Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision : 09.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 290/2026 & CM APPL. 1391/2026
EX SEA II UW RAHUL KUMAR SARASWAT .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ajit Kakkar and Mr. Tejas
Bhonge, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Brijesh Kr. Tamber, CGSC with
Ms. Arani Mukherjee, Mr. Prateek
Kushwaha, Mr. Vinay Singh Bist and
Mr. Aryan Data, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J. (ORAL)
CM APPL. 1391/2026
1.
Allowed, subject to just exceptions.
2.
The application is disposed of.
W.P.(C) 290/2026
3.
This petition lays a challenge to an order dated 12.09.2025 passed by
the Armed Forces Tribunal at New Delhi (Principal Bench) in O.A.
3999/2023 filed by the petitioner, whereby the Tribunal has dismissed the
O.A. by stating in paragraph 6 onwards as under:
“6. As reproduced hereinabove Regulation 278(1) of the
Regulations for the Navy permits the Commanding Officer to
discharge a sailor who is mentally or physically unfit or who is
incompetent to perform duties. On account of physical condition,
inefficiency or professional incompetency such a sailor can be
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:14.01.2026 12:50
W.P.(C) 290/2026
discharged if found unsuitable. Admittedly from the material
available on record it is clear that the applicant after joining
duties in February 2016 was not able to clear the swimming test.
It was only on 31.08.2021 i.e. after five years of joining service
and more than a year and a half after the issuance of the show
cause notice Annexure A3 dated 27.03.2020 that he cleared the
examination.
7. From the counter affidavit and the documents filed by the
respondents particularly Annexure R11 dated 14.05.2018 it is
evident that the applicant was counselled for failing to clear the
swimming test. He was repeatedly counselled with regard to his
fear of water and inability to swim. Annexures R11 to R20 are
communications relating to counselling and advice given to the
applicant on his swimming ability, non-passing of the swimming
test, suicidal tendencies and acts of self-harm, casual attitude
towards work, absence from place of duty on various occasions,
unauthorized use of mobile phone during working hours,
reluctance in discharging duties, lack of organisational or
professional knowledge and below-average conduct in
performance of duties. With specific reference to non-clearance of
the swimming test counselling was given not only in 2018 but also
in 2019 (Annexure R15), 2020 (Annexure R17) and again in
March 2020 (Annexure R20). The overwhelming documentary
evidence adduced by the respondents indicates that the applicant
was not performing his duties and that his conduct was
unbecoming of a member of the Armed Forces. He did not clear
the swimming lest for nearly five years and even the PQ test wascleared only after the show cause notice was issued.
8. Taking note of all these factors the documents clearly indicate
that after affording him repeated opportunities, including
counselling and advice for more than 4 ½ years and when no
improvement was shown the respondents treated him as an
unsuitable sailor and proceeded to take action under Regulation
278. In our considered view the applicant being a member of a
disciplined Force such as the Indian Navy was required to
perform duties onboard ships where clearing the swimming test is
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:14.01.2026 12:50
W.P.(C) 290/2026
of paramount importance. Not only did the applicant fail to clear
the test for early five years after entry into service but he also
consistently exhibited reluctance, inability and fear of entering the
water. These are factors of critical importance and a sailor cannot
be permitted to be retained in service with such shortcomings. The
applicant's conduct also clearly indicates reluctance in
performing duties while citing physical ailments and family
problems as excuses to remain absent from duty on various
occasions. In this background the respondents analysed the
applicant's work and shortcomings for a period of about five
years, repeatedly counselled and advised him and when no
improvement was forthcoming discharged him from service upon
being satisfied that he was unfit to serve as a sailor in the Navy.
9. The subjective satisfaction arrived at by the competent authority
in assessing the applicant's work and thereafter discharging him
in accordance with Regulation 278(1) in our considered view is a
fair, reasonable and justifiable action based on the facts and
circumstances. A member of the Armed Forces is expected to be fit
in all respects both mentally and physically and to be capable of
performing the onerous duties attached to service conditions. If
the competent authority finds a person unsuitable for retention in
the Force the subjective satisfaction so arrived at in the absence
of bias, mala fides, ill motive or violation of statutory rules cannot
be interfered with by this Tribunal on sympathetic considerations.
In the present case based on the material on record and the
analysis as detailed hereinabove we find that the competent
authority has taken the decision after due evaluation of all
relevant material. The assessment being in accordance with law
we cannot sit in appeal over the same and take a different view.
10. As far as the ground that the show cause notice was issued by
an incompetent authority is concerned it is of no consequence.
This is because the entire material on the basis of which the show
cause notice was issued along with the reply to it and all other
relevant records was placed before the competent authority viz.
the Commanding Officer, the statutory authority empowered to
take action in the matter. That authority after evaluating each and
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:14.01.2026 12:50
W.P.(C) 290/2026
every aspect has taken a conscious decision as demonstrated by
the respondents through their counter affidavit and the
overwhelming documents filed.
11. Furthermore in his rejoinder (Paragraphs 2 to 5) the
applicant himself admits to the shortcomings but attempts to
explain them on the ground of personal health issues and family
problems. In our considered view in the totality of the facts and
circumstances and for the reasons discussed hereinabove the
action taken against the applicant is in accordance with law. The
respondents have adopted a fair and reasonable approach in
dealing with his case and there is no reason for this Tribunal to
interfere, particularly in a case involving the discharge of a man
in uniform who has been found unfit for retention on account of
the numerous shortcomings detailed in this order.
12. Accordingly, finding no merit, we dismiss the application, 12.
without any order as to costs.”
4.
The facts to be noted from the petition are that the petitioner was
enrolled in the Indian Navy on 16.02.2016 as a Senior Secondary Recruit
(SSR) with the basic date of engagement as 22.02.2016 for a period of 16
years, which was to end on 28.06.2031. He was discharged from service
vide order dated 22.04.2022.
5.
The case of the respondents is that the same is in accordance with the
provisions of regulation 278 of the Regulations for the Navy Part III
(Statutory). The record shows that a show cause notice dated 27.03.2020
was issued to the petitioner, wherein the following was alleged:
“4(a) You have not passed your mandatory swimming test since
your induction into Indian Navy on 22 Feb 2016. Despite
adequate opportunities provided by the ship towards improving
your swimming skill, you have not passed your basic swimming
test in four years of service and, therefore, failed to be promoted
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:14.01.2026 12:50
W.P.(C) 290/2026
to the next rank to date.
(b) Your professional competency has been observed to be poor
and have failed repeatedly in all ASW Department POS tests
conducted at regular interval by the ship and also by CITs.
(c) You have been found habitual of feigning sickness and
projecting personal issues with an intention to avoid operational
commitments of the ship. Further, on several occasions, you have
displayed conduct unbecoming of a uniformed person, insisting
upon disembarkation from long sailings while breaking the
authorized channel”
6.
There is no dispute that the petitioner had submitted a reply dated
03.04.2020 to the aforesaid show cause notice. The case set up by the
petitioner before the Tribunal was that he had certain difficulties, and as
such, he could not clear the swimming test. It was contended on behalf of
the petitioner, as canvassed by learned counsel before this Court, that since
the petitioner had cleared the test on 31.08.2021 and the PQ examination on
01.09.2021, he could not have been discharged and was entitled to be
promoted.
7.
His case was also that the allegations of habitual sickness and absence
from duty have been properly explained by him, and also from time to time
requesting leave from the Divisional Officer, which was ultimately denied.
In substance, it was contended on behalf of the petitioner, as argued by
learned counsel, that the petitioner had duly explained all the relevant
circumstances; however, despite the explanations and justifications
furnished, the authority, without considering the reply to the show-cause
notice in its proper perspective and without affording him an opportunity to
demonstrate his merit in service, declared him unsuitable under Regulation
278(1) of the Regulations, rendering the action taken by the respondents
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:14.01.2026 12:50
W.P.(C) 290/2026
illegal.
8.
We find that the respondents in their stand before the Tribunal have
stated the following:
“3. … …
It is the case of the respondents that despite being given adequate
opportunity to improve his conduct and character and come up to
the Naval standard required the applicant was setting a bad
example to other sailors and the respondents had no option but to
discharge the applicant on being satisfied that he is unsuitable
and lacks professional competency for discharging the duties in
the Navy. The respondents in the detailed counter affidavit filed
stated that the applicant's performance on board was just average
or below average. On numerous occasions, he was found to be
either missing from his duty place or absent on the ground that he
was feeling ill, with complaints such as fever, backache, and chest
pain, and he would cite family problems as an excuse for shirking
duties and avoiding departmental responsibilities and work. It is
the case of the respondents that the professional competency of the
applicant was observed to be very poor, he repeatedly failed in all
the swimming tests and the PQ tests conducted by the ship at
regular intervals. Не was counselled to improve himself, in spite
of that, he exhibited work-shyyness, had a very reluctant attitude
towards service, and was not showing any progress in his work.
The respondents have brought on record the following details with
regard to his professional capabilities, conduct, disciplinary
actions, and attitude towards work while on board various Naval
ships from time to time. The details are as follows:
(a) Counselled on 14 May 2018 (Annexure R/11) for clearing
his swimming test as the same will affect his date of
promotion.
(b) Counselled by Executive Officer on 01 August 2018
(Annexure R/12) with respect to discharge of duties, act of
self harm/suicidal misbehavior/bad conduct towards ladies
and act of stealing onboard act,
(c) Counselled by ASWO 11 (Annexure R/13) for his casual
attitude towards work, missing from place of duty and using
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:14.01.2026 12:50
W.P.(C) 290/2026
mobile phone during working hours.
(d) Counselled by Department Officer (Annexure/14) for his
misconduct and reluctant attitude towards service.
(e) Counselled and warned by Executive Officer on 13
December 2019 (Annexure R/15) for his reluctance towards
the organisation, professional knowledge below average
and not clearing mandatory swimming test.
(f) Counselled by Divisional Officer (Annexure R/16) to clear
his PET and swimming test at an early date.
(g) (Counselled by Divisional Officer on 24 February 2020
(Annexure R/17) to improve his professional standards and
pass swimming test at the earliest.
(h) Counselled and warned by Divisional Officer on 27
February 2020 (Annexure R/18) to improve his professional
knowledge and pass his swimming test at the earliest.
(i) Advised and counselled by Divisional Officer on 06 March
2020 (Annexure R/19) to channelize his efforts towards
improving professional knowledge and clearing swimming
test.
(j) Counselled and warned by Divisional Officer on 16 March
2020 (Annexure R/20) for his professional incompetence
and failure on swimming.
It is the case of the respondents that the applicant was motivated,
counselled and informed about the activities. He was found to be a
non-swimmer since joining the service, he took many attempts to
pass the swimming test, he lacked skills and had fear of water.
Even though he was enrolled on 16.02.2016 and started
discharging duties immediately it took him five years to clear the
swimming test on 31.08.2021, ie. much after the issuance of the
show cause notice itself on 27.03.2020. The respondents further
submit that on the excuse of facing several family problems and
personal issues the applicant was away from duty. He would take
leave and be away from duty and sometimes not available in the
place of duty on the excuse of suffering from backache or chest
pain and not being able to sit properly. He took leave in 2019 for
various periods on account of his mother's ailment and operation
for kidney stone. He got married in January 2019 and thereafter
started taking leave on account of his wife's health problems and
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:14.01.2026 12:50
W.P.(C) 290/2026
various other issues. It is the case of the respondents that because
of his absence and his continued habit of breaking the rules he
was punished on various occasions. On 12.06.2018 he ran away
from INS Mysore and was subsequently awarded "Warning
Punishment" by the Commanding Officer of the ship for remaining
absent without leave for 206 hours. He was awarded solitary
confinement in the cell for seven days, stoppage of leave for 41
days and deduction of pay and allowances for 41 days. He used to
seek leave off and on and the respondents have in detail narrated
various acts of commission and omission and lack of initiative in
performing duties by the applicant as detailed in the counter
affidavit.”
9.
Though the petitioner had filed a rejoinder to the reply filed by the
respondents, the Tribunal, in paragraph 6 onwards, which we have already
reproduced above, has, on a consideration of facts which arose before it had
dismissed the original application.
10.
Today, before us as well, learned counsel for the petitioner has
advanced submissions similar to those made before the Tribunal. On a
perusal of the show cause notice, it is clear that the respondents have
primarily alleged two grounds on which he was sought to be discharged (i)
that despite adequate opportunities provided by the ship towards improving
his swimming skills, he has not passed the swimming tests in four years of
service, and (ii) that the professional competency of the petitioner as
observed was held to be poor as he failed repeatedly in all ASW Department
POS tests conducted at the regular interval by the ship and also by CITs.
11.
The submission of learned counsel for the petitioner is that, although
the petitioner had not passed the swimming test within four years, having
cleared the test on 31.08.2021, the same ought to have been treated as a
mitigating factor and, therefore, the respondents should not have terminated
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:14.01.2026 12:50
W.P.(C) 290/2026
the services of the petitioner.
12.
We are unable to agree with the submission made by the learned
counsel for the petitioner for the simple reason that the petitioner was
required to pass the test within the period of four years as stipulated under
the Rules. His connected submission is that, despite the petitioner not having
cleared the swimming test within four years and the show-cause notice
having been issued much thereafter, the action initiated by the respondents is
itself bad; inasmuch as the delay must enure in his favour. This submission
does not impress us.
13.
This is for the simple reason that the respondents, having not taken
action against the petitioner immediately after four years has not caused any
prejudice to the petitioner; rather it was to the benefit of the petitioner that
he could able to continue in the service even thereafter. Insofar as the overall
performance of the petitioner while working for the respondents, the
petitioner has not disputed the case as set up by the respondents in their
reply, nor has any argument been advanced by the counsel for the petitioner
before us to state that what has been contended by the respondents in their
reply is contrary to the record.
14.
In fact, during the course of the submissions, the learned counsel for
the petitioner has stated that because of certain family problems, he was not
able to discharge his duties diligently.
15.
If that be so, the grounds on which the petitioner has been discharged
are not perverse; there is some basis for the respondents to come to a
conclusion that they are required to invoke the provisions of regulation
278(1) to discharge the petitioner from the services of the Navy.
16.
We are of the view that the Tribunal is justified in coming to the
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:14.01.2026 12:50
W.P.(C) 290/2026
conclusion as it has done in the impugned order.
17.
The petition being without merit is dismissed.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
JANUARY 9, 2026/msh
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:14.01.2026 12:50
W.P.(C) 290/2026
Page 10 of
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review