Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/eragaboina-gangamma-vs-the-state-of-andhra-pradesh-20260714/ · Printed 21 Nov 2026
Constitutional

Eragaboina Gangamma vs The State of Andhra Pradesh

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Andhra Pradesh High Court
Date
14 July 2026
Case No.
WP 28399/2018
Result
Dismissed
Bench
V.sujatha
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

7. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, and in view of the fact that the petitioners were paid ex gratia, as per the terms and conditions of G.O.Rt.No.192, dated 02.12.1998 read with G.O.Ms.No.1307, dated 23.12.1993, this court is of the view that claiming full compensation in respect of the land resumed equivalent to the market value of the land as per the ratio laid down in Mekala Pandu’s case is unconstitutional for the reason that the acquisition of lands and structures of the petitioners were made in December 2003, whereas the decision rendered in Mekala Pandu’s case was on 09.03.2004, much later to the acquisition in the present case. In that view of the matter, since the acquisition was made in the year 2003 prior to the judgment in Makala Pandu’s case and the petitioners were paid ex gratia to a tune of Rs.2,62,35,887/- in the year 2004 in terms of G.O.Rt.No.192, dated 02.12.1998. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 It is to be observed that the judgment in Mekala Pandu is prospective in operation. Accordingly, it does not apply to cases where the acquisition had already been completed and ex gratia had been paid prior to the pronouncement of the said judgment. Admittedly, in the present case, the acquisition took place in the year 2003 and ex gratia was paid in the year 2004. Therefore, the petitioners are not entitled for any compensation as per the said Judg…

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

APHC010594492018 IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI (Special Original Jurisdiction) WEDNESDAY, THE 15th DAY OF JULY 2026 PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA WRIT PETITION NO: 28399 OF 2018 Between: 1. Eragaboina Gangamma, W/o. Peda Subbanna ,Aged about 60 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 2. Mannem Venkata Subbamma, W/o. Mallem Kondaiah, Aged about 52 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 3. Yelakacherla Penchalaiah, S/o.Chinnaiah , Aged about 65 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 4. Pothapi Ramulamma (died) as per L.R P.Sambaiah, S/o.Thirupalaiah , Aged about 50 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 5. Obulam Yerraiah @ Kondaiah, S/o.Jolaiah, Aged about 48 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 6. Obulam Bharathamma, W/o. Kondaiah @Yerraiah, Aged about 40 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 7. Shaik Peda Masthan, S/o.Subhan Saheb , Aged about 55 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 8. Pothapi Adi Lakshumma, W/o. Kondaiah , Aged about 50 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 9. Itta Kondaiah, S/o. China Kondaiah , Aged about 35 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 10. Thummuluru Gopalamma, W/o. Thirupalu Aged about 65 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 11. Thummuluru Mallikarjuna, S/o. Thirupalaiah , Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 12. Thummuluru Thirupalu, S/o. Ramaiah , Aged about 70 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 13. Thummuluru Thirupalu, S/o. Ramaiah , Aged about 70 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 14. Peruru China Penchalaiah, S/o. Penchalaiah , Aged about 48 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 15. Mannem Kondaiah, S/o. Pedda Buddaiah , Aged about 50 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 16. Shaik Baba Saheb, S/o.Pakeer Saheb , Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 17. Sagili Sankaraiah, S/o. Venkataiah @Peda Kondaiah Aged about 35 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 18. Bandi Subbaiah, S/o. Subbaiah , Aged about 70 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 19. Chintam Subbaiah, S/o. Chinna Venkataiah W/o. Rosaiah , Aged about 60 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 20. Thummaluru Jayaramaiah, S/o.Kondaiah , Aged about 48 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 21. Thummaluru Kondaiah, S/o.Ramaiah , Aged about 65 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 22. Thummaluru Subhadramma, W/o.Narasimhulu , Aged about 38 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 23. Thummaluru Devi, W/o.Jayaramaiah , Aged about 38 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 24. Thummaluru Lakshumma, W/o. Kondaiah , Aged about 60 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 25. Kasula Malleswaramma, W/o. Late K.Subbarayudu Aged about 48 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 26. Sagili Peda Kondaiah, S/o.Peddaiah , Aged about 70 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 27. Sagili Sankaraiah, S/o.Peda Kondaiah , Aged about 35 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 28. Sagili Peda Kondaiah, S/o. Peddaiah , Aged about 70 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 29. Kasula Mallem Kondamma, W/o. Kondaiah , Aged about 38 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 30. Kasula Mallem Kondamma, W/o. Kondaiah , Aged about 38 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 31. Sagili Sambaiah (died ) as per L.R S.Prameela, W/o. Late S.Sambaiah , Aged about 30 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 32. Minuku Kondamma, W/o. Venkata Subbaiah , Aged about 52 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 33. Kasula Malleswaramma, W/o. Late Kasula Subbarayudu, Aged about 48 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 34. Sagili Mallem Kondaiah, S/o. Peddiaiah , Aged about 65 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 35. Pothapi Tirupalu, S/o. Achari Kondaiah ,Aged about 30 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 36. Pothapi Narasimhuiu, S/o.Yanadaiah , Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 37. Pothapi Gangamma, W/o. MaItem Kondaiah , Aged about 60 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 38. Pothapi Venkatamma, W/o.Chinnaiah , Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 39. Gopidevi Subbakka (Yadava), W/o. Kondaiah , Aged about years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 40. Tippana Narashimhulu, S/o.Penchalaiah, Aged about years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 41. Eeri Gopaiaiah, S/o.Narayana, Aged about years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 42. Eeri Subbarayudu, S/o. Gopalaiah ,Aged about years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 43. Eeri Santhamma, W/o. Gopalaiah ,Aged about years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 44. Varapalli Thirupalu, S/o. Peddaiah. Aged about years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 45. Eri Narayana, S/o. Chinaiah ,Aged about years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 46. Konduru Salamma, W/o.Chinna Narasaiah , Aged about 35 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 47. Konduru Salamma, W/o.Chinna Narasaiah , Aged about 35 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 48. Konduru Salamma, W/o.Chinna Narasaiah , Aged about 35 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 49. Pothapi Adi Lakshmamma, W/o. Achari Kondaiah ,Aged about 50 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 50. Pothapi Adi Lakshmamma, W/o. Achari Kondaiah ,Aged about 50 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 51. Pothapi Sambaiah, S/o,Mallem Kondaiah , Aged about 40 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 52. Pothapi Venkatamma, W/o. Chinnaiah , Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 53. Pothapi Venkatamma, W/o. Chinnaiah , Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 54. Pothapi Gangamma (died ) as per L.R. P.Chinnaiah, S/o. Pedda Kondaiah , Aged about 50 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 55. Pothapi Gangamma (died ) as per L.R. P.Chinnaiah, S/o. Pedda Kondaiah , Aged about 50 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 56. Anampalli Kondamma, S/o. Venkata Subbaiah ,Aged about 60 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 57. Anampalli Kondamma, S/o. Venkata Subbaiah ,Aged about 60 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 58. Pothapi Chinnaiah, S/o.Ramaiah, Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 59. Pothapi Narasamma, W/o. Thirupalu, Aged about 65 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 60. Pothapi Chinnakka, W/o. Ramaiah ,Aged about 60 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 61. Pothapi Bujjaiah, S/o. Pedda Kondaiah @ Mallem Kondaiah ,Aged about 35 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 62. Pothapi Bujjaiah, S/o. Pedda Kondaiah @ Mallem Kondaiah ,Aged about 35 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 63. Pothapi Bujjaiah, S/o. Pedda Kondaiah @ Mallem Kondaiah ,Aged about 35 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 64. Pothapi Narasamma (Died) as per L.R Pothapi Thirupal, S/o. Achari Kondaiah ,Aged about 30 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 65. Pothapi Chinnakka, W/o. Ramaiah ,Aged about 60 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 66. Pothapi Subbamma, W/o. Mallikarjun, Aged about 38 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 67. Kota Narasamma, W/o.Subba Narasaiah ,Aged about 65 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 68. Kota Narasamma, W/o.Subba Narasaiah ,Aged about 65 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 69. Pothapi Bhaskar, S/o.Thirupalaiah ,Aged about 38 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 70. Pothapi Bhaskar, S/o.Thirupalaiah ,Aged about 38 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 71. Yelakacherla Narasaiah, S/o. Narasaiah ,Aged about 30 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 72. Pothapi Narasimhulu, S/o.Yanadaiah ,Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 73. Pothapi Chinnakka, W/o.Narasimhulu ,Aged about 40 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 74. Pothapi Chinnakka, W/o.Narasimhulu ,Aged about 40 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 75. Pothapi Penchalamma (died) As per L.R Pothapi Thirupal, S/o. Yanadaiah ,Aged about 32 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 76. Pothapi Penchalamma (died) As per L.R Pothapi Thirupal, S/o.Yanadaiah ,Aged about 32 years, resident of Kotha VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 77. Pothapi Rajeswara Rao, S/o. Thirupalaiah, Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 78. Pothapi Rajeswara Rao, S/o. Thirupalaiah, Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 79. Pothapi Chinna Kondaiah, S/o. Matha Kondaiah, Aged about 55 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 80. Pothapi Maliem Kondaiah, S/o. Chinna Kondaiah Aged about 35 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 81. Annupalli Penchaiamma (Died) As per L.R A.Venkata Subbaiah, S/o. Late Venkata Subbaiah, Aged about 48 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 82. Annupalli Penchalamma (Died) As per L.R A.Venkata Subbaiah, S/o. Late Venkata Subbaiah, Aged about 48 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 83. Yelakacherla Pedda Kondamma (Died) as per LR Y.Narasimhuiu, S/o. Narasaiah, Aged about 55 years, resident of VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 84. Pothapi Siddamma, W/o. Chinna Kondaiah ,Aged about 71 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 85. Pothapi Siddamma, W/o. Chinna Kondaiah, Aged about 71 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 86. Pothapi Ashamma, W/o, Chinnaiah, Aged about 38 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 87. Pothapi Ashamma, W/o. Chinnaiah, Aged about 38 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 88. Pothapi Subbamma, W/o. MaNem Konda/ah, Aged about 55 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 89. Pothapi Subbamma, W/o. Mailem Kondaiah, Aged about 55 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 90. Pothapi Subbamma, W/o. MaHem Kondaiah, Aged about 55 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 91. Pothapi Venkata Subbamma, W/o. Chinnaiah, Aged about 40 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 92. Pothapi Bombay Kondaiah (died) asper LR Pothapi Thirupal, S/o.Late P.Bombay Kondaiah, Aged about 33 years, 93. Pothapi Thirupalu, S/o. Late P. Bombay Kondaiah, Aged about 33years, 94. Pothapi Eswaramma, W/o.Chinnaiah @ Penchalaiah, Aged about 40 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 95. Pothapi Eswaramma, W/o.Chinnalah @ Penchalaiah, Aged about 40 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 96. Pothapi Mariyamma, W/o. Yanadaiah, Aged abut 65 yeas, 97. Yalakacherla Pitchamma, W/o. Chinnaiah, Aged about 40 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 98. Peruru Padma, W/o, Rangaiah, Aged about 35 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 99. Yalakacherla Kondamma, W/o. Narasimhulu , Aged about 53 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 100. Yalakacherla Kondamma, W/o. Narasimhulu, Aged about 53 years. 101. Yalakacherla Kondamma, W/o. Narasimhulu , Aged about 53 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 102. Pothapi Venkata Laxmamma, W/o. Sambaiah , Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 103. Pothapi Venkata Laxmamma, W/o. Sambaiah , Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 104. Pothapi Venkata Laxmamma, W/o.Sambaiah , Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 105. Pothapi Mahesh, S/o, Thirupaialah , Aged about 32 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 106. Pothapi Ramulamma (died) as per LR P.Sambaiah, S/o.Thirupalaiah, Aged about 50years, , resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 107. Pothapi Ramulamma (died) as per LR P.Sambaiah, S/o.Thirupalaiah , Aged about 50 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 108. Yelakacherla Yellamma, W/o. Chinna Narasaiah , Aged about 33years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 109. Yelakacherla Bujjamma, W/o. Penchalaiah @Mugaiah , Aged about 35 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 110. Yelakacherla Bujjamma @ Y.Yellamma, W/o. Penchalaiah @Mugaiah , Aged about 35 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 111. Yelakacherla Yellamma, W/o. Chinna Narasaiah , Aged about 33 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 112. Yelakacherla Yellamma, W/o. Chinna Narasaiah , Aged about 33 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 113. Yelakacherla Yellamma, W/o, Chinna Narasaiah , Aged about 33 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 114. Pothapi Rajamma, W/o. Pothapi Adivigandla Chinnaiah , Aged about 50 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 115. Gollapalli Rajaiah, S/o.Gollapalli Guravaiah . Aged about 65 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 116. Yalakacherla Yellamma, W/o. Narasimhulu, Aged about 52 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 117. Yalakacherla Yellamma, W/o. Narasimhulu, Aged about 52 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 118. Gollapalli Rajaiah, S/o. Gollapalli Guravaiah Aged about 65 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 119. Pothapi Rajamma, W/o. Pothapi Adivigandla Chinnaiah, Aged about 50 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 120. Pothapi Nagamma, W/o. Yerraiahgari Narasimhulu, Aged about 58 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 121. Pothapi Nagamma, W/o. Yerraiahgari Narasimhulu, Aged about 58 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 122. Pothapi Ayyavaramma, W/o. Penchalaiah , Aged about 48 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 123. Pothapi Rajamma, W/o. Pothapi Adavigandla Chinnaiah, Aged about 50 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 124. Perur Narasamma, W/o. Penchalaiah , Aged about 45 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 125. Gollapalli Vijayamma, W/o. Prakash , Aged about 40 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 126. Tallapaka Penchalamma, W/o. Subbaiah Aged about 65 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 127. Konduru Chinna Narasimhulu, S/o.Pullaiah Aged about 35 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 128. Konduru Subbarayudu, S/o.Pullaiah , Aged about 33 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 129. Yelakacherla Yellamma, W/o. Narasimhulu, Aged about 52 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 130. Pothapi Narasimhulu, S/o.Chinna Penchalaiah, Aged about 55 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 131. Pothapi Narasimhulu, S/o.Chinna Penchalaiah, Aged about 55 years resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 132. Gattupalli Kondaiah, S/o.Kondaiah, Aged about 60 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District 133. Irraganaboyina Sampoornamma, W/o. Subbarayudu , Aged about 40 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 134. Yalakacherla Gangamma, W/o. Narasimhulu, Aged about 55 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 135. Yalakacherla Gangamma, W/o. Narasimhulu, Aged about 55 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 136. Pothapi Rosamma, W/o. Chinna Kuntaiah , Aged about 50 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 137. Pothpi Chinna Kuntaiah @ Chinnaiah, S/o. Buttaiah Aged about 55 years,resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 138. Pothpi Chinna Kuntaiah @ Chinnaiah, S/o. Buttaiah Aged about 55 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 139. Pothpi Chinna Kuntaiah @ Chinnaiah, S/o. Buttaiah Aged about 55 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 140. Yalakacherla Narasimhulu, S/o. Narasaiah, Aged about 55 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. 141. Yalakacherla Narasimhulu, S/o. Narasaiah, Aged about 55 years, resident of Kotha Rekalakunta and Arundatiwada Village, Gopavaram Mandal, Kadapa District. ...Petitioners AND 1. The State of Andhra Pradesh, Rep.by its Principal Secretary, Irrigation (CAD) Department .(S.S.P.Division), At Velagapudi ,Secretariat Buildings, Guntur District 2. The Special Collector LA, G.N.S.S., Kadapa. 3. The Executive Engineer, Irrigation Department , S,P.Division No.VI, Atmakur, Nellore District. 4. The Special Deputy Collector LA, Telugu Ganga Project, UnitII, Kadapa, Kadapa District. ...Respondents Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased toto issue an order, direction or writ more particularly in the nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not awarding compensation under the provisions of Land Acquisition Act., 1894, to the structures of the petitioners in S.No.84 of Rekalakunta -Harizanawada and S.No.94, 351 of Rekalakunta -Arundatiwada of Rekalakunta VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 village, Gopavaram (Mandal), Cuddapah District, mentioned in PV statement vide Rc. D2/585/2003 dated 27/12/2003 in terms of the judgment of this Honourable court in W.A.No.170 of 2002 and batch, as arbitrary, illegal, null and void and against the Principles of natural Justice, contrary to the dicta laid down by this Honourable court in W.A.No.170 of 2002 and batch and violative of fundamental rights apart from Article 300-A of the Constitution of India and consequently direct the respondent authorities to pay the full compensation to the petitioners with all statutory benefits in respect of the lands and structures resumed under Rc.B.No.243/99 dt.22/12/2003 and to pass IA NO: 1 OF 2018 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the respondent authorities to pass appropriate orders on the representations dt. 26/08/2004,16/08/2008,24/12/2014,07/09/2016 and on the Memo No.30024/ 23/LA/A2/2016 dt.11/11/2016 in regard to payment of compensation for the structures of the petitioners in S.No.84 of Rekalakunta-Harizanawada and S.No.94,351 of Rekalakunta Arundatiwad of Rekalakunta village, Gopavaram (Mandal), Cuddapah District, in terms of the full bench Judgment of this Honourable court in W.A.No.170 of 2002 and batch , pending disposal of the above writ petition and to pass IA NO: 1 OF 2025 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 the High Court may be pleased May be pleased to permit the petitioner to reconstruct the case bundle of W.P.No. 28399 of from the photo copy of case bundle annexed to this interlocutory application and pass Counsel for the Petitioners: VENKATA RAMANA RAO BATCHU Counsel for the Respondents: GP FOR LAND ACQUISITION (AP) Counsel for the Respondents:GP FOR IRRI AND CAD (AP) VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 The Court made the following ORDER: Challenging the action of the respondents in not awarding compensation under the provisions of Land Acquisition Act, 1894, to the structures of the petitioners in Survey No.94, 351 of Rekalakunta-Arundatiwada of Rekalakunta village, Gopavaram (Mandal), Cuddapah District, mentioned in PV Statement vide Rc.D2/585/2003, dated 27.12.2003 in terms of the judgment of this court in W.A.No.170 of 2002 and batch, the present writ petition is filed. 2. The case of the petitioners is that the State of Andhra Pradesh had started construction of Somasila Project on river Penna and had acquired several villages in several Mandals in Cuddapah District for foreshore submersion under the said project. In such acquisition, they acquired several villages in Gopavaram Mandal, in which Rekalakunta is one such village where all the lands and structures existing in the village were acquired and the village was completely displaced from its original habitation. In such acquisition, the lands were assigned and the structures existing on the assigned lands situated in Survey No.84, Rekalakunta – Harizanawada and Survey No.94, VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 351 of Rekalakunta-Arundatiwada, Gopavaram Mandal were regularized vide file Ref.No.A/890/2003, dated 26.12.2003 and all the structures were resumed vide Preliminary Valuation Statement proceedings in Rc.No.D2/585/2003, dated 27.12.2003. While acquiring the same, ex gratia towards developments over the lands were alone mentioned to the respective owners without taking into account the market value of the structure including the land component. As per the Preliminary Valuation proceedings dated 27.12.2003, the petitioners and other owners of the structures were paid ex gratia of Rs.2,62,35,887/- as per the list annexed to the said proceedings. Though the petitioners raised their objection for non-payment of compensation on par with patta land owners and also for non-payment of adequate compensation, the respondent authorities failed to consider the same and paid ex gratia alone for the developments under G.O.Ms.No.1307, dated 23.12.1993. In spite of several attempts made by the petitioners for payment of difference amount of compensation, the respondent authorities are not responding for payment of such difference amount of compensation. Aggrieved by the same, the present writ petition came to be filed. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 3. The 4th respondent-Special Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition, filed his counter, contending that the land an extent of Ac.3.63 cents in Survey No.84 was classified as village site poramboke of Rekalakunta Harizanawada and the land an extent of Ac.45.08 cents in Survey No.94 was classified as Kunta Poramboke and the land an extent of Ac.554.34 cents in Survey No.351 of Rekalakunta Harijanawada are not notified for publication of houses as they were issued DKT pattas however, ex gratia was paid including 30% Solatium during the month of December, as per the terms and conditions of G.O.Rt.No.192, dated 02.12.1998 read with G.O.Ms.No.1307, dated 23.12.1993. All the structure owners including the petitioners were paid ex gratia to a tune of Rs.2,62,35,887/- in the year 2004. As a policy of the Government, compensation is paid by granting formal DKT pattas to the encroachers on Government land. It is further stated that regarding payment of ex gratia to the land component not included in the structures value, according to Section 23 (48) of the Land Acquisition Manual in Andhra Pradesh, in determining compensation payable in respect of lands with buildings, compensation cannot be determined by ascertaining the value of the land and the break-up value of the VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 building separately and the land and the buildings constitute one unit and the value of the entire unit must be determined with all its advantage and its potentialities. It is further stated that the ratio laid down in the judgment in W.A.No.170 of 2022 and batch and Civil Appeal Nos.7904, 7912 of 2004 is applicable to the lands only but not structures existed on Government lands, as the said judgment has no retrospective effect i.e. structures taken over prior to the date of judgment. Compensation paid to the petitioners as per the guidelines of the Government is accepted by them without any protest. As all the structure owners including the petitioners were paid ex gratia to a tune of Rs.1,13,18,579/- in the year 2004, the ratio laid down in Mekala Pandu’s case i.e. W.A.No.170 of 2022 and batch is not applicable to the present case. 4. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners and the learned Assistant Government Pleader for Revenue. 5. It is not in dispute that the lands and the structures of the petitioners existing in Survey No.84 to an extent of Ac.3.63 cents of Rekulakunta Harizanawada, Gopavaram Mandal, were acquired for the purpose of foreshore submersion under Somasila Project. It is also not in dispute that the petitioners including the VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 other structure owners were paid ex gratia to a tune of Rs.2,62,35,887/- in the year 2004 including 30% Solatium as per the terms and conditions of G.O.Rt.No.192, dated 02.12.1998 read with G.O.Ms.No.1307, dated 23.12.1993. Now, the grievance of the petitioners is that as per the ratio laid down in Land Acquisition Officer-cum-Revenue Divisional Officer, Chevella Division, Domalaguda, Hyderabad and others v. Mekala Pandu and others1 (W.A.No.170 of 2022 and batch), the petitioners are entitled for payment of compensation equivalent to the full market value of the land and other statutory benefits. 6. As seen from the counter contents of the 4th respondent- Special Deputy Collector, it is stated that the land an extent of Ac.3.63 cents in Survey No.84 was classified as village site poramboke of Rekalakunta Harizanawada and the land an extent of Ac.45.08 cents in Survey No.94 was classified as Kunta Poramboke and the land an extent of Ac.554.34 cents in Survey No.351 of Rekalakunta Harijanawada are not notified for publication of houses as they were issued DKT pattas however, ex gratia was paid including 30% Solatium during the month of 2004 (2) ALD 451 (LB) VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 December, as per the terms and conditions of G.O.Rt.No.192, dated 02.12.1998 read with G.O.Ms.No.1307, dated 23.12.1993. All the structure owners including the petitioners were paid ex gratia to a tune of Rs.2,62,35,887/- in the year 2004. 7. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, and in view of the fact that the petitioners were paid ex gratia, as per the terms and conditions of G.O.Rt.No.192, dated 02.12.1998 read with G.O.Ms.No.1307, dated 23.12.1993, this court is of the view that claiming full compensation in respect of the land resumed equivalent to the market value of the land as per the ratio laid down in Mekala Pandu’s case is unconstitutional for the reason that the acquisition of lands and structures of the petitioners were made in December 2003, whereas the decision rendered in Mekala Pandu’s case was on 09.03.2004, much later to the acquisition in the present case. In that view of the matter, since the acquisition was made in the year 2003 prior to the judgment in Makala Pandu’s case and the petitioners were paid ex gratia to a tune of Rs.2,62,35,887/- in the year 2004 in terms of G.O.Rt.No.192, dated 02.12.1998. VS, J W.P.No.28399 of 2018 It is to be observed that the judgment in Mekala Pandu is prospective in operation. Accordingly, it does not apply to cases where the acquisition had already been completed and ex gratia had been paid prior to the pronouncement of the said judgment. Admittedly, in the present case, the acquisition took place in the year 2003 and ex gratia was paid in the year 2004. Therefore, the petitioners are not entitled for any compensation as per the said Judgment, and they would be entitled for ex gratia, which was already paid way back in the year 2004. Therefore, nothing survives for adjudication in the present writ petition and the writ petition is devoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs. As a sequel thereto, interlocutory applications pending, if any in the Writ Petition, shall also stand closed. _____________ V. SUJATHA, J Date: 15.07.2026 Ksn

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All AP HC judgments →