Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
"
!
%
&
!"#$$$"
%
&
'
'
(
'
!"#")$
NIJAMUDDIN
JAMKHANDI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
&
(
!
$$
%
&
'
*
(
+
!'
,
,
"
$ )!
'
!
$ "
$ "
!
'
$ "! +!
$
!
-
.
-2-
/
?07474<602 163
56478
12981:
:012603 ;<56=0: ><2 780
@007 '5@12
0=8?1630
064<2 ;<56=0: 1??01246A <6 B081:> <>
:012603 ;<56=0: ><2 20=?<63067
@7
:012603
4:5>128161C
<
84= ?07474<6 4= >4:03 BD 780 ?07474<602 =00946A 7<
E51=8 780 4@?5A603 460:4A4B4:47D :4=7 31703
B01246A
<
660G520!
<'
660G520!
"
$ )!
<74>4;174<6 31703
!
'
,
!'
$
$ "
F430
$ " B01246A
$ "! +!
F430
163 ><2 4==516;0 <> H247 <> @1631@5= BD H1D
<> 3420;74<6 7< 20=?<63067
<
7< 46;:530 780 ?07474<602 46
780 0:4A4B4:47D :4=7 BD ;<6=430246A 780 ?07474<602.= 20E50=7
:07702= 20?20=067174<6= 31703 $
660G520=! 163 '
$ " 163
$ "
-3-
<6
240> >1;7= <> 780 ;1=0 120 7817
4J1D:1G@4 ;<@?:0703 802
$ $+
0A200
$ -
1=702.=
0A200 46
0=?470 802 ;<@?:0746A 780
07024612D
;406;0
A24;5:7521:
;40674=7=
0;2547@067
K
?07474<602 I
<6
$ $+
<123
;
1=702.=
$ &><2
=8<27
.( 81= 6<7 46F4703 780 1??:4;174<6 ><2 ;<635;746A
174<61:
)$
:4A4B4:47D
$ "
0=7 &
20=?<63067
G1@46174<6= 4==503 1
;<@B4603
( =46;0 >2<@
<
0=012;8
5BJ0;7
17702
?0;41:4=7 &
( & !+( 163
>>4;02 &
(
G1@46174<6
$ "
=;8035:03 >2<@ $
?<=7?<603
"$
7<
$ " 7<
-
$ "
4F0=7<;9
$ "
20;2547@067
$
<>
)$
$ " ><2
02F4;0
&
(
064<2 0;864;1:
80 0G1@46174<6 H1=
$ " 7< $) $
801FD
$ - 7<
<672<::02
<74>4;174<6 31703
A24;5:7521:
) $-
2146=
$ " 163 47 H1=
20=;8035:03
7<
$ " H478 1 ?5B:4; 6<74;0 31703
80 0G1@46174<6 ><2 780 ?07474<602/= =5BJ0;7 !
2<35;74<6
161A0@067
6 780 @016H84:0
<74>4;174<6 31703
H1=
;<635;703
20=?<63067
<
<6
4==503
$ " ><2 20;2547@067
-4-
<>
701;846A
=71>>
<6
F124<5=
=5BJ0;7=
>2<@
0:4A4B:0
;16343170=
07474<602 A1F0 1 20E50=7 :07702 20?20=067174<6
31703 $
$ " 782<5A8
@14: 7< 20=?<63067
<
><2
;<6=4302174<6 <> 802 ;1634317520 350 7< 6<6!;<635;7 <>
G1@46174<6
)$
=46;0
>2<@
) $-
$ -
7<
$ " 350 7< 4220A5:124740= H47846
)
$
0=?<63067
$ "
<
166<56;46A
F024>4;174<6
<>
4==503 1
3<;5@067=
<74>4;174<6 31703
=;8035:0
<>
<6
$ "
-
0F067=
><2
><2
?07474<602.= =5BJ0;7 ><2 ?5B:4;174<6 <> 780 ?2<F4=4<61: :4=7 <>
0:4A4B:0 ;16343170= ><2 46702F40H 163 >461: =0:0;74<6 <6 <2
B0><20 $+ $
"
$ +
80 ?07474<602 813 1??:403 ><2 780 ?<=7 <>
==4=7167
161A0@067
2<>0==<2
,
4F0=7<;9
$ " 20=?<63067
2<35;74<6
<
166<56;03
780 :4=7 <> 460:4A4B:0 ;16343170= ><2 780 ?<=7 <>
==4=7167
2<>0==<2 H802046 780 61@0 <> ?07474<602 H1= ><563 17
:
<= , 163 # @0674<646A 780 201=<6 ><2 460:4A4B4:47D 1=
-5-
?07474<602 3<0= 6<7 ?<==0==
64@1:
<2
46 780 =5BJ0;7 <>
572474<6
+
0=?<63067
<6
$ "
?07474<602
<
;<635;703
0G1@46174<6
80 20=5:7= H020 30;:1203 <6
;<67063=
$ "
=80
E51:4>403
0G1@46174<6 46 780 34=;4?:460 <>
4F0=7<;9
2<35;74<6 163
161A0@067
,
7 4= 780 ;<670674<6 <> :012603 ;<56=0: ><2 780
?07474<602
,
4@?5A603
$ " 4==503 BD 20=?<63067
12B47212D
022<60<5=
460:4A4B:0
<
:4=7
31703
4= 84A8:D 4::0A1:
56;<6=747574<61:
8020><20
81F46A 6< <7802 1:7026174F0 163 0>>4;1;4<5= 20@03D 780
?07474<602 1??2<1;803 784=
A240F16;0
<527 ><2 20320==1: <> 802
7 4= >527802 ;<6706703 BD 780 :012603 ;<56=0:
><2 780 ?07474<602 7817 1= ?02 780 20;2547@067
31703
$ "
035;174<61:
A5430:460= >4G03 ><2 780 ?<=7 <>
@0674<603 17
:
<74>4;174<6
E51:4>4;174<6=
==4=7167
2<>0==<2 120
< ) H802046 47 4= @0674<603 1= L
4=
-6-
0G0@?703 ><2 =5;8
1=702.=
0A200 ?2<A21@@0= H8020
4= 6<7 ;<635;703 BD 780
;<6;02603
64F02=47DM
::403
=5BJ0;7=
1=
6<74>403
BD
7 4= 780 ;<670674<6 <> :012603 ;<56=0: ><2 780
?07474<602 7817 780 ?07474<602 81= ;<@?:0703 802
0A200 <6
$ $+
$ -
>702 ;<@?:074<6 <>
0A200 BD 780 ?07474<602 780
1??:4;174<6 ><2 ;<635;746A
)$
$ "
1=702/=
1=702/=
81= 6<7 46F4703 780
=46;0 >2<@
) $-
$ - 7<
8020><20 780 4@?5A603 460:4A4B:0 :4=7 4= :41B:0
7< B0 =07 1=430 1= B046A 4::0A1: 163 12B47212D
#
7 4= 1:=< 780 ;<670674<6 <> :012603 ;<56=0: ><2
780 ?07474<602 7817 =80 81= E51:4>403 780
;<635;703 <6
$ " 163 780 ;0274>4;170 <> E51:4>D46A
H1=
4==503 7< 780 ?07474<602 <6
$ "
?07474<602 813 1??:403 ><2 780 ?<=7 <>
==4=7167 2<>0==<2 46
4F0=7<;9
2<35;74<6 163
<H0F02
161A0@067 <6
$ " 163
7817 350 7< 6<6!166<56;0@067 <> 780 20=5:7 BD 20=?<63067
<
780 ?07474<602 20E50=703 20=?<63067
<
!1578<247D
7< ;<6=4302 802 ;1634317520 ><2 780 ?<=7 <>
==4=7167
-7-
2<>0==<2 163 780 ?07474<602 813 1==5203 =5B@47746A 780
E51:4>D46A ;0274>4;170 <6 <2 B0><20 780 3170 <>
3<;5@067 F024>4;174<6 46 780 =143 20;2547@067 ?2<;0==
7 4=
1:=< 84= ;<670674<6 7817 ?07474<602 E51:4>403 780
<6
$ "
B57 350
7< 6<6!1F14:1B4:47D <> 780 =143
E51:4>D46A ;0274>4;170 17 780 74@0 <> >4:46A 1??:4;174<6
?07474<602 H1= 6<7 1B:0 7< ?2<35;0 780 =1@0
07474<602
H1= 81F46A 780 =143 ;0274>4;170 B0><20 ;<@?:074<6 <>
3<;5@067 F024>4;174<6 ?2<;0== H84;8 H1= =;8035:03 <6
-
$ " 163 78020><20 80 ;<67063= 7817 780 4@?5A603
460:4A4B:0 :4=7 4= H478<57 1578<247D 163 4= 46 F4<:174<6 <>
?246;4?:0= <> 617521: J5=74;0
7 4= >527802 ;<6706703 7817 780 20;2547@067
1A06;D =8<5:3 4A6<20 ?2<;03521: :1?=0= 46 ?2<35;74<6 <>
3<;5@067= 163 47 81= 7< ;<6=4302 780 ;16343170/= 3170 <>
?1==46A <> 780 0G1@ 163 6<7 780 3170 <> 4==516;0 <>
30A200= 46 F40H <> 780 ?07474<602 81F46A E51:4>403 780
<6
$ "
$ "
780 ;0274>4;170 81F46A B006 4==503 <6
50 7< 6<6!1F14:1B4:47D <> 780 =143 ;0274>4;170
-8-
17 780 74@0 <> >4:46A 780 1??:4;174<6 780 ?07474<602 ;166<7
B0 ><563 7< B0 460:4A4B:0 163 780 4@?5A603 460:4A4B:0 :4=7
4==503 BD 20=?<63067
<
4= 4::0A1:
12B47212D 163 780
=1@0 30=02F0= 7< B0 =07 1=430 163 780 ?07474<602 4=
20E54203 7< B0 ?02@47703 7< ?1274;4?170 >527802 46 780
20;2547@067 ?2<;0==
7 4= 1:=< ;<6706703 7817 1= <6 3170 <>
780 20;2547@067 <2 =;25746D =46;0 780 ?07474<602 E51:4>403 46
780 =1@0 81= 7< B0 71906 467< ;<6=4302174<6 ><2 802
1??<467@067 7< 780 20:0F167 ?<=7
1F46A 6<7 3<60 =< 163
81F46A 4==503 780 4@?5A603 460:4A4B:0 :4=7
780 =1@0
20E5420= 7< B0 E51=803
$
20:416;0 <6
20=?0;7 <>
012603 ;<56=0: ><2 780 ?07474<602 81= ?:1;03
:15=0!) <> 780 20;2547@067
==4=7167
<74>4;174<6 46
2<>0==<2/= ?<=7 H8020 E51:4>4;174<6
163 A5430:460= 120 @0674<603
0 ;<67063= 7817 46 F40H <>
780 0G0@?74<6 ?2<F4303 46 780
:15=0!) <> 780
<74>4;174<6
780 ?07474<602 H<5:3 =E5120:D ;<@0 56302 784= 163 H<5:3
B0 0G0@?703 >2<@ 780
<74>4;174<6
1= 6<74>403 46 780 20;2547@067
-9-
:012603
@7
064<2
;<56=0:
4:5>128161C
@007
'5@12
1??01246A
0=8?1630
<6
B081:>
:012603 ;<56=0: ><2 20=?<63067
<>
<
F080@067:D ;<6706303 7817 780 460:4A4B:0 :4=7 4==503 BD
20=?<63067
<
3<0= 6<7 =70@ <57 >2<@ 16D 4::0A1:47D <2
?02F02=47D <2 12B47212460==
780 20;2547@067
80 =1@0 4= 46 1;;<2316;0 H478
<74>4;174<6 163 780 25:0= 163 A5430:460=
><2@5:1703 46 780 =143
<74>4;174<6
H478
E51:4>4;174<6
?20=;24B03
20;2547@067
=71703
;0274>4;174<6 <6 <2 B0><20
$ " =80 H<5:3 6<7 B0 0:4A4B:0 ><2 20;2547@067 7<
780 ?<=7 <>
==4=7167
31703
$ "
:012603
1=
<74>4;174<6 163 780 ?07474<602 81F46A 6<7
?2<;5203 163 =0;5203 780
-
7 4= 1:=< 46 ;<6=<616;0
2<>0==<2 1= ?02 780
7 4= 1:=< F080@067:D ;<6706703 BD
064<2 ;<56=0: 7817
A5430:460=
<74>4;174<6
?20=;24B03
:15=0!) <> 780 E51:4>4;174<6
><2
?<=7
<>
==4=7167
2<>0==<2 H<5:3 6<7 B0 1??:4;1B:0 7< 780 ?07474<602 46 780
;1=0 <6 8163
< 1:=< 80 ;<67063= 7817 78020 120 ;027146
A06021: 46=725;74<6= 163 A5430:460= 7< 1:: 780 ;16343170= ><2
- 10 -
>4::46A 5? 780 1??:4;174<6 ><2 780 20;2547@067 7< 780 =143
?<=7= 163
:15=0!), <> 780 =143 20;2547@067
56302
A06021:
46=725;74<6=
=?0;4>4;1::D =71703 1= L),
7<
<74>4;174<6
;16343170=
4=
80 0:4A4B4:47D <> 780 ;16343170
H4:: B0 30702@4603 1= ?02 780 :1=7 3170 <> =5B@4==4<6 <>
1??:4;174<6 4 0
-
$ "M
012603
064<2 ;<56=0: 81= >4:03 1 @0@< 1:<6A
H478 >0H 3<;5@067= 61@0:D 780 20;2547@067
<74>4;174<6
1??:4;174<6 <> 780 ?07474<602 20E50=7 :07702 <> 780 ?07474<602
H84;8 H1= 5?:<1303 46=7013 <> 780
;0274>4;170
064<2 ;<56=0: 1??01246A ><2 20=?<63067
780 6<74;0 <> 784=
780 ?<=7 <>
<
012603
B246A= 7<
<527 7817 780 ?07474<602 813 1??:403 ><2
==4=7167
2<>0==<2 46 4F0=7<;9
2<35;74<6 163
161A0@067 =5BJ0;7 H84;8 4= 6<7 46 34=?570 163 H84:0
>4:46A 780 1??:4;174<6 163 =71746A 780 ?02=<61: 46><2@174<6
56302 780 ;1?74<6 L < D<5 81F0
;0274>4;170NM 780
16=H02 4= =71703 1= L 0=M H84;8 @1D 6<7 B0 ;<220;7 1= 47 4=
1 >1:=0 =7170@067 @130 BD 780 ?07474<602 ><2 780 201=<6
7817 1= <6 3170 <> >4:46A 780 1??:4;174<6 780 ?07474<602 343
- 11 -
6<7 ?<==0== <2 =0;520 780
780 ?07474<602 802=0:>
;0274>4;170 0F06 1;;<2346A 7<
7 4= 1:=< =5B@47703 BD 780 :012603
064<2 ;<56=0: 7817 780 ?07474<602 802=0:> @130 1 20E50=7
BD >4:46A 1 20?20=067174<6 :07702 ><2 ;<6=4302174<6 <> 802
;1634317520 350 7< 6<6!;<635;7 <>
0 B246A= 7< 780 6<74;0 <> 784=
0G1@46174<6
<527 780 :07702 H84;8 4=
1660G03 1:<6A H478 780 @0@< 163 H84;8 H1= 1:=<
5?:<1303 1:<6A H478 780 1??:4;174<6 H802046 17 ?121A21?8!
780 ?07474<602 802=0:> 81= =71703 1= 56302
!$!#
%
!"
#$
!
'
!$!&%
!$!&(
)
++
+#
%
*
)
%
!$!&
,
*
*
% .
/0
)
- 12 -
-
012603
064<2 ;<56=0: =5B@47= 7817 H84:0
=5B@47746A =5;8 20?20=067174<6 780 ?07474<602 81= =<5A87
><2 ;<6=4302174<6 7< 1;;0?7 780 1??:4;174<6 ><2 780 ?<=7 <>
==4=7167
2<>0==<2
4F0=7<;9
161A0@067 163 7< ?02@47 802 7< =5B@47
780 74@0 <> 3<;5@067 F024>4;174<6
2<35;74<6
;0274>4;170 17
8020><20 80 ;<67063=
7817 13@47703:D 0F06 1;;<2346A 7< 780 ?07474<602 1= <6
780 3170 <> >4:46A <> 780 1??:4;174<6 ><2 20;2547@067 7< 780
?<=7 <>
==4=7167
2<>0==<2 46
161A0@067 =5BJ0;7
4F0=7<;9
2<35;74<6 163
780 ?07474<602 343 6<7 81F0
;0274>4;170 H478 802 163 6047802 343 =80 5?:<13 780 =1@0
H84;8 4= 0F43067 >2<@ 780 :07702 <> 20E50=7 @130 ><2
;<6=4302174<6 <> 802 ;1634317520 ><2 ?2<35;74<6 <>
;0274>4;170 17 780 74@0 <> 3<;5@067 F024>4;174<6
A2<563= :012603
6 780=0
064<2 ;<56=0: ;<67063= 7817 13@47703:D
0F06 1;;<2346A 7< 780 ?07474<602 163 <6 780 B1=4= <> >1;7=
61221703 BD 780 ?07474<602 163 780 20;<23= ?:1;03 B0><20
<527 1= H0:: 1= 780 1??:4;174<6 163 780 :07702 >4:03
1:<6A H478 780 1??:4;174<6 ><2 >4::46A 780 ?<=7 <>
==4=7167
- 13 -
2<>0==<2
?07474<602
0:4A4B4:47D ;2470241 <>
6<7 81F0
;0274>4;174<6
20E54203
806 =5;8 B046A 780
;42;5@=716;0 163 780 0:4A4B4:47D <> 780 ;1634317520 B046A
780 20E5420@067 <>
;0274>4;170 6<6!?2<35;74<6 <> 780
=1@0
34=06747:0
H4::
;027146:D
?07474<602
?1274;4?174<6 46 780 20;2547@067 ?2<;0==
>2<@
;;<2346A:D 780
?07474<602 81= B006 24A87:D F4=4703 H478 780 4@?5A603
460:4A4B:0
:4=7
78020BD
=80
B0;<@0=
460:4A4B:0
7<
?1274;4?170 46 780 20;2547@067 ?2<;0== H84;8 3<0= 6<7 ;1::
><2 46702>0206;0 163 6047802 4= 47 4::0A1: <2 12B47212D <2
;<67212D 7< 780 20;2547@067
<74>4;174<6 163 780 25:0= 163
A5430:460= :143 3<H6 7802046
)
012603
064<2 ;<56=0: 1:=< >4:0= 1:<6A H478 1
@0@< 780 ?2<;00346A= <> 780
<F026@067 <> '12617191
?02714646A 7< 780 =5BJ0;7 <> 20F4=4<6 <>
=;1:0= <>
01;802=
4B212416= 163
H<2946A 46 '12617191
;406;0
64F02=47D
<F026@067
07024612D
E54F1:067
64@1: 163
4312 H478 0>>0;7 >2<@ $
31703
?1D
+ $-
$
1320=
4=80240=
$$+ 163
$
- 14 -
E51:4>4;174<6= 163
01;802= 46 780
0:4A4B4:47D ><2
3420;7 20;2547@067 <>
64F02=47D 4= ?20=;24B03 ><2 780 ?<=7 <>
==4=7167 2<>0==<2 H84;8 =7170= 1= 56302
&&3
* )
,
)
9 )
)
%
.
* )
)
)
*
%
)
9:;7.;
9:;%
7; . %
,
<
)
9 )
:
;
% !$$=
7 <
"
012603
464@5@
- -
!$+"
064<2 ;<56=0: 1:=< ?<467= <57 BD
?:1;46A 20:416;0 <6 780
H478
<74>4;174<6 H84;8 1:=< 301:=
51:4>4;174<6=
><2
??<467@067
<>
- 15 -
01;802= 163
<::0A0= 163
01=520= ><2 780
4A802
;130@4;
35;174<6
$ #
71>> 46
64F02=4740= 163
14670616;0 <>
7163123=
H802046 17 ;:15=0 - - 47 4=
=71703 1= 56302
##
<
< )
* )
)
>
%
<
)
)
9 )
;
7.
)
)
)
-
9 )
:
;
%
;
!$$=%
9 )
- -
:
-
-
*
%
%
*
7 <
* )
9 )
%;
.
% !$+"%
- 16 -
)
?
)
++%
-
!$$=%
)
@
.
*
7 <
* )
9 )
7;
7.
A
(
%
- ))
)
A
-
,
(
%
9:;7.;
7; .
,
- 17 -
9 )
..
7 <
*
7 <
+
012603
064<2 ;<56=0: 20:40= 5?<6 780 ><::<H46A
J53A@067= 46 =5??<27 <> 84= ;1=0
!
'
(
"#$%&
)
"",%&
*
- .
*
/+ "
,
012603
"+
)
"%
064<2 ;<56=0: ;<67063= 7817 780=0
78200 J53A@067= ;<F02 780 1=?0;7 <> 0:4A4B4:47D ;2470241
;<63474<6=
13F0274=0@067 <2 46 780
;57!<>>
?2<F4303
5:0= 163 780 :1=7 3170 ><2 >4:46A <>
780 1??:4;174<6 7< B0 ;<6=430203 1= 1 ;57!<>> 3170 H84:0
;<6=430246A 780 1??:4;174<6 ><2 20E54=470 E51:4>4;174<6 46 780
20;2547@067
<74>4;174<6
8020><20
80 ;<67063= 7817 46
- 18 -
F40H <> ;17061 <> J53A@067= 163 780 ;<6=4=7067 25:46A= <>
<6.B:0
;<63474<6=
20;2547@067
?0G
<527 ;<6;02646A 780 ;2470241 0:4A4B4:47D
20E5420@067=
<74>4;174<6
?20=;24B03
=1@0
@5=7
1380203 7< 46 B<78 :07702 163 =?4247
;16343170
46;:5346A 780 ?07474<602
56302
B0
=724;7:D
8020><20
6<
;16 ;:14@ 0:4A4B4:47D
1>702 780 20;2547@067 6<74>4;174<6 <2 B0D<63 780 :1=7 3170
>4G03 ><2 =5B@47746A 780 20E54203 ;0274>4;170=
#
163 :012603
81F0 80123 :012603 ;<56=0: ><2 780 ?07474<602
064<2 ;<56=0: ><2 20=?<63067
<
80 ?<467 7817 H<5:3 124=0 ><2 ;<6=4302174<6
B0><20 784=
<527 4= H807802 780 ?07474<602/= 0:4A4B4:47D ><2
?1274;4?174<6 46 780 20;2547@067 ?2<;0== ;16 B0 ;<6=430203
46 F40H <> 802 =0;5246A 780
20;2547@067
;0274>4;174<6 ?<=7 780
<74>4;174<6 ;57!<>> 3170
B006 ;<6=430203 BD 780
<6/B:0
J53A@067 20:403 <6 BD 780 :012603
=?0;4>4;1::D 46 780 ;1=0 <> '
(
84= F02D 1=?0;7 81=
?0G
<527 46 780
064<2 ;<56=0:
&=5?21(
<20
- 19 -
$
012603
064<2 ;<56=0: 1:=< 20:40= 5?<6 780
J53A@067 46 780 ;1=0 <>
H802046 780
<6/B:0
?0G
- .
&=5?21(
<527 17 ?121A21?8
<= ) 7<
$ 80:3 1= 56302
"
)
5?
;
) ;
,
, B
@
.
A 4 ;;
!+%
C4+6 D
4E
&6
)
+
,
-
F
% ?? 6
*
)
)
*
)
%
#G
)
;
HC
.
A 4 ;;
!+5!!%
+5=5+==&
"6
%
#
- 20 -
-
F
B
% ?? 6
%
%
)
%
*
*
*
)
.
@
,
*
)
)
%
)
?
*
*
%
)
)
- 21 -
,
;
)
)
9 )
##
)
%
)
%
%
%
.
%
.
%
-)
E
%? 4
;
##
)
)
C
%
%
)
# .
%
*
E
%
*
%
%
- 22 -
/ .
)
;
)
)
)
)
%
A 4 ;;
!"G5"I%
%
+#6
C+#
;
,B
,
) ;
%
)
;
% -
)
;
FK
J ;
%
D
)
,
;
1F
- )%
)
) 9 )
4- 6 )
)
E
;
%
.
;
)
;
4+6
*
,
)
)
)
( 4 6
)
)
)
,
E
;
- 23 -
)
;
E
,
)
%
) ,
+'!
;
)
;
)
?
C
)
, L
,
+$
B 1
)
;
A 4 ;;
C4+6
*
,
)
)
4!6 .
)
4#6 .
)
&!#%
&6
- 24 -
*
*
.
)
%
%
%
.
)
)
%
%
%
;
6 780 ;1=0 <> ' (
&=5?21( 780
<6/B:0
?0G
<527 20:D46A 5?<6 780 J53A@067= 46 780 ;1=0 <>
- .
- .
7< 780
.
&=5?21( 34=746A54=803 780 ;1=0 <>
(
&=5?21( H802046 47 301:7 <6:D H478 20A123
;0274>4;170 H802046 17 ?121!+
47 4= 80:3 1=
56302
#
B
'
:8
)
)
% M4!$+"6
;; G&'N
E
)
;
O
?
,
5"%
, B
M+==G '
A
.
;; +IN
- 25 -
"
+5=5+==&
%
-
B
F
% ?? 6
%
%
)
%
*
*
*
)
.
@
,
*
)
)
%
)
- 26 -
?
*
*
%
)
8020BD 20:D46A 5?<6 780 012:402 J53A@067 46
780 ;1=0 <>
53A0
- .
.
06;8 J53A@067
&=5?21( <> 780
<6/B:0
?0G
<527 46 780
:170=7 J53A@067 46 780 ;1=0 <>
?121A21?8
<= ,
* )
%
;
)
)
E
&=5?21( 17
-) 163 -" 80:3 1= 56302
!G @
@
,
@
%
E
;
)
)
%
%
)
)
E
)
%
%
%
.
%
- 27 -
%
)
%
*
)
!=
%
%
, B
,
;
@
-)
) 9
.
%
D
.
;
%
#!
%
%
<
%
%
C
C
)
*
)
%
#' 1
)
%
)
)
;
)
- 28 -
#& .
%
)
%
%
%
*
-
6 780 ?20=067 ;1=0 <6 8163 780 20;2547@067
<74>4;174<6 ;1@0 7< B0 4==503 <6
$ " H802046 47
?2<F4303 780 0:4A4B4:47D <> 780 ;16343170 7< B0 30702@4603
1= ?02 780 :1=7 3170 <> =5B@4==4<6 <> 780 1??:4;174<6 4 0
-
$ " H802046 13@47703:D
;0274>4;174<6 <6
780 ?07474<602 =0;5203
$ " 1= ?02 780 =7170@067 <>
780 ?07474<602 H84;8 ;1@0 7< B0 5?:<1303 46 780 46702607
1>702 780 0G1@46174<6 H1= ;<635;703 <6
?2<35;03 17
660G520!
80 =1@0 4= 6<7 46 34=?570 7< 780
>1;7 7817 1= <6 780 3170 <> 780 20;2547@067
31703
$ "
<74>4;174<6
$ " <2 ;57!<>> 3170 ?2<F4303 ><2 780 :1=7 3170
><2 =5B@4==4<6 <> 780 1??:4;174<6 31703
-
$ "
13@47703:D 780 ?07474<602 343 6<7 =0;520 <2 ?<==0== 780
;0274>4;174<6 7< B0 0:4A4B:0 7< B0 1 ;16343170 ><2 780
?<=7 <>
==4=7167
2<>0==<2 ;1::03 ><2 46 780 20;2547@067
- 29 -
<74>4;174<6 ><2 780 ?<=7 <>
4F0=7<;9
2<35;74<6 163
161A0@067
)
8020><20
46 F40H <> 780 ?07474<602 B046A
460:4A4B:0 ><2 81F46A 6<7 =5B@47703
;0274>4;174<6 ?24<2
7< 780 ;57!<>> 3170 <2 780 3170 <> :1=7 =5B@4==4<6 1= ?02
780 20;2547@067
<74>4;174<6 20=?<63067
<
4==503 780
:4=7 <> 460:4A4B:0 ;16343170= ><2 780 ?<=7 <>
==4=7167
2<>0==<2 H8020BD 780 ?07474<602/= 61@0 4= ><563 17 =0241:
< , 163 1A146=7 780 61@0 47 4= =71703 7817 K;16343170
3<0= 6<7 ?<==0==
<2
2<35;74<6 163
161A0@067.
31703
-
46 780 =5BJ0;7 <> 4F0=7<;9
84=
<527
F430
$ " 3420;703 780 ?07474<602 7< ?1274;4?170 46
780 =;25746D <> 780 1??:4;174<6 163 F024>4;174<6 <> 780
<24A461: 3<;5@067= 80:3 <6
-
$ " 163 ;:012:D =71703
7817 A216746A <> =5;8 ?02@4==4<6 =81:: B0 =5BJ0;7 7< 780
20=5:7 <> 780 H247 ?07474<6
80 ?07474<602 7190= =80:702
56302 780 =143 467024@ <2302 163 1:=< 780 >1;7 7817 ?24<2 7<
166<56;0@067 <> 780 20=5:7 <2 =;25746D <> 780 3<;5@067=
=80 81= ?<==0==03 163 =0;5203
;0274>4;174<6 163
- 30 -
78020BD
B0><20
20=5:7=
;<5:3
B0
166<56;03
<2
3<;5@067= ;<5:3 B0 F024>403 163 =;257464C03 =46;0 =80
?<==0==0= 780
;0274>4;174<6
=80 B0 ?02@47703 7<
?1274;4?170 46 780 >527802 ?2<;0== 3<0= 6<7 4@?20== 784=
<527 @5;8 163 256= ;<67212D 7< 780 20E54203 A5430:460= <>
780 20;2547@067
<74>4;174<6 163 780 ;57!<>> 3170 1= H0:: 1=
780 :1=7 3170 <> =5B@4==4<6 ?20=;24B03 46 780
"
:012603
<74>4;174<6
6 F40H <> ;17061 <> J53A@067= 20:403 <6 BD
064<2
20;2547@067
<56=0: ><2 20=?<63067
<
163 1:=< 780
<74>4;174<6 B046A F02D ;:012 H478 20=?0;7 7<
780 0:4A4B4:47D ;2470241 163 780 A5430:460= 163 =1@0 81F46A
6<7 B006 ?<==0==03 163 =0;5203 BD 780 ?07474<602 1= <6
780 3170 <> >4:46A 780 1??:4;174<6 ><2 780 =143 ?<=7
1@ <>
780 <?464<6 7817 780 ?07474<602 H<5:3 6<7 B0 0:4A4B:0 7<
?1274;4?170 46 780 ?20=067 20;2547@067
<> ?<==0==46A
;0274>4;174<6 1= <6 780 :1=7 3170 <>
=5B@4==4<6 <> 780 1??:4;174<6 4 0
+
<74>4;174<6 ><2 :1;9
6302 780 ;42;5@=716;0=
-
$ "
?1== 780 ><::<H46A
- 31 -
80 ?07474<6 4= 30F<43 <> @0247= 163 4=
84= H<5:3 6<7 @016 7817 780 ?07474<602
H<5:3 B0 B12203 ><20F02
80 H<5:3 B0 17
:4B027D 7<
H8060F02
1??:D 1>20=8
=5;8
<74>4;174<6 4= ;1::03 46 >57520
'(
%
&
!
4=7
<
:
<
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review