Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 26th February, 2026
Pronounced on: 30th March, 2026
Uploaded on: 30th March, 2026
+
RFA (COMM) 162/2025, CM APPL. 16990/2025 & CM APPL.
8357/2026
FEROZ KHAN AND ORS.
Through:
versus
...Appellants
Mr. Gaurav Dalal, Adv.
ANIL JAIN
...Respondent
Through:
Mr. Tejveer Singh Bhatia & Mr.
Sanjog Singh Arneja, Advs. (M:
8888887663)
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
MADHU JAIN, J.
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present appeal has been filed by the Appellants under Section 13
of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 read with Section 96 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908, inter alia, assailing the Impugned Judgment and Decree
dated 1st June, 2024 passed by the ld. District Judge (Commercial Court - 05),
Tis Hazari Courts, West Delhi, in CS (COMM.) No. 116/2019 titled ‘Sh. Anil
Jain v. Sh. Feroz Khan & Ors.’ (hereinafter, ‘Impugned Judgment and
Decree’).
3.
Vide
the
Impugned
Judgment,
the
suit
preferred
by
the
Respondent/Plaintiff has been decreed in the following terms:
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
“RELIEF
11. In view of my issues wise findings, the suit of the
plaintiff is decreed for recovery of Rs.8,89,350/alongwith costs. Plaintiff is also awarded
pendentelite and future interest @ 9% per annum.
The defendants shall be jointly and severally liable to
pay the decreetal amount to the plaintiff. Decree sheet
be prepared. File be consigned to record Room.”
Factual Background
4.
The brief factual matrix giving rise to the present appeal is as follows:
5.
The Respondent/Plaintiff (hereinafter, ‘Plaintiff’) is engaged in the
business of sale and supply of various chemical products and carries on
business in the name and style of its proprietorship firm M/s Jain Chemicals.
Appellant No. 3/Defendant No. 3 is a partnership firm in the name and style
of M/s New Chemical Industries, engaged in the business of wholesale and
retail trade of various acids and chemicals, and Appellant Nos.1 and
2/Defendant Nos.1 and 2 (hereinafter, collectively ‘Defendants’) are its
partners.
6.
The Plaintiff and the Defendants had an established business
relationship for several years. The Defendants placed orders for chemical
products on credit, and goods were supplied in accordance with their
instructions. In March 2016, the Plaintiff raised three invoices amounting to
Rs.5,77,500/-, and the goods were dispatched from Nangloi, Delhi, in
accordance with the specifications provided by the Defendants, who are stated
to have acknowledged receipt thereof.
7.
The Plaintiff issued a legal notice dated 23rd February, 2019 calling
upon Defendant No.1 to discharge the outstanding principal amount of Rs.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
5,77,500/-. The Plaintiff also claimed interest at the rate of 18% per annum
on the said amount, which was calculated at Rs. 3,11,850/-. Accordingly, the
total amount claimed by the Plaintiff was Rs. 8,89,350/-.
8.
On the contrary, the Defendants stated that although the invoices were
delivered by Mr. Ashok Jain, the Special Power of Attorney holder of the
Plaintiff, in March 2016, the goods corresponding to those invoices were
never physically supplied or delivered to them. According to the Defendants,
the said invoices were inadvertently entered in the books of account of
Defendant No. 3 and were also reflected in their VAT returns, despite no
goods having been received and no corresponding payment having been
made.
9.
In the Written Statement filed by Defendant No. 1, the stand taken by
the Defendants was that the invoices in question were fictitious bills or entry
bills and that no goods were ever supplied to them. Furthermore, the entries
in the books of accounts were inadvertently made by their accountant and,
therefore, no liability arises against them in respect of the said invoices. In the
Replication, the Plaintiff denied the averments made by the Defendants in the
Written Statement and reiterated the contents of the plaint.
10.
Prior to institution of the suit, the Plaintiff had initiated Pre-Institution
Mediation Proceedings before the District Legal Services Authority (West)
(hereinafter, ‘DLSA’) on 5th March 2019, wherein Defendant No. 1 had
appeared and stated that mediation in the present dispute was not possible.
Consequently, a Non-Starter Report was issued on 12th April 2019.
11.
In the subject suit, the ld. Commercial Court framed issues on 3rd
August, 2022. The issues framed are reproduced below:
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
“ISSUES
1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for recovery of
amount of Rs.8,89,350/-? OPP
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to interest @ 18%
per annum, if any? OPP
3. Relief”
12.
Evidence was led by both parties. On behalf of the Plaintiff, Mr. Ashok
Jain, was examined as PW1, who tendered his affidavit in evidence and
proved the Special Power of Attorney (Ex. PW1/1), Statement of Account
(Ex. PW1/2), Invoices/Bills (Ex. PW1/3 (Colly.)), Legal Notice with
postal/courier receipts (Ex. PW1/4 (Colly.)), original returned envelope (Ex.
PW1/5) and the non-starter report of pre-institution mediation (Ex. PW1/6).
PW1 also relied upon Annexure-2B of the VAT return for the period
01.01.2016 to 31.03.2016 (Ex. PW1/7) and the certificate under Section 65B
of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (hereinafter, ‘IEA’) (Ex. PW1/8).
13.
On behalf of the Defendants, Defendant No.1, Mr. Feroz Khan, was
examined as DW1. The Defendants relied upon details of ‘C-Forms’, which
were de-exhibited by the ld. Commercial Court and marked only as Mark-D1.
14.
Upon appreciation of the evidence, the ld. Commercial Court held that
the Plaintiff had proved its claim for recovery under the three invoices. The
Court observed that although the Defendants alleged that the invoices were
fictitious bills, they had themselves entered the same in their books of
accounts and reflected them in their VAT returns. The Court further noted that
the Defendants failed to produce any cogent evidence, including examination
of their accountant or production of account books, to substantiate their
defence. The Court concluded that the defence was an afterthought and
decreed the suit in favour of the Plaintiff.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
15.
Aggrieved by the Impugned Judgment and Decree passed by the ld.
Commercial Court; the Defendants have preferred the present Appeal.
Submissions on behalf of the Appellants/Defendants
16.
Mr. Gaurav Dalal, ld. counsel for the Appellants submits that the ld.
Commercial Court failed to properly appreciate the evidence on record while
decreeing the suit. Ld. Counsel submits that the entire case of the Plaintiff
rests on the allegation that the Defendants had purchased certain chemicals
under three invoices and had failed to make payment in respect thereof.
However, the consistent defence of the Defendants has been that the said
invoices are fictitious and that no sale transaction ever took place between the
parties.
17.
Ld. counsel further submits that the Plaintiff failed to place on record
any material to establish that the goods mentioned in the said invoices were
ever supplied or delivered to the Defendants. He further submits that even
according to the Plaintiff’s own admission in cross- examination, there is no
acknowledgment of receipt of goods by the Defendants or their
representatives. Reliance in this regard is placed on the cross-examination of
the Plaintiff dated 24th March, 2023, wherein the Plaintiff admitted as under:
“It is correct that there is no signature on behalf of
the defendant or his representative to receive the
chemicals on credit basis as mentioned in Ex. PWl/3
(Colly.) and as stated by me in my plaint. I cannot
produce any document which can show receiving of
chemicals on behalf of defendant or his
representative which is mentioned in Ex. PWl/3
(Colly.).”
18.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
Ld. Counsel submits that once receipt of goods was specifically
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
disputed by the Defendants, the burden lay upon the Plaintiff to establish
delivery through cogent evidence. However, no such evidence has been
produced on record.
19.
Ld. Counsel further submits that during the course of cross-
examination dated 10th February 2023, when the Plaintiff was questioned
regarding documents evidencing dispatch or delivery of the goods, the
Plaintiff sought to shift the responsibility on the defendants by stating that
preparation of such documents was the responsibility of the Defendants and
not the Plaintiff.
20.
Ld. Counsel submits that the invoices relied upon by the Plaintiff do
not contain essential particulars such as the name of the transporter, vehicle
number, or other transportation details which could establish that the goods
were actually dispatched or delivered. In a transaction involving supply of
large quantities of chemical substances, the existence of such records would
ordinarily be expected, and their absence raises doubt regarding the
genuineness of the alleged transaction.
21.
Ld. Counsel further submits that the Plaintiff has relied primarily on
copies of invoices and a statement of account maintained by him. Such
documents are self-serving in nature and cannot by themselves establish
liability unless supported by independent proof of the underlying transaction.
In the absence of evidence demonstrating actual supply or delivery of goods,
the reliance placed on such documents is insufficient to sustain the decree
passed by the ld. Commercial Court.
Submissions on behalf of the Respondent/Plaintiff
22.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
Mr. Tejveer Singh, ld. counsel for the Respondent submits that the
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
defence raised by the Appellants/Defendants that the goods were never
received is clearly an afterthought to avoid liability.
23.
Ld. Counsel submits that prior to the institution of the suit, the Plaintiff
had issued a legal notice to the Defendants and the parties had also
participated in Pre-Institution Mediation proceedings before the DLSA. At no
stage during this period did the Defendants dispute the said invoices or
contend that the goods covered thereunder were never supplied. The plea
denying receipt of goods has been raised for the first time only after the
institution of the suit before the ld. Commercial Court and therefore lacks
credibility.
24.
Ld. Counsel further submits that the conduct of the Defendants is
inconsistent with their present stand. Ld. Counsel submits that the Defendants
admittedly availed input tax credit in respect of the invoices in question under
the Delhi Value Added Tax Act, 2004. Having availed such credit on the
strength of the said invoices, the Defendants cannot now contend that the
transactions were fictitious or that no goods were received.
25.
Ld. Counsel further submits that the explanation offered by the
Defendants regarding the alleged fictitious nature of the invoices is
unsupported by any evidence. The Defendants have not produced any
document or taken any action to show that the entries made in their tax returns
were incorrect or required rectification. Their failure to take any such step
clearly indicates that the defence raised is merely an attempt to avoid payment
of the outstanding dues.
Analysis and Findings
26.
The submissions advanced on behalf of the Appellants/Defendants and
the Respondent/Plaintiff have been heard and the material placed on record
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
by the parties has been duly perused. This Court now proceeds to examine the
issues arising in the present appeal.
27.
In light of the rival submissions advanced by the parties and the
material placed on record, the following questions arise for consideration in
the present appeal:
i.
Whether the Plaintiff has been able to establish that the transactions
reflected in the invoices Ex. PW1/3 (colly.) represent genuine
commercial transactions and that the amount reflected in the
statement of account Ex. PW1/2 is legally recoverable from the
Defendants?
ii.
Whether the award of pendente lite and future interest @ 9% per
annum by the ld. Commercial Court calls for any interference in the
present appeal?
28.
Before delving into these issues, it would be apposite to briefly notice
the scope and duty of a First Appellate Court. As explained by the Supreme
Court in Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari, 2001 (3) SCC 179, a first
appeal is a valuable right of the parties and, unless restricted by law, the whole
case is open for rehearing both on questions of fact and law. The first appellate
court is therefore required to apply its mind to the entire evidence on record
and record findings supported by cogent reasons on the issues arising in the
appeal.
29.
The Plaintiff has relied upon the statement of account Ex. PW1/2
maintained in the regular course of business and the invoices dated
28.03.2016, 29.03.2016 and 30.03.2016 exhibited as Ex. PW1/3 (colly.). The
evidentiary value of entries in books of account maintained in the ordinary
course of business is governed by Section 34 of the IEA, 1872.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
30.
It is well settled that while such entries are relevant evidence, they are
not by themselves sufficient to fasten liability upon a person. In Chandradhar
Goswami and Others v. Gauhati Bank Ltd., 1966 SCC OnLine SC 255, the
Supreme Court observed as follows:
“Entries in books of account, regularly kept in the
course of business, are relevant whenever they refer
to a matter into which the court has to inquire, but
such statements shall not alone be sufficient evidence
to charge any person with liability.”
It is clear from a bare perusal of the section that no
person can be charged with liability merely on the
basis of entries in books of account, even where such
books of account are kept in the regular course of
business. There has to be further evidence to prove
payment of the money which may appear in the books
of account in order that a person may be charged with
liability thereunder, except where the person to be
charged accepts the correctness of the books of
account and does not challenge them.”
31.
The position that thus emerges is that while a statement of account
constitutes relevant evidence, it must ordinarily be supported by additional
material establishing the underlying transaction. In the present case, such
corroboration is found in the invoices Ex. PW1/3 (colly.) as well as in the
admissions emerging from the testimony of DW1 – Mr. Feroz Khan.
32.
At this stage, it is necessary to notice the principle governing the burden
of proof in such matters. The Supreme Court in Mohd. Abdullah Azam Khan
v. Nawab Kazim Ali Khan, (2022) 20 SCC 233, observed that in terms of
Section 102 of the IEA, 1872, the initial burden to prove its claim lies upon
the plaintiff and if he discharges that burden and makes out a case which
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
entitles him to relief, the onus shifts to the defendant to prove those
circumstances, if any, which would disentitle the plaintiff from the same.
33.
Considering this legal position, the evidentiary material placed on
record by the parties may now be examined. The evidentiary approach
adopted by courts in commercial disputes involving supply transactions has
been discussed by a Coordinate Bench of this Court in Haryana Medical Hall
v Dr Roshanlal Aggarwal and Sons Pvt Ltd, 2023 SCC OnLine Del 8105,
where the Court observed:
“16………We are of the view that the respondent had
duly proved that the statement of accounts was
maintained in the normal course of business and had
reflected a balance of Rs. 28,80,847/- as outstanding
and payable by the appellants.
17. The respondent had also produced GSTR returns,
which were referred to by the learned Commercial
Court. The contention that the said returns had no
evidentiary value, is erroneous. The said returns
clearly indicated that the respondent had paid central
tax as well as state/UT tax and the benefit of such
input tax credit of the said amount would be available
to the appellants.”
34.
The documentary evidence produced by the Plaintiff, including the
invoices forming the basis of the claim and the statement of account
maintained in the ordinary course of business, supports the transactions relied
upon by the Plaintiff and must be considered alongside the Defendants’
conduct in availing VAT input credit in respect of the very same invoices.
35.
In the course of examining the evidentiary record, a material admission
emerges from the testimony of DW1. During the course of cross-examination,
DW1 – Mr. Feroz Khan, made the following admission:
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
“It is correct that I have taken VAT input in regard
to all these three invoices i.e. Ex.PWl/3 (Colly.) (VolMr. Ashok Jain had approached me as he wanted to
raise certain fake invoices qua their stock and no sale
had actually taken place and it was mutually agreed
between me and Mr. Ashok Jain the we will share the
VAT input equally. As per agreement I was to deposit
the amount of these bills i.e. Rs.5,77,500/- in the bank
account of Sh. Ashok Jain after he will pay the
aforesaid amount in cash, however, he did not pay
any cash amount to me thereafter I did not deposit the
said amount in the bank account)”
36.
This admission assumes considerable significance in the context of the
defence raised by the Defendants. The claim of VAT input credit necessarily
proceeds on the premise that the purchasing dealer recognizes the transaction
as a genuine purchase from the supplier. The admission of DW1 therefore
reflects the manner in which the Defendants themselves acknowledged and
treated the transactions represented by the invoices.
37.
The relevance of such conduct has been considered by a Coordinate
Bench of this Court in Ranjeet Saini v M/s Banwarilal Arora and Sons, 2026
DHC: 444 – DB. In that case, while dealing with a similar contention
disputing supply of goods despite the availing of input tax credit, the Court
observed:
“16. A perusal of the above two extracts from the
cross-examination of the Appellant would show that
the Appellant admits his signatures at all the invoices
except one. Moreover, once the Appellant availed of
the Input Tax Credit on the GST inputs in respect of
all the invoices, the Appellant cannot argue that on
the one hand, it is entitled to Input Tax Credit on the
ground of supply of goods having been made and on
the other hand, for the same very invoices, argue
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
that the goods have been returned.
17. Such contradictory pleas would not be
permissible especially in a commercial case where
the contract is for supply of goods, invoices are
accepted, GST Input Tax Credit is availed of, and the
Appellant admits during cross-examination that all
the invoices except one bear his signatures.”
(EMPHASIS SUPPLIED)
38.
The reasoning in the aforesaid decision assumes relevance in the
present factual matrix. The Defendants have admittedly availed VAT input
credit on the basis of the very invoices which they now seek to characterise
as fictitious or entry bills. This conduct, when viewed in conjunction with the
documentary evidence and the admissions of DW1, shows the lack of bona
fides in the Defendants’ plea.
39.
However, this Court also considers the principal defence advanced by
the Defendants. The principal contention advanced by the ld. counsel for the
Defendants is that the Plaintiff has not produced any document evidencing
physical delivery of goods, such as transport receipts or acknowledgments of
receipt.
40.
As per the record, it is correct that the invoices relied upon by the
Plaintiff do not bear any signature of the Defendants acknowledging receipt
of the goods. In this context, PW1 in his cross-examination dated 10th
February 2023 stated that the responsibility for preparing the road permit and
transportation builty lay with the purchasing party and not with the supplier.
The relevant portion of the cross- examination is reproduced below:
“The responsibility of preparing the road permit and
transportation bilti relates to our clients only who
purchase the product from our firm. At the relevant
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
time , procedure of e-way bill was not in
practice……”
41.
This testimony carries weight in the present context. It offers an
explanation, from the perspective of the Plaintiff’s witness, as to why
transportation documents were not produced by the Plaintiff. The statement
indicates that the preparation and retention of such documents was, according
to the Plaintiff, the responsibility of the purchasing party.
42.
In the light of the explanation furnished by PW1, the absence of
transportation documents or acknowledgment of delivery on the invoices
cannot, by itself, be treated as establishing non-supply of goods. The said
circumstance must therefore be appreciated in conjunction with the other
material appearing on record.
43.
Apart from the above evidentiary aspects, another important legal
principle is relevant here. The principle that a party cannot accept the benefit
of a transaction and simultaneously dispute its existence is well recognised in
law. In this context, the Supreme Court in Cauvery Coffee Traders,
Mangalore v. Hornor Resources Company Limited, 2011 SCC OnLine SC
1255, has elucidated the doctrine of approbate and reprobate in the following
terms:
“34. A party cannot be permitted to “blow hot and cold”,
“fast and loose” or “approbate and reprobate”. Where one
knowingly accepts the benefits of a contract or conveyance
or an order, is estopped to deny the validity or binding effect
on him of such contract or conveyance or order. This rule
is applied to do equity, however, it must not be applied in a
manner as to violate the principles of right and good
conscience.
35. Thus, it is evident that the doctrine of election is based
on the rule of estoppel—the principle that one cannot
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
approbate and reprobate inheres in it. The doctrine of
estoppel by election is one of the species of estoppels in pais
(or equitable estoppel), which is a rule in equity. By that
law, a person may be precluded by his actions or conduct
or silence when it is his duty to speak, from asserting a right
which he otherwise would have had.”
44.
The underlying principle that a party cannot accept the benefit of a
transaction and simultaneously deny its existence is clearly attracted in the
present factual matrix. Having availed VAT input credit on the basis of the
invoices in question, the Defendants cannot now be permitted to contend that
the said invoices were fictitious or that the transactions never took place.
45.
There is yet another circumstance which merits consideration. The
record reflects that the Plaintiff had issued a legal notice dated 23rd February,
2019 calling upon the Defendants to discharge the outstanding amount
claimed under the invoices in question.
46.
Despite receipt of the said notice, the Defendants did not issue any reply
disputing the transactions or denying their liability. In Metropolis Travels &
Resorts (I) Pvt. Ltd. v. Sumit Kalra & Anr., 2002 SCC OnLine Del 521, a
Coordinate Bench of this Court while relying upon Kalu Ram v. Sita Ram,
1980 RLR (Note) 44 observed that where a notice is served and the recipient
fails to reply thereto, an adverse inference may be drawn from such conduct.
47.
This factor merits particular attention when viewed alongside the fact
that no contemporaneous dispute regarding the transactions had been raised
by the Defendants at any earlier stage. The silence maintained by the
Defendants both at the time of the transactions and upon receipt of the legal
notice raises serious doubt on the defence taken by them. The further positive
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
conduct of availing VAT credit also obliterates any doubt as to the genuinity
of the transactions.
48.
The operation of the evidentiary burden in such situations has also been
considered by this Court in Metropolis Travels & Resorts (I) Pvt. Ltd.
(supra). The Court was dealing with a case wherein the plaintiff had proved
invoices bearing the signatures of the defendant’s employees acknowledging
receipt of tickets. The Court observed that once such evidence had been led
and it stood established that the persons whose signatures appeared on the
invoices were employees of the defendant and had been dealing with the
plaintiff on behalf of the defendant, the burden shifted upon the defendant to
show, by cogent and reliable evidence, that the signatures were not genuine
or that the said employees were not authorised or were not in service at the
relevant time.
49.
Tested on the touchstone of the aforesaid principles, the material on
record shows that the Plaintiff has produced the invoices forming the basis of
the claim and led evidence in support of the transactions reflected therein.
Despite disputing their liability, the Defendants have not placed any credible
material on record to substantiate the defence raised by them.
50.
In these circumstances, this Court is of the view that a mere denial of
the transactions, unsupported by contemporaneous correspondence or denials
or other reliable evidence, cannot prevail against the documentary evidence
placed on record by the Plaintiff. The Defendants having failed to discharge
the evidentiary burden cast upon them, the contention that the invoices were
fictitious or merely accommodation entries cannot be accepted.
51.
The documentary evidence on record, including the statement of
account and the invoices, read in conjunction with the admissions of DW1
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
regarding availing VAT input credit, clearly establishes the genuineness of
the transactions relied upon by the Plaintiff. The Defendants’ conduct in
availing VAT input credit on these very invoices is manifestly inconsistent
with their plea that the invoices were fictitious or that no goods were supplied.
52.
In view of the aforesaid evidence and the surrounding circumstances,
this Court is satisfied that the transactions reflected in the invoices were duly
entered into between the parties. The defence raised by the Defendants is
therefore untenable and cannot be accepted.
53.
Consequently, the Plaintiff has successfully proved the transactions in
question and is entitled to recover the amounts claimed on the basis of the said
invoices and statement of account.
54.
The next question that arises for consideration relates to the rate of
interest awarded by the ld. Commercial Court.
55.
The question of pre-suit, pendente lite, and future interest was
examined and decided by the ld. Commercial Court as another important issue
in the subject suit. The Plaintiff had claimed interest at the rate of 18% per
annum on the principal sum, relying upon the terms and conditions set forth
in the invoices Ex. PW1/3 (colly.), which provided that the Defendants would
be liable to pay interest at 18% per annum in the event of non-payment within
thirty days of supply of goods. Based on these facts and circumstances, the ld.
Commercial Court granted pre-suit interest at the contractual rate of 18% per
annum and awarded pendente lite and future interest at 9% per annum.
56.
This Court finds no infirmity in the award of pre-suit interest at the
contractual rate of 18% per annum, amounting to Rs. 3,11,850/-, as claimed
by the Plaintiff. However, so far as pendente lite and future interest are
concerned, the same fall within the discretionary domain of the Court under
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
Section 34 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. While the ld. Commercial
Court has awarded pendente lite and future interest at the rate of 9% per
annum, it is well settled that the Court, while exercising such discretion, may
take into account the nature of the transaction, the period involved and the
prevailing commercial lending rates.
57.
Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the present case, this
Court is of the view that interest at the rate of 6% per annum on the decretal
amount would be just and reasonable for the purposes of pendente lite and
future interest.
Conclusion
58.
Subject to the modification in the rate of pendente lite and future
interest as indicated above, the Impugned Judgment and Decree passed by the
ld. Commercial Court are upheld. The rate of pendente lite and future interest
shall stand reduced from 9% per annum to 6% per annum.
59.
Vide order dated 24th March 2025, this Court directed the Appellants to
deposit a sum of Rs.5,75,500/- with the Registrar General, to be kept in an
FDR on auto-renewal mode. This direction was partly modified vide order
dated 3rd July 2025, taking note that the FDR had been prepared in the name
of the Registrar General and directing its submission for safe custody, with a
stipulation for its encashment on maturity and reinvestment in an autorenewable FDR.
60.
In compliance thereof, FDR bearing No. 50301162976453 dated 22nd
May 2025 for Rs.5,75,500/-, carrying interest @ 7.05% p.a. and maturing on
23rd November 2026, was deposited with the Registrar General. Vide order
dated 20th November 2025, the Respondent was granted liberty to seek release
of the deposited amount and, pursuant thereto, CM APPL. 8357/2026 was
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
filed. Accordingly, in view of the aforesaid discussion, the said FDR, along
with accrued interest (after deduction of TDS on interest component), is
directed to be released to the Respondent/Plaintiff.
61.
The Respondent/Plaintiff shall be at liberty to execute the Impugned
Judgment and Decree for the remaining amount in accordance with law.
62.
The appeal, along with all pending applications, stands dismissed.
MADHU JAIN
JUDGE
PRATIBHA M. SINGH
JUDGE
MARCH 30, 2026/M
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:33:40
RFA (COMM) 162/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review