Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3302 J
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
I/ONDAY, THE THIRTIETH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K, SARATH
Between:
WRIT PETITION NO: 33785 0F 2023
G. Narayana, S/o. Kistaiah, Aged about 56 years, Drrver (F- 175946), TSRTC,
Yadagirigutta Bus Depot, Yadadri- Bhongir District, T S. (R/o Ambedkar
Colony, Narayanapur (V and M), Yadadri- Bhongir District)
..Pi:TITIONER
AND
1 The Telangana State Road Transport Corporation, Rep. by rts Managing
Director, Bus Bhavan, Musheerabad, T. S.
2. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its princrpal Secretarr itirnsltort
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad
3. The Regional Manager, TSRTC, Nalgonda Region, Nalgonda -f 3
4 The Depot Manager, TSRTC, Yadagirigutta Bus Depot, yad,-,.in- Bhongir
Diskict, T. S.
RESi-}CNDENTS
Petition under Nltcle 226 of the Constitution of lndia o;:i,ri;r fhat n the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High couri ma ce pieased
to issue a writ or order or direction more particularly one in the n-.rt,i .. of ,vrit of
mandamus declaring that the action of the respondents in alterrng, ti:i; ,late of birth
of the petitioner from 25-07 -1968 to 06-03-1966 is bad, arbitrary,, rliega, :nC against
to the Principles of natural justice and consequenfly direct the r:,,i cnoents to
confirm the date of birth of the petitioner as 25-07-1968 and contii;ue .. :-. rn service
by treating his date of birth as 25-07-1968 till his superannuatrcn
l.A. NO: 1 oF 2023
Petition under Section i 51 cpc praying that in the circu r stances ,ated
affidavit frled in support of the petitron, the High Court may
b,: L-leased . r direct the
Respondents to continue the petitioner in service by treatinc
his dai., cr birth as
25-07-1968, pending disposat of the writ petition
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI p.VENKATESWAR RAO
Counsel for the Respondent No..l,3 & 4: SRI R.ANURAG,
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: AGp FOR SERVICES_I
The Court made the following: ORDER
rn the
{i ; FOR -i'S.tfC
/
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT TIYDERABAD
,1'
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SARATH
WRIT PETITION No.33785 of 2o23
THE 3OTH DAY OF MARCH 2026
Between:
G.Narayana.
...Petitioner
AND
The Telangana State Road Transport Corporation,
Rep. by its Managing Director and others.
...Respondents
ORDER:
Heard Sri P.Venkateswar Rao, learned Counsel for the
petitioner, Sri R.Anurag, learned Standing Counsel for the
Telangana State Road Transport Corporation appearing for
the respondent Nos.l, 3 and 4 and the learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Services-l appearing lor the
respondent No.2. Perused the material on record.
2.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that this
Writ Petition is hled questioning the action of the respondents
in altering the date cf birth of the petitioner from 25.07.1968
to 06.03.1966, as illcgal and arbitrary
\
l
3.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner lurther submits that
the petitioner joined as Driver in the respondet 1-Corporation
in the year, 2OO0 and his services were r rgularized on
01.01.2OO9. Initially, the petitioner's date o birth in the
service record was recorded as 06.03.1966 z,: Ld thereafter,,
the Road Transport Corporation (RTC) issued (l rcular No.PD-
lL/2011, dated 31.03.2O11, for correct recorcl ng of the date
of birth of employees in service records, and in the
PMS/payrolls of the employees in th,: respondentCorporation. The respondents verihed the sr: vice record of
the petitioner and as per the verification, the 1t :titioner's date
of birth was recorded as 25.07.1968. Wh.: it being so,
without issuing any notice to the petitioner ar d without any
proceedings, the respondents asked the pet .ioner to retire
from service with effect from 31.03.2026 on ,. re ground that
the date of the birth of the petitioner wil ; recorded as
06.03.1966 in the service record.
4.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner furtht r submits that
the petitioner was not having any qualif,rcaticr at the time of
joining duty. The petitioner's date of birth w: s mentioned in
\
his driving license as 25.07.1968, even prior to his joining
duty. In view of the same, after verification as per Circular
No.PD-11/20ll, dated 31.03.2011, the respondents had
altered the date of birth of the petitioner to 25.O7.1968, along
with other employees. Without issuing any notice to the
petitioner, the respondents had again altered the date of the
birth of the petitioner as 06.03.1966. The said action of the
respondents is illegal and arbitrary and in view of the same,
learned Counsel for the petitioner requested this Court to
allow the Writ Petition by declaring the date of birth of the
petitioner as 25.07.1968 and directing the respondents to
continue him in service till his superannuation by treating
the said date as date ol birth of the petitioner.
5.
On the other hand, Iearned Standing Counsel appearing
for the respondent Nos.l, 3 and 4, basing on the counter
afhdavit submits that, as per the Service Regulations of the
Corporation, the age of an employee is to be assessed as
under:
"As per regulotion 19 (2) (b) o/? SRTC Seruice Regulation, 1964,
"where the person concerned ts unable to fumish satisfactory
euidence of his age, it should be assessed by a Medical Officer
of the Corporotion and the age so assessed of the age as
)
)
decLared bg the person, whicheuer is more, shall be rccepted as
f,nal and the emplogee sholl be ossumed to hot,, cornpleted
that age on the date of attestation bg the Medical Cl.icer".
6.
Learned Standing Counsel appearing for , re respondent
Nos.1,3 and 4 further submits that, in accor,lance with the
above provisions, the petitioner was examinecl I ,v the Medical
Oflicer for assessment of age at the time of rr: :ruitment and
since the petitioner had not submitted all / educational
certificates to establish proof of age or date of r-- rth before the
appointing authority, the Medical Officer assessed the
petitioner's age as 34 years as on 06.03.200( uide Medical
Certificate No.AO/0288. Based on this cer tification, the
petitioner's date of birth was determined as 0(i 03.1966. The
then Selection Committee, while fotlowing the l,rocedure, had
followed the rules and regulations existing duri tg that period.
In view of the above provisions, there are nt merits in the
Writ Petition and requested to dismiss the sarrr r.
7. After hearing both sides and on a perusi d of the entire
material on record, this Court is of the consi( ered view that
there is no dispute with regard to the petition :r joining duty
in the respondent-Corporation in the year, 2OOO and his
I
I
servrces
being regularized on 01.01.2009. At the time of
joining duty, in the service record, the petitioner's date ol
birth was recorded as 06.03.1966 and it is also not disputed
that the date of the birth of the petitioner was altered as
25.O7.1968 in pursuance of Circular No.PD-1L/2011, dated
31.03.2011, issued by the respondent-Corporation.
Thereafter, the respondents once again informed the
petitioner that they
are
treating his date of birth as
06.03.1966 and informed the petitioner that his date of
retirement is 31.03.2026. Aggrieved by the said action of the
respondents, the petitioner liled the instant Writ Petition.
8. At the time of arguments, this Court directed the
respondents to produce the original service records pertaining
to the petitioner and the learned Standing Counsel produced
the original record on 25.03.2026. A perusal of the records
clearly shows that, initially, the petitioner's date of birth was
recorded in the service record as 06.03.1966. Thereafter, in
pursuance of Circular No.PD-1tl2OI1, dated 31.03.2O11, it
was corrected as 25.07.1968 and the same was signed by the
competent authorities with seal as per the said circular. In
l
)
.:
the same service record, the said entry was ro rnded off and
once again the date of birth of the petitionelr as mentioned
as O6.03.1966, signed by the Assistant Marager, TSRTC,
Nalgonda, without any mention with r:3ard to the
proceedings or notice to the petitioner. Moreor 3r, there is no
date of signature on the said entry. It clearly sh >ws that, after
the date of birth of the petitioner was altered fir m 06.03.1966
to 25.09.1968 in pursuance of the Circular Irl, r.PD-11/2011,
dated 31.O3 .2Ol I , without issuing any notice t r the petitioner
and without any proceedings, the responrl:nts are now
asking the petitioner to retire from service on 11.03.2O26 on
the ground that the petitioner's date of birtfL is recorded in
the service record as 06.09.1966.
9. The contention of the respondents is that they have
followed Regulation 19(3) r/w. 19(2Xb) of thc llTC Employees
(Service) Regulations, 1964 at the time the p :titioner joined
duties. But they have not disputed with rc1: rrd to Circular
No.PD-il/2011, dated 31.03.2011. In view,r'the same, the
respondents cannot now rely on Regulation 19 of the said
Regulations, which was relaxed by issu:r:t:e of Circular
I
No.PD- 1 I l2Ol1, dated 31.03.201 1 and a-lso after following
the procedure as contemplated in the circular, altered the
date of birth of the petitioner as 25.07. 1968. In view of the
same, the respondents have to continue the petitioner tn
service treating his date of birth as 25.07.1968.
10. The Division Bench of this Court in P.Pochammq. os.
Principal Secretary, Technico.l Education, Govt. of
Andhro. Prq.d.esh and othersr, at para-Nos.8, 10 and 11,
held as under:
"8. There are uorious other judgments refened to by the leamed
CounseL for the petitioner, which pertain to claim of employees
for change of dote of birth and it has been consistentlg trcld bg
the Supreme Court that date of birth os entered in the seruice
register should not be ordered to be changed unless there is
unimpeachable euidence. The some pinciple uill opplg to tle
emploger uLho wants to change the recorded date of birth an
employee.
10. ..-..uthereas in the present case the I urit petitioner was not
retired on the accepted date of birth as entered in her seruice
register, tuhereos in the present case the I writ petitioner u)as
not retired on the accepted date of birth as entered in her
seruice register, but on the basis of date arriued at bg the
respondents on the bosis of a forensic expert uhich LUas not
euen euer put to the petitioner. The petitioner wds not euen
giuen a chance to shotu-cause as to whether the reporl of tLe
forensic experi obtained in 1994 should be relied upon or not.
She wos not euen giuen a chance to shou thot the cettificate
issued in her fauour in 1983 bg the Sarponcll Gram
Panchagat, Chintakunta uillage uas genuine.
| 2OO4 (41 ALT 156 (DB)
i
ue allout the urit appea| se I aside the
order of the learned Single Judge and direct llt, t tl'te writ
petitioner shall be reinstated into seruice uith all c,> t.sequential
benefts. No order as lo costs. "
1 1. For these reasons
11. The above hndings of the Division Bench r,t this Court in
P.Pocho,mma (supra) squarely apply to th€ facts of the
present case. In the instant case, in implemr: rtation of the
Circular No.PD-1 I /2O11, dated 31.03.201 l, ttL : respondents
a.ltered the date of birth of the petitioner fronr )6.03.1966 to
25.07.1968. The respondents failed to show il: y proceedings
on record with regard to changing of the entrv . Ls 25.09.1968
to O6.03.1966 by following procedure as well z s issuing any
notice to the petitioner. Without doing the i tme, the said
entry of date of birth was changed by the Assis _ant Manager,
TSRTC, Nalgonda, who is not a competent aulhority to alter
the date of birth of the petitioner. In view ol the same, the
impugned alteration of the date of birth of tt., petitioner by
the Assistant Manager, TSRTC, Nalgonda, r:zt rnot be taken
into account. The petitioner's date of birth hr s to be taken
into account as 25.07.1968, as recorded by he competent
authority in pursuance of Circular No.pD-1 /2011 , dated
\ \31,03.2011. ln view of the same, the respor dents have to
\
ra
continue the petitioner in service treating his date of birth as
2s.o7.t968.
12. In view of the above findings, this Writ petition is
I
allowed by declaring that the date of birth of the petitioner is
I
I
I
25.07.1968 as recorded by the respondent authorities in
pursuance of the Circular No.pD-1 l /2011, dated 31.03.2011
and the respondents are directed to continue the service of
the petitioner till his age of superannuation as per said date
of birth.
13. Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this Writ
Petition shall stand closed. There shall be no order as to
costs.
SD/-S. MALLIKII; .IUNA RAO
ASSISTAN; iIGISTRAR
(e
//TRUE COPY//
SECTIDI{ OFFICER
To,
1. The Managing Drrector, Telangana State Road Transpoit C:: .atior,, Bus
Bhavan, [Vlusheerabad, T. S.
2 The Principal Secretary, Transport Department, Secretariat, H1':i: ; rbad, State
of Telangana.
3. The Regronal lvlanager, TSRTC, Nalgonda Region, Nalgorrda.
4 The Depot Manager, TSRTC, Yadagingutta Bus Depot, Yal,,ri- Btrongir
I
District, T S.
5. One CC to SRI P.VENKATESWAR RAO, Advocate [OPUC]
6 One CC to SRI R ANURAG, SC FOR TSRTC [OPUC]
7. Two CCs to GP FOR SERVICES-|, High Court for the State o
Hyderabad [OUT]
8. Two CD Copies
BSR
BS &l
i;rr t; na at
,/
\
\
I
i
CC
l
-TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED: 30t03t2126
---:,--:: a r-.
ti ii-'l- "L4
:
I r,
ORDER
WP.No.337BS ot 2023
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION,
WITHOUT COSTS
*\s
s st
-r(.\
^\
[2
trt-'
t
t rF 7n?t
\,
'ir
ti
a.
/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review