The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. The Respondents have candidly admitted that the impugned order dated 14.07.2017 erroneously refers to the relevant circular as dated "22.09.2016" instead of the correct date of "22.09.2014." The correct circular is on record as Annexure R-3, and the reasoning of the order flows coherently from it. A typographical error that has no bearing on the merits of the decision does not vitiate the order. This contention is rejected. As regards the Petitioner's grievance concerning non-disposal of the legal notice dated 20.08.2017, since the substantive claim has been examined and determined on merits in these proceedings, no separate relief survives on this count.
17. In view of the foregoing, the present Writ Petition is dismissed. The Impugned Order dated 14.07.2017 is upheld and pending application, is disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 28.04.2026
+
W.P.(C) 5522/2018 and CM APPL. 18458/2026
EX. HC GOVERDHAN SINGH
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. M. K. Gaur, Mr. Pawan
Kumar, Mr. Anup Kumar, Mr.
Gaurav Sarawat and Mr. U.
Srivastava, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Vivekanand Mishra, SPC.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
J U D G M E N T (ORAL)
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
INTRODUCTION
1.
The present Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India has been filed by the Petitioner, a retired member of the
Border Security Force, laying challenge to the order passed by the
Deputy Inspector General (Pers), Directorate General, Border Security
Force, Block No.10, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi,
whereby the Petitioner’s claim for grant of first financial upgradation
under the Assured Career Progression Scheme (‘ACP’) was rejected.
By way of the present Writ Petition, the Petitioner seeks quashing of
the aforesaid order and a consequential direction to the Respondents to
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:17:12
grant him first ACP benefit with all attendant monetary and service
advantages. The controversy, in substance, turns upon whether
completion of qualifying service by itself entitled the Petitioner to
ACP benefits, or whether the Respondents were justified in declining
the same upon consideration of the Petitioner’s service record,
including the relevant Annual Confidential Reports (ACRs).
2.
In order to comprehend the issue involved in the present case,
some briefs facts are required to be examined.
FACTS
3.
The Petitioner was enrolled in the Border Security Force on
02.04.1975 as a Constable (GD) bearing Force No. 750011921.
During the course of his service, he was progressively promoted to the
rank of Head Constable on 10.11.1992. He served in 173 Bn BSF
from 27.11.1991 until his voluntary retirement w.e.f. 30.06.2005,
having completed 30 years, 2 months and 28 days of qualifying
service.
4.
The Government of India introduced the Assured Career
Progression Scheme vide DoP&T O.M. dated 09.08.1999 on the
recommendation of the 5th Central Pay Commission, with a view to
mitigate stagnation among Central Government employees. The
Scheme provided for two financial upgradations upon completion of
12 and 24 years of regular service respectively, subject to fulfilment of
all prescribed promotional norms including the minimum ACR
benchmark. The Scheme remained operative from 09.08.1999 to
31.08.2008. In the context of BSF, the promotional norms for
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:17:12
advancement from Head Constable (GD) to the equivalent grade of
Sub Inspector (GD) required, inter alia, a minimum overall ACR
grading of "Good" as prescribed under the MHA guidelines dated
25.11.1988.
5.
Subsequently, the HQ DG BSF (Pers Dte) circular dated
22.09.2014 relaxed the requirement of Pre-Promotion Courses,
namely Map Reading Std-1st and PPC List 'D' - for the purposes of
financial upgradation in the pay scale of Rs. 5500-9000/-, while
expressly preserving all other promotional norms including ACR
benchmark and conduct record.
6.
During his service career, the Petitioner's ACR gradings for the
period 1994-95 to 1998-99 - the years directly relevant to assessment
of his 2nd ACP entitlement upon completion of 24 years of service on
02.04.1999, were consistently "Satisfactory," falling below the
prescribed benchmark of "Good." His ACRs for the period 1998 to
2002 were not initiated, owing to a pending criminal proceeding under
Section 302 IPC arising out of his deputation with NTPC, during
which he was placed under suspension from 20.07.1999 to
12.03.2002.
7.
He was eventually acquitted and the suspension period was
regularized as "spent on duty" vide order dated 03.10.2004. He was
additionally subjected to Summary Trial on two occasions during
service - awarded "Reprimand" on 26.02.1999 under Section 40 of the
BSF Act for conduct prejudicial to good order and discipline, and
"Severe Reprimand" on 19.02.2001 under Section 19(a) of the BSF
Act for absenting without leave.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:17:12
8.
In compliance with the circular dated 22.09.2014, the
Petitioner's case for grant of ACP benefits was examined by a duly
constituted Departmental Screening Committee at SHQ BSF,
Krishnanagar on 07.05.2015. The Committee, upon scrutiny of the
service record, declined to recommend the Petitioner for financial
upgradation on account of below-benchmark ACR grading and
adverse punishment entries during the relevant period. The Board
Proceedings are placed on record as Annexure R-4.
9.
Subsequently, upon learning of a HQ DG BSF clarification
dated 22.09.2016 regarding financial upgradation for retired Head
Constables in the pay scale of Rs. 5500-9000/-, the Petitioner
submitted a representation seeking extension of ACP benefits. The
said representation was rejected vide the impugned order dated
14.07.2017 issued by Respondent No.4, on the grounds that the
Petitioner had completed 24 years of service on 02.04.1999 but did
not fulfil the requisite criteria under the governing instructions. A
legal notice dated 20.08.2017 also failed to elicit relief. The Petitioner
has challenged the impugned order and the inaction of the
Respondents by way of the present writ petition under Articles
226/227 of the Constitution. A Counter Affidavit has been filed by the
Respondents, and a Rejoinder has been filed by the Petitioner, placing
on record a DoP&T OM dated 06.12.2016 clarifying the effect of
warnings and reprimands on promotion.
ANALYSIS
10.
The ACP Scheme is a beneficial measure conceived to address
stagnation where regular promotion avenues are limited. It is,
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:17:12
however, equally well settled that financial upgradation under such a
scheme is not automatic upon completion of the prescribed years of
service. The entitlement is conditional upon satisfaction of eligibility
criteria prescribed under the governing policy, of which the ACR
benchmark is a central and non-negotiable component. Completion of
qualifying service is therefore a necessary but not sufficient condition.
An employee seeking ACP must also demonstrate the minimum
standard of fitness and suitability as reflected in his service record.
11.
In the present case, the Petitioner's ACR gradings for the period
1994-95 to 1998-99, which form the zone of consideration for the 2nd
ACP falling due on completion of 24 years of service, were uniformly
"Satisfactory" - below the prescribed benchmark of "Good." The
ACRs for the period 1998 to 2002 were not initiated on account of the
pending criminal case and consequent suspension, a circumstance
substantially attributable to the Petitioner's own conduct. A Screening
Committee is entitled to take such absence of ACRs into account as
part of its overall assessment. Viewed in totality, the Petitioner's
service record does not satisfy the minimum eligibility threshold
prescribed under the Scheme. This deficiency is objective, recordbased, and unrebutted.
12.
The Departmental Screening Committee constituted on
07.05.2015 was the competent, duly authorized body for examining
entitlements under the ACP Scheme. It scrutinized the Petitioner's
service dossier and returned a specific finding against him on two
independent grounds - below-benchmark ACR grading and adverse
punishment entries.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:17:12
13.
It is well settled that this Court, in exercise of jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution, does not sit in appeal over assessments
of suitability made by departmental authorities. Interference is
warranted only where the decision is shown to be perverse, mala fide,
or contrary to the governing rules. No such infirmity has been
demonstrated. No material has been placed before this Court to
suggest that the ACR entries were fabricated, recorded by an
incompetent authority, or influenced by bias. The DSC's decision is
accordingly upheld.
14.
The Petitioner has, in his Rejoinder, placed reliance on the
DoP&T OM dated 06.12.2016 to contend that reprimands and
warnings do not amount to penalties and cannot constitute a bar to
promotion. This position is accepted as a correct statement of law. It
does not, however, advance the Petitioner's case. The belowbenchmark ACR grading constitutes an entirely independent and selfsufficient ground for denial of ACP benefits, wholly distinct from the
punishment entries. Even if the reprimands are entirely excluded from
consideration, the Petitioner's failure to meet the ACR benchmark
alone is sufficient to disentitle him. The 2016 OM, moreover, operates
prospectively and cannot retrospectively alter the criteria by which the
DSC assessed the Petitioner's service record in 2015 with reference to
a career ending in 2005.
15.
The Petitioner has further alleged that similarly situated
colleagues and juniors were extended ACP benefits while he was
excluded. This allegation is unsubstantiated. No names, service
numbers, comparative ACR gradings, or conduct records of any such
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:17:12
person have been placed on record. A constitutional challenge
founded on discrimination under Articles 14 and 16 must rest on
specific and comparable material. Further, even if it were assumed
that other persons were incorrectly extended benefits, that cannot
create an enforceable right in the Petitioner. Parity in alleged illegality
is not a permissible constitutional claim.
16.
The Respondents have candidly admitted that the impugned
order dated 14.07.2017 erroneously refers to the relevant circular as
dated "22.09.2016" instead of the correct date of "22.09.2014." The
correct circular is on record as Annexure R-3, and the reasoning of the
order flows coherently from it. A typographical error that has no
bearing on the merits of the decision does not vitiate the order. This
contention is rejected. As regards the Petitioner's grievance
concerning non-disposal of the legal notice dated 20.08.2017, since
the substantive claim has been examined and determined on merits in
these proceedings, no separate relief survives on this count.
CONCLUSION
17.
In view of the foregoing, the present Writ Petition is dismissed.
The Impugned Order dated 14.07.2017 is upheld and pending
application, is disposed of.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
APRIL 28, 2026
s.godara/kb
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:17:12
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review