board was fully competent to evaluate the Petitioner for both the surgical
and ophthalmic conditions strictly in accordance with the medical standards
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
16:12:49
W.P.(C) 16917/2025
and procedures laid down in the Guidelines issued vide MHA UO No. A. VI1/2014-Rectt (SSB) dated 20.05.2015.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
4.
She contends that, though it is correct, that the Petitioner’s right eye
currently does not suffer from any disability, however, it is possible that in
future, the cluster of pigment cells on the anterior capsule of the right-eye
lens has the potential to progress to lenticular opacity or glaucoma; and this
is a significant finding of RME report.
5.
This Court has considered the submissions of the parties.
6.
The RME report dated 24.10.2025 records that Petitioner’s vision in
the right eye is 6/6. The report records “Unfit d/t Iris pigment present over
lens capsule [RE]”. On this sole ground, the Petitioner has been declared
unfit in the medical examination. The Respondents have sought to justify the
said ground of disqualification by relying upon the submissions, set out at
paragraph 10 of the counter affidavit, which has been extracted hereinabove
at paragraph ‘3’.
7.
Perusal of the said paragraph 10 of the counter affidavit shows that
Respondents apprehend that the said condition may progress in future and
may cause lenticular opacity, glaucoma in future.
8.
The Petitioner has placed on record the medical report dated
25.10.20251 obtained by it from AIIMS, New Delhi which after taking note
of the Iris pigment states that it is an incidental finding and there is no
pathology in the right eye and the Petitioner is fit for duty in CAPFs. The
Respondent in its counter affidavit has responded2 to the said report by
Filed as annexure P-7 and pleaded at paragraph 13 of the writ.
Page 10 of the counter affidavit.
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
16:12:49
W.P.(C) 16917/2025
stating that the said report is an assessment of the present [medical]
condition of the Petitioner and it does not opine on whether this condition
can progress in future or not.
9.
Having perused the Respondent’s response in the counter affidavit at
paragraph nos. 10 and 13, it is evident that the Petitioner has been declared
unfit by the RME on the finding that in future the Iris pigment present over
the lens capsule [RE] may progress causing lenticular opacity, glaucoma in
future. However, the medical report dated 25.10.2025 issued by AIIMS,
Delhi has opined that there is no pathology in the Petitioner’s right eye and
has noted that the Iris pigments is an incidental finding. In these facts, it is
apparent that the Petitioner currently does not suffer from any disability in
his right eye and the Petitioner has been disqualified from participating in
LDCE on an apprehension that the disability may occur in future. The RME
itself does not record this possibility of disability occurring in the future and
therefore it also does not opine whether any such disability if it occurs in the
future would be capable of surgical correction or not.
10.
The impugned RME itself however, records that the Petitioner’s
vision in right eye is 6/6 presently and this is not disputed in the counter
affidavit. The Petitioner has also contended that he has been evaluated in
SHAPE 1 medical fitness in his last annual review, and is currently serving
the force on the post of Sub-inspector (General Duty). These facts raise a
presumption of current medical fitness in favour of the Petitioner. The
rejection of the Petitioner on the possibility of occurrence of a future
disability, which may or may not occur appears to be harsh as the RME also
does not opine on the effect of this disability on the discharge of the duties
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
16:12:49
W.P.(C) 16917/2025
of the Petitioner and whether such a disability is capable or incapable of
cure.
11.
In these peculiar facts, this Court is of the considered opinion that it
would be appropriate if the Petitioner’s prayer seeking fresh medical
examination before an independent Medical Board in terms of para (ii) of
the writ petition is allowed. It is ordered accordingly. The Medical Board is
directed to conduct a medical examination and record its findings keeping in
view the observations made in the preceding paragraph.
12.
It is further directed that if found fit, then Petitioner’s candidature
should be restored for further consideration for promotion to the post of
Assistant Commandant against the vacancies notified in that regard.
13.
The interim order dated 07.11.2025, directing the Respondents to
keep one post of Assistant Commandant vacant, shall continue to operate
until the final decision of the fresh medical examination by the Review
Medical Board is taken.
14.
In the DME report, another ground has been recorded, i.e. Surgical
scar on the left inguinal region (left Varicocele operated). The said reason
was however not cited in the RME and has not been pressed upon by the
Respondents as a ground for unfitness during arguments.
15.
With the aforesaid directions, the present petition stands allowed.
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
JANUARY 21, 2026/IB
Digitally Signed
By:MAHIMA SHARMA
16:12:49
W.P.(C) 16917/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review