Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 9 March 2026
Pronounced on: 01 July 2026
+
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
FLAT OWNERS ASSOCIATION OF MEDIA
MAGESTIC TOWER
.....Appellant
Through: Ms. Purnima Maheshwari and
Mr. Mukul Aryan, Advs.
versus
ARUN KUMAR BHOWMIK
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Ankur Mahindro, Mr.
Rohan Taneja, Mr. Mohit Dagar, Mr.
Raghav Kalra and Ms. Radhika Agarwal,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE OM PRAKASH SHUKLA
%
JUDGMENT
01.07.2026
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
A.
The lis
1.
This appeal, under Section 37 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 19961, assails judgment dated 17 November 2025
passed by a learned Single Judge of this Court in OMP (Comm)
255/2025 under Section 34 of the 1996 Act. By the impugned
judgment, the learned Single Judge has set aside an arbitral award
1 “the 1996 Act” hereinafter
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
dated 31 May 2025 passed by a learned Sole Arbitrator in arbitral
proceedings between the appellant and the respondent. The appellant
was the claimant before the learned Arbitrator and the respondent, as
the proprietor of M/s Amtech Engineers, was the respondent.
2.
Claims were raised by the appellant and counter-claims were
raised by the respondent before the learned Arbitrator. The total
amount claimed by the appellant in its claim was ₹ 2,78,38,172/- and
the amount claimed by the respondent in its counter-claim was ₹
8,52,22,235/-.
3.
The arbitral award allowed the appellant’s claim to the extent of
₹ 2 crores and the respondent’s counter-claim to the extent of ₹ 1
crore.
4.
The appellant did not challenge the arbitral award. However,
the respondent approached this Court, by means of OMP (Comm)
255/2025, under Section 34 of the 1996 Act.
5.
By the impugned judgment, the learned Single Judge has set
aside the arbitral award in totality on the ground that it is unreasoned.
6.
The appellant has approached this Court, under Section 37 of
the 1996 Act, challenging the judgment of the learned Single Judge.
B.
The Issue
7.
The findings of the learned Arbitrator are contained under
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
heading XIII of the arbitral award, titled “Issue wise findings of the
Arbitral Tribunal”, which merits reproduction, in extenso, thus:
“a.
Whether the work was assigned was delayed/not completed
by the Respondent within time as per the Agreement dated
9.1.2018?
Finding of Tribunal: Yes, the work assigned to Respondent
including the extra work was delayed and not completed by the
Respondent in terms of the Agreement dt.9.1.2018 and additional
and extra work assigned later on and certain works were left
incomplete. The issue is thus decided in favour of the Claimant.
b. Whether the work done suffered from deficiencies i.e.
completed/left/rectification not done, etc.?
Finding of Tribunal: Yes, the work performed by the Respondent
was not up to the mark and as specified and the verification reports
placed on record proves that. The issue is accordingly decided in
favour of the Claimant.
c.
Whether the Claimant is entitled to penalty of
Rs.2,78,38,172/-, or any amount, if so, at what rate and what
period?
Finding of the Tribunal: No. The Claimant is not entitled to
recover the whole of the amount claimed of Rs.2,78,38,172/- which
is mainly on account of penalty clause in the Agreement and for
the delay caused in the execution of the works, because Petitioner
Society also has contributed to some extent to the delay in the work
by changing the drawings and specifications of the work during the
execution of the work and the Respondent alone cannot be blamed
for the delay in the work, but the Respondent is largely responsible
for the said delay and deficiencies in the work done. The Petitioner
society is therefore held entitled to the overall compensation of
Rs.2,00,00,000/- (Rs. Two Crores ) on ad-hoc and fair estimation
basis on account of delay in the execution of the works and the
defects and deficiencies in the work executed by the Respondent
and damages for some works left incomplete by the Respondent.
d.
Whether the Claimant is entitled to interest @12% from the
date of filing of claim i.e.18.10.2021 till payment?
Finding of the Tribunal: The rate of interest of 12% claimed by
the Petitioner Society is on higher side. The same is reduced to 6%
p.a. simple interest payable from the date of Award till the actual
payment. The rate of interest of 6% will be applicable to both sides
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
on their respective partial reliefs granted by this Tribunal. The
issue is accordingly partly decided in favour of the Claimant.
e. Whether the Respondent has no cause of action to file the
present counter claim after audit reports made with due
participation of the Respondent and no claim raised therein?
Finding of the Tribunal: No. The Respondent is entitled to raise a
Counter Claim and has raised the same, which has been considered
by this Tribunal and the issue wise findings are given below. This
issue is accordingly decided against the Claimant.
*****
f.
Whether the instant contract is Item Rate Tender or Lump
sum Contract?
Finding of the Tribunal: The Tribunal has held above that the
Contract dt.9.1.2018 between the parties was actually a Lump Sum
Contract and not an item rate contract even though the Agreement
described it to be so and the Respondent has claimed it to be so.
This is established by the conduct of the parties and the evidence
placed on the record of this Tribunal. The Issue is decided against
the Respondent accordingly.
g. Whether the breach of contract has been committed by the
Claimant?
Finding of the Tribunal: The breach of contract has not been
committed by the Petitioner Claimant Society, but it has not paid
the Running Bills of the Respondent Contractor to the extent of
work done by him and more particularly the extra work assigned to
him which was not covered by the original Agreement dt. 9.1.2018.
The Issue is decided accordingly.”
h.
Whether the delay/prolongation of the Contract is
attributable to the Claimant?
Finding of the Tribunal: Partly Yes. The Claimant Society did
not approve the drawings and Committee concerned did not clarify
the doubts and issues raised by the Contractor nor the verification
of work was carried out with due promptitude, which delayed the
execution of the work and nonpayment of the Running Bills after
due verification was not done in time, which perhaps compelled the
Respondent Contractor to leave the work incomplete, but the entire
responsibility of non-completion of the work cannot be laid upon
the Petitioner Society, and it was essentially the contractual
obligation of the Respondent Contractor to complete the same.
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
Some delay was caused by the reasons beyond the control of the
parties like restrictions of Covid-19 period etc. The Issue is decided
accordingly.
i.
Whether the Respondent/counter claimant is entitled to get
pre-suit, pendent lite and future interest @18% p.a.?
Finding of the Tribunal: The Respondent is also entitled to
simple interest @ 6% p.a. payable from the date of Award till the
actual payment and not at 18% p.a. as claimed, on the amount
found due to be payable to him. The Issue is decided accordingly.
j.
Whether the Respondent/counter claimant is entitled to the
relief claimed in the counter claim?
Finding by the Tribunal: The Respondent Contractor is found
entitled to receive the sum of Rs.1,00,00,000/- (Rs. One Crore}
only on lump sum basis on a fair and reasonable basis, from the
petitioner society, for the works executed by him and the Bills not
paid by the Claimant Society so far and not the entire amount
claimed by him after the 11th Running Bill already paid by the
Petitioner Claimant Society.
The Rest of the Counter Claims made by the Respondent like
Escalation of costs during execution of work, Idling charges of
labour and machinery, watch and ward charges during extended
period of work, loss of profit, refund of earnest money, extra
payment for high rise structure work etc. are liable to be dismissed
as they were not proved at all by the Respondent with any
evidence, what to say, by the cogent evidence.
Costs of Litigation / Arbitration In view of the divided success of
both the parties, both the parties are directed to bear their
respective legal costs for this arbitration.”
8.
A reading of the above findings of the learned Arbitrator
indicate that ₹ 2 crores has been awarded in favour of the appellant
and against the respondent primarily on the ground that the respondent
had failed to complete the contractual and additional work within the
time provided in that regard, and that there were deficiencies in the
work executed by the respondent. ₹ 1 crore has been awarded to the
respondent against work executed by the respondent, which had
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
remained unpaid by the appellant. However, all other counter-claims
of the respondent, relating to escalation, idling charges, watch and
ward charges, loss and profit, refund of earnest money and extra
payment for high rise structures, were dismissed on the ground of
want of evidence.
9.
The learned Single Judge has set aside the arbitral award on the
ground that it does not discuss the applicable evidence and is
unreasoned.
10.
Inasmuch as the respondent alone is aggrieved by the impugned
award, we are required to examine as to whether there was any
evidence led by the respondent (i) to rebut the claims of the appellant
regarding delay in completion of the assigned and additional work and
deficiencies in the work executed by the respondent and (ii) in support
of the counter-claims of the respondent which the learned Arbitrator
has rejected.
C.
Facts
11.
In 2005-06, AJS Builders commenced work on a project known
as Media Majestic Tower Project. By 2008-09, work on the project
had been completed till the 10th floor.
12.
At this stage, AJS Builders had availed a loan of ₹ 4 crores from
the Punjab National Bank Housing Finance Ltd2. On AJS Builders
defaulting in liquidating the loan, the PNBFHL initiated proceedings
2 “PNBFHL” hereinafter
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
against it under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial
Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 20023. In the said
proceedings, by order dated 7 December 2022, the learned Debt
Recovery Tribunal granted possession of the project to the appellant.
Thereafter, a Memorandum of Understanding along with a General
Power of Attorney was executed, authorising the appellant to register
the properties forming subject matter of the project in favour of the
respective flat owners and hand over possession.
13.
The dispute which was referred to arbitration relates to the
remaining uncompleted part of the Media Majestic Tower Project.
14.
Initially, in 2012, M/s Shivam Project was contracted to
complete the project. However, owing to want of funds, Shivam
Project abandoned the contract. Thereafter, M/s Asian Projects
commenced the work, but also had to discontinue the project owing to
the unfortunate demise of its proprietor. The respondent was thereafter
contracted to complete the work, under an agreement dated 9 January
2018.
15.
Disputes arose between the parties under the said agreement.
16.
It is not necessary, given the nature of the present controversy,
to refer to the pre-arbitral proceedings. Suffice it to state that,
following the issuance of the requisite Section 21 notice, the dispute
was referred to the Indian Council of Arbitration which appointed the
learned Sole Arbitrator, who has rendered the arbitral award forming
3 “SARFAESI Act” hereinafter
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
subject matter of the controversy, to arbitrate on the disputes.
17.
The details of the claims and counter-claims may be provided,
thus.
18.
The claims raised by the appellant were based on an audit
verification report of M/s Adhikari Consultants which, according to
the appellant, indicated that there were discrepancies in the work
undertaken by the respondent. Additionally, the delay in completion
of the work by the respondent rendered the respondent liable to pay
penalty in terms of Clause 3 of the Agreement dated 9 January 2018.
The worksheet of the claims raised by the claimant was thus provided
with the statement of claim:
2.
19.
(a) Average of the two recommendations
made by verifying team/ auditor for the
final bill submitted by Amtech Engineers
(b) Delay penalty 52% for delay of 104
weeks upto submission of final bill no
work is complete
Penalty amount
(c) Net payable to Amtech
(d) Payments made to Amtech Engineers
as per summary given to them on
01.09.2019
(e) (Directly received from flat buyer of
201)
Total Received By Amtech
(f) Excess payment made to Amtech
43124852/- + 18135470/Interest @ 12 % P.A. from 06.01.2021 to
18.10.2021
Total Claim Amount
₹ 37782230/₹ 19646760/-
₹ 18135470/₹ 41499852/- (Excluding
GST paid on bills)
₹ 1625000/₹ 43124852/₹ 24989382/₹ 28,49,790/₹ 2,78,38,172/-
Insofar as the counter claims of the respondent are concerned,
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
the award of the learned Arbitrator provides the following abstract
thereof:
S. No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Description
Counter Claims towards escalation in construction
cost due to market inflation for the work executed
during the contract period and during the
prolongation period of contract on the basis of 10CC
as per C.P.W.D method of contract as the breach of
contract was committed by the Claimant.
Counter Claim on account of balance payment for
the work executed for Civil and Electrical works
under the contract i/c additional work, extra work,
and extra involvements etc. but not paid/ short paid
in quantities/rate and also made illegal
deductions/reductions in the bill by the Claimant.
Counter Claim against security/watch & ward during
the prolongation of contract period (Reason of
hindrances not attributable to the Respondent).
beyond stipulated date of completion as the breach of
contract committed by the Claimant.
Counter Claim towards on-site over heads due to
damages/compensations on account of overheads,
staff establishments, cost for T&P and machinery
due to prolongation of contract (Reason of
hindrances not attributable to the Respondent)
caused by the Claimant and breach of contract
committed by them.
Counter Claim on account of Non utilization of
fund/loss of productivity/loss of profit due to delay
in work for various hindrance (Reason of hindrances
not attributable to the Respondent) in work as the
breach of contract committed by the Claimant.
Counter Claims on account of refund of Earnest
Money plus interest @18% amounting to Rs
16,23,781/- deposited at the time of submission of
tender and kept as Security Deposit by the Claimant
for effective prolongation of contract i.e. 502 days.
Counter Claim due to delay in payment of R/A Bills
and Final Bill from the due date till the date of
18.10.2021 (date from which the Claimant submitted
their Claim to ICA as per contract agreement clause.
Counter Claim on account of extra payment to
worker employed on high rise structure i.e. on or
above 30 feet height even for one hour in a day, for
the work executed under Extra Item/Substitute
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
Amount (₹)
24,68,827/-
2,88,30,924/-
21,58,000/-
43,61,980/-
1,50,00,000/-
6,23,781/-
1,51,25,892/-
16,52,831/-
9.
10.
11.
12.
Item/Deviated items.
Counter Claim on account of Goodwill and
manpower & machinery remained idle at site during
the period of various hindrances as the breach of
contract committed by the Claimant.
Counter Claim on account of Non-payment of
deviation, extra & substitute items on prevailing
market rate at the time of execution.
Respondent Counter Claim pre-suit pendent lite and
future interest @18%.
Counter Claim towards cost of arbitration
proceedings as per actual as the breach of contract
committed by the Claimant.
Total Counter Claim Amount
60,00,000/-
10,00,000/-
50,00,000/30,00,000/-
8,52,22,235/-
20. Stand of the respondent with respect to the claims of the
appellant and the counter claims of the respondent:
20.1 Re: Claims of the appellant
I.
Re: Delay
20.1.1The respondent contended, with respect to the appellant’s
allegation that there had been delay on the respondent’s part in
completion of the work, as under:
(i)
Delay was attributable to the time taken by the appellant
in deciding upon the additional work which the respondent was
required to undertake, outside the BOQ, and deviations in
quantity beyond the scope of the agreement. Extra time was
required for executing such additional work. Reliance was
placed, in this context, on the answers provided by CW-1 Vinod
Kumar Goel, Secretary/Authorized Representative of the
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
appellant, to Q. 14, 15 and 38 posed to him and the response of
Arun Bhowmik testifying as RW-1, to Q. 48, 49, 50 and 51
posed to him in cross examination. Additionally, reliance was
placed on material contained in the affidavit in evidence filed
by RW-2 Vinod Gunsai, Architect. This material, it was
submitted, indicated that various extra works had been given to
the respondent. Additionally, the respondent placed on record a
list of the extra and deviated items which were undertaken by
the respondent during the subsistence of the work at the behest
of the appellant. The respondent also placed material on record
to indicate that at least 261 days were required for completion
of the total work, including the extra work contracted by the
appellant.
(ii)
The work undertaken by the previous contractor was
substandard. This was not known to the respondent at the time
of entering into the agreement. The respondent was required to
undertake extra work within 10 days of commencement. For
this, the respondent had to rectify, dismantle and recast the
damage column. The respondent relied on the affidavit in
evidence of RW-2 as well as the response of RW-2 to Q. 5
posed to him in cross-examination, to contend that this was one
of the primary reasons for failure to complete the work in a
timely fashion. Reliance was also placed on Clause 10 of the
agreement which provided that, if delay in execution of the
work was attributable to neglect of the appellant, time for
completion would be extended.
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
(iii)
The execution of the work was also delayed on account
of failure on the part of the appellant to release payments in
time. It was admitted by CW-1, in his cross-examination, that
interest was paid by the appellant on delayed payment. To
substantiate this contention, the respondent relied on e-mails
dated 22 June 2020, 24 June 2020, 20 July 2020, 23 June 2020,
21 August 2020, 22 August 2020 and a noting of 7 September
2020. It was further contended that the appellant’s stand that
payments were not required to be released until RA Bills were
raised was contrary to Clause 17(c) of the agreement. The
respondent contended that the bills had been raised by it strictly
in terms of the agreed arrangement as recorded in letter dated
11 November 2017.
(iv)
Part of the work was allotted by the appellant to another
agency, which also hampered progress and caused delay in
execution.
(v)
Delay in execution of the work was also attributed to
some extent to the COVID-19 pandemic.
II.
Re: Allegation of deficiencies in the work undertaken by the
respondent
20.1.2 In response to the appellant’s contention that the work
undertaken by the respondent was deficient in various aspects, the
respondent submitted thus:
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
(i)
No complaint was ever received from the appellant
regarding the quality of construction undertaken by the
respondent.
(ii)
No formal quality test was undertaken by the appellant to
verify the quality of construction.
(iii)
The allegation of deficiencies was based on an audit
report. It was contended that the audit report was unreliable for
a variety of reasons. In the first place, the agreement did not
envisage audit by any third party, as was acknowledged by CW1 in his answer to Q. 54 in cross-examination. Besides, the
auditors were on the pay rolls of the appellant, as acknowledged
by CW-1 in his response to Q. 66 in cross-examination. There
was also a difference of as much as ₹ 1 crore in the report of the
two auditors.
(iv)
The Work Experience Certificate dated 1 August 2019,
which was provided by the appellant and signed by its
authorized representative CW-1 clearly stated that the delay was
occasioned on account of delay in approval of the decision by
the appellant. All other parameters were found satisfactory.
20.2 Re. Counter claims raised by the respondent
I.
Re. Counter claim 1 – escalation in construction cost due to
inflation
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
20.2.1
The respondent claimed ₹ 24,68,827/- towards escalation
in construction cost owing to market inflation. Reliance was placed,
by the respondent, on Clause 14 of the agreement which explicitly
contemplated such escalation and allowed for revision of agreed rates
if market conditions changed by more than 10%. In working out the
escalation, the respondent submitted that it had applied the formula
envisaged in Clause 10CC of the General Clauses of Contract of the
Central Public Works Department. Delay in execution of the work had
been occasioned owing to breaches and hindrances committed by the
appellant. As such, the respondent submitted that it was entitled to
additional payment on account of escalation.
II.
Re: Counter claim 3 – claim relating to watch and ward services
provided during extended period of work
20.2.2 The respondent submitted that, under the agreement, it was
responsible to provide watch and ward services for the stipulated
period of nine months within which the contract was to be completed.
The detailed computation of the actual expenses incurred during the
said period was provided by the respondent. As there was no
requirement, in the agreement, for providing watch and ward services
for extended periods of work, this constituted an extra item which was
claimed by the respondent in counter claim 3.
III. Re: Counter claim 5 – for loss of profit and productivity during
extended period of work
20.2.3 The respondent contended that, owing to the extension in the
period of work at the request of the appellant, the manpower and
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
machinery of the respondent could not be employed elsewhere
resulting in loss of profit suffered by the respondent. Reliance was
placed, in this context, on the response of RW-1 to Q. 20 posed to him
in cross-examination. ₹ 1.5 crores was claimed on this ground.
IV. Re: Counter claim 7 – interest for delay in release of payment
against the RA Bills and Final Bill from the due date till the date of
the Section 21 notice
20.2.4For this claim, the respondent relied on Clause 17(c) of the
agreement which required payment of submitted bills to be made
within 7 to 10 days with mandatory penal interest at the rate of 15%
per annum in the case of delay beyond the said period. It was pointed
out that the respondent had addressed emails to the appellant on 22
June 2020, 23 June 2020, 24 June 2020, 20 July 2020, 21 August
2020, 22 August 2020 and 5 October 2020 followed by a legal notice
dated 7 September 2020 for timely release of payment, to no avail.
The fact that payments could not be released within the stipulated time
was in fact acknowledged by the appellant, for which purpose, the
respondent relied on the minutes of the Executive Committee held on
5 July 2020 and 11 July 2020.
V.
Re: Counter claim 8 – extra payment to workers employed on
high rise structures above 30 feet
20.2.5The respondent submitted that the extra work which the
appellant required the respondent to undertake involved deployment
of workers at heights of over 30 feet. As per notification dated 19
January 2017 of the Ministry of Labour and Employment, workers
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
employed at such heights were required to be paid 20% extra wages.
An amount of ₹ 16,52,831/- was claimed under this head.
VI. Re: Counter claim 9 –idling of manpower and machinery during
extended time.
20.2.6During the period for which the performance of the contract
was extended at the instance of the appellant, the respondent had to
incur expenses towards labour etc. Referring the emails dated 22 June
2020, 24 June 2020 and 22 August 2020, addressed by the respondent
to the appellant in this regard, a claim was raised for labour and
machinery which remained idle during the extended period.
D.
The Arbitral Award
21.
Observations and Conclusions of the learned Arbitrator
Having thus set out the various contentions advanced by the
respondent to dispute the appellant’s claim and in support of the
counter claims raised by it, it becomes necessary, at this juncture, to
refer to the “Observations and Conclusion of the Tribunal” as
contained in the arbitral award, whichcommenced with the following
observations on the aspect of whether the contract was an item-wise
contract or a lumpsum contract.
“1.
The Arbitration Tribunal is of the considered view that the
Contract/Agreement dt. 9.1.2018 is not in fact, an item rate based
contract, as claimed by the Respondent, though BOQ rates were
mentioned in the Agreement, but de facto and de jure, it was a
lump sum contract, as contended by the Petitioner Claimant, for the
various repair and renovation work assigned to the Respondent by
the Petitioner Society for being undertaken on the Building
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
Majestic Tower in question. The very fact that consolidated
Running Bills were raised by the Respondent Amtech Engineers
and were paid by the Petitioner claimant, after due scrutiny, up to
11th RA Bill shows and establishes that the mode of execution of
the contract made it a Lump sum Contract with the description of
the Work given in the Contract.
2.
The Arbitration Tribunal has reached this conclusion
relying upon the conduct of the parties, mails and Running Bills
placed on record, as also the cross-examination statement of CW-1
Dr. VK Goel and the following case laws about interpretation of
clauses of the Contract and actual working and cases of multiple
contracts disputes referable to one arbitration, because the very
basis of uniformity of the entire economic transaction and not the
number or individual clauses of the separate arguments. They
emphasize the need to go the real intention of the parties and not
only by the terms and tenor of the contract.
The relevant part of the cross-examination of CW-1 is quoted
below:
Q. 20
Ans.
Q. 21
Ans.
Q. 22
Ans.
Q. 23
Ans.
In this RA Bill, an extra item has been mentioned i.e.
strengthening of the column at 9th Floor, dismantling of
RCC, dismantling of brick work and repair of plaster.
The same has been charged and has been paid by the
Claimant Society. Is this correct?
Yes. All RA Bills were paid by the Society on Ad-hoc
basis and no finality can be attached to such payments.
What was the procedure prescribed for, in the contract,
raising of the bills process of payment of bills raised by
the contractor?
The procedure is prescribed in clause 17 of the contract.
Is it correct that if there was a delay in payment of the
bills beyond the seven days of submissions of the bills
then interest @ 15% PA was payable by the Society to
the contractor?
As per clause 17 (c) of the contract, if the delay is more
then seven- ten days and further that the bills are
accepted by the Society, only then the question of
interest could arise.
Vol: The bills were to be submitted after every 15 days
of the work and the same was not complied with by the
Contractor.
Did the Claimant Society ever pay interest to the
Contractor on the delayed payments of the RA Bills?
Yes.
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
Vol: The contractor agreed to reduce the interest to 12%
as such occasion to pay interest arose only once and
approximately a sum of Rs. 12 Lakhs was paid towards
such interest.
Can you tell me when and on what occasion did the
Respondent agree to receive a reduced rate of interest of
12%?
It was in the annual general meeting of the society held
on 29.09.2019 where Mr. Arun Kumar Bhaumik was
present.
Q. 24
Ans.
The following clause 8 of the Agreement dt.9.1.2018 itself shows
that it was not an item rate based contract, where the parties have
agreed for re-execution of the defective work done. The same is
quoted below:
"8.
The Contractor agrees to re-execute any work which
does not conform to the drawings and specifications,
warrants the work performed, and agrees to remedy and
defects resulting, from faulty materials or workmanship
which shall become evident during a period of 6 months
after completion and successful handover of the work.”
22.
Thereafter, the learned Arbitrator, for no clearly discernible
reason, refers to the judgment of the High Court of Calcutta in
Johnson Control Hitachi Air Conditioning India Ltd v. Shapoorji
Pallonji & Co. P. Ltd4, Lord Hoffman's opinion in Premium Nafta
Products Ltd. v Fili Shipping Co. Ltd.5, the judgment of the Supreme
Court in Chloro Controls India (P) Ltd. v. Severn Trent Water
Purification lnc.6 and the judgments of the High Court of Calcutta in
Mohd Malik Chauhan v. Tata Steel Utilities and Infrastructure
Services Ltd7. and Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. Shapoorji
Pallonji & Co. P. Ltd.8.
4 MANU/WB/0938/2025
5 MANU/UKHL/0067/2007
6 (2013) 1 SCC 641
7 No such judgement could be found. The extract in the award appears to be from Johnson Controls Hitachi
Air Conditioning India Ltd. v. Shapoorji Pallonji And Company Pvt Ltd., MANU/WB/0938/2025
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
23.
Somewhat strangely, after the reference to the judgment of the
High Court of Calcutta in Mohd Malik Chauhan, there is again an
extract from the statement of Lord Hoffman with no context.
24.
We agree with the learned Single Judge, in the impugned
judgment, that the reference to the aforesaid decisions which basically
deal with consolidation of arbitral proceedings, does not seem to have
any connection with the dispute at hand. Indeed, the arbitral award,
too, does not indicate why reference has been made to these decisions.
25.
Thereafter, the observations and conclusions of the learned
Arbitrator conclude with the following three paragraphs:
“4.
That the Respondent was definitely called upon the
undertake some extra works and he did execute the same at the
instruction and the directions of the petitioner society and thus
under such additional contract or extension of the original contract
as was proved by various emails, verification reports and Running
Bills produced by the Contractor, the contractor was entitled to
additional payment for the same, even though the original
Agreement did not specify such additional and the extra work
assigned to him.
5.
That the Respondent Contractor did not complete the
assigned work either as per the terms of the original contract nor
the additional work assigned to him and the quality of work was
not upto the mark, specially the 10th floor columns in the Building
and left several works incomplete like connecting sewerage lines,
electrical installations etc. and which caused a breach of contract
on his part and caused inconvenience to the petitioner society and
its members.
6.
That both the sides have proved their respective case with
the help of evidence led by them oral as well as the documentary
evidence, and are entitled to partial relief, but all the claims and the
entire extent of the respective claims made by them in the Claim
petition and the Counter Claim, have not been proved and some of
8 2023 SCC Online Cal 1120
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
the claims, especially in the various Counter Claims of the
Respondent, some claims made by the Respondent are frivolous
and unfounded and therefore both the parties are entitled to only
the partial relief on their respective Claims, on an estimated basis
on a fair and reasonable estimation in the present arbitration
proceedings, which are being discussed below issue wise.”
26.
This is followed by the “Issue-wise Finding” of the learned
Arbitrator, which already stands reproduced in para 7 supra.
E.
The Impugned Judgment
27.
The learned Single Judge holds, in the impugned judgment, that
the arbitral award is completely unreasoned, save and except with
respect to the finding that the contract was a lump-sum contract –
which finding, too, as per the impugned judgment, was incorrect on
facts and in law. The learned Single Judge has observed that Clause
16 of the Agreement specifically envisaged payment by the
respondent to the appellant as per finally agreed item rates:
“16. Amtech Engineers represented by Mr. Arun Kumar Bhowmik
will undertake the work of balance construction at MMT as per
the item rates finally agreed for the common civil works/Electrical
& Plumbing including elevators for working in Common Areas
only. Interiors of flats are not governed and covered in this
Contract. The contractor will give the further rates for the work not
covered in this estimate, as may be demanded.”
Additionally, notes the learned Single Judge, CW-2, in his answer to
Q.8 posed to him in cross-examination, in which it was specifically
queried as to whether the contract was for payment on item rates,
responded in the affirmative. The learned Single Judge notes that the
learned Arbitrator has overlooked these vital pieces of evidence while
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
arriving at the finding that the contract was not an item rate contract.
Non-consideration of material evidence, as per the impugned
judgment, renders the arbitral award bad on the ground of publicity, as
held by the Supreme Court in Associate Builders v. DDA9.
28.
Apart from this, notes the learned Single Judge, there is no
reasoning in support of any of the other findings of the learned
Arbitrator. Para 6 of the arbitral award, as the learned Single Judge
notes, contains omnibus observations to the effect that all the claims
and counter-claims had not been proved, some were frivolous and
unfounded and that the parties were entitled to partial relief. Specifics
of the claims and counter-claims to which this paragraph refers, are
not to be found in the arbitral award.
29.
With respect to the findings of the learned Arbitrator on the
individual issues, the learned Single Judge holds thus:
“25. A perusal of the analysis of the findings of the first issue
shows that it is bereft of any details as to identifying which
documents, which site reports, or which depositions justify the
finding of delay. The Award does not clearly indicate what
constituted the extra work said to be delayed, or which portion of
the work remained incomplete.
26.
A perusal of findings upon issue 2 shows that while
concluding that the work performed by the petitioner suffered from
deficiencies, the Award under Issue 2 offers only the bare assertion
that “verification reports placed on record proves that,” without
analysing what those reports contain, whether they were proved, or
whether they were challenged in cross-examination. The Sole
Arbitrator also does not mention what “was not upto the mark”
means.
9 (2015) 3 SCC 49
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
27.
With respect to findings of Issues 3 and 4, the
determination of compensation of Rs. 2 crore is made “on an adhoc and fair estimation basis,” again without any formula, or
evidence for supporting the arbitrary figure adopted by the Sole
Arbitrator. Similarly, for interest it is simply stated that the interest
is on the higher side and therefore it needs to be reduced without
any reference to the law.
28.
The contention of learned counsel for the respondent that
guesswork is also a valid way of ascertaining the figure and
reliance on Cobra Instalaciones10 and related cases is misplaced as
rough and ready estimate method can only be available in facts of a
particular case when exact loss cannot be ascertained. The relevant
finding of Cobra Instalaciones (Supra) read as under:
“32.2 … It is when such circumstances are present in a
given case, that the court could proceed based on
“guesswork” with regard to the quantum of compensation
to be allowed to the aggrieved party. The following
observations made in the Construction and Design Services
case being apposite are set forth hereafter:
“15. Once it is held that even in absence of specific
evidence, the respondent could be held to have
suffered loss on account of breach of contract, and it
is entitled to compensation to the extent of loss
suffered, it is for the appellant to show that
stipulated damages are by way of penalty. In a
given case, when highest limit is stipulated instead
of a fixed sum, in absence of evidence of loss, part
of it can be held to be reasonable, compensation and
the remaining by way of penalty. The party
complaining of breach can certainly be allowed
reasonable compensation out of the said amount if
not the entire amount. If the entire amount
stipulated is genuine pre-estimate of loss, the actual
loss need not be proved. Burden to prove that no
loss was likely to be suffered is on party committing
breach, as already observed.
*****
17.
Applying the above principle to the present
case, it could certainly be presumed that delay in
executing the work resulted in loss for which the
respondent
was
entitled
to
reasonable
10 Cobra Instalaciones Y Servicos, SA v. Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Ltd, 2024 SCC OnLine Del
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
compensation. Evidence of precise amount of loss
may not be possible but in absence of any evidence
by the party committing breach that no loss was
suffered by the party complaining of breach, the
Court has to proceed on guess work as to the
quantum of compensation to be allowed in the given
circumstances. Since the respondent also could have
led evidence to show the extent of higher amount
paid for the work got done or produce any other
specific material but it did not do so, we are of the
view that it will be fair to award half of the amount
claimed as reasonable compensation.”
29.
The case of Cobra Instalaciones (Supra) does not sanction
arbitrary quantification of damages in every case. On the contrary,
the judgment carefully confines the use of such estimation to a
narrow category of cases namely where a contract stipulates a sum
by way of liquidated damages or prescribes a maximum limit for
damages, and where the Court finds that the stipulated amount is
partly penal.
30.
In the present case, the Sole Arbitrator has not held that the
evidence was insufficient to arrive at a loss figure or that liquidated
damages clause being Clause 3 of the Agreement is partly penal.
Instead, it has rejected the contractual figure outrightly and
substituted it with an ad-hoc number of its own invention. This
constitutes an impermissible rewriting of the contract and falls
within the scope of interference under Section 34 of the Act.
31.
While deciding whether the delay or prolongation of the
Contract was attributable to the claimant/respondent, under Issue 8
it is clear that the findings recorded under this head are themselves
premised on assumptions rather than concrete evidence.
32.
The observations that “the Claimant Society did not
approve the drawings,” or that “the Committee did not clarify the
doubts and issues raised by the Contractor,” or that “verification of
work was not carried out with due promptitude,” and that “nonpayment of Running Bills in time perhaps compelled the
Contractor to leave the work incomplete,” clearly indicate that the
conclusions are speculative. The use of expressions such as
“perhaps” further demonstrates that the findings are not based on
proven facts.
33.
Likewise, in relation to the counterclaims, while the Sole
Arbitrator summarily grants Rs. 1 crore “on a fair and reasonable
basis,” it expressly dismisses the remaining counterclaims on the
ground of “no evidence,” without explaining which evidence was
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
lacking, how the burden of proof was discharged or not discharged,
or how the contradictory finding that many extra works were in
fact executed was reconciled with this conclusion.
34.
Thus, a reading of the issue-wise findings shows that the
Sole Arbitrator has delivered conclusions without reasons,
inasmuch as there is no discussion of how the evidence supports
each finding, which clauses are applicable, no application of law to
the facts, and no rational basis disclosed for the amounts awarded,
rendering the Award unreasoned and contrary to the requirements
of Section 31(3) of the Act as explained and reinforced by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Dyna Technologies11 and reiterated in
the OPG12.
F.
Our view
30.
We entirely agree.
31.
We find the view of the learned Single Judge, that the arbitral
award is vitiated both on the ground of vagueness as well as complete
want of application of mind to the various contentions advanced
before the Tribunal, to be justified both on facts as well as in law.
Additionally, the award is unreasoned and all the counter claims of the
respondent have been rejected with an umbrella observation that there
was no evidence in support thereof.
32.
The Supreme Court has held that the requirement of providing
reasons for the conclusion arrived at by the learned arbitrator is
fundamental to any valid arbitral award. Additionally, the arbitrator is
required to address the various contentions advanced before her, or
him, failing which the award is liable to be set aside even on this
11 Dyna Technologies (P) Ltd. v. Crompton Greaves Ltd., (2019) 20 SCC 1
12 OPG Power Generation (P) Ltd. v. Enexio Power Cooling Solutions (India) (P) Ltd., (2025) 2 SCC
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
ground. Reliance may be placed on the following paragraphs from the
judgments of the Supreme Court in Dyna Technologies, OPG Power
Generation, Som Datt Builders Ltd. v. State of Kerala13 and I-Pay
Clearing Services (P) Ltd. v. ICICI Bank Ltd.14
From Dyna Technologies
“35. When we consider the requirement of a reasoned order,
three characteristics of a reasoned order can be fathomed. They are:
proper, intelligible and adequate. If the reasonings in the order are
improper, they reveal a flaw in the decision-making process. If the
challenge to an award is based on impropriety or perversity in the
reasoning, then it can be challenged strictly on the grounds
provided under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act. If the challenge
to an award is based on the ground that the same is unintelligible,
the same would be equivalent of providing no reasons at all.
Coming to the last aspect concerning the challenge on adequacy of
reasons, the Court while exercising jurisdiction under Section 34
has to adjudicate the validity of such an award based on the degree
of particularity of reasoning required having regard to the nature of
issues falling for consideration. The degree of particularity cannot
be stated in a precise manner as the same would depend on the
complexity of the issue. Even if the Court comes to a conclusion
that there were gaps in the reasoning for the conclusions reached
by the Tribunal, the Court needs to have regard to the documents
submitted by the parties and the contentions raised before the
Tribunal so that awards with inadequate reasons are not set aside in
casual and cavalier manner. On the other hand, ordinarily
unintelligible awards are to be set aside, subject to party autonomy
to do away with the reasoned award. Therefore, the courts are
required to be careful while distinguishing between inadequacy of
reasons in an award and unintelligible awards.”
From OPG Power Generation
73.
In a recent three-Judge Bench decision of this Court
in DMRC Ltd. v. Delhi Airport Metro Express (P) Ltd.15, the
ground of patent illegality/perversity was delineated in the
following terms:
13 (2009) 10 SCC 259
14 (2022) 3 SCC 121
15 (2024) 6 SCC 357
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
“39. In essence, the ground of patent illegality is
available for setting aside a domestic award, if the decision
of the arbitrator is found to be perverse, or so irrational that
no reasonable person would have arrived at it; or the
construction of the contract is such that no fair or
reasonable person would take; or, that the view of the
arbitrator is not even a possible view. A finding based on
no evidence at all or an award which ignores vital evidence
in arriving at its decision would be perverse and liable to be
set aside under the head of “patent illegality”. An award
without reasons would suffer from patent illegality. The
arbitrator commits a patent illegality by deciding a matter
not within its jurisdiction or violating a fundamental
principle of natural justice.”
*****
78.
As to the form of a reasoned award, in Russell on
Arbitration (24th Edn., p. 304) it is stated thus:
“6.032. No particular form is required for a reasoned award
although ‘the giving of clearly expressed reasons responsive to the
issues as they were debated before the arbitrators reduces the scope
for the making of unmeritorious challenges’. When giving a
reasoned award the Tribunal need only set out what, on its view of
the evidence, did or did not happen and explain succinctly why, in
the light of what happened, the Tribunal has reached its decision,
and state what that decision is. In order to avoid being vulnerable
to challenge, the Tribunal's reasons must deal with all the issues
that were put to it. It should set out its findings of fact and its
reasoning so as to enable the parties to understand them and state
why particular points were decisive. It should also indicate the
Tribunal's findings and reasoning on issues argued before it but not
considered decisive, so as to enable the parties and the court to
consider the position with respect to appeal on all the issues before
the Tribunal. When dealing with controversial matters, it is helpful
for the Tribunal to set out not only its view of what occurred, but
also to make it clear that it has considered any alternative version
and has rejected it. Even if several reasons lead to the same result,
the Tribunal should still set them out. That said, so long as the
relevant issues are addressed there is no need to deal with every
possible argument or to explain why the Tribunal attached more
weight to some evidence than to other evidence. The Tribunal is
not expected to recite at great length communications exchanged or
submissions made by the parties. Nor is it required to set out each
step by which it reached its conclusion or to deal with each and
every point made by the parties. It is sufficient that the Tribunal
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
should explain what its findings are and the evidential route by
which it reached its conclusions.”
From Som Datt Builders
“25. The requirement of reasons in support of the award under
Section 31(3) is not an empty formality. It guarantees fair and
legitimate consideration of the controversy by the Arbitral
Tribunal. It is true that the Arbitral Tribunal is not expected to
write a judgment like a court nor is it expected to give elaborate
and detailed reasons in support of its finding(s) but mere noticing
the submissions of the parties or reference to documents is no
substitute for reasons which the Arbitral Tribunal is obliged to
give. Howsoever brief these may be, reasons must be indicated in
the award as that would reflect the thought process leading to a
particular conclusion. To satisfy the requirement of Section 31(3),
the reasons must be stated by the Arbitral Tribunal upon which the
award is based; want of reasons would make such award legally
flawed.”
From I-Pay Clearing Services
“41. Under the guise of additional reasons and filling up the
gaps in the reasoning, no award can be remitted to the arbitrator,
where there are no findings on the contentious issues in the award.
If there are no findings on the contentious issues in the award or if
any findings are recorded ignoring the material evidence on record,
the same are acceptable grounds for setting aside the award itself.
Under the guise of either additional reasons or filling up the gaps in
the reasoning, the power conferred on the Court cannot be
relegated to the arbitrator. In absence of any finding on contentious
issue, no amount of reasons can cure the defect in the award.
42.
A harmonious reading of Sections 31, 34(1), 34(2-A) and
34(4) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, make it clear
that in appropriate cases, on the request made by a party, Court can
give an opportunity to the arbitrator to resume the arbitral
proceedings for giving reasons or to fill up the gaps in the
reasoning in support of a finding, which is already rendered in the
award. But at the same time, when it prima facie appears that there
is a patent illegality in the award itself, by not recording a finding
on a contentious issue, in such cases, Court may not accede to the
request of a party for giving an opportunity to the Arbitral Tribunal
to resume the arbitral proceedings.”
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
33.
We are of the opinion that the arbitral award passed by the
learned Arbitrator was liable to be set aside as violating the principles
contained in the aforesaid decisions. It is entirely bereft of reasons,
relies on judgments which have nothing to do with the controversy at
hand, thereby reflecting non-application of mind, and does not address
any of the contentions advanced by learned Counsel for the
respondent either by way of contest to the claims of the appellant or
while pressing its counter claims.
34.
Section 31(3)16 of the 1996 Act requires every arbitral award to
contain the reasons for the findings returned therein.
35.
We have not deemed it necessary to enter into the rival
contentions of learned Counsel before us. Suffice it to state that
learned Counsel for the appellant was unable to satisfy us that the
arbitral award contains reasons as required by Section 31(3) of the
1996 Act.
36.
If an arbitral award contains reasons, the extent to which the
Court, under Section 34 of the 1996 Act, would second-guess or
examine the justifiability thereof may be considerably circumscribed,
confined within the peripheries of Section 34 of the Act as interpreted
by the Supreme Court in a wide plethora of decisions. However, an
arbitral award without reasons, or relying on material which is
extraneous to the issue at hand, and which does not address any of the
contentions advanced by the parties, is not merely perverse; it is no
16 (3)
The arbitral award shall state the reasons upon which it is based, unless—
(a)
the parties have agreed that no reasons are to be given; or
(b)
the award is an arbitral award on agreed terms under Section 30.
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
award in the eyes of law, as it breaches Section 31(3).
37.
We, therefore, find no reason to interfere with the impugned
judgment of the learned Single Judge which is upheld in its entirety.
38.
The appeal is dismissed.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J.
JULY 01, 2026
FAO(OS) (COMM) 200/2025
KUMAR
17:04:05
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review