Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010639812023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3573]
THURSDAY, THE 6th DAY OF AUGUST 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
WRIT PETITION NO: 32957/2023
Between:
1. G.DORA BABU, S/O G.MANOHAR, AGED 38 YEARS,
OCC
LECTURER IN AEIE, SGPR GOVERNMENT POLYTECHNIC, AT
B.TANDRAPADU, KUMOOL
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
DEPARTMENT OF SKILLS
DEVELOPMENT AND TRAINING ,
214, 5TH BLOCK, AP
SECRETARIAT, VELAGAPUDI, AMARAVATHI, GUNTUR DISTRICT 522503
2. THE DIRECTOR OF TECHNICAL EDUCATION, A.P., D.NO. 11-307,
GKRUDADRI KK TOWERS,
LAKSHMI NARASIMHA COLONY,
SERVICE ROAD, NEAR DR. YSR AROGYA SREE HEALTH CARE
TRUST, MANGALAGIRI, GUNTUR DISTRICT - 522503
3. THE PRINCIPAL, SGPR GOVERNMENT
B.TANDRAPADU, KUMOOL.
POLYTECHNIC,
AT
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature
of Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the respondents herein more
particularly the 2nd and 3rd imposing the minor punishment of Censure vide
respondents herein in impugned ProcNo.G/10863/2018, dated 1-3-2023 and
consequential recovery of subsistence allowances which were paid during the
suspension period vide Memo. No.C/312/2015, dated 6-6-2023 and fixation of
recovery installments vide Rc.NO.A/Salary Recovery/2023-24, dated 15-112023 are highly illegal, arbitrary and also in violation of Rule 20 of CCA Rules
and also contrary to the F.R. 53(l)(ii) of AP Fundamental Rules and
consequential the Hon’ble court may pleased to set aside the impugned
punishment order dated 1-3- 2023 and all consequential proc. dated 6-6-2023
and 15-11-2023 with a further direction to treat the suspension period from
30-10-2018 to 9-3-2020 (497 day) as on duty with all consequential benefits
and may pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to suspend the recovery of subsistence allowance which were paid
during the suspension period as per F.R.53 [I][ii] vide impugned Memo.
No.C/312/2015, dated 6-6-2023 and consequential proc. Rc.NO.A/Salary
Recovery/2023-24, dated 15-11-2023, pending disposal of the writ petition
and may pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to vacate the interim orders dated 23.12.2023 in I.A.No.1 of 2023
and dismiss the W.P.No.32957 of 2023 in the interest of justice and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M R TAGORE
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR SERVICES III (AP)
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
ORDER:
The Writ Petition is filed for the following relief:
“…pleased to issue a Writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ
nd
rd
of Mandamus declaring the action of the respondents herein more particularly the 2 and 3
imposing the minor punishment of Censure vide respondents herein in impugned
ProcNo.G/10863/2018, dated 1-3-2023 and consequential recovery of subsistence allowances
which were paid during the suspension period vide Memo.No.C/312/2015, dated 6-6-2023 and
fixation of recovery installments vide Rc.NO.A/Salary Recovery/2023-24, dated 15-11-2023
are highly illegal, arbitrary and also in violation of Rule 20 of CCA Rules and also contrary to
the F.R. 53(l)(ii) of AP Fundamental Rules and consequential the Hon’ble court may pleased to
set aside the impugned punishment order dated 1-3-2023 and all consequential proc. dated
6-6-2023 and 15-11-2023 with a further direction to treat the suspension period from 30-102018 to 9-3-2020 (497 day) as on duty with all consequential benefits and may pass…”
2.
The case of the petitioner is that the petitioner while working as Lecturer
in AEIE at SGPR, Government Polytechnic at Kurnool, placed under
suspension, on 30.10.2018, on the ground that the petitioner did not follow the
instructions to record the attendance through biometric and was manual
signing attendance. The said suspension period was continued till 09.03.2020
and later he was reinstated into service. Thereupon, the respondents have not
issued charge memo and without even framing charges, straightaway have
imposed punishment of censure in Proc.No.G/10863/2018 dated 01.03.2023.
3.
For reference, the relevant portion of impugned punishment of censure
is extracted hereunder:
6.
After careful examination of the matter, the Director of Technical
Education has decided to impose punishment of award of “Censure” to Sri G.Dora
Babu, Lecturer in AEIE, SGPR Government of Andhra Pradesh. Polytechnic,
Kurnool as per APCs rules, 1991.
7.
The Director of Technical Education hereby regularize the suspension
period of Sri G.Dora Babu, Lecturer of AEIE, SGPR Govt. Polytechnic, Kurnool
i.e., from 30.10.2018 to 09.03.2020 for 497 days by granting HPL & EL (on private
affairs) up to 62 days from the date of his suspension i.e., 30.10.2018 and the
remaining period of suspension i.e., from 31.12.2018 to 09.03.2020 for 435 days
is treated as EOL on Private affairs.
4.
Aggrieved by the said order referred above, the present Writ Petition is
filed.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that though the respondents
initiated disciplinary proceedings against the petitioner, ultimately the said
proceedings ended in imposing minor penalty like censure and treating the
suspension period of 497 days as ‘not on duty’ and adjusting the said 497
days has HPL & EL (private affairs) upto 62 days and entered the remaining
period as extraordinary leave. Consequent upon the same, the respondents
have issued proceedings dated 06.06.2023 vide Memo.No.C/312/2015 for
recovery of subsistence allowance for the period for 435 days EOL period of
Rs.4,70,028/- and granting installments for such recovery vide proceedings
dated 15.11.2023, will amounts to major penalty against the petitioner without
conducting any enquiry as contemplated under Rule 23 of CCA Rules.
6.
In support of his contentions, learned counsel for the petitioner relied on
G.O.Ms.No.238, General Administration (Services. C) Department, dated
07.04.1992, wherein, it is stated as follows:
Amendment
In Appendix-VI to the Andhra Pradesh Civil Services (Classification,
Control and Appeal) Rules, 1963, for instruction 19 of the following shall be
added at the end, namely:
“(iii) Where the departmental proceedings against a suspended employee
for the imposition of a major penalty finally end with the imposition of a minor
penalty the suspension can be said to be wholly unjustified and the employee
concerned shall, therefore, be paid full pay and allowances for the period of
suspension by passing a suitable order under F.R.54-B”
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner also placed his reliance on the order
of this Court in Ch.Vara Prasad v. The State of Andhra Pradesh and
others1, at para No.8, it is held as follows:
“…8. Under those circumstances, in the present case, this Court is of the
opinion that treating the period of suspension as not on duty, while imposing a
punishment of censure in the disciplinary proceedings, will lead to imposing a
major punishment, as such, the action of the disciplinary authority in treating the
period of suspension as not on duty is unreasonable and against good
conscience. Therefore, the impugned order dated 04.06.2019 is liable to be set
aside…”
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further relied on a decision of
erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh, at Hyderabad in A.V.Vinod Kumar
v. Executive Committee of the Central Warehousing Corporation, New
Delhi and another2, wherein at Para No.10, it is stated as follows:
“…10. Censure is a minor punishment something like a warning to be careful in
future. In fact, in the order dated 24-12-1991, it was stated that a lenient view in
the matter was taken to afford an opportunity to the petitioner to improve his
behavior and to be careful in his work in future. While holding so, treating the
period of suspension as ‘not on duty’, cannot be said to have bene done in good
faith and good conscience. The censure itself is a punishment of minor nature.
To treat the period of suspension as not on duty is a severe punishment, by
which the petitioner is denied continuity of service for the purpose of seniority,
promotion etc. Therefore, the though the disciplinary authority has got power,
such power, in this case, was not exercised reasonably and no reasonable
person could have treated the period of suspension as not on duty while
imposing the minor punishment of censure…”
9.
He also placed his reliance on the decision of High Court of Telangana,
at Hyderabad in Vanam Srinivasulu vs. The State of Telangana and
another3, at para No.12, it is held that:
“…12. The instant case is better footing than that case, as there is no
punishment as per TSCS (CCA) Rules, 1991 and the impugned order passed
contrary to the Circular Memo No.60897/Ser.C/1999 dated 12.11.1999. Once the
charge was not proved and further action dropped by the competent authority,
the question of treating the suspension period as eligible leave does not arise
and the respondents have to treat the suspension period of the petitioner from
W.P.No.19390 of 2020
2007 (5) ALD 445
W.P.No.20019 of 2021
27.12.2016 to 10.09.2017 as spent on-duty for all purposes and the impugned
order is liable to be set aside…”
10.
By relying on the decisions referred above, learned counsel for the
petitioner submits that once a major penalty is proposed and finally termed to
be a minor penalty, the period of suspension cannot be treated as ‘not on
duty’ and the same has to be treated as ‘on duty’, otherwise, it amounts to
imposition of major penalty.
11.
In the instant case, the petitioner was placed under suspension for 497
days and ultimately a minor penalty of censure was imposed and treated the
entire period of suspension as ‘not on duty’ and adjusted the said period
against his Half Pay Leave and Earned Leave. The remaining period was
treated as extraordinary leave, which cause severe financial loss to the
petitioner and also initiated proceedings for recovery of the subsistence
allowance paid during the suspension period, would definitely amounts to
major punishment. Without conducting proper enquiry and without issuing
charge memo, such major penalty cannot be imposed.
12.
Learned Assistant Government Pleader for Services-III, reiterating the
contentions raised in the counter-affidavit, submitted that the recovery
proceedings were initiated pursuant to the impugned memo. However, this
Court, by order dated 23.12.2023, granted an interim order staying the
operation of Memo No. C/312/2015, dated 06.06.2023, until further orders. He
further submits that the other period treated as leave and there is no
justification in challenging the said proceedings and prays to dismiss this Writ
Petition.
13.
Considering the submissions made by learned counsel on either side,
this Court is of the considered view that, the proceedings issued by the
respondent authorities in treating the period of suspension of 497 days as ‘not
on duty’, and also initiating the proceedings for recovery would amounts to
major penalty, which is contrary to the punishment of censure imposed by the
competent authority.
14.
Considering the Judgments relied on by the learned counsel for the
petitioner and taking into consideration of the G.O.Ms.No.238, General
Administration (Services.C) Department, dated 07.04.1992, where the
departmental proceedings against a suspended employee for the imposition of
major penalty finally end with imposition of a minor penalty, the suspension
can be said to be wholly unjustified and the employee concerned shall,
therefore, be paid full pay and allowances for the period of suspension by
passing a suitable order under F.R.54-B.
15.
In view of the above, the impugned orders, treating the period of
suspension as ‘not on duty’ and consequential proceedings of recovery as
well as converting installments are unsustainable.
16.
Accordingly, this Writ Petition is allowed. The proceedings vide
Proc.No.G/10863/2018, dated 01.03.2023 and consequential recovery of
subsistence allowances which were paid during the suspension period vide
Memo.No.C/312/2015, dated 06.06.2023 and fixation of recovery of
installments vide Rc.No.A/Salary Recovery/2023-24, dated 15.11.2023, are
hereby set aside. No costs.
Consequently, miscellaneous petitions if any, shall stand closed.
Interim orders granted earlier if any, also shall stand closed.
________________________________
JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
Dated: 06.08.2026
MKK
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
Writ Petition No. 32957 of 2023
Date: 06.08.2026
MKK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review