Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision : 10.02.2026
+
W.P.(C) 17641/2025 & CM APPL. 72869/2025
FINANCIAL AND RISK ORGANISATION LIMITED .....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Ajay Vohra, Sr. Adv. with Dr.
Shashwat Bajpai, Adv.
versus
THE INCOME TAX OFFICER CIRCLE INT. TAX 1(3)(1) NEW
DELHI
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Debesh Panda, SSC and Ms.
Anauntta Shankar, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DINESH MEHTA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD KUMAR
JUDGMENT
DINESH MEHTA, J. (ORAL)
1.
By way of the present writ petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, the petitioner has called in question the order dated
23.06.2025 (passed on 21.08.2025) passed by Circle INT TAX 1(3)(1)
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the competent authority’) and consequential
certificate dated 21.08.2025 issued under Section 197 of the Income Tax
Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act of 1961’) whereby the tax
W.P.(C) 17641/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
17:55:02
withholding certificate (hereinafter referred to as ‘the certificate’) at the rate
of 15% has been issued, as against petitioner’s request for issuance of ‘NIL’
rate certificate.
2.
As per the pleadings of the petitioner, it is a company incorporated in
the United Kingdom and is a tax resident thereof for Assessment Year (AY)
2026–27, having furnished a valid Tax Residency Certificate. The petitioner
is engaged in providing subscription-based information and software
products, which grant access to publicly available financial, economic,
commercial and regulatory data, including market data, reports, news and
other financial information. It also provides FXall products, being an
electronic platform facilitating real-time online trading in foreign exchange
instruments such as spots, forwards, swaps and options.
3.
The petitioner claims to have entered into a non-exclusive distribution
agreement with Refinitiv India Private Limited (hereinafter referred to as
‘RIPL’) and Refinitiv India Transaction Services Private Limited
(hereinafter referred to as ‘RITSPL’) on a principal-to-principal basis.
Under the said agreement, RIPL and RITSPL purchase the petitioner’s
products for distribution in India and pay the consideration to petitioner in
accordance with the distribution agreement. The payments so received by
the petitioner fall for consideration under the provisions of the Act of 1961
and India-United Kingdom (‘UK’) Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement
(hereinafter referred to as ‘DTAA’)
4.
In view of the nature of the services, which the petitioner-company
provides to its Indian customers through its counterparts namely RIPL and
RITSPL since no income chargeable to tax has been earned, an application
dated 20.06.2025 under Section 197 of the Act of 1961 for AY 2026-27 was
W.P.(C) 17641/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
17:55:02
filed by the petitioner-Company, which was received by the competent
authority on 23.06.2025 and came to be disposed of vide order dated
21.08.2025. Consequently, a tax withholding certificate dated 21.08.2025 at
the rate of 15% tax came to be issued.
5.
Mr. Ajay Vohra, learned senior counsel for the petitioner submitted
that the petitioner’s services are not taxable in India if the provisions of the
Act of 1961 and the India-UK Treaty are taken into account and in spite of
the fact that the petitioner had relied upon the judgment passed by the
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal “I” Bench, Mumbai (hereinafter referred to
as ‘the Tribunal’) on 21.12.2020 for AYs 1998-99 and 1999-2000, the
competent authority has surprisingly relied upon the assessment order for
AY 1999-2000 and rejected its request of certificate at ‘NIL’ rate. He
contended that the same is an example of arbitrary exercise of the statutory
powers, which the competent authority has been bestowed with under the
Act of 1961.
6.
He submitted that even if the order of the Tribunal is kept aside for
the time being, there is no trace of evidence on the basis whereof the
services provided by the petitioner can be brought within the ambit of
‘Royalty’ for which the petitioner’s request of certificate at NIL rate can be
denied.
7.
Learned counsel submitted that the issue in hand is covered by the
judgment of Hon’ble the Supreme Court in the case of Engineering
Analysis Centre of Excellence (P.) Ltd. v CIT, reported as (2021) 432 ITR
471 SC and argued that the competent authority has not followed the
binding decision of Hon’ble the Supreme Court and has passed the
impugned order to issue a certificate at 15% rate, which not only affects
W.P.(C) 17641/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
17:55:02
petitioner’s business rights but also violates the settled statutory and legal
position as well as the India-UK Treaty.
8.
Mr. Debesh Panda, learned Senior Standing Counsel for the
respondent submitted that the competent authority has taken his own
perspective of the matter, taking into account the nature of transactions,
given the limited time and jurisdiction available with him.
9.
He argued that the tax deducted at the rate of 15% is only advance tax
and once the assessment is made and no tax is found payable by the
petitioner, naturally the amount shall be refunded with applicable interest
and thus no interference is warranted.
10.
Heard learned rival counsel.
11.
There is no denial of the fact that in the case of M/S Thomson
Reuters Pvt. Ltd. vs. DCIT Circle-8(3)(1) (erstwhile group entity), the
Tribunal vide its order dated 21.12.2020 had dilated upon all relevant facts,
including the agreement in question and the nature of transactions/services
which the petitioner provides to its Indian customers through its counterparts
in India namely RIPL and RITSPL. No appeal has perhaps been filed against
such order, as the petitioner has not received any notice of appeal (if filed).
12.
We are shocked to see that regardless of the factum of the order
having been passed by the Tribunal on 21.12.2020 and such factual and
legal position having been brought to the notice of the competent authority
in the application which the petitioner had filed, he has relied upon an
assessment order for Assessment Year 1999-2000, which stood set aside by
the Tribunal.
13.
Although there is much to say about such approach of the competent
authority, however, we refrain from doing so because he appears to have
W.P.(C) 17641/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
17:55:02
been propelled by revenue consideration rather than being guided by the law
and judicial discipline which are the cornerstone of justice delivery system
of our country.
14.
When the Tribunal being the last fact finding authority under the Act
of 1961 has recorded a finding qua the issue that the payment of distribution
fees does not amount to royalty in the case of M/s Thomson Reuters Pvt
Ltd.(supra), and no fact or striking feature distinguishing the facts of the
Assessment Year involved therein vis-a-vis the year under consideration has
come to his notice, the competent authority should not and cannot take a
view other than what has been taken by the Tribunal on similar set of facts,
that too in the case of petitioner is erstwhile group entity.
15.
On perusal of the impugned order dated 23.06.2025, we observe that
the finding of the subject transactions amounting to ‘Royalty’ is based upon
conjectures and surmises. No concrete reasoning has been provided for the
same.
16.
We are conscious of this fact that the orders under Section 197 of the
Act of 1961 are in the nature of advance tax and the tax if deducted from the
payments made to the payee can ultimately be refunded, in case the same are
not exigible to tax, but if such argument of the Revenue is to be accepted,
then, the whole purpose of the provision under Section 197 of the Act of
1961 would be frustrated.
17.
Considering that the application was filed on 20.06.2025; the
impugned order came to be passed on 21.08.2025 and that by the time the
matter has ripened for hearing today (10.02.2026), more than 80% of the
period is already over, and during this period the petitioner-company has
transacted in India and its tax has been deducted.
W.P.(C) 17641/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
17:55:02
18.
Such being the position, we not only set aside the impugned order
dated 23.06.2025 (passed on 21.08.2025), certificate dated 21.08.2025 and
direct the competent authority to issue a certificate at NIL rate for AY 202627 within fifteen days from today, we also direct him to continue to issue
certificate(s) at ‘NIL’ rate for each subsequent year within thirty days of the
application being filed by the petitioner.
19.
For the purpose of clarity, the directions are enumerated hereunder:
i.
The competent officer or any other authority who is supposed
to consider the petitioner’s application under Section 197 of the
Act of 1961, shall issue a certificate of ‘NIL’ rate of tax not
only for the Financial Year 2025-26 (AY 2026-27), but also for
the subsequent years in case an application is filed. The
certificate(s) shall be issued within 30 days of the application
being filed by the petitioner.
ii.
The competent authority dealing with petitioner’s subsequent
application(s) under Section 197 of the Act of 1961 shall not be
bound by direction given in clause (i) above, if he comes to a
conclusion and records a finding that the petitioner is having a
Permanent Establishment in India or the transactions which the
company has carried/is carrying out in India are liable to be
taxed in India. However, before recording such finding, a notice
in this regard shall be issued to the petitioner.
iii.
It will also be required from the petitioner-company to disclose
truly and fully all facts in its applications to be filed each year.
It shall be required of the petitioner to extend full cooperation
when any such notice (as provided in clause (ii) above) is
W.P.(C) 17641/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
17:55:02
issued for the subsequent year(s).
20.
Accordingly, the petition stands allowed and pending application(s)
stand disposed of.
DINESH MEHTA, J.
VINOD KUMAR, J.
FEBRUARY 10, 2026/cd
W.P.(C) 17641/2025
Signed By:PRAMOD
KUMAR VATS
17:55:02
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review