Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 16th September, 2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC010709292005
+
W.P.(C) 5368/2005
DTC
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC, DTC
with Mr. Nitesh Kumar Singh,
Ms. Aliza Alam and Mr.
Mohnish Sehrawat, Advs.
versus
SH ROHTASH SINGH
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Anil Mittal, Mr. Shaurya
Mittal and Mr. Atul Chauhan,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
AMIT MAHAJAN, J. (Oral)
1.
By the present petition, the petitioner challenges the award
dated 11.03.2004 (hereafter ‘impugned award’) passed by the
learned Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
in ID No. 137/90 whereby the learned Labour Court, noting that the
charge of non-issuance of tickets despite receipt of due fare had not
been made out against the respondent, had directed the petitioner to
reinstate the respondent with payment of 25% back wages.
2.
Succinctly put, the respondent was employed as a conductor
with the petitioner on 08.11.1979. It is the case against the respondent
that on 20.12.1988, when bus No. 6050 on Delhi – Faridabad route
was checked by the checking officials, four passengers were found to
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 5368/2005
KAUR
18:15:39
be alighting the bus without tickets who claimed that they had, in
aggregate, paid a sum of ₹16/- to the respondent (₹4/- per passenger)
and were not issued any ticket. It is further the case against the
respondent that on checking the cash available with the respondent, a
sum of ₹29.65 was found in excess.
3.
On the basis of the same, a chargesheet was issued to the
respondent on 17.01.1989. Thereafter, in the aftermath of the enquiry
proceedings, the charges against the respondent were found to be
proved and the respondent was removed from service with effect from
05.05.1989. The approval application preferred by the petitioner under
Section 33(2)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 was also
allowed. On that occasion, the learned Tribunal noted that the enquiry
was conducted in accordance with the principles of natural justice and
the respondent was given full opportunity to defend his case.
4.
Thereafter, in the industrial dispute raised by the respondent,
the learned Labour Court found that the enquiry was not fair and
proper. In doing so, the learned Labour Court noted that the onus was
on the management to prove that the enquiry was fair and in failing to
lead any evidence in that regard, the management had failed to
discharge the burden of proving that the enquiry proceedings were
proper.
5.
Further, by the impugned award, the learned Labour Court
noted that the management had failed to prove that the respondent had
collected fare from 4 passengers and had not issued tickets. For
rendering the said finding, the sole ground taken into consideration by
the learned Labour Court was that the management did not examine
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 5368/2005
KAUR
18:15:39
one Shri. Khem Chand who was the one who had recorded the
statements of the passengers. Consequently, it was found that the
management had failed to prove the charge of non-issuance of tickets.
On the second charge, the learned Labour Court noted that since the
respondent himself admitted that upon checking, a sum of ₹29.65/was found in excess, the said charge against the respondent stood
proved. On the basis of the aforesaid, the learned Labour Court
directed that the respondent be reinstated in service along with 25%
back wages. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner has filed the
present petition.
6.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
impugned award is perverse and is liable to be set aside. He submits
that the respondent has not denied that on the said date, the bus was
checked and four ticketless passengers were found. He submits that
the statements of the passengers were also countersigned by the
respondent. He submits that on checking, the cash was also found to
be in excess.
7.
He submits that the learned Labour Court erred in
reappreciating evidence and finding the enquiry to be perverse only
because the management did not produce any evidence before the
learned Labour Court. He submits that the material before the enquiry
officer was sufficient to prove the charges against the respondent.
8.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent submits that
the impugned award is well reasoned and warrants no interference by
this Court. He submits that since the management failed to produce
one Khem Chand who had recorded the statement of the passengers
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 5368/2005
KAUR
18:15:39
and had checked the cash of the respondent, the charge against the
respondent was rightly found to be not proved.
9.
By order dated 26.03.2008, the application preferred by the
respondent under Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
was allowed. Subsequently, on 17.07.2009, on the petitioner’s
statement that he was ready to take the respondent back on duty, the
respondent had resumed his duties with the petitioner. On 11.08.2011,
learned counsel for the petitioner clarified that for the period during
which the respondent workman was taken back on duty, in lieu of
Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 he would be paid
regular wages; and if discontinued thereafter, the respondent would
continue to receive wages as per Section 17B of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947.
10.
I have heard the counsel and perused the record.
11.
In the present case, on a holistic appraisal of the entire material
on record, this Court is of the view that the learned Labour Court
erroneously found the enquiry to be unfair and perverse. Further on
merits as well, undue emphasis was placed on the non-examination of
Khem Chand or any of the passengers before the learned Labour in
rendering the finding that there was no material to prove the
misconduct of the respondent. Before this Court adverts to pen its
reasons, it is pertinent to note that in departmental enquiry, the
standard of proof is one of preponderance of probabilities and not
beyond reasonable doubt. In that regard, while dealing with the aspect
of sufficiency of evidence in a departmental enquiry, the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of State of Haryana v. Rattan Singh : (1977)
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 5368/2005
KAUR
18:15:39
2 SCC 491 observed as under:
“4. It is well settled that in a domestic enquiry the strict and
sophisticated rules of evidence under the Indian Evidence
Act may not apply. All materials which are logically
probative for a prudent mind are permissible. There is no
allergy to hearsay evidence provided it has reasonable nexus
and credibility. It is true that departmental authorities and
Administrative Tribunals must be careful in evaluating such
material and should not glibly swallow what is strictly
speaking not relevant under the Indian Evidence Act. For this
proposition it is not necessary to cite decisions nor text books,
although we have been taken through case-law and other
authorities by counsel on both sides. The essence of a judicial
approach is objectivity, exclusion of extraneous materials or
considerations and observance of rules of natural justice. Of
course, fairplay is the basis and if perversity or arbitrariness,
bias or surrender of independence of judgment vitiate the
conclusions reached, such finding, even though of a domestic
tribunal, cannot be held good. However, the courts below
misdirected themselves, perhaps, in insisting that passengers
who had come in and gone out should be chased and brought
before the tribunal before a valid finding could be recorded.
The ‘residuum’ rule to which counsel for the respondent
referred, based upon certain passages from American
Jurisprudence does not go to that extent nor does the
passage from Halsbury insist on such rigid requirement. The
simple point is, was there some evidence or was there no
evidence — not in the sense of the technical rules governing
regular court proceedings but in a fair commonsense way as
men of understanding and worldly wisdom will accept.
Viewed in this way, sufficiency of evidence in proof of the
finding by a domestic tribunal is beyond scrutiny. Absence of
any evidence in support of a finding is certainly available for
the court to look into because it amounts to an error of law
apparent on the record. We find, in this case, that the
evidence of Chamanlal, Inspector of the Flying Squad, is some
evidence which has relevance to the charge levelled against
the respondent. Therefore, we are unable to hold that the
order is invalid on that ground.”
(emphasis supplied)
12.
Adverting now to the merits of the present case, the learned
Labour Court found the enquiry proceedings to be unfair merely
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 5368/2005
KAUR
18:15:39
because the management had not led evidence before it to prove that
the enquiry was conducted in a proper manner. The learned Labour
Court noted that the management had failed to examine the
passengers. Further, the learned Labour Court noted that since the
management failed to examine Shri Khem Chand, one who had
recorded the statement of the passengers and checked the cash of the
respondent, there was no material to prove misconduct of the
respondent.
13.
In doing so, the learned Labour Court virtually undertook a
fresh appreciation of evidence and substituted its own conclusions by
insisting upon further corroborative material. From a perusal of the
enquiry report and the other material on record, it is apparent that as
per the Inspection Report, when the respondent was confronted with
the passengers, he admitted his fault. The statement of the passengers
were recorded on the back of the challan and the same was also
countersigned by the respondent. In fact, as per the respondent’s own
admission, when cash was checked, he was found in possession of
excess cash by ₹29.60/-.
14.
The record reveals that the copy of the challan was supplied to
the respondent. Consequently, when chargesheet was issued, the
respondent was given 10 days’ time to reply to the same. The
respondent furnished the reply which was not found satisfactory
leading to initiation of enquiry against the respondent. The respondent
actively participated in the proceedings, he was explained the charges
and he also denied assistance of any co-worker. Sufficient opportunity
to defend the case, including opportunity to examine and crossSignature Not Verified
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 5368/2005
KAUR
18:15:39
examine, was duly provided and availed by the respondent. In fact, the
enquiry report reveals that the respondent only cross-examined Shri
Niwas (who was also examined before the learned Labour Court) and
rather refused to cross examine Shri Khem Chand – the absence of
whose examination before the learned Labour Court has been
considered to cast a fatal blow to the case of the management.
15.
On an appraisal of the same, it cannot be said that there was no
material before the learned Labour Court merely because Shri Khem
Chand who had recorded the statement of the passengers or the
passengers themselves were not examined before the learned Labour
Court. It is no longer res integra that non examination of passengers
does not vitiate the enquiry proceedings [Ref. State of Haryana v.
Rattan Singh : (1977) 2 SCC 491]. Further, merely because Shri
Khem Chand himself was not examined does not efface the other
material against the respondent. In the opinion of this Court, the
approach taken by the learned Labour Court proceeds on an erroneous
standard of proof. As noted above, a disciplinary enquiry is not
governed by the strict rules of evidence applicable to criminal
proceedings. The misconduct is required to be established only on the
touchstone of preponderance of probabilities. Once there existed
material in the form of the checking report, signatures of the
respondent thereon, admission of presence of excess cash, the Enquiry
Officer could reasonably arrive at the conclusion that the charges
stood proved. Infact, Shri Niwas, though was not the person to have
recorded the statement of the passengers or checked the cash, he was
one of the raiding team members who had categorically deposed even
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 5368/2005
KAUR
18:15:39
before the enquiry officer that he was performing duties along side
Khem Chand and when the bus was checked four persons were found
ticketless who claimed to have paid the due fare to the respondent.
16.
Furthermore, while this Court ought not and is not roving into a
detailed examination of the evidence, undisputedly, the application
preferred by the petitioner under Section 33(2)(b) of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 was allowed by the learned Industrial Tribunal and
on that occasion, while finding the enquiry to be fair, the learned
Tribunal had holistically appraised the evidence on record. Further, on
that occasion, Shri Khem Chand (who recorded the statement of the
passengers and also checked the cash of the respondent) was also
examined who categorically deposed that when the bus was checked
four passengers were found without tickets who had paid due fare to
the respondent. Although, the Tribunal in the proceedings under
Section 33(2)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is only required
to take a prima facie view and the width of jurisdiction in the
proceedings under Section 10 and 11A of the Industrial Disputes Act,
1947 is wider, on a holistic appraisal of the facts, this Court is of the
opinion that there existed sufficient material on record for the learned
Labour Court to have come to a conclusion that the charges stood
proved on the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities.
17.
The learned Labour Court thus, while finding that the enquiry
was not fair and proper, and insisting only on the non-examination of
Shri Khem Chand in oblivion to the other material on record,
exceeded the permissible limits of judicial scrutiny over departmental
proceedings.
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 5368/2005
KAUR
18:15:39
18.
Consequently, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
findings recorded by the learned Labour Court setting aside enquiry
proceedings cannot be sustained. The impugned award suffers from
patent infirmity inasmuch as it re-appreciates the evidence as an
appellate authority and applies a standard of proof alien to domestic
disciplinary proceedings.
19.
Insofar as the amounts paid to the Respondent pursuant to the
order passed under Section 17B of the Industrial Disputes Act are
concerned, it is settled that such payments are not recoverable from
the workman as they are subsistence allowance granted when the
Workman remains unemployed. Therefore, no direction for recovery
thereof is called for.
20.
The writ petition stands allowed in the aforesaid terms and the
impugned award is set aside.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
SEPTEMBER 16, 2026
‘KDK’
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 5368/2005
KAUR
18:15:39
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review