Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC010485122022
+
CS(COMM) 897/2022 and I.A. 22071/2022
Date of Decision: 25.09.2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
1. DS INTELLECTUAL PROPERTIES LLP
4828/24, PLOT NO. 2, GF BASEMENT, WARD NO. XI,
DARYA GANJ, NEW DELHI- 110 002, DELHI, INDIA
2. DHARAMPAL SATYAPAL LIMITED,
98, OKHLA INDUSTRIAL ESTATE, PHASE- III,
NEW DELHI-110020
.....Plaintiffs
(Through: Ms. Vaishali Mittal, Mr. Siddhant Chamola and Mr.
Shivang Sharma, Advocates.)
versus
1. ABHINAV SINGH
(DETAILS PROVIDED BY BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED)
MD. SHAKIR QURAISHI
S/O HABIB QUARISHI
VILLAGE BANAUTIYA, ANCHAL THANA, BIHARSHARIF,
NALANDA, BIHAR -803101
AND
1-A, RAJA BAZAR, SAHEB BAGAN,
KOLKATA, WEST BENGAL-700009
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
2. RUDRA PRATAP
(DETAILS PROVIDED BY BANK OF INDIA)
MR. APPA BHIKU NIKAM,
AT POST RAMPUR,TAL-CHIPLUN
DIST: RATNAGIRI -415605
3. KRISNIN PHARMA
OWNER OF THE DOMAIN NAME
< HTTPS://ONLINERAJNIGANDHARETAIL.IN/>
PHYSICAL ADDRESS: DELHI, INDIA
4. RAJNIGANDHA DISTRIBUTORS PRIVATE LIMITED,
3A MANGOE LANE,
4TH FLOOR, KOLKATA,
WEST BENGAL 700001
5. TRAFFIC TAIL TECHNOLOGIES PRIVATE LIMITED,
CIN NO. U72200DL2021PTC388418
LGF-1, KH. NO. 357/302,
VILLAGE SAIDULAJAB,
NEAR SAKET METRO STATION,
NEW DELHI DL 110030
.....Defendants
(Through:
None.)
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV
JUDGEMENT
PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV, J. (ORAL)
1.
By the present suit, the plaintiffs, inter alia, seek a decree of
permanent injunction restraining defendant nos. 1 to 5 from using the
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
trademarks/trading names “DS GROUP”, “RAJNIGANDHA” and variants
thereof, including as a domain name, or otherwise dealing in goods/services
thereunder, amounting to infringement of the plaintiffs’ trademarks and
copyright, passing off, unfair competition, unjust enrichment and dilution.
The plaintiffs further seek suspension, locking and transfer of the domain
name “www.onlinerajnigandharetail.in” by defendant no. 6; freezing of the
bank accounts of defendant nos. 1 to 5 by defendant no. 7; disclosure by
defendant no. 8 of their KYC, mobile and GPS details; delivery-up of the
impugned materials; rendition of accounts and damages; declaration of the
“DS GROUP” marks as well-known trademarks; and costs.
2.
The case set up by the plaintiffs is that, in December 2022, they came
across the website “www.onlinerajnigandharetail.in”, which was allegedly
being used to lure members of the public into paying money under the
pretext of offering “RAJNIGANDHA” distributorships. It is averred that
defendant nos. 1 to 5 had registered and were operating the said domain,
through which dealerships/distributorships in the name of DS Group were
being promoted, while prominently displaying the plaintiffs’ trademarks and
mentioning the address of the plaintiffs’ zonal office in Telangana as the
corporate office address. It is further alleged that defendant nos. 1 and 2,
representing themselves as employees of the plaintiffs, were offering
distributorships under the mark “RAJNIGANDHA” and collecting monies
from members of the public, and that the defendants had also copied the
plaintiffs’ privacy policy, thereby infringing the plaintiffs’ copyright.
3.
The plaintiffs are the registered proprietors of the trademark “DS
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
GROUP”
well
as
and its corresponding composite/device marks, as
the
trademark
“RAJNIGANDHA”
and
its
formative/label marks.
4.
The plaint was first taken up for hearing on 22.12.2022, when the
same was registered as a suit and summons were directed to be issued to the
defendants. Vide order dated 22.12.2022, this Court also granted an ex parte
ad-interim injunction in terms of the directions contained in paragraph 31
thereof. The paragraph no. 31 of the order dated 22.12.2022 is extracted as
under:
“31. Consequently, till the next date of hearing, an ex parte ad interim
injunction order is passed in the following terms:
I. The defendants no.1 to 5, their partners or proprietor, as the case
may be, their principal officers, servants and agents, and all others
acting on their behalf are restrained from offering for sale or
advertising directly or indirectly fake distributorships/dealerships of
the plaintiffs or using the plaintiffs' "DS Group" and "Rajnigandha"
trademarks or any other marks identical and/or deceptively similar
thereto.
II. The defendants no.1 to 5 are further restrained from using the
impugned domain name, being "https://onlinerajnigandharetail.in",
and the e-mail address "dsgroup@rajnigandhadealership.online" or
any other e-mail addresses similar thereto.
III. The defendants no. 1 to 5 are directed to file a statement of
accounts within four weeks of service of notice in the present
application, giving the details of the amounts collected by them by
offering of dealerships/distributorships under the plaintiffs' marks
through the aforesaid website.
IV. The defendant no.6 is directed to suspend and lock the domain
name "https//onlinerajnigandharetail.in" .
V. The defendant no.6 is directed to disclose all details made available
by the defendants no. 1 to 5 at the time of purchasing/issuance of the
domain name https://onlinerajnigandharetail.in / along with the
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
transaction details through which payment was made.
VI. The defendant no.7 is directed to freeze the bank account bearing
Account 148310110002297, IFSC Code BKID0001483. The defendant
no.7 is also directed to disclose the KYC details in respect of the
aforesaid Bank Account.
VII. The defendant no.7 is directed to place on record the up to date
bank statement pertaining to account no. 148310110002297 having
IFSC Code BKID0001483 since the said bank account was opened.
VIII. The defendant no.8 is directed to disclose the KYC details of
Mobile No. 8276073316.”
5.
Vide order dated 04.01.2023, this Court made the following correction
to the terms of the ex parte ad-interim injunction granted vide order dated
22.12.2022:
“1. The present application has been filed on behalf of the plaintiffs
seeking correction of clerical error that has occurred in the order passed
by this Court on 22nd December, 2022. It is stated that the email address
has been wrongly noted in paragraph 31(II) of the aforesaid order. The
correct email address has been noted in paragraph 24 of the aforesaid
order as below: “contact@onlinerajnigandharetail.in”
2. Accordingly, the order dated 22nd December, 2022 stands corrected
and the email ID given in paragraph 31(II) shall be read as
“contact@onlinerajnigandharetail.in”
instead
of
“dsgroup@rajnigandhadealership.online”.
3. In view of the aforesaid correction, compliance under Order XXXIX
Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) be done within three
days.
4. The application stands disposed of.”
6.
Ms. Vaishali Mittal, learned counsel for the plaintiffs submits that the
plaintiffs are the registered proprietors of the trademarks “DS GROUP” and
“RAJNIGANDHA”, including their respective composite, device and label
marks, and have placed on record the registration certificates and other
documents evidencing their adoption, use, goodwill and reputation. She
submits that the rights of the plaintiffs in the aforesaid marks and the
protection available thereto have also been recognised by this Court in
earlier proceedings concerning the plaintiffs’ marks and products. Reliance
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
is placed, inter alia, upon Dharampal Satyapal Ltd. v. Suneel Kumar
Rajput & Anr.,1 wherein the Court, after granting interim protection against
use of marks identical or similar to “RAJNIGANDHA”, ultimately decreed
the suit in favour of the plaintiff and confirmed the interim injunction,
Dharampal Satyapal Sons Pvt. Ltd. v. G. Chandra Babu & Anr.,2 wherein
this Court granted interim injunction restraining the defendants from using
the impugned logo along with their trademark, and Dharampal Satyapal
Ltd. v. Rajnigandha Distributors Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.,3 wherein, upon finding a
prima facie case, this Court directed blocking of the impugned domain name
and the concerned bank accounts in proceedings arising out of unauthorised
offers of distributorships under the “RAJNIGANDHA” mark.
7.
Learned counsel further submits that the present case bears close
similarity to the aforesaid proceedings, particularly inasmuch as the
defendants have allegedly used the plaintiffs’ “DS GROUP” and
“RAJNIGANDHA” marks on the impugned website for offering
distributorships/dealerships to members of the public. Reliance is also
placed upon the order in DS Intellectual Properties LLP & Anr. Vs.
Ashutosh Kumar Singh & Ors.,4 concerning the same plaintiffs and similar
allegations relating to an online distributorship website, wherein this Court
considered the plaintiffs’ case of infringement of their trademarks and
copyright and granted ex parte ad interim protection. She further submits
that the use of the plaintiffs registered marks, together with the
representation of an association with the plaintiffs, amounts to infringement
CS(OS) 381/2012; Dated 13.02.2014
CS(COMM) 742/2017; Dated 01.11.2017
CS(COMM) 317/2019; Dated 31.05.2019
(COMM) 867/2022; Dated 13.12.2022
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
of the plaintiffs’ trademark and copyright and also constitutes passing off
and dilution, warranting a decree of permanent injunction in the present
proceedings.
8.
Defendant nos. 6 to 8 were deleted from the array of parties, having
complied with the respective directions of this Court and their presence
being no longer required for adjudication of the present suit, vide orders
dated 10.04.2023, 19.02.2024 and 13.03.2024, respectively. Defendants nos.
1 to 5, having remained continuously absent, were proceeded ex-parte vide
order dated 16.11.2023. Thus, none of the defendants are contesting the
present suit.
9.
On the basis of the pleadings, the evidence led by the plaintiffs and
the submissions advanced, the following issues arise for determination in the
present suit:
I.
Whether the plaintiffs have established infringement of their trademarks and
copyright, passing off, dilution and unfair competition by defendant nos. 1 to 5
and are consequently entitled to a decree of permanent injunction?
II.
Whether the “DS GROUP” trademarks and corresponding Logo of the plaintiffs
are entitled to be declared “well-known trademark” within the meaning of
Section 2(1)(zg) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999?
10.
Since, there is no contest to the plaintiffs’ case and the evidence led
by them has remained unrebutted. The aforesaid issues are, therefore,
considered on the basis of the pleadings, evidence and material placed on
record by the plaintiffs.
11.
The plaintiffs have placed on record the registration certificates in
respect of the trademarks “DS GROUP” and “RAJNIGANDHA” and the
corresponding device/label marks, thereby establishing their registered
rights therein. The plaintiffs have also led evidence regarding the use of
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
these marks and the corresponding artistic and literary works. The case set
up by the plaintiffs is that defendant nos. 1 to 5 were operating the impugned
website “www.onlinerajnigandharetail.in”, on which the plaintiffs’ aforesaid
trademarks were prominently displayed in connection with offers of
distributorships/dealerships under the name of DS Group. The website also
represented an association with the plaintiffs by referring to the plaintiffs’
address, while defendant nos. 1 and 2 were alleged to have represented
themselves as employees of the plaintiffs and offered distributorships under
the mark “RAJNIGANDHA”. The plaintiffs have further led evidence that
their privacy policy was reproduced on the impugned website.
12.
The aforesaid use was not authorised by the plaintiffs and was in
relation to an activity which was represented to the public as being
connected with the plaintiffs. The use of the plaintiffs registered marks in
such circumstances is therefore actionable as infringement and also supports
the plaintiffs’ case of passing off and dilution. The reproduction of the
plaintiffs’ privacy policy, as established from the material on record, further
supports the claim of infringement of copyright.
13.
The subsequent conduct of defendant nos. 6 and 8 is also relevant in
this regard. Pursuant to the order dated 22.12.2022, defendant no. 6
suspended and locked the impugned domain name and furnished the details
relating to its registration, while defendant no. 8 complied with the direction
for disclosure of the KYC details of the mobile number used in connection
with the impugned activity. The said compliances were placed before the
Court and, upon such compliance, the respective defendants were deleted
from the array of parties. These circumstances, read with the documentary
and oral evidence led by the plaintiffs and the absence of any rebuttal by
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
defendant nos. 1 to 5, provide corroboration to the factual foundation of the
plaintiffs’ claim concerning the impugned website and the unauthorised use
of their marks.
14.
Accordingly, the plaintiffs have established their entitlement to
protection against the acts complained of by defendant nos. 1 to 5. Issue No.
1 is, therefore, answered in favour of the plaintiffs and against defendant
nos. 1 to 5.
15.
In so far as the issue no. II i.e. declaration of the plaintiffs’ “DS
GROUP” trademarks as a “well-known trademark” is concerned, Section
2(1)(zg) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 defines a “well-known trade mark” as
under:
“(zg)“well-known trade mark”, in relation to any goods or services,
means a mark which has become so to the substantial segment of the
public which uses such goods or receives such services that the use of
such mark in relation to other goods or services would be likely to be
taken as indicating a connection in the course of trade or rendering of
services between those goods or services and a person using the mark
in relation to the first-mentioned goods or services.”
16.
Section 11(2) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 provides protection to
well-known trademarks in the following terms:
“Section 11
(2) A trade mark which—
(a) is identical with or similar to an earlier trade mark; and
(b) is to be registered for goods or services which are not similar to
those for which the earlier trade mark is registered in the name of a
different proprietor, shall not be registered, if or to the extent, the
earlier trade mark is a well-known trade mark in India and the use of
the later mark without due cause would take unfair advantage of or be
detrimental to the distinctive character or repute of the earlier trade
mark”
17.
Rule 124 of the Trade Marks Rules, 2017 provides for declaration of
the “well-known” status of a trademark by way of an application, without
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
the requirement of instituting separate proceedings or seeking rectification.
Pertinently, Section 11(6) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 sets out the factors
to be taken into consideration while determining whether a mark is a “wellknown trade mark”. Section 11(6) reads as under:
“(6) The Registrar shall, while determining whether a trade mark is a
well-known trade mark, take into account any fact which he considers
relevant for determining a trade mark as a well-known trade mark
including—
(i)the knowledge or recognition of that trade mark in the relevant
section of the public including knowledge in India obtained as a result
of promotion of the trade mark;
(ii)the duration, extent and geographical area of any use of that trade
mark;
(iii)the duration, extent and geographical area of any promotion of the
trade mark, including advertising or publicity and presentation, at fairs
or exhibition of the goods or services to which the trade mark applies;
(iv)the duration and geographical area of any registration of or any
application for registration of that trade mark under this Act to the
extent they reflect the use or recognition of the trade mark;
(v)the record of successful enforcement of the rights in that trade mark;
in particular, the extent to which the trade mark has been recognised as
a well-known trade mark by any court or Registrar under that record.”
18.
In NR Dongre v. Whirlpool Corporation & Anr.,5 a Division Bench
of this Court observed as under:
“27. From the aforesaid facts including the extensive advertisements of
the goods of the first respondent and its trade mark „WHIRLPOOL‟ and
the legal position adumberated hitherto we are prima facie of the
opinion that the trade mark „WHIRLPOOL‟ has acquired reputation
and goodwill in this country and the same has become associated in the
minds of the public or potential buyers with the goods of the first
respondent. Even advertisement of trade mark without existence of
goods in the market is also to be considered as use of the trade mark. It
is also not necessary however that the association of the plaintiff's mark
with his goods should be known all over the country or to every person
in the area where it is known best. (See: Faulder & Co. Ltd. v. O. and
G. Rushton, [(1903 20 RFC 477] (9). Besides the facts prima facie
demonstrate that the first respondent was prior user of the trade mark
1995 SCC OnLine Del 310
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
„WHIRLPOOL‟ as it was using the same since 1941, while the
appellants themselves claim the adoption thereof from 1986.”
19.
In Rolex SA v. Alex Jewellery Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.,6 this Court, while
considering the factors relevant for determining whether a trademark is a
“well-known trademark”, held that the test is to be applied with reference to
the relevant segment of the public using the goods in question. The Court
took into consideration, inter alia, the extensive advertising and promotion
of the mark, registrations obtained in India and abroad, the duration and
geographical extent of its use, and the enforcement of rights in respect of the
mark. The Court further observed that, in view of the advent of the internet
and diminishing international boundaries, the fact that a mark is well known
internationally may also be relevant in assessing its reputation in India.
Applying the aforesaid principles, the Court held the trademark “ROLEX”
to satisfy the requirements of a well-known trademark and restrained the
defendants from using the said mark in relation to their goods.
20.
Dealing with the issue of a well-known trademark, this Court in Tata
Sons Ltd. v. Manoj Dodia & Ors.,7 held that a well-known trademark enjoys
protection against dilution and unfair exploitation of the goodwill and
reputation attached to the mark, including where the impugned use is in
relation to dissimilar goods or services.
“5. A well-known trademark is a mark which is widely known to the
relevant general public and enjoys a comparatively high reputation
amongst them. On account of advancement of technology, fast access to
information, manifold increase in international business, international
travel and advertising/publicity on internet, television, magazines and
periodicals, which now are widely available throughout the world, of
goods and services during fairs/exhibitions, more and more persons are
coming to know of the trademarks, which are well known in other
2009 SCC OnLine Del 753
2011 SCC OnLine Del 1520
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
countries and which on account of the quality of the products being
sold under those names and extensive promotional and marketing
efforts have come to enjoy trans-border reputation. It is, therefore,
being increasingly felt that such trademark needs to be protected not
only in the countries in which they are registered but also in the
countries where they are otherwise widely known in the relevant circles
so that the owners of well known trademarks are encouraged to expand
their business activities under those marks to other jurisdictions as
well.
The relevant general public in the case of a well known trademark
would mean consumers, manufacturing and business circles and
persons involved in the sale of the goods or service carrying such a
trademark.
6. The doctrine of dilution, which has recently gained momentus,
particularly in respect of well known trademarks emphasises that use of
a well known mark even in respect of goods or services, which are not
similar to those provided by the trademark owner, though it may not
cause confusion amongst the consumer as to the source of goods or
services, may cause damage to the reputation which the well known
trademark enjoys by reducing or diluting the trademark's power to
indicate the source of goods or services.
7. Another reason for growing acceptance of trans-border reputation is
that a person using a well known trademark even in respect of goods or
services which are not similar tries to take unfair advantage of the
trans-border reputation which that brand enjoys in the market and
thereby tries to exploit and capitalize on the attraction and reputation
which it enjoys amongst the consumers. When a person uses another
person's well known trademark, he tries to take advantage of the
goodwill that well known trademark enjoys and such an act constitutes
an unfair competition.”
21.
The aforesaid principles furnish the framework for determining
whether the DS GROUP mark satisfies the requirements of a well-known
trade mark. The evidence led by the plaintiffs is, therefore, required to be
examined with reference to the factors stipulated in Section 11(6) of the
Trade Marks Act, 1999.
22.
At the outset, it is appropriate to briefly notice the material placed on
record concerning the plaintiffs and the DS Group mark. The plaintiffs trace
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
the inception of the Group to 1929, while the DS Group Logo is stated to
have been adopted in 2003. The Logo is stated to have been used as a house
mark in relation to various products marketed under, inter alia, the marks
RAJNIGANDHA, CATCH, TULSI, PASS-PASS and PULSE.
23.
The plaintiffs have placed on record material concerning the
development of the Group, adoption and use of the DS Group Logo, its use
upon various products, registrations of the relevant trademarks, promotional
activities, third-party material, online presence, corporate publications and
enforcement proceedings. The said material is examined hereinafter with
reference to the individual statutory factors.
24.
In relation to the first factor under Section 11(6)(i), concerning the
knowledge or recognition of the trade mark in the relevant section of the
public in India, the plaintiffs have relied upon material relating to the
inception of the Group in 1929 (Ex. PW-1/4; Ex. PW-2/7), registration of
the domain “www.dsgroup.com” since 30.07.1995 (Ex. PW-1/3), and
adoption of the present DS Group Logo in 2003, supported by the affidavit
of its creator and copyright registration material (Ex. PW-2/3). The record
further contains product images and price lists evidencing use of the Logo
since 2003 (Ex. PW-2/5), including its use as a house mark in relation to
RAJNIGANDHA, CATCH, TULSI, PASS PASS and PULSE. The
plaintiffs have also relied upon material concerning promotional activities,
third-party articles and online presence (Ex. PW-2/7), as well as the DS
DUNIYA publications covering the period 2011–2022 (Ex. PW-2/8). The
CA certificates (Ex. PW-2/6), recording the turnover of the Group, also form
part of the material placed before the Court and are relevant to the scale of
the commercial operations associated with the mark.
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
25.
The aforesaid material, considered collectively, bears upon the
knowledge and recognition of the DS GROUP mark in the relevant section
of the public in India. The use of the Logo as a house mark across multiple
consumer products, its continued public-facing presence and the material
showing the scale of the plaintiffs’ business constitute relevant
circumstances while assessing the recognition of the mark under Section
11(6)(i).
26.
As regards the second factor under Section 11(6)(ii), concerning the
duration, extent and geographical area of use of the trade mark, the plaintiffs
have placed reliance upon the material distinguishing the adoption of the DS
Group word mark in 1929 from the adoption of the present DS Group Logo
in 2003. The affidavit and copyright material concerning the Logo (Ex. PW2/3), the timeline of development of the Group (Ex. PW-2/4), and the price
lists and product material evidencing use since 2003 (Ex. PW-2/5)
demonstrate the duration and extent of the use relied upon by the plaintiffs.
The MCA material (Ex. PW-1/2) and the trade mark extracts relating to the
DS Group marks (Ex. PW-1/6) further form part of the record concerning
the plaintiffs and their marks. The material showing use of the Logo across
different products and brands also bears upon the extent of its commercial
use.
27.
In relation to the third factor under Section 11(6)(iii), concerning the
duration, extent and geographical area of promotion of the trade mark,
including advertising and publicity, the plaintiffs have relied upon the
material relating to promotional activities, third-party articles and online
presence (Ex. PW-2/7), the DS DUNIYA publications (Ex. PW-2/8), and the
website
material
relating
to
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
“www.dsgroup.com”
and
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
“www.rajnigandha.com” (Ex. PW-1/3; Ex. PW-1/10; Ex. PW-1/11). The
record also contains material relating to promotional activities and publicity
undertaken by the plaintiffs over the relevant period. The CA certificates
(Ex. PW-2/6) contain figures concerning advertising expenditure, which are
relevant to the extent and continuity of the promotional activities undertaken
in relation to the plaintiffs’ marks.
28.
As regards the fourth factor under Section 11(6)(iv), concerning the
duration and geographical area of registration or applications for registration
to the extent they reflect use or recognition of the trade mark, the plaintiffs
have relied upon the trade mark extracts relating to the DS GROUP marks
(Ex. PW-1/6) and the RAJNIGANDHA marks (Ex. PW-1/12). The
registration records placed on record demonstrate the statutory protection
obtained by the plaintiffs in respect of their marks over the relevant periods.
The plaintiffs have also relied upon the fact that their marks
RAJNIGANDHA, CATCH and PULSE have previously been recognised as
well-known marks by this Court and/or the Trade Marks Registry, and that
the packaging of these products carries the DS Group Logo (Ex. PW-1/13;
Ex. PW-2/9).
29.
The aforesaid material is relevant to the recognition associated with
the DS GROUP mark, particularly when considered with the manner in
which the Logo has been used as a house mark upon products whose
individual marks have themselves received recognition. The duration and
extent of the registrations, read with the evidence of use placed on record,
therefore constitute relevant circumstances under Section 11(6)(iv).
30.
For the fifth factor under Section 11(6)(v), concerning the record of
successful enforcement of rights in the trade mark and the extent to which
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
the trade mark has been recognised as a well-known mark by any Court or
the Registrar, the plaintiffs have relied upon the orders passed in
proceedings concerning enforcement of their trade mark rights, including
Dharampal Satyapal Ltd. v. Rajnigandha Distributors Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
(supra) (Ex. PW-1/18) and DS Intellectual Properties LLP & Anr. Vs.
Ashutosh Kumar Singh & Ors. (supra) (Ex. PW-1/26), the affidavit filed in
Dharampal Satyapal Sons Ltd. v. G. Chandra Babu & Anr. (supra) (Ex.
PW-2/3), and the compilation of orders relied upon by the plaintiffs (Ex.
PW-2/9). These documents evidence the enforcement of the plaintiffs’ rights
in respect of their trademarks and the protection granted thereto by this
Court.
31.
The plaintiffs have also placed on record orders recognising
RAJNIGANDHA, CATCH and PULSE as well-known marks by this Court
and/or the Trade Marks Registry. The packaging of these products bears the
DS Group Logo, and the recognition accorded to these marks, read with the
manner in which the DS Group Logo has been used upon such products,
constitutes relevant material bearing upon the reputation and recognition
associated with the DS GROUP mark. The aforesaid record of enforcement,
together with the prior recognition of the plaintiffs’ marks and the evidence
regarding the continuous use and promotion of the DS Group Logo,
constitutes relevant evidence for determining whether the DS GROUP mark
satisfies the requirement of Section 11(6)(v).
32.
The evidence discussed above, when considered cumulatively in the
context of the five factors stipulated in Section 11(6) of the Trade Marks
Act, demonstrates the long duration of use of the DS GROUP name, the
continuous use of the present Logo since 2003, its use as a house mark
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
across the plaintiffs’ products, the extent of its promotion and commercial
use, the statutory registrations obtained in respect thereof, and the record of
enforcement and recognition of the plaintiffs’ marks. The cumulative effect
of the aforesaid circumstances is that the DS GROUP mark has acquired the
requisite knowledge and recognition amongst the relevant section of the
public and merits declaration as a well-known trade mark within the
meaning of Section 2(1)(zg) read with Section 11(6) of the Trade Marks
Act, 1999.
33.
Accordingly, Issue No. 1 is answered in favour of the plaintiffs and
against defendant nos. 1 to 5. In view of the subsequent deletion of
defendant nos. 6 to 8 from the array of parties upon compliance with the
directions of this Court, the ex parte ad-interim injunction granted vide order
dated 22.12.2022, as corrected vide order dated 04.01.2023, is made
absolute qua defendant nos. 1 to 5, and a decree of permanent injunction is
accordingly passed against defendant nos. 1 to 5 in terms thereof.
34.
Issue No. 2 is also answered in favour of the plaintiffs. Accordingly,
in terms of prayer clause 90(vii) of the plaint, a decree of declaration is
passed declaring the “DS GROUP” trademark and the corresponding
Logo
as well-known trademarks within the meaning of Section
2(1)(zg) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
35.
The plaintiffs have abandoned the reliefs sought under prayer clauses
90(viii) and 90(ix) towards damages and costs. Accordingly, no relief is
granted in respect of the said prayers.
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
36.
The Registry is directed to draw up the decree sheet accordingly.
37.
The civil suit, along with pending application, stands disposed of.
(PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV)
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER 25, 2026
aks/SA
Signed By:AMIT KUMAR
SHARMA
11:18:27
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review