Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
132521
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION Nos: 19591 and 41351of 2022
WRIT PETITIO N NO:19591 of2022
Between:
G.Venkateshwarlu, S/o. G.R amulu, Aged about 54 Years, Occ. RDO,
Hyderabad, F/o. 3-1 1-433 L.B .Nagar, Hyderabad-TS
...PETITIONER
AND
The State Of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Revenue
Department, Secretariat at Hyderabad
The Chief Commissioner of Land Administration, (CCLA) Nampally,
Hyderabad-TS
The District Collector, Ranga Reddy District At Lakdikapool, Hyderabad-TS
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of lhe constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be
pleased to issue a writ, order or Direction more particularly one in the nature of
writ of l\Iandamus to call for records by ordering Rule Nisi in connection to
initiating enquiry against the Petttioner by the Respondents more particularly the
Respondent No.3 by passing an order dt.19-O2-2020 in File No.A3/99612O2O by
declaring their action as arbitrary, highhanded, discriminatory, ex-facie illegal, in
violation of principles of natural iustice, by giving colourable exercise to its
statutory powers in dereliction of duty, and consequently may set-aside the same
in the interest of .iustice.
lA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the cir lumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Courl rray be pleased to
suspend the operation of the Order dt.19-O2-202O in File No.1 l/996/2020 passed
by the Respondents more particularly the Respondent No.3 ir cluding the stay of
enquiry against the Petitioner pending disposal of the above / rit Petition.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Between:
1. The State Of Telangana, Rep.
by
its Principal S ecretary, Revenue
Department, Secretariat at Hyderaba d
2. The Chief Commissioner of Land Administration, (CCLA) Nampally,
Hyderabad-TS
3. The District Collector, Ranga Reddy District At Lakdikapc,r l, Hyderabad-TS
,..PETITIONERS
AND
G.Venkateshwarlu, S/o. G.R amulu, Aged about 5,4 7ears, Occ. RDO,
Hyderabad, RYo. 3-1 1-433 L.B .Nagar, Hyderabad-TS
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the ci :umstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High CourL may be pleased to
vacate the interim orders dated 27 -O4-2O22 passed in W.P. l'l r. 19591 of 2022 in
the interest of justice, to enable the respondents to co''r;lude the pending
proceedings in accordance with law.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI B.MAYUR REDDY, Sr. COUlll EL, REP
SMT P.CHANDANA
Counsel for the Respondents: GP FOR SERVICES-I
WRIT PETITION NO: 41351 of 2022
Between:
G.Venkateshwarlu, S/o. G.Ramulu Aged about 54 years, Occ RDO,
Hyderabad, Rl/o. 3 -1 1-433, L.B.Nagar, Hyderabad-TS
.,.PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Chief Secretary, Revenue Department,
Secretariat at Hyderabad
2. The Principal Secretary, Revenue Department, Secretariat at Hyderabad-TS
3. The Chief Commissioner of Land Administration (CCLA)' Nampally'
Hyderabad-TS
4. The District Collector, Ranga Reddy District At Lakdikapool, Hyderabad-TS
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a writ, order or Direction more particularly one in the nature of
Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the Respondent No.1 in passing an
order dt.04-1 1- 2022 in G.O.Rt.No.348 against the Petitioner herein for framing
charges etc when the whole process against the Petitioner is already stayed as
illegal and unconstitutional and consequently set aside the order dt. 04-11-2022
in G.O.Rt.No.348 while making it clear that an officer cannot be proceeded
against when he is implementing the Orders of Courts
lA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to
Suspend the operation of the Order dt.O4-11-2022 ln G.O.Rt.No.348 passed by
the Respondent No.1 so that the Respondents do not proceed any further in any
manner, pending disposal of the main Writ Petition.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Between:
'l . The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Chief Secretary, Revenue Department'
Secretariat at Hyderabad
2. The Principal Secretary, Revenue Department, Secretariat at Hyderabad-TS
3. The Chief Commissioner of Land Administration (CCLA)' Nampally,
Hyderabad-TS
4. The District Collector, Ranga Reddy District At Lakdikapool, Hyderabad-TS
...PETITIONERS
AND
G.Venkateshwarlu, S/o. G.Ramulu Aged about t 4 years, Occ
Hyderabad, R/o. 3 -1.1-433, L.B.Nagar, ft"VOeraUaO_fS
RDO
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 15'1 cpc praying that in th r circumstances
in the affidavit fired in support of the petition, the High c, rr1 nray
vacate the interim orders dt.14-11_2022 in Wp.No.4135 1 ol 2022
be preased to
and dismiss the
Writ Petition, pending disposal of the writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI B.MAyUR REDDy, Sr. COL
NSEL, REp.
SMT P.CHANDANA
Counsel for the Respondents: Gp FOR SERVICES_l
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
stated
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION No. 19 59 1 & 4 L35L ot 2022
COMMON ORDER:
Heard Sri B.Mayur Reddy, learned senior designated
counsel representing Smt. Porika Chandana, learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner on record
and learned Government Pleader for Services-I appearing
on behalf of the respondents.
The oetitioner aooroached the Court seekinq Draver
.19
1 of 2O22 as u
"...to issue a Writ, Order or Direction more particularly one
in the nature oF "Writ of Mandamus" to call for records by
ordering Rule Nisi in connection to initiating enquiry
against the Petitioner by the Respondents more particularly
the Respondent No. 3 by passing an Order dt 19.02.2020
in File No. A3l996/2020 by declaring their action as
arbitrary, highhanded, discriminatory, ex-acie, illegal, in
violation of principles of natural justice, by giving
colourab.le exercise to its statutory powers in dereliction of
duty, and consequently may set-aside the same in the
interest of justice and may Pass..."
The oetitioner a ooroached the Court s ekino oraver
in W.P.No.41351 of 2O22 as under:
"...to issue a Writ, Order or Direction more particularly one
in the nature of "Writ of [r4andamus" declaring the action of
the Respondent No. 1 in passing an Order dt 04.tL.2022 in
G.O.Rt. No. 348 against the Petitioner heretn for framing
charges etc when the whole process against the Petitioner
is already stayed as illegal and unconstitutional and
consequently set-aside the Order dt 04.1 t. tO22 in G.O.Rt
No.34B while making it clear that an olf cer cannot be
proceeded against when he is implementirr, the Orders of
Co u rts and pass..."
The petitione r tn W.P.No.1 9591 of
peti
022 and the
er tn W.P,N o.4 1351 of 2022 are the i rme.
r
4, The case of the Detitio er, in b r e t
ave rme nts made
v the
titio ner in t he aff d
er the
it file
t he Detiti oner in suoo ort of W.P.No.1 9591 r f 2022 is as
u n der:
The petitioner, while acting stricUy in accc r jance with the
decrees of competent civil courts that had affirm: i title in favour
oF private parties and whose findings had attaine 1 finality up to
the Supreme Court, passed mutation orders in rl;pect of certain
lands. The petitioner was himself a party to the rnderlying civil
surts, and non-compliance with the court decr::s would have
exposed petitioner to contempt proceedings, as I utation entries
are fiscal in nature, do not confer tiUe, and do r ot prevent the
Government From initiating independent procee: ngs under the
Ag ricu ltu ra I Ceiling Act.
It is further the case of the petitioner th;r despite being
aware of these Facts and relevant ;udicial f r )nouncements,
Respondent No. 3 issued disciplinary enquiry order against the
petitioner on 19.02.2020, alleging failure to veriFy revenue
records, improper land classification, prior handover to APIIC,
and lack of pnor permission from district authorities. As the
enquiry had not yet commenced and no effective alternative
remedy was available, the petltioner approached this Court,
seeking a writ of mandamus to call for records to declare the
enquiry order illegal and unconstitutional, and set it aside, along
with interim relief suspending the enquiry to prevent irreparable
harm and abuse oF process.
T he ca s e
of the D etitioner in brief
th
v
a s Der
t he
e itioner in the affidavit filed b
the oetitioner in support of p resent W.P.No.4135L ot 2022
is as under
The petitioner was responsible for the revenue administration
of land in Sy.No.613, Nadergul Village, Ranga Reddy District,
which was subject to prolonged civil litigation. The Supreme
Court, on 09.10.2015, confirmed ownership in favour of private
parties, and registered sale deeds were executed in 2014. The
purchasers applied for mutation in 2016, and the petitioner, after
seeking objections, legal opinions, and instructions from higher
authorities but having failed to receive any guidance from
superior officers, passed the mutation orders on t4.09.2016. The
orders were however made subject to third-par1 7 claims, future
court outcomes, and government instructions.
It is further the case of the petitioner t rat subsequent
disputes arose when applications for non- I lricultural land
conversion were rejected, leading to writ jetitions being
dismissed by the High Court in 2020, u I ich noted the
petitioner's compliance with judicial decrees.
It is further the case of the petitioner rl at despite this,
departmental authorities initiated an enquiry rrr February 2020,
alleging procedural lapses. The petitioner chalr( nged the same
through W.P, No. 19591 of 2022, and the High (ourt stayed the
enquiry on 21 .04.2022. While the enquiry renr,: ned stayed, the
State Government, via G.O. Rt. Na. 348 dtrl ed 04.1 1.2022,
initiated fresh proceedings on the same sub1e(:. Aggrieved by
this, the petitioner filed the present writ pet t on seeking the
quashing of the government order.
6. PERU SED THE RECORD:
A)
The interim orders, dated 27.O4.1 t22
ssed in
favour o f the oetitioner i n W.P.No.19s 91 ot 2O22 ls
extracted h e reu nd er: -
The case of the petitioner is that mutation proceedings
vide order dated 24.09.2016 were issued pursuant to the
judgment of the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.2963 of
2013 dated 09.10.2015. However, without reference to the
judgment of this Court A.S.No.274 of 2007 dated
19.72.2071 and the judgment of the Supreme Court in
Civil Appeal No.2963 of 2073 dated 09.10.2015,
imputations are made against the petitioner alleging that
orders are passed by without following the procedure
contemplated under the A.P. Rights in Land And Pattadar
Passbooks Acl, t97t (for short the Act') and the Rules
made thereunder and violating the time to time
instructions issued by the District Administration. There is
also reference to the revenue records i.e. Khasra Pahanies
of Nadergul village wherein land in Sy.No.613 was
classified as Dastagardan. A further point raised ls that the
Government has not issued orders for implementing the
judgment of the Supreme Court dated 09.10.2015.
It needs to be noted, as per Section B of the Act, the
recording authority is bound to Implement the orders of a
civil Court. The matter has attained finality in Appeal Suit
No.274 of 2007 dated 19.12.2011 and confirmed by the
Supreme Court vide judgment dated 09.10.2015 in Civil
Appeal No.2963 of 2013. Merely because permission is not
obtained from the Government for implementing the
judgment of the Supreme Court, it cannot be said that the
provisions of the Act and the Rules thereunder or
instructions issued by the District Administration are not
being followed and the same amounts to misconduct.
Regarding delay, learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that though the impugned order was passed on
19.02.2020, it was received by the petitioner recently,
which is seriously disputed by the learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Services II.
Irrespective of the delay, in the light of the above
discussion this Court is oF the opinion that the petitioner
has made out a prima facie case for grant of interim order.
In the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be
interim suspension as prayed for.
B
The above said
interim orders ar e j r force as on
date.
B
Th
04.tL,2022
or
Das sed b
u n
Rt.l o. 348.
vt he re s D ond r nt
dated
No.1
tn
W.P.No.41351 of 2O22, is extracted hereung er:_
It
is proposed to hold an
r
quiry against
Sri.G.Venkateshwarlu, the then Deput z Collector &
Tahsildar, Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga fL rddy District in
accordance with the procedure laid dolt r in Rule 20 of
Telangana State Civil Services (Classifica :ion, Control &
Appeal) Rules, 1991,
2. The substance of the imputations cf misconduct or
misbehaviour in respect of which the inqu r / is proposed to
be held is set out in the enclosed statem€ rt oi Articles of
charges (Annexure-1). A Statement of imputation of
misconduct or Misbehaviour in support c f each article of
charge is enclosed (Annexure-II). A Iist of documents, by,
which, and a list of witness by whom, the : -ticle of charges
are proposed to be sustained are also enclosed.
(Annexure-III & IV).
3. Sri. G. Venkateshwarlu, the then ):puty Collector
&Tahsildar, Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga F eddy District is
directed to submit within ( 10) days of tir, receipt of this
order, a written statement of his defence,
4. Sri. G. Venkateshwarlu, the then Det rty Collector &
Tahsildar, Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga R rddy District is
informed that an inquiry will be held on / in respect of
those- articles of charges as are not admil :ed. He should,
therefore specifically admit or deny each ar icle of charge.
5. Sri. G. Venkateshwarlu, the then Dep.lty Collector &
Tahsildar, Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga t{:ddy District is
further informed that if he does noi sut mit his written
statement of defence on or before the I rte specified in
para-3 above further action will be processed based on the
material available.
6. Attention of Sri.G. Venkateshwarlu, the then Deputy
Collector & Tahsildar, Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy
District is invited to Rule 24 of Telangana Stale Civil
Service (Conduct) Rules, t964, under which no
Government Servant shall bring or attempt to bring any
political or outside influence to bear upon any superior
authority to further his interest in respect of matters
pertaining to his service under the Government. If any
representation is received on his behalf from another
person in respect of any matter dealt with in these
proceedings it will be presumed that Sri. G.
Venkateshwarlu, the then Deputy Collector & Tahsildar,
Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District is aware of such
a representation and that it has been made at his instance
and action will be taken against him for violation of Rule 24
of the Telangana State Civil Services (Conduct) Rules,
7964.
7. The receipt of the G.O may be acknowledged.
c)
Th e interim or ers. dated 14. lL.2O22 oassed in
favou r
of the petitioner ln W.P.No.41351 of 2022 is
extracted here u nder: Learned Government Pleader for Services-II takes notice for
respondent Nos.1 to 4
I.A. No.1 of 2022 is filed seeking direction to Suspend the
operation of the Order dated 04.11.2022 in G.O.Rt.No.34B,
passed by the respondent No.1, so that the respondents do
not proceed any further in any manner, pending disposal of
the main Writ Petition.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that earlier the
petitioner filed W.P.No.19591 of 2022 and in I.A.No.1 of
2022 in W.P.No.19591 of 2022, praYed to suspend the
operation of the Order dated 79.O2.2020 in File
No.A3/996/2020 passed by the respondents more
particularly the respondent No.3 includir I the stay of
enquiry against the Petitioner pendrng J sposal of writ
petition and this Court by order dated 27 ( 4.2022 passed
the following order:-
"The case of the petitioner is that mutati )n proceedings
vide order- dated 24.09.2016 were issuerl lursuant to the
judgment of the Supreme Court in Civil Ap 1 eal No.2963 of
2013 dated 09.10.2015. However, without r:ference to the
judgment of this Court A.S.No.274 o 2007 dated
19.72.2011 and the judgment of the Sup reme Court in
Civil Appeal No.2963 of 2013 dater 09.10.2015,
imputations are made against the petitiorr, r alleging that
orders are passed by him without followinc the procedure
contemplated under the A.P. Rights in La I j And pattadar
Passbooks Act, 1971 (for short 'the Act and the Rules
made thereunder and violating the ime to time
instructions issued by the District Administ ation. There is
also reference to the revenue records i.e,,. Khasra
Pahanies of Nadergul village wherein larr in Sy.No.613
was classified as Dastagardan. A further pci rt raised is that
the Government has not issued orders f,t implementing
the judgment of the Supreme Court dated I ).10.2015.
It needs to be noted, as per Section B r f the Act, the
recording authority is bound to implement he orders of a
civil Court. The matter has attained finalit) in Appeal Suit
No.274 of 2007 dated 19.12.2011 and ct rfirmed by the
Supreme Court vide judgment dated 09,11.2015 in Civil
Appeal No.2963 of 20:13. Merely becau:;r permission is
not obtained from the Government for irr )lementing the
judgment of the Supreme Court, it cannot le said that the
provisions of the Act and the Rules thereunder or
instructions issued by the District Admin's,ration are not
being followed and the same amounts to n i ;conduct.
Regarding delay, learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that thor-rgh the impugned order was passed on
t9.02.2020, it was received by the peti ioner recently,
which is seriously disputed by the lee -ned Assistant
Government Pleader for Services-Ii irres lective of the
delay, in the light of the above discussior ,his Court is of
the opinion that the petitioner has made r,r t a prima facie
case for grant of interim order.
In the Facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be
interim suspension as prayed for."
Thereafter, the respondent No.1 issued impugned orders
vide G.o.Rt.No.348 dated 04.L1.2022, initiating Artlcles of
charges against the petitioner when the whole process
against the petitioner is already suspended by order, dated
27.O4.2022 in W.P.No.19597 of 2022.
Prima facie the impugned order issued by respondent No.1,
vide G.O.Rt.No.34B dated 04.LL.2022, is not sustainable
and is against the order of this Court in WP.No.19591 of
2022 dated 27.04.2022, which is pending till date. In view
of the same there shall be interim suspension of
G.O.Rt.No.34B dated 04.71.2022, for a period of (04) four
wee ks.
Learned Government Pleader for Services-Il seeks time to
file counter.
The said interim order s are in force as on date.
D)
The counter affidavit filed on behalf of the
resoondent No .1 in W.P.No.19591 of 2()22 and in
oarticular oar a Nos.4 to 9 are extracte hereunder:-
4. It is submitted that, the following article of charges were
framed against the petitioner on the following charges
/imputations as below:-
a. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Kandukur Division has
reported that, as per basic Revenue Records i.e., Khasra Pahani
of Nadergul Village the land in Sy.No.613 extent Ac.373-229ts is
classified as "Dasthagardhan" and Shivaraj Ilaka is recorded in
Pattada r Column.
b. On perusal of the mutation orders dated 24-09-2Ot6 passed
by the Deputy Collector & Tahsildar, Saroornagar Mandal, the
following lacunas noticed and also passed orders without
following the laid down procedure as contempl,t ed in the ROR
Act & Rules and also violating the time to tir re instructions
issued by the District Administration.
i) The classification of the land Sy.No.613 is ,::arly shown in
base record i.e., Khasi-a Pahani (1954-55) is Dar; hugardhan and
no ORCS were issued by the competent authority.
ii) No orders were issued from the (ii vernment for
implementation of Apex court orders dated 09 0-2015 as the
entire land of Ac.373-22 gts was handed over to he APIIC in the
year 2007 for development of Hardware Park.
iii) The land is notified in 22-A Pr-ohibitory Prope,r :ies maintained
by the Reg istra tion Department.
iv) No orders were received from the compet€r t authority denotifying the subject land from 22-A Prohibitory I operties
v) The Deputy Collector & Tahsildar, Saroornag rr has failed to
verify the ground status and occupation of the I nd claiming by
the compan ies,
vi) The Deputy Collector & Tahsildar, Saroorn I ;ar has passed
mutation orders without verifying the ceiling asp: tt.
vii) The Deputy Collector & Tahsildar being the : rstodian of land
records, should have verified the ground p tssession with
reference to the revenue records before gran - rg of mutation
against the interest of Government.
5. tt is submitted that, the oet itioner he rr: n woul d have
wait unde r the aooroval from t he Governm e nt when there
is a huoe extent of Government land is ir volved before
tn
utation orders and al
se(l the mutation
orders without de-notif vinq the subiect lanr J; from the 22A Reoist erb com etent authoritv whi c 1 rs a rav
irreq u la rity,
6. It is submitted that, as per rule 20 (2) c,l the CCA rules
whenever the disciplinary authority is of the o I nion that there
are grounds for enquiring into the truth of a r / imputation of
misconduct or misbehavior against a governmerr servant it may
inquire into or appoint under this rule as tlr, case may be
authority to enquire into the truth thereof. The Deputy Collector
& Tahsildar has shown clearly dereliction of duties and sheer
negligence towards his duty has violated the above rules has
caused cumbersome litigations by passing the mutation orders
involving 150 acres of Land whose original classification was
Dastugardhan and vests with the Government unless a
declaration under ceiling on holdings Act was made.
7. It is submitted that, as per the TSCS CCA rules, every
subordinate employee is governed by certain rules and
regulations which are meant to be scrupulously followed, but in
this case the present writ petitioner and the then Deputy
Collector and Tahsildar Saroornagar Mandal is trying to escape
by quoting certain general rules from the root cause of the issue
and Decree of the Hon'ble Trlal Court. But, being a Deputy
Collector Rank the Officer ought to have taken steps other than
passing the mutation orders and creating an unwanted litigation
over valuable Government interested lands. In this regard it is
relevant to submit that, it is not the case of the petitioner that,
the present action of the Respondents in initiating disciplinary
action is without jurisdiction or competency.
Therefore, the verv Writ Petition is not maintainable
aqainst charqe memo, and it is not a case that, the
authorities alreadv arrived a conclusion with Dreln
n hin
h
tn
him
issuinq charqe memo and callinq explanation.
xc
B. It is submitted that, the Government is the appointing
authority and Disciplinary Authority in respect of the official in
the rank of Deputy Collector and above and has special powers
under CCA rules to enquire and frame charges by giving ample
opportunity to the officers on whom imputations were drawn,
that too it is only charge memo/ being issued calling for
explanation, the petitioner as well can give his explanation
defending his case. Instead, hurriedly approached this Hon'ble
Court by way oF filing present W.P.
In view of the above and since there are huge extent of
Government lands involved and the petitioner passed mutation
orders wlthout consulting the Government. Such is the reason to
find out the role of the Writ Petitioner, the Disciplinary
Authorities by exercising their powers rightly initiated
Departmental proceedings by way of framing specific charge,
calling explanation from the delinquent emp o ee. Instead of
submitting his explanation if any in a hurried mar 1er approached
this Hon'ble Court, questioning the charge mc 1o,s by raising
certain untenable grounds. It is well settled pr I )osition of law,
no writ lie against charge memo, or to show : luse notice, as
held by many catena of judgments of Hon,ble Al), x Court as well
as this Hon'ble Court.
9. It is further submitted that, it is r ( t a case of
ive/re pea ted enqui fles aga inst a same rs!, I e/ it is onlv at
the staqe of calli n exol a natio n from tl e Del inouent
EmD loyee bv wav o f issuino charqe memo. -herefore, the
petitioner
s uccess
without submittinq his exolanati ( n aoDroached
this Hon'ble Court, and obtained interim r rrders. In th is
regard it is further submitted that as stated s r )ra, No writ lie
against charge memo. ThereFore, in rr interest of
administration, to enable the Department to pr( ceed further in
tune with procedure contemplated under Rule .l r of 6aO Or,"r,
this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to vacate the irterim orders.
E) The counter affidavit filed on behalf of E re respondent
No.4 in w .P.No.4 1351 of 2022 and in o a rtic q lar oara Nos.4
oSar
xtract d her
der:-
4. It is submitted that, the following a rticle I
framed against the
petitioner
cha rges/im puta tions as below:-
on
a. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Kanduk I
charges were
he following
Divislon has
reported that, as per basic Revenue Records i.c. Khasra Pahani
of Nadergul Village the land in Sy.No.613 exten. qc.373-22gts is
classlfied as "Dasthagardhan,, and Shivaraj Ilal:, is recorded in
Pattadar Column.
b. On perusal of the mutation orders date J 24-O9 -2OL6
gassgd by the Deputy Collector & Tahsitdar, Saroornagar
Mandal, the following lacunas noticed arrr also pasied
orders without following the laid down procedure as
contemplated in the ROR Act & Rules ancl also violating
the time to time instructions issued b1 the District
Administration.
i) The classification of the land Sy.No.613 is clearly shown in
base record i.e., Khasra Pahani (i954-55) is Dasthugardhan and
no ORCs were issued by the competent authority.
ii) No orders were issued from the Government for
implementation of Apex court orders dated 09-10-2015 as the
entire land of Ac.373-22 gts was handed over to the APIIC in the
year 2007 for development of Hardware Park.
iii) The land is notified in 22-A Prohibitory Properties maintalned
by the Registration Department.
iv) No orders were received from the competent authority denotifying the subject land from 22-A Prohibitory Properties.
v) The Deputy Collector & Tahsildar, Saroornagar has failed to
verify the ground status and occupation of the land claiming by
the companies.
vi) The Deputy Collector & Tahsildar, Saroornagar has passed
mutation orders without verifying the ceiling aspect.
vii) The Deputy Collector & Tahsildar being the custodian of land
records, should have verified the ground possession with
reference to the revenue records before granting of mutation
against the interest of Government.
viii) The Deputy Collector & Tahsildar being the custodian of land
records, should have verified the ground possession with
reference to the revenue records before granting of mutation
against the interest of Government.
5. It is submitted that, the petitioner herein would have wait
under the approval from the Government when there is a huge
extent of Government land is involved before passing mutation
orders and also passed the mutation orders without denotiFying
the subject lands from the 22-A Register by competent authority
which is a grave irregularity.
6. It is submitted that, according to rule 20 (2) ot the CCA rules
whenever the disciplinary authority is of the opinion that there
are grounds for enquiring into the truth of any imputation of
misconduct or misbehavior against a government servant it may
inqulry into or appoint under this rule as th( case may be
authority to enquire into the truth thereof. The tt:puty Collector
& Tahsildar has shown clearly dereliction of dLr ies and sheer
negligence towards his duty has violated the a I ove rules has
caused cumbersome litigations by passing the rr utation orders
involving 150 acres of Land whose original cl r ;sification was
Dastugardhan and vests with the Governrr:rt unless a
declaration under ceiling on holdings Act was marl,
7. It is submitted thai, as per the TSCS C(l \ rules, every
subordinate employee is governed by certa n rules and
regulations which are meant to be scrupulously f rllowed, but in
this case Sri G. Venkateshwarlu the then Depu.' Collector and
Tahsildar Saroornagar Mandal is trying to escr le by quoting
certain general rules from the root cause of the ssue as stated
supra just merely based on a decree of the cour: This authority
has high respect towards the Judiciary. Being a l) rputy Collector
Rank the Officer ought to have taken steps oth€ r than passing
the mutation orders and creating an unwantc(l litigation over
valuable Government interested lands. Therefo', , it is humbly
prayed to restore the departmental action vide ., O RT 348., Dt
04.17.2022., in the interest oF lustice and irr he interest of
protecting huge govern ment interest.
B. It is submitted that, there is nothing to l- t ld against the
individual unilaterally if it is not proved against im. As alleged
by the petitioner herein, Yes, the individual mt, have recently
promoted to the post of SGDC, just by calling or Explanation
means arbitrariness and mere questioning the a: of the Deputy
Collector will never cause to injustice and not I. all cause any
irreparable loss if enquiry precedes his fear (,1 losing service
benefits and the earlier W. P will become infructu ) ls is just a fear
of the Deputy Collector and nothing but r thholding this
authority from exercising its statutory powers . nd diluting the
g ravity of the case.
DISCUS ION AND CONCLU SION:-
t7
7,
The learned senior desi qnated counsel aooearinq on
behalf of the petitioner mainlv outs-forth the followinq
submissions in s u DD ort of the petitioner's case.
i)
The present set of writ petitions arise out of disciplinary
action initiated against the Petitioner in connection with mutation
orders dated 24.09.20L6 passed while petitioner was holding the
post of Deputy Collector & Tahsildar, Saroornagar lvlandal, Ranga
Reddy District, in compliance with final judicial decrees of the
High Court and Supreme Court.
ii) On 30.04.2007, the Principal District Judge, Ranga Reddy
District dismissed O.S. No. 155 of 2005 filed by one Pratab Karan
and 16 others seeking declaration oF title, injunction, and
rectification of revenue records for land in Sy. No. 613, Nadergul
Village.
iii)
On 19-12-2011 in A.S. No.274 of 2O07, this Court, by
majority opinion, reversed the trial court's judgment and decreed
the suit in favour of the plalntiffs. On 09.10.2015, the Supreme
Court in Civil Appeal Nos. 2963 &2964 of 2013 upheld the High
Court's judgment, thus finalising the title oF the plaintiFfs.
iv) On 01.09.2014, the decree-holders sold 50 acres each to
M/s Omega Development Ventures Pvt. Ltd. and M/s AIfa Estate
Holding Pvt. Ltd. Thereafter, on 08.02.2016, lre purchasers
applied for mutation of their names in the re' enue records.
Between February and September 2016, the F:titioner while
discharging his duties sought objections from ti
=
public, legal
opinion from the Government Pleader, and instrLr, tions from the
Government and the District Administration, but rowever failed
to receive any response.
v) On 24.09.2016, under threat of contempt nd in view of
binding decrees, the Petitioner passed three mut rtion orders in
favour of the purchasers, very clearly stipulatir ( that the said
orders are subject to claims of third parties, outcc me of pending
cases, and further Government instructions.
vi) Based on these mutations, the purchasers ap plied for NALA
conversion, which was rejected by the RDO, Iandukur. The
purchasers thereafter challenged the same by 1i ing W. P. Nos.
2247I,22487 &.22489 of 2019 and the same w,r;dismissed by
this Court on 72.02.2020.
vii) Curiously on 19.02.2020, the District Collector Ranga Reddy
District, issued proceedings in File No.A3l996/2A',0 initiating an
enquiry against the Petitioner. Challenging tt e same, the
Petitioner filed W.P. No. 19591 of 2022. On 27 04.2022, this
Court granted interim suspension of the impugned proceedings,
dated t9.02.2020, very clearly observing that the
implementation of a final Supreme Court decree cannot amount
to misconduct
viii)
While the said writ petition was still pending, on
04.11.2022, the State Government issued G.O.Rt. No.348
initiating departmental proceedings against the petitioner under
Rule 20 of the Telangana CCA Rules on the same subject,
framing the same articles of charge and calling for the
petitioner's explanation.
ix) The petitioner approached this Court aggrieved by the said
action by filing W.P. No.41351 of 2022. On 14.71.2022, this
Court granted interim suspension of G.O.Rt. No. 348 for a period
of four(04) four weeks, observing that the proceedings initiated
vide the impugned G.O.Rt.No.34B, dated 04.71.2022 were
contrary to the earlier order granted in favour of the petitioner,
dated 27.04.2022 passed in W.P.NO.19591 of 2022 filed by the
petitioner on an earlier occasion. The interim orders granted in
W.P.No.4135]' of 2022 were ordered to be continued until further
orders vide order of this Court, dated 02.03.2023 and the said
orders are in force as on date.
x) In view of the fact that the impugned o roceedings in
File No.A31996/2O2O, dated L9.O2.2O2O :-ejudged and
predetermined the subject issue against I he petitioner
herein at the threshold of show-cause noti :e itself, the
entire enquiry would be rendered a futile ext rcise.
xi) The impugned proceedings, dated 19.() l.2020 of the
District Collector, Ranga Reddy District, in File No.
A3/996/2O2O, clearly indicate that the disciplinary
Authority had prejudged the subject iss ue, and any
enquiry, if allowed to be conducted, would r lventuatly put
the petitioner into serious hardship.
xii) The petitioner discharged his duties, or lV taking into
consideration the verdict of the Apex Court and the three
mutation orders passed by the petitioner clearly stipulated that
the said orders were subject to claims by - t1 pa rties, the
outcome of the pending cases and furtl-e r Government
instructions, and hence, there is no illegality wi , respect to the
charges alleged against the petitioner and the impugned
proceedings, dated 19.02.2O2O of the District ( ollector, Ranga
Reddy District. Accordingly, the petitioner is entit ed for the reliet
2t
as prayed for by the petitioner in W.P.No.l959l of 2022 and the
W.P.no.19591 of 2022 needs to be allowed as prayed for.
xiii) The W.P.No.41351 of 2022 had been filed by the petitioner
challenging the G.O.Rt.No.34B, dated 04.11.2022, issued under
the Rule 20 of the Telangana CCA Rules on the same subject,
framing the same articles of charge and calling for the
petitioner's explanation. In view of the fact that this Court had
already granted stay in favour of the petitioner vide its order,
dated 27.04.2022 passed in W.P.No.19591 of 2022, the
subsequent departmental proceedings initiated against the
petitioner under Rule 20 are only intended to harass the
petitioner, indicating a colourable exercise of power, and are
arbitrary and in violation of the orders of this Court, dated
27.04.2022 passed in favour of the petitioner in W.P.No.19591 of
Based on the aforesaid submissions, the learned
senior desiqnated counsel aooearinq on behalf of the
petitioner contends that W.P.Nos. 19591 & 41351 ot 2()22
need to be allowed as praved for bv the petitioner in the
present writ oetitions.
l
8.
Learned G overnment Plea der for S ervt( :r rs-I aDoearino
onb ehalf of the res ondents on the othe f h nd
I
acin
rel lance o nthea verme nts mad eint he cc rnte r affid av it
r.!
filed bv the 1't res ondent in W.P.No.19
L of 2022
mainlv Duts-f ort h the followinq submiss lons: -
i) fhe articles of charge were framed against t le petitioner in
view of the fact that the petitioner did not aw, t the approval
From the Government prior to issuing the sr tject mutation
orders.
ii) The huge extent of Government,s land is involved and
therefore, the approval of the competent Autl ority i.e., the
Government is necessa ry
iii) As per Rule 20(2) of the Telangana CCA R I es, whenever
the disciplinary authority is of the opinion that the -e are grounds
for enquiring into the truth of misconduct c r misbehaviour
against the Government servant, the responclr nts have the
power to conduct an enquiry and to go into truth : rereof.
iv) The petitioner created an unwanted litigatio- over valuable
Government interested lands by passlng mutation orders instead
of informing the Government and taking necess 3 .y steps other
than passing mutation orders. Hence, the writ petition is not
maintainable against fhe charge memo
v) The o etitioner aooroach d this Court at a
staoe ft is not corre cttos a
rematu re
that the Authori t sa lread v
arrived at a con clusion with a Dre-determin ed mind, when
in fac t nothinq has been held aqainst the Detitio ner exceDt
th e issuance of a charoe memo and callinq for the
etitioner'
x
been issued
ation. It is onl
h
e memo that h
llinq for Detitioner's exDl anation, and the
can submit
titioner's case. In
n
's ex lanation d I n
f submittin
n
x
nation
the Deti tioner aooroached t his Court hastilv bv filinq the
present writ petition.
vi) Since a huge extent of Government land is involved and
since the petitioner passed mutation orders without consulting
the Government, the Disciplinary Authorities by exercising their
powers, have rightly initiated Departmental proceedings by way
of framing specific charges against the petitioner, calling for an
explanation from the petitioner. There is no illegality in the
action of respondents herein. The Apex Court, in the judgment
reported in 2006 ( 12) SCC 28 between Union of India Vs.
Kunisetty Satyanarayana, categorically held that the writ does
not lie against a charge memo or show cause n::ice, since the
charge memo or show cause notice does not gi ,e rise to any
cause of action as it does not adversely affect tir, rights of any
party.
vii)
Th e learned Governme
ADDEA fln o on behalf of
t Pleader f rr Services-I
t he r es D ondents in: i rooort of his
su bmissions olaced relia nce on the followir I r Apex Court
iudqments:-
i) In State of U. P. Vs. Brahma Datt Sharnr r, reported in
r9e7Q) SCC 179
ii) In Secretary, Ministry of Defence & Others Vs. Prabhash
Chandra Mirdha reported in 2012(11) SC( 565
iii) In State of Orissa Vs. Sangam Jeshari lvli:; a, reported in
2010 (13) SCC 311
iv) in Union of India Vs. Upendra Singh report rd in 1994 (3)
SCC 357
Lea rn e
d Government Pleader I r r Services- I
aooearino on be half of the resoondents on t I
ther hand
Dlacinq reliance on th e averments made ir the counter
affidavit filed bv the 4th respondent in W. ll No.41351 of
2O22, mainlv puts-forth the followinq submi ;;ions:-
i) On perusal of the mutation orders granted by the petitioner,
dated 24.09.2016, certain lacunas came to light since the
petitioner passed the orders without following the laid down
procedure as contemplated under the ROR Act & Rules, in
violation of the instructions issued from time to time by the
District Administration. Further, the subject land is a huge extent
of Government land and the petitioner passed mutation orders
without denotifying the subject lands from the 22-A Register by
competent Authority, which amounts to a grave irregularity,
without intimating to the Government and without obtaining
approval from the Government.
ii) The departmental action lnitiated against the petitioner vide
G.O.Rt.No.34B, dated 04.11.2022 is in the interest of justice and
for protecting huge government interest. Although, the same
had been stayed by this Court, in view of the fact that the
subject lands are valuable Government lands, the disciplinary
proceedings initiated against the petltioner are warranted and
necessary. There is no illegality in the action inltiated by the
responcients against the petitioner. Therefore, the interim orders
granted in favour of the petitioner, dated 27.04.2022 passed in
W.P.No-19591 of 2022 and the interim order, dated 14.I7.2022
n
passed in W.P.No. 41351 of 2O2Z need to be yacated in the
interest of justice and the wnt petitions need to tr, d;tr'rr"O
Based
on the aforesaid sub mtssrons th e lea rned
L
Govern ment Pleade r for Service s-I aDDearirr, I on beh alf of
the res pondents contends that the
,etition er ln
W .P,Nos.195 91 & 413s L ot 2O22 is not er 1:itled for anv
relief as orav ed for bv the oetition er in th € DT esent writ
petitio n s.
DISCUS ION AND C ONCLUSION:10
A bare o erusal o f the subiect c olumn I eferred to in
the impuoned notice, dated 19.02.2020_ of the 3.d
resoondent i ssu ed to the pet itioner clearlv i ndicat es that
the
f the dis ci olina rv action aqain t the
herein was for the reason th rt petitioner
in itiatio n
Petitioner
recom mended illeo allv to orant mutation ir Governm ent
land. T he above ob servations in t h e su biect 1 olumn of the
order imDu qned in the Drese nt writ or::ition, dated
L9.O2 .2020 itself i n d icates that disciolinarv I ruthori tv had
un
ilater allv conclu ded the en o u!
oetition er
ut
holditro
that the
had illeo allv recomme nded tl e qrant of
oninG V
n
ent lan
P
r
N
6 of the im u ned
vt
No.A3l996/2O20 dat ed 19.02.2O2O of the 3'd respondent
is extracted he reu n der: -
6. Attention of Sri.G. Venkateshwarlu, Deputy Collector &
Tahsildar, Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District is
invited to Rule 24 of the A.P. Civil Services (Conduct)
Rules 1964, under which no Government Servant shall
bring or attempt to bring any political or out side
influence to bear upon any superior Authority to further
his interest in respect of matters pertaining to his services
under the Government. If any representation is received
on his behalf from another person in respect of any matter
deal within these proceedings it will be presumed that
Sri.G.Venkateshwarlu, Deputy Collector & Tahsildar,
Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District is aware of
such a representation and that it has been made at her
instance and action will be taken against her for violation
of Rule 24 of the APCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.
t2.
A ba
D
erusal o f oara No.6 ( refer r e d to and
extracted above ) of th e imouoned ord r of the 3'd
resoondent h rein. dated 19.02.2O20 cl arlv indicates
that the 3'd
soondent is biased aqainst the oetitioner.
The oetitioner is warned that action w ould be taken
r Rule 24 ot the APCS
(Conduct) Rules, 1964 co ntendinq that if the Detitioner
aqainst t he petitioner
il
attemDts to brinq anv polit ica I or out side influence to
bear uo on anv suoerior Authori tv to furt her anv interest in
resDect
f matters oertainin o to oetitioner's servtces
under the Government, it wou ld be oresul red th at the
petitioner herein as a are of such a reDre: ; lntation, and
that action would be initiated aoainst the peL tioner.
13. Th s ourt oDines th at the initiation 1f disciplinarv
proceedinqs aoainst the oetitioner at the _ threshold of
s h o w -cau
noti ce
Dre-determined and
ts e f
indica te
a
_ pre-iudoed,
biased aooroach
aqa in st
the
oetitioner herein,
L4. This Court ooines that th e iustice shotr d not onlv be
done. bu t also manifest
seem to be dorr
n
in the
present case, admittedl v as borne on recor q, the same is
not ind icated and therefore. t his Court vic e its i nterim
orders, dated 24.(J7.2022 in W.P.No.19591 of 2022 verv
clearlv observed that mer elv because oerm i: sion was not
obtaaned from th e Government for imol t mentin q the
iudqment of the Aoex Court, it cannot be said t hat the
orovisions of the Act and the Rules ma ! e thereunder
alono with the instructions issued bv
h
istrict
Administration were to be ionored and the 5 rme does not
amount to misconduct, since th e recordin< Aut[ority is
rs
fth
Civi Court a
sa I of the im u
ed
.o.R .No 48
ent he or
Ie
er
Section I of the Act.
15. A ba e
te
indi
h
he
m
h
be
nts ue tr
a
ans
he
eti
ne
wh nt
ofc
o
init ted
tr
n
tt
al
tn
rti
le
c
w
elf
loner
d
su sDen ed bvt he ord ero f thi sCo urt. d ated
fin
ad
ts
a
le
1ot 2022
.19
P
n
rs
a
.o4.
a
nd when th
ma er
u
di
final
rca
n
ls
urt
tio
of he
rli
at
th
ition r
w.P No.
591 of
t
t isC rt
fa our ln
endin
eDar tme tal
s
20 2
t
tn
hi
fi
ist
r lc
1l
n
roce edin osh dbe en
he or ers ass
.P.N o.19 91
n
tn
et
ne
f20 22 filed !n Aoril 2022b v
th e oetiti oner he rei n and to circum vent the s ame
w
tn
o
vl
onl to
e
t
fi
f v r
ln iate
e
isC u rt. tn
f
nt
aid
es
.o4.2022
ee
hic ha
io
OD ines that the
cle a rlv
resp ond ent No.1,
bv the
04.11 2022 Das ed
d
a
ln
u nwa rr
J
witho ut
hes idw P.N .19
nted a nd
nca I
t r
f
16. In the A oex Court Judqme nt reDortec in( 2010) 13
SCC 427 in Orvx Fisheries Pvt., Ltd., Vs. Ur irn of India &
Others, in particular a t Dara Nos,24,27.29, i1, 32 & 33-!t
is observed as under :
"It is well settled that a quasi-judicial authoi i , , while acting in
exercise of its Statutory power must act fairly : rd must act with
an open mind while initiating a show-cause pr > eeding. A showcause proceeding is meant to give the person Ioceeded against
a reasonable opportunity of making his objc, tion against the
proposed charges indicated in the notice. (Par;r 24).
At the staqe of s how-cause, the o, : son proceecled
aqainst must be told the charoes aoains: him so that he
can take his defence a nd orove his in rrr cence. At that
staoe the authoritv issuino the charor h et cannot
instead of tellinq him the charoes. cor l ront him with
def inite eoncluslons slhis allesed-slJiluf that is done, as
ha< hap n do n tn f he resent case th e J tire proceeding
h
show-ca use n t e ! ts vitiated by
unfairness and bia and the subseou 3lt Droceedinos
P
m anr le ceremon
Justice is rooted in confidence and just ( c is the goal of a
quasi-judicial proceeding also. If the funct. r ing of a quasijudicial authority has to inspire confidence in I rr: minds of those
subjected to its jurisdiction, such authority m l t act with utmost
fairness. Its fairness is obviously to be r' rnifested by the
language in which charges are couched an,l conveyed to the
person proceeded a g a inst.
In the present case, from the show-cause notice it is clear
that the third respondent, Deputy Director, MPEDA HAS
demonstrated a totally closed mind at the stage of show-cause
notice itself. Such a closed mind is inconsistent with the scheme
of Rule 43 of the MPEDA Rules. (Para 29).
It is true that the show-cause notice cannot be read
hyper technically and it is well settled that it is to be read
reasonably. But, while reading a show-cause notice the person
who is subject to it must get an impression that he will get an
effective opportunity to rebut the allegataons contained in the
show-cause notice and prove his innocence. If on a reasonable
reading oF a show-cause notice a person of ordinary prudence
gets the feeling that his reply to the show-cause notice will be
an empty ceremony and he will merely knock his head against
the impenetrable wall of prejudged opinion, such a show-cause
notice does not commence a fair procedure especially when it is
issued in a quasi-judicial proceeding under a statutory
regulation which promises to give the person proceeded against
a reasonable opportunity oi deicncc. (para 31).
Therefora- while issuin o a show -c ause notice
t he
authorities must take care to manifestlv keeo an ooen
mind as thev are to act fairl v in adiudqinq the quilt or
otherwise of the person proceeded aoainst and soecially
when the authoritv has the power to take a punitive step
aqainst the Derson after qivinq him a show- cause notice.
(para 32)
The principle that justice must not only be done but
it must eminently appear to be done as well is equally
applicable to quasi-judicial proceeding if such a
proceeding has to inspire confidence in the I lind of those
who are subject to it. (Para 33)"
vide
N
ne
rau eno lce
sho
.A3/ 996/2020 dat ed 19. 02.2 O2O i:;;ue dto the
the 3'dr esoon dent and th !
Det itione rbv
o
f the im
eru al
bar
22 iss
o .11.
at
.No
imDuqned
the 1rt
bv
Dasse d
res oonde nt cle arlv i ndica tes t hat t e same vere
eiud qrnq the
Dre- deter minin q he su biec t lSSU eth rebv or
as ( b v the Hiqh
es ea I the r lev nt order
tte
Cou r
th
an
Co
A e
rto
th
rss ue. t he
ec t
s
! conclusion'
titi ner
ha
he
the
Gove rnme nt
err ne
sl
e
wit
li
ut
inst tl ! :
aq
Droce eded
tio
I )Droval f rom
ekin
with ut
of
ind
Detitioner
lna
ro uti ne
! re Petitioner
he retn of the r eason able oppo rtunitv ofd
sta qe of iss uanc
of
a sho w -ca u se
n () tce,
resDo ndent mu st take care to manife stlv
ind
th
rd
s
nd nt is
x
d
rl'ence. At the
I ee
the 3'd
ano en
1:t fairlv while
proceeded
adiudqinq the quilt or otherwise of the Derg on
with the
aoainst, esDeciallv when the authoritv is v( sted
wer to ak
a
u
ive a ion
ain
s (: l Derson a fter
a sho w -ca use no tice. The pr inciple of natu ral
t u tic be done utt at
ired oto
tce r
ear to hav b en one Th
lne
al
mu
urnq
Dfl nciD le as eq uallv ap lica ble
DE
5 nce
st
ne ess ril
resp onde nt
3td res
nde
lns ire c nfid nce in t h e mind
ft
rocee ln
he
re n
to the 3 rd
lss edb th
tit ioner, who as su bi ected to it, the o rders tm uqned
how ver
on
aki
18.
ln
at
m
he
c nsid rati n
a) The aforesaid facts and circumstances of the case'
b) The submissions put-forth by the learned senior
the
designated counsel aPPearing on behalf of
petitioner
and learned Government Pleader for
Services-I appearing on behalf of the respondents
on
record.
The averments made in the counter affidavit filed on
of the respondent No'1 in W'P'Nos'19591 &
c)
behalf
41351 of 2022 (referred to and extracted above)
d)
The averments made in the counter affidavit filed
on
behalf of the respondent No'4 in W'P'Nos'41351 of
2022 (referced to and extracted above)
I
e) The interim orders granted in favour of the
petitioner'
dated 27.O4.2(.22 passed in W'P'No'1959' of 2022
(referred to and extracted above) which art: in force as
on date.
f) The interim orders granted in favour of thr: petitioner'
dated 14.11.2O22 passed in W'P'No'4135i of 2022'
which are in force as on date (referred to an I extracted
above), which are in force as on date'
g) The allegations made against the petitioner :hat orders
were passed by the petitioner without fr: lowing the
procedure contemplated under the A'P' Rig hts in Land
And Pattadar Passbooks Act, 1971 and tht: rules
made
thereu nd e r
h) The fact that proceedings were initiate(l against the
petitioner ignoring the fact pleaded by th e petitioner
thatthemutationproceedingsmadebyttepetitioner
to the
vide order, dated 22'09'2016 were in purt;' rance
judgment of the Apex Court in Civil Appea No'2963 of
2013, dated 09.10.2015, duly taking into c cnsideration
the judgment of this Court in A'S'No'274 ol 2OO7'
dated
L9.Lz.zOLL, since the matter had attained finality in
A.S.No.274 of 2OO7, dated 19.12.2011 and the same
was confirmed by the Apex Court vide judgment ,dated
09.1O.2015 in C.A.No.2963 of 2O13 and as a recording
Authority, the petitioner had only discharged his duty'
i) The contents of the impugned proceedings vide File
No.A3l996/202O, dated 19.02.2020 passed by the 3'd
respondent in W.P.No.1959L of 2022.
j) The contents of the impugned G.O.Rt'No.348, dated
O4.LL.2O22 passed by the 1't respondent in
w.P.No.41351 of 2O22(referred to and extracted
above)
k) The judgment of the Apex Court reported in (201O) 13
SCC 427 in Oryx Fisheries Pvt., Ltd,, Vs. Union of India)
(referred to and extracted above)
l) The discussion and conclusion as arrived at para Nos.1O
to 17 of the present order,
m)
The averments made in the counter affidavit filed bv
the 1"t respo ndent in W.P.No.19591 of 2022 in
particular at para No.7, which indicates a specific stand
that it is not a case that lhe Authoraties ha d alreadv
r
ed at conclu
a
ainst the
n
r herein with
ore-determin ed mind and that nothinq ha d been held
aq ainst the petitioner exceot is uinq char< I : memo, and
ca llin ofo ranex D lan ation, o rl ines that th e _ ;aid stand is
no t convincino, in vie w of the clear word s indicated in
the imouqned charqe memo , dated 19.O:l 2O2O issued
by the 3'd resoondent herein concludin, ) unilaterallv
that the oetitioner ha d illeqallv re commenc ed the qrant
of mutation in G overnment land.
n) The intimation to the Detitioner, that pror eedin qs will
be issued aoains t the Detitioner under R q le 24 of the
APCS Conduct rules, 1964, if anv reDrc sentation is
received on oetitioner' s behalf from anotl" er oerson in
resoect of subi ect matter and further thal . then in such
2C
+rr2+
n
tri t action would
lnl t t+6 ( aqainst the
oetitioner for violatio n of Rule 24 of the A t CS(conduct)
Rules. 1964. indicat e a clear bias on th e
resoondent Authori ties in
roceedin
s
art of the
initiatinq _ disciplinarv
n
o) Ion o ri no the orders of the Hiqh Court ;r r
the A ex
Court pertaininq to the subiect la n ds with a
termined a
Droceed ed
roach
the 3'd res ondent havin
n ilatera llv.
Hence, this Court opines that petitioner is entitled
for qrant of relief as Draved for in the Dresent writ
petition.
Both the Writ Petitions are allowed as Draved for. The
imouoned order,
dated
L9.O2.2O2O in
File
No.A3l996/2O20 Dassed b v the 3'd resoondent in
W.P.No.19591 of 2022 and t he imouoned order. dated
.1L.2 22 in G.O.Rt.No.348
assed b th
st
n
n
aqainst the petitioner in W.P.No.41351 ot 2022 herein are
set-a sid e.
It is however observed that it i s orren to t h e
resoondents herein to initiate action aqainst the
e
ti
if
r
n
in accordance to law, in
nt intend to do so but strictl
nformitv with orincioles of
natural iustice, However, there shall be no order as to
costs.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pendinc in this Writ
Petition, shall stand closed.
SD/. K.MADHAVI
ASSI ;TANT RE TSTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTIOfud.FFICER
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble MRS JUSTICE SURET', rLLl NANDA
(For Her Ladyships Kind Perusal)
To,
'1
. The Chief Secretary, Revenue Department, Secretariat at Hyderabad, State
of Telangana.
1. The Principal Secretary, Revenue Department, Secr: ariat at Hyderabad,
State of Telangana.
2. The Chief Commissioner of Land Administration, (CCLA) Nampally,
Hyderabad-TS
3. The District Collector, Ranga Reddy District At Lakdikap r ol, Hyderabad-TS
4. 11 LR Copies
5. The Under Secretary, Union of lndia, Ministry of Law, . ustice and Company
Affairs, New Delhi.
6. The Secrelary, Telangana Advocates Association, -ibrary, High Court
Buildings, Hyderabad.
7. One CC to SIVT P CHANDANA, Advocate [OPUC]
8. Two CCs to GP FOR SERVICES-|, High Court for the ;tate of Telangana at
Hyderabad [OUT]
9. Two CD Copies
BS
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2910112026
(-
o .-:
J/ tt
(
COMMON ORDER
WP.Nos.19591 & 41351 of 2022
\ur
04 f :8 'tfr6
::.
\ \.1.:t...
\..'\.r, -'i
ALLOWING BOTH THE WRIT PETITIOT\I J,
WITHOUT COSTS
at
a
vz
c)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review