The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. Having regard to the rival contentions and the material I t on record, this Court finds that the charges were framed against 31 employees including the petitioner and similar punishments have been irnposed against all the employees. This Court, in a batch of ) writ petitions, has granted relief to the petitioners therein and thereafter, the Govemment has also implemented the orders of this Court. Singling out the petitioner in not granting similar relief, would be discriminatory. Therefore, this Court is also inclined to set aside the impugned order dated 10.07.1996 and the appellate order dated 19.09.2020 and direct the respondents to grant full pension to the petitioner within a period of four (4) months from the date ofreceipt ofa copy ofthis order.
6. Accordingly, the writ petition is disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs
7. Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this writ petition, shall stand closed SD/-MOHD. ISMAIL //TRUE COPY// To ,Castes 1 The Principal Secretary' Scheduled at Hvderabad' relansana of J:t";;;i:"s,"te D eveloPment dePartment ' HYderabad' castes Development Department scneo"uea , il;;.Jm;Gon"r.' waransal Urban' warangar' Telangana at ; +'#;[i;i;i-Cotr""to'' Hish court ror the State of sERVTbES-rrr' FoFi i. i[""EtJi;:; at the sERVtcES-t, Hish court ror . ?#%t3i",3Hlo* Hvderabad. [OUTI 6 3,n""'#1,; dir npnaeunKAR' Advocate toPUCl
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
I
[ 321e I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE FOURTH DAY OF MAY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUST]CE T.MADHAVI DEVI
WRIT PETITION NO:45622 OF 2022
Between:
G. Muthamma, Wo Late G. Venkata Swamy, aged about 60 years, Occ.
Housewife, R/o H.No. 4-62, Gandhipuram, Anantaram Town lMahabubabad
District.
.....PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana,, Rep by its Principal Secretary Scheduled Castes
Development department Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Commissioner, Scheduled Castes Development Department Hyderabad.
3. The District Collector, Warangal Urban, Warangal.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affrdavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a Writ order or direction more particularly one in the nature of WRIT OF
MANDAMUS : i) declare the Proc.Rc.No.A3/780/94-95-XXlX, dated 10.07.1996
issued by the 3rd Respondent / District Collector, Warangal and its consequential
Proceedings in Govt. Memo. No. 16766 S.W Ser-|.1993, Dated 25.02.2000 issued
by the 1st Respondent and rejecting of appeals vide Govt. Memo. No.
567/SCD.Vig./2020, dated 19.09.2020 despite of setting aside the Disciplinary
Proceedings against the husband of the Petitioner herein vide Govt. Memo.No.
165S0/A3/97-1 SW Dated 13.10.1997 arid its implementation order issued in
G.O.Rt.No. 408 SCD ( Ser.A2) Dept. Dated 29.09.2015 and the husband of the
Petitioner was acquitted in the Criminal Cases in C.C.No.'179 of 2012 after full
dressed trial by the criminal court / punishment imposed per contra to the procedure
contemplated in terms of rS ccA Rutes, 1996 and set aside proc.Rc.No.A3/7g0/94-
gs-xxlx dated 10.07.1 996 issued by the 3rd Respondent / District coltector,
Warangal and its consequential Proceedings in Govt. Memo. No. 16766 S.W Ser1.1993, Dated 25.02.2000 issued by the 1st Respondent and rejecting of appeals
vide Go,,,t Memo No. 567/SCD.Vig./2020, dated 19.09.2020 is illegat, unjust,
impermissible, unfair, arbitrary u nconstitutional, procedural violation in imposing of
the penalty, enquiry proceedings were also conducted oeliteoty, suffered from deray
on part of the respondents in concluding the same in reopened case till today and
contrary to the G O.No. 679 GAD (SER-C) Dept. dated 01 .11.2018 and contrary to
the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in State of A.p. Vs.
V.N. Radhakrishna (1998 (4) SCC 154, in p.V.Mahadevan. Vs. M.D.Tamitnadu
Housing Board (2005 (5) scc 636), and in M.V.Biltani Vs. Union of lndia and others
(2006 (5) scc 88 and further direct the respondents to release of two (2) annuat
grade increments which were stopped with cumulative effect and treating the period
of suspension as on duty with all consequential benefits by following common order
dated 06.09.2024 in w.P.No. 23146 of 2019 and others, common order dated
11.11 2024 in W.P.No. 21425 and 21430 of 2017 of this Hon'ble court, order dated
3,08.201 5 in w. P.No. 16264 of 20'13 (Hon'bte Division Bench) of this Hon'bte court,
order dated 09.12.2013 in w.p.No. 16263 of 2013 and batch (Hon'ble Division
Bench) of this Hon'ble court and order dated oz.og.2o2s in W.A.No. 611 oI 2o2s
(Hon'ble Division Bench) of this Hon'ble court and pass such other order or orders
as this Hon'ble court may deem fit and proper in the interest of Justice" lN THE
PLACE oF this Hon'ble court may be pleased to issue a writ order or direction more
particulady one in the nature of wRlr oF MANDAMUS, declaring the Memo No
567/scD vig 12020 dated 19.09.2020 issued by the 1St Respondent as iilegal
arbitrary uniust and discriminatory and contrary to law and set aside the same and
consequently direct the respondents to release the two increments to the petitioner
immediately in the interest of justice.
(Prayer is amended as per Court Order dt 12t0312026 in l.A.No.03/2026)
|.A.NO: 2OF 2026
Petition under section '1 s'r cpc praying that in the circumstances
affidavit filed in supporr of the petition, the High court may be preased
stated in the
to issue a writ
order or direction more particularly one in the nature of wRlr oF MANDAMUS
to
declare the Proc.Rc.No.A3/780/94-95-XXlX, dated 10.07.1996 issued by the 3rd
Respondent / District collector, warangal and its consequential Proceeding in
rejecting the appeals vide Govt. Memo. No. 567/SCD.Vig./2020, dated 19.09.2020 is
in
illegal, unjust, impermissible, unfair, arbitrary unconstitutional, procedural violation
imposing of the penalty, enquiry proceedings were also conducted belatedly and set
aside the Proc.Rc.No.A3/780/94-95-XXlX, dated 10.07.1996 issued by the 3rd
Respondent / District collector, warangal and its consequential Proceedings
rejecting the appeals vide Govt. Memo. No. 567/SCD.Vig./2020, dated 1g.og.2o2o
in
of
and consequently direct the respondents to release full pension including release
two (2) annual grade increments whieh were stopped with cumulative effect and
duly
treating the period of suspension as on duty with all consequential benefits by
following common order dated 06.09.2024 in w.P.No. 23146 of 2019 and others
proper in
and pass such other order or orders as this Hon',ble court may deem fit and
the interest of Justice" lN THE PLACE OF this Hon'ble court may be pleased to
issue a writ order or direction more particularly one in the nature of wRlT
MANDAMUS, declaring the Memo No 567/SCD Yig l2O2O dated 19.09.2020 issued
OF
to
by the 1st Respondent as illegal arbitrary unjust and discriminatory and contrary
the
law and set aside the same and consequently direct the respondents to release
two increments to the petitioner immediately in the interest of
justice'
t.A.NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under section 151 cPc praying that in the circumstances stated in
theaffidavitfiIedinsupportofthepetition,theHighCourtmaybepleasedto
'1st
suspend the Memo No. 567/SCD.Vig.t2O2O dated 19-09-2020 issued by the
the
respondent and also direct the respondents to direct the respondents to release
two increments to the petitioner immediately in the interest of
justice pending disposal of the above writ petition.
justice in the interest of
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI R.PRABHAKAR
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 & 2 : GP FOR SERVICES -lll
Counsel for the Respondent No'3 : GP FOR SERVICES -l
The Court made the following ORDER
n
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABI,E SMTJUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI
W.P.NO. 45622 0F 2022
DATED: 04.05.2026
Behveen
G.Muthamma. W/o.Lare G. Venkata Swamy.
...
Petitioner
And
The State of Telangana,
Represented bv its Principal Secretary,
Scheduled Castcs Dcvclopment Department,
Secretariat. H1'derabad and Two Others.
.. Respondents
ORDER
In this writ petition, the petitioner is challenging the
proceedings of the respondenr No.3 dated 10.07.1996 and appeal
proceedings dated 19.09.2020 as illegal, arbitrary and
unconstitutional and to consequently set aside the same and to
grant all consequential benefits of releasing full pension including
release of trvo annual grade increments which were stopped with
cumulative efl'ect and fbr treating the period of suspension as on
duty with all conscquential benehts by duly following cor non
order of this Courr dared 06.09.2024 in W.p.No.23l 46 of 2019.
2.
Leamed counsel for the petitioner, submitted that the
petitioner is the wife of one Sri.G.Venkata Swamy, who was
working as Warden, Social Welfare, Boys Hostel, Thomlr and
retired as HWO Gr.II at Social Welfare Boys Hostel, Quilashpur
and thereafter expired on 28.10.2018. It is submitted that vide
proceedings dated 20. I 1.1997 , the disciplinary proceedings against
3l Wardens/lr,latrons of Social Welfare Hostels in the Warangal
District was reopened under Rule (41) APCS (CCA) Rules, 1991
and after due enquiry, the punishment of stoppage of two
increments with cumulative effect was awarded on 10.07.1996. He
submitted that similar punishments were given to all other Wardens
as well. It is submitted that the petitioner filed O.A.No.6112/2011
before the Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal and the
Tribunal has set aside the impugned order of District Collector,
Warangal, vide judgment dated 19.10.2012 and further directed the
respondents to pay full pension and other retirement benefits to the
applicant with interest at the rate of 9%o per annum from the date of
filing of the O.As., other than gratuity. The gratuity amount was
also directed to be paid together with interest as per rules. It is
*w
submitted that aggrieved by the orders of the Tribunal, the
Department has filed writ petitions before this Court i.e.,
W.P.Nos.16263, 16264, 16265 and t6266 of 2013 and the
petitioner's husband had filed C.A.No.474l2013'and 47112013 for
not implementation of the orders of the Tribunal. In the meanwhile,
the Iligh Court of Andhra Pradesh vide orders dated 09.12.2013
has set aside the order of the Tribunal to the extent of granting
interest on the pension and other retiral benefits payable to the
applicants and the Department was directed to release the
consequential benellts to the respondents/applicants within a period
of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of the order.
Thereafter, the Govemment had issued G.O.Rt.No.40g, dated
29.09.2015 ordering release of the pension and other retiral
beneflts payable to the petitioners therein which included the
petitioner's husband and after conclusion of the disciplinary
proceedings, the pensionary benefits were released to the
petitioner's husband. However, the respondents vide proceedings
dated 10.07.1996, have nor concluded the disciplinary proceedings
imposing punishment of stoppage of two increments with
cumulative eflect while treating the period of suspension fiom
23.08.1994 to 11.07.1996 as leave on loss of pay. Further, an
amount of Rs.4,000/- was recovered lrom the charged officer
towards misappropriation of Govemment funds in maintenance of
SW Boys Hostel, Thomrr for the year 1993-94 and remitted to the
Govemment vide Challan No.2926, dated 15.04.1996. However,
the case against the petitioner was not settled. In the meantime, the
Criminal Court in C.C.No.l7912012 on the file of Hon'ble I Addl.,
Judicial Magistrate of First Class at Warangal, has delivered the
judgment on 29.08.2018 acquitting the petitioner and others fiom
the charges. The petitioner, therefore, made a representation to
issue necessary orders to set aside the order dated 10.07.1996 but
since no action was taken thereon, the petitioner hled an appeal
and the appeal was also dismissed vide orders dated 19.09.2020
and therefore, since the petitioner's husband died, the petitioner has
fiIed this writ petition.
3.
Leamed counsel for the petitioner submitted that all
the other Social Welfare Wardens, who were also charged with
similar offences, have been granted relief by this Court and the
respondents have also implemented the orders of this Court. A
copy ol the order of this Court in W.P.Nos.23 146 of 2019 and
batch dated 06.09.2024, is filed along with the I.A.No.3/2026. It is
submitted that the petitioner also should be granted simitar relief
and to release all the retiral benefits including the full pension to
the petitioner in accordance with taw.
4.
Learned Govemment Pleader for Services-Ill, on the
other hand, submitted that the petitioner has approached this Court
by u'ay of amendment petition in the year 2026 for relief and
therefore, it is at a belated stage. It is stated that the petitioner has
already been granted retiral benefits and only the punishment order
which has not been set aside has been given effect to. As regards
the relief granted by this Court in similar matters, he stated that the
Court may take a decision in accordance with law.
5.
Having regard to the rival contentions and the material
I
t
on record, this Court finds that the charges were framed against 31
employees including the petitioner and similar punishments have
been irnposed against all the employees. This Court, in a batch of
)
writ petitions, has granted relief to the petitioners therein and
thereafter, the Govemment has also implemented the orders of this
Court. Singling out the petitioner in not granting similar relief,
would be discriminatory. Therefore, this Court is also inclined to
set aside the impugned order dated 10.07.1996 and the appellate
order dated 19.09.2020 and direct the respondents to grant full
pension to the petitioner within a period of four (4) months from
the date ofreceipt ofa copy ofthis order.
6.
Accordingly, the writ petition is disposed of. There
shall be no order as to costs
7.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this writ
petition, shall stand closed
SD/-MOHD. ISMAIL
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTIO
To
,Castes
1 The Principal Secretary' Scheduled
at Hvderabad'
relansana
of
J:t";;;i:"s,"te
OFFICER
D eveloPment dePartment
'
HYderabad'
castes Development Department
scneo"uea
, il;;.Jm;Gon"r.' waransal Urban' warangar'
Telangana at
; +'#;[i;i;i-Cotr""to''
Hish court ror the State of
sERVTbES-rrr'
FoFi
i. i[""EtJi;:;
at
the
sERVtcES-t, Hish court ror
. ?#%t3i",3Hlo*
Hvderabad. [OUTI
6 3,n""'#1,; dir npnaeunKAR' Advocate toPUCl
7. Two CD CoPies
SA
BS
A
State or relansana
t
I
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0410512026
t os
o
ORDER
1B ilny :u
t:
\:r_
..i..
WP.No.45622 of 2022
I
DISPOSING OF THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
/i\)S, , t
-to\tt
1 HE5 Iq
p
rtj
,,-//
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review