Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 3RD DAY OF MARCH, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
WRIT PETITION NO.36088 OF 2025 (EDN-RES)
BETWEEN:
G.R.MEDICAL COLLEGE AND HOSPITAL
AND RESEARCH CENTRE,
43846, KARAVALI COLLEGE BUILDING,
NEAR KOTTARA CHOWKI, MANGALURU,
KARNATAKA – 575 013
AUTHORISED SIGNATORY / AO
MR.MOHAMMED SABITH M.,
S/O LATE ABUBAKKAR M.,
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. PRABHULING K. NAVADGI, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
MISS. SANJEEVINI P. NAVADGI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
Digitally
signed by
CHANDANA
BM
Location:
High Court of
Karnataka
1.
NATIONAL MEDICAL COMMISSION,
POCKET-14, SECTOR- 8, DWARKA PHASE-1,
NEW DELHI – 110 077.
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN
2.
MEDICAL ASSESSMENT AND RATING BOARD,
NATIONAL MEDICAL COMMISSION,
POCKET-14, SECTOR- 8, DWARKA PHASE-1,
NEW DELHI – 110 077.
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
3.
UNDERGRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION BOARD,
NATIONAL MEDICAL COMMISSION, POCKET-14,
SECTOR- 8, DWARKA PHASE-1,
NEW DELHI – 110 077.
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. H.R. SHOWRI, ADVOCATE)
-2NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
THIS W.P. IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THE
MAINTENANCE OF STANDARDS OF MEDICAL EDUCATION
REGULATIONS, 2023 NOTIFIED VIDE NOTIFICATION BEARING NO.
F.NO.N-P016/1/2023-PGMEB-NMC DATED 19TH SEPTEMBER, 2023
ISSUED BY THE RESPONDENT NO.1 INSOFAR AS IT VESTS THE
RESPONDENT NO.3 UGMEB WITH THE POWER TO UNDERTAKE
THE EVALUATION FOR VERIFYING WHETHER THE MEDICAL
COLLEGE OR MEDICAL INSTITUTION FULFILLS THE REQUIRED
CONDITIONS PRESCRIBED BY WAY OF MSRs OR NMC
REGULATIONS AND POWER TO IMPOSE PENALTIES INCLUDING
DENIAL OF PERMISSION, AS ULTRA-VIRES SECTIONS 26, 28 AND
29 OF THE NATIONAL MEDICAL COMMISSION ACT, 2019.
ANNEXURE- A AND ETC.,
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR FURTHER HEARING, THIS
DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
ORAL ORDER
In this petition, the petitioner seeks the following reliefs:
i. Issue writ in the nature of Mandamus, or any other
appropriate
Writ,
MAINTENANCE
EDUCATION
Order
OF
or
direction,
STANDARDS
REGULATIONS,
declaring
OF
the
MEDICAL
notified
vide
notification bearing NO.F.No.N-P016/1/2023-PGMEB-NMC
dated 19th September, 2023 issued by the Respondent No.1
insofar as it vests the Respondent No.3 -UGMEB with the
power to undertake the evaluation for verifying whether the
medical college or medical institution fulfils the required
conditions prescribed by way of MSRs or NMC Regulations
and power to impose penalties including denial of
permission, as ultra-vires Section 26, 28 and 29 of the
National Medical Commission, Act, 2019. Annexure A
-3NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
ii. Issue writ in the nature of Mandamus, or any other
appropriate Writ, Order or direction, declaring that the
Respondent No.3- UGMEB has no legal authority to
inspect/evaluate any medical institution with respect to
verifying compliance with minimum standards requirements
and is beyond the scope of Section 24 of the National
Medical
Commission
Act,
and
the
power
of
inspection/assessment/evaluation of medical institutions for
compliance with minimum standards requirements is vested
with the Respondent No.2- MARB.
iii. Issue Writ in the nature of Certiorari, or any other
appropriate Writ, Order or direction, and quash the show
cause notice issued by the Respondent No.3 dated
11.05.2025
bearing
No.
Renewal/UGMEB/2023-
24/214.Annexure B.
iv. Issue Writ in the nature of Certiorari, or any other
appropriate Writ, Order or direction, and set-aside the
decision of the Respondent No.3 vide communication/order
dated 30.06.2025 bearing No. Renewal/UGMEB/202324/214.Annexure B1.
v. Issue a Writ in the nature of Mandamus, or any
other appropriate Writ, Order or direction directing the
Respondent No.2 to consider the application submitted by
the Petitioner dated 10.12.2024 along with representation
dated 30.07.2025. Annexure C & C1.
V(a). Issue a Writ in the nature of Certiorari, or any
other appropriate Writ, Order or direction, and set aside the
impugned
order
bearing
No.
Renewal/UGMEB/2025-
-4NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
26/dated 2.01.2026, passed by the Respondent No.3 as
highly arbitrary, illegal, and bad in law. (Annexure R)
vi. Grant such other relief that this Hon'ble Court may
deem fit in the facts and circumstances of the matter.
2.
The petitioner – Institution i.e., ‘G.R. Medical College
and Hospital and Research Centre’ is said to be sponsored and
managed by GR Education Trust ® which comprises of persons
from Tulu linguistic minority and initially established a 330 bedded
medical hospital in Mangalore City, which was proportionately
enhanced to 750 beds as on today.
3.
The
respondent
No.1
is
the
National
Medical
Commission established under the National Medical Commission
Act, 2019 (for short, the ‘NMC Act’). The respondent No.2 is the
Medical Assessment and Rating Board (for short, the ‘MARB’),
constituted under Section 16(1)(c) of the NMC Act. So also, the
respondent No. 3 is the Undergraduate Medical Education Board
(for short, the ‘UGMEB’), constituted under Section 16(1)(a) of the
NMC Act. It is necessary to state that while Section 24 of the NMC
Act provides for powers and functions of UGMEB, the powers and
functions of the MARB are provided under Section 26 of the NMC
Act.
-5NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
4.
It is contended that after due process and being
satisfied with the facilities available, the petitioner – Institution was
initially granted permission by the respondent No.2 – MARB by
Order dated 13.12.2021 in exercise of powers under Sections
26(1)(a) & (b) read with Section 28(1) & (2) of the NMC Act to start
new Medical College of the petitioner for the academic year 20212022. However, renewal was refused in favour of the petitioner for
the academic year 2022–2023, on account of non-compliance of
the infrastructure, etc.,
Further, on 19.09.2023, the respondent
No.1 – NMC exercised its powers under Sections 10, 24, 25 and 57
and framed the Maintenance of Standards of Medical Education
Regulations, 2023 (for short, the said ‘Regulations, 2023’). The
petitioner having submitted an application seeking renewal of
permission for the Academic year 2025-2026 in favour of the
petitioner-Institution, the respondent No.3 – UGMEB issued a
Show Cause Notice dated 11.05.2025 pointing out certain
deficiencies, to which the petitioner submitted a detailed reply
dated 17.05.2025 in pursuance of which respondent No.3 –
UGMEB passed the impugned order dated 30.06.2025 refusing to
grant renewal in favour of the petitioner for the Academic year
-6NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2025-2026. Subsequently, petitioner submitted a representation at
Annexure – C1 dated 30.07.2025 and thereafter approached this
Court by way of the present petition on 28.11.2025 interalia not
only challenging the impugned notice and order but also the
constitutional validity and vires of the said Regulations, 2023 by
seeking the aforesaid reliefs.
5.
During the pendency of the present petition, this
Court passed the following interim order dated 03.12.2025 with the
consent of both sides as hereunder:
“Heard learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner and
learned counsel for the respondents.
2.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
would invite my attention to Sections 16 and 26 of the
National Medical Commission Act, in order to point out that
the 2nd respondent-Medical Assessment and Rating Board is
an independent and autonomous Board conferred with
functions and powers under Section 26 of the NMC Act and
is
distinct
and
different
from
the
3rd
respondent-
Undergraduate Medical Education Board, which is also an
independent/autonomous Board conferred with specific
powers and functions under Section 24 of the NMC Act and
both Boards are independent and mutually exclusive of each
other. It is further submitted that the impugned Notification
at Annexure-A dated 19.09.2023 containing the NMC
-7NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Regulations is illegal, arbitrary and ultravires the provisions
of the NMC Act since they seek to traverse beyond the
scope and powers conferred upon respective Boards under
Sections 16, 24 and 26 of NMC Act. It is also contended
that since it is the 2nd respondent-Board which has granted
initial permission to establish respondent-Institution, 3rd
respondent-Board does not have jurisdiction or authority of
law to either issue impugned show-cause notice or consider
the request for issuance of Renewal Certificate or for
continuation of the Course by the petitioner-College and
same would have to be necessarily done by the 2nd
respondent-MARB.
3.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents submits that apart from the fact that the
petitioner had responded to the show-cause notice issued by
3rd respondent – Board, the petitioner would not be entitled
to challenge the jurisdiction of 3rd respondent –Board to
grant renewal, which is permissible under Section 24(1)(i) of
the NMC Act and the Regulations.
4.
Submissions of both sides are placed on
record.
5.
Though several contentions have been urged
by both sides in support of their respective claims, by way of
an interim arrangement and without prejudice to the rights
and contentions of the parties, the 2nd respondent-Medical
Assessment and Rating Board is hereby directed to conduct
an independent evaluation of the Annual Disclosure Report
submitted by the petitioner and also conduct physical
-8NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
inspection of the premises of the petitioner-Institution and
submit a report in this regard, by the next date of hearing.
Re-list on 10.12.2025.
6.
In pursuance of the aforesaid order, the respondent
No.2 – MARB submitted an Inspection Assessor’s Report, the
summary of which was recorded by this Court in its interim order
dated 16.12.2025 as hereunder:
Learned counsel for the respondents has filed a memo
dated 16.12.2025 enclosing a copy of the inspection assessor's
report, the summary of which reads as under:
"Summary as per the Assessor's report1.
Faculty deficiency - 2.68%
2.
OPD on the day of assessment- 1060 (average
of past three days-1216/1214/1208).
3.
Bed occupancy on the day of assessment- 65%
(average of past three days- 89.42/87.11/89)
4.
College infrastructure- adequate
5.
Availability of equipment in each departmentadequate
6.
Hostel facility- adequate
7.
Committees- adequate
8.
Skill lab-adequate
9.
Teaching facility- adequate
10.
Research lab-adequate
11.
Hospital infrastructure- adequate
12.
Clinical material-adequate
13.
Investigations-adequate
14.
Variety of surgical procedures- adequate"
-9NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner submits that
respondent Nos.2 and 3 may be directed to take a decision, as
expeditiously as possible.
Learned counsel for the respondents submits that a
decision would be taken by the concerned respondent on or
before, by the next dater of hearing.
Re-list the matter on 18.12.2025 at 2:30 p.m.
7.
Subsequently, vide impugned order dated 02.01.2026,
the respondent No.3 once again upheld its earlier decision dated
30.06.2025 thereby denying the grant of renewal of 150 MBBS
seats for Academic Year 2025-2026 in favour of the petitioner –
Institution, which accordingly got the petition amended and
assailed this impugned order also. Under these circumstances,
petitioner is before this Court by way of the present petition.
8.
The
respondents
have
filed
their
statement
of
objections disputing and denying the claim of the petitioner and
sought for dismissal of the petition.
The petitioner has filed its
rejoinder reiterating its earlier contentions and refuting the defence
of the respondents.
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
9.
Heard Sri. Prabhuling K. Navadgi, learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner and Sri. H.R.Showri, learned counsel for
the respondents and perused the material on record.
10.
The petitioner has also filed written submissions, which
are as under:
3. ISSUES FOR CONSIDERATION
The following issues arise for consideration:
A. Whether a true and correct interpretation of the
provisions of the National Medical Council Act, 2019
disclose as to whether the Respondent No. 3/ the
UGMEB is vested with any power to grant/refuse
renewal of permission to an undergraduate medical
institution?
B. Whether the regulations framed by the National
Medical Commission in particular the Maintenance of
Standards of Medical Education Regulations, 2023 are in
conflict with the provisions of the Act thereby making
them ultra-vires of the Act?
C. Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case,
the order of the UGMEB refusing to grant permission for
the Petitioner Institution for the academic year 20252026 is sustainable in law?
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
A. Whether a true and correct interpretation of the
provisions of the National Medical Council Act, 2019
disclose as to whether the Respondent No. 3/ the
UGMEB is vested with any power to grant/refuse
renewal of permission to an undergraduate medical
institution?
14. The National Medical Commission Act, 2019 replaced
the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, creating four
autonomous boards with distinct statutory functions.
15. The moot question in the facts of the present case is, as
to whether the power to inspect and grant renewal/refusal
of permission vest with the UGMEB. The powers and
duties of UGMEB are traced to Section. 24 which reads
as under:
“24. Powers and functions of Under-Graduate
Medical Education Board.—
(1) The Under- Graduate Medical Education
Board shall perform the following functions,
namely:—
(a)
determine
education
at
standards
of
undergraduate
medical
level
and
oversee all aspects relating thereto;
(b) develop competency based dynamic
curriculum
at
undergraduate
level
in
accordance with the regulations made under
this Act;
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
(c) develop competency based dynamic
curriculum for addressing the needs of
primary health services, community medicine
and family medicine to ensure healthcare in
such areas, in accordance with the provisions
of the regulations made under this Act;
(d) frame guidelines for setting up of
medical
institutions
for
imparting
undergraduate courses, having regard to the
needs of the country and the global norms, in
accordance
with
the
provisions
of
the
regulations made under this Act;
(e) determine the minimum requirements
and standards for conducting courses and
examinations for undergraduates in medical
institutions, having regard to the needs of
creativity at local levels, including designing of
some courses by individual institutions, in
accordance
with
the
provisions
of
the
regulations made under this Act;
(f) determine standards and norms for
infrastructure, faculty and quality of education
in
medical
institutions
undergraduate
medical
accordance
the
with
providing
education
provisions
regulations made under this Act;
of
in
the
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
(g) facilitate development and training of
faculty
members
teaching
undergraduate
courses;
(h) facilitate research and the international
student and faculty exchange programmes
relating to undergraduate medical education;
(i) specify norms for compulsory annual
disclosures, electronically or otherwise, by
medical
institutions,
in
respect
of
their
functions that has a bearing on the interest of
all stakeholders including students, faculty,
the Commission and the Central Government;
(j) grant recognition to a medical qualification
at the undergraduate level.
(2) The Under-Graduate Medical Education
Board may, in the discharge of its duties,
make such recommendations to, and seek
such directions from, the Commission, as it
deems necessary.”
16. A bare reading of Section. 24 would show that the
UGMEB is primarily vested with the power of prescribing
norms
and
guidelines
for
undergraduate
medical
institutions across the country. It is a generic power
vested in the Board for prescribing guidelines and norms
which every medical institution should adhere to. The
power
to
inspect,
grant/refusing
permission
is
conspicuously absent qua medical institution. This power
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
as could be seen from the statement of law to be made
infra vests with MARB.
17. Section. 26 of the National Medical Commission Act, 2019
reads as under:
“26.
Powers
and
functions
of
Medical
Assessment and Rating Board.—
(1) The Medical Assessment and Rating
Board shall perform the following functions,
namely:—
(a) determine the procedure for assessing
and rating the medical institutions for their
compliance with the standards laid down by
the Under-Graduate Medical Education Board
or the Post-Graduate Medical Education
Board, as the case may be, in accordance
with the regulations made under this Act;
(b) grant permission for establishment of a
new medical institution, or to start any
postgraduate course or to increase number of
seats, in accordance with the provisions of
section 28;
(c)
carry
out
inspections
of
medical
institutions for assessing and rating such
institutions
in
accordance
with
the
regulations made under this Act: Provided that
the Medical Assessment and Rating Board
may, if it deems necessary, hire and authorise
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
any other third party agency or persons for
carrying out inspections of medical institutions
for assessing and rating such institutions:
Provided further that where inspection of
medical institutions is carried out by such third
party agency or persons authorised by the
Medical Assessment and Rating Board, it
shall be obligatory on such institutions to
provide access to such agency or person;
(d) conduct, or where it deems necessary,
empanel independent rating agencies to
conduct,
assess
institutions,
and
within
rate
such
all
period
medical
of
their
opening, and every year thereafter, at such
time, and in such manner, as may be
specified by the regulations;
(e) make available on its website or in public
domain
the
assessment
and
ratings
of
medical institutions at regular intervals in
accordance with the regulations made under
this Act;
(f) take such measures, including issuing
warning, imposition of monetary penalty,
reducing intake or stoppage of admissions
and recommending to the Commission for
withdrawal
of
recognition,
against
a
medical institution for failure to maintain
the minimum essential standards specified
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
by the Under-Graduate Medical Education
Board
or
the
Post-Graduate
Medical
Education Board, as the case may be, in
accordance with the regulations made under
this Act.
(2) The Medical Assessment and Rating
Board may, in the discharge of its functions,
make such recommendations to, and seek
such directions from, the Commission, as it
deems necessary.”
18. It could be seen that the power to grant permission is
specifically vested under Section 26(b) of the Act with
MARB. 26(f) provides for power of MARB to take such
measures, including issuing warning, imposition of
monetary penalty, reducing intake or stoppage of
admissions and recommending to the Commission for
withdrawal of recognition, against a medical institution.
19. The concepts of ‘permission’, ‘renewal’, ‘recognition’ and
‘regulatory control’ have definite connotations in law. This
Hon’ble Court may permit the Petitioners to explain the
said concepts as under:
a) Permission: Required before establishment or expansion of
medical colleges.
b) Renewal:
Annual
verification
to
ensure
continued
compliance with standards.
c) Recognition: Final acknowledgement that the degree
granted is valid for registration and practice.
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
d) Regulatory
Control:
Medical
regulators
have
strict
supervisory powers to maintain educational standards.
20. It could therefore be seen that all of these concepts are
mutually exclusive and on plain reading of Section. 26
vests with MARB.
21. It would be incongruous, and an incorrect interpretation of
the provisions of the Act if the power of permission is
granted to one board (in this case MARB) – and the
power of renewal is granted to another board (the
UGMEB).
22. The power to refuse renewal should follow the power to
grant permission. Section 26(f) also includes stoppage of
admissions. In these circumstances, it requires to be held
that the power to grant renewal after granting permission
to a Medical Institution vests with MARB and MARB alone
and not the UGMEB. This is for the reason that the statute
does not contemplate such power. It also requires to be
held the power to grant renewal/ refusal of renewal is not
contemplated under the Act. Once permission is granted
the only measure which any of the regulatory boards
could impose upon a medical institution is to impose
punishments as contemplated under Section 26(f) which
includes stoppage of admissions. Indiscriminate vesting of
power with multiple boards of grant of permissions, would
also be determinant to public interest as medical
education has wide reaching consequences on the
healthcare of the country.
23. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of TMA Pai
Foundation v State of Karnataka (2002) 8 SCC 481,
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
has held that the concept of Medical Education, unlike
other education has a vital bearing on the health care of
the country. See in this regard, as follows:
“54.The right to establish an educational
institution
can
be
regulated;
but
such
regulatory measures must, in general, be to
ensure the maintenance of proper academic
standards,
atmosphere
and
infrastructure
including qualified staff) and the prevention of
maladministration by those in charge of
management. The fixing of a rigid fee
structure,
dictating
the
formation
and
composition of a governing body, compulsory
nomination
of
teachers
appointment
or
nominating
admissions
would
be
and
staff
for
students
for
unacceptable
restrictions.
55.The Constitution recognizes the right of the
individual or religious denomination, or a
religious or linguistic minority to establish an
educational institution. If aid or financial
assistance is not sought, then such institution
will be a private unaided institution. Although,
in Unni Krishnan case the Court emphasized
the important role played by private unaided
institutions and the need for private funding, in
the scheme that was framed, restrictions were
placed on some of the important ingredients
relating to the functioning of an educational
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
institution. There can be no doubt that in
seeking affiliation or recognition, the Board or
the university or the affiliating or recognizing
authority can lay down conditions consistent
with the requirement to ensure the excellence
of education. It can, for instance, indicate the
quality of the teachers by prescribing the
minimum
qualifications
that
they
must
possess, and the courses of study and
curricula. It can, for the same reasons, also
stipulate
the
existence
of
infrastructure
sufficient for its growth, as a prerequisite. But
the essence of a private educational institution
is the autonomy that the institution must have
in its management and administration. There,
necessarily, has to be a difference in the
administration of private unaided institutions
and
the
government-aided
institutions.
Whereas in the latter case, the Government
will have greater say in the administration,
including admissions and fixing of fees, in the
case of private unaided institutions, maximum
autonomy in the day-to-day administration has
to be with the private unaided institutions.
Bureaucratic or governmental interference in
the administration of such an institution will
undermine
its
independence.
While
an
educational institution is not a business, in
order to examine the degree of independence
that can be given to a recognized educational
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
institution, like any private entity that does not
seek aid or assistance from the Government,
and that exists by virtue of the funds
generated
by it,
including
its loans
or
borrowings, it is important to note that the
essential ingredients of the management of
the private institution include the recruiting
students and staff, and the quantum of fee
that is to be charged.”
B.) Whether the regulations framed by the National
Medical Commission in particular the Maintenance of
Standards of Medical Education Regulations, 2023 are in
conflict with the provisions of the Act thereby making
them ultra-vires of the Act?
24. Regulations beyond the power vested under Section. 57 i)
The
Maintenance
of
Standards
of
Medical
Education
Regulations, 2023 have been framed in exercise of the power
granted under Section 57 of the Act. Section 57 of the Act
empowers the commission to frame regulations. The relevant
provision reads as under:
“57. Power to make regulations- (2) In
particular,
and
without
prejudice
to
the
generality of the foregoing power, such
regulations may provide for all or any of the
following matters, namely:—
(r) the minimum requirements and standards
for conducting courses and examinations for
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
undergraduates in medical institutions under
clause (e) of sub-section (1) of section 24;
(s) the standards and norms for infrastructure,
faculty
and
quality
of
education
at
undergraduate level in medical institutions
under clause (f) of sub-section (1) of section
24;
(x) the standards and norms for infrastructure,
faculty and quality of education in medical
institutions
conducting
super-speciality
medical
postgraduate
and
education
under
clause (e) of sub-section (1) of section 25;
(y) the procedure for assessing and rating the
medical institutions under clause (a) of subsection (1) of section 26;
(z) the manner of carrying out inspections of
medical institutions for assessing and rating
such institutions under clause (c) of subsection (1) of section 26”
25. A plain reading of the above provisions would show that
the regulations have to be framed strictly in accordance
with the provisions of the Act. The impugned regulations
now viz Maintenance of Standards of Medical Education
Regulations, 2023 directly run contrary and in the teeth of
the statutory provisions. Whereas the power to inspect
and grant permission and direct stoppage of admissions
is statutorily been made available to MARB under the
regulations. Prior to coming into force these regulations,
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
the power to grant renewal vested with MARB as could be
seen from the regulations framed under Section 10 (a) of
the Medical Council of India Act, 1956. Under Section 60
(iv) of the Act these regulations were brought in and
enforced. In the alternative, it requires to be stated that
since Petitioner Institution was granted permission under
the regulations framed under Section 10(a) of the Act.
Further, those regulations contemplated renewal by
MARB. The power of renewal therefore must be held with
MARB itself by virtue of the regulations framed.
26. Under the impugned regulations, the power to inspect and
impose collective penalties is now vested in the Clause 4,
5 & 8. Clause 7 now provides for grants for renewal
certificates after compliance; these provisions on the face
of it are impermissible to remain as they run directly
contrary to Section. 24 & 26 of the Act. Therefore, the
entire regulations now framed by the National Medical
Council are beyond the power vested in it under Section.
57.
27. Even assuming that such a regulation is held sustainable,
it could be seen that Regulation 7 which vests the power
of grant of renewal to all medical institutions by UGMEB,
even after compliance, is arbitrary and goes against the
very object of the Act. The question of granting renewal
after compliance by an authority which is not vested with
the power of inspection does not arise.
28. On the contra, the regulations framed, for establishment
of
medical
institutions
of
assessment
and
rating
regulations, 2023 specifically provides similar powers to
MARB, though not of renewal.
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
(Ref: Annexure L at Page No: 213-214)
29. It would be incongruous to hold that two authorities under
an act, can simultaneously conduct the same powers,
thereby with the possible consequence of arriving at two
different conclusions, such a scenario requires to be
avoided. It would certainly not be in public interest or to
preserve the institutional autonomy for such a course to
be adopted. In these circumstances, the regulations must
be held to be contrary to the statute.
30. The
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
Indian
Express
Newspapers v. Union of India (1985) 1 SCC 641the
Supreme Court held that a Subordinate legislation is not
on par with the Competent Legislature, that is seen as
follows:
“75. A piece of subordinate legislation does
not carry the same degree of immunity which
is enjoyed by a statute passed by a
competent Legislature. Subordinate legislation
may be questioned on any of the grounds on
which plenary legislation is questioned. In
addition it may also be questioned on the
ground that it does not conform to the statute
under which it is made. It may further be
questioned on the ground that it is contrary to
some
other
statute.
That
is
because
subordinate legislation must yield to plenary
legislation. It may also be questioned on the
ground that it is unreason-able, unreasonable
not in the sense of not being reasonable, but
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
in the sense that it is manifestly arbitrary. In
England, the Judges would say "Parliament
never intended authority to make such rules.
They are unreasonable and ultra vires".
77. In India arbitrariness is not a separate
ground since it will come within the embargo
of Article 14 of the Constitution. In India any
enquiry into the vires of delegated legislation
must be confined to the grounds on which
plenary legislation may be questioned, to the
ground that it is contrary to the statute under
which it is made, to the ground that it is
contrary to other statutory provisions or that it
is so arbitrary that it could not be said to be in
conformity with the statute or that it offends
Article 14 of the Constitution.
78. That subordinate legislation cannot be
questioned on the ground of violation of
principles of natural justice on which administrative action may be questioned has been
held by this Court in The Tulsipur Sugar Co.
Ltd.
v.
Notified
Area
Committee,
TulsipurRameshchandraKachardas Porwal v.
State of Maharashtra and in Bates v. Lord
Hailsham of St. Marylebone. A distinction
must be made between delegation of a
legislative function in the case of which the
question
of
reasonableness
cannot
be
enquired into and the invest-ment by statute
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
to exercise particular discretionary powers. In
the
latter
case
the
considered
on
all
question
grounds
may
on
be
which
administrative action may be questioned, such
as, non-application of mind, taking irrelevant
matters into consideration, failure to take
relevant matters into consideration, etc., etc.
On the facts and circum-stances of a case, a
subordinate legislation may be struck down
arbitrary or contrary to statute if it fails to take
into account very vital facts which either
expressly or by necessary implication are
required to be taken into consideration by the
statute or, say, the Constitution. This can only
be done on the ground that it does not
conform to the statutory or constitutional
requirements of that it offends Article 14 or
Article 19(1) (a) of the Constitution. It cannot,
no doubt, be done merely on the ground that it
is not reasonable or that it has not taken into
account relevant circumstances which the
Court considers relevant.”
C.) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case,
the order of the UGMEB refusing to grant permission for
the Petitioner Institution for the academic year 20252026 is sustainable in law?
31. In the facts of the present case, it is seen that a thorough
and proper inspection was conducted by MARB (the
authority that has power to conduct inspection under the
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Act) and a report was submitted on 11.12.2025. The
report would disclose that the institution had complied
with all the requirements prescribed by the UGMEB, with
only a marginal deficiency of 2.68% in faculty, which was
a curable one.
32. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of TMA Pai
Foundation (supra) also held that any regulation which
has the effect of destroying institutional autonomy would
amount to unreasonable regulation, thereby transgressing
the fundamental right granted under Article 19(1)(g). The
relevant para is stated as hereunder,
“19. We will first consider the right to establish
and administer an educational institution
under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, and
deal with the right to establish educational
institutions under Articles 26 and 30 in the
next part of the judgment while considering
the rights of the minorities.
20. Article 19(1)(g) employs four expressions
viz.
profession,
occupation,
trade
and
business. Their fields may overlap, but each
of them does have a content of its own.
Education is per se regarded as an activity
that is charitable in nature (see State of
Bombay
v.
R.M.D.
Chamarbaugwalas).
Education has so far not been regarded as a
trade or business where profit is the motive.
Even if there is any doubt about whether
education is a profession or not, it does
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
appear that education will fall within the
meaning of the expression "occupation".
Article 19(1)(g) uses the four expressions so
as to cover all activities of a citizen in respect
of which income or profit is generated, and
which can consequently be regulated under
Article
19(6).
International
In
Webster's
Dictionary,
at
Third
New
p.
1650,
"occupation" is, inter alia, defined as "an
activity in which one engages" or "a craft,
trade, profession or other means of earning a
living".
25. The establishment and running of an
educational institution where a large number
of persons are employed as teachers or
administrative staff, and an activity is carried
on that results in the imparting of knowledge
to the students, must necessarily be regarded
as an occupation, even if there is no element
of
profit
generation.
It
is
difficult
to
comprehend that education, per se, will not
fall under any of the four expressions in Article
19(1)(g). "Occupation" would be an activity of
a person undertaken as a means of livelihood
or a mission in life. The abovequoted
observations in Sodan Singh case correctly
interpret the expression "occupation" in Article
19(1)(g).”
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
33. The UGMEB however now, by the Impugned Order in
complete disregard of the report submitted which was
based
on
a
factual
verification
has
rejected
the
permission. apart from being without jurisdiction even
factually it is illegal as it is sans any reasons and runs
counter to the inspection report submitted by MARB.
34. In the case of Royal Medical Trust v. Union of India
(2015) 10 SCC 19, the Hon’ble Supreme Court speaks
about the conflict of regulations of authorities with the
legal statutes, which is seen in Paragraph 12:
“12. In the instant case, the appellant mindful
of the aforesaid directions of this Court, had
applied in due time adhering to the statutory
timelines. Its application in terms of necessary
documents was in fact complete but for the
affiliation certificate from KUHS which was
awaited by the appellant even after several
reminders for its issuance to KUHS pressing
upon the urgency of the matter. Since the
appellant was not at fault but constrained due
to the delay on the part of KUHS, the Council
was
expected
to
have
appropriately
considered the facts and circumstances of the
case pleaded by the appellant and thereafter,
reached a conclusion one way or the other on
its merits instead of functioning in such
mechanical
manner
by
rejecting
the
application
filed
the
appellant
and,
by
thereafter, forward1ing it to the Central
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Government
with
its
adverse
recommendations. In our considered opinion,
this aspect of the matter ought to have been
noticed by the writ court in writ petition as well
as the writ appeal. Since that has not been
done, in our considered view, we cannot
sustain the impugned judgement and order
passed by the high court.”
35. In these circumstances, the said impugned Order requires
to be quashed, on the ground, that it fails to take into
consideration the report preferred by MARB and has
arrived at conclusions contrary to the record.
11.
Before adverting to the rival contentions, it is
necessary to reiterate that as stated supra, pursuant to this Court’s
interim order dated 03.12.2025, an inspection of the petitioner –
Institution was conducted on 11.12.2025 and a report was
submitted to this Court along with the memo dated 16.12.2025.
The said report reads as under:
`“G.R. Medical College Hospital & Research Centre
First Renewal / LOP for Academic year 2025-26 (for annual intake of 150
MBBS students)
Summary as per the Assessor’s report:
1.
Faculty deficiency – 2.68%
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.
OPD on the day of assessment – 1060
(average of past three days – 1216/1214/1208).
3.
Bed occupancy on the day of assessment –
65%
(average
of
past
three
days
–
89.42/87.11/89)
4.
College infrastructure-adequate.
5.
Availability of equipment in each department –
adequate.
6.
Hostel facility – adequate.
7.
Committees – adequate.
Skill lab-adequate.
9.
Teaching facility – adequate.
10.
Research lab-adequate.
11.
Hospital infrastructure – adequate.
12.
Clinical material – adequate.
13.
Investigations – adequate.
14.
Variety of surgical procedures – adequate.
Sd/Consultant – MARB
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Name of the Institution
G.R. MEDICAL COLLEGE HOSPITAL & RESEARCH CENTRE
Whether Govt/ Private/ Trust/ Society
Trust
Address
NEERMARGA, MANGALORE
Telephone No.
0824-2988375, 8147073101
Principal’s mobile number
8123584746
E-mail
principalgrmc@gmail.com
College Website (as per annexure III of
MSR 2023)
www.grmedicalcollege.in
Affiliating University
Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences, Bangalore, Karnataka
Stage of Assessment
First Renewal / LOP for Academic Year 2025-26
LOP for Establishment (date& letter No)
NCM/UG/2020/000095/047506 dt. 13.12.2021 copy attached as Annexure-I
Permitted annual intake of UG students
Year of Recognition
NA
- 32 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
LOP for Increase of seats/ Renewal.
NA
(Provide relevant details)
PG Courses
Subject
(Provide department wise details)
NA
Number of Seats
NA
Was the college ever denied a batch
(If yes, give reason)
Any
other college
Trust/Society/Members
run
by
the No
(If yes, give details)
Last Assessment Date
05th & 06th September 2022
MEDICAL COLLEGE
1.1
College area (this is to be filled only during LOP and Recognition)
The campus plot is Unitary
Has the Building Plan been approved by the competent
authority YES/ NO
Name: Office of the Neermarga Panchayath no.52/2014-15, dt:
10.03.2015 and Building License No.53/2020-201 dt. 29.12.2020
Annexure Attached as Annexure-II
- 33 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Kindly provide a copy of Building Use/ Occupancy Certificate
from the competent authority
Name: Neermarga Grama Panchayath No.-Gra Pan CR 2018-19
dt. 28.03.2019
Annexure Attached as Annexure-III
1.2
Dean/Principal: Dr.Devidas Shetty N., with 23 years of teaching experience – 14yrs. Of Professor
& 4 yrs. And 2 months of experience of Asso.Prof. He is also holding the post of P r o f e s s o r i n
the Department of General Surgery.
Office Space Requirement
Dean/Principal Office
Required Space
Adequate:
Yes/No
Adequate
Staff Room
Adequate
College Council Room
Adequate
1.3
Available
Available as per NMC
Requirement
Available as per NMC
Requirement
Available as per NMC
Requirement
Remarks
(* To be filled by the
Assessor)
Adequate and available
College Website:
S No.
Details of information
1.
Details of Dean / Principal and Medical Superintendent Including their
name,
qualification complete address with telephone and STD code, and E-mail etc.
Teaching staff, Resident doctors,non-teachingstaff, Technical staff, Nursing
staff--(a)department & designation wise with joining date (b) Unit wise faculty & resident list
Details of the affiliated university and its Vice-Chancellor and Registrars.
Details of fees for various courses and other costs.
2.
3.
4.
YES/NO
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Remarks
(* To be filled by the
Assessor)
- 34 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
S No.
5.
Details of information
List of students admitted merit-wise category-wise (UG & PG) for the current
and
previous year.
6. Result of all the examinations of last one year.
7. Details of members of the Anti Ragging Committee with contact details including
landline
Phone, mobile, email etc...
8. Details of members of the Gender Harassment Committee with contact details
including
landline Ph. mobile, email etc...
9. Toll free number to report ragging.
10. Details of the sanctioned intake capacity of various courses UG as well as PGs by the
MCI.
(With the scan copies of permission letter)
11. Any research publication during the last one year.
12. Details of any CME programs, conferences and/or any academic activities conducted
by
the institution.
13. Details of any awards and achievements received by the students or faculty.
14. Detailed status of recognition of all the courses(with the scan copies of permission
letter)
15. Details of clinical material in the hospital, OPD & IPD
YES/NO
NA
NA
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Remarks
(* To be filled by the
Assessor)
- 35 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
1.4
Medical Education Unit (MEU):
Available as per Regulations
Document
attached.
Yes/ No
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
•
Name of the MEU coordinator Dr. Thilak S A
Yes
•
Name, Designation & Experience of affiliated faculty Annexure IV
Yes
•
Name of the NMC/MCI Regional (Nodal) Centre where above
training has been undertaken.
rBCW at Government Medical College, Kozhikode
NA
ACME at Government Medical College, Kottayam
•
Details of the Orientation programme and Basic Course
Workshop undergone by MEU(No. of programmes organized
during Academic year, No. of Persons who attended, proceedings
(to be verified at the time of assessment)
•
Date/s of the above workshops
•
Details & Duration of Workshops
Technology conducted by MEU.
•
Details of faculty who have undergone basic course workshop in
Medical Education Technology at the allocated NMC/MCI
Regional Centre
•
Details of faculty who have undergone advanced course workshop
in Medical Education Technology at the allocated NMC/MCI
NA
Regional Centre
•
Feedback evaluation of workshops and action taken reports based
on feedback obtained.
NA
in
Medical
Education
NA
Annexure IV
- 36 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
1.5 Continuing Medical Education: Nil
Available as per Regulations
Document
Attached
Yes/ No
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
NA
No. and Details of CMEs/workshop organized by the college held in the
past 1 year.
1.6 (a) College Council:
Available as per Regulations
Document attached.
Yes/ No
•
Name, designation, contact no. and address of the
President & Secretary
•
Composition of the Council (HODs as members & Principal /
Dean as chairperson)
•
Is there a student representative in the council?
•
No. of times the College Council meets per year (min 4)
•
Details of college Council meetings where students Welfare
was discussed, and Action taken report (details / comments in
annexure II)
Yes
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Annexure V
Yes
- 37 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
1.6 (b) Curriculum Committee:
Available as per Regulations
Document attached.
Name and designation of the Members
Yes/ No
Yes Annexure VI
No. of meeting in the previous year
Action taken report to be stated
Yes
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
1.6 (c) Pharmacovigilance Committee:
Available as per Regulations
Document attached.
•
Name and designation of the Members
Yes/ No
Yes Annexure VII
•
No. of meeting in the previous year
•
Action taken report to be stated
Yes
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
1.6 (d) Gender Harassment Committee:
Available as per Regulations
Document attached.
•
Name and designation of the Members
Yes/ No
Yes Annexure VIII
•
No. of meeting in the previous year
•
Action taken report to be stated
Yes
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
- 38 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
1.6 (e) Anti Ragging Committee:
Available as per Regulations
•
Name and designation of the Members
Document
attached
Yes/No
Yes Annexure IX
•
No. of meeting in the previous year
•
Action taken report to be stated
Yes
1.7
College timings: 09.00 AM To 05.00 PM
1.8
Teaching facility
1.8 (A)Small Group Teaching
i. Teaching room
Present / Not present
Available
Number
AV aids (Yes / No)
8 in College Side and 10 Rooms in
clinical departments
Yes
Internet facility (Yes / No)
Yes
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
- 39 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
ii.
Student Practical Labs –
AV aids
Internet facility
Histology
Available / Not Number
Available
Available
Yes
Yes
Clinical Physiology
Available
Yes
Yes
Biochemistry
Available
Yes
Yes
Histopathology & Cytopathology
Available
Yes
Yes
Clinical Pathology & Hematology
Available
Yes
Yes
Microbiology
Available
Yes
Yes
Clinical pharmacology
Available
Yes
Yes
Computer Assisted Learning (CAL) Available
in Pharmacology
Yes
Yes
Lab name
iii.
Museum (for 50 students each)
Present / Not present
Present
Capacity (1.2 sq.mt. per student)
650 sq. mt
Number
AV aids (Yes / No)
Yes
Internet facility (Yes / No)
Yes
*Attach schedule of sharing time if shared between the department (NA)
- 40 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
1.8(B) Skills laboratory
Present / Not present
Present
Capacity (600 sq.mt. / 800 sq. mt.)
600 sq. mt.
Number (minimum 4)
Yes
Room for demonstration (Yes/No)
Yes
Area of review or debriefing (Yes/ No)
Yes
Room for faculty coordinator and support staff (Yes/ No)
Yes
Adequate storage area for mannequin and other equipment (Yes/No)
Yes
Facility for video recording (Yes/ No)
Yes
Station for practicing skills individually/ group (Yes/ No)
Yes
Dedicated technical officer and adequate support staff (Yes/ No)
Yes
AV aids (Yes / No)
Yes
Internet facility (Yes / No)
Yes
1.9 Teaching Programme and assessment of Quality of medical education- direct observation of conduct
of activity, interactions with faculty, interactions with student and evaluation process:
Qualitative indicators – Not Applicable
1. Implementation of the competency-based curriculum
• Whether latest National Medical Commission (NMC), Competency Based Curriculum implemented
•
in all phases (1st MBBS, 2nd MBBS, 3rd MBBS part-1 and 3rd MBBS part-2) of MBBS program:
Yes/ No
A notice regarding teaching timetable for first MBBS, Second MBBS, Third MBBS Part-I and Third
- 41 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
MBBS Part-II is released from the office of Principal and Controller which clearly mentions the time and
day allotted for theory lecture, demonstrations, clinical posting and practical classes in various
subjects: Yes/ No
Is Competency based teaching schedule with specific learning objectives being followed: Yes/ No
Is Horizontal and vertical integration across one and multiple phases done: Yes/ No
Is the Orientation/ foundation course implemented: Yes/ No
Is AETCOM (Attitude, Ethics and Communication) being implemented in all phases: Yes/ No
Is the teaching for AETCOM done in small groups using innovative teaching learning methods: Yes/ No
Two months electives are being introduced for student: Yes/ No
Does the college ensure that all the aspects of clinical medicine are included as part of required clinical instruction:
Yes/ No
Is the regular updating of student attendance done: Yes/ No
Are the Competency based logbooks being implemented in all subjects of MBBS course in all the
phases including electives and family adoption program: Yes/ No
It is ensured that all the students complete their logbooks before appearing in the University
examination: Yes/ No (take at least two samples of logbook)
Curriculum displayed on notice board: Yes/ No
Has the assessor directly observed whether faculty member displayed the specific learning objective
for the student in the teaching session in lecture theatre? Yes/ No
Is evidence-based teaching done (e.g.: through bedside case discussion and presentation by students): Yes/ No
Do the students participate in required laboratory exercises (real or simulated): Yes/ No
Is regular Mentor-mentee program being conducted where mentors are available 24*7 to solve any
problem encountered by the students: Yes/ No
Is the college using optimal technology as teaching aid for medical education: Yes/ No
Does college have implemented overall student development programme: Yes/No (support with documentary
evidence)
- 42 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Extracurricular activities: Yes/No
Yoga and Physical activity: Yes/No
Programme for societal needs and demand on healthcare (field visit, industry visit and family adoption
•
program): Yes/No
Implementation of faculty development program:Yes/No
Revised Basic Course Workshop (rBCW)/ Basic Course in Medical Education (BCME)/
Advanced course in Medical Education (ACME): Yes/ No
Are faculty members trained for Curriculum Implementation Support Program (CISP): Yes/ No
Faculty development activities to enhance skills for assessment of student’s performance: Yes/No
Does the Medical Education unit continuously update all the faculty members regarding the
•
curriculum and CBME: Yes/ No
Is feedback from students regularly obtained: Yes/No
1.9(A) Teaching Modalities
Available as per Regulations
YES/NO
Didactic teaching
Not Applicable
Demonstrations
Not Applicable
Integrated teaching (Horizontal/Vertical teaching)
Not Applicable
Clinical postings
Not Applicable
Clinical Pathological Conference
Not Applicable
Grand Rounds
Not Applicable
Statistical Meeting
Not Applicable
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Not Applicable (At present Students are
not admitted)
- 43 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
YES/NO
Available as per Regulations
Seminars
Not Applicable
SDL (Self Directed Learning)
Not Applicable
AETCOM
Not Applicable
SGD (Small group Discussion)
Not Applicable
Integration of classes Phase I
Phase II
Phase II
Phase III
Not Applicable
Internship training logbook (whether as per CBME curriculum)
Not Applicable
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
1.9(B) Provide the examination results for the three most recently completed academic, including supplementary
exams……..years.
E.g.:
Year
No. examined
% passing
% Distinction
2022-23 (II Year of
batch 2021-22)
92%
2%
2021-22 (I Year of
batch 2021-22)
81%
3%
- 44 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
1.9 (C). Pass percentage /Graduation completion (for the last five years) Not Applicable
Last Year
No.
%
2 Years Prior
3 Years Prior
4 Years Prior
5 Years Prior
No.
No.
No.
No.
%
%
%
%
Number of students graduated per
year
Number of students failed
Graduates placed in internship
Graduates successfully
internship
completed
1.8(D) Lecture Theatres:
Medical college
Hospital (*mandatory in case of
hospital not in same unitary
campus)
Required
Available
Required
Number
Capacity
>20% of
180 Each
Availabel
>20% of annual
intake
annual
intake
Gallery Type
Yes Available
Yes
A.V. Aids
Yes
Available
Yes
Available
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Unitary Campus. Available
Not Applicable
- 45 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Medical college
Hospital (*mandatory in case of
hospital not in same unitary
campus)
Required
Available
Required
Internet facility
Yes
Available
Yes
ICT enabled
Yes
Available
Yes
Available
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
(Information,
Communication
and Technology)
1.8 (E) Examination Hall:
Requirement (as per NMC guidelines)
No. – 2
Area – Adequate
Capacity - 300
(In the purpose of examination used the Lecture Theatre,
Reading Room of Library)
Available as per Regulations
YES/ NO
Yes
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
- 46 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
1.9
Library:
a. Air-conditioned – Yes
c. Stack room - Yes
b. Working Hours – 9 a.m. to 9.00 p.m. X 6 days
d. Reading room - Yes
Area
Student Reading Room
Room for stocking old books,
journals, etc.,
No. of Books
Internet Nodes (at least 10% of
annual intake of students)
Faculty Reading Room
Room for librarian and other staff
Required
Available
1000 Sq.mtr.
150 Capacity
1000 Sq.mtr.
150 Seats in Library +
150seats in reading room
Yes
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Yes
Yes
Available Nos.
Required Nos.
Hard copy / e journals
Hard copy / e journals
Journals (Indian)
Journals (Foreign)
* List of books and journals attached – YES/ NO
Kindly provide invoice and proof of money paid in case order has been placed for new journals and books.
1.10 Common Room for Boys & Girls:
Area Required
(as per NMC guidelines)
Boys
Girls
150 sq. mtr
150 sq. mtr
Available Area
Available
Available
Toilet – Attached
Yes/No
Yes
Yes
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
- 47 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
1.11
Recreational Facilities:
Requirement
(as per NMC guidelines)
Available as per Regulations
Outdoor games facilities
Play field/s
Available
Yes
Yes (Basket Ball, Football, Throwball, Kabaddi)
Indoor games facilities
Yes
Gymnasium
Yes
Cafeteria
Yes
Space for cultural activities
Yes
1.12 Central Photography Section:
Available: Yes
Staff: (give details as annexure XI)
1.13
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Equipment: (give stock details as annexure XII)
Hostel: Location – Within campus / Outside campus (distance
Hostel
Catego
ry
Required
Capacity
as per
NMC
guideline
s
Available
Capacity
(RoomsXcapaci
t y = Total
capacity)
UG
Students
At least
75% of
Boys 60X3 = 180
Furnishe
d
(Y/N)
Yes
Toilet
(Y/N)
Yes
Hygiene
of
Mess
Hostel
(Y/N)
campus
Yes
Yes
)
Commo
n room
(Y/N)
Yes
Visitor
room,
Recreatio
Remarks
n room
(* To be filled by the
with TV,
Assessor)
Music,
Indoor
Games
(Y/N)
Available
Yes
- 48 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Hostel
Catego
ry
Interns
Resident
s
includin
g PGs
Required
Capacity
as per
NMC
guideline
s
total
annual
intake
Hygiene
of
Mess
Hostel
(Y/N)
campus
Commo
n room
(Y/N)
Visitor
room,
Recreatio
n room
with TV,
Music,
Indoor
Games
(Y/N)
Yes
Available
Capacity
(RoomsXcapaci
t y = Total
capacity)
Furnishe
d
(Y/N)
Girls 56X3 = 168
Yes
Boys
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
Girls
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
Boys
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
Toilet
(Y/N)
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Remarks
(* To be filled by the
Assessor)
Girls
*As per new MSR,It is desirable that hostel rooms are double accommodation facilities. Adequate recreational,
dining and 24x7 security facilities shall be provided at the hostels.
1.14 Department of radio diagnosis: Available
• Personal Monitoring System of BARC.: Available
• X Ray machine – conventional, static, portable, fluoroscopy, contrast studies : Yes
• Ultrasonography machine and color doppler: Yes
• CT machine: Yes
• Digital record room: Yes
- 49 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Equipment
Mobile X Ray
60 mA
100 mA
Static X Ray
300 mA
500 mA
600 mA
800 mA
1000 mA
With Fluoroscopy
USG (with Color
Doppler)
CT
(Spiral Minimum
slice)
MRI
(Minimum 1.5 Tesla)
Mammography
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Required
no.*
Available
no.
AERB/ PNDT
Approval
Y/N
Functional Status at
the time of
assessment
Y/N
NA
Yes
NA
Yes
NA
Available
Yes
Yes
Available
Yes
Yes
Available
Yes
Yes
Available
NA
NA
Not Available
NA
NA
Not Available
1.15 Department of Yoga: Available
Staff: 1 male and 1 female Yoga instructor/ trainer: Yes
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
- 50 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
1.16 Department of Radiation Oncology(Optional): Not Available
• Is the department in accordance with the regulatory requirements and approval of AERB: Yes/ No
• BARCapprovaloftheradiationtherapyrooms/planalongwithcompletelayoutoftheentire department: Yes / No
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Not Available
TEACHING HOSPITAL
2.1
Name of the Hospital: G R Hospital and Research Centre, Neermarga, Mangalore
Owned by: Government/Trust/Society/Company/Autonomous body/Consortium.
Inside the campus/ Outside the campus
2.2
Name of the Medical Superintendent: Dr. Baliga Kallianpur Suresh, Professor of General
Surgery
Qualification of the Medical Superintendent: MBBS, MS (General Surgery)
Years of administrative experience: 10 years of administrative experience
Adequate space
Available / not available
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Medical Supdt’s Office
Available
Available
Administrative Office
Available
- 51 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.3
OPD Facilities:
OPD timings
09.00 A.M. to 3 . 0 0 P.M.
Adequate reception area
Patient waiting hall
Demonstration room
Examination Room
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
2.4
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Available
Available
Available
Facilities available in the OPDs :
Department
Medicine
Dermatology
Psychiatry
OPD Area
Injection room
- Male Yes/No
- Female Yes/No
E.C.G. Room - Yes/No
Clinical demonstration room - Yes/No
Patient examination rooms (give numbers)
Average OPD Attendance (per day) Clinical demonstration room - Yes/No
Patient examination rooms (give numbers)
Average OPD Attendance (per day) Clinical demonstration room - Yes/No
Patient examination rooms (give numbers)
Average OPD Attendance (per day) -
Available as per
requirement (Yes/ No or
Give Numbers)
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Remarks (including direct
observation of the
activity)
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Available
Available
- 52 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Department
Surgery
Orthopaedics
Ophthalmology
OPD Area
Dressing room - Male Yes/No
- Female Yes/No
Minor OT - Yes/No
Clinical demonstration room - Yes/No
Patient examination rooms (give numbers)
Average OPD attendance (per day) –
Dressing room - Male Yes/No
- Female Yes/No
Plaster room - Yes/No
Plaster cutting room – Yes/No
Minor OT – Yes / No
Clinical demonstration room – Yes/No
Patient examination rooms (given numbers)
Average OPD Attendance (per day) -
Refraction Rooms - Yes/No
Dressing Rooms / Minor Procedure
Room Minor OT - Yes/No
Clinical demonstration room - Yes/No Patient
examination rooms (give numbers)
Average OPD attendance (per day) –
Available as per
requirement (Yes/ No or
Give Numbers)
Available
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Available
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Remarks (including direct
observation of the
activity)
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Available
Available
- 53 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Department
ENT
Pediatrics
OBS & GYN
OPD Area
Available as per
requirement (Yes/ No or
Give Numbers)
Audiometry (Room AC &Soundproof) Yes/No Speech Therapy - Yes/No
Minor OT - Yes/No
Clinical demonstration room - Yes/No Patient
examination rooms (give numbers)
Average OPD attendance (per day) –
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Available
Well Baby Clinic - Yes/No Immunization
Clinic - Yes/No Child Rehabilitation
Clinic - Yes/No
Clinical demonstration room - Yes/No Patient
examination rooms (give numbers)
Average OPD attendance (per day) –
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Available
Antenatal Clinic - Yes/No
Infertility Clinic - Yes/No
Family Welfare Clinic - Yes/No
Cancer Detection Clinic - Yes/No
Minor OT - Yes/No
Clinical demonstration room - Yes/No Patient
examination rooms (give numbers)
Average OPD attendance (per day) -
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Remarks (including direct
observation of the
activity)
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
- 54 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.5 Department of Anaesthesia
Services available 24*7: Yes
2.5 (A)PAC (Pre-Anesthetic Checkup): Available
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
2.5(B) Pain Clinic: Available
2.6 ART Centre: Available and functional: Yes
Facility for management of (MDR)-TB: )-TB : Yes
Under control of department : General
Medicine
Average number of cases: 1-3 Per Month
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
2.7 Central Clinical Laboratory: Under control of department of: Pathology
Separate sections for Clinical Pathology, Microbiology, Hematology &Clinical Biochemistry: Available
- 55 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Labs
Number of samples required/ day
Available number of samples/ day
Histopathology
At least 20% of total major surgeries
Cytopathology
At least 1% of total hospital OPD
Hematology
At least 15% of OPD and 30 % of indoor beds
Clinical Pathology
At least 15% of OPD and 30 % of indoor beds
Clinical Biochemistry
At least 15% of OPD and 30 % of indoor beds
Microbiology
At least 30% of indoor beds and 50% of total surgery 80
cases
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Most of the investigations are found OPD patients. The indoor patients’
investigations needs improvement.
2.8 Department of Dentistry: Available / Not Available
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
- 56 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.9
Department of Integrative Medical Research: Available / Not Available
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
2.10 Hospital Infection Control Committee (HICC): Available / Not Available
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
2.11 Blood Bank:
Available and functional: Yes
Under control of department of : Pathology
Airconditioned: Yes
License valid up to: 24/06/2026 (licence number and copy to be appended as annexure XIII)
Blood component Facility – Available
Number of units dispensed in a day: 0 3 - 0 5
Number of units stored on day of assessment: 6
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
- 57 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.12 Pharmacy:24-Hour Pharmacy services available: YES
Pharmacist In charge and other staff available: Yes/ No(Annexure –XIV List enclosed)
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
2.13
Medical Record Section:
•
Manual / Computerized: Computerized
•
ICD X classification of diseases followed for indexing: Yes
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
2.14
•
Central sterilization Department: Available
Timings: 08:00 AM to 08:00 PM & Shifts: 02
•
Equipment: Horizontal autoclaves: 01 / Vertical autoclaves01, ETO Sterilisers: 01
•
Separate receiving and distribution points - Yes
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
- 58 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.15
Central laundry/Alternative Arrangements: Available
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
2.16
•
•
•
•
Kitchen/ Pantry Arrangements
In House/Outsourced {if outsourced, then MOU copy to be annexed}:
Food free of charge: Yes
Provision of special diet: Yes
Services of a nutritionist/dietician: Available
2.17 (a) Total no. of Canteens: 2, For staff and For students: 1 , For Patients/Relatives:1
(b) Total no. of Mess in campus: 2
2.18
•
•
•
•
Arrangements for Biomedical Waste Management:
Outsourced/in-house: (if outsourced, append MOU) (If in-house, please give details of facilities available as annexure)
Annexure XV
Is it compliant as per BMW (Management & Handling) Rules 2019: Yes
Provide registration certificate and receipt. Annexure XV
Is the provision of fire safety & PWD(Person with disability)-friendly arrangement available: Yes
- 59 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
2.19 Central Research Lab: Available – Yes
Manpower available (as per annexure I of new MSR 2023): Yes
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
2.20
Research projects of the Institution: Yes/ No
o Completed Nos. 2
o Ongoing Nos. 2
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
2.21 Intercom: Available: Yes
No. of incoming lines 02
No. of extension lines: 16
2.22(A) Aadhar Enabled Biometric Attendance System (AEBAS): Available: Yes
(a) If available, for faculty: Yes
(b) For residents: Yes
- 60 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
(c) For support staff: Yes
(d) For students (preferably with face recognition) :NA
* Biometric attendance to be collected by the Assessors on the day of assessment and adequacy to be checked as per
guidelines
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
(B) Closed circuit TV monitoring of Medical Colleges (as per annexure II of new MSR): Available: Yes
2.22(B) Is close circuit TV monitoring of Medical College (as per annexure II of new MSR 2023) available? Yes
•
Is Close circuit camera available?: Yes
•
Are Cameras installed as per Annexure II of new UG MSR 2023 : Yes
•
Mention the number of cameras as per the annexure II of new UG MSR 2023: 25
Remarks (* To be filled by the Assessor): Available
2.23
Total Number of Teaching Beds (Distance between two beds should be 1.5 m)
Total Beds in Teaching Hospital (Inside Campus) - 635
Total Beds in Teaching Hospital (Outside the Campus) (
Kms. from the main campus) – Not Applicable
- 61 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
*For hospitals with 100 or more beds dedicated for Gen. Surgeon, at least 10'% shall be dedicated to Pediatric surgery.
* If PG courses are running, beds requirement to be increased according to PG seats.
2.24
Central casualty/ Emergency services:
No of Beds: Required*30
Available 30 ICU and 3 Casualty
Beds
Required
*
(as per
NMC
guideline s)
No. of
Wards
and
Units
Total
Beds
Availab
le
Dermatolog
y
Gen.
Surgery
Department
Gen.
Medicine
Pediatrics
Psychiatry
Orthopedics
Ophthalmol
ogy
Is there
PG
course
running
.
Y/N
Are
Additiona l
beds
available
for PG
seats
Nursing
Station
Y/N
Exam
and
Treat
Room
Y/N
N
NA
Y
Y
N
NA
Y
N
NA
N
Pantr
y
room
HDU
(High
Depend
ency
Unit)
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
NA
Y
N
NA
N
N
Reside
nt and
Student
Duty
Room
Y/N
Clini
cal
demo
Roo
m Y/N
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
NA
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
NA
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Storeroo
m Y/N
Remark
s
(* To be
filled by
the
Assesso
r)
Available
- 62 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Department
ENT
OBS & GYN
Total
Beds
Required
*
(as per
NMC
guideline s)
No. of
Wards
and
Units
Total
Beds
Availab
le
Is there
PG
course
running
.
Y/N
Are
Additiona l
beds
available
for PG
seats
Nursing
Station
Y/N
Exam
and
Treat
Room
Y/N
N
NA
Y
Y
N
NA
Y
Y
Pantr
y
room
HDU
(High
Depend
ency
Unit)
Y
Y
Y
Y
Storeroo
m Y/N
Reside
nt and
Student
Duty
Room
Y/N
Clini
cal
demo
Roo
m Y/N
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
•
Number of CMO posted/Shift: 02 CMO each in the 3 shift
No. of CMO present during Assessment round: 02
•
Number of nurses posted /Shift: 03 Nurses each in the 3 shif
No. of nurses present during Assessment round: 03
•
Separate casualty for OBGY cases: Yes
If available, No. of beds 1
•
Facilities for triage: Yes
•
Accommodation for resuscitation services: Yes
•
Minor OT: Yes
Equipment
No. of patient trolleys: 6
No. of Triage area beds: 3
Plaster room: Yes
Number
Availability
Yes/No
Central Oxygen & suction facility
Yes
Pulse oximeter
Yes
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Avaialable
Remark
s
(* To be
filled by
the
Assesso
r)
- 63 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Equipment
Number
Availability
Yes/No
Ambu bag
Yes
Ultrasonography Machine
Yes
Crash Cart
Yes
Emergency Drug Tray
Yes
Defibrillator
Yes
Ventilator
Yes
X-ray Unit – (Mobile)
Yes
Investigation facilities
Yes
Yes
2.25
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
4 sets
Operation theatres:
Required
OT FOR MBBS SEAT
CAPACITY
Available
Yes/ No
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Major OT
9 Yes
Available
Minor OT- well equipped (with
Anaesthesia facility)
1 for each surgical specialty
5 Yes
Available
- 64 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
*Every surgical specialty shall have at least one well equipped Minor OT attached to it
Equipment available in O. T. (Specify numbers)
Gen Surgery
ENT
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Average
no. of
major
surgeries
per week
Ophthal
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Ortho
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Obs & Gyne
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Emergency
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Septic
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
AC
Y/N
Department
Central
Oxygen/
Nitrous
Oxide
Y/N
Anesthesia
Machine
Y/N
Multipara
Monitor with
Capnograph
Y/N
No. of Pre-operative Beds available: 06
No. of Post Operative Beds available: 10
Defibrillators
Y/N
Infusion
Pumps
Y/N
Remarks
(* To be filled by the
Assessor)
Satisfactory
- 65 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.26
Intensive Care:
Type
ICCU
ICU
Intensive
Respiratory
Care Unit
Post – op
surgical
critical care
unit
NICU
PICU
Critical care
burns unit
OBS
HDU/ICU
Beds
(Require
d*)
Beds
(Available)
AC
Y/
N
Central
Oxyge
n/
Suction
Y/N
Y
Y
Y
Y
Major
Equipment
(Trolley-cumbeds, Monitors,
Ventilators,
ABG, Pulse
Oximeters,
Infusion pumps,
Glucometers
etc.)
Y/N
Y
Y
Portabl
e
X-Ray,
USG,
ECG
Residents
Appointe
d
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Nurses
Appointe
d
Patients on
day of
assessment
(* To be
filled by the
Assessor)
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
* Total no of ICU beds should be either 20 or 30 depending on the number of UG seats as per new UG MSR 2023
Remarks
(* To be
filled by the
Assessor)
Satisfactory
- 66 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.27
Labor Room:
Rooms
Beds
Clean Cases
Septic Cases
Eclampsia
Average No. of cases per
week
7-8
0-1
0-1
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Satisfactory
2.28 Non-teaching staff (Doctors, Nurses, Paramedical and Support staff):
Category
Available No.
Non-Teaching Specialists
NA
Medical Officers
Non-PG Junior Residents
NA
Paramedical & Technical staff
Sanitary & Support staff
Nursing staff
Available No.
Staff Nurses
Sister Incharge
ANS
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
- 67 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Nursing staff
Available No.
DNS
Nursing Suptd
Total
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
DEPARTMENT WISE TEACHING FACILITIES
2.29
Anatomy
Required
Demonstration Room/s
No
Capacity
Histology practical laboratory Number of Lab seats
Number of microscopes
Available
Required
25 capacity of AV Aids:
4 Rooms 50
Capacity of 4
rooms
available in the
pre and para
clinical
departments
Museum:
seating
capacity
Mounted specimens
Available
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Available
50 seating
- 68 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Required
Available
Required
• Dissection
Hall
(should
accommodate 50% of annual
student intake)
Number of dissection tables Cold store / cooling chambers
– Capacity of
Bodies
Embalming room –
Number of Cadavers
– Storage tanks –
Band saw -
Models – Wet & Dry
Bone Sets Articulated
DisarticulatedMRI & CT images
Lockers - 150
Departmental Library(Mention No. of Books.
And attach list)
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Not required
As per NMC
Adequate exhaust, light, water supply and drainage facilities – Available
Rooms for Faculty – Available
Rooms for non teaching staff - Available
*Please attach List of available Equipment (as per schedule III of new MSR 2023) along with their functional status.
ANNEXURE - XVI
2.30 Physiology
Required
Demonstration Room/s
No –
Capacity -
Available
25 capacity of 4 Rooms
50 capacity of 4 rooms
available in the pre and
para clinical departments
Required
Available
AV Aids:
Available
Clinical
Physiology Lab.
Available
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
- 69 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Required
Available
Departmental Library –
(Mention No. of Books. And attach
list)
Not required as per NMC
for UG
Required
Available
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Rooms for Faculty - Available
Rooms for non-teaching staff – Available
*Please attach List of available Equipment (as per schedule III of new MSR 2023) along with their functional status.
ANNEXURE - XIV
2.31
Biochemistry
Required
Demonstration
Room/s No
Available
Required
25 capacity of 4 Rooms 50 capacity AV Aids:
of 4 rooms available in the pre and
para clinical departments
Available
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Capacity Number of practical
laboratories
Number of Lab seats -
Library / Seminar rooms–
(Mention No. of Books.
And attach list)
Not required
as per NMC for
UG
Available
Rooms for Faculty - Available
Rooms for non-teaching staff – Available
*Please attach List of available Equipment (as per schedule III of new MSR 2023) along with their functional status.
ANNEXURE - XIV
- 70 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.32
Pathology
Required
Workstation/ (Lab seats)
Practical labs –
Morbid Anatomy/Histopath./
Cytology –
Microscopes
Clinical Pathology/Hematology –
Microscopes
Available
Available
60 Available
AV Aids:
Available
Available
Museum: Seating
Capacity- 50 students
Shared with
Forensic
Medicine
Departmental library – (Mention No. of Not required as
per NMC for UG
Books. And attach list)
Service Lab –
Histopathology/Cytopathology/
Hematology/Any specialized work
Required
Specimens:
• Mounted
• Unmounted
• Catalogues
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Available
Available
Available
Available
Rooms for Faculty – Available
Rooms for non-teaching staff – Available
*Please attach List of available Equipment (as per schedule III of new MSR 2023) along with their functional status.
ANNEXURE- XIV
- 71 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.33
Microbiology
Required
Service Lab for
• Bacteriology including
anaerobic bacteria.
• Serology
• Virology
• Parasitology
• Mycology
• Tuberculosis
• Immunology
Practical laboratory
Available
Yes/ No
Yes
Departmental library - (Mention No. of
Books. And attach list)
AV Aids:
Available
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Number of Lab seats Number of microscopes/laboratory 60
Number of service laboratories -7BSL-2 Virology lab – Yes/ No
Required
Yes
Media preparation facility Available
Autoclaving,
Washing,
and drawing room
Available
Museum:
Available
Specimen, Charts, Models Shared with
Pharmacology
& Catalogue
and
Seating capacity Community
___________
Medicine
Rooms for Faculty - Available
Rooms for non-teaching staff – Available
*Please attach List of available Equipment (as per schedule III of new MSR 2023) along with their functional status.
ANNEXURE - XVI
- 72 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.34
Pharmacology
Required
Demonstration Room/s
No – ___________
Capacity students
Clinical pharmacology Lab
Is there animal holding area:
Yes/No If yes, then is it as per
CPCSEA guidelines: Yes/No
Available
Required
AV Aids:
25 capacity of 4
Rooms 50 capacity Museum: 50 seating
of 4 rooms available capacity
in the pre and para
Specimens
clinical departments
Charts
Available
Models
History of Medicine
No
Catalogues
Computer Assisted Learning Lab Available
Mannequins
Available
Available
Available
Shared with
Pharmacolog
y and
Community
Medicine
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Available
Rooms for Faculty - Available
Rooms for non-teaching staff – Available
*Please attach List of available Equipment (as per schedule III of new MSR 2023) along with their functional status.
ANNEXURE – XVI
- 73 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.35
Forensic Medicine and Toxicology
Required
Available
Required
25 capacity of 4 Rooms 50
capacity of 4 rooms
available in the pre and
para clinical departments
Forensic Medicine Practical Lab Available (Shared with
Pathology)
NA
Autopsy Block.
Location – In/Near hospital in a
separate structure.
Mortuary available: Yes/No
No
Cold storage -_ Capacity
of_______Bodies
Not required as per NMC
Departmental library for UG
Demonstration Room/s
No – ________
Capacity students
AV Aids:
Remarks
Available (* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Museum : 50 Seats Shared with
Pathology
• Medico-Legal Specimens Yes
• Charts Yes
• Prototype fire arms Yes
• Slides Yes
• Poisons Yes
• Photographs Yes
Catalogues Yes
Available
Rooms for Faculty - Available
Rooms for non-teaching staff – Available
*Please attach List of available Equipment (as per schedule III of new MSR 2023) along with their functional status. ANNEXURE –
XVI
2.36
Community Medicine
Required
Demonstration Room/s
No –
Capacity students
Available
Required
25 capacity of 4 AV Aids:
Rooms 50 capacity
of 4 rooms
Available
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Available
Available
- 74 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Required
Museum:
• Charts
• Models
• Specimens
• Catalogues
Available
available in the pre
and para clinical
departments
50 seats Available
Shared with
Microbiology and
Pharmacology
departments
Required
Available
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Departmental Library (Mention
No.
of
Books. And attach
list)
Not required as
per NMC
Rooms for Faculty - Available
3.37 (a) Health Centers (Department of Community Medicine)
Manpower
Students
Assistant Professor in-charge (in rotation) & MO (one
male,
one female) (at least one must be a Lady Medical Officer)
PHN/trained staff nurse with community field experience
ANM
Medical Social Worker
Technician/ Technical Assistant
Pharmacist
Sanitary inspector/ health Inspector
Health educator
Storekeeper/ record keeper
RHTC for population of 30,000 and
UHTC for population of 50,000
Actual
Availability
Deficiency
1 AP (On
Rotation) + 2 MO
Available
- 75 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
RHTC: Ganjimata-Primary Health Centre, Kudupu-Rural Health Centre and Rural Health Training Centre-V amanjoor
(Distance from the college) 8 KM and 9 KM
Population covered by the RHTC
Ganjimata- 22065 Kudupu and
Vamanjoor – 20545
Yes (Vamanjoor)
Remarks
(* To be filled by the
Assessor)
Yes
Is it owned by /affiliated to College(Yes/No) OR
Yes (Ganjimata and Kudupu-MOU
with Govt of Karnataka ANNEXUREXVII)
Yes
Yes
Distance from the college (within 30 Kms for Tier I cities or within
50 Kms) Yes/No
NA
NA
No. of Students
Visit per batch throughout the year
No. of Interns
Posted per batch throughout the year
Affiliated to Government owned health centres (Yes/No)
Separate residential arrangement for accommodating boys
and Girls (For Interns): Yes/No
NA
NA
Facilities for cooking &dining: Yes/No OR
Yes
NA
Mess facility: Yes/No
Yes
Transport facility: Yes/No
Yes
Yes
Is there scheme of adoption of families: Yes/No
Yes
NA
NA
NA
50-60
Flexibility of distribution of interns in various OPDs: Yes/No
(In addition to current CRMI postings)
Daily OPD
- 76 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Population covered by the RHTC
Specialist visits if any
Ganjimata- 22065 Kudupu and
Vamanjoor – 20545
General Medicine, Surgery, OBG,
Orthopaedics ENT and
Ophthalmology
Remarks
(* To be filled by the
Assessor)
Yes
Cold chain equipment available
Available
Yes
Survey/MCH/Immunization/FP registers
Available
Yes
Activities under the National Health Programmes
Awareness programmes under Yes
NVBDCP, NTEP, RMNCHA+N,
National Immunization
Programme, NACP, Family
Planning programmes and on
nutrition.
2.37 (b) U.H.T.C.: Shakthinagara- Urban Health Centre and Urban Health Training Centre-Kottara Chowki (Distance from
the College) 7 KM and 12 KM
Population covered by the UHC
52245 and 50245
Is it owned by /affiliated to College (Yes/No) OR
Kottara Chowki- Yes
Affiliated to Government owned health centres (Yes/No) Shakthinagara- Yes (MOU with Govt
of Karnataka ANNEXURE-XVII)
Remarks
(* To be filled by the Assessor)
Yes
- 77 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Daily OPD
75-85
Diagnostics camps
Yes
Yes
Survey/MCH/Immunization/FP registers
Available
Yes
Specialist visits if any
General Medicine, Surgery, OBG,
OBG weekly twice (Tuesday and
Orthopaedics ENT and Opthalmology Friday)
Pediatrics, Medicine weekly once
ENT and Ophthal weekly twice
No. of Students and interns posted in batches of
NA
Deficiency if any
NA
Nil
2.38 CONDUCT OF III MBBS EXAMINATION (only for recognition under 11(2)) Not Applicable
•
•
•
•
University which conducts Examination:
No. of Candidates appeared in Examination:
The III MBBS examination (Part-II) was conducted satisfactorily: Yes/No
Centre for written/practical examination:
•
Was the standard sufficient for MBBS Examination as required by Regulations of the Medical Council of India read
with section 61(2) of NMC Act 2019?
THE FOLLOWING TABLES TO BE FILLED BY THE
ASSESSORS ON THE DAY OF ASSESSMENT
- 78 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Assessment date:
11/12/2025
Name of the Assessors
Correspondence Address
1. Dr. Mahendra Parmar
GMC/GMERS Medical College, Godhra
Contact No.
Email
9824326550
Mcparmar1961@gmail.com
9810477114
shaileshkdr@gmail.com
3. Dr. Thejaswi Hiriyur
Atal Bihari Vajpayee Institute of Medical 9717473100
thejaswitht@gmail.com
Thipperudrappa
Sciences and Dr. RML Hospital, New
Panchmahal
2. Dr. Shailesh Kumar
Atal Bihari Vajpayee Institute of Medical
Sciences and Dr. RML Hospital, New
Delhi
Delhi
4. Dr. Shivpal Vithalaro Tambe Government Medical College, Amravati
8888954813
Shivtambe@gmail.com
- 79 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.39
CLINICAL MATERIAL (*Random verification to be done by the Assessor)
O.P.D. attendance (at 2.00 PM On first day)
Data of past three days(to
be checked from hospital
register or MRD record)
Casualty attendance (24 hrs. data)
No. of admissions
No. of discharges
Bed occupancy% (at 10.00AM On first day)
65%
89.42% 87.11%
89%
No. of Medico-legal cases
-
-
-
-
No. of Births
No. of Deaths
-
-
-
No. of major surgical operations
No. of minor/day-care surgical procedures
No. of normal deliveries
No. of caesarian sections
-
Radiological Investigations (No. of cases)
O.P. D
I.P.D
X-ray
Ultrasonography
Contrast X-rays
-
-
-
C.T. Scans
MRI
-
-
-
-
-
Angiography
-
-
-
-
-
On the Day of
Assessment
Item
Operative Work
Remarks
- 80 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
On the Day of
assessment
Laboratory Investigations (No. of cases)
Data of past three days (to be
checked from hospital register
or MRD record)
O.P. D
I. P. D
Biochemistry
Microbiology
Serology
Hematology
Clinical pathology/ Lab medicine
Histopathology
Immunohistochemistry
-
-
-
-
-
Cytopathology
Remarks
- 81 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Teaching Faculty
Department
Professor
Asstt.Prof.
Nil
Nil
Sr. Resident
Tutor/Demons
trator
Professor
5 Deficiency of SR
compensated with
Tutors
Nil
Nil
Nil
Nil
4 Deficiency of SR
compensated with
Tutors
Assoc. Prof.
Physiology
Deficiency (for
UG)
Assoc. Prof.
Anatomy
Requirement
as per MSR
(UG)
Designation
Available
number as
per AEBAS
registration &
attendance
(for UG)
Asstt.Prof.
Sr. Resident
Additional
faculty required
for running PG
courses.
(If any)
Available
number as
per
AEBAS
registration
&
attendance
(For PG)
Deficiency
(for PG)
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
- 82 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Department
Designation
Biochemistry
Tutor/Demons
trator
Professor
Assoc. Prof.
Asstt.Prof.
Requirement
as per MSR
(UG)
Deficiency (for
UG)
Nil
Nil
Nil
Nil
4 Deficiency of SR
compensated with
Tutors
Tutor/Demons 3
trator
Professor
Assoc. Prof. 2
Asstt.Prof.
Sr. Resident 4
Nil
Nil
Nil
Nil
Nil
Sr. Resident
Pharmacology
Available
number as
per AEBAS
registration &
attendance
(for UG)
Tutor/Demons 3
trator
4 Deficiency of SR
compensated with
Tutors
Additional
faculty required
for running PG
courses.
(If any)
Available
number as
per
AEBAS
registration
&
attendance
(For PG)
Deficiency
(for PG)
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
- 83 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Department
Requirement
as per MSR
(UG)
Designation
Professor
Assoc. Prof.
Available
number as
per AEBAS
registration &
attendance
(for UG)
Asstt.Prof.
Sr. Resident
Tutor/Demons
trator
Professor
Assoc. Prof.
Asstt.Prof.
Pathology
Microbiology
Deficiency (for
UG)
Nil
Two extra
professors
compensated for
associate
Nil
Deficiency of SR
compensated with
Tutors
Nil
One extra
professor
compensated for
associate
Nil
Additional
faculty required
for running PG
courses.
(If any)
NA
Available
number as
per
AEBAS
registration
&
attendance
(For PG)
NA
Deficiency
(for PG)
NA
- 84 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Department
Forensic
Medicine and
Toxicology
Available
number as
per AEBAS
registration &
attendance
(for UG)
Requirement
as per MSR
(UG)
Designation
Sr. Resident
Tutor/Demons
trator
Professor
Assoc. Prof.
Asstt.Prof.
Sr. Resident
Tutor/Demons
trator
Professor
Assoc. Prof.
Deficiency (for
UG)
Additional
faculty required
for running PG
courses.
(If any)
Available
number as
per
AEBAS
registration
&
attendance
(For PG)
Deficiency
(for PG)
Deficiency of SR
Compensated
with Tutors
Nil
Nil
Nil
Deficiency of SR
compensated with
Tutors
Nil
Nil
1 (One extra
professor
NA
NA
NA
- 85 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Department
Community
Medicine
Requirement
as per MSR
(UG)
Designation
Available
number as
per AEBAS
registration &
attendance
(for UG)
Deficiency (for
UG)
Asstt.Prof.
Sr.Resident
Statistician
(minimum AP
level)
Tutor/Demons
trator
compensated for
the Associate)
Nil
Nil
Nil
Nil
Professor
Nil
Nil
Nil
NA
Nil
NA
Nil
Two extra
professors
Assoc. Prof.
General Medicine Asstt.Prof.
Sr. Resident
Jr. Resident
Professor
Assoc. Prof.
Additional
faculty required
for running PG
courses.
(If any)
Available
number as
per
AEBAS
registration
&
attendance
(For PG)
NA
NA
Deficiency
(for PG)
- 86 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Department
Requirement
as per MSR
(UG)
Designation
Available
number as
per AEBAS
registration &
attendance
(for UG)
Paediatrics
Deficiency (for
UG)
compensated for
Associate
Nil
Nil
NA
NA
Sr. Resident
Not required
Professor
compensated for
Associate
Nil
Nil
Jr. Resident
NA
NA
Professor
Nil
Nil
Nil
Nil
Asstt.Prof.
Sr. Resident
Jr. Resident
Professor
Assoc. Prof.
Dermatology
Asstt.Prof.
Assoc. Prof.
Asstt.Prof.
Additional
faculty required
for running PG
courses.
(If any)
Available
number as
per
AEBAS
registration
&
attendance
(For PG)
NA
NA
Deficiency
(for PG)
- 87 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Requirement
as per MSR
(UG)
Available
number as
per AEBAS
registration &
attendance
(for UG)
Deficiency (for
UG)
Department
Designation
Psychiatry
Sr. Resident
Clinical
Psychologist
Nil
Nil
Jr. Resident
Professor
NA
NA
NA
Nil
4 extra professors
compensated for
the Associate
Nil
Nil
NA
Nil
Nil
Nil
Nil
NA
NA
Nil
Assoc. Prof.
General Surgery Asstt.Prof.
Sr. Resident
Jr. Resident
Professor
Orthopaedics
Assoc. Prof.
Asstt.Prof.
Sr. Resident
Jr. Resident
Professor
Additional
faculty required
for running PG
courses.
(If any)
Available
number as
per
AEBAS
registration
&
attendance
(For PG)
NA
NA
NA
Deficiency
(for PG)
- 88 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Department
Designation
Oto-RhinoLaryngology
Assoc. Prof.
Asstt.Prof.
Sr. Resident
Jr. Resident
Professor
Assoc. Prof.
Ophthalmology
Requirement
as per MSR
(UG)
Available
number as
per AEBAS
registration &
attendance
(for UG)
Deficiency (for
UG)
Nil
Nil
Nil
NA
NA
Nil
Nil
Asstt.Prof.
Sr. Resident
Nil
Nil
Jr. Resident
NA
NA
Professor
Nil
Assoc. Prof.
Two extra
professors
compensated for
Associate
1 (Maternity
Leave)
Obstetrics
&Gynaecology
Asstt.Prof.
Additional
faculty required
for running PG
courses.
(If any)
Available
number as
per
AEBAS
registration
&
attendance
(For PG)
NA
NA
Deficiency
(for PG)
- 89 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Department
Requirement
as per MSR
(UG)
Designation
Sr. Resident
Jr. Resident
Professor
Assoc. Prof.
Anaesthesiology Asstt.Prof.
Sr. Resident
Jr. Resident
Professor
Assoc. Prof.
Radio-Diagnosis Asstt.Prof.
Sr. Resident
Professor
Assoc. Prof.
Available
number as
per AEBAS
registration &
attendance
(for UG)
Deficiency (for
UG)
NA
Nil
NA
NA
Nil
Nil
Nil
Nil
NA
Nil
Nil
Nil
Nil
Nil
Nil
Additional
faculty required
for running PG
courses.
(If any)
Available
number as
per
AEBAS
registration
&
attendance
(For PG)
NA
NA
NA
Deficiency
(for PG)
- 90 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
Department
Dentistry
Requirement
as per MSR
(UG)
Designation
Available
number as
per AEBAS
registration &
attendance
(for UG)
Deficiency (for
UG)
Asstt.Prof.
Nil
Sr. Resident
Nil
Additional
faculty required
for running PG
courses.
(If any)
Available
number as
per
AEBAS
registration
&
attendance
(For PG)
Department wise list of Faculty Members: to be attached as per point no 30, of annexure III of new UG MSR 2023
1) Deficiency of Teaching Faculty for UG seats: 2.68%
Deficiency of Teaching Faculty for additional PG seats (Department wise): Not Applicable
2) Deficiency of Tutors/Residents for UG seats: Nil
3) Deficiency of Tutors/Residents for additional PG seats (Department wise): Note Applicable
NOTE: For purpose of working out the deficiency, please refer New MSR 2023.
Deficiency
(for PG)
- 91 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
(A) For Teaching Faculty:
a) The teaching staff of all departments of medical college, shall be full-time, faculty shall not indulge in private practice
during college functioning hours.
b) These regulations cover the minimum requirements of undergraduate medical education as per the annual MBBS student
intake and the minimum patient load indicated in these regulations. However, the medical colleges/institutions and
teaching hospital(s) need to make provision for additional staff as indicated below.
•
Additional staff shall be provided proportionate to the workload.
•
Non-teaching staff shall also be required in OPD, Indoors, Operation theatres and Intensive Care areas, emergency care
area, labor room, clinical laboratories, or for outreach work where workload is heavy or is of specialized nature.
•
Additional teaching staff shall be required when starting postgraduate courses in accordance with "Postgraduate
Medical Education Regulations" as prescribed from time to time.
c) In department of Anatomy, Physiology, Biochemistry, non-medical teachers may be appointed to the extent of 15% of the
total number of posts in the department subject to non-availability of medical teachers. 'The above mentioned non-medical
teachers and the Statistician in the department of Community Medicine should possess qualification in that particular
subject from a recognized University as per requirements in Teacher Eligibility Qualification Regulations.
- 92 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
d) Post of junior cadre faculties up to Assistant Professors can be filled by senior cadre faculties, for example Assistant
Professor, by Associate Professor or Professor. Similarly Associate Professor by Professor, Tutors/demonstrators, and S. Rs
together shall meet the total number of required persons.
e) Senior Resident Doctors (SRs) shall be postgraduate candidates of the corresponding specialty or department. Tutors
shall be MBBS candidates. Demonstrators shall be postgraduates with PhD in the subject to be appointed, and not having
qualifications of MBBS.
f) Teachers appointed as faculty in super-specialty departments shall not be counted against the complement of teachers
required for under graduate medical education in broad specialty departments. However. teachers appointed in a broad
specialty department who may also have super-specialty qualifications shall be counted against the complement of teachers
required for under graduate medical education in the concerned broad specialty department.
g) Visiting faculty. With a view to enhance the comprehensiveness and quality of teaching of undergraduate students,
"Visiting Faculty" may be appointed as prescribed in "Minimum Qualifications for Teachers in Medical Institutions"
regulations over and above the minimum faculty prescribed herewith. The Visiting Faculty, however, shall not be considered
as faculty as per minimum requirements prescribed herewith.
- 93 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
(B) For Tutors/ Demonstrator/ Resident Doctors:
(a) Excess of Tutors/ Demonstrator/ SR can be compensated to the deficiency of JR of the same department only.
(b) Excess Tutors/ Demonstrator/ SR/JR of any department cannot compensate the deficiency of Tutors/ Demonstrator/
SR/JR in any other department.
(c) Any excess of JR cannot compensate the deficiency of SR in same or any other department.
(d) Any excess/ extra Teaching Faculty of same or any other department cannot compensate the deficiency of Tutors/
Demonstrator/ SR/JR.
e.g. excess of Assistant Professor cannot compensate the deficiency of Tutors/ Demonstrator/ SR / JR.
• A separate department of Dentistry/Dental faculty is not required where a dental college is available in same
campus/city and run by the same management.
•
Colleges running PG program require additional staff, beds & other requirements as per the PG Regulations – 2000.
Annexure-XVIII
Summary of Assessment
1. College Name: G.R. MEDICAL COLLEGE HOSPITAL &
RESEARCH CENTRE, Neermarga, Mangalore. Is run by Trust.
2. The college has got Permission from GOI/MCI with intake of ____ seats for the last academic year.
3. Type of assessment: Surprise Physical Inspection
4. PG courses : No
No. of seats: 1 5 0
- 94 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
5. Salient points of assessmentS No.
Major categories
Deficient/ Adequate
Deficiency of Teaching Faculty (% deficient)
2.68%
Manpower
Deficiency of Tutor/ Residents/Demonstrators(%
deficient)
College Infrastructure
Availability of Equipment in each Department
Hostel facility
Adequate
Committees
Adequate
Skill Lab
Adequate
Quality medical education and evaluation process
(MEU, Curriculum,T- L Methods, Feedback, Assessment
methodology etc.,)
Faculty (Professor, Associate Professor, Asst. Professor & Sr
Resident)
Teaching facility
Research Lab
Adequate
AEBAS (Aadhar Enabled Biometric Attendance System)
Adequate
Hospital Infrastructure
Adequate
Nil
Adequate
Adequate
Not Applicable
Adequate
Adequate
- 95 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
S No.
Major categories
Deficient/ Adequate
Clinical Material
Adequate
Adequate
Investigations (numbers adequate or not)
Equipment available as per schedule III of UG MSR 2023
Variety of Surgical Procedures
Adequate
Any other Remarks: Dissection hall is on third floor, provision for lift is available and should be made available. The
infrastructure of the OTs, ward, ICUs Labor room etc are adequate and good.
NOTE: No recommendations, only observations to be recorded
- 96 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
NATIONAL MEDICAL COMMISSION
UG ASSESSMENT FORM
Part A-II (a)
(FOR ANNUAL INTAKE OF 150ADMISSIONS OR INCREASE IN INTAKE FROM
TO
ADMISSIONS)
For Academic year 2025 - 2026
All relevant sections of NMC Act 2019 and the regulations made thereunder
The following have to be filled by the Institution/ Medical college and Assessor have to write their remarks.
Type of Assessment: Surprise Physical Inspection
Regular/ Compliance: Letter of Permission ( ), 1st renewal ( ), 2nd renewal ( ), 3rd renewal ( ), 4th renewal ( )
- NA
Increase Admission Capacity: Regular/Compliance: Letter of Permission ( ),
1st renewal ( ), 2nd renewal ( ), 3rd renewal ( ), 4th renewal ( ) - NA
Recognition - Regular/ Compliance - NA
Continuation of Recognition - Regular / Compliance - NA
Any Other: NA
- 97 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
12.
As can be seen from the aforesaid report and its
summary, the respondent No.2 has recorded all findings in favour
of the petitioner by noticing that there was adequate occupancy in
the OPD Department and Bed occupancy as required for the
purpose of obtaining renewal; so also, the aforesaid Inspection
report records that the petitioner – Institution possessed adequate
infrastructure, availability of equipment in each department,
adequate hostel facility, committees, skill labs, teaching facility,
research labs, hospital infrastructure, clinical material, investigation
as well as adequate variety of surgical procedures; insofar as the
minor deficiency of 2.68% in the faculty, it is submitted on behalf of
the petitioner that the said deficiency would also be rectified and
covered
by
the
petitioner
at
the
earliest.
Under
these
circumstances, I am of the considered opinion that despite the
petitioner – Institution possessing adequate facilities, infrastructure
etc., as required in law as can be seen from the undisputed
Inspection report submitted by the MARB, the respondent No.3
clearly fell in error in passing the subsequent impugned order at
Annexure – R dated 02.01.2026, which is not only contrary to the
aforesaid report but also to the material on record warranting
interference by this Court in the present petition.
- 98 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
13.
A perusal of the impugned order at Annexure – R
dated 02.01.2026 will also indicate that after noticing sufficient
faculty presence as on the date of the inspection conducted on
11.12.2025, the respondent No.3 – UGMEB clearly committed an
error in coming to the conclusion that as per the year long AEBAS
data, there was sustained and continued deficiencies falling behind
the prescribed norms by placing reliance upon insufficient
attendance on the part of the faculty; in this context, it is relevant to
state that apart from the fact that alleged lack of attendance on the
part of certain faculty due to various reasons was not the criteria for
the purpose of evaluation of eligibility for renewal in favour of the
petitioner – Institution, it is the existence of sufficient faculty
employed by the petitioner that was relevant and germane for the
purpose of obtaining renewal and mere alleged shortage / lack of
attendance of certain members of the faculty for valid reasons
could not have been made the basis by the respondent No.3 –
UGMEB to refuse renewal in favour of the petitioner – Institution
and consequently, the impugned order deserves to be quashed on
this ground also.
- 99 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
14.
A perusal of the material on record will indicate that it
is an undisputed fact that the initial permission to start the MBBS
course with 150 seats was granted in favour of the petitioner –
Institution by the respondent No.2 – MARB vide letter of permission
dated 13.12.2021 issued under Section 26 (1) (a)(b) and 28 (1) &
(2) of the NMC Act and not by the respondent No.3 – UGMEB
coupled with the fact that both MARB and UGMEB were
constituted together under Section 16 of the NMC Act; it follows
therefrom that the initial permission to establish the petitioner –
Institution having been granted by the MARB and not by the
UGMEB, it was only the respondent No.2 – MARB that could have
considered the request of the petitioner for renewal and not the
UGMEB and as such, the impugned order passed by the
respondent No.3 – UGMEB deserves to be quashed on this score
also.
15.
The aforesaid facts and circumstances will clearly
indicate that respondent No.2 clearly fell in error in refusing to
renew the permission to run the petitioner – Institution for the
Academic year 2025-2026 by passing the impugned orders dated
30.06.2025 and 02.01.2026, which accordingly deserve to be
- 100 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
quashed as stated hereinbefore; further, having regard to the fact
that the academic year 2025-2026 has already commenced, the
question of directing the respondents to grant renewal in favour of
the petitioner for the academic year 2025-2026 does not arise in
the facts and circumstances of the instant case; however, having
regard to the findings recorded by me hereinbefore and quashment
of the impugned orders and as a consequence of the same, I deem
it just and appropriate to direct the concerned respondents to
renew the permission granted in favour of the petitioner to run the
petitioner – Institution for the next academic year i.e., 2026-2027
by passing appropriate orders in this regard in favour of the
petitioner within a period of one month from the date of receipt of a
copy of this order.
16.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner also took
this Court in detail to the various provisions contained in the NMC
Act as well as the Regulations of 2023 in order to point out that
there is various ambiguities and discrepancies, deficiencies
lacunae, etc., in the Regulations, which are contrary to the
provisions of the NMC Act and the impugned Regulations deserve
to be declared and struck down as unconstitutional and ultra-vires
- 101 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
the provisions of the NMC Act; on the other hand, the learned
counsel for the respondents would vehemently refute the said
contentions urged on behalf of the petitioner.
However, having
regard to the findings recorded by me in the facts and
circumstances obtaining in the instant case as stated hereinbefore,
I do not deem it necessary to consider prayer Nos.(i) and (ii)
sought for by the petitioner for the purpose of the present order
except directing the respondent No.1 – National Medical
Commission to reconsider and revisit / relook / re-examine the
Maintenance of Standards of Medical Education Regulations, 2023
in the light of the provisions contained in the NMC Act, 2019 by
considering the various contentions put-forth by both sides in this
regard and as such, the said issue / question is kept / left open to
be decided in an appropriate case and no opinion is expressed in
this regard for the purpose of the present order.
17.
In the result, I pass the following:
ORDER
(i)
The petition is hereby allowed-in-part.
- 102 NC: 2026:KHC:13049
WP No. 36088 of 2025
HC-KAR
(ii)
The
impugned
orders
at
Annexure-B1
dated
30.06.2025 and Annexure – R dated 02.01.2026, both passed by
respondent No.3 – UGMEB are hereby quashed.
(iii)
The concerned respondents are hereby directed to
renew the permission granted in favour of the petitioner to run the
petitioner – Institution for the next academic year i.e., 2026-2027
by passing appropriate orders in this regard in favour of the
petitioner within a period of one month from the date of receipt of a
copy of this order
(iv)
The
respondent
No.1
–
the
National
Medical
Commission is hereby directed to reconsider and revisit / relook /
re-examine the Maintenance of Standards of Medical Education
Regulations, 2023 in the light of the provisions contained in the
NMC Act, 2019 bearing in mind the present order and by
considering the various contentions put-forth by both sides in this
regard, in accordance with law.
Sd/(S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
BMC / SV
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 4
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review