The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. MC (WA) No. 1 of 2023 is disposed of.
17. WA No. 3 of 2023 is dismissed.
18. There will, however, be no order as to costs. (W. Diengdoh) Judge (Sanjib Banerjee) Chief Justice Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC(WA) No. 1 of 2023 in
WA No.3 of 2023
Date of order: 13.02.2023
E.B. Khyriem
vs
The State of Meghalaya & ors
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Applicant/Appellant
:
Mr N. Syngkon, Adv.
For the Respondents
:
Mr B. Bhattacharjee, AAG with
Ms R. Colney, GA
Dr N. Mozika, Sr Adv. with
Ms A. Pradhan, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
Considering the good grounds shown, the delay of about 198 days
in preferring the appeal is condoned and the appeal is taken on board.
2.
The appeal is taken up for immediate consideration.
3.
The appeal arises out of an order dated May 25, 2022 by which a
writ petition instituted by the respondent Nos. 3 and 4 was allowed and a
seniority list published by the Public Health Engineering Department of
the State, insofar as it was at variance with the inter se seniority between
the writ petitioners and the private respondents to the writ petition as
published in the year 2017, was set aside.
4.
The facts are admitted. The writ petitioners in this case were
recruited in the year 2003 but, as per the terms of their initial
employment, they were subject to discharge without notice. The writ
court held that the writ petitioners were appointed on purely temporary
basis and under authority of Regulation 3(f) of the Meghalaya Public
Service Commission (Limitation of Functions) Regulation, 1972. The
writ court appropriately concluded that the relevant Regulation could be
resorted to for immediate appointments to be made in public interest as
any reference to the public service commission would cause delay.
5.
It is also the undisputed position that it was on June 8, 2006 that
the writ petitioners were recommended for absorption and became
regular appointees as Assistant Engineers (Electrical) in the PHE
Department. The veracity of the writ petitioners’ regularisation was not
questioned and, in any event, such regularisation was found to be in
accordance with a memorandum of April 30, 1974.
6.
The private respondents to the writ petition, including the
appellant herein, were promoted on the recommendation of a
departmental promotion committee by virtue of a notification dated
October 13, 2006. Such promotion was, however, temporary under
Regulation 4(d) of the said Regulation of 1972. It was only by a
subsequent notification of October 29, 2007 that the services of the
private respondents to the writ petition were regularised with effect from
October 13, 2006.
7.
Thus, what is the undisputed position is that the services of the
writ petitioners stood regularised on June 8, 2006 whereas the promotion
of the private respondents to the writ petition as Assistant Engineers in
the PHE Department came to be with effect from October 13, 2006.
8.
It appears that the first seniority list that was published reflecting
the names of both the writ petitioners and the private respondents to the
writ petition was in the year 2009. In the relevant notification, the writ
petitioners were indicated to be senior to the private respondents to the
writ petition. The same seniority position was maintained in further
publications made in the years 2010, 2013, 2014, 2016 and 2017. It
appears that subsequent to the publication of the seniority list in 2017, the
private respondents to the writ petition made a representation to the
employer, following which the applecart was upset and the notification
indicating the seniority position published on May 23, 2018 showed the
writ petitioners to be below the private respondents to the writ petition in
the seniority list.
9.
Only one of the private respondents to the writ petition has carried
this appeal since one of the others has died and the third has attained
superannuation.
10.
Several issues were framed by the writ court, inter alia, as to the
merits of the rival claims of the writ petitioners and the private
respondents to the writ petition on basis of the rules that governed them.
However, ultimately, some of such issues were not answered as they were
not necessary to be gone into. The matter turned on a sound legal
principle that a settled position that had been accepted for several years
could not be unsettled by a subsequent objection or representation. The
ancillary ground that weighed with the writ court was that the
modification to the seniority list and the departure from what was
indicated in at least six previous lists was without affording the writ
petitioners any opportunity of being heard. The third factor that may have
been taken into account by the writ court was the fact that the writ
petitioners’ services were regularised in June, 2006 whereas the private
respondents to the writ petition stood promoted to the same post as the
writ petitioners – Assistant Engineers – only in October, 2006 upon being
given retrospective effect pursuant to a notification issued in 2007.
11.
With respect, the second and third aspects taken into
consideration by the writ court need not have been adverted to at all. Once
it is evident that a particular position has been accepted by a person not
for a few months or a few years but for seven long years with repeated
publications being made in the interregnum, such person has no further
right to object to the position consistently indicated for such a long period
of time. In other words, even if the private respondents to the writ petition
could demonstrate that they had been wronged in the seniority list having
been erroneously published in the year 2009 and the error being repeated
down the years till 2017, the private respondents could not have obtained
a modification to the settled seniority list. Indeed, the applicable rules of
the employer permitted a representation or an objection to be raised
against a published seniority list within 30 days of its notification. Upon
a person having a grievance but choosing not to assert the same within
the stipulated time, the person is deemed to have acquiesced in the
position shown in the notification and in consciously not availing of the
right to object there to, waived the same. Such waiver was not limited to
the list published in 2009 but continued over the years in 2010, 2013,
2014, 2016 and 2017. Whatever may have been the grievance and
however justified the appellant or others of his ilk may have been, upon
the appellant and the similarly situated persons having consciously
waived their right to object to the seniority list published at least six times
before till 2017, a belated objection made in the year 2017 could not have
been entertained.
12.
At any rate, there is some solace in the fact that the writ
petitioners’ entry into the Assistant Engineer cadre was in June, 2006
which was a few months before the deemed entry of the private
respondents to the writ petition into the same cadre in October, 2006.
13.
Two special grounds have been urged by the appellant herein. The
appellant claims that at the time that the original seniority list was
published in the year 2009 and for a few years thereafter, the
Superintending Engineer, the person who was to take a decision in the
matter, was a close relative of the writ petitioners and, as such, inimical
to the private respondents to the writ petition and the private respondents
to the writ petition perceived such person to be unlikely to accept any
objection raised by the private respondents to the writ petition. A more
specious ground could not have been urged as an excuse for the abject
failure, despite due opportunity, on the part of the appellant and the
similarly placed persons in failing to object to the seniority list repeatedly
published in the same form over a period of eight years.
14.
The second ground taken by the appellant is that the proviso to
Rule 20(4) of the Meghalaya PHE Service Rules, 1996 is in favour of the
appellant and such aspect of the matter was not taken into consideration.
In the light of the basis of the decision being the failure on the part of the
appellant herein to object to the seniority list at the first available
opportunity and for a period of eight years, the merits of the matter need
no longer be gone into. Indeed, even if it is demonstrated to the hilt that
the original seniority list published in the year 2009 was erroneous and
the appellant deserved the place ahead of the writ petitioners therein, the
same cannot be corrected at this stage in view of the inaction on the part
of the appellant herein till the year 2017 and the waiver to object and
consequent acceptance on his part of the seniority position.
15.
The judgment and order impugned dated May 25, 2022 do not
call for any interference.
16.
MC (WA) No. 1 of 2023 is disposed of.
17.
WA No. 3 of 2023 is dismissed.
18.
There will, however, be no order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
13.02.2023
“Sylvana PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review