Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:JHHC:19125 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W. P. (L) No. 4519 of 2022
Employer in relation to the Management of Dobari Colliery under
Bastascolla Area of M/s. BCCL (M/s Bharat Coking Coal Limited),
having its office at Bastacolla Area, P.O. & P.S. Bastacolla, District Dhanbad (Jharkhand) through its Chief Manager (Personnel) / H.O.D.
(Legal) Sri Ved Prakash, aged about 56 years, son of Late Radha
Krishna Prasad, residing near Koyla Bhawan, PO BCCL Township, PS
- Saraidhela, District - Dhanbad (Jharkhand).
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
Their Workman represented through Bihar Colliery Kamgar Union,
through its Central Secretary having its office at Shramik Nagar, Bhuli,
Block “E”, Sector-II, Qtr. No.483, PO- Bhuli (D), PS- Bhuli, DistrictDhanbad (Jharkhand).
…
… Respondent
--CORAM :HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Petitioner
: Ms. Swati Shalini, AC
To Mr. A. K. Das, Sr. Advocate
For the Respondent
: Mr. Uday Prakash, Advocate
Mr. Manoj Kr. Sinha, Advocate
--10/29.06.2026
Heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the parties.
2.
The instant Writ Petition has been filed against the Award dated
29.01.2021 (Annexure-6) passed by the Presiding Officer, Central
Government Industrial Tribunal No.1, Dhanbad, in Reference Case
No.78 of 2014, whereby reference has been answered in favour of the
concerned workman and direction has been made to reinstate the
concerned workman with 50% back-wages with all consequential
benefits from the date of dismissal within one month from the date of
publication of the Award.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner- M/s BCCL has submitted
that so far as the background of the case is concerned, certain land was
acquired and the husband of the concerned Workman, Late Fakir
Chand, was given employment as per the scheme of the petitioner- M/s
BCCL and after his death, his widow was given compassionate
appointment and the widow is respondent in this case.
4.
Charge-sheet dated 28.11.2012 was issued to the concerned
workman. It has been alleged that the management had asked the
concerned workman to handover the peaceful possession of 2.64 2/3
( 2026:JHHC:19125 )
acres of land to the BCCL, but he failed to give the possession of the
land and another person, Ganesh Chand had been claiming employment
against the said land and disturbing the possession of BCCL over the
said land. Accordingly, it has been alleged that the husband of the
concerned Workman and the concerned workman fraudulently obtained
employment in BCCL.
5.
A reply was filed by the concerned Workman disputing the
allegations. The reply has been placed on record in the counter-affidavit
at Annexure-E.
6.
Learned counsel submits that the concerned Workman was
subjected to the domestic enquiry and the domestic enquiry was held to
be fair and proper vide order dated 09.07.2015 and it was for the learned
Industrial Tribunal to examine the records of the Domestic Enquiry in
the light of the provisions of Section 11 A of the Industrial Disputes
Act, 1947.
7.
The learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the
learned Tribunal has interfered with the finding of the domestic enquiry
and such interference is not as per the law and hence not permissible.
Further, the learned Tribunal has also found that the punishment was
disproportionate to the gravity of alleged misconduct and the order of
punishment of dismissal dated 04.06.2013 has been set aside.
8.
Learned counsel submits that the learned Tribunal has travelled
beyond the scope of Section 11A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
and therefore, the impugned award is fit to be set-aside.
9.
Learned counsel appearing for the Respondent has opposed the
prayer and has submitted that in the reply [Annexure-E to the counteraffidavit] it was pointed out by the concerned Workman that out of 2.64
acres of land, her husband’s share was 1/4th which was equivalent to
0.56 acres of land and the same was acquired by the BCCL through land
acquisition proceeding vide L.A. Case No.30 of 1983-84 and
possession of 0.56 acres was taken by the BCCL and compensation was
also paid to her husband to that extent. It was also mentioned in the
reply filed by the concerned workman that her husband had also sworn
affidavit dated 18.05.1987 and had given it to the Management of the
petitioner at the time of entering into employment in the year 1987.
( 2026:JHHC:19125 )
10.
He has further submitted that as per the reply itself, the husband
of the concerned workman died in the month of August, 1995 and the
present Workman was offered compassionate appointment and was
offered employment in the year 1997. It was the specific case that her
husband’s share, total of 0.56 acres of land, was acquired by the
petitioner- BCCL whose possession was taken and further
compensation was paid in the year 1983-84, that is, about 25 years back
and during this period, petitioner-BCCL never raised any plea that they
were not in possession of the land.
11.
Learned counsel has submitted that merely because the domestic
enquiry was held to be fair and proper that does not mean that the
Industrial Tribunal cannot scrutinize the material and come to a
different finding and certainly it is open to the Industrial Tribunal to
also consider the gravity of alleged misconduct and the punishment
inflicted.
12.
The learned counsel for the respondent submits that on both the
counts, the Tribunal has passed the order in favour of the concerned
workman. The learned counsel submits that there is no perversity or
illegality in the impugned judgment and the same has been passed in
accordance with the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
reported in (1973) 1 SCC 813 [The Workmen of M/s Firestone Tyre
and Rubber Co. of India (Pvt.) Ltd.] at Para 40 to 41A which reads as
follows :“40. Therefore, it will be seen that both in respect of cases
where a domestic enquiry has been held as also in cases
where the Tribunal considers the matter on the evidence
adduced before it for the first time, the satisfaction under
Section 11-A, about the guilt or otherwise of the workman
concerned, is that of the Tribunal. It has to consider the
evidence and come to a conclusion one way or other.
Even in cases where an enquiry has been held by an
employer and a finding of misconduct arrived at, the
Tribunal can now differ from that finding in a proper case
and hold that no misconduct is proved.
41. We are not inclined to accept the contentions advanced
on behalf of the employers that the stage for interference
under Section 11-A by the Tribunal is reached only when
it has to consider the punishment after having accepted
the finding of guilt recorded by an employer. It has to be
remembered that a Tribunal may hold that the
punishment is not justified because the misconduct
alleged and found proved is such that it does not warrant
( 2026:JHHC:19125 )
dismissal or discharge The Tribunal may also hold that
the order of discharge or dismissal is not justified
because the alleged misconduct itself is not established
by the evidence. To come to a conclusion either way, the
Tribunal will have to re-appraise the evidence for itself.
Ultimately it may hold that the misconduct itself is not
proved or that the misconduct proved does not warrant
the punishment of dismissal or discharge. That is why,
according to us, Section 11-A now gives full power to the
Tribunal to go into the evidence and satisfy itself on both
these points. Now the jurisdiction of the Tribunal to
reappraise the evidence and come to its conclusion
enures to it when it bas to adjudicate upon the dispute
referred to it in which an employer relies on the findings
recorded by him in a domestic enquiry. Such a power to
appreciate the evidence and come to its own conclusion
deciding a dispute on the basis of evidence adduced
before it for the first about the guilt or otherwise was
always recognised in a Tribunal when it was time. Both
categories are now put on a par by Section 11-A.
41-A. Another change that has been effected by Section
11-A is the power conferred on a Tribunal to alter the
punishment imposed by an employer. If the Tribunal
comes to the conclusion that the misconduct is
established, either by the domestic enquiry accepted by it
or by the evidence adduced before it for the first time, the
Tribunal originally had no power to interfere with the
punishment imposed by the management. Once the misconduct is proved, the Tribunal had to sustain the order
of punishment unless it was harsh indicating
victimisation. Under Section 11-A, though the Tribunal
may hold that the misconduct is proved, nevertheless it
may be of the opinion that the order of discharge or
dismissal for the said misconduct is not justified. In other
words, the Tribunal may hold that the proved misconduct
does not merit punishment by way of discharge or
dismissal. It can, under such circumstances, award to the
workman only lesser punishment instead. The power to
interfere with the punishment and alter the same has been
now conferred on the Tribunal by Section 11-A”
13.
After hearing learned counsel for both the parties, it is not in
dispute while hearing the instant case that the land total 2.64 2/3 acres
was acquired by the BCCL and the husband of the concerned workman
was granted employment as a land looser. It is further not in dispute that
the husband of the concerned workman was granted compensation in
L.A. Case No.30 of 1983-84 and in addition to the compensation, he
was also granted employment. It is also not in dispute that the husband
of the concerned workman was employed in the year 1987 and died in
( 2026:JHHC:19125 )
the month of August, 1995 and thereafter the concerned workman
herein was offered employment on compassionate ground in the year,
1997 and she has been working with the writ petitioner- M/s BCCL
continuously.
14.
A charge-sheet was issued to the concerned workman alleging
that the concerned workman had not handed-over possession of 2.64
2/3 acres of land to the petitioner BCCL and there are other claimants,
namely, Ganesh Chandra who are disturbing the possession of BCCL
over the land. In this background, it was alleged that the husband of the
concerned Workman and the concerned workman, appointed on
compassionate ground, both have fraudulently obtained employment in
BCCL.
15.
The concerned workman responded to the charge-sheet by
clearly stating that her husband had only 0.56 acres of land which was
1/4th of 2.64 acres and the land was acquired by the BCCL through L.A.
Case No.30 of 1983-84 and possession of 0.56 acres was taken by
BCCL and compensation was also paid to her husband to that extent
only. An affidavit to this effect was also sworn by her husband dated
18.05.1987 and being satisfied, he was granted employment in the year
1987 and before entering into employment, the possession was taken
and no objection with regard to possession was ever raised since the
year 1983-84.
16.
However, the concerned Workman was subjected to disciplinary
proceedings and was dismissed vide order dated 04.06.2013 and the
dispute between the Management and the Workman was referred to the
Industrial Tribunal.
17.
The Schedule of the dispute of the reference is as under: “Whether the action of the management of Dobari
Colliery under Bastacolla Area of M/s BCCL in
dismissing Smt. Anjala Chandra Lathman from the
services of the Company vide office order dated
04.06.2013 is fair and justified? To what relief the
concerned workman is entitled to?”
18.
Both the parties filed their written statement and the legality and
validity of the domestic enquiry was examined before the Tribunal and
vide order dated 09.07.2015, the enquiry was held to be fair and proper
( 2026:JHHC:19125 )
and ultimately the matter was examined by the learned Tribunal in
terms of Section 11A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
19.
The learned Tribunal took into consideration the judgment
passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of “The Workmen
of M/s Firestone Tyre”(supra) and it has been held that even in cases
where an enquiry has been held by the employer and finding of
misconduct has been arrived at, the Tribunal can differ from the finding
in the proper case and hold that no misconduct is proved. In para-41
of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, it has been held that
Section 11 A of the I.D. Act, gives full power to the Tribunal to go to
the evidence and satisfy itself on both the points, that is finding of guilt
of the workman and also proportionality of punishment inflicted. It has
been held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that a Tribunal may hold that
the punishment is not justified because the misconduct alleged and
found to be proved is such that it does not warrant dismissal or
discharge and the Tribunal may also hold that the order of discharge or
dismissal is not justified because the alleged misconduct itself is not
established by the evidence. It has been further held that in order to
come to a conclusion either way, the Tribunal will have to re-appraise
the evidence for itself and ultimately, the tribunal may hold that the
misconduct itself is not proved or that the misconduct proved does not
warrant the punishment of dismissal or discharge. It has been held that
Section 11-A of the I.D. Act gives full power to the Tribunal to go into
the evidence and satisfy itself on both these points.
20.
This Court finds that the learned Tribunal, after considering the
materials on record, has come to an specific finding in Para-23 onwards
wherein it was admitted in the domestic enquiry proceedings that the
husband of the concerned workman was appointed under land looser
scheme on the recommendation of the Committee dated 13.07.1987
and there is categorical evidence that the entire land of 2.64 2 /3 acres
of land was acquired vide L.A. No.30 of 1983-84 and in the affidavit,
Fakir Chandra (husband of the concerned workman ) had categorically
stated that he had only 1/4th share of the acquired land and his share of
land was already acquired by the BCCL and the land was vested in
BCCL.
( 2026:JHHC:19125 )
21.
Further, the learned Tribunal recorded that during life time of
Fakir Chandra (husband of the concerned workman) , the Management
of the petitioner never raised the issue of handing over of possession of
entire 2.64 acres 2 /3 acres of land although it was an specific affidavit
of Fakir Chandra that he had only 1/4th share which was already
acquired and vested in BCCL. The finding of the learned Tribunal in
paragraphs 21 to 25 is quoted as under: “21. At this stage it is essential to mention here that the Exhibit M-2
which is charge sheet issued by the Project Officer, Dobari Colliery
to the concerned workwoman in which it is mentioned that her
husband Late Fakir Chandra obtained employment in BCCL on land
looser scheme against the 2.64 2/3 acres of land in plot no. 72, 73,
1/2, 1/3, 1/4, 162, 193, 219, 220, 232, 233 of Kahta no. 16 within
Mouza Jharna and after his death she had been employed and had
been asked to handover the peaceful possession of 2.64 2/3 acres of
land to BCCL but she had failed to give the possession of the land till
date.
22. Further in the enquiry proceeding (Exhibit M-6) the
representative of the management Sri R.N. Singh has stated that
Fakir Chandra husband of concerned workwoman Anjala Chandra
was employed under land looser scheme on the basis of report dated
/07/1987 of a committee and the land of Fakir Chandra was acquired
by the company vide LA Case No. 30/83. He has also stated that Late
Fakir Chandra had filed an affidavit dated 18/05/1987 showing there
in that he had share of 0.56 acres (1/4th) out of 2.64 2/3 acres of land
which is not as per recommendations of 30/07/1987.
23. Now, it is admitted in the enquiry proceeding that Late Fakir
Chandra was appointed under the land looser scheme on the
recommendation of the committee dated 30/07/1987 and there is a
categorical evidence that the entire land of 2.64 2/3 acres land was
acquired in LA Case No. 30/83. Moreover in the affidavit of Late
Fakir Chandra it had been categorically stated that he had 1/4th
share of the land situated in Mauza Jharna Khata no. 16 measuring
2.64 2/3 acres. Further in the enquiry report it has been mentioned
that the entire land of 2.64 2/3 acres was acquired by the BCCL on
payment of compensation, so the entire land vested to BCCL.
Moreover 1/4th share of land of Late Fakir Chandra had also been
acquired along with 2.64 2/3 acres of land, which also vested to the
BCCL
24. It is further required to mention here that as per Rule 6 (i) (iii)
of Land Looser Scheme (part of Enquiry Proceeding Exhibit M-6)
there was no condition for acquisition of minimum area of the land
on which employment would be given but the BCCL had accepted the
2.64 2/3 acres of land including 1/4th share of Late Fakir Chandra
for giving him employment. Moreover during the lifetime of Late
Fakir Chandra the management had not raised the issue of handing
( 2026:JHHC:19125 )
over the possession of entire land of 2.64 2/3 acres of land and
management had raised the issue after death of Late Fakir Chandra
when his wife had been employed in his place under NCWA.
25. In view of above discussion it is very much clear that the share
of hate Fakir Chandra husband of the concerned workwoman had
been acquired by the BCCL and at that time there was no provision
on the initiation of the area of acquisition of land for giving
employment.”
22.
Apart from the aforesaid, learned Tribunal was also of the view
that the punishment of dismissal was disproportionate to the gravity of
alleged misconduct and the punishment imposed disturbed the
conscience of the Court. The finding of the learned Tribunal in
Paragraphs 28 and 29 of the impugned award is quoted hereunder: -
23.
“28. In view of such fact the Tribunal finds that the
punishment of dismissal awarded to the concerned
workman is being disproportionate to the gravity of the
misconduct, so as to disturb the conscious of the court.
29. Hence, the Tribunal comes to the conclusion that
the order of dismissal of concerned workwoman is not
fair and justified, so the punishment of dismissal order
dated 04.06.2013 is set aside. ”
This Court finds that the learned Tribunal has passed the
impugned Award within the contours of Section 11A of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 when seen in the light of the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of “The Workmen of M/s Firestone
Tyre” (supra). There is neither any perversity nor any illegality in the
impugned award. The impugned award is well reasoned. The arguments
of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the learned tribunal has
exceeded its jurisdiction conferred under section 11A of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 is devoid of any merits, hence rejected.
24.
Accordingly, the instant Writ Petition being devoid of merit is
dismissed.
25.
Let this order be immediately communicated to the learned
Tribunal through FAX/e-mail.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
29.06.2026
Uploaded on.
sandeep/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review