Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 21.04.2026
Date of decision: 04.08.2026
Uploaded on: 04.08.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC015047632017
+
W.P.(C) 10502/2017, CM APPL. 42977/2017, CM APPL.
16274/2018
FEDERAL BANK LTD
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Rajat Arora, Mr. Niraj
Kumar and Mr. Sourabh Mahla,
Advs.
versus
VIKAS GUPTA
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Sahil A. Garg Narwana,
Mr. Kapil Gaba and Mr. Kesri
Nandan V. Atri, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
JUDGMENT
SHAIL JAIN, J
1.
The present Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India has been instituted by the petitioner–Bank assailing the Award
dated 22.05.2017 (hereinafter ‘the Impugned Award’) passed by the
learned Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court-I,
Delhi (hereinafter ‘the tribunal’), in Industrial Dispute No.147/2003
under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter ‘the Act’).
2.
By the impugned Award, the CGIT answered the industrial
reference in favour of the respondent-workman and held that the order
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
of dismissal from service was illegal and unjustified. Consequently,
CGIT directed reinstatement of the respondent in service with
continuity of service, all consequential benefits and full back wages.
3.
The petitioner also assails the earlier order dated 28.03.2012
passed by the tribunal, whereby the domestic enquiry against the
workman was held to be unfair and vitiated.
4.
The petition has been filed on behalf of the petitioner-Bank
through its authorized officer, namely the Vice President and Zonal
Head of its New Delhi Zonal Office, who is stated to be duly
empowered under a General Power of Attorney to institute and
prosecute the present proceedings.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND:
5.
The brief facts and procedural history of the present case are
that the respondent joined the services of the petitioner-Bank as a
Clerk on 16.10.1998. He was initially posted at the Gurgaon Branch,
which functioned under the administrative control of the Regional
Office at New Delhi. According to the petitioner, during the course of
his service, allegations of misconduct came to be levelled against the
respondent, culminating in the initiation of disciplinary proceedings.
6.
In pursuance to which, the first charge-sheet dated 13.10.2001
was issued to the respondent alleging that, on 04.09.2001, he had
entered into a verbal altercation with the Manager (Administration)
and the Senior Manager of the Branch. It was alleged that the incident
occurred when an office order concerning allocation of duties was
issued to another employee, namely Ms. Rachna Chadha. The
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
petitioner alleged that the respondent displayed unruly and boisterous
behaviour, raised his voice in the branch premises and acted in a
manner unbecoming of a bank employee.
7.
Shortly thereafter, a second charge-sheet dated 31.10.2001 was
issued against the respondent. The allegations therein pertained to the
opening of certain savings bank accounts. According to the petitioner,
the respondent had introduced a few persons for opening accounts, one
of whom was alleged to be a fictitious person. It was further alleged
that the respondent had knowingly facilitated the opening of such
accounts with the intention of enabling fraudulent withdrawal of funds
and had thereby committed acts amounting to gross misconduct,
dishonesty, wilful insubordination and conduct prejudicial to the
interests of the Bank.
8.
The respondent denied the allegations contained in both charge-
sheets. The petitioner thereafter initiated a departmental enquiry. An
Enquiry Officer was appointed to enquire into the charges, and enquiry
proceedings were conducted after issuance of notices to the
respondent.
9.
Upon completion of the enquiry, the Enquiry Officer submitted
his report dated 08.04.2002, holding the charges against the
respondent to have been proved. The findings recorded by the Enquiry
Officer were thereafter placed before the Disciplinary Authority.
10.
On 05.07.2002, the Disciplinary Authority issued a notice
proposing the punishment of dismissal from service without notice.
Consequently, the respondent submitted his representation against the
proposed punishment.
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
11.
After considering the enquiry report, the representation
submitted by the respondent and the material available on record, the
Disciplinary Authority passed an order dated 10.08.2002 imposing the
penalty of dismissal from service without notice upon the respondent.
12.
Aggrieved by the order of dismissal, the respondent preferred a
departmental
appeal
before
the
Appellate
Authority.
Upon
consideration of the appeal, the Appellate Authority, by order dated
20.11.2002, affirmed the findings recorded by the Disciplinary
Authority and rejected the appeal, thereby maintaining the punishment
of dismissal.
13.
Following the dismissal of his departmental appeal, the
respondent raised an industrial dispute. Conciliation proceedings
having failed, the Central Government, in exercise of powers under the
Act, made a reference dated 14.11.2003 to the Central Government
Industrial Tribunal for adjudication on the following question:
“Whether the action of the management of Federal
Bank in dismissing Shri Vikas Gupta, Clerk from
10.08.2002 is just, fair and legal? If not, to what
relief and from which date the workman is entitled
for?”
14.
Pursuant to the reference, the respondent-workman filed a
Statement of Claim before the Tribunal. The respondent asserted that
he had rendered satisfactory service and that the disciplinary
proceedings had been initiated solely to victimize him. It was pleaded
that he had been actively associated with the employees' union and had
raised issues concerning the working conditions of employees,
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
including the practice of requiring employees to work beyond office
hours without payment of overtime wages. According to the
respondent, these activities had displeased the management, resulting
in false complaints being engineered against him.
15.
The respondent in his Statement of Claim further pleaded that
both charge-sheets were baseless and had been issued with a view to
victimizing him. It was alleged that the domestic enquiry was
conducted in violation of the principles of natural justice. The
respondent additionally submitted that the adequate opportunity to
defend himself was not afforded, his defence representative was not
properly accommodated, effective cross-examination of management
witnesses was not permitted and he was not allowed to produce
defence evidence. The respondent accordingly prayed that the enquiry
proceedings and the consequential punishment be declared illegal.
16.
The petitioner-Bank in response filed its Written Statement
contesting the claim. It denied all allegations of victimization and
asserted that the respondent had repeatedly displayed indiscipline and
misconduct in the discharge of his duties. The petitioner maintained
that the enquiry had been conducted fairly and in accordance with the
applicable service regulations and principles of natural justice. It was
pleaded that the findings of the Enquiry Officer were based upon
evidence and that the punishment imposed was proportionate to the
gravity of the misconduct established against the respondent.
17.
The respondent filed a rejoinder reiterating the averments made
in the Statement of Claim while denying those contained in the
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
Written Statement. Upon completion of pleadings, the learned
Tribunal, by order dated 23.07.2007, framed the following issues:
“(i)Whether the enquiry conducted by the
respondent management is proper and fair? If not,
its effect?
(ii)As per terms of reference.”
18.
Both parties led evidence on the preliminary issue i.e. fairness
and legality of the domestic enquiry. Upon appreciation of the
evidence, the Tribunal passed an order dated 28.03.2012, holding that
the domestic inquiry suffered from violation of the principles of
natural justice and was not fair and proper. Consequently, the enquiry
was held to be vitiated.
19.
However, in view of the settled legal position, the Tribunal
granted liberty to the petitioner-management to lead evidence before it
to establish the charges independently on merits.
20.
Pursuant to the aforesaid order, the petitioner adduced fresh
evidence before the Tribunal. The petitioner examined Shri S. Rajan,
Assistant General Manager, who tendered his affidavit and relied upon
various documents relating to the disciplinary proceedings and the
incidents forming the subject matter of the charge-sheets. The
petitioner also examined Shri P.V. Sebastian, who similarly filed his
affidavit and produced documents in support of the allegations
contained in the charge-sheets.
21.
Both management witnesses were subjected to detailed cross-
examination by the respondent.
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
22.
In rebuttal, the respondent deposed himself by filing an affidavit
in evidence denying the allegations of misconduct and disputing the
correctness of the allegations contained in both charge-sheets. The
respondent also faced cross-examination by the petitioner.
23.
After completion of oral evidence, both parties filed written
submissions before the Tribunal in support of their respective cases.
24.
Upon consideration of the pleadings, oral and documentary
evidence, and the submissions advanced by the parties, the learned
Tribunal passed the impugned Award dated 22.05.2017. The Tribunal
held that, after the domestic enquiry had been declared vitiated, the
petitioner had failed to establish the charges independently before the
Tribunal.
25.
Consequently, the learned Tribunal directed reinstatement of the
respondent in service with continuity of service, all consequential
benefits and full back wages.
26.
Aggrieved by the Award dated 22.05.2017 and order dated
28.03.2012 the petitioner has preferred the present writ petition.
SUBMISSIONS OF PARTIES:
On behalf of the Petitioner–Bank:
27.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner-Bank
assailed the impugned Award, contending, at the outset, that the
learned Tribunal has returned findings which are contrary to the
evidence available on record and the settled principles governing
adjudication of disciplinary proceedings. It was submitted that the
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
impugned Award proceeds on a mis-appreciation of evidence, applies
incorrect legal standards while examining the domestic enquiry, and
grants reliefs which are wholly disproportionate to the facts and
circumstances of the case.
28.
Elaborating the challenge to the findings returned in relation to
the first charge-sheet, learned counsel submitted that the learned
Tribunal committed a manifest error in discarding the testimony of the
Bank's witnesses, namely, Sh. S. Rajan, Assistant General Manager,
and Sh. P.V. Sebastian, solely on the premise that they were
"interested witnesses". It was argued that both the aforesaid officials
were the only persons present during the incident dated 04.09.2001
and were, therefore, the most natural witnesses to depose regarding the
misconduct alleged against the Respondent. Merely because they were
officers of the petitioner-Bank could not, by itself, furnish a valid
ground to discard their testimony.
29.
Learned counsel further submitted that the Tribunal also failed
to appreciate the gravity of the allegations forming the subject matter
of the second charge-sheet dated 31.10.2001. It was contended that the
material on record clearly established that the Respondent had
introduced a person represented as "Prakash Bhadoria" for opening a
savings bank account, whereas the individual so introduced was not
the person he was purported to be. It was argued that a bank officer
facilitating the opening of an account through false introduction
commits a serious breach of fiduciary obligations, and the misconduct
cannot be trivialised merely because no immediate pecuniary loss was
ultimately suffered either by the Bank or by any account-holder.
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
30.
Assailing the findings of the learned Tribunal on the issue of
victimisation, learned counsel submitted that the conclusion reached in
the impugned Award is wholly unsustainable in law. It was argued that
the Respondent neither pleaded the necessary particulars constituting
victimisation nor adduced any evidence whatsoever to establish that
the disciplinary proceedings were actuated by mala fides arising out of
any trade union activity. It was submitted that victimisation is a
serious allegation carrying grave civil consequences and cannot be
inferred on mere conjectures or surmises. Reliance was placed upon
Hamdard Dawakhana Wakf v. Its Workmen, 1962 (2) LLJ 772, and
Bharat Iron Works v. Bhagubhai Balubhai Patel, AIR 1976 SC 98,
to contend that such a plea must be specifically pleaded and
established by cogent evidence. It was further submitted that the
Respondent did not even disclose before the Tribunal the name of the
trade union of which he claimed to be a member, thereby rendering the
finding of victimisation entirely speculative and unsupported by the
record.
31.
Learned counsel next assailed the order dated 28.03.2012
whereby the domestic enquiry was held to be unfair and improper. It
was submitted that the learned Tribunal adopted an unduly pedantic
approach while examining proceedings which are essentially factfinding in nature and are not governed by the strict rules of evidence
applicable to judicial trials.
32.
Learned counsel further submitted that, even assuming any
infirmity in the disciplinary proceedings, the relief of reinstatement
with continuity of service and full back wages is wholly
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
disproportionate. It was contended that despite the Respondent having
rendered only about four years of service, the impugned Award
effectively grants service benefits for nearly fifteen years, without
regard to the settled principles governing such relief.
33.
It was further contended that the learned Tribunal has awarded
full back wages in a mechanical manner, overlooking the well-settled
principle that reinstatement does not automatically entail an award of
back wages. Learned counsel submitted that while determining
entitlement to back wages, the Court is required to consider several
relevant factors including the length of service rendered, the nature of
employment, the time elapsed since termination and the financial
implications upon the employer.
34.
Learned counsel lastly submitted that the Respondent had failed
to discharge the initial burden cast upon him to establish that he
remained unemployed during the interregnum or that he had made any
reasonable effort to secure alternative employment. It was argued that
no pleadings or evidence whatsoever were produced before the learned
Tribunal regarding his alleged unemployment, and in the absence of
such foundational material, no occasion arose for the burden to shift
upon the petitioner-Bank. Reliance was placed upon Kendriya
Vidyalaya Sangathan v. S.C. Sharma, AIR 2005 SC 768, and
Managing Director, Balasaheb Desai Sahakari S.K. Ltd. v.
Kashinath Ganapati Kambale, 2009 (1) LLN 770, to contend that the
grant of back wages in the absence of proof of non-employment is
contrary to the settled position of law.
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
35.
On the aforesaid grounds, learned counsel submitted that the
impugned Award is vitiated by errors of law as well as perversity in
appreciation of evidence and, therefore, warrants interference by this
Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction.
On behalf of the Respondent:
36.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Respondent, at the
outset, raised a preliminary objection to the maintainability of the
present writ petition. It was submitted that the petition does not
disclose any jurisdictional error, patent illegality or perversity in the
impugned Award so as to warrant interference under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution of India. According to learned counsel, the
petitioner-Bank, under the guise of invoking the writ jurisdiction of
this Court, merely seeks a re-appreciation of the oral and documentary
evidence already considered by the learned Industrial Tribunal. It was
submitted that such an exercise is wholly impermissible in writ
proceedings, where interference with findings of fact is confined only
to cases where the findings are based on no evidence, suffer from
patent perversity, or are vitiated by jurisdictional error or violation of
the principles of natural justice. In support of the aforesaid
submissions, reliance was placed upon Chandravarkar Sita Ratna
Rao v. Ashalata S. Guram, (1986) Supp SCC 315, and G.M., ONGC,
Silchar v. ONGC Contractual Workers Union, AIR 2008 SCW 3996.
37.
Learned counsel further submitted that the challenge mounted
by the petitioner-Bank to the order dated 28.03.2012, whereby the
domestic enquiry was held to be unfair and improper, is itself belated
and legally impermissible. It was argued that the petitioner never
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
questioned the said order when it came to be passed and, on the
contrary, accepted the same without demur, participated in the
subsequent proceedings before the learned Tribunal, and availed the
opportunity granted to lead independent evidence in support of the
charges. Having consciously elected to prove the charges afresh before
the Tribunal and having failed to do so, it was submitted that the
petitioner cannot now be permitted to reopen the correctness of the
order dated 28.03.2012 merely because the final Award has gone
against it.
38.
On merits, learned counsel submitted that the contention of the
petitioner that the testimony of Sh. S. Rajan and Sh. P.V. Sebastian
was discarded merely because they were employees of the Bank is
factually incorrect and contrary to the record. Drawing attention to
paragraphs 13 to 16 of the impugned Award, learned counsel
submitted that the learned Tribunal has undertaken a detailed
appreciation of their evidence and has assigned cogent reasons for not
accepting the version put forth by the petitioner. It was pointed out
that the complaint allegedly made by Sh. P.V. Sebastian was found to
have been lodged after an unexplained delay, thereby creating doubt
regarding its spontaneity and credibility. It was further observed by the
Tribunal that no independent witness had been examined to
corroborate the alleged incident of misconduct, whereas the material
on record indicated that disturbances in the concerned branch
commenced only after the posting of the aforesaid officials. It was,
therefore, submitted that the findings recorded by the Tribunal are
reasoned findings based upon appreciation of evidence and cannot, by
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
any stretch, be characterised as findings based on no evidence or as
perverse so as to justify interference in writ jurisdiction.
39.
Learned counsel next submitted that the challenge to the
findings recorded in relation to the second charge-sheet is equally
misconceived. It was contended that the learned Tribunal has, at
paragraph 17 of the impugned Award, examined the documentary
evidence in detail, including Ex. WW-1/17 and the connected
documents, and has returned a categorical finding that the account in
question was neither fictitious nor forged. It was submitted that the
Tribunal found that the signatures appearing on the account opening
form and the subsequent closure application were similar and genuine,
and further took note of the fact that the complainants themselves had
withdrawn their complaints. Learned counsel further submitted that the
petitioner-Bank failed to explain the fate of the cheques issued by the
Provident Fund authorities in favour of the alleged account holder,
which circumstance was also considered by the Tribunal while
concluding that the allegations had not been substantiated. It was,
therefore, argued that these are findings resting upon documentary
evidence and cannot be displaced merely because the petitioner seeks
a different appreciation of the material available on record.
40.
Refuting the challenge to the finding of victimisation, learned
counsel submitted that the contention that there were neither pleadings
nor evidence in support thereof is wholly unfounded. It was argued
that the circumstances indicating victimisation emerged from the
evidence led by the parties during the course of the proceedings and
were duly considered by the learned Tribunal while returning its
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
findings. According to learned counsel, the Tribunal found that
repeated allegations unsupported by credible evidence had been
levelled
against
the
Respondent
and
that
the
surrounding
circumstances justified the inference drawn in the impugned Award. It
was further submitted that the decisions relied upon by the petitionerBank, namely Hamdard Dawakhana Wakf (supra) and Bharat Iron
Works(supra), turned upon the peculiar facts and pleadings in those
cases and do not lay down any proposition which would render the
finding recorded by the Tribunal in the present case unsustainable.
41.
Learned counsel further submitted that the contention regarding
non-employment is equally devoid of merit. It was argued that the
Respondent had specifically stated during his cross-examination, as
also in the written submissions filed before the learned Tribunal, that
after his dismissal he remained without any regular employment and
could secure only occasional and casual work for sustenance.
Attention was invited to Annexures P-16 and P-17 filed by the
petitioner itself to demonstrate that such evidence formed part of the
record. It was submitted that once the Respondent had discharged the
initial burden of asserting and deposing regarding his unemployment,
the burden shifted upon the petitioner-Bank to establish gainful
employment by leading rebuttal evidence, which admittedly was never
done.
42.
Learned counsel also opposed the petitioner's challenge to the
relief of reinstatement with continuity of service and consequential
benefits. It was submitted that the petitioner proceeds on an erroneous
premise in comparing the Respondent's past service of approximately
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
four years with the period for which consequential benefits have been
awarded. According to learned counsel, once the dismissal itself has
been held to be illegal and vitiated by victimisation, the Respondent is
entitled to be placed, as far as possible, in the same position in which
he would have continued but for the illegal action of the employer. It
was argued that the relief granted by the learned Tribunal is merely a
consequence flowing from the finding that the dismissal was unlawful
and cannot be characterised as arbitrary or disproportionate merely
because the litigation remained pending for a considerable period.
43.
Learned counsel lastly submitted that the order dated
28.03.2012, holding the domestic enquiry to be unfair and improper, is
itself a detailed and reasoned order which attained finality insofar as
the petitioner-Bank is concerned. It was reiterated that the petitioner
accepted the said order, led fresh evidence before the learned Tribunal
in support of the charges and fully participated in the adjudication on
merits. Having failed to establish the allegations even after being
afforded such opportunity, the petitioner cannot now seek to assail the
said order collaterally in the present writ proceedings. It was,
therefore, submitted that the impugned Award suffers from no legal
infirmity warranting interference under Articles 226 or 227 of the
Constitution and the present petition deserves to be dismissed.
DISCUSSION & ANALYSIS :
44.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
impugned Award, the pleadings and the material placed on record, this
Court finds that the controversy requires consideration at two distinct
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
but interconnected levels. The first concerns the legality and fairness
of the domestic enquiry conducted against the respondent-workman.
The second concerns the manner in which the learned Tribunal, after
permitting the petitioner-management to lead evidence independently
on the charges, appreciated such evidence and arrived at the
conclusion that the misconduct alleged against the respondent had not
been established.
45.
Before proceeding further, it is necessary to bear in mind the
limited scope of judicial review available to this Court in exercise of
jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution. This Court
does not sit as an appellate authority over an Industrial Tribunal and
ordinarily does not substitute its own appreciation of evidence for that
of the Tribunal. However, judicial review is available where the
decision-making process suffers from an error of law, violation of the
principles of natural justice, application of an erroneous legal standard,
or where the conclusions are such as cannot reasonably follow from
the material on record. A finding of fact does not become immune
from judicial review merely because it is described as such, where the
process by which the finding has been arrived at is legally flawed.
46.
In the present case, the learned Tribunal initially proceeded to
examine the fairness of the domestic enquiry as a preliminary issue.
Upon considering the material then available, it concluded that the
enquiry had not been conducted fairly and was violative of the
principles of natural justice. Consequently, the petitioner-management
was granted an opportunity to establish the charges independently by
leading evidence before the Tribunal. The Award records that,
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
pursuant thereto, the management examined Shri S. Rajan, Assistant
General Manager, as MW-3 and Shri P.V. Sebastian as MW-4, while
the respondent examined himself as WW-1.
47.
The first question, therefore, is whether the domestic enquiry
was, in fact, vitiated for violation of the principles of natural justice.
48.
Reliance in this regard can be placed upon the judgment of
Hon’ble the Supreme Court rendered in Sur Enamel and Stamping
Works Ltd. v. Workmen,1963 SCC OnLine SC 97, wherein the
essential ingredients of a domestic enquiry have been laid down. The
relevant extract reads as under:
“4. It has been laid down by this Court in a series of
decisions that if an industrial employee's services
are terminated after a proper Domestic enquiry held
in accordance with the Rules of natural justice and
the conclusions reached at the enquiry are not
perverse the Industrial Tribunal is not entitled to
consider the propriety or the correctness of the said
conclusions. In a number of cases which have come
to this Court in recent months, we find that some
employers have misunderstood the decisions of this
Court to mean that the mere form of an enquiry
would satisfy the requirements of industrial law and
would protect the disciplinary action taken by them
from challenge. This attitude is wholly
misconceived. An enquiry cannot be said to have
been properly held unless, (i) the employee
proceeded against has been informed clearly of the
charges levelled against him, (ii) the witnesses are
examined — ordinarily in the presence of the
employee — in respect of the charges, (iii) the
employee is given a fair opportunity to crossexamine witnesses, (iv) he is given a fair opportunity
to examine witnesses including himself in his
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
defence if he so wishes on any relevant matter, and
(v) the enquiry officer records his findings with
reasons for the same in his report. In the present
case the persons whose statements made behind the
backs of the employees were used by the enquiring
authority were not made available for crossexamination but it would appear that they were not
even present at the enquiry. It does not even appear
that these reports were made available to the
employee at any time before the enquiry was held.
Even if the persons who made the reports had been
present and the employee given an opportunity to
cross-examine them, it would have been difficult to
say in these circumstances that that was a fair and
sufficient opportunity. But in this case it appears
that the persons who made the reports did not attend
the enquiry at all. From whatever aspect the matter
is examined is clear that there was no enquiry worth
the name and the Tribunal was justified in entirely
ignoring the conclusion reached by the Domestic
Tribunal.”
(Emphasis applied)
49.
The requirements of a fair disciplinary enquiry may, for present
purposes, be broadly examined through three essential safeguards.
First, whether the delinquent employee was afforded a reasonable and
adequate opportunity of hearing and of duly representing his case.
Second, whether he was afforded an effective opportunity to crossexamine the witnesses relied upon by the management. Third, whether
the relevant documents and material relied upon in support of the
charges were made available to him so as to enable him to effectively
defend himself.
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
50.
These requirements, however, are not to be tested by importing
into a domestic enquiry the strict procedural requirements applicable
to a criminal trial. A departmental enquiry is essentially a fact-finding
proceeding. What is indispensable is a fair opportunity to meet the
case set up by the management and a fair procedure for determining
the allegations. The delinquent is not entitled to insist upon a particular
procedure or a particular result merely because he disputes the
allegations against him.
51.
Examined from this perspective, the conclusion of the learned
Tribunal that the domestic enquiry was vitiated does not prima facie
appear to be borne out from the enquiry proceedings. The enquiry
report, which was available before the learned Tribunal, indicates that
the respondent was afforded an opportunity to defend himself and was
represented in the proceedings. He was permitted to participate
through his representative, contest the allegations, examine the
material placed before the Enquiry Officer and challenge the evidence
led by the management.
52.
Equally significant is the fact that the management witnesses
were subjected to examination and the respondent was afforded an
opportunity to cross-examine them. The record does not disclose that
the respondent was prevented from putting questions to any
management witness or that a request for cross-examination was
rejected by the Enquiry Officer. There is also no material to establish
that the respondent was prohibited from advancing his defence or from
challenging the documents relied upon by the management.
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
53.
The distinction between denial of an opportunity and failure
to avail an opportunity is fundamental. The principles of natural
justice require the employer to provide a reasonable and effective
opportunity to the delinquent employee. The principles do not require
the Enquiry Officer to compel the delinquent to utilise every
opportunity afforded to him. Where the record demonstrates that an
opportunity was duly provided, but the delinquent chose not to utilise
it, or did not utilise it to the extent he could have, such conduct cannot
subsequently be characterised as a denial of natural justice.
54.
The same principle applies to the documents relied upon by the
management. The respondent was entitled to know the material upon
which the charges were founded and to have an opportunity to
examine and contest such material. The record, however, indicates that
the relevant documents relied upon by the management were produced
before the Enquiry Officer. The respondent was afforded an
opportunity to examine and challenge them. What the respondent was
required to establish was not merely that, in his assessment, the
documents were insufficient to prove the charges, but that relevant
material relied upon against him had not been supplied or that its nonsupply caused prejudice to his defence.
55.
No such demonstrable prejudice is prima facie apparent from
the material before this Court. The respondent's case that the material
was not sufficient to establish the charges goes to the merits of the
charges and not to the fairness of the procedure by which those
charges were enquired into. These two concepts cannot be conflated.
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
56.
The Award records the respondent's allegation that he was not
afforded the opportunity to cross-examine material witnesses and was
not permitted to produce his own witnesses. However, such an
allegation was required to be tested against the actual enquiry
proceedings. A mere assertion that the enquiry was conducted in a
biased, hurried or prejudicial manner cannot, without more, establish
violation of natural justice. There must be a demonstrable denial of
reasonable opportunity or prejudice resulting therefrom.
57.
The charge-sheets themselves also set out the allegations with
sufficient particularity. The first charge-sheet identified the alleged
incident of 04.09.2001, the circumstances concerning allocation of
duties to Ms. Rachna Chandna, the alleged altercation with superior
officers, the alleged unruly conduct and the alleged refusal to obey
instructions. The second charge-sheet specifically referred to the
alleged introduction by the respondent of persons for opening savings
bank accounts and the allegation that such introduction facilitated
impersonation and fraud. Therefore, it would not be incorrect to
observe at this stage that the respondent was thus aware of the case he
was required to meet.
58.
The aforesaid discussion also brings into focus an important
distinction which appears to have been blurred in the proceedings
before the Tribunal viz the validity of the domestic enquiry and the
proof of the charges are two separate questions.
59.
The first concerns the fairness of the procedure adopted against
the delinquent employee i.e., whether he was informed of the
allegations, given reasonable opportunity to represent himself,
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
permitted to cross-examine the management witnesses and afforded
access to the material relied upon against him. The second concerns
the evidentiary question whether the material placed before the
Enquiry Officer is sufficient to establish the misconduct.
60.
A charge may ultimately fail for want of sufficient evidence
even though the enquiry was conducted fairly. Conversely, the fact
that a delinquent employee has been afforded a fair enquiry does not
mean that the charges automatically stand proved. The two questions
cannot be conflated.
61.
In the present case, the learned Tribunal appears to have first
treated the enquiry as procedurally defective without identifying a
demonstrable denial of opportunity and thereafter, while examining
the charges independently, applied an unduly restrictive approach to
the evidence led by the management. The cumulative effect is that the
impugned Award rests materially upon legal standards which cannot
be sustained.
62.
Furthermore, learned counsel for the respondent submits that
the petitioner cannot, at this stage, assail the order whereby the
domestic enquiry was held to be vitiated. The said order was passed by
the Tribunal at an earlier stage of the proceedings and was never
challenged by the petitioner at the appropriate stage or within the time
available to it. On the contrary, the petitioner consciously accepted the
said order, availed the liberty granted by the Tribunal and proceeded to
lead fresh evidence in support of the charges.
63.
This Court finds considerable force in the aforesaid submission.
The petitioner, having consciously elected to accept the order holding
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
the domestic enquiry to be vitiated and having thereafter participated
in the proceedings pursuant to the liberty granted by the Tribunal,
cannot, after having contested the matter on merits and suffered an
adverse Award, seek to reopen the correctness of the said interlocutory
order in proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution. Having
chosen to proceed with the adjudication on the basis of the said order
and having taken its chance before the Tribunal, the petitioner cannot
be permitted to approbate and reprobate by challenging, at this belated
stage, the very foundation upon which it had elected to proceed.
64.
Accordingly, this Court is not inclined to examine the
correctness of the Tribunal’s earlier order whereby the domestic
enquiry was held to be vitiated. The said order, having not been
challenged by the petitioner at the appropriate stage, has attained
finality inter partes for the purposes of the subsequent proceedings.
The scope of the present petition is, therefore, confined to examining
the legality and sustainability of the final Award passed by the
Tribunal on the basis of the proceedings subsequently undertaken
pursuant to the said order. The challenge to the earlier order holding
the domestic enquiry to be vitiated cannot be permitted to be
introduced collaterally in the present proceedings against the final
Award.
65.
Additionally, the finding of the learned Tribunal that the
domestic enquiry was vitiated on account of violation of natural
justice, therefore, prima facie is not just, but the said finding, having
been accepted while leading evidence to prove the misconduct of the
Respondent, cannot now be re-agitated or reconsidered by this Court.
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
66.
This brings the Court to the second aspect, namely, the manner
in which the learned Tribunal appreciated the evidence after granting
the petitioner-management an opportunity to establish the charges
independently. It is at this stage that the reasoning in the impugned
Award requires closer examination.
67.
In respect of the first charge-sheet, the management examined
Shri S. Rajan as MW-3 and Shri P.V. Sebastian as MW-4. The Award
records that MW-3 stated that the incident dated 04.09.2001 took place
within his view and that he was present in the branch. He attributed the
commotion to the respondent and Ms. Rachna Chandna. The Award
further records that MW-4 deposed regarding the incident and the
surrounding circumstances, although in cross-examination he clarified
that the actual incident had not taken place in his presence.
68.
Upon a careful perusal of the evidence available on record, this
Court finds that the Tribunal has failed to duly appreciate the presence
and involvement of MW-4 in the incident in question. The record does
not support the Tribunal’s observation that the incident did not take
place in the presence of MW-4. On the contrary, MW-4 was himself
directly involved in the incident. It was his oral directions regarding
allocation of work that the workmen allegedly refused to comply with,
whereafter MW-4, the Manager (Administration), came with the
printed orders relating to the allocation of work. Thus, MW-4 was not
a mere witness to the incident but was himself the person against
whom the alleged altercation had taken place and, in that sense, was
the immediate complainant. The Tribunal’s observation regarding the
presence and involvement of MW-4, therefore, does not appear to
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
have been arrived at upon a proper consideration of the evidence on
record and cannot, for this reason, be sustained.
69.
The learned Tribunal nevertheless attached considerable
significance to the fact that no independent witness had been
produced. It further treated the complaint made by MW-4 on
06.09.2001 in respect of the incident of 04.09.2001 as an act of
afterthought and took note of the fact that, according to the evidence,
there existed considerable tension between the Bank management and
the employees' union. The Tribunal also noticed that no subordinate
employee had made a complaint regarding the alleged misconduct.
70.
In the opinion of this Court, these circumstances could certainly
have been considered while assessing the weight of the evidence, but
they could not have been converted into legal presumptions against the
management. There is no rule of law that testimony of a management
witness must necessarily be corroborated by an independent witness
before it can be relied upon.
71.
The mere fact that a witness is an officer or employee of the
management does not, by itself, render him an "interested witness"
whose testimony is liable to be discarded. The correct approach is to
examine the testimony on its own merits, consider its consistency, test
it in cross-examination, examine the surrounding circumstances and
determine whether the witness has any demonstrated reason to falsely
implicate the delinquent employee.
72.
Reliance in this regard can be placed upon the judgment of
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in State of Haryana v. Rattan Singh,
(1977) 2 SCC 491, wherein, the Supreme Court upheld a domestic
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
enquiry finding a bus conductor guilty of not issuing tickets, based
solely on the checking inspector's report and testimony, without
examining the passengers concerned. The Apex Court held that
domestic enquiries are not bound by the strict rules of the Evidence
Act, and any material logically probative to a prudent mind including
hearsay with reasonable nexus and credibility is admissible. The mere
absence of independent corroboration from passenger-witnesses does
not vitiate an otherwise credible finding based on the sole testimony of
an interested departmental witness. The relevant paragraph is extracted
below:
“4. It is well settled that in a domestic enquiry the
strict and sophisticated rules of evidence under the
Indian Evidence Act may not apply. All materials
which are logically probative for a prudent mind are
permissible. There is no allergy to hearsay evidence
provided it has reasonable nexus and credibility. It
is true that departmental authorities and
Administrative Tribunals must be careful in
evaluating such material and should not glibly
swallow what is strictly speaking not relevant under
the Indian Evidence Act. For this proposition it is
not necessary to cite decisions nor text books,
although we have been taken through case-law and
other authorities by counsel on both sides. The
essence of a judicial approach is objectivity,
exclusion of extraneous materials or considerations
and observance of rules of natural justice. Of
course, fairplay is the basis and if perversity or
arbitrariness, bias or surrender of independence of
judgment vitiate the conclusions reached, such
finding, even though of a domestic tribunal, cannot
be held good. However, the courts below
misdirected themselves, perhaps, in insisting that
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
passengers who had come in and gone out should be
chased and brought before the tribunal before a
valid finding could be recorded. The ‘residuum’ rule
to which counsel for the respondent referred, based
upon certain passages from American Jurisprudence
does not go to that extent nor does the passage from
Halsbury insist on such rigid requirement. The
simple point is, was there some evidence or was
there no evidence — not in the sense of the technical
rules governing regular court proceedings but in a
fair commonsense way as men of understanding and
worldly wisdom will accept. Viewed in this way,
sufficiency of evidence in proof of the finding by a
domestic tribunal is beyond scrutiny. Absence of any
evidence in support of a finding is certainly
available for the court to look into because it
amounts to an error of law apparent on the record.
We find, in this case, that the evidence of
Chamanlal, Inspector of the Flying Squad, is some
evidence which has relevance to the charge levelled
against the respondent. Therefore, we are unable to
hold that the order is invalid on that ground.”
(emphasis applied)
73.
Additionally, the learned Tribunal's approach becomes
particularly difficult to sustain when considered against the evidence
of the respondent himself. The respondent chose to examine himself as
WW-1 in rebuttal. His evidence was naturally directed towards
establishing his own defence and denying the allegations levelled
against him. His direct interest in the outcome did not render his
testimony inadmissible or incapable of consideration. The same
principle necessarily applies to the evidence led by the management.
74.
In other words, if the testimony of the respondent could be
evaluated despite his direct interest in the outcome of the proceedings,
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
the testimony of the management witnesses could not be rejected
merely because they were officers of the Bank. The evidence of both
sides was required to be subjected to the same test of credibility and
reliability.
75.
The absence of an independent witness may, in an appropriate
case, be a circumstance relevant to the weight of the evidence. It
cannot, however, be elevated into an inflexible rule that an allegation
of misconduct within a workplace must fail in the absence of an
independent third-party witness as has also been held in Rattan Singh
(supra). Moreover, workplace incidents ordinarily take place in the
presence of co-employees and officers of the employer. The mere fact
that such witnesses are employees of the employer does not render
their evidence legally incapable of consideration.
76.
Similarly, the fact that the complaint was made two days after
the incident could be considered as a circumstance affecting
credibility, but a delay of two days cannot, without examination of the
surrounding circumstances, automatically render the complaint an
afterthought. The Tribunal was required to determine what
significance, if any, should be attached to such delay in the totality of
the evidence.
77.
The same applies to the alleged tension between the
management and the employees' union. The existence of tension may
justify a more careful scrutiny of the evidence, but it cannot itself
prima facie establish that the management witnesses had falsely
implicated the respondent. The Tribunal was required to assess
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
whether the allegations were supported by the evidence and whether
the witnesses had been materially shaken in cross-examination.
78.
The approach adopted by the Tribunal thus suffers from an error
of principle. It did not merely prefer one version of facts over another;
it attached an impermissible legal consequence to the status of the
management witnesses and to the absence of independent witnesses.
The evidentiary worth of the testimony had to be determined on its
intrinsic merits.
79.
The same issue arises, though in a somewhat different form, in
relation to the second charge-sheet. The learned Tribunal concluded
that there was no evidence worth the name to establish that the
respondent had fabricated any account. It relied upon Ex. WW-1/7, the
withdrawal of complaints, the alleged silence of the management
regarding the PF cheques, the similarity of signatures on the accountopening and closure documents and the fact that the relevant
documents contained identity cards and other particulars. The Tribunal
consequently concluded that the accounts were genuine and that there
was no role played by the respondent in their opening or closure.
80.
The Tribunal was undoubtedly required to examine this
documentary evidence. However, in doing so, it appears to have
approached the charge substantially from the standpoint of
establishing the criminal offences of forgery and cheating. The chargesheet, as reproduced in the Award, alleged that the respondent had
introduced persons for opening accounts and, by doing so, had
facilitated impersonation and fraud and acted prejudicially to the
interests of the Bank. The question before the Tribunal was whether
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
the misconduct specified in the charge-sheet stood established on the
standard applicable to a departmental proceeding.
81.
The standard applicable to a domestic disciplinary proceeding is
not that of proof beyond reasonable doubt. The Tribunal itself
correctly recognised this position in the Award. Yet, while considering
the second charge, it observed that evidence regarding forgery or
cheating must be cogent and clear and proceeded to examine the
matter substantially as though the management was required to
establish a criminal case.
82.
The question, therefore, was not simply whether the Bank had
proved that a criminal offence of forgery or cheating had been
committed. The relevant inquiry was whether, on the evidence
available, the respondent's conduct in introducing the account-holders
and the surrounding circumstances established the particular acts of
misconduct alleged against him.
83.
The Tribunal was entitled to take into account the subsequent
withdrawal of complaints, the similarity of signatures, the documents
accompanying the account-opening forms and the fact that the
accounts were subsequently closed. But these circumstances were
required to be weighed against the entire evidence concerning the
respondent's role as introducer, the allegations concerning the identity
of the account-holders, the PF cheques and the explanation furnished
by the respondent.
84.
Similarly, the absence of the alleged aggrieved account-holder
as a witness could be considered while evaluating the weight of the
management's case, but it could not be treated as an indispensable
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
legal requirement for proof of departmental misconduct. Nor could the
fact that the alleged fraud was detected at an early stage, or that the
Bank did not initiate criminal action against the account-holders, by
itself conclusively establish that the respondent had no role in the
conduct alleged against him.
85.
The Tribunal was therefore required to consider whether the
totality of the evidence, viewed on the applicable standard of
preponderance of probabilities, established the misconduct alleged.
The approach of testing the allegations as though the Bank were
required to prove criminal offences of forgery and cheating beyond
reasonable doubt was legally erroneous.
86.
More importantly, this Court has found that the foundational
conclusion regarding violation of natural justice is itself prima facie
unsustainable. Participation by the petitioner in the subsequent
proceedings, while relevant to the procedural history of the case,
cannot prevent this Court from examining whether the final Award has
been rendered on an erroneous legal foundation.
87.
At the same time, this Court does not consider it appropriate to
itself determine whether the respondent is guilty of either of the
charges. The exercise of jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 does
not warrant this Court substituting its own appreciation of the entire
evidence for that of the Industrial Tribunal, particularly when the
Tribunal has not considered the evidence in accordance with the
correct legal principles identified herein.
88.
Once this Court is of the opinion that the observation of the
Tribunal holding the domestic enquiry to be vitiated is prima facie
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
unsustainable and that the findings on the merits have also been
arrived at by applying erroneous standards to the evidence on record,
the direction for reinstatement with continuity of service and
consequential benefits cannot be permitted to stand.
89.
The question of proportionality of punishment, reinstatement,
continuity of service, consequential benefits and back wages would
necessarily depend upon the ultimate determination as to whether the
charges are established and whether the punishment imposed by the
management is legally sustainable. These questions are, therefore, best
left open for consideration by the learned Tribunal upon fresh
adjudication.
90.
This Court is also not inclined to examine at this stage the
competing
submissions
regarding
the
respondent's
alleged
unemployment and the burden relating to back wages. Those questions
would become relevant only after the legality of the dismissal is
finally determined.
91.
In these circumstances, the appropriate course is not to finally
determine the charges in writ jurisdiction but to set aside the impugned
Award and remit the matter to the learned Tribunal for fresh
adjudication. Such a remand would ensure that the respondent's
defence is fully considered while simultaneously ensuring that the
petitioner-management's evidence is assessed without applying an
erroneous legal standard.
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
CONCLUSION:
92.
For the reasons recorded hereinabove, this Court is of the
considered view that the learned Tribunal did not properly appreciate
the settled principles governing departmental enquiries while holding
the domestic enquiry to be vitiated on the ground of violation of the
principles of natural justice. However, no opinion is being expressed
on the correctness of the order dated 28.03.2012, whereby the
domestic enquiry was held to be vitiated, as the said order was not
challenged by the petitioner at the appropriate stage and has, therefore,
attained finality.
93.
The learned Tribunal further fell into error in its approach to the
evidence led by the management. The mere fact that MW-3 and MW-4
were officers of the petitioner-Bank did not render their testimony
inherently unreliable or incapable of being relied upon. The absence of
independent witnesses, the delay in lodging the complaint, or the
existence of tension between the management and the union in the
absence of direct evidence
could be relevant circumstances for
assessing the weight of the evidence, but none could constitute an
inflexible rule requiring rejection of the management's case.
94.
In particular, the evidence of MW-3, who according to the
Award, claimed to have been present at the incident of 04.09.2001,
required assessment on its own merits. Similarly, in relation to the
second charge-sheet, the documentary evidence concerning the
accounts, the account-opening and closure forms, the complaints and
their withdrawal, and the alleged PF cheques required consideration in
their entirety and on the standard applicable to a departmental
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
proceeding, rather than by importing the standard applicable to proof
of criminal offences of forgery or cheating.
95.
The learned Tribunal was required to maintain a clear
distinction between the fairness of the domestic enquiry and the
sufficiency of evidence to establish the charges. The two inquiries
having been materially conflated, the impugned Award cannot be
sustained.
96.
Accordingly, the impugned Award dated 22.05.2017 passed by
the learned Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour
Court-I, Delhi, in I.D. No.147/2003 is set aside.
97.
The matter is remanded to the learned Tribunal for fresh
adjudication in accordance with law. The learned Tribunal shall
reconsider the reference afresh, keeping in view the observations
contained in the present judgment. It shall assess the evidence of the
management witnesses on its intrinsic merits and shall not reject their
testimony merely because they are employees or officers of the
petitioner-Bank. At the same time, it shall remain free to scrutinise
their evidence with due care, consider the effect of cross-examination,
the contemporaneous documents and all relevant surrounding
circumstances.
98.
The learned Tribunal shall thereafter determine, in accordance
with law, whether the charges stand established and, depending upon
such determination, whether the order of dismissal is just, fair and
legal. The consequential questions concerning proportionality of
punishment, reinstatement, continuity of service, consequential
benefits and back wages shall also be considered, if they arise.
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
99.
It is clarified that this Court has not expressed any final opinion
on the merits of either of the charges, the allegation of victimisation,
or the quantum and nature of relief to which the respondent may
ultimately be entitled. The observations contained herein are confined
to the legal errors in the approach adopted by the learned Tribunal and
shall not be construed as a finding either of guilt or innocence.
100. Considering the considerable period for which the industrial
dispute has remained pending, the learned Tribunal is requested to
endeavour to dispose of the reference expeditiously, preferably within
a period of six months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment.
101. The writ petition is accordingly allowed in the aforesaid terms.
Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
102. There shall be no order as to costs.
SHAIL JAIN
JUDGE
AUGUST 4, 2026
hp
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
17:02:27
W.P.(C) 10502/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review