Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CR No.9511 of 2025 (O&M)
had
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
****
CR No.9511 of 2025 (O&M)
Smt. Enu Chawla
.....Petitioner
Vs.
Gurmeet Singh
.....Respondent
1. Judgment reserved on
25.02.2026
2. Judgment pronounced on
22.05.2026
3. Judgment uploaded on
25.05.2026
4. Whether only operative part of the judgment is Full
pronounced or whether the full judgment is
pronounced.
5. The delay, if any of the pronouncement is full
Nil
judgment and reason thereof.
CORAM:- HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR
Argued By:-Mr. Aakriti Mittal, Advocate with
Ms. Kashish, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. Gurmeet Singh, respondent in person
(through V.C.).
****
Yashvir Singh Rathor, J.
1.
The present revision has been instituted under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India for setting aside of the order dated 20.11.2025 (Annexure
P.11) passed by the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Gurugram in Civil Suit
No.CS-2153-2025 titled “Enu Chawla Vs. Gurmeet Singh” (Annexure P-7),
RENU
2026.05.25 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9511 of 2025 (O&M)
had
-2-
whereby the application filed by the petitioner under order XII Rule 6 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908 was rejected and the plaintiff- petitioner was called upon
to lead evidence.
2.
I have heard learned counsel for the petitioner and respondent in
person and have gone through the material placed on record.
3.
Case of plaintiff is that she alongwith her brother Sh. Manjeet Singh,
was the joint owner of Flat No.101 and Flat No.102, situated in House No.131/9,
Shivpuri, Gurugram, by virtue of registered sale deeds dated 08.12.2017 in equal
shares. Her brother Sh. Manjeet Singh died on 05.01.2025, who was unmarried
and issueless & his ½ share in the suit properties devolved equally upon his
surviving siblings i.e. the plaintiff and the defendant to the extent of ¼th each,
thereby making the plaintiff – owner of 3/4th share. It is further alleged that by
way of an oral family settlement subsequently affirmed vide compromise deed
(Annexure P-9), the defendant voluntarily relinquished his 1/4th share in favour of
plaintiff. Thereafter, plaintiff instituted a civil suit for declaration to the effect that
she is owner in possession of the suit property wherein defendant filed written
statement admitting her claim and further made a prayer that he has no objection
in case the suit is decreed as prayed for. However, the learned trial Court vide
impugned order dated 20.11.2025 declined the plaintiff’s application under Order
XII Rule 6 CPC for judgment on admissions, on the ground that the matter
requires adducing of evidence to substantiate the claim.
4.
Feeling aggrieved, the plaintiff has approached this Court assailing
the said order being illegal, null and
expeditious disposal of the case.
RENU
2026.05.25 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
void and seeking directions for the
CR No.9511 of 2025 (O&M)
had
5.
-3-
Before proceeding further, the impugned order dated 20.11.2025 is
hereby reproduced as under:“Written statement is filed on behalf of the defendant. An
application is moved under order 12 rule 6, CPC for passing
judgment on the basis of facts admitted by the defendant, on behalf of
the plaintiff.
Pleadings perused. According to the plaintiff, the parties have
arrived at a mutual settlement as per which the defendant has agreed
to transfer his share in the properties as mentioned in para no. 2(i)
and (ii) of the plaint, the plaintiff seeks a decree of declaration to the
effect that plaintiff is owner and in possession of the suit properties as
fully detailed and described in para no. 2(i) and (ii) of the plaint.
However, upon a further and careful perusal of the plaint, it emerges
that the plaintiff along with her real brother, claims ownership and
possession over the properties enumerated in para nos. 2(i) and 2(ii)
of the plaint. In view of this position, the court is of the considered
opinion that the plaintiff is required to lead evidence to substantiate
her claim, and that a declaratory decree cannot be granted solely on
the basis of the written statement, even if certain admissions are
alleged. Furthermore, perusal of written statement filed by defendant
reveals that the plaintiff’s case has not been admitted in its entirety.
The written statement raises some contested aspects of the plaintiff’s
claim. Consequently, the matter necessitates the adducing of
RENU
2026.05.25 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9511 of 2025 (O&M)
had
-4-
evidence, and the relief sought under Order XII Rule 6 CPC cannot
be granted at this stage.
Considering the nature of dispute, the court finds it appropriate
to call for Evidence from both sides and to settle the issues to be
established through such evidence. Accordingly, the following issues
is here by framed:
1.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of declaration to
the effect that the plaintiff is absolute and exclusive owner in
possession of suit property mentioned in para no. 2(i) and (ii)
of the plaint, as prayed for? -OPP
List on 02.01.2026 for plaintiff evidence, to be led at plaintiff's
own responsibility. If the plaintiff wishes to summon any witnesses,
process fee, diet money, etc. be deposited, and file list of witnesses
within 15 days from the date of this order.”
6.
A perusal of the plaint annexed with the petition shows that as per
version of plaintiff, she alongwith her brother Manjeet Singh was owner of the
suit properties in equal shares. Her brother Manjeet Singh was unmarried and
issueless who died on 05.01.2025 leaving behind plaintiff and defendant as the
only surviving legal heirs.
Their mother and father had already died on
29.04.2021 and 30.8.1996 as reflected in the death certificates.
Thereafter,
plaintiff obtained a Family Member Certificate which has been issued by Deptuy
District Magistrate Sadar, Bareilly for District Magistrate vide certificate
No.595/A-Nazir-2025 2025 dated 5.3.2025 in which it has been categorically
mentioned that deceased – Manjeet Singh was unmarried and sssueless. It is
RENU
2026.05.25 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9511 of 2025 (O&M)
had
-5-
further alleged that a family settlement took place between plaintiff and defendant
in which defendant relinquished his 1/4th share in favour of plaintiff in the said
oral settlement in May, 2025 and since then plaintiff is owner in possession of the
suit property. Later on, he started resiling from the said settlement which
necessitated the present suit. A perusal of the written statement filed by the
defendant shows that the defendant has admitted the claim of the plaintiff
regarding ownership and relinquishment of 1/4th share by him in her favour on
the basis of the family settlement. He has further made a prayer that he has no
objection in case the suit is decreed.
7.
Once defendant has admitted the claim of the plaintiff, parties were
not at dispute either on a question of fact or law and the suit could have been
disposed of on the basis of the admission in terms of Order 12 Rule 6 CPC.
particularly because the admission made by defendant in the written statement is
clear, unambiguous, unequivocal and unconditional. Hon’ble Supreme Court in
2025 SCC Online SC 751 – Rajiv Ghosh Vs. Satya Naryan Jaiswal, while
interpreting the provision contained in Order 12 Rule 6 CPC has held as under:“36. A Division Bench of the Delhi High Court very correctly laid
down the following interpretation of the provision of O. 12, R.
6, CPC, in the decision of ITDC Limited v. Chander Pal Sood and
Son, reported in (2000) 84 DLT 337 (DB): (2000 AIHC 1990):
“Order 12, R. 6 of Code gives a very wide discretion to
the Court. Under this rule the Court may at any stage of the suit
either on the application of any party or of its own motion and
without determination of any other question between the
RENU
2026.05.25 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9511 of 2025 (O&M)
had
-6-
parties can make such order giving such judgment as it may
think fit on the basis of admission of a fact made in the
pleadings or otherwise whether orally or in writing.”
37.
The use of the expression ‘otherwise’ in the aforesaid context
came to be interpreted by the High Court. Considering the expression
the Court interpreted the said word by stating that it permits the Court
to pass judgment on the basis of the statement made by the parties not
only on the pleadings but also dehors the pleadings i.e. either in any
document or even in the statement recorded in the Court. If one of the
parties' statement is recorded under O. 10, Rr. 1 and 2 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, the same is also a statement which elucidates matters
in controversy. Any admission in such statement is relevant not only
for the purpose of finding out the real dispute between the parties but
also to ascertain as to whether or not any dispute or controversy
exists between the parties. Admission if any is made by a party in the
statement recorded, would be conclusive against him and the Court
can proceed to pass judgment on the basis of the admission made
therein.
38. Rule 6 of Order XII, before the amendment, allowed judgment on
admission only on an application by a party. The Law Commission,
however, suggested that a judgment may be pronounced either on an
application by a party or even suo motu [See: Throp (supra)]
39. This rule authorizes the court to enter a judgment where a claim is
admitted and to pass a decree on such admitted claim. This can be
RENU
2026.05.25 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9511 of 2025 (O&M)
had
-7-
done at any stage. [See: Uttam Singh (supra)]. Thus, a plaintiff may
move for judgment upon admission by the defendant in his written
statement at any stage of the suit although he has joined issue on the
defence.” [See: Brown v. Pearson, (1882) 21 Ch D 716]. Likewise, a
defendant may apply for dismissal of the suit on the basis of
admission by the plaintiff in rejoinder.”
8.
Besides this, Hon’ble Supreme Court in (2000) 7 Supreme Court
Cases 120 – Uttam Singh Duggal & Co. Ltd Vs. Union Bank of India has held
that meaning of Order 12 Rule 6 CPC should not be unduly narrowed down,
because the object of Rule 6 is to enable a party to obtain a speedy judgment.
9.
In the present case, the parties are not at issue over any question of
fact or law. Oral family settlement has been entered into between the parties and
defendant has admitted the claim of plaintiff and has further made a prayer that he
has no objection in case the suit is decreed. No doubt Order 12 Rule 6 CPC
empowers the Court to call upon the parties to lead evidence and judgment based
on admission cannot be claimed as an absolute right but such a recourse should
be adopted only in the cases where the admission is not unambiguous, clear and
unequivocal. This provision empowers the Court to deliver a judgment based on
clear and categorical admission of fact made by the parties at any stage of the suit.
As already mentioned above, defendant is the brother of the plaintiff and as per
version of plaintiff, suit property fell in her share in an oral family settlement
wherein defendant relinquished his 1 1/4th share in her favour. It is well settled
that if a pre-existing family settlement is admitted, the suit can be decreed on the
basis of the same and it even does not require any registration under Registration
RENU
2026.05.25 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9511 of 2025 (O&M)
had
-8-
Act. In view of law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in AIR 1976 SC 807Kale Vs. Deputy Director and others, and a co-ordinate Bench of this Court in
2009(3) CCC 418 – Chanan Singh and others Vs. Surjit Singh and others.
10.
As a result of afore-asid discussion, I am of the considered opinion
that the impugned order suffers from manifest error and material illegality has
been committed while rejecting the application under Order 12 Rule 6 CPC and
the impugned order dated 20.11.2025 (Annexure P.11) is set aside so far as the
parties have been called upon to adduce evidence. Learned Trial Court is directed
to decide the suit in hand accordingly, in the light of the observations made above.
No order as to costs.
11.
Pending misc. applications, if any, shall stand disposed of.
(Yashvir Singh Rathor)
Judge
May 22, 2026
renu
Whether Speaking/reasoned
Whether Reportable
RENU
2026.05.25 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Chandigarh
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review