Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
t 3300I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF AUGUST
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO : 37499 OF 2025
Between:
Gade Laxman, son of Gade Venkat, aged about 44 yearc, Occupation. Private
Employee, resident of 2-56133115, Khanamet Village, Hyderabad-500081.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. Telangana lndustrial lnfrastructure Corpo-Ration (TGllC),, represented by its
Vice Chairman and Managing Director, office at 6th Floor, Parisrama Bhavan,
Fateh Maidan Road, Basheerbagh
2. The Deputy lnspector of Survey (Head Quarter), Survey Settlements and
Land Records (SS and LR), Ranga Reddy District
3. The Assistant Director, Survey Settlements and Land Records (SS and LR),
Ranga Reddy District.
4. The Regional Deputy Director, Survey Settlements and Land Records (SS
and LR), having its office at having its office at Survey Bhavan, Narayanguda,
Hyderabad.
5. The Joint Director, Survey Settlements and Land Records (SS and LR),
having its office at Survey Bhavan, Narayanguda, Hyderabad.
6. The Survey Settlements and Land Records (SS and LR), represented by its
Commissioner.
7. The District Collector, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana State
8. The District Collector, Medchal-Malkajgiri District, Telangana State
9. State of Telangana, represented by its Prl. Secretary, Revenue Department,
Secretariat, Telangana.
'10. M/s. Rajeswari Farms and Estates PW. LTD., represented by D. Suresh
Babu, having office at Plot No. 29, Co-Op Housing Society, Jubilee Hills
Hyderabad, Telangana-500022.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Unde. Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to grant a Writ, Order or Direction, more particularly one i1 the nature of Writ of
I\ilandamus, lvlandamus, (a) declaring the action of the Respondents in trying to
interfere with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the Petitioner in respect of
Plot No. 435, admeasuring 500.00 Sq. yards, forming part of land admeasuring
Acres 70-00 Guntas, in Survey No.1 007, situated at Kukatpally Revenue Village,
Kukatpally Mandal, Medchal-Malkajgiri District under the garb of conducting a
purported survey vide notrce bearing Rc. No. 441233912024, dated 28.11.2025
(received on 04.12.2025) as illegal, arbitrary, without jurisdiction, violative of the
principles of natural justice, null and void, non-est in the eye of law, and violative of
the orders passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of lndia in Contempt Petition (Civil)
No. 433 of 2020 in Civil Appeal No. 10128 of 2018, as well as the orders passed by
this Hon'ble Court in W P. Nos. 23164 of 2021 and 22575 ol 2021 , and Articles 14,
'19, 21 and 300-A of the Constitution of lndia and consequently restrain the
Respondents from interfering with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the
Petitioner in respect of Plot No. 435, admeasuring 500.00 Sq. yards, forming part of
land admeasuring Acres 70-00 Guntas, in Survey No.1007, situated at Kukatpally
Revenue Village, Kukatpally I\,4andal, Medchal-lVlalkajgiri District (b) to set aside the
impugned notice bearing Rc. No. A41233912024 dated 28.'l 1 .2025 (received on
04.12.2025) issued by Respondent No. 2 and all further action taken in pursuance
thereof and consequently Respondents be restrained from taking any action of
conducting survey or fixing boundaries in relation to the lands in Survey No, '1007 of
Kukatpally Revenue Village. Kukatpally lVandal, Medchal-Malkajgiri District in any
manner whatsoever including but not limited to by placing reliance or considerrng the
proceedings bearing No. A5168212010 dated 07-02-2014117.02-2014 (along with
sketch issued by the Joint Committee) of the Respondent Nos. 4 and 5 (c) Declaring
the action of the Respondents in relying upon the proceedings bearing No.
A5168212010 dated 07.02.2014117.02.2014, which were issued without any notice to
the Petitioner and in violation of law, to benefit the unofficial Respondent with an
intention to crassify the private lands situated in survey No, 1007
of Kukatpally
Vi'age and [/andar, Medchar-Markajgiri District, as rands
failing under survey No, 4,
:i, B,9,41/9,41/10.41,,11 86 41112
of Khanamet
Village, Serilingampally Mandal,
Il R District as iregal, arbitrary, without jurisdiction,
viorative of the principres
of
natural justice, null and void, non-est in the eye of law, and violative of the orders
passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of lndia in Contempt Petition (Civil) No. 433 of
2O2O in Civil Appeal No. 10'128 ol 2018 and Articles 14. 19,21 and 300-A of the
constitution of lndia and consequently set aside the proceedings bearing No.
A5t682t2O1O dated o7-02-2014t17-02-2014 (along with sketch issued by the Joint
Committee) of the Respondent Nos, 4 and 5.
t.A.No.1 0F 2025
Petition Under section '1 51 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to direct
the Respondents to not interfere in any manner whatsoever in the peaceful
possession and enjoyment of the Petitioner in respect of all that Plot No 435'
admeasuring 500.00 Sq. yards, forming part of land admeasuring Acres 70-00
Guntas, in Survey No.'1007, situated at Kukatpally Revenue Village, Kukatpally
Mandal, Medchal-Malkajgiri District during the subsistence of the status Quo orders
passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of lndia in Contempt Petition (Civil) No. 433 of
2020 in Civil Appeal No. 10128 of 2018.
l.A. NO: 2OF 2025
Petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to restrain
Respondents from conducting any survey, demarcation, or fixation of boundaries in
respect of the lands situated in Survey No. 1007 Kukatpally Revenue Village,
Kukatpally Mandal, Medchal-Malkajgiri District in view of the order of suspension
passed by this Hon'ble Court in W.P. Nos. 23164 of 2021 and 22575 of 2021
suspending the proceedings bearing No. A5/682/2010 dated 07-02-20141 17-022014 (along with sketch issued by the Joint Committee) of the Respondent Nos 4
and 5.
LA.NO:3 OF 2025
Petition Under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to
stay/suspend the impugned survey notice bearing Rc. No. 4412339/2024, dated.
28.11.2025 (received on 04.12.202) issued by the Respondents along with all further
action taken by the Respondents in pursuance of the said notice.
Counsel for the Petitioners : SRI DHARMESH D.K.JAISWAL
Counsel forthe Respondent Nos.1 to 9 : SRI P.SREEDHAR REDDY, SpL G.p
ON BEHALF OF ADVOCATE GENERAL
Counsel for the Respondent No.10 : SRI P.SRI RAGHU RAM
The Court made the following ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO. 37499 0F 2025
L3.OA.2026
Between:
Gade Laxman
Petitioner
And
Telangana Industrial Infrastructure Corporation (TGIIC),
Rep by its Vice-Chairman and Managing Director
& others
Respondents
ORDER:
Petitioner claims to be the absolute owner and
possessor of PIot No. 435, admeasuring 500.00 square yards,
forrning part of the land admeasuring Acs. 70 O0 guntas in
Survey No. 1OO7 of Kukatpally RevenLre Village, having
purchased the same through registered Sale Deed dated
25.07.2011. The plot forms part of the layout of Bharyanagar
Co-operative Housing Society Limited and petitioner ancl other
plot holders have been in settled and peaceful possession and
enjoyment for several decades
1.1.
It is the case of petitioner that the 3'd respondent
- Assistant Director, Survey Settlements and Land Records had
earlier conducl.ed a survcy and prepared a ground sketch uide
tile No. A3/ 1185/2005, rlated 15 02.2005, submitted to the
Colle<:tor. Rirnga Reddr- District ujde Ietter dated
thcreirfter, a second survev ulde file No. A 1
16.02.2O05;
l223g l2OOg.ln both
the sun'c-r-s. it u'as categoncallv concluded that there \l.as
ove
no
rlap ltetu ecn Kukatpalll. and Khanamet Villages and
boundarv stones $'cre fixed on the ground in the presence of
the
Mandal Sun'cr.ors ol Balanagar and Serilin gampally, the Village
Secretarir-'s ol both villages and the residents of parvath Nagar.
It is contcndr:d, those surveys, having been conducted on [he
ground and n,:vcr cluestioned, hold the field.
]r2.
It is also contended, under a prlrport(,cl proceedings
bearing No. 45i682/2010 dated 07.O2.2O14/17.O2.2Ot4, a
Joint Committee comprising the Joint Director anrl the Regional
Deput). llirector, Surr.ev Settlements and Land Records,
conclucted an alleqed sun e_v from the side of Khanamet Village
and rccordcd a fincring rhat parr of Survel Nos. 1OO3 to 1007 of
Kukarpallv Villagc overlaps Survey Nos. 4, 5, g, 9, 4l
41 / l)
lg, 4l /lO,
and .4 I7 l2 ol Khanamct Village. According to petitioner,
thts sun cr' \\:,r.s a paper exercise carriecl out without any
inspcction on thc gr-ound. behind his back and tlle other plot
holders. s ithoutr noticc to them, therefore, it is non est in the
e,ye of lau'.
1.3
P('ritioner sl.rted
on lt inr ,rr lllr,,gr,rndUar.
that firstly, no notice
L,,, operatire
was served
Housing Society
Limited,
who are the persons in possession; secondly, the proceedings
are contrary to the earlier surveys of 2005 and 2008 which
confirmed that there was no overlap; thirdly, the impugned
survey was prepared relying upon the records of Khanamet
Village, which is a non Diwani village whose village map was
prepared in or about 1950 and whose traverse was conducted at
a later date but never incorporated in its village map, whereas
Kukatpally Village is a Diwani (Khalsa) village which was
surveyed first and whose traverse boundary and traverse
stations stand incorporated in its village map of 1918, so that
the survey and settlement records of Diwani village must
prevail; fourthly, Survey and Settlement authorities themselves
had found that traverse boundary of Khanamet is defectively
prepared and is not tallying with the traverse of Kukatpally
Village, which alone has resulted in the so-called overlap, and
that on the correct combined plotting of the traverse data, there
is, in truth, no overlap between the two villages.
.4.
Petitioner has relied upon the order dated
19.O8.2O2O of the Hon'ble Supreme Court irr Contempt Petition
(Civil) No. 433 of 2O2O in Civil Appeal No. 10128 ot 2018,
wherein all the parties were directed to maintain sratus qLo as
to possession and not to create any third party interest in
respect of the lands, and the order dated 23.09.2021 of this
+
Court rn Writ Petirion No. 23164 of 2021-, whereby the very
07.O2.2014 l17.O2.2O1,4 \!'ere suspended, wrth a further
direction to rcspondcnt aull-rorities no1 to int(rrfere "t'ith the
possessior.r of petitioner therein. Petitioner states that despite
thc s:rid proceedLngs of 2014 haring been suspended,
responclents arc no\l . br,'the impugned notice dated 28.11 2025,
onc:r: again seeking lo conduct a sun'ev on the ver]' samc
o,,,erlap prcmisc, u hich amounts to overreaching the orders of
the Hon'blc Suprcme Court and of this Court.
1.5.
Frnalh , pe titioner contends thal Respondent No 2 -
r-he Dt'putv lnspccLor rtf Survev (Head Quarter) has no
lurisdiction to cotrducl a fresh survev in respect of the very
lands lor u.h:c}'r sun'e1' slood concludecl in 2OO5 and 2008 as
afores:ric1, zrncl u,hrch thc superior officers (respondent Nos.4
anrl 5) h:rve :rlre:tdr. though r"'rongll', treaLcd as overlapping
through the in-rpugncd 201'1 proceedings, and the impugned
notice is, in an'n event, \\rithout jurisdiction, arbitrary and
violativc ol Arlrcles 11.19.2i and 300-A of the Constitution.
2.
This Cotrrt b_v- order dated 05.12 2025 granted
ir.ttt rim st:r\' ,f impLrqned notice dated 28.11.2()25 insofar as
Su] r.c--r. Nos J I r 9 anri .1 j / l2 of Khanamet Village
ord.r pirsst.d t,r,this Courr in
and since the
Writ petition No, 23,] 64
of 2021 is
subsisting, the respondent - authorities are directed not to
conduct any survey in respect of Survey Nos. 41/9, 4l/12 of
Khanamet Village.
3.
Respondent No. I - TGIIC hled counter stating that
they hled requisition for acquisition of Government land
measuring Acs.2O4-24 Gts. in Survey No. 41/ I of Khanamet
Village of Serilingampally Mandal, Ranga Reddy District for
establishment of Hyderabad Internatronal Exhibition and
Convention (HIECON) Centre. The Revenue Authoritics have
handed over advance possession lo an extent of Acs.75-00 of
land in the said survey number on 12.71.7997. On measuring
the land physically, lhe available land was only Acs.6B-00 as
per the boundaries shown by the Revenue Department. In
compliance with the orders of the Government, the District
Collector, Ranga Reddy District, resumed Acs.4-20 gts. from the
lands handed over to TGIIC and handed over to the NIA. The
Principal Secretary to the Government, Revenue Department
has resumed the Government Iand admeasuring Acs.63 20 gts.
and Acs.62-24 gts. situated in Survey No.4 1 / 14 of Khanamet
Village from TSIIC (now TGIIC) and HMDA for vrolation of
allotment condition uide Memo dated 23.04.2016 and Memo
dated 23.O4.2016 respectively. Respondent No. 1, it is
stated, 1s no1 in possession of the land in Survey No'41/ 14,
Kh:rnamct Vrl iage.
Responrlent No. 7
4.
District Collector, Ranga
Recicly Districr filecl i:ounler stating that pursuan t to the notice
dared 28. tl.2025, in compliance u'ith the comm()n order dated
and
19. I 1.2025 irr Writ Petitions No 32594 ancl 326O4 of 2025
thc interim or-der daleci O).12 2025 passed in the presenl u'rit
petition. thc Lands in Survey Nos 4, 5' 8' 9' 10' 41110 and
,i 1 ,, I I ol Khanamct Village r', ere survel ed and the boundaries
lixed on Ob 1.1.2O25 undcr a panchanama' the lelnds in Survey-
to thc
Nos. 4119 and 41/12 having been left out in dt:ference
rnterim ordel It is asserted that survey was conltned to
Khanamet village and it u'as not extendecl to Survey No 1007 of
Kukatpzrlh' Vrilage ' r'r I'rich lies u'ithin a different Mandal and
Distnct over t hich this respondent has no jurisdi':tion' and that
consequentlv no occilsion arose lo put petitioner on notice
.:l
.1.
It is lurther crontended that no reliance u'hatsoever
is placcd upon. nor is any reference made to the suspended
lrroc't:erLinqs bt-aring
No.
AS l682 l20lO
dated
A7.O2.2O11i 17 .O2.2O14 lor the conduct of the survey; survey
'..as
raken up onlr a r rhe insrance of Respondent No.
prrrsLrant lo [he orders oi
I0 and
this Court in Writ petitton Nos.
and ) t (, o1. -t025 trncj Wrrt petitions
4g2
No. 32594 and 32604
of
2025, and that the order of status quo of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court operates only inter se the private parties to the suits and
does not bind the survey authorities from demarcating the
Khanamet lands. It is also stated that petitioner, who claims
only 5OO square yards, cannol stall the survey of a larger extent
and that the other pattadars have never objected.
5.
A separate counter-affidavit was filed by
Respondent No. 10 - M/s Rajeswari Farms and Eslates Private
Limited averring that Respondent No. 10 and others are the
absolute owners ofAcs.26.14 guntas in Survey Nos.4,5,8,9,
10 and 4119, 4IllO, 41,/11 and 41/\2 of Khanamet Village,
having purchased the same under registered sale deeds and
being in possession since 1995; the survey was sought only in
respect of their rightfully owned land in Khanamet Village and
not in Kukatpally Village. It is contended, petitioner himself
asserts that there is no overlap and that being so, he cannot
obstruct the survey of Khanamel lands. It is further contended
that petitioner is concerned only with his 5OO square yards and
not with the larger extents in Survey Nos. 1003 to 1007, and
thar, not having been made a party to Writ Petition No. 23 164 of
202 1, Respondent No. 10 is not bound by the orders passed
therein.
6.
In the repll' filed by petitioner to the counter o[
Rcspondent \o. 7. ir is stated that the assertion that survey
il'a s cor rfincd to Kl'ranamet survev numbers is a tnere plav upon
labcls. for tl'te ven prcmise on r.l'hich Khanamet boundaries
u'erc frxecl orL 06. I 2.202a is the overlap theory propounded in
lhe procecdir-Lgs of 20 14 and the necessary ':ffect of fixing
Khanantet bouttdaries upon lhat premise is to treat a part of the
Iand in Survr:1' No. I OO7 of Kukatpally Village ers belongtng to
Khanamet, :herebl rndirectll' diminishing the extent ol
petilioner's land. It rs pointed out that on 04 )'2 2025, Lhe
officrals. in flact. t:ntered upon the land in Survey No 1007,
sen'ed the in:pugr-recl notice al the site, and operly stated that
surve\ \1'as tc resoh'e the overlapping showl-r in proceedirrgs No'
LS i 682 I 20 10. u'hich belies the plea of u'ant of
jr-rrisdiction over
Surr er No. 1C07.
6. L
P,:titioncr further stated that the distinction
f)et\\'ecn :r Di\\'ani Vrllage and a non-Di'"r'ani village is decisive;
the rccords of Kuka tpailv Village, being a I)iwani Village
sun'evecl llrst u'rth its trar,erse in(lorporated rn its village map,
rlr-Lsr prcvail ()\'Ier [h( clefectir,'e non-Dis'ani records of Khanamet
Vili:rge.
and the survcvs of 2OO5 and 2008, wtrich found no
ovcr iar p
:rnd pursuan r to u.hich bounda{ stones
rogcrhcr rr-ith suspension
were fixed,
of 2014 proceedrngs by tl.ris Court
and
the s/afus quo of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, conclusively
establish his case.
7.
Petitioner also filed reply to the counter affidavit of
Respondenl No. 10 pointing out lhat while Respondent No. 10
asserts ownership under registered sale deeds with its name
mutated in the revenue records, it has not set out the
particulars of any such deed nor produced the same. Bare
assertion of title in Khanamet Village does not meet and cannot
cure the specific and document based grounds urged in the Writ
Petition. Petitioner states that the contention that the survey
was conhned to Khanamet lands is demonstrably incorrect, for
the impugned notice issued at the instance of Respondent No.
10 is not a routine demarcation of undisputed Khanamet lands
but, on its own terms, summons the adjacent pattadars and
interested parties, including the representatives of Bhagvanagar
Co-operative Housing Society of Kukatpally Village, and is thus
a boundary fixation exercise directed at resolving the very
overlap affecting Survey No. 1007, in violation of the orders of
status quo.
7.1.
[t is also stated, RespondenL No. 10's assertion that
petitioner admits that there is no overlap is a misreading of his
case; petitioner's case being that there is no overlap on a correct
plotting of the traverse data and appearance of an overlap is the
i0
produci ol the defecrir,e Khanamet Lraverse. lt is further slated
thar non impk:zrdment of Respondent No. 10 in Writ Petition
No. 23 1 6.+ of 2021 cloes not exempt it from compliance r,r'ith the
ordcrs of status quo, more so ',vhen the impugaed notice was
issuecl r:pon its ou n application. Significantly, petitioner has
lairll' concedcd Lhat he clalms no right in thc lanrls of Khanamet
Villzigc. and :hat a sur\ ev strictly confined to Khranamet Village
conducled consisrentlv u'rth the correcL trav(lrse dala and
witholrt altering the boundaries of Kukatpally Village or
violating the crders ol the Courts, would not be impeded by him
ancl it rs rrnl', to the extent that the proposed survel' seeks to
disturb Sunev No. 1OO7 and to rest upon :he suspended
procecdings ol 201.1 that pelitioner is constrainr:d to approach
th is Court.
8.
Bv thc mcmo, petitioner has placed on record the
[ollou'rnq aclditronal documents in support of his case, namel1',
(i) panch:rna;la in fiLc No. A5/948O/2008 dated 31.05.2011
t'irh irs rran\l:ltion and neat copy; (ii) report cf the Regional
Dcputr Director, Survev and Land Records, Hyderabad, in Rc.
No. A5/()840i 2011 dated 04.O5.2O12, along with the
panchanama ir) r(.spect of the survev conducted in the year
2012-. trr-rci (iii) copr ot. Lhc ordcr dated 22.O2.2C22
this CoLrrt in \[ rjL pctiriorr
No. 30773 o{ 2O2L These
passed by
documents
II
bear directly upon the controversy and are adverted to in the
course of the consideration that follows.
9.
It is a significant feature of the record that no
reply of any nature has been filed by any of the respondents to
the said memo, nor has any dispute been raised before this
Court as to the genuineness, authenticity or contents of the
panchanama dated 31.05.201 1, report dated 04.05.20 l2 and
the panchanama of the survey of 2012, or the order dated
22.02.2022 in Writ Petition No. 30773 ol 2021. Even the
counter filed by Respondents 7 and 10 contain no specific
answer whatsoever to these surveys. The said documents,
emanating as they do from the ofhcial record of the Survey
Department itself, therefore stand wholly unrebutted, and this
Court proceeds upon them as such-
10.
Srr Dharmesh D.K. Jaiswal, learned counsel for
petitioner submits that on five separate occasions spread over
two decades, in 2005, 2OO8,2Oll,2072 and 2018, the Survey
Department went to the ground and found the boundary
between Kukatpally Village and Khanamet Village exactly where
it has always stood, with no overlap between the two villages.
The 2O05 exercise in lile No. A3/ i 185/2005, and the 20O8
exercise in lrle No. Al 1223812OO8, hxed the village boundary on
the ground in the presence of Mandal Surveyors of both
a
Baian:rgar and Scrilingampally, Village Secretaries ol both
vrllages arrcl the residcnts clf Parvath Nagar, and had any overlap
trtilv t'xistcd. the survelor present for Khanamet Village rvould
harve objecrecL thert and there, rvhich he did not. ln 20 1 1, under
file No. A5/9.180/2008, the stretch bet$'een traverse points 43
and 44 u'as demarcated using Electrontc Total Stations on
28.05.201i, :he points rvere agreed to bv both the parties, and
thc panchanama \\'as drau'n on 31.05.2011 In 2012, a lurther
sun'e\ covering Survel' No 1OO7 of Kukatpalty Village and
Sun,cr No. 11 ol Khanamer Village recorded that from
Kukatpalh,tr.rverse point 43 up to traverse point 35, Kukatpally
Village bounrlary and Khanamet Village map are tallying, and
Khanamct trurversc points do not tally even rvith rhe viliage map
ol Khanermet rtsclf. In 2018 in file No. A5/ 1a3/2018, lteld
verificatiorr ri ith tippon measurements found the iands in
Surr i:-r Nos. I OO3 ro 1 006 ol Kukatpalll Village correct to the
grouncl sith no ovcrlap. trach of thesc surveys has attained
[inalin, nont havitrq been questioned bl the State in the
rranncr knrtu Il trl iau
10.1.
.
It is also argued, as against the said five consistent
grolrnd sLln'er s. stands one solitary paper exercise, proceedings
bea ring
No. A.> i 682 i 20 1O dated
u hir:h.
\\'rrhorrt no1,ce to a single
07 02.20 1,+ / 17.02,2014,
pattadar or person
in
li
possession and without any site inspection, propounded an
overlap of Acs. 64.16 guntas. Those proceedings stand
suspended by this Court by orders dated 23.09.2021 in Writ
Petilion No. 23164 of 2O2L and in Writ Petition No. 22575 of
202 I, stand declared illegal, bad and against the principles of
natural justice by this Court by order dated 22.O2.2022 in Writ
Petition No. 30773 ol 2021, and stand disowned by rhe
Government itself in the counter filed in the present case.
1O.2.
According to learned counsel, the impugned notice
overreaches subsisting judicial orders. The Hon,ble Supreme
Court, by order dated 79 .O8.2O2O, bound all the parties to
status quo as to possession ol the land in Survey No. 1007 and
interdicted creation of third party interests, and directed the
title suits O.S. Nos. 898 to 90 1 of 2OO I to be decided. A survey
whose avowed object, as disclosed by the ofhcials on
04.12.2025, is to resolve the overlapping shown in the
suspended 2074 proceedings, so as to enable the l"r
respondent to auction lands by treating petitioner,s patta land
in Survey No. 1O07 of Kukatpally Village as land falling in
Survey No. 41 of Khanamet VilJage, is a direct alteration of the
status quo. What the respondents cannot do directly, namely act
upon the suspended proceedings, they cannot do indirectly
under the garb of a fresh survey to implement their conclusions.
il
10.3
Learncd counsel submits that, in truth' there is
no c>r'erlap on the ground; the alleged overlap is a paper artefact
olthc'trar,crscolKhanametVillage,whichthedepartment'sort'n
report clatcd 04.05.2012 certifies to be ciefectively prepared'
map' and
rr'hic:h does not Lallr'cvcn u'ilh Khanamet's on'n viJlage
s'hich the 20 14 proceedings themselves admit does not talll'
*'ith the vrllage boundarY- of Khanamet The remt:dy prescribed
bv that ven' report. namely that the Collector he;lr and
resolve
the boundary clrspule and send a proposal for correction
of the
traverse rc'corcls to the Commissioner' Survey Settlement
and
LandRecords.\[IaSncvercarriedoul,andthereisadmittedly,
a
no clecision of anr Collector to lhis day' A defect in
clepartmental record c:annot be permitted to swallolv
the patta
lands of cit tzetls,
10.1.
It is stLbmitted, the 2Ol4 exerclse I'as a
precir'fcrmined di:sk c'xercise Both the report datt:d
04 05 2Ol2
ancl thc proceeclings ol 2Ol4 emanate from t]re very
olliccr. the lhcn Reqional Deputv Direclor' Survey and Land
same
Records. Hvdt rabacl. In 201I and 2Ol2 that officer
personally
vtsitcd tl,re sitc. conducted surve,vs u'ith EIe clronic Total
St.rli()ns in tl.c prcse nce of panchas and found no ovellap,
qtra.rifYi'rg th. cliscordance thrown up bv the defective traverse
ar Ar.s. .ji3.OO gunras. In 2014, without anv fresh
lleld exercise.
t5
without site inspection and without notice, the aileged overlap
was inflated lo Acs. 64.16 gts., and no explanation whatsoever
is forthcoming as to how lhe extent nearly doubled between
2Ol2 and 2074 al the hands o[ [he same officer on the same
record.
10.5
Learned counsel for petitioner also submils
that respondents' own stand and conduct destroy the defence.
The Government has, in paragraph 5 of the counter of
Respondent No. 7, categorically disclaimed reliance upon the
2014 proceedings, yet defends a notice which exists only to
resolve the overlap shown in those very proceedings.
Respondents have, further, withheld the survey map relating to
the survey of 06.12.2025 despite specific directions of this
Court, inviting the adverse inference recognised in the decision
of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Gopal KrlshnaJi Ketkar u,
Mohamed Haji Latif . The counters are, moreover, wholly
silent about the surveys of 2O1l and 2Ol2 and about the fact
thal 2014 survey itself was conducted at the behcst of
interested parties, amounting to suppression. The State thus
holds records wholly in its own favour, namely five consistent
surveys and its ou.n certification that Khanamet traverse is
defective, yet declines to take advantage of them and instead,
' AIR 1968 sc 1413
t6
supports an ilction \\'hich serves only Respondent No. l0 and
the propos<'d auctlon bl the 1'' respondent
11.
Sri Pottigari Sreedhar Reedl', learned Special
Governmen t Pleadcr appearrng on behalf of leeLrned Advocate
Gcner:rl for Responclcnls i Lo 9 submrts thal the lands in
Kr-rkatpalll' \'r11agc and Khanamet Village ari distinct and
separat(', its '.uc'h. thcre \\as no question of isstting any notice
lo petitroncr, sinct' t.to sun'cr is bcing undcrtaken in respect of
thc Iancls in Sur','ev No. l OOT The Statc is not interfering with
thc possessiort ancl cnloyment of petitioner, and possession of
pelitioncr rvoLtlcl I-tot be interfered u'ith, The State does not
ciispute lhc ezrrlicr sll rvcvs.
11 1.
Reading paragraph 5 of the counter in its entirety,
learnecl Spec:al Clor t'rumetlt Pleader highlighteC the specific
stzrnd ol'tht: State thrt (i) no reliance is placed upcrn, nor is an,r'
refcrcncc lnace Lo Lht' proceedlngs in No Ar l682l2OlO for the
conducr of tht'surl'er'. the same having been susllcnded b1'this
Court, and (ii) rt:sponrlenls are not relying upon the proceedings
in No. A57'b82, 2O I O
t2
Srr P Sri Raghurarn, learned Senior Counsel
assisrerl br. Sri p. Srjrarn. learned counsel for
lO a rl va n cr.rl titc lbllorr rng
Respondent No
submrssions: (i) rehance \t.as
placed
upon the decision of this Court rn Boorla Amqrnath u- Stdte
of Telangana2 at paragraph 25; (ii) survey being conducted in
Khanamet Village is nol binding on Kukatpally Village; (iii) the
allegation that respondents are interfering with petitioner's
possession is a mere apprehension and is not correct; (iv)
Application for survey is founded upon a statutory right, and
Respondent No. 10 only seeks demarcation of its own lands, by
which petitioner cannot be aggrieved; (v) the prayer in the writ
petition as regards interference is without any cause of action;
(vi) as regards the proceedings of 2014, learned Senior Counsel,
with characteristrc fairness, stated that he had appeared in the
earlier round of that very matter, that a writ petition had then
been Illed in which a direction was issued against the
Government not to interfere with the survey numbers. Upon
violation, a contempt case was filed, in which this Court
appointed a Commissioner to conduct survey with the surveyor,
and t the report of 2Ol4 came into existence in that manner; he
then stated, in terms, that Respondent No. 10 is nowhere
concerned wilh that survey and is not relying upon that survey;
(vii) no rights of petitioner will be affected by the survey now
sought; and (viii) in case of any overlap, petitioner wrll have
t 2020 scc online TS 3517
even- right to object to [hc survey and can take all steps to stop
lhe si-rn'r:r' in accorcl:rnce rr-ith lav".
13.
In rcplr'. learncd counsel for petitioner pointed
olrt that rhr: area of the alleged overlap has, without an1'
expJanarion, qror,'n from Acs. 38.00 in the report of 2O12 to Acs'
54.16 gr-rntas in thc impugned proceedings of 2O14'
14.
At lhis stage, it is necessary to record a
circumstance that has an important bearing rpon the rival
contentions. Bv order dated 1'1.O2.2026, this Court had
spccificzrlh'dirccted Responden[s 1 to 9 to produce the sltrvel'
report said 1() hav( been conducted by thcm' Despite thal
clircction and dcsltite the matter having been adjourned from
timc to tinre t:rereaftcr, on 18 O2.2026,26.O2 2026, 02 03'2026,
16 03.2026, 17 .O?,.2026, 07 .O4.2026, 28.O4.2026 and
29.O1.2O2o,lhe sur\c)' map and reporL have been \\-ithheld from
rhis Courr for rt:asons bcst knorvn to the said respondents' Thc
survev map arncl report u'ere the documents that could have
denlonsl r:lt( d u'hcthcr thc impugned action dcles or does not
rcsl upon the suspencled proceedings oi 2014, that being the
ven matter in issue belween the parties. Withholding of lhat
doclrmcnl. in thc reerh of an order of this Cour: direCting itS
p:q(lLtctlor.t. cornpcls thrs Court to drau.the
tcr-nrs ot thc dcc:isron :n
adverse inference, in
Gopal Krishnaji Ketkar u,
Mohamed.
HaJi Latif that survey record was not produced because, if
produced, it would have falsified the stand of Respondents 1 to
9 that they had nol placed rehance upon the suspended
proceedings of 2014. This Court draws that inference
accordingly.
15.
Upon a consideration of the rival contentions and
the material on record, the following points arise for
determination:
(i) Whether the proceedings bearing No. A5/682/2O10 dated
07.02.2014/ 17.02.2014, along uith the sketch issued bA the Joint
Commtttee of respondent Nos. 4 and 5, are sustainable rn lana;
(ti) Whether the impugned notice beaing Rc. No. 44/ 2339/ 2024 dated
28.11.2025, and the oction taken in pursuance thereof, can be
sustained; and
(iii) Whether ang furlher directtons are required to be gtuen to meet the
end.s of lustice?
16.
Before adverting to the merits, it is necessary to
delineate the precise area of controversy, for much of the
apparent conflict between the parties dissolves once the
documents are read together. The dispute is not at large over
the whole of the common border between Kukatpally and
Khanamet Villages. It is confined to a defined segment of that
border, and the material on record, including the documents
filed by memo, identifies that segment with precision.
17.
In the hrst place, there is no dispute u'hatsoever as
regards tra\'€ ise ltoints 43 and 44. The panchanama dated
31.05.2011 ir-, l'ilc No. A5/9480/2008 records, in lerms' that
part of the b, rundarv ll ing betwecll traverse point No 43 and
tra\'ersr pornt No. -14 u'as demarcated on 28 t)5 2011 using
lllccrronic To al Srations, and that thosc travers;e points were
agrecd to b5 t,or h thc parties That demarcation pertained to the
strctch zrcij or rting Sun'e1 Nos. 1OO3 to 1006 of KukatPallY
Village. and [hose S ltrl'ev Numbers stood conoluded bY the
order datccl 2).O).2A22 of this Court in Writ Petitron No 30773
c>f 2O2). and :irc not t hc subject matter of the present
petition'
Thc lrosition rtf tr:lvct-se points 43 and 44 is therefore, concluded
bl agrcemcnt anrl l>1 the said order, and is not in controversy
To thc extcnl o[ th,rst: t\\'o points' accordinglv, th(:re is and can
be no occasiort for itnt fresh exercise
18.
in
In rhc' second Place, as sterted
aforr:me t'rirtne,.l p:rnchanama dated 31 OIl 20 1 1'
the
a
further
surYev was (tondlrcLed from traverse points 43 to
of
Kukatpalh Viilaqe unclcr Lhe cover of panchtrnama and a report
dat('d O+.05.,'O l2 rtas sr-rbmitted br' the Regional Deputy
Dirccror to th( Commissioner, Survel' and Settle;nents stating
inter alict rhat rlte are:t Of overlap rs corfined to the
ing bcru.e. 1ra\-.rse pornr 43 and traverse
Segment
point 35 and that
2t
upon combined plotting of the traverse data of the two villages,
the overlap is found to arise in this segment, and that it arises
lor a sing.le, identified reason, namely, that the travcrse of
Khanamet Village has been defectively prepared. The portion of
the report dated 04.05.2012 relevant to the present discussion
reads as follows:
" Kukatpally was initrally surveyed in 1299 Fasli and Revision map
was published in 1352 Fasli. Hence Kukatpally village is surveyed first
... Though Khanamet has traversed the traverse is not shown in the
village map of Khanamet ... Traverse boundary of Khanamet is
defectively prepared and it is not tallying with the traverse of Kukatpally
village. This is resulting in overlapping ... Kukatpally is khalsa village
and it is surveyed first. This map is prepared using traverse dala and
these points are relaid on ground. The boundary of Kukatpally is tallylng
with boundary shown rn vrllage map of Kukatpally and that of
Khanamet. Only the village traverse of Khanamet ls not tallying with
traverse and village map of Kukatpally ... Hence we can sa], that
Khanamet traverse is not correct and appears to have been conducted
without following village map. "
The controversy, when reduced to its true
dimensions, is therefore a narrow one, confined to the stretch
between traverse points 43 and 35, and traceable to the
defective Khanamet traverse. As per the panchanama on the
basis of which the report of O4.OS.2OI2 came to be given, the
overlapping lies between traverse points 43 to 35 of Kukatpally
Village as against traverse points 8 to 1 of Khanamet Village.
The said panchanama, in terms, records that from Kukatpally
traverse point 43 up to traverse point 35 Kukatpally Village
boundary and the Khanamet village map are tallying. It is
further recorded that Khanamet traverse point g to point 1, as
2l
againsl Kukalpalh Lraverse points 43 lo 35 do not tally'
Khanamct tralers(r points clo not tally even u'ith the village map
of Khan:rmct irsclf IL also desen'es [o be noticed that the
said
report qtlatrtilLed thc overlap throu'n up b1'the delective traverse
at Ac:s. 38.00 guntas and rtself prescribed the rernedial
course'
nanlel.r'.that''heCollcctorhearthecase,resolvetheboundary
dispute on facts and evtdence, and send a proposal
correction ()f th(' lravers(l rt:cords of one ol the two
villages to the
Commissioncr. SLtrvev Settlement and t'and Rer'ords
unclisputecl lact that thr: said course \('as never
for
lt is an
taken and thal
there is no dtcision of an1' Collector to this dav'
so that the
defcctivc Khanamct tralerse slands uncorrected'
POINT No _. (il:
l9
lt rs :rgainst this background that validitl' of
irnl>ugned procecclings of 20 14 falis to be
tested The starting
to
point is re pot.t ol 2i) l2 Respondents have not been ablc
clisiodgc thc [()111(']lLs of rhat report Thc report
records three
defects in the rec:orci rrf Khanamet Village Firstll"
lhe traverse of
KhanametVillirgehasnotbeenrelaiduponthevillagemapof
shou'n in the
Khanamct. ln other t\.ords, the traverse is not
villagc map oi lih.lnamet, Secondll', thc traverse boundarv of
Khananrt r rs n l talir inq rvith thc vrllage boundary of Khanamet.
Thirdl-r. thc r.iLlergc map of Khanamct is not tallying
with its
traverse data. As against this, the very same report records the
correctness of the record of Kukatpally Village. The village
boundary of Kukatpally is tallying with its traverse boundary.
The traverse of Kukatpally has been relaid upon the ground and
is found to tally. The report itself concludes that traverse of
Khanamet is not correct and appears to have been conducted
without following the village map. Kukatpally Village is a Khalsa
(Diwani) village , it was surveyed first and its traverse stands
incorporated in its village map. For all practical purposes,
therefore, Kukatpally record is to be laken as correct and
Khanamet record as incorrec[. Reliance can be placed only upon
the survey data of Kukatpally Village and not upon thar of
Khanamet Village. The impugned proceedings of 2014, reach a
finding of overlap by placing reliance upon the admittedly
defective Khanamet record. A surve_y which rests upon a record
condemned by the department itself cannot stand.
20.
The categorical assertion of petitioner that no notice
was given to him prior to the survey ol 2OI4 has not been
lraversed as required by law. The record pertaining to issuance
of any such notice has also not been placed before this Court by
Respondents 1 to 9. Taken with the adverse inference already
drawn in preceding paragraph above, the assertion of w,ant of
notice stands not merely unrebufted but reinforced. Therefore,
l,+
this CoLrrt has no hesitation in holding that petitioner and other
pal tadars zrnti persot-ts in possession ol lands in Survey
Oo7 of Kr.tk:r Lpalh Village u'ere not put on notice before
No'
those
Writ Petttion
proc:ecclrngs u et e drau n up Further, this Cor-rrt in
No 3077.?, ot 2O2l bv Order daLed' 22 02 2022 follou'ing the
luclgmerLt in Sree Pancha Murthg
Co-Op' House Building
Societg Limited v. Gouernment of A'P'3' State of A'P'
v'
Sattirajua and Stcrte of A'P' u' Hgderabad' Potteries Pvt'
Ltd.shelcilhat:rsurYevconductedbehindth':backofthe
u'ithout
patraclars or lhe pcrsons in possession of the land'
notice 'Lo rhcr:-.. is rloL binding upon them and
stands vitiated'
Thr' aurh<>riri< s arc legaLIl -bouncl to issue notice
to the actual
patt.rd.ars and the persons in possession belore conductitrg
sur\'(r\'. The ir''rpr-rgnecl proceedings ol 201'4
any
were drawn wilhout
anlslrchnoticeztnclaretherefore,againsttheprinciplesof
natr.lral lustic' lt rs on the sell same ground of
q'ant of notice
thalthisCourtSlls})endedtheverl'procecdingsbl,itsOrcler
2021 A similar
datccl 23.09 2021 in Writ Petirron No 23l64 of
ordcr of sltsp,'nsion u'as passcd in Wrrt Pctition No
22575 ol
2021. Bot}'r tlte abr>r e rcfcrred Orders subsist as on
date' The
infilmirl is comportndccl b,r. a further cirr:umstanue pointed out
br, lcarnr:d cor-,,nsei for petrtioner, namelv the survey report of
'2O0.) (3) r\LL) 52 t,
20 1 r) (.1) 111-t) l Oi)
(.10 I 1)l .') SC( 3t3.1
2Ol2 quantifted the overlap thrown up by the defective traverse
at Acs. 38.00 and the proceedings of 2014 inflate the alleged
overlap to Acs. 64.16 gunlas. This Court finds force in the
submission advanced by petitioner that no fresh field exercise
was undertaken in the interregnum and that when both the
survey proceedings (i.e. survey report ol 2Ol2 and impugned
survey proceedings of 20 14) emanate from the very same officer,
no explanation is forthcoming for the near doubling of the
extent. This Court is of the considered view lhat the same officer
cannot, on the same record, produce two irreconcilable
outcomes. In view of the foregoing discussion, the contention of
petitioner that the impugned survey of 20 14 was conducted
without a site inspection and without any satisfactory
explanation forthcoming on record merits accepLance.
Consequently, the impugned survey of 20l4 is rendered
arbitrary on the face of the record and cannot be countenanced
in law.
21.
The necessary effect of the overlap propounded in
impugned survey proceedrngs of 2014 is to show the lands of
the State as falling within the private patta lands of Kukatpally
Village. The overlap thereby casts a cloud upon the
Government's lands and invites endless litigation. The earlier
surveys of 2005, 2OOa,2OIl,2Ol2 and 2018 stand in contrast
and a conjornt readlng of the said surveys secLlres the interest
ol the SLate . inasmuch as the reports categoricalll' establish
that th€ ov,'rlap is confined to Acs. 38-00 betr,l'een traverse
poinls .1.3 to 35 :rs against the extent ol Acs. 64- 16 Guntas
mention('d i:r imlrugncd sun'e) proceedings of 2014.Therefore,
there rs no orerlap o\(r an extent olAcs. 26 i6 (luntas (i.e. Acs.
6.1 16 Guntzrs minus Acs. 38-00 Guntas). In vi,:u' of lhe same,
Acs. 26 16 Ciuntas of Clovcrnment Iand rs free from any issue of
overlap, therebl enabling the Government to identify and
demarcate its lands (Acres 26- 16 Guntas) in Khanamet Village
rr"'rrhin a c1e,rr and dispute fiee frameu.'ork, rvithout trer-rching
upon thc privatc lands of Kukatpally Village. lt is difficult to
comprehcnd ,,r'h_1 rhe Statc declines to tzrke tldvzLntage of earlier
surve\-s ol 2005, 2008. 201 1., '2012 and 2018 which are u'holly
in its os'n fi.vour. Tht' proceedings of 2012+ are detrimental lo
th(. \,en Stat,' u-hose dcpartment authored them.
22.
l'he stand taken by the State itself 1n the present
pro<:eeclings, mort: perrticularlf in paragraph 5 of the counter
afficlar ir of R,'spondent No. 7 is material to the (rase. The State
has catcgoric:rllr staLcd that no reliance is placerl upon, and no
r-e1i rt-rrc.r' rs rrracJc
lo Lhe proceedings in No A5 t6g2l20i0
rhe c.orrrlLrcr ot'th(, s Lr r_r.e-!.
oi 2O2S. l.he Starr. has
through the impugned
fur.ther stated that
fOr
surve,\. notlce
respondents
are not
relying upon the said proceedings. The learned Special
Government Pleader read over the said paragraph in open Court
and reiLerated the said sland at the Bar. The sta[emen[ is made
on afhdavit by the District Collector of the State on his behalf
and on behalf of the State, binds the State and confirms that
the proceedings of 20 14 furnish no lawful basis for any action
whatsoever. It further confirms that the proceedings ought to be
formally effaced from the record so that they are not invoked
again.
23.
Learned Senior Counsel Sri Sri Raghu Ram
appearing for Respondent No. 10 fairly informed the Court that
the impugned survey exercis e of 2074 was set in motion at the
behest of Respondent No. 10 and that he had appeared in the
earlier round in which proceedings of 2OI4 came into existence.
He then stated in unambiguous terms that Respondent No. 10
is not concerned with the said survey report and is not relying
upon the impr-rgned survey of 2014. This Court is of lhe
considered view that the stand of Respondent No. lO is
consistent with his case, in as much as, if the 2014 survey is
allowed to stand, the survey through impugned survey notice of
2025 as sought for, Respondent No. 10 cannot go on in the
teeth of the impugned 2Ol4 survey. Therefore, it is in the
interest of Respondent No. 10 and also consistent wrth the
stand of even' partv bcfore this Court that the 2 0 1 4 impugned
survev be set astdc.
24.
As noticecl in the preceding paragraphs' lhe
additronal documents filed b1' memo i e the panchanama of
20 1 1, rhe repr)rt and panchanama of 2Ol2 and the order in
Writ
Petition No. 30773 of 2021 drew no repl1' from any respondent'
Tht' cor-tnter alliclavit of Respondent No 7/State contains no
spccrlic cle:nizrl about the earlier surveys conducted b]' it
I-earncd Spt:c,al Government Pleader has expressll' stated that
the State docs not dispute the earlier surve)'s
'l'he sun'eys of
2005, 2008. )'O11, 2012 and 2018 therefore, stand admitted'
unrebuttecl and have attained finalitl' having never been
questionecl in the manncr known to la\""'' lt is clanfied in
lairnr:ss to the rccord, that surve]' procecdings of the year 2018
in frle No. A./ i4:,i 2018 have not themselves becn filed by
petrtioner. Reli:rcnt:e lo them is drau'n from thr: order dated
22.O2.2022 of this Court in Writ Petition No. 3C)773 of 2021.
That order rvas passed upon a perusal of the original record
produccd beforc the Court and expressly records that field
verific:ation of 19.06,2018 \t'ith tippon measurements found the
lands c:orret:L ro rhc.ground and disclosed no overlapping. The
said ;rrdicial rer.ord h:rs not been disputed by
any of the
resp()n(lcnts. .lhc solttan exercise
of impugned survev
proceedings of 2OI4 alone propounds an overlap of Acs. 64-16
guntas, is irreconcilable lr,ith every one of the five surveys of
2005, 2008, 2O1 1, 2012 and 2018.
25.
For all the aforesaid reasons, the proceedings
bearing No. A5/ 682 / 2010 dated 07.O2.2O14 I 17.O2.2014, along
with the sketch issued by the Joint Committee of Respondent
Nos. 4 and 5, are held to be illegal, unsustainable in law and are
therefore set aside.
Point No. tiit:
26.
Learned Special Government pleader submitted that
the lands of the two villages are distinct and separate, and that
no notice was therefore, due to petitioner. This Court places on
record the twin statements of learned Special Government
Pleader. The first statement is that earlier surveys are borne by
record. The second statement is that possession of petitioner
would not be interfered with. This Court holds the State to those
statements and they shall bind the respondents.
27.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of
Respondent No. lO placed reliance upon the decision of this
Court in Boorla Ama.rnath a. State of Telangana to contend
lhat a landholder has a statutory right to seek survey and
demarcation of his ou,n land. Thar right is not in dispure.
l0
Learncd Seni,-rr Coullsel himsell, u'ith fairness, accepted that in
the cas(' of anv or.'erlap/objection, petitioner would have every
rigl-rr ro olrjcci to lhi: sun'et'and lo take all steps to stop it in
accordance u'ith lau
28.
.
In vieu of the fair submrssions made across the Bar
b1' Ieanted Speclal ()overnment Pleader and learned Senior
Corrnsel ancl f indings rendered b1'this Court in setting aside
the
impugncd survev proceedings of 2014' this Court need not
burden itself u'ith going threadbare into the conrentions raised
b1,' thc parties, rnorc parlicuiarll' petitioner'
29.
Rr-'spondcnl No' 10 is a private party asserting a
statLlton' right to har e its or'vn lands sun-e1'ed and demarcated'
It- cannot be nrade to suffer the consequences
of tlre State's own
clelar.rit in dr:lectitelr preparing the traverse of Khanamet
Village. It c'qualh cannot be made to suffer for the State having
left th.It dr'fecl ltnr:orrccted for u.eIl over a decar:Ie despite the
prescripliorl ol its or,r'n report dated 04 05'2O)'2 Respondent No'
lOl.rashirrrselllairlrr.oncedeclthatheclaimsnorightinthe
conceded that a
lanc1s oi hurk:rtpallr Village He has lurther
sur'e\ would be strictlv conlined to Khanamet Village'
concluctcd on co rre('t records and without altering the
bounclarics of Kuka tpa llr Village or violarrng the
Courts. Rcspo:r,:ien: No
crders of the
10 has pursued its request lor
JI
demarcation with diligence and through the process of law. Its
Iegitimate expectation of having its lands identrfied on the
ground deserves to be met rather than deferred. This Court
accordingly, holds that the survey sought by Respondent No. 10
pursuant to the notice dated 28. lI.2025 shall be permitted to
go on subject to the following conditions:
(a) Survey shall be conducred only after putting petitioner
and all the interested parties on notice by duly following the
procedure prescribed under law.
(b)
Petitioner and all other interested parties shall be at
liberty to raise all objections, if any, to the said survey. The
survey authorities shall consider the said ob..lections and deal
with them in accordance with law.
(c)
While conducting the said survey, respondent authorities
shall not rely upon the defective survey records of Khanamet
Village and the said survey shall not extend to, or in any
manner disturb, the lands in Kukatpally Village.
30.
Before parting with this point, it is necessary ro
address petitioner s contention regarding the subsisting slatus
quo orders passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. lt is reiterated
that respondents have furnished a categorical undertaking that
they would not interfere, in any manner, with the lands situated
1n
Krrkatpalll' ''illage, and lhal the
imptigned noticc dated 28. ll
sun'ey pursuant to lhe
2025 u'ou1d be conltned so1ell'
said undertaking'
Khanirmet villagtr In vicrv ol the
sun'eying
surv('v ar.Lthorit ies tire not
village
cannol bc accelltccl zrnd is
the impugned
the Status Quo order'
vrolation of
sun'il\ u oulcl z mollnt to a
No
and since the
anl land in Kukatpally
the ( orrtentron ol the Petitioner that
s'hic h ts tn respcct n1 5l.',11'gY
to
IUOT of Kukat Pallv village '
accordingly rejected
Point N o. iiil
to record
lns (lourt considers it nccessary
a
the Governnrent ln a position
of
clrcLrmsttln(re'r'llich
places
grie"'auce
advatttagt: l athcr than ol
2005, 2008. 2t)1i 2012 and
The czLrlicr survev reports of
clearll and consistently state
that thcre is no overlapping between
the l\.o villages except to
Lraverse
an crtcnL ol Ai:s 38-00 betrveen
point
Kukatpalh Vrl agc ilnci traversc
from
Vill:rgc. This p()sitiol-t cmanates
point Nos 43 to 35 of
Nos
1 to 8 of Khanamet
Government's ou-n records'
Government When the
It rs sclLtureh btncili:ial to the
clisclose no overlap to the
cio\ crltnle nt s i)\\ n s''lr\ e\ records
exL( rrl ol Ar:s f6 1rr gs11135, as aforesaid, the Goi'ernment has
nottring to gain b\'('nterlng into unnecessary- disputes r,r.'ith the
private landowners of Kukatpally Village to the extent of the said
Iand of Acs. 26- 16 guntas. It has, in fact, everything to lose.
Such disputes would cast a needless cloud upon the
Government's own land in Khaname[ Village. They would invite
protracted litigation. They would imperil the certainty which its
own records presently secure [o it. Adherence to its own surveys
costs the Government nothing and protects it entirely. It
therefore, protects the interest of the Government no less than
that of petitioner.
32.
The correction of the traverse of Khanamet Viltage is
considered next. Respondenls are at liberty to correct the
defective traverse of Khanamet Village. The correction shall
ensure that the said traverse is in alignment not only with the
vi.llage map of Khanamet Village but also with the village map,
the village boundary and the traverse ol Kukatpally Village. In
doing so, respondents shall follow the remedial course indicated
in the report dated 04.05.2012 and the procedure prescribed by
lai.r', after notice to all the affected parties. An express .limitation
is also necessary. Even after the said exercise of correction is
carried out, the survey authorities shall stand injuncted from
reopening, altering or in any manner disturbing the earlier
surveys of 2005, 2OO8, 2}ll, 2OI2 and 2018. Those surveys
already stand concluded and have attained finality. The survey
l.+
authorities shall ecluallt s[and injuncted from reopentng'
alterinq or in anr' nranner disturbing the undisputed traverse
points 43 anct '14. An1' resun'e1' consequent upon the correction
of Khanamet travcrsc shall be con{'ined to the segment i e Acs'
38-OO lvirtg be[s'cen traverse point 43 and 35 of Kukatpally
Village corrcsponcling to traverse points 8 to 1 of Khanamet
Village as recrrrd.ed irr the panchanama of 2Ol2'
'lto clarLlications are necessan'before the operative
33.
(lrr('cLrons ilre set out. Firs[, nothing in this judgment shall
cltsrurb.()rb,]COnStrucdtodisturb,anl,existingStructureor
the
ernr subsislinq rc gu larization / ailotmen t of land made by
(iovernmcnt rn th( overlap area This inclucles the lands
reli rrcd to ir-, the report dated 04 05 2012 as having
aLllotterl to tht' )rlaltor-tal Academy of Construction'
tht'
Na tiolla
lnvcstigalion AgencY. A11
been
Hyundai and
sur:h subsisting
regula rtzat ion s, srrLlc turcs and allorments etc. ,
shall rematn
ri'hrr1h' ttt-taf'fer:ted llv Lhis judgment Secondly'
this judgment
rleciclcs no (luestion of litle or possesslon as betneen the
No. iO or an)' other person All such
petrtlol-rt'r,
Re spond ent
clua'sttons
ari lel-t to be adjudicated in lhe aPProPriate
procccd i nqs
'l'hc findings recorded herein are c,tnfined to the
valic|tr oi rhe rmptrgncd surve,\. proceedings and to the manner
and sequence in which the survey and demarcation shall
hereafter be undertaken
34.
In the result, in view of the findings rendered in
respect of the Poinr Nos. (i), (ii) and (iii), rhe Writ petition is
disposed of as indicated above. No costs.
35.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
SD/'P.PONN/r KRISHNA
SISTANT
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To
'1
. The Vice Chairman and Managing Director, Telangana lndustrial
lnfrastru6ture Corpo-Ration (TGllC), office at 6th Floor, Parisrama Bhavan,
Fateh Maidan Road, Basheerbagh.
2. The Deputy lnspector of Survey (Head Quarter), Survey Settlements and
Land Records (SS and LR), Ranga Reddy District.
3. The Assistant Director, Survey Settlements and Land Records (SS and LR)'
Ranga Reddy District.
4. The Regional Deputy Director, Survey Settlements and Land Records (SS
and LR), having its office at having its office at Survey Bhavan, Narayanguda,
Hyderabad.
5. The Joint Director, Survey Settlements and Land Records (SS and LR),
having its office at Survey Bhavan, Narayanguda, Hyderabad.
6. The Commissioner, Survey Settlements and Land Records (SS and LR).
7. The District Collector, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana State.
B. The District Collector, IVledchal-Malkajgiri District, Telangana State.
9. The Principal Secretary, Revenue Department, State of Telangana at
Secretariat, Telangana.
10. Sri D.Suresh Babu, M/s. Rajeswari Farms and Estates PW. LTD., having
office at Plot No. 29, Co-Op Housing Society, Jubilee Hills Hyderabad,
Telangana-500022.
'1
1 . One CC to SRI DHARMESH D.K.JAISWAL, Advocate [OPUCI
12.One CC to SRI P.SRI RAGHU RAM, Advocate [OPUC]
13. One CC to SRI P.SREEDHAR REDDY, Advocate (OPUC)
14.Two CD Copies
SA
TKS
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1310812026
.y'-:;a sl ATp
,7^Q,
,,,,,t
*
i,/q
/:)
lo
u
ORDER
t 1}iSPAT cS.
WP.No.37499 of 2025
DISPOSING OF THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
.z- ,,
\bl
I t\
2T2
1 B AUE
t
0O tb
*:
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review