Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
%
!
"
&
' !
#
#$
!
#
( &
)
( &
)
*
*
!
"
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
#
#
$
%
& ' %()
)
&
#
& ' %(%
& ' %()
!
"
#
$
-2-
))
))*
$
)* %) )(%
)
)(%
)* %) )(%
)
+
$
*
"
#
#
$
%
& ' %()
)
&
#
& ' %(%
& ' %()
"
#
$
&
-3-
))
))*
$
)*&%)&)(%
),
)(%
)* %) )(%
)
+
$
- .
/
0121 314545672 891 :5;1< => 401 31454567192 211?57@ 46
AB820
62 )
69<192
<841<
6C<>20114
),
6C<>20114
D5<1
771EB91&
)* %) )(%
=18957@
)(%
)(%
38221< => 912367<174
87<
6)
-4-
)
4 52 401 F821 6: 401 31454567192 4084 401> 891 401
=B257122G17 9125<57@ 84
8;8=B98@5
C954417 8 ;14419 46 912367<174
12367<174
6 ) 17BG198457@ 401
<1485;2 6: 401 F821 91@524191< 8@85724 401 31454567192
B92B874 46 4084 912367<174
6 ) 9154198457@ 401 F6741742
6: 401 ;14419 248457@ 4084 401 31454567192 C540 40159
2B33694192 891
5745G5<8457@
4091841757@
87<
217<57@
C967@ G1228@12 46 401 3B=;5F 87< 8F457@ 57 @96B32 87<
<524B9=57@ ;8C 87< 69<19 57 401 D5;;8@12
91@524191< 8@85724 401 31454567192 57
484567 57
B7<19
95G1
6 ) I )(%
1F45672 %,
() 918< C540
%,*
17F1 8 F821 52
484567
8H89
6;5F1
:69 401 6::17F12 3B75208=;1
)
),
,%
(,
(
87<
1F4567 %,I 6:
821< 67 401 91@524984567 6: 401 F95G1 87< :5;57@
6: 401 F089@1 20114 912367<174
91F6GG17<1<
31454567192 019157
96C<>
7231F469 6:
20114
8@85724
821< 67 C05F0 912367<174
6;5F1
6 ) 082
38221< 401 69<192 57F;B<57@ 401 78G12 6: 401 31454567192
=> 631757@ 96C<> 201142 8@85724 401G 57 401 91@52419
-5-
<841< )* %) )(%
95G1
82 401 31454567192 C191 57D6;D1< 57
6 ) I )(%
,
F67417<1<
=>
F6B721;
:69
31454567192 4084 401 31454567192 08D1 =117 8FAB5441< 57
1225672
6 '' )(%*
895257@
6 ) I )(%
C8> =8F? 67 )* (% )(%'
6B4
6:
95G1
123541 C05F0 401
31454567192. 78G12 891 57F;B<1< 57 401 96C<> 201142 87<
401> 891 2BGG671< 46 401 36;5F1 2484567 45G1 87< 8@857
C5406B4 87> 918267 C084261D19 5;;1@8;;> 87< F674989> 46
401 396D525672 6:
897848?8 6;5F1
9<19
87B8;
62 %( ' 87< %( I 6: 401
4 52 8;26 F67417<1< 4084 76 206C
F8B21 7645F1 52 522B1< 87< G191;> 67 401 =8252 6: 87 189;519
F95G1 7BG=19 401 78G12 6: 401 31454567192 891 57F;B<1< 57
96C<>
201142
0191:691
31454567192
913912174845672
(
:69 91D51C57@ 401 5G3B@71< 69<192 87< 46
)()
912367<174
G8<1
91231F45D1
(
6%
<1;141 40159 78G12 :96G 401 96C<> 201142 82 401> 08D1
=117 8FAB5441< 57 401 F821 =821< 67 C05F0 40159 78G12
-6-
C191 57F;B<1< 57 401 96C<> 201142
F6725<191< => 912367<174
01 28G1 082 764 =117
6%
4 52 F67417<1< 4084 C017 401 31454567192 G8<1
833;5F845672 69 913912174845672 401 912367<174 8B406954512
6B@04 46 08D1 8FF1341< 401 913912174845672 87< 396D5<1<
87 633694B754> 46 401 31454567192 46 3B4 :6940 40159 F821 6:
40191 =157@ 76 8;;1@84567 6: F95G578; F8212 317<57@ 8@85724
401G 87< 4084 57F;B2567 6: 40159 78G12 87< F67457B57@
40159 78G12 57 401
6C<>
1@524192 52 D56;845D1 6:
401 3957F53;12 6: 784B98; JB245F1 57F;B<57@ 40159 3192678;
;5=194>
4 52 8;26 F67417<1< 4084 57 23541 6: 401
31454567192 =157@ 8FAB5441< 57 401 F821 4084 C82 :5;1<
8@85724 401G 87< <123541 401 913912174845672 =157@ G8<1
401 31454567192. 78G12 891 764 249BF? 6:: :96G 401 91@524192
6: 96C<512 40191=> F8B257@ B746;< 089<2053 87< D56;84567
6: 40159 :B7<8G1748; 95@04 6: :911 G6D1G174 87< 40159
;5=194>
-7-
*
4 52 8;26 F67417<1< => 401 ;18971< F6B721; 4084
912367<1742 08D1 764 :6;;6C1< 401 71F12289> @B5<1;5712
;85< <6C7 => 4052
6B94 57 401 F821 6:
9136941< 57
! "
0191:691 01 F67417<2 4084 5G3;5F8457@ 401
31454567192 87< 91@5241957@ 40159 78G12 57 401 96C<>
201142 52 5;;1@8; 87< D56;845D1 6: 3957F53;12 6: 784B98;
JB245F1
17F1 401 78G12 6: 401 31454567192 91AB591 46 =1
91G6D1< 87< F6721AB174;> 401 285< 69<192 =1 AB8201<
17F1
401 31454567192 891 319:69F1< 46 833968F0 4052
6B94 57D6?57@ 401 C954 JB952<5F4567
'
<D6F841
;18971<
91391217457@
<<545678;
912367<174& 4841
6D197G174
8<G542
8FAB5448; 6: 401 31454567192 57 401 8:691285< F95G578; F821
87< 67 D195:5F84567 87< 8:419 48?57@ 57249BF45672 2B=G542
4084 401 31454567192. 78G12 891 245;; F67457B57@ 57 401
96C<> 201142
57F;B<1< 57 401
=B4 401 78G12 6: 401 31454567192 C191
6C<>
1@524192 39569 46 8FAB5448;
87< 8;26 AB124567 6: :6;;6C57@ 401 @B5<1;5712 ;85< <6C7 =>
-8-
6&69<57841
17F0 6: 4052
6B94 57 401 F821 6:
"2B398$ C6B;< 764 89521 :69 401 918267 4084
57F;B2567 6: 401 78G12 6: 401 31454567192 57 401
1@524192 52 39569 46 401 285< JB<@G174
28G1 C5;; 764 17B91 46 40159 =171:54
6C<>
17F1 401
FF69<57@;> 01 211?2
46 <52G522 401 314545672
I
08D1 0189< ;18971< F6B721; :69 401 31454567192
87< ;18971<
%(
<<545678;
6D197G174
<D6F841 :69 401
4 52 8 :B7<8G1748; 9B;1 6: ;8C 4084 C017 8
319267 52 5G3;5F841< 82 8 96C<> 2011419 => 57F;B<57@ 052
78G1 57 401 ;524 6: 96C<> 20114 401 67B2 52 B367 401
46 :6;;6C 401 <B1 396F1<B91 F6741G3;841< B7<19 401
91;1D874 9B;12 87< 91@B;845672
897848?8
6;5F1
7 401 3912174 F821 401
87B8; G691 231F5:5F8;;> 401
6C<512 G85748571< 57 69<19
1@52419 6:
6 %( I C05F0 <18;2 C540
052469> 201142 87< 96C<> 201142 87< 1796;;G174 69
91@524984567 6: 3192672 57 401 285< 20114 :69 91@52419 :69
F67457B6B2 G67546957@ => 401 36;5F1 8B406954512
:6;;6C1<
487<57@
9<19
52 764
6 %( I <18;2 C540 91@524984567
-9-
6: 96C<512
01 <1:5754567 396D5<1< 52 4084 8 96C<> G8> =1
<1:571< 82 8 @B7<8 87< 57F;B<12 8 066;5@87
46B@0
D8@8=67< 69 87> 319267 C06 52 <87@196B2 46 3B=;5F 318F1
87< 4987AB5;54>
0191 891 G87> :69G2 6: 96C<52G C05F0
891 <12F95=1< 4019157 87< 401 396F122 87< 396F1<B91
F6741G3;841< 46 =1 G85748571< 57 <5::19174 38942 78G1;>
87<
C05F0 @6D197 401 G85741787F1
6: 8 91@52419 87< 401 78G12 6: 401 96C<512 57 40159
91231F45D1 38942
4 52 401 <B4> 87< 6=;5@84567 F824 B367
401 912367<1742 C05F0 52 764 6345678; 46 :6;;6C 401 <B1
396F1<B91 F6741G3;841< B7<19 401 2487<57@ 69<192 6: 401
897848?8
319267
6;5F1
87B8;
96C<>
C05;1 1741957@ 401 78G1 6: 8
20114
87<
40191
F194857
396F1<B912 46 =1 G87<84695;> :6;;6C1< =1:691 1741957@ 401
78G12
31454567192
F67417<1<
=>
;18971<
F6B721;
:69
401 396F122 87< 396F1<B91 82 F6741G3;841<
B7<19 401 2487<57@
9<19
6 %( I 6: 401
897848?8
6;5F1
87B8; 082 764 =117 :6;;6C1< 87< 76 633694B754> C82
@5D17 46 401 31454567192 46 :5;1 40159 913;> 69 1E3;8784567 :69
- 10 -
91G6D57@ 40159 78G12 57 401
6C<>
1@524192 87<
G191;> =1F8B21 401> C191 57D6;D1< 57 F95G578; F821 57
C05F0 8;26 401 31454567192 08D1 =117 8FAB5441< 57 401 >189
)(%'
4 52 8;26 F67417<1< 4084 406B@0 401 31454567192 08D1
G8<1 913912174845672 46 401 912367<174 8B406954512 8:419
401 8FAB5448; 67 (
(
)()
401 913912174845672 08D1 764
=117 F6725<191< 87< 1D17 8:419 401 8FAB5448; 401> 08D1
=117 2BGG671< 46 401 JB952<5F45678; 36;5F1 2484567 :69
B771F12289> 5741996@84567 C017 40191 52 76 F821 317<57@
8@85724 401G
%%
4 C6B;< =1 91;1D874 46 1E498F4 3898@9830
6: 401 JB<@G174 6:
6:
#
#$
9136941< 57 ()
5D52567
% &'
**
17F0 6: 4052
6 %*
6B94 57 401 F821
'
+
C019157 401
5D52567
17F0 <18;4 C540 25G5;89 2B=J1F4 G84419 C05F0 918<2 82
B7<19
- 11 -
!
"
#
#
%
&'(
$
#
)
$
%
)
#
* )
$
&'(
#
+
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
#
)
)
)
)
,
)
#
-
K
%)
487<57@
9<19
6 %( I 6:
897848?8
6;5F1
87B8; %II' 52 1E498F41< =1;6C
&'( . / 0
#
)
)
.2/
3+
/
!
,
/ 6
#
)
)
#
/
)
,
- 12 -
/
!
)
)
)
+
+
)
))
/*
,
,
/
,
/
.7/ 6
#
#9
)
;
%
:
.</ . / %
&&
)
#
)
)
)
. / %
)
)
=
8"
:
)
#
)
. / %
)
>% #
>
+
.'/
$
+* #
)
$
#
.?/ %
)
!
)
:
)
- 13 -
. / @
)
#
)
#
)
$
.A/
#
)
)
)
)
)
)
"
)
*
)
)
.(/ $
"
*
#
)
#
#
:
)
)
"
)
*
* $
#
#
. &/
)
#
)
#
#
.
)
/ @
)
#
+
$
!
8:8
)
)
$
!
- 14 -
. 2/ @
+
8:8
@
)
!
$
. 7/ %
8:8
)
!
)
)
)
+* #
. </
$
)
+
)
)
)
. '/ B
!
)
C
./
)
!
#
. /
))
)
2(<
4 .
/,
. /
#
!
(2 . / .)/ .1/
. /
D
!
- 15 -
(?7
)
#
. #/ 0
C
#
&A . /
,
.#/ 0
& 4
.# / 0
&4
.# / 0
,
)
# / EC
'?
#
#
)
D
''
!
. C/ 0
(?7,
'&( 6
# +
. ?/ E#
)
E
"
:
)
)
#
+
)
+ +
#
)
)
!
)
+
.
/ @
#
$
)
)
"
#
#
. A/
)
&?
)
3+
/
2/ %
%
)
- 16 -
7/ 5
)
)
</ %
)
'/
?/ $
F
/%
A/
!
. (/ 6
)
)
#
)
)
#
!
%
)
6&69<57841
6:
-
17F0 6: 4052
6B94 57 401 F821
"2B398$ 082 ;85< <6C7 @B5<1;5712
C05F0 891 46 =1 :6;;6C1< C05;1 91@5241957@ 401 78G1 6: 8
319267 57 401
6C<>
1@52419 C05F0 1D17 39569 46
401 285< JB<@G174 C82 8 G87<841 :69 401 912367<1742 46
08D1 :6;;6C1< 2495F4;> 57 8FF69<87F1 46 401 2487<57@ 69<19
6 %( I 6: 401
6357567
897848?8
6;5F1
87B8;
C05F0 57 G>
F6725<1957@ 401 :8F42 87< F59FBG2487F1 6: 401
3912174 F8212 082 764 =117 :6;;6C1< 87< 1D17 8:419 401
8FAB5448;
6:
31454567192
87<
1D17
8:419
- 17 -
913912174845672 @5D17 => 401 31454567192 :69 91G6D57@ 40159
78G12 :96G 401
6C<>
1@524192
40191 52 76
91236721 69 913;> 69 8F4567 => 401 912367<1742 57
91G6D57@ 40159 78G12
%,
7 D51C 6: 767&F6G3;587F1 6: 401 396F1<B91
F6741G3;841<
897848?8
B7<19
6;5F1
2487<57@
69<19
6 %( I
6:
87B8; 87< 767&F6725<1984567 6: 401
913912174845672 @5D17 => 401 31454567192 3B92B874 46 40159
8FAB5448; 4052
6B94 52 6: 401 6357567 4084 401 31454567192
08D1 G8<1 6B4 8 D8;5< F821 46 F6725<19 :8D6B98=;>
%
FF69<57@;>
3822 401 :6;;6C57@
954 14545672 891
,, %
01 5G3B@71< 69<192 <841< )* %) )(%
91@89<57@ 631757@
6C<>
1@524192
57 401 78G12 6: 401 31454567192 =18957@
6)
),
6C<>20114
6C<>20114
912367<174
)(%
)(%
87<
38221<
6 ) 891 0191=> AB8201<
=>
- 18 -
01 912367<1742 891 0191=> <591F41< 46
91G6D1 401 78G12 6: 401 31454567192 :96G
6C<>
1@524192 G85748571< =>
401G C54057 8 31956< 6: :6B9 C11?2 :96G
401 <841 6: 91F1534 6: F1945:51< F63> 6: 401
69<19
5D
5=194>
06C1D19
912367<174
91219D1<
4841 46 396F11< 57 8FF69<87F1
C540 ;8C 8@85724 401 31454567192 5: 84 8;; 87>
F821 52 G8<1 6B4 87< C05;1 <657@ 26 401>
208;; 2495F4;> :6;;6C 401 @B5<1;5712 ;85< <6C7
=> 4052
6B94 57 401 F821 6:
9136941< 57
(
,
;
%
! "
!+*
!
'
#
)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review