Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 06.05.2026
Date of decision: 17.08.2026
Uploaded on: 17.08.2026
#
+
CNR No: DLHC011077262010
W.P.(C) 4943/2010 & CM APPL. 9765/2010
DTC
.....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Manisha Singh, Mr. George
Pothan Poothicote, Mr. Kanav
Khatan, Ms. Jyoti Singh and Ms.
Ojeswita Singh, Advs.
versus
PRATAP SINGH
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Anil Mittal, Mr. Atul Chauhan,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
JUDGMENT
SHAIL JAIN, J.
1.
The present Writ Petition has been filed by the Petitioner, Delhi
Transport Corporation, under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of
India, assailing the Award dated 19th March, 2009 (hereinafter referred to as
the “Impugned Award”) passed by the learned Presiding Officer, POLCXVII, Karkardooma Court, Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the “ Labour
Court”) arising out of an industrial dispute between the petitioner Management/Delhi Transport Corporation (hereinafter referred to as
“DTC”) and the respondent–workman, Sh. Pratap Singh.
2.
The petitioner also assails the order dated 30.09.2004 passed by the
Labour Court on preliminary issue viz the Departmental Enquiry.
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
FACTS:
3.
The respondent joined the services of the petitioner–Delhi Transport
Corporation ("DTC") as a Driver(Retainer) on 06.02.1981.
4.
The controversy commenced with the issuance of a charge-sheet
dated 28.06.1994 alleging that the respondent had remained absent from
duty, without authority or sanctioned leave, for a period of 139 days
between September 1993 to May 1994. The respondent submitted his
explanation to the charge-sheet, pursuant whereto a domestic enquiry was
initiated in accordance with the applicable service regulations.
5.
According to the respondent, while explaining the circumstances in
which he remained absent, he never admitted the charge leveled against him.
His grievance is that the Inquiry Officer misconstrued his explanation as an
admission of guilt and, proceeding on that premise, returned a finding
holding the charge of unauthorized absence to be proved.
6.
Accepting the findings returned in the enquiry report, the disciplinary
authority passed an order dated 28.11.1994 removing the respondent from
service. Aggrieved thereby, the respondent invoked the jurisdiction of the
Labour Court by raising an industrial dispute assailing the order of removal.
7.
Vide an order dated 30.09.2004, the Labour Court held that the
domestic enquiry stood vitiated, observing that the respondent's explanation
could not be construed as an unequivocal admission of guilt. The issue
relating to the validity of the enquiry was, accordingly, answered in favor of
the respondent-workman.
8.
Consequent upon the enquiry having been held to be vitiated, the
parties were afforded an opportunity to lead evidence before the Labour
Court on the merits of the dispute.
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
9.
Upon appreciation of the evidence so led, the Labour Court, by its
Award dated 19.03.2009, concluded that the respondent's removal from
service was illegal and unjustified and, consequently, directed his
reinstatement with continuity of service and 10% back wages.
10.
The petitioner has, by means of the present writ petition under
Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, laid challenge both to the
order whereby the domestic enquiry was held to be vitiated as well as to the
consequential Award directing reinstatement.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE PETITIONER:
11.
Assailing the impugned Award, learned counsel for the petitioner
submits, at the outset, that the Labour Court fundamentally erred in holding
the domestic enquiry to be vitiated. According to him, the respondent had,
during the course of the enquiry itself, admitted the factum of his
unauthorized absence. Once such admission existed, the Labour Court could
not have ignored the same and proceeded to hold that the charges had not
been established. The finding that the enquiry stood vitiated is, therefore,
urged to be contrary to the record.
12.
Proceeding further, it is contended that, the respondent having
admitted the misconduct, no occasion arose to invoke the principles of
natural justice. The respondent was afforded every opportunity to defend
himself during the enquiry, including the opportunity to lead evidence and
make his final submissions. Having chosen not to avail of such
opportunities, he cannot subsequently complain that the enquiry suffered
from procedural infirmity.
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
13.
Learned counsel would further submit that prolonged unauthorized
absence from duty has consistently been recognized as grave misconduct.
The Labour Court, according to him, overlooked the settled legal position
that an employee who remains absent from duty for an extended period
without authority commits misconduct warranting a major penalty. The
punishment of removal, viewed in the backdrop of the nature and gravity of
the misconduct, is, therefore, stated to be wholly proportionate.
14.
It is next contended that, once the respondent admitted the factum of
absence, the burden shifted upon him to establish that such absence was
neither willful nor attributable to negligence. Instead, the Labour Court
erroneously cast the burden upon the petitioner-management and thereby
misdirected itself on a fundamental principle governing disciplinary
proceedings.
15.
The petitioner further submits that the Labour Court travelled beyond
the limits of its jurisdiction while examining the validity of the domestic
enquiry. Rather than confining itself to the limited scope of judicial review
over disciplinary proceedings, it virtually assumed the role of an appellate
authority and re-appreciated the findings recorded by the Inquiry Officer.
Such an approach, according to the petitioner, runs contrary to the settled
principles governing interference with domestic enquiries.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE RESPONDENT:
16.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent supports the
impugned Award and submits that no case for interference under Articles
226 and 227 of the Constitution is made out.
17.
At the threshold, it is submitted that the Labour Court rightly
concluded that the domestic enquiry stood vitiated, as the respondent had
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
never made any clear or unequivocal admission of guilt. The Inquiry
Officer, according to the respondent, erroneously elevated the explanation
furnished by him regarding the circumstances of his absence to the status of
an admission and proceeded to record findings of guilt solely on that basis.
18.
It is further submitted that, after the enquiry had been declared
invalid, the petitioner was granted adequate opportunity to establish the
misconduct independently before the Labour Court. Despite such
opportunity, however, the petitioner failed to produce the material records
necessary to substantiate the allegation of unauthorized absence. The Labour
Court was, therefore, fully justified in returning findings against the
petitioner.
19.
Learned counsel also points out that the respondent had submitted
leave applications which were never rejected or communicated as rejected.
Indeed, according to the respondent, the petitioner itself admitted before the
Labour Court that no communication rejecting the leave applications had
ever been issued, in derogation of its own service regulations.
20.
Developing the submission further, it is urged that the Labour Court is
the final fact-finding authority under the Industrial Disputes Act and that the
conclusions recorded by it are based on a proper appreciation of the oral as
well as documentary evidence available on record. No perversity, illegality
or jurisdictional error, warranting interference in exercise of writ
jurisdiction, is shown to exist.
21.
The respondent thus submits that the present writ petition, in
substance, seeks nothing more than a re-appreciation of evidence and
substitution of the findings recorded by the Labour Court with another
possible view. Such an exercise, it is contended, falls outside the well-
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
recognized limits of judicial review under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution and the petition, therefore, deserves to be dismissed.
DISCUSSION & ANALYSIS :
22.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
impugned Award, the order dated 30.09.2004 passed by the learned Labour
Court on the preliminary issue concerning the validity of the domestic
enquiry, as well as the material placed on record, this Court is of the view
that the controversy falls for consideration in three distinct stages. The first
concerns the validity of the domestic enquiry conducted against the
respondent-workman. The second concerns the finding recorded by the
learned Labour Court on the charge of unauthorized absence, upon the
evidence led by the parties after the enquiry was held to be invalid. The third
concerns the relief of reinstatement with continuity of service and 10% back
wages granted to the respondent.
23.
At the outset, it is necessary to bear in mind the limited scope of
interference available to this Court in exercise of jurisdiction under Articles
226 and 227 of the Constitution. This Court does not sit as an appellate
authority over an Industrial Tribunal or Labour Court and ordinarily does
not substitute its own appreciation of evidence for that of the adjudicating
authority. At the same time, where the decision under challenge proceeds
upon an erroneous legal principle, ignores material evidence, suffers from
perversity, or the decision-making process itself is vitiated by an error of law
or violation of the principles of natural justice, interference would be
warranted.
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
24.
The first issue, therefore, is whether the learned Labour Court was
justified in holding, by its order dated 30.09.2004, that the domestic enquiry
conducted against the respondent stood vitiated.
25.
The law relating to the minimum requirements of a fair and proper
domestic enquiry is well settled. In Sur Enamel and Stamping Works Ltd.
v. Workmen, 1963 SCC Online SC 97, the Supreme Court held that a
domestic enquiry cannot be regarded as properly conducted merely because
the employer has gone through the formal motions of an enquiry. The
employee must be informed clearly of the charges, must be afforded an
opportunity to meet the evidence against him, including an opportunity to
cross-examine witnesses where necessary, must be afforded an opportunity
to lead evidence in defense, and the Enquiry Officer must record his findings
upon consideration of the material before him. The relevant extract reads as
under:
“4. It has been laid down by this Court in a series of
decisions that if an industrial employee's services are
terminated after a proper Domestic enquiry held in
accordance with the Rules of natural justice and the
conclusions reached at the enquiry are not perverse the
Industrial Tribunal is not entitled to consider the
propriety or the correctness of the said conclusions. In
a number of cases which have come to this Court in
recent months, we find that some employers have
misunderstood the decisions of this Court to mean that
the mere form of an enquiry would satisfy the
requirements of industrial law and would protect the
disciplinary action taken by them from challenge. This
attitude is wholly misconceived. An enquiry cannot be
said to have been properly held unless, (i) the
employee proceeded against has been informed clearly
of the charges levelled against him, (ii) the witnesses
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
are examined — ordinarily in the presence of the
employee — in respect of the charges, (iii) the
employee is given a fair opportunity to cross-examine
witnesses, (iv) he is given a fair opportunity to examine
witnesses including himself in his defense if he so
wishes on any relevant matter, and (v) the enquiry
officer records his findings with reasons for the same
in his report. In the present case the persons whose
statements made behind the backs of the employees
were used by the enquiring authority were not made
available for cross-examination but it would appear
that they were not even present at the enquiry. It does
not even appear that these reports were made available
to the employee at any time before the enquiry was
held. Even if the persons who made the reports had
been present and the employee given an opportunity to
cross-examine them, it would have been difficult to say
in these circumstances that that was a fair and
sufficient opportunity. But in this case it appears that
the persons who made the reports did not attend the
enquiry at all. From whatever aspect the matter is
examined is clear that there was no enquiry worth the
name and the Tribunal was justified in entirely
ignoring the conclusion reached by the Domestic
Tribunal.”
(Emphasis applied)
26.
These requirements, however, do not mean that a domestic enquiry is
to be tested on the same standards as a criminal trial. Nevertheless, a
domestic enquiry must adhere to a fair and reasonable procedure. A
departmental enquiry is essentially a fact-finding proceeding, but the
requirement of natural justice cannot be reduced to the mere observance of
procedural formalities. What is required is that the delinquent employee be
afforded a real, effective and meaningful opportunity to know, meet and
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
defend the case against him. The question, therefore, is not merely whether
an opportunity was formally afforded, but whether the procedure adopted
was such as enabled the employee to meaningfully avail of that opportunity
and whether any denial or curtailment thereof caused prejudice to his
defense.
27.
The distinction between a denial of opportunity and a mere failure to
avail of an opportunity is, in this context, fundamental. An employee who,
after being afforded a genuine and effective opportunity, chooses not to
avail of it cannot subsequently complain of violation of natural justice.
Equally, however, the employer cannot discharge its obligation merely by
recording, as a matter of form, that an opportunity was afforded. The Court
must examine the substance of the proceedings to determine whether the
opportunity so afforded was real and capable of being effectively utilized by
the delinquent employee.
28.
Examined from this perspective, this Court prima facie finds no
infirmity in the conclusion of the learned Labour Court that the domestic
enquiry stood vitiated for violation of the principles of natural justice.
29.
It is reflected from the order of the learned Labour Court that
considerable emphasis was placed upon the nature of the enquiry report and
the manner in which the alleged opportunities to the respondent were
recorded therein. The enquiry report as is reflected from the records is a
one-page, pre-typed document, containing recitals to the effect that the
respondent had been afforded an opportunity to represent his case, to
produce witnesses and to make his submissions, with the document
ultimately bearing his signature.
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
30.
Such formal recitals, however, cannot by themselves establish
compliance with the principles of natural justice. What was required was a
meaningful opportunity to participate in the enquiry and to defend the
charge. The material on record does not satisfactorily demonstrate that the
opportunities recorded in the pre-typed enquiry report were actually
extended and meaningfully available to the respondent. The manner in
which the enquiry report came to be prepared, coupled with the absence of
any substantive material evidencing effective participation by the
respondent in his defense, supports the conclusion reached by the learned
Labour Court that the opportunity afforded to him was merely formal.
31.
The fact that the respondent was given an option to engage a
representative but chose to conduct his defense himself cannot, by itself,
amount to a waiver of his right to a fair enquiry. Likewise, his signature
upon the pre-typed enquiry report cannot be treated as an unequivocal
acknowledgment that he had been afforded a meaningful opportunity to
defend himself. The enquiry proceedings must stand the test of substance
and cannot be sustained merely on the basis of formal endorsements.
32.
The petitioner’s contention that the respondent did not examine
witnesses, produce documents or otherwise avail of the opportunities
allegedly afforded to him, therefore, cannot be accepted as sufficient to cure
the defect. Had the record demonstrated that the respondent was given a
genuine opportunity to lead his defense and had thereafter consciously
chosen not to do so, the position would have been different. In the present
case, however, the very manner in which the enquiry was conducted does
not establish that such an effective opportunity was ever made available to
him.
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
33.
The finding of the learned Labour Court that the domestic enquiry
was vitiated is, accordingly, upheld. This Court finds no perversity,
illegality or jurisdictional error in the said finding warranting interference
under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
34.
The aforesaid conclusion, however, does not bring the matter to an
end. Once a domestic enquiry is held to be vitiated, the question whether the
misconduct alleged against the workman was nevertheless established on the
evidence subsequently led before the Labour Court requires independent
consideration.
35.
The respondent did not dispute the basic fact of his absence from duty
during the period in question. His explanation was that his wife was
pregnant and required to undergo delivery and that, being the sole caretaker
of his family, he was required to remain with her. His case was further that
he had applied for leave and that the leave applications had been sent
through a person known to him in his village. Thus, the respondent did not
dispute the factum of absence; his defense was that such absence was
justified and ought to have been treated as authorized leave.
36.
The evidence led before the learned Labour Court, however, does not
establish that the leave allegedly applied for by the respondent was ever
sanctioned. The person through whom the leave applications were stated to
have been forwarded was unable to furnish particulars regarding the precise
dates or circumstances in which the applications were delivered to the
management. The respondent himself admitted that he was not aware
whether the leave applications had been rejected by the management.
37.
It is also significant that, despite relying upon the pregnancy and
related medical circumstances of his wife and child as justification for his
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
prolonged absence, the respondent did not produce material of sufficient
probative value to establish that the entire period of 139 days was covered
by such circumstances. The documents relied upon before the learned
Labour Court, as noticed in the Award, did not correspond to or
satisfactorily account for the entire period of absence.
38.
As per the case of the petitioner-DTC, the respondent was absent for a
total period of 139 days between September 1993 and May 1994. The
absence was not necessarily continuous throughout this entire period; rather,
the allegation was of absence on different days falling within the said
period. This circumstance assumes significance. The respondent, having
admittedly remained absent on the dates in question, had sufficient
opportunity to ascertain the status of the leave allegedly applied for and to
produce material demonstrating that the same had been sanctioned or
otherwise authorized.
39.
Once the factum of absence stood admitted, the evidentiary burden of
establishing that such absence was sanctioned or otherwise justified lay
upon the respondent. The ultimate burden of proving misconduct
undoubtedly remained upon the management; however, the respondent
could not, after admitting his absence and setting up a positive defence that
the absence was authorized by leave, remain without producing material to
substantiate that defense.
40.
The learned Labour Court, nevertheless, appears to have placed
considerable emphasis upon the non-production of the original Master
Attendance Register and the leave applications by the management and
proceeded on the premise that, since neither party had conclusively
established its case in its entirety, the charge could not be held to have been
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
proved. In the facts of the present case, such an approach does not appear to
be justified.
41.
The absence of the original Master Attendance Register, by itself,
could not efface the respondent's admission regarding his absence. Nor
could the management be required to establish the fact of absence on every
individual date in a manner akin to proof in a criminal prosecution,
particularly when the factum of absence itself was not disputed. The
relevant question was whether the respondent had remained absent without
sanctioned leave or authority and whether the explanation furnished by him
satisfactorily established otherwise.
42.
The respondent's explanation that he remained away from duty on
account of circumstances prevailing in his family may explain why he chose
to remain absent; it does not, by itself, establish that the absence was
authorized. Similarly, the assertion that leave applications had been sent
through another person cannot amount to proof of sanctioned leave,
particularly when neither the respondent nor the person through whom the
applications were allegedly forwarded could establish that the leave had in
fact been sanctioned by the management.
43.
The learned Labour Court, therefore, fell into error in treating the
absence of certain documentary evidence from the side of the management
as sufficient to neutralize the admitted fact of absence and the respondent's
failure to substantiate his defense. The evidentiary burden arising from the
admitted fact of absence was not discharged merely by offering an
explanation for such absence.
44.
The material on record further reflects that the respondent had a
substantial past disciplinary record, with more than thirty entries relating to
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
instances of misconduct. It is true that several of these proceedings resulted
only in caution, warning or minor penalties, and such past conduct cannot
constitute proof of the specific charge involved in the present proceedings. It
is, however, a relevant circumstance while considering the nature of the
misconduct and the question of punishment.
45.
Unauthorized absence, particularly when frequent and extending over
a substantial number of days, is a matter of serious concern in a disciplined
organization such as the DTC. The fact that the absence occurred on
different dates over a period extending from September 1993 to May 1994
does not dilute the misconduct; rather, it indicates repeated instances of
absence for which the respondent was required to establish authorization or
justification.
46.
In the present case, the respondent admittedly remained absent for
139 days and failed to establish that the said absence was covered by
sanctioned leave. The medical documents relied upon by him did not
satisfactorily account for the period in which he remained absent as those
documents were qua the month of April, 1993 and the absence in dispute
related to the period from September 1993 to May 1994. The learned Labour
Court, therefore, erred in extending the benefit of doubt to the respondent
merely on account of the non-production of the original Master Attendance
Register and certain leave-related documents by the management, despite
the admitted factum of absence and the respondent's failure to establish that
such absence had been duly authorized.
47.
The learned counsel appearing for the respondent has relied upon
Chikkam Koteswara Rao v. Chikkam Subbarao, AIR 1971 SC 1542; Life
Insurance Corporation of India v. R. Suresh, (2008) 11 SCC 319; Mavji C.
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
Lakum v. Central Bank of India, (2008) 12 SCC 726; and State of
Haryana v. Devi Dutt, (2006) 13 SCC 32, in support of the submission that
the findings of the learned Labour Court ought not to be interfered with and
that the punishment imposed upon the respondent warranted interference.
48.
The reliance placed upon these decisions, however, does not advance
the case of the respondent in the facts and circumstances of the present case
49.
In Chikkam Koteswara Rao v. Chikkam Subbarao, AIR 1971 SC
1542, the Supreme Court dealt with the evidentiary effect of an admission.
The said principle is not attracted in the present case, where the respondent
admittedly remained absent and his case was only that such absence was
justified and covered by leave.
50.
In LIC v. R. Suresh, (2008) 11 SCC 319, and Mavji C. Lakum v.
Central Bank of India, (2008) 12 SCC 726, the Supreme Court considered
the powers of the Industrial Adjudicator under Section 11-A of the Industrial
Disputes Act, including the question of proportionality of punishment.
Those decisions turned upon their respective facts and do not lay down that
reinstatement must follow merely because the domestic enquiry is found to
be defective. In the present case, the misconduct was subsequently
established on the evidence led before the Labour Court.
51.
Likewise, State of Haryana v. Devi Dutt, (2006) 13 SCC 32,
reiterates the limited scope of interference by a writ Court with findings of
fact. The present case, however, involves an erroneous appreciation of the
evidentiary effect of the admitted absence of the respondent and his failure
to establish that the absence was sanctioned or otherwise justified. The
interference is, therefore, not on account of a mere re-appreciation of
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
evidence, but on account of the erroneous approach adopted by the learned
Labour Court in determining whether the misconduct stood established.
52.
The aforesaid judgments, therefore, do not assist the respondent in the
facts and circumstances of the present case. The finding that the domestic
enquiry was vitiated is liable to be upheld. The finding of the learned
Labour Court that the misconduct had not been established is,
accordingly, unsustainable. The material on record, when considered as a
whole, establishes that the respondent's absence was unauthorized and
constituted misconduct.
53.
The next question is whether the punishment of removal from service
warrants interference.
54.
The power of a Labour Court to interfere with the punishment
imposed by the disciplinary authority is not to be exercised merely because
another punishment may appear to be preferable. The disciplinary authority
is ordinarily best placed to assess the seriousness of the misconduct and the
appropriate penalty. Interference is warranted where the punishment is
shockingly disproportionate to the misconduct or where the relevant
circumstances have been wholly ignored.
55.
In the present case, the misconduct relates to prolonged and repeated
unauthorised absence aggregating to 139 days. The factum of absence
during the relevant period was not disputed by the respondent. His
explanation was that he had applied for leave and that, for certain periods,
the leave applications had been sent through another person or that the
department had been informed telephonically. Once the misconduct is
proved or found to have been established, the punishment imposed by the
disciplinary authority ordinarily deserves to be upheld, unless it is
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
demonstrated
that
the
punishment
is
so
grossly
or
shockingly
disproportionate to the misconduct proved as to warrant judicial
interference.
56.
In the present case, admittedly, the workman was absent for 139 days,
as reflected in the charge-sheet. Though such absence was not the subject
matter of the charge-sheet, it has been repeatedly stated by the management
that the workman had also remained absent on previous occasions, i.e. prior
to the charge-sheet, and even during the enquiry he had remained absent for
certain days. This aspect could have been taken into consideration by the
management while awarding punishment to the workman. Once the
misconduct is held to have been proved, this Court does not find any
justification to interfere with the punishment of dismissal awarded to the
workman.
57.
In the present case, the learned Labour Court's order granting
reinstatement with continuity of service and back wages proceeded
substantially from its conclusion that the misconduct itself had not been
proved. Once that foundational conclusion is found to be unsustainable and
the domestic enquiry is held to be vitiated, the consequential relief granted
by the Labour Court cannot independently survive.
58.
This Court is, therefore, of the view that, though the learned Labour
Court was correct in holding the domestic enquiry to be vitiated, it erred
thereafter, while considering the evidence led before it, in extending the
benefit of doubt to the respondent merely because both parties had not
produced every piece of evidence that could have been produced. The
admitted fact of absence, coupled with the respondent’s failure to establish
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
that such prolonged absence was duly authorised or sanctioned, could not
have been disregarded in the manner in which it has been done.
59.
The impugned Award, insofar as it holds the removal of the
respondent to be illegal and unjustified and consequently directs his
reinstatement with continuity of service and 10% back wages, therefore,
cannot be sustained.
60.
At the same time, this Court does not consider it necessary to
undertake any further re-appreciation of the entire evidentiary record beyond
what is necessary for determining the legality of the impugned Award. The
interference herein is founded upon the erroneous legal approach adopted by
the learned Labour Court in relation to the validity of the domestic enquiry
and the consequent assessment of the charge and relief, and not upon a mere
substitution of this Court's view for another possible view on the evidence.
61.
The order of the learned Labour Court dated 30.09.2004 holding the
domestic enquiry to be vitiated is upheld. However, the consequential
Award dated 19.03.2009 directing reinstatement with continuity of service
and 10% back wages is quashed. The order of removal from service, being
founded upon misconduct which stands established on the evidence, is
consequently restored.
62.
The Writ petition is, accordingly, partly allowed to the aforesaid
extent. Pending application(s) if any, stand disposed of. There shall be no
order as to costs.
SHAIL JAIN
JUDGE
AUGUST 17, 2026/HP
Signed By:POOJA DUTT
15:09:10
W.P.(C) 4943/2010
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review