Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 I
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
ERABAD
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY.SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION
: 33716 OF 2025
Between:
G. Vijaya Vardhan, S/o. G. Sundara Rao, aged about 60 years, Tea Stall Contractor,
Stall No. 17, Plat Form No. 4-5, Kachiguda Railway Station, Hyderabad. R/o. 183431112, Mallikarjuna Nagar, West Malkajgiri, Secunderabad - 500047
.,.PETITIONER
AND
'1
. The Union of lndia, rep., by its Secretary, Ministry of Railways, Railway
Bhavan, Sansadh Marg, New Delhi.
2. The South-Central Railway (SCR), rep., by its General Manager, Rail
Nilayam, Secunderabad.
3. The Principal Chief Commercial Manager, South Central Railway, Rail
Nilayam, Secunderabad
4. The Senior Divisional Commercial Manager, Hyderabad Division, South
Central Railway, Secunderabad
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more particularly one ln
the nature of Writ of Certiorari, to call for the records relating to and in connection
with the lmpugned Proceedings No. Y/C.79/Catg/KCG-GMU-TSIPF-41512O25 dt'
26.09.2025, issued by the 4th Respondent, in terminating the Tea Stall contract of
the Petitioner at Plat Form No. 4/5 Middle (KCG-0171 and set aside the same by
declaring them as highly illegal, unjust, arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of lndia and consequently, direct the
Respondents to renew/extend the Petitioner's contract period in respect of Tea
Stall No. 17, Plat Form No. 4-5 tViddle at Kachiguda Railway Station, as per
Clause 3.2 ol [Vaster License Agreement and as per the policy of the IVinistry of
Railways, as implemented by the South Central Railway, as was done and
considered in respect of similarly placed license holders and to pass any such
order or ord,:rs as this Honorable Court may deem fit and proper in the
circumstances; of the case.
:
lA NO: 3 OF 2025
Petition underSection 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant stay of all further proceedings in respect of Tender No. YC-79-CATG-KCG017-TS, dt: 13.11.2025, and Bid Notice No. Y/C/79/CaIg/GIVU/A1,A,B&C1112O25,
dt: 10.11.2025 to the extent of Tea Stall (GMU-017) situated in between Platform
no. 415, Kachiguda Railway Station, Hyderabad Division, by suspending the
above proceedings and to pass any such order or orders.
lA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition rlnder Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit fik:d in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the Respondents to renew / extend the Petitioner's contract period in
respect of Tea Stall No. 17, Plat Form No. 4-5 Middle at Kachiguda Railway
Station, as per Clause 3.2 of Master License Agreement and as per the policy of
the tVlinistry of Railways, as implemented by the South Central Railway, as was
done and consi,Jered in respect of similarly placed license holders, by suspending
the operation of lmpugned Proceedings No. YlC.T9lCatglKCG-GIVIU-TS/PF41512025 dt: 26.09.2025, issued by the 4th Respondent.
IA NO: 1 OF 201!5
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit fileC in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
permit the Petiti,:ner to file, this WP by dispensing with the filing of Original Copy
of the lmpugned Proceedings No. Y1C.TS|CaIg|KCG-GMU-TS/PF-41512O25 dt:
26.O9.2025, issued by the 4th Respondent.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI POODATTU AMARENDER
co u nse I ror the Res ponde
nt'
SXLIi".li:i tl:*"Tt?i
The Court made the following: ORDER
^r,,
€6
L
wp_33716_2025
i1
NBK, J
IN THB HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
NAGE,SH BHEEMAPAKA
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTI
No-33716 of 2O25
WRITPETITIO
09th Januarv.2026
Between:
G. Vijaya Vardhan S/o G. Sundara Rao
... Petitioner
AND
-fhe
1.
Union of India, rep. by its Secretary,
Ministry of F:ailways, ancl others
Respondents
ORDER:
.The
pe titioner seeks quashing
of the impugned proceedings dated
26.09.2025 by which the 4th Respondent-Senior Divisional Commercial
Manager, tenninated his tea stall contract at Platform Nos. 4/5 (Middle),
Kachiguda Re.ilway Station, and to direct renewal or extension of his licence
in accordancr: with Clause 3.2 of the Master Licence Agreement dated
03.10.2016 and the Catering Policy-2010.
1.1 T'he facts of the case are that the 4th Respondent-Senior
Divisional Crrmmercial Manager, issued a tender notification dated
30.11 .2015 inviting bids for various stalls, including Tea Stall No.
017/KCG/4-5/TS at Kachiguda Railway Station. The petitioner applied for
multiple stalls and emerged as the successful bidder for the Kachiguda stall.
By letter datecl 11.07.2016, the 4th Respondent awarded him the contract,
.wp_33716_2025
NBK,
J
and pursuant to the agreement, he commenced operations with effect from
01.09.2016. Under the Railway Board's Catering Policy-2010, as
incorporated in Article 3.2 of the Master Licence Agreement dated
03.10.2016, the initial licence tenure was five years, with a provision for
renewal for further periods of three years each upon satisfactory
performance. Accordingly, the petitioner's initial five-year term was to
expire on 31.08.2021, and he asserts that he operated continuously from
01.09.20[6, cleared all dues, and ran the stall to the satisfaction of both
authorities and the public.
1.2 Before completion of the initial term, the petitionen applied on
23.08.2021 for renewal of the licence for a further three years underArticle
3.2. Due to the Covid-19 pandemic, a dies-non extension was granted up to
16.04.2022. The petitioner maintains that, in normal course, the renewal
ought to have carried the licence up to 16.04.2025. lnstead, the 4th
Respondent granted a series of short-term extensions: from 01 .11.2022 to
31.01 .2023 by orders dated 19.10.2022; from 01.02.2023 to 30.04.2023 by
orders dated 25.01,.2023; from 01.05.2023 to 31.07.2023 by orders dated
20.05.2023; from 01.11.2023 to 31.01.2024 by orders dated 01.11.2023;
from 01.02.2024 to 30.04.2024 by orders dated 01.02.2024; from
01,.05.2024 to 31.07.2024 by orders dated 22.04.2024; and finally from
01.1 1 .2024 to 31.07 .2025 by orders dated 26.12.2024.
1.3 In the midst of this, the 4th Respondent issued a letter dated
10.03.2022 stating that the renewal process would be initiated subject to
submission of documents and an affidavit in the prescribed format under
Commercial Circular No. 22 of 201 7 on Rs. 100/- stamp paper. The petitioner
states that the respondent demanded an affidavit that he would forego all
other stalls and retain only one, citing the Railway Board's Circular No. 22
I
wp_33715_2025
il
NBK, J
of 20[7 datt:d 15.03.2017, which limited one person to one stall. Aggrieved,
the petitione:r filed W.P. No. 18604 of 2022, wherein interim directions were
granted on 13 .04.2022 directing the respondents to continue his stall at
Platflorm Nos. 4/5, Kachiguda. He asserts that pursuant to these interirn
directions and Railway policy, his licence was extended fiom time to time,
culrrrinating in the extension up to 3l .07.2025 by orders dated 26.12.2024.
1.4 As the extended period approached expiry, the petitioner
submitted ar, application dated 31.07.2025 to the 4th Respondent seeking
further exter':sior1 in accordance with headquarters guidclines. He alleges
that there was no response, and that on 01.08.2025 his tea stall was abruptly
closed witho,rt notice and without consideration of his application. He then
addressed a detailed representation dated 22.09.2025, invoking directions of
the IJon'ble liuprerne Court, Railway Board guidelines, and South Central
Railway clarifications, asserting that existing licensees of rninor static
catering units were entitled to continue operations under status-quo orders
until a further policy decision, and requesting reopening of the stall and also
sought an explanation for closure of tea stall. According to the petitioner,
this representation also elicited no response.
1.5 I\{eanwhile, W.P. No. 18604 of 2022 was listed on 25.08.2025
and dismisse<l on the basis of what the petitioner characterizes as an
elroneous sub nission by the Standing Counsel for the Central Government
that his licenc,: had expired on 16.04.2025 and that no cause survived. The
petitioner contends that this was factually incorrect because his licence had
been extended up to 3 1 .07 .2025 and his application dated 31.07 .2025 for
extension was oending. He further explains that his earlier counsel could not
effectively represent him due to shifting practice after bifurcation, and he
has since initiated a review application which is pending.
wp_33716_2025
NBK, J
1.6 Shortly thereafteq the 4th Respondent issued the impugned
Proceedings dated 26.09.2025 tenninating his contract on the ground that
the writ petition No.18604 of 2022 had been closed as infructuous. The
petitioner alleges that this termination was passed without notice or
opportunity of hearing, solely relying on the dismissal of the writ petition
No. 18604 of 2022, and without considering his pending application dated
31.07.2025 or his representation dated 22.09.2025. He contends that the
dismissal of the writ petition No. 18604 of 2022 cannot have bearing on
termination because his contract had repeatedly been extended in line with
Ministry of Railways instructions dated 13.05.2019, 21.05.2019,
27.08.201.9, 13.12.2021, 12.05.2022, 13.07.2023, and 18.04.2024, all of
which directed maintenance of "status qlto" for rninor catering units based
on judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court and the Delhi High Court.
1.7 The petitioner asserts that his licence was valid until
31.07.2025; that he submitted an application for renewal on the very last day
i.e., on 31.07.2025; and that termination of his licence without considering
his application violates Clause 3.2 of the Master Licence Agreement. The
petitioner alleges that he has been discriminated, pointing out that
partnership firms were granted three-year renewals while individuals like
him were given only six-month status-quo extensions, and that similarly
placed licensees received more favorable treatment. He specifically cites
that P. Srinivas Rao at Bheemavaram Town received renewal up to
03.11 .2025 by orders dated 30.04.2025, and that G. Vijayvardhan at Tenali
and Annavaram was granted a three-year extension from ?1.07.2025 to
20.07.2028 by orders dated 07.07.2025 of the DCM, South Central Railway,
Vijayawada, while others in the Secunderabad division were extended up to
I
wp_33716_2025
.,)
NBK, J
2027. He contends that clespite headquarters advising issuance of status-quo
orders for individual contracts, this division denied him the same benefit.
1.8 The petitioner also relies on the history of litigation challenging
Commercia Circular No. 22 of 2017 before the Delhi High Court, interim
status-quo orders therein, subsequent directions of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court, and Railway Board communications, including eurails and letters
dated 21.05.10[9, directing maintenance of status quo as on 31.03.2019 and
even reopening ol' closed stalls. He alleges that the 4th Respondent
rnisinterprett:d these judgments and policies and acted contrary to them. On
these grouncs. and noting that he was not even served a signed copy of the
impugned order dated 26.09.2025, the petitioner seeks a writ of certiorari to
call for the 'ecords pertaining to the impugned Termination Proceedings
dated 26.09.'.2025, and to set aside the same, and to issue a consequential
direction to renew or extend his licence on the same footing as other
similarly plar;ed license holders.
2. . A courter affidavit has been filed by the 4th respondent, on behalf of
all the respondents. While admitting that the General Minor Unit (Tea Stall)
bearing No. 017|KCG|4-5/TS at Kacheguda Railway Station on Platforms 4
and 5 was awarded to the petitioner, G. Vrjay Vardhan, for a period of five
years from 0 L09.201 6 to 3 I .08.2021, under an agreement dated 03. 10.2016,
it is contendt:d that due to the COVID-l9 pandemic, the contract was
extended by 228 days, resulting in the effective completion of the original
contractual tenure on 16.04.2022.It is contended that under Clause 20.2 of
the Master Lir:ence Agreement, the parties are independent contractors and
no vested or p:lrtnership-like rights accrue to the licensee.
2.1 Referring to .{rticle 3.2 of the Master Licence Agreement,
which governs tenure and renewal, it is contended that licence has an initial
wp_33715_2025
NBK, J
term of five years with a provision for renewal for periods of three years,
however, renewal is explicitly "not a matter of right." The clause requires
the licensee to apply for renewal at least six months in advance of expiry,
and submit a no-dues certificate, and also turnish documents afresh as per
Chapter I of Section B of the Bid Document, and withdraw any court cases.
According to the respondents, since the contract stood extended up to
16.04.2022, the petitioner ought to have applied for renewal by 16.10.2021
with all requisite documents, however, the petitioner did not do so.
Consequently, the Railways addressed a letter dated 10.03.?022 to the
petitioner, calling upon him to submit the prescribed docutnents, including
an affidavit under Commercial Circular No. 22 of 2017 . This letter, marked
as Annexure R-[[, was intended to afford the petitioner an opportunity to
comply with policy before the contract expired.
2.2 [n response to the letter dated 1,0.03.2022 addressed by the
Railways, the petitioner sent a letter dated I 1.03 .2022, which the
respondents reproduce and rely upon heavily. They point out that instead of
submitting the required documents or affidavit, the petitioner raised
objections and hypothetical concems, stating that if he submitted the
affidavit he would have to forgo his entire railway business in future, and
the petitioner questioned how the clause was being implemented against
him, and asserted that he had participated in an open tender on the
understanding of a "5+3 years" tenure. The respondents argue that this reply
neither expressed a clear willingness to renew on policy terms nor complied
with the contractual prerequisites, thereby demonstrating that the petitioner
was unwilling to accept renewal conditions. Nevertheless, the Railways
issued a further letter dated 16.03.2022, granting him a final opportunity to
submit the documents within l0 days, and the petitioner was warned that if
,,)
wp_33716_2025
NBK, J
he fails to :;ubmit the documents, the contract would stand terminated on
I 6.04.2022 rvithout further notice.
2-3 It is contended that the petitioneq instead of submitting the
documents, filed W.P. No. 18604 of 2022 on ll .04.2022, even before the
expiry of tht: l0-da,v period nrentioned in the letter dated 16.03.2022. The
respondents :ontend that this conduct shows that the petitioner attempted to
put pressure rn the administration to secure extension without following the
agreed proct:dure. They further allege that the petitioner was already
operating rnrrltiple stalls in other divisions and had doubts about his
eligibility un,ler the "one person-one unit" rule, which is why he avoided
submitting th,: atlidavit. According to the respondents, this conduct amounts
to lack of clean hands and bias, as the petitioner sought to continue multiple
stalls in violation of fair competition norms.
2.4 T'he respondents placed strong reliance on commercial
circular No.22 of 2017, issued pursuant to Railway policy and Supreme
Court judgments, which overrides earlier catering policies. [t is contended
that the Circular mandates that only those minor catering static unit licensees
who declare otl affidavit that they do not hold more than one unit-such as
one refreshment room, one catering stall, or one trolley-anywhere on
Indian Railwa.rs, whether in their own name or benami, are eligibte for
renewal. [f a licensee holds more than one unit, he must forgo all others
except the one sought to be renewed. False declarations are treated as
material breact, leading to termination and debarment. The respondents
asseft that the retitioner admittedly held at least two other stalls, one at
Annavaram and one at Tenali, which the petitioner himself disclosed in the
writ proceeding:;. This, they argue, conclusively establishes his ineligibility
for renewal unless he tumished the prescribed affidavit agreeing to forgo the
i
wp_33716_2025
NBK, J
other units, which he refused to do. They further allege suppression of this
material fact before the Court.
2.5 [n rebuttal to the petitioner's reliance on Article 3.2 and the
petitioner's claims of an assured "5+3" or eight-year tenure, the respondents
argue that the petitioner selectively quoted the agreernent while suppressing
crucial portions. They explain that Clause 3.1 states that renewal is on
mutually agreed terms, and Article 20.1 lays down an order of precedence
in interpretation, placing Railway's latest policies above the agreement
itself. Thus, Cornmercial Circular No. 22 of 2017 and subsequent Railway
Board letters prevail. They also rely on the petitioner's own letter dated
11r,.03.2022, where he asserted that he had bid high believing the contract to
be for eight years, to show that he misunderstood and misinterpreted the
contract conditions.
2.6 With regard to the petitioner's allegation of discrimination, the
respondents state that all similarly placed licensees under Catering Policy-
2010. in the division were granted extensions only after submitting the
mandatory affrdavit and documents under Commercial Circular No. 22 of
2017 . They refer to tabular statements (Annexure R-VI and other annexures)
listing such vendors to demonstrate uniform application of poticy.
According to them, the petitioner is not similarly situated because he holds
multiple stalls and has persistently refused to comply with the affidavit
requirement. They also clariff that the extensions granted to the petitioner
beyond the original term, including the three-year period from 01.08.2022
to31.07.2025, were given only out of deference to interim orders of the High
Court in W.P. No. 18604 of 2022 and not because he satisfied renewal
conditions.
(
wp_33716_2025
NBK, J
2.7 With respect to the closure of the earlier writ petition, the
respondentt; state that W.P. No. 18604 of 2022 was dismissed as infructuous
by order dated 25.08.2025, after the petitioner's extended period had
effectively run its course. Following the dismissal of the writ petition
No.18604 ol- 2022, thc railway administration sought legal opinion on
whether the stall should be renewed or terminated. Upon noting that the
petitioner hzrd still not submitted the rnandatory affidavit or documents and
considering the legal advice, the administration decided to terminate the
contract, wh ch \vas conlmunicated by letter dated 26.09.2025. It is therefore
contended tltat this was a reasoned adrrrinistrative decision grounded in
contract, policy. and law, and not an arbitrary action.
2.8 Thc respondents rebut the petitioner's reliance on various
Railway Board circulars and status-quo directions by citing Railway Board
letter No.20l6lTG-lII1600/01 dated 13.12.2021, which clarified that even
licenses granled prior to Catering Policy-2017 are governed by Commercial
Circular No. .]2 of 201 7 and the Board's letter dated 27 .08.2019. According
to the- respon,Jents, this clarifrcation squarely applies to the petitioner and
negates his claim that the circular is inapplicable to him. Further, the
respondents contend that the petitioner suppressed material facts, attempting
to monopolize catering units by continuing multiple stalls indefinitely. They
allege that the petitioner is operating stalls at Tenali and Annavaram and has
even obtained interim orders in W.P. No. 13582 of 2022 before the High
Court ofAndh.'a Pradesh to continue operations at Tenali without submitting
the mandated lffidavit. They contend that such conduct defeats the social
objectives of Railway catering policies, which are designed to prevent
monopolies &fl,1 ensure wider livelihood opportunities.
wp_33716_2O25
NBK, J
2.9 It is finally contended that since the petitioner's contract stood
Iawfully terminated, the Railway administration has issued a fresh tender
notification for the subject stall on 17.11.2025, with bids scheduled to be
opened on 05.12.2025, emphasizing that public interest and fair competition
require that the stall be reallotted through due process. On these grounds,
the respondents contend that the writ petition lacks merit and is liable to be
dismissed.
3.
Heard Mr. P. Amarendeq learned counsel for the petitioner; and Ms.
N.V.R. Rajyalakshmi, learned counsel appearing for Mr. N. Bhujanga Rao,
learned Deputy Solicitor General tbr the respondents. Perused the record.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the petitioner was
lawfully granted a tea stall licence under the Catering Policy,20l0 for an
initial period of five years commencing from 0l .09.2016, with a contractual
assurance of renewal for a further period of three years on satisfactory
performance, as embodied in Clause 3.2 of the Master Licence Agreement
dated 03.10.2016. It is urged that the petitioner duly performed all
contractual obligations, cleared all dues, and was continuously permitted to
operate the stall, including through successive extensions granted by the
respondents up to 31.07.2025, thereby creating a legitimate expectation of
renewal. Learned counsel submits that the abrupt closure of the stall on
01.08.2025 and the subsequent termination order dated 26.A9.2025 were
passed without notice, without considering the petitioner's application dated
31.07.2025 and representation dated 22.09.2025, and in violation of
principles of natural justice. It is further argued that the insistence on an
aflidavit under Commercial Circular No. 22 of 2017 is arbitrary and
inapplicable to the petitioneq who secured the contract through an open
++-
t
t
tender, and that similarly placed vendors were granted renewals or long-term
wp_33715_2025
NBK, J
extensions, rendering the impugned action discriminatory and violative of
Articles 14 and l6 of the Constitution of India.
5.
Leanred counsel for the respondents would subrnit that the licence
granted to the petitioner expired by etllux of time and that renewal under
Clause 3.2 of the Mastcr Liccnce Agreernent is not a matter of right but is
conditional upon strict compliance with contractual stipulations and
prevailing Railway policies. [t is contended that the petitioner failed to apply
for renewal six months in advance, failed to submit mandatory documents,
and deliberately retused lo furnish the affidavit required under Commercial
Circular No 22 of 2017, despite repeated notices dated 10.03.2022 and
16.03.2022. Learned counsel ernphasizes that the petitioner was holding
multiple catering units at Annavaram and Tenali, making him ineligible for
renewal unle'ss he agreed to forgo the other units, and that all similarly
situated licensees who cornplied with the policy were granted renewal. It is
further subnLitted that the extensions granted to the petitioner up to
31.07.2025 uere only in deference to interim orders of this Court and not in
recoghition of any vested right. Learned counsel therefore contends that
there is no illegality in the irnpugned termination order dated 26.09.2025,
and therefore the writ petition is liable to be dismissed.
6.
Having considered the respective contentions and perused the record,
it may be nott:d that the dispute arises out of the termination of a catering
licence granted to the petitioner for a General Minor Unit (Tea Stall) at
Kachiguda Railway Station. On fbcts, there is no serious controversy that
the petitioner was granted a licence for a fixed period of five years from
01.09.2016 to 31.08.2021 under the Master Licence Agreement dated
03.10.2016, and that owing to the Covid- I 9 pandemic, a dies-non extension
L2
wp_33716_2025
NBK, J
of 228 days was granted, resulting in completion of the original contractual
tenure on 16.04.2022.
6.1 [t is to be noted that the petitioner's assertion that he had an
automatic and vested right to renerval for a fur-ther three years and that the
respondent authorities acted arbitrarily in not granting such renewal, is
misplaced assertion, as it is not in accordance with the terms of Article 3.2
of the Master Licence Agreement itself. While the petitioner emphasizes the
availability of renewal, he conspicuously omits the equally explicit
stipulations that renewal is "not a matter of right," that an application must
be made at least six months prior to expiry, and that renewal is conditional
upon submission of prescribed documents, including an affidavit, no-dues
certificate, and compliance with prevailing Railway policies.
6.2 The record further reveals that the petitioner did not apply fior
renewal six months prior to 16.04.2022, that is, by 16.10.2021, as
contractually mandated. This factual lapse has not been disputed by the
petitioner with any documentary proof. Instead, when the respondent
authorities, by letter dated 10.03.2022, specifically called upon him to
submit the requisite documents and affidavit in terms of Commercial
Circular No. 22 of 2017, the petitioner responded on 11.03.2022 not by
complying with the demand, but by questioning the applicability of the
policy, asserting an assumed "5+3 years" entitlement, and expressly
declining to submit the affidavit on the ground that it would require him to
forgo other stalls. This correspondence, relied upon by the respondents and
not denied by the petitioneq clearly demonstrates that the petitioner was
unwilling to comply with the goveming policy conditions for renewal. The
respondents issued a further letter dated 16.03.2022 grarttingan additional
10 days' time and clearly warning that failure to comply would result in
\
wp_33716_2025
NBK, J
termination on 16.04.2022. The petitioner has not rebutted the issuance or
contents ol'this notice; instead, he filed W.P. No. 18604 of 2022 even before
the expiry,rf the said period.
6.3 It is to be noted that Cornrnercial Circular No. 22 of 2017
assumes clitical significance, and the said circulaq issued pursuant to
Railway policy and in the backdrop of judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme
Couft, exp:essly overrides earlier catering policies and mandates that
renewal of minor catering units is permissible only upon an affidavit
declaring that the licensee holds not more than one unit, and that if rnultiple
units are ht:ld, all others must be tbryone except the one sought to be
renewed. TtLe petitioner has neither disputed the existence nor the contents
of this circular; his case rests solely on the contention that it should not apply
to him. Thir; contention is directly contradicted by Article 20.1 of the
Master Licrlnce Agreement, which accords primacy, in the order of
precedence, to 6'Railway's latest policies as applicable from time. to
time." The respondents have also placed reliance on Railway Board
clarification dated L3.t2.2021, which reiterates that even licences granted
prior to the Catering Policy-2017 are governed by Commercial Circular No.
22 of 2017. The petitioner has lailed to place any cogent material to counter
this clarification. Therefore, the petitioner's contention of an automatic or
indefeasible right to renewal is legally untenable. The law is well settled that
where a contr;lct or policy confers a discretion coupled with conditions, and
expressly negiltes a right of renewal, no mandamus can be issued to compel
renewal contrary to such terms. Further, the parties cannot claim equities
merely based rtn interim orders of "status QUO", and their case has to rest on
the foundation of compliance rvith mandatory conditions. In the instant case,
there is no plausible reason fbrthcoming from the petitioner as to what
wp_33715_2025
NBK, J
prevented him from furnishing the mandatory affidavit as per the Master
Circular Guidelines, and Railway polices, stating that in case he is operating
more than one Tea Stall/General Minor Unit, anywhere under the Indian
Railways, he would disclose the sarne and would forgo all the other Tea
Stalls/General Minor Units, except the one he is intending to seek renewal.
lt is not the case of the petitioner that the respondent-Railways has been
renewing, even without furnishing affidavit, and even if the persons are
operating multiple Stalls, and specifically denying only to the petitioner.
6.4 From a perusal of the record, and the respective submissions, it
is evident that the respondent authorities acted as per the Circular
instructions and policies governing the Contract, and after affording
repeated opportunities to the petitioner. The impugned order dated
26.09.2025 was passed by the competent authority, namely the Senior
Divisional Commercial Manageq after the expiry of the extended period up
to 3.1 .07.2025, after dismissal of W.P. No. 18604 of 2022 as infructuous on
25.08.2025, and after obtaining legal opinion. It is not the case of the
petitiqner that he complied with all mandatory requirement of submission of
.\,
docum6ntt including the mandatory affidavit. Admittedly, the petitioner for
the reasons best known to him evaded from furnishing the mandatory
affidavit, and sought to project an argument that he tendered more amount
for the contract hoping that it would be "5 * 3" term. Merely because the
petitionerhas assumed that his contract would be for "5 +3", his contract
cannot be governed on assumptions, and cannot be continued despite non-
compliance with mandatory requirement of furnishing documents and
affrdavit that he would forgo all other Stalls if he is operating more than one
Stall. Law cannot take a detour for the benefit of petitioner. The impugned
decision to terminate the petitioner's contract was based on the petitioner's
t5
wp_337L6_2025
N8K, J
admitted lailure to submit mandatory documents and affidavit and his
continued insistence on retaining multiple stalls, which is expressly
prohibited The plea of violation of principles of natural justice is
unsustainable in view of the notices dated 10.03.2022 and 16.03.2022,the
petitioner's own written response dated 11.03.2022, and the prolonged
extensions granted during pendency of earlier litigation. The action cannot
be charactr:rised as arbitrary or malafrde, as it is supported by cogent
documentary evidence and a consistent policy rationale aimed at preventing
monopoly and ensuring fair competition.
6.5 The petitioner has failed to demonstrate any procedural
irregularity, substantive illegality, or jurisdictional infirmity in the impugned
proceedings. On the contrary the material on record establishes that the
petitioner sought to continue under the guise of judicial protection u,ithout
complying rvith the contractual and policy framework governing renewal.
Therefore, no case is therefore made out for interf-erence under Afticle 226
of the Constitution. l'he impugned termination Proceedings dated
26.09.2025 ire sustainable both in fact and in law, and the writ petition,
being devoic of rnerit, is liable to be dismissed.
7.
Accorrlingly, the writ petition is dismissed. No costs. Miscellaneous
petitions penCing, if any, shall stand closed.
SD/.P. PONNA KRISHNA
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
/TRUE COPYII
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC to SRI POODATTU AMARENDER, Advocate. [OPUC]
2. one cc t,: SRI N.BHUJANGA RAo, Deputy solicitor Generar of rndia, High
Court for':he State of Telangana at Hyderabad. [OPUC]
3. Two CD C)opies.
BSK
BS
f;
t
HIGH COURT
DATED :09/0112026
I
t
c)
2 3 JAil 2028
ORDER
WP.No.3i3716 of 2025
*
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
RI I LL
THF. S;-4 i
;.)
t
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review