Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
CRP No. 18 of 2022
Date of Decision: 13.07.2023
Smti. Everian Siena Marybell Blah
Vs. Shri. Gregory Dominic K Blah
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. V.G.K. Kynta, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. M. Kynta, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. S. Marpan, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This is an application under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India, read with Rule 6 of The High Court of Meghalaya (Jurisdiction
Over District Council Courts) Order, 2014 directed against order dated
06.05.2022, passed by the Learned Presiding Officer of the Subordinate District Council Court, Shillong in Title Suit No. 2/4 of 2017.
2.
The facts and brief are that, the respondent as plaintiff had
instituted a suit being T.S. No. 2/4 of 2017 against the petitioner/
defendant and others before the District Council Court, Shillong for a
declaration and permanent injunction in respect of a suit property
situated at Jaiaw Pdeng, Shillong. The petitioner/defendant No. 1, then
filed a written statement cum counter claim in the said suit, for
judgment and decree in respect of the same suit property situated at
Jaiaw Pdeng, Shillong, and also in respect of a shop/stall bearing No.
118 C (old stall No. 67 C) situated at Iewduh, Shillong. The Title Suit,
then came to be disposed of vide order dated 06.05.2022, pursuant to a
Settlement Deed dated 29.04.2022, arrived at between the parties, but
only in respect of the suit property situated at Jaiaw Pdeng, Shillong.
3.
The grievance of the petitioner is that, the Lower Court while
passing the order dated 06.05.2022, had acted illegally and without
jurisdiction, in holding that the counter claim in respect of the
shop/stall at Iewduh, Shillong, is not part of T.S. No. 2/4 of 2017, and
that, the petitioner was at liberty to institute a separate or fresh suit,
with regard to the claim over the shop/stall. Hence, the instant Revision
Application.
4.
Mr. V.G.K. Kynta, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. M.
Kynta, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the learned Lower
Court, while passing the impugned order dated 06.05.2022, had
travelled beyond the mandate of law, by holding that the counter claim
in respect of shops/stall at Iewduh, Shillong is not part of T.S. No. 2/4
of 2017. The learned Senior counsel submits that, the counter claim in
the Title Suit, is an off shoot of a registered Gift Deed dated
10.09.1980, which formed part of the cause of action of T.S. No. 2/4 of
2017. He contends that, the impugned order has the effect of
terminating the suit of the petitioner filed in the form of a counter claim
without considering the fact that, though the suit filed by the
respondents may be disposed of, as not pressed or by settlement as to
their claim, the counter claim of the petitioner, should have been treated
as a counter suit.
5.
Learned Senior counsel submits that, the learned Lower Court
ignored the mandate of Order 8 Rule 6-A (4) of the CPC, in holding
that, the petitioner was at liberty to institute a fresh suit, as the subject
matter that is, the shop/stall at Iewduh, Shillong is not in issue in T.S.
No. 2/4 of 2017, nor in Title Suit No. 1/4 of 2019, a suit that had also
been instituted by the petitioner subsequently on the same cause and
tried together with T.S. No. 2/4 of 2017. In this context, learned Senior
counsel has placed reliance on the following decisions;
i)
Satyender & Ors. Vs. Saroj & Ors. (2022) SCC
OnLine SC 1026
ii)
Jag Mohan Chawla & Anr. Vs. Dera Radha Swami
Satsang & Ors. (1996) 4 SCC 699.
6.
Mr. S. Marpan, learned counsel for the respondent submits
that the respondent as plaintiff had filed Title Suit No. 2/4 of 2017,
against the petitioner and thereafter, the petitioner had also instituted
Title Suit No. 1/4 of 2019, against the respondent and both the suits,
were specifically only in respect of the property situated at Jaiaw
Pdeng, Shillong. He further submits that the written statements of both
the petitioner and the respondents in their respective suits, do not
disclose any cause of action, with regard to the stall at Iewduh, and that
the issues framed by the Court were specifically only in respect of the
property at Jaiaw Pdeng, Shillong.
7.
The learned counsel submits that no application was ever filed
by the petitioner before the Trial Court, following the framing of issues
to seek framing of additional issues, with regard to the stall at Iewduh,
and that the both the suits proceeded only with regard to the property at
Jaiaw Pdeng, Shillong. The settlement arrived at between the petitioner
and the respondent based on the Deed of Settlement dated 29.04.2022,
he asserts was only in respect of the property at Jaiaw Pdeng, Shillong,
and the counter claim of the petitioner was set off only in respect of the
said property. It is also contended by the learned counsel that, it was on
the request of the petitioner through her counsel that liberty was
granted to institute a fresh suit, if desired.
8.
It has been contended that, both the suits which were disposed
of as per the Deed of Settlement, were in no manner connected with the
stall at Iewduh, for which a counter claim has been put up. It is also
submitted that, the petitioner by agreeing to setting off the counter
claim, in respect of the property at Jaiaw Pdeng, and by agreeing that
the settlement arrived at was only to the Jaiaw Pdeng property implies
that, the petitioner did not consider the stall at Iewduh to be part of the
suit, which has been disposed of, and as such, had prayed for liberty to
institute a fresh suit. It is also been submitted that, in the event the
counter claim filed by the petitioner in the Title Suit No. 2/4 of 2017, is
treated as a plaint, as per Order 8 Rule 6-A (4), the same is liable to be
rejected under Order 7 Rule 11(a), as the same does not disclose any
cause of action.
9.
The learned counsel placing reliance on Satyender & Ors. Vs.
Saroj & Ors. (supra), has submitted that as the respondent had not
sought a decree or any relief in respect of the stall at Iewduh, in both
the suits, the petitioner is barred from raising any counter claim against
the same. He further submits that, the judgment cited by the petitioner
namely Jag Mohan Chawla & Anr. Vs. Dera Radha Swami Satsang
& Ors. (supra), will have no application, as it speaks only of a statutory
right given to the defendant to set up a counter or an independent claim
on his own cause of action, and there being no cause of action made out
in the written statements and counter claim, this ruling is of no
assistance to the petitioner. He therefore submits that, there being no
irregularity in the impugned order, no grounds have been made out for
any interference by this Court, in exercise of powers under Article 227
of the Constitution of India.
10.
Heard learned counsels for the parties. The question for
determination in the instant Civil Revision Application as noted from
the submissions and records, is whether the counter claim put up by the
petitioner/defendant under Order 8 Rule 6(A) of the CPC, on an
independent cause of action for a stall at Iewduh, can be allowed, when
the subject matter of both the suits related only to a certain property at
Jaiaw Pdeng, which was resolved by way of a Deed of Settlement.
11.
A counter claim is normally by operation of Order 8 Rule 6-A
(4), to be treated as a plaint and governed by the rules applicable to
plaints. The counter claim as noted above, was with regard to a
different suit property that is, the stall at Iewduh, which did not form
part of the adjudicatory proceedings, nor was any issue framed by the
Trial Court. From the records and submissions, it is noted that neither
the petitioner moved any application for framing of issues, with regard
to the said property, nor was any application filed by the respondent
under Order 8 Rule 6-C for exclusion of the counter claim and for it to
be tried as an independent suit.
12.
At this stage, it would be expedient to examine the legal
authorities, which had been cited by the counsels for the parties. Firstly,
in Satyender & Ors. Vs. Saroj & Ors. (supra), the Supreme Court at
Paras – 18, 19 and 20 had held as follows.
“18. The other finding of Second Appellate Court
regarding the counter claim of the defendants on Killa
Nos. 6//18 and 23 is, however, correct and is based on
right interpretation of Order VIII, Rule 6A of CPC.
From the pleadings of the plaintiffs, it is clear that they
had never raised any claim on Killa No. 6//18 or Killa
No.23. The defendants in their written statement while
denying the rights of the plaintiffs on the land of which
particulars had been given by the plaintiffs, quite
ingeniously inserted the two Killa Nos.6//18 and 23,
setting a counter-claim on these plots. The Trial Court
and the First Appellate Court while dismissing the
plaintiffs’ suit had allowed this claim for without
assigning any reasons. In fact, this counter claim
which was raised by the defendant is barred under
Order VIII, Rule 6A of the CPC. Order VIII, Rule 6A
reads as under:[6A. Counter-claim by defendant.—(1) A defendant in
a suit may, in addition to his right of pleading a set-off
under rule 6, set up, by way of counter-claim against
the claim of the plaintiff, any right or claim in respect
of a cause of action accruing to the defendant against
the plaintiff either before or after the filing of the suit
but before the defendant has delivered his defence or
before the time limited for delivering his defence has
expired, whether such counter-claim is in the nature of
a claim for damages or not:
Provided that such counter-claim shall not exceed the
pecuniary limits of the jurisdiction of the court.
(2) Such counter-claim shall have the same effect as a
cross-suit so as to enable the Court to pronounce a
final judgment in the same suit, both on the original
claim and on the counter-claim.
(3) The plaintiff shall be at liberty to file a written
statement in answer to the counter-claim of the
defendant within such period as may be fixed by the
court.
(4) The counter-claim shall be treated as a plaint and
governed by the rules applicable to plaints.
19. A counter claim can be set up only “against the
claim of the plaintiffs”. Since there was no claim of the
plaintiffs regarding Killa No. 6//8 and 23, the
defendants were barred to raise any counter claim on
these Killa numbers in view of Order VIII, Rule 6A of
the CPC as it has nothing to do with the plaintiffs. It is
true that a counter claim can be made by the
defendant, even on a separate or independent cause of
action (Jag Mohan Chawla v. Dera Radha Swami
Satsang).
20. The Legislature permits the institution of a counter
claim, in order to avoid multiplicity of litigation. But
then it has certain limitations such as that the counter
claim cannot exceed the pecuniary limits of the
jurisdiction of the court, and that such counter claim
must be instituted before the defendant has delivered
his defence or before the time limit for delivering his
defence has expired. More importantly, such a counter
claim must be against the plaintiff! Evidently, in the
present case the counter claim was not against the
plaintiffs. Moreover, as the plaintiffs had not claimed
any right over the property and the Killa Nos. 6//8 and
23 are not even a part of the suit property described in
the plaint by the plaintiffs. Despite the same, such a
claim has been allowed against the plaintiffs. In fact,
we do not find on record any reply submitted by the
plaintiffs against the counter claim. To be fair, such a
counter claim should have been excluded in terms of
Order VIII, Rule 6C of the CPC. Suffice it to state here
that the counter claim set up by the defendants
has been rightly rejected by the High Court.”
A plain reading of this judgment shows that, a counter claim
can be set up only against the claim of the plaintiffs, and that if there
is no claim of right or interest by the plaintiffs, as in the above quoted
case, to a certain plot of land, the defendants were barred to raise such
counter claim, but however, it has also been held that, a counter claim
can be made by the defendant, even on a separate or independent
cause of action. In the other judgment, Jag Mohan Chawla & Anr.
Vs. Dera Radha Swami Satsang & Ors. (supra), it has been held that,
a counter claim need not relate to the original cause of action, but can
be made on an independent and different cause of action, even on one
which accrued to the defendant, after the institution of the suit. Para –
5 which is relevant is reproduced hereinbelow.
“5. The question, therefore is: whether in a suit for
injunction, counter-claim for injunction in respect of
the same or a different property is maintainable?
Whether counter-claim can be made on different cause
of action? It is true that preceding CPC Amendment
Act, 1976, Rule 6 of Order 8 limited the remedy to setoff or counter-claim laid in a written statement only in
a money suit. By CPC Amendment Act, 1976, Rules 6A to 6-G were brought on statute. Rule 6-A(1) provides
that a defendant in a suit may, in addition to his right
of pleading a set-off under Rule 6, set up by way of
counter-claim against the claim of the plaintiff, any
right or claim in respect of a cause of action accruing
to the defendant against the plaintiff either before or
after the filing of the suit but before the defendant has
delivered his defence or before the time limited for
delivering his defence has expired, whether such
counter-claim is in the nature of a claim for damage or
not. A limitation put in entertaining the counter-claim
is as provided in the proviso to sub-rule (1), namely, the
counter-claim shall not exceed the pecuniary limits of
the jurisdiction of the court. Sub-rule (2) amplifies that
such counter-claim shall have the same effect as a
cross-suit so as to enable the Court to pronounce a
final judgment in the same suit, both on the original
claim and on the counter- claim. The plaintiff shall be
given liberty to file a written statement to answer the
counter-claim of the defendant within such period as
may be fixed by the court. The counter-claim is
directed to be treated, by operation of sub-rule (4)
thereof, as a plaint governed by the rules of the
pleadings of the plaint. Even before 1976 Act was
brought on statute, this Court in Laxmidas Dahyabhai
Kabarwala v. Nanabhai Chunilal Kabarwala, had
come to consider the case of suit and cross-suit by way
of
counter-claim.
Therein,
suit
was
filed
for
enforcement of an agreement to the effect that
partnership between the parties had been dissolved and
the partners had arrived at a specific amount to be paid
to the appellant in full satisfaction of the share of one
of the partners in the partnership and thereby decree
for settlement of accounts was sought. Therein the
legal representatives of the deceased partner contended
in the written statement, not only denying the
settlement of accounts but also made a counter-claim
in the written statement for the rendition of accounts
against the appellant and paid the court fee as plaint.
They also sought a prayer to treat the counter- claim as
a cross-suit. The trial court dismissed the suit and the
counter-claim. On appeal, the learned Single Judge
accepted the counter-claim on a plaint in a cross-suit
and remitted the suit for trial in accordance with law.
On appeal, per majority, this Court had accepted the
respondents' plea in the written statement to be a
counter-claim for settlement of their claim and defence
in written statement as a cross-suit. The counter-claim
could be treated as a cross-suit and it could be decided
in the same suit without relegating the parties to a
fresh suit. It is true that in money suits, decree must be
conformable to Order 20, Rule 18, CPC but the object
of the amendments introduced by Rules 6-A to 6-G are
conferment of a statutory right on the defendant to set
up a counter-claim independent of the claim on the
basis of which the plaintiff laid the suit, on his own
cause of action. In sub-rule (1) of Rule 6-A, the
language is so couched with words of wide width as to
enable the parties to bring his own independent cause
of action in respect of any claim that would be the
subject-matter of an independent suit. Thereby, it is no
longer confined to money claim or to cause of action of
the same nature as original action of the plaintiff. It
need not relate to or be connected with the original
cause of action or matter pleaded by the plaintiff. The
words "any right or claim in respect of a cause of
action accruing with the defendant" would show that
the cause of action from which the counter-claim
arises need not necessarily arise from or have any
nexus with the cause of action of the plaintiff that
occasioned to lay the suit. The only limitation is that
the cause of action should arise before the time fixed
for filing the written statement expires. The defendant
may set up a cause of action which has accrued to him
even after the institution of the suit. The counter-claim
expressly is treated as a cross-suit with all the indicia of
pleadings as a plaint including the duty to aver his
cause of action and also payment of the requisite court
fee thereon. Instead of relegating the defendant to an
independent suit, to avert multiplicity of the proceeding
and needless protection (sic protraction), the legislature
intended to try both the suit and the counter-claim in
the same suit as suit and cross-suit and have them
disposed of in the same trial. In other words, a
defendant can claim any right by way of a counterclaim in respect of any cause of action that has accrued
to him even though it is independent of the cause of
action averred by the plaintiff and have the same cause
of action adjudicated without relegating the defendant
to file a separate suit. Acceptance of the contention of
the appellant tends to defeat the purpose of
amendment. Opportunity also has been provided under
Rule 6-C to seek deletion of the counter-claim. It is
seen that the trial court had not found it necessary to
delete the counter-claim. The High Court directed to
examine the identity of the property. Even otherwise, it
being an independent cause of action, though the
identity of the property may be different, there arises no
illegality
warranting
dismissal
of
counter-claim.
Nonetheless, in the same suit, both the claim in the suit
and the counter-claim could be tried and decided and
disposed of in the same suit. In Mahendra Kumar v.
State of M.P. where a Bench of two Judges of this
Court was to consider the controversy, held that since
the cause of action for the counter-claim had arisen
before filing of the written statement, the counter-claim
was maintainable. The question therein was of
limitation with which we are not concerned in this
case. Thus considered we find that there is no merit in
the appeal.”
[Emphasis supplied]
13.
What emerges from the judgments cited above is that, the
object of the amendments by Rules 6-A to 6-G, is the conferment of a
statutory right on the defendant to set up a counter claim, independent
of the claim on the basis of which the plaintiff had filed the suit, but on
his own cause of action. In the instant case, the counter claim in
satisfaction of the requirements as elucidated in the judgments would
be said to have been met, if the counter claim related to a property that
the plaintiff had interest or claim thereon, and if the same though not
subject matter of the suit was on an independent cause of action. It is
not in dispute that, both the suit properties were subject matter of a Gift
Deed dated 10.09.1980, and though suits by the respective parties, had
been instituted only with regard to the Jaiaw Pdeng property, the
plaintiffs also possessed considerable interest in the stall at Iewduh, and
cannot be held that they have no interest, whatsoever to make the
counter claim not maintainable.
14.
The next point relates to the examination as to the cause of
action of the counter claim by the petitioner. A detailed perusal of the
counter claim filed by the petitioner before the Trial Court, however,
does not disclose any cause of action for the counter claim,
notwithstanding the fact that, the same could have been raised, even if
it was independent of the claim made by the respondents as plaintiff in
the suit. In this view of the matter, though there is no finding by the
learned Trial Court, and though no application under Rule 6-C had
been filed by the respondents, the counter claim is hit by Order 7 Rule
11(a), which mandates that, a plaint be rejected, where it does not
disclose a cause of action.
15.
In this view of the matter, though Order 8 Rule 6-A, was with
objective to prevent the multiplicity of suits, the counter claim of the
petitioner being incompetent, the same is disallowed and the petitioner
as per the order of the Trial Court, is at liberty to institute a
fresh/separate suit, in respect of the shop/stall at Iewduh, Shillong
bearing Stall No. 118-C (Old Stall No. 67 Section C).
16.
As such, for the foregoing reasons, this Civil Revision
Application accordingly stands dismissed.
17.
No order as to costs.
18.
Lower Court Case records to be sent back immediately.
Judge
Meghalaya
13.07.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review