Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 33021
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWELFTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K. SARATH
WRIT PETITION N os.4052 0.40521 and 40522 ot 2025
't'l
OF
m
T.Parashuramulu, s/o chandraiah, Aged about 38 years, Artisan Gradell operation,
Keesara Section, TGSPDCL, Ri/o. Keesaragutta
...PETITIONER
by
1. Southern Power Distribution, Company of Telangana Limited' Represlnted
T'G'
is Ctriiiman ano Managing birectbr, Mint Comp-ound, Hyderabad,
2. The Chairman and Managing Director, Southern Power Distribution Company
of Telangana Ltd. Mint Comfound, Hyderabad, T.G.
3. The Director, HRD TGSPDCL, Corporate Office, Mint Compound, Hyderabad,
T.G.
4. The Chief General Manager (HRD)' TGSPDCL, Corporate Office, Mint
Compound, Hyderabad, T.G.
5. The Chief General Manager, (O & M) Rural Zone, TGSPDCL, Corporate
Office, Mint ComPound, HYderabad.
6. The Chief General Manager, Operation TGSPDCL, Medchal Zonal,
Hyderabad.
7. The Superintending Engineer, Operation, TGSPDCL, Habsiguda, Hyderabad'
8. The Divisional Engineer Elecl, Op6ration, Keesara, TGSPDCL' Keesara'
Habsiguda Circle.
9. State of Telangana, Represented- by its Principal Secretary, Energy
Department, Secietariat, Hyderabad, T.G.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia pralng that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be
pleased to issue writ or direction preferably Writ of Mandamus by declaring the
action of the: Respondents in imposing the penalty of stoppage of two (2) annual
grade incrr:ments with cumulative effect vide impugned Memo. No.
CGM/OP/Merdchal Zone/DE(Ty AAO/JAO/Adm./D.No.31 68/23 dated 24-02-2024
of the 6th Respondent without furnishing a copy of the enquiry report and on the
dictates of the higher authority and further ordering recovery of an amount of
Rupees 3,82,6721- vide Memo. No. DEE/OP/KEESARA/JAO(PAS)/D.No.
dated nit-
12-2025 of tre 8th Respondent by placing reliance on subsequent material, which
did not form part of enquiry proceedings, as being arbitrary, illegal, opposed to
principles of natural justice, erroneous, contrary to the material on record and in
violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of lndia and to set-aside the same
accordingly in interest of justice.
IAN
Petition under Section 'l5l CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the operation of impugned Memo. No. CGM/Op/Medchal
ZonelDE(T/r\AO/JAO/Adm./D. No. 3168/23 dated 24-02-2024 and the retated
recovery proceedings issued vide Memo. No. DEE/OP/KEESARA/JAO(PASyD.
No. dated nil..12-2}25 by the 6th and 8th Respondents respectively.
WRIT
NO: 40521 oF 2025
Between:
G.Nagarjun S;/o G.Bala _Syvar1y, Aged about 34 years,
Artisan Grade-ll Operation,
Keesara Section, TGSPDCL, R7o. Keesaragutta
...PETITIONER
AND
1. Southern Power Distribution Company of Telangana Limited, Represented by
its Chairman and Managing Directbr, Mint Comp-ound, Hyderabaci, T.G.
2. The Chairman and Managing Director,.Southern Power Distribution Company
of Telangana Ltd. Mint Compound, Hyderabad, T.G.
3. Th_e Director, HRD TGSPDCL, Corporate Office, Mint Compound, Hyderabad,
T.G.
4. The Chief General Mq4qger (HRD), TGSPDCL, Corporate Office, Mint
Compound, Hyderabad, T.G.
5. The Chief General Manager, (O and M) Rural Zone, TGSPDCL' Corporate
Office, Mint Compound, HYderabad.
6. The Chief General Manager, Operation TGSPDCL' Medchal Zone,
Hyderabad.
7. The Superintending Engineer, Operation, TGSPDCL, Habsiguda, Hyderabad.
8. The Divisional Engineer Elecl., Operation. Keesara, TGSPDCL, Keesara,
Habsiguda Circle.
9. State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary, Energy
Department, Secietariat, Hyderabad, T.G.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue writ or direction preferably writ of Mandamus by declaring the
action of the Respondents in imposing the penalty of stoppage of two (2) annual
grade increments with cumulative effect vide impugned Memo. No.
CG M/OP/Medchal ZoneIDE(T/AAO/JAO/Ad m./D. No. 3'l 7 0 I 23 daled 241 O2l 2024
of the 6th Respondent without furnishing a copy of the enquiry report and on the
dictates of the higher authority and further ordering recovery of an amount of
Rupees 3,82,672t- vide Memo. No. DEE/OP/KEESARA/JAO(PASyD. No dated
nilt12t2o25 of the 8th Respondent by placing reliance on subsequent material,
which did not form part of enquiry proceedings, as being arbitrary, illegal, opposed
to principles of natural justice, erroneous, contrary to the material on record and in
violation of Article 14 0f the constitution of lndia and to set-aside the same
accrrdingly in interest of justice.
Petition under Section 15'l CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the operation of impugned Memo. No. CGM/OP/Medchal
ZonelDE(T)/AAO/JAO/Adm./D. No. 3170/23 daled 241o212024 and the related
recovery proceedings issued vide Memo. No. DEE/OP/KEESARA/JAO(PAS/D'
No. dated nilt12l2025 by the 6th and 8th Respondents respectively
Ch.Masoom, !i/o Chinna lddaiah, Aged about 39 years, Junior Lineman Operation,
Keesara Section, TGSPDCL, Rl/o. Keesaragutta
...PETITIONER
AND
Southern Power Distribution Company of Telangana Limited., Represented by
its Chairman & Managing Director, Mint Compound, Hyderabad, T.G.
The Chairman and Managing Director, Southern Power Distribution Company
of Telangana Ltd. Mint Compound, Hyderabad, T.G.
3. The Director, HRD TGSPDCL, Corporate Office, Mint Compound, Hyderabad,
T.G.
4. The Chief General Manager (HRD), TGSPDCL, Corporate Office, Mint
Compo.rnd, Hyderabad, T.G.
5. The Chief General Manager, (O&M) Rural Zone, TGSPDCL, Corporate Office,
Mint Cc,mpound, Hyderabad.
6. The C:hief General Manager, Operation TGSPDCL, Medchal Zone,
Hyderabad.
7. The Superintending Engineer, Operation, TGSPDCL, Habsiguda, Hyderabad.
8. The Divisional Engineer, Elecl. Operation Keesara, TGSPDCL, Keesara,
Habsiguda Circle.
9. State of Telangana, Represented
by
Departrnent, Secretariat, Hyderabad, T G.
its Principal Secretary, Energy
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 ot lhe Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstance'; stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to is sue writ or direction preferably Writ of Mandamus by declaring the
action of the Respondents in imposing the penalty of stoppage of two (2) annual
grade increrents with cumulative effect vide impugned Memo. No.
CG M/O P/Medcha I Zon e/DE(T/AAO/JAO/Ad m./D. No. 31 69 I 23 dated 24 -O2-2O24
of the 6th Respondent without furnishing a copy of the enquiry report and on the
dictates of tl're higher authority and further ordering recovery of an amount of
Rupees 3,82,6721- vide Memo. No. DEE/OP/KEESARA/JAO(PAS/D. No. dated
nil-12-2O25 cf the 8th Respondent by placing reliance on subsequent material,
which did nr:t form part of enquiry proceedings, as being arbitrary, illegal,
opposed to principles of natural justice, erroneous, contrary to the material on
record and in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of lndia and to set-aside
the same accordingly in interest of justice.
,,1
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the operation of impugned Memo. No. CcM/Op/tvledchal
ZonelDE(TyAAO/JAO/Adm./D. No. 3169123 dated 24-02-2024 and the retated
recovery proceedings issued vide Memo. No. DEE/OP/KEESARA/JAO(PASyD.
No. dated nil-12-2025 by the 6th and 8th Respondents respectively.
Counsel for the Petitioner in all the Writ Petitions:
Ms. CHEKURI JYOTSNA DEVI
Counsel for the Respondents No.1 to 8 in allthe Writ Petitions:
SRI N. SREEDHAR REDDY, S.C. FOR TGSPDCL
Counsel for the Respondent No.9 in all the Writ Petitions: GP FoR ENERGY
The Court made the following: ORDER
"-'--'-'-""-7
SK, J
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF.
TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SARATH
WRIT PETITION Nos.4OS 20. 4O52L and.40522 of
2o.25
DATE:L2.O2
Between:
1. T.Parshuramulu
2.
G.llagarjuna
3.
Ch.Masoom
Petitioner in WP No.4O52O of 2025
Petitioner in WP No.40521 of 2025
Petitioner in WP No.40522 of 2025
AND
1. South,:rn Po'*,er Distribution Company Ltd., represented
by its C:hairman and Managing Director, Hyderabad and
others
.Respondents
COMMO}I ORDER:
1. AIl these Writ Petitions are Iiled questioning the
action o[ the rcspondents ln imposing the penalty of
stoppage ol two (2) annual grade increments with
cumulative effect vide Impugned Memo No.CGM/OP/
Medchal ZonelDE (T)iAAOIJAO /Adm./ D.No.3168, 3170,
and 3169/2023 dated 24.02.2024 respectively, issued by
the respondent No.6 without furnishing a copy of the
SI(, J
enquiry report and further ordering recovery of amount of
Rs.3,82,6721 - from each petitioner vide Memo No.DBE/
OP/KEESARA/JAO(PAS)/D.No. dated Nil- 1 2-2025 issued
by the respondent No.8 as arbitraqr and illegal.
2.
Heard Ms.Chekuri Jyotsna Devi, learned Counsel for
the petitioners and Sri N.Sreedhar Reddy, learned Standing
Counsel for Respondents.
3.
Since all the writ petitions arise out of one and the
same issue, they are being taken up together and disposed
of by this common order.
4.
The learned Counsel for the petitioners submits that
while the petitioners were working as Artisan Grade-I[, they
were
placed under suspension vide Proceedings
dated 30.0L.2O23 on the allegation that due to their
negligence, theft of certain material had taken place. Later
they were reinstated into service vide proceedings
dated 02.06.2023. Departmental proceedings
were
initiated against the petitioners on 12.05.2023 on the
ground that theft had taken place due to negligence and
dereliction on their part. The contents of the charge Memo
SK, J
would disclose that a theft took place on 30.01.2O23, but it
is not the case of the respondents that the petitioners are
responsible for the alleged theft. Similar charges were also
framed against the Assistant Engineer.
5. The learned Counsel for the petitioners further
submits that the petitioners have submitted explanation
denying the allegations made in the charge Memo and
stated that the petitioners have been performing various
duties a nd there is no security guard and requested to
drop the proceedings. Apart from Charge Memo
dated 12.05.2023, another charge Memo dated OS.l2.2O2g
was issrled by the respondent No.5 with the similar
allegatiorrs. Later enquiry was restricted only to the Charge
Memo clated 12.O5.2023. After conducting enquiry,
punishment of stoppage of two (2) annual grade increments
with cunrulative effect lvas imposed on each petitioner vide
Proceedings dated 24.02.2024 issued by the respondent
No.6. Eleing aggrieved by the same, the petitioners have
filed appeals on 20.05.2024 before the respondent No.3
and the same are still pending. Howerrer, the respondents
\
are
SK, J
taking steps to recover the amounts from the
petitioners with effect from 01.0L.2026'
6. The learned counsel for the petitioners further
submits that the respondents straight away, without
furnishing the coPY of enquiry report, imPosed
punishment, which is gross violation of PrinciPles of
justice. During pendency of appeals, the respondent No.S
issued a Memo dated Nil- 1 2-2025 for recovery of amount of
Rs.3,82,6721-from each petitioner. A common proceedings
of recovery was issued by the respond.ent No.8, where the
narnes of petitioners are figured in the table contained
therein. Being aggrieved by the saIne, these writ petitions
are filed and. requested. to allow the writ petitions by setting
aside the imPunged orders'
7.
The learned standing counsel for the respondents
basing on the counter submits that while the petitioners
were working as Artisans Grade-II Operators in Yadgarpally
Sub-station, they were placed under suspension on
30.0 t.2o23 due to negligence and dereliction of their
SK, J
duties resulting in theft of certain material from the said
Sub-station. Thereafter, a charge Memo was issued to the
petitioners on 12.05.2023 and an Enquiry Officer was
appointe<l to conduct enquiry. Pending the said enquiry,
the petitirners were reinstated into service on 02.06 .2023.
During the course of enquiry, the charges levered against
the petitioners were proved and in view of the same the
competer.t authority i.e., the respondent No.6-Chief
General Ivlanager has imposed punishment of stoppage of
t';vo annual grade increments with.cumulative effect on the
petitione.s vide
Memo
No.cGM /op lMedchal
Zone/DEgllAAO/JAO/Adm./D.No.3168, 3170
and
3169 /20:23 dated 24.02.2024 respectively due to
negligence on the part of the petitioners.
8. The learned Standing counsel for the respond.ents
further submits that petitioners preferred appeals to the
Director (HRD), TGSPDCL and the said appeals have not
yet been Laken up for hearing. For the purpose of recovery
of loss ca.used to the respondent-company in view of theft
of materjal from the Sub-station due to dereliction, the
I
I
SK, J
Chief Engineer (O & M) has appointed a Committee of Four
Senior Members vide Memo dated 22.10.2024 to ascertain
the amount to be recovered due to theft from the
Sub-station and the said committee has submitted a
report to take stringent action against the petitioners for
the lapses in discharging their duties and also for recovery
of cost of the stolen material of Rs.19,13,359/- from the
concerned i.e. 41o/o from the Assistant Engineer and 2Oo/o
each of the petitioners herein. As the enquiry was already
conducted and decided to recover the loss from the
concerned, no further notice is required to be issued to the
petitioners, in as much as the petitioners are also
responsible for the loss caused to the respondent-company.
Moreover, having filed appeals before the appellate
authority, the petitioners cannot initiate parallel
proceedings by way of filing the instant writ petitions
questioning the very same proceedings and there are no
merits and requested to dismiss all the writ petitions.
g.
After hearing both sides and on perusing the record,
this Court is of the considered view that the petitioners are
questioning the impugned order for stopping of two
i.
SK, J
increments with cumulative effect dated 24.O2.2024
passed b'f the respondent N o.6 and also the proceedings
for recov,-'ry of amounts dated nil.l2.2o25 issued by the
respondent No.8. Once the petitioners have filed appeals
aggrieved by the said orders before the appellate authority,
the petitioners cannot challenge the said proceedings in
the instant writ petitions. The respondents without waiting
for disposal of those appeals, now constituted a Committee
for fixing the responsibility, there was no mention about
the reco!'ery of amounts in the punishment orders dated
24.02.20'.24, ir:. spite of that issued impugned proceedings
dated N:il.12.2025 for recovery of amounts from the
petitioners to a tune of Rs.3,82,6721- each, which is
arbitrary and illegal. After disposal of the appeals, if the
petitioners are found to be responsible, the respondent
authoritir:s are at liberty to take steps for recovery of the
amounts by following due procedure of law.
10. In view of the same, recovery orders passed by the
respondent authorities pending disposal of the appeals
filed by r:he petitioners before the appetlate authority are
liable to be set aside.
I
t
,#
l!t@
\ia'r
B
SK, J
11. [n view of the above findings, these writ
Petitions are disposed of by setting aside the
impugned Memo No.DEE/OP/KEESARA/JAO(pAS)/D.No.
dated nil.12.2025 issued by the respondent No.g and the
respondent No.3 is further directed to dispose of the
appeals fited by the petitioners dated 2o.os.2o24, as
expeditiously as possible. If the respondents wants to
take any action against the petitioners, they are at liberty
to do so by following due procedure as per law, after
diSposal of the appeals filed by the petitioners dated
20.O5.2024. No order as to costs.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any pending in these writ
petitions, shall stand closed.
-1?\
SD/- C. DEEPIKA
ASSISTAT.IT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
To
SECTION OFFICER
Represented by
Telangana Limited'
1. Southern Power Distribution, compaqy.of
fifint Comp-ound, Hyderabad' T'G'
its Chairman ana-t,t-anrgi,ig bit"Ctbi
Southern P^ower Distribution
2. The Chairman and Managing Director,
L'
;iTd""g""" r-to. rtt.t Co"mpouno, Hyderabad' T'G'
3. The Director, HRD TGSPDCL, Corporate office, Mint compound,
Company
Hyderabad,
T.G.
4.
-' The Chief General Manager (HRD), TGSPDCL, Corporate
Office' Mint
Compound, HYderabad, T.G.
\
5. The Chief General Manager, (O & M) Rural Zone, TGSPDCL,
.
Office, Mint ComPound, HYderabact
CorPorat'e
\
\'l
\\
\\
\
6. The Chief General Manager, Operation TGSPDCL, Medchal Zonal,
Hyderabad.
7. The {iuperintending Engineer, Operation, TGSPDCL, Habsiguda, Hyderabad. /
/
8. The Divisional Engineer Elecl, Operation, Keesara, TGSPDCL, Keesara,
Habsiguda Circle.
9. State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary, Energy
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad, T.G.
10.One rlC to Ms. CHEKURI JYOTSNA DEVI Advocate [OPUC]
11.One tlC to SRI N. SREEDHAR REDDY, S.C. for TGSPDCL [OPUC]
12.Two CCs to GP for Energy, High Court for the State of Telangana at
Hyderabad [OUT]
13.Two tlD Copies
MP
HIGH COURT
ATED:1210212026
,
8t$2m
r)
+.
c
,I,
tY/
N
=i
W.P.Nos.40520 40521 and 40522 ot 2025
,)
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITIONS
TI
rl OUT COSTS
fl"
a"t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review