Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Reserved on : 03.12.2025
Pronounced on : 04.02.2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA DHARWAD BENCH
DATED THIS THE 04TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M. NAGAPRASANNA
WRIT PETITION No.101766 OF 2024 (S - PRO)
BETWEEN:
DR.USHARANI N.,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS
W/O DR.C.RAGHUVEER
OCCN.: PROFESSOR
DEPARTMENT OF OBSTETRICS AND
GYNAECOLOGY (OBG)
VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF
MEDICAL SCIENCES (VIMS)
BALLARI – 583 104.
... PETITIONER
(BY SRI P.A.KULKARNI, SR.ADVOCATE A/W
SRI P.G.CHIKKANARAGUND, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF MEDICAL EDUCATION
(HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE)
VIKAS SOUDHA
BENGALURU – 560 001.
2.
THE DIRECTOR
VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF
MEDICAL SCIENCES (VIMS)
BALLARI – 583 104.
3.
CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER
VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF
MEDICAL SCIENCES (VIMS)
BALLARI – 583 104.
4.
DR. SHAILA CHIKKAGOWDRA
OCCN : PROFESSOR
DEPARTMENT OF OBSTETRICS AND
GYNAECOLOGY (OBG)
VIJAYANAGAR INSTITUTE OF
MEDICAL SCIENCES (VIMS)
BALLARI – 583 104.
... RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT.GIRIJA S.HIREMATH, HCGP FOR R1;
SRI J.M.ANILKUMAR, ADVOCATE FOR R2 AND R3;
SRI A.S.PATIL, A/W
SRI SABEEL AHMED, ADVOCATE FOR R4)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO – A.DECLARE AND DIRECT
THE RESPONDENTS HEREIN BY ISSUE OF A WRIT IN THE NATURE
OF MANDAMUS OR ANY OTHER WRIT ORDER OR DIRECTION;
(1) TO EXTEND THE TIME BOUND PROMOTION PROFESSOR SCALE
IN TERMS OF GO DATED 16.12.2011 READ WITH MODIFICATION
GO DATED 12.02.2013 BOTH AVAILABLE VIDE ANNEXURE-L TO
THIS PETITION w.e.f 06.08.2022 WITH ALL CONSEQUENTIAL
BENEFITS INCLUDING THE MONETARY BENEFITS; (II) TO EXTEND
THE BENEFIT OF REGULAR PROMOTION TO THE GRADE OF
PROFESSOR W.E.F 16.10.2023 ON PAR WITH HER COMPARES IN
OTHER DEPARTMENTS AS EVIDENCED BY R-2's OM DATED
11.12.2023 ANNEXURE-M WITH ALL CONSEQUENTIAL BENEFITS
INCLUDING THE MONETARY BENEFITS; III) TO REMOVE THE
REMARKS APPEARING IN THE SENIORITY LIST DATED 10.02.2023
OF THE ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR GRADE IN OBG DEPARTMENT OF
R-2 INSTITUTE AND TO SETTLE THE SENIORITY POSITION OF
PETITIONER AND R-4 ONCE AND FOR ALL IN THE GRADES OF
ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR AND PROFESSOR ON THE BASIS OF THE
RELIEF (I) AND (II) ABOVE; B. DIRECT THE RESPONDENTS 1 TO 3
HEREIN FOR COMPLIANCE OF THE ABOVE DIRECTIONS WITHIN A
STIPULATED PERIOD OF THREE MONTHS OR WITHIN SUCH PERIOD
THAT MAY BE FIXED BY THIS HON’BLE COURT IN THE
CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE.
THIS WRIT PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR ORDERS ON 03.12.2025, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT
THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
CAV ORDER
The petitioner is before this Court seeking the following
prayers:
A.
“Declare and direct the Respondents herein by issue of a
writ in the nature of mandamus or any other writ order or
direction;
(i)
To extend the Time Bound Promotion Professor scale in
terms of G.O. dated 16-12-2011 read with modification
G.O. dated 12-02-2013 both available vide Ann-L to this
petition w.e.f. 06-08-2022 with all consequential benefits
including the monetary benefits.
(ii)
To extend the benefit of regular promotion to the grade of
Professor w.e.f. 16-10-2023 on par with her compares in
other departments as evidenced by R-2’s O.M. dated
11-12-2023 Annexure-M with all consequential benefits
including the monetary benefits.
(iii)
To remove the remarks appearing in the seniority list
dated 10-02-2023 of the Associate Professor grade in
OBG Department of R-2 Institute and to settle the
seniority position of petitioner and R-4 once and for all in
the grades of Associate Professor and Professor on the
basis of the relief (i) & (ii) above.
B.
Direct the respondents 1 to 3 herein for compliance of the
above directions within a stipulated period of three
months or within such period that may be fixed by this
Hon’ble Court in the circumstances of the case.
C.
Pass any other order or direction that this Hon’ble Court
may deem it fit and necessary in the facts and
circumstances of the present case and in the interest of
justice and equity.”
2. Heard Sri P.A. Kulkarni, learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner, Smt. Girija S. Hiremath, learned High Court
Government Pleader appearing for respondent No.1, Sri J.M. Anil
Kumar, learned counsel appearing for respondents 2 and 3 and
Sri A.S. Patil, learned counsel appearing for respondent No.4.
3. Facts, in brief, germane, are as follows: 3.1. The petitioner was appointed as Assistant Professor in
Alluri Sitarama Raju Academy of Medical Sciences, Eluru, Andhra
Pradesh, an institution regulated by the Medical Council of India.
That appointment happens on 26-06-2006. Vijayanagar Institute of
Medical
Sciences
(‘the
Institute’
for
short),
an
autonomous
institution issues a Notification for direct recruitment of eligible
persons to various cadres including the cadre of Assistant Professor.
The petitioner applies and is selected, pursuant to which an
appointment of the petitioner is made on 29-12-2007 as Assistant
Professor in OBG Department with the then pay scale of ₹12000420-18300. The petitioner was permitted time upto 11-01-2008 to
join duties pursuant to the order of appointment dated 29-12-2007.
The petitioner then represents to the respondents requesting two
more months’ time to join duties. The request of the petitioner was
accepted and on 04-01-2008 two more months’ time was granted.
The petitioner then gets herself relieved from Alluri Sitarama Raju
Academy of Medical Sciences, Andhra Pradesh on 31-01-2008 and
joins duties at the Institute on 01-02-2008. Owing to the service
rendered by the petitioner as Assistant Professor both at the
erstwhile institution and the present Institute, the petitioner is
promoted as Associate Professor on 06-08-2012.
3.2. The promotion of the petitioner to the post of Associate
Professor comes to be challenged before this Court by the 4th
respondent
in
Writ
Petition
No.76753
of
2013.
During
the
subsistence of the said petition, the 4th respondent also gets
promoted as Associate Professor, but with effect from 15-07-2013
on completion of qualifying experience of teaching of five years. On
19-04-2018 the petition filed by the 4th respondent comes to be
disposed of, with a direction to the Institute to redo and publish the
seniority list in the cadres of Assistant Professor and Associate
Professor in the Department of OBG, particularly with reference to
the inter se seniority of the petitioner and the 4th respondent. This
was not done. Therefore, the 4th respondent invokes the contempt
jurisdiction of this Court in C.C.C.No.100088 of 2019. The Institute
then files a counter affidavit that the provisional seniority list in the
cadre of Assistant and Associate Professor has been issued taking
into consideration the order passed by the learned single Judge
dated 19-04-2018. Liberty was reserved to challenge, if the 4th
respondent was so aggrieved.
3.3. After the said drawal of the seniority list, the Institute
initiated promotion from the posts of Assistant Professor to
Associate Professor and from Associate Professor to Professor. On
01-07-2022,
the
petitioner
is
said
to
have
submitted
a
representation that her placement in the grade of Professor in
terms of Government order with regard to time bound advancement
issued on 16-12-2011 should be from the date on which she
completes 10 years’ service in the grade of Associate Professor.
This was not considered and the petitioner had to approach this
Court in Writ Petition No.105744 of 2022 seeking a direction to the
Institute for consideration of her claim for promotion to the cadre of
Professor. This writ petition comes to be disposed of directing
consideration of her case, which again resulted in a contempt
petition filed by the petitioner in C.C.C.No.100375 of 2023. The
Institute after issuance of notice, filed a memo of compliance before
the Contempt Court that the petitioner is promoted to the grade of
Professor in terms of the order dated 24-01-2024. Contempt
proceedings are dropped on the score of substantial compliance
with the order, but reserving liberty to challenge the said order if
the petitioner is aggrieved. The petitioner claiming to be aggrieved
by the order impugned is before the Court yet again, claiming
seniority in the cadre of Professor qua the 4th respondent.
4. The learned senior counsel Sri P.A. Kulkarni appearing for
the petitioner would vehemently contend that the petitioner is
entitled to be promoted to the cadre of Professor 10 years from the
date on which she was promoted to the cadre of Associate Professor
in
terms
of
Government
order
dated
16-12-2011.
The
4th
respondent could not have been posted as Associate Professor over
and above the claim of the petitioner. To that effect, the learned
counsel submits that the error in the seniority must be rectified and
the petitioner must be shown as senior.
5. Per contra, the learned counsel Sri J.M. Anil Kumar
appearing for respondents 2 and 3 submits that aforementioned
Government order is not applicable to the case of the petitioner.
The petitioner is granted seniority in terms of law and there is
neither illegality nor irregularity in the grant of seniority, as the
petitioner joins the Institute on 01-02-2008 when the 4threspondent
was already in the Institute. Therefore, the 4th respondent is
undoubtedly senior to the petitioner. He would seek dismissal of the
petition.
6. The learned counsel Sri A.S.Patil, appearing for the 4th
respondent would toe the lines of the learned counsel appearing for
the Institute in seeking dismissal of the petition.
7. I have given my anxious consideration to the submissions
made by the respective learned counsel and have perused the
material on record.,
8. The afore-narrated facts are all a matter of record. The
petitioner gets appointed on 29-12-2007 pursuant to a process of
direct recruitment. The order of appointment is as follows:
“¸ÀA.«ªÀiïì:¹(1);374:07-08
ಾಂಕ: 29-12-07
ಅ ಸೂಚ ೆ
ಷಯ:- ಸ ಾಯಕ ಾ ಾ ಪಕರ ಹು ೆ ೆ ೇಮ ಾ ಬ ೆ.
G¯ÉèÃR: 1) F PÀóbÉÃjAiÀÄ ¥ÀvÀæ ¸ÀA.«ªÀiïì;¹§âA¢(2);374;07-08 ¢:02-12-07
2) ¸ÀPÁðgÀzÀ ¥ÀvÀæ ¸ÀA:CPÀÄPÀ;381/JA.JA.¹:2007 ¢:19.12.07.
ಈ ಕ%ೇ& ೆ
ಾಂಕ: 28.12.07ರಂದು ()ೕಕ&( ೆ.
-
-
-
ಈ ೆಳ ೆ ಾ+(ದ ,ೈದ ರನು/ 0ಾ)ಯತ2 ಸಂ0ೆ34ಾದ
ಸಂ0ೆ3 ಬ9ಾ:& ಇ<= >ೇ?ೆ >ೇ?ೆ
ಜಯನಗರ ,ೈದ 7ೕಯ
@ಾಗಗಳ<= Aಾ< ಇರುವ ಸ ಾಯಕ
ಾ ಾ ಪಕರ ಹು ೆ ೆ ಾ<ಕ
,ೇತನ Cೆ ೕ+ ರೂ.12000-420-18300ರ<= DಾತEF ಕ ಆ ಾರದ HೕIೆ ಅವರ
ಾ+(ದ
@ಾಗದ<= ೇರ ೇಮ ಾ
JಾಡIಾL ೆ. ಅಭ NFಗಳO
8ಾನ
ೆಸ&ನ ಮುಂ ೆ
ಾಂಕ; 11.01.2008ರ ಒಳ ೆ
ಈ ಸಂ0ೆ3ಯ Q ೇFಶಕ& ೆ ವರ JಾS ೊಳO:ವTದು.
ಪ ಸೂ ಮತು2 (Uೕ?ೋಗ CಾಸU
ಕಮ
@ಾಗ (OBG Dept.)
,ೈದ ರ ೆಸರು ಮತು2 9ಾಸ
ವಗF
ಸಂAೆ
.
Dr. Usha Rani.N
C/o. Venkateshwarulu.N
H.No.1030/D,Rly Qrts,
Vinobanagar Gadag Road,
Hubli.
S.T
ಈ ೇರ ೇಮ ಾ ಯು ಈ ೆಳಕಂಡ Qಬಂಧ ೆಗW ೆ ಒಳಪXYರುತ2 ೆ.
1)
2ವಷF Aಾಯಂ ಪZ,ಾFವ
ೆ ([ >ೇಷನ&) ಒಳ ೊಂS ೆ, ಈ ಅವ ಯ<= Qಗ ಪS(ದ
ಎIಾ= ಇIಾAಾ ಪ&ೕ]ೆಗಳನು/ DೇಗF^ೆ4ಾಗ>ೇಕು.
2)
ೇಮ ಾ ಯು ಈ ಸಂ0ೆ3ಯ >ೈIಾ ಾಗೂ ಕ ಾFಟಕ ಾಗ&ೕಕ ಸ ಾF& 0ೇ,ಾ QಯಮಗW ೆ
ಒಳಪXY ೆ.
3)
`E ಸಂ0ೆ3ಯ<= ಸತತ,ಾL ಮೂರು ವಷF 0ೇ,ೆ ಸ<=ಸುವ ಬ ೆ ರೂ.100-00ರ ಅL ೕHಂa
0ಾYbಂc ೇಪdನ<= ಅL Hಂa >ಾಂe ಸ<=ಸತಕfದು.
4)
Jಾ(ಕ ,ೇತನದ<= ಮೂಲ ,ೇತನದ ಾಗೂ ತುXYಭತ ದ Cೇಕಡ 10% hತ2ವನು/ ಸ ಾF&
DzÉñÀ (The contributory pension scheme shall be mandatory to the
employees joining on or after 01.04.2006 10% of Basic Pay
*Dearness allowances to be paid by the employee (GovtOrder
No.FD9sPL) 04 PET 2005, Bangalore dt:31.03.2006.)
ಅಭ NFಯು ೆಲಸ ೆf ಾಜ?ಾಗು,ಾಗ ಈ ೆಳಕಂಡ ಮೂಲ ಾಖIೆಗಳನು/ ಪ&jೕಲ ೆ ೆ ಸ<=ಸತಕfದು.
1.
ಜನk
ಾಂಕವನು/ ದೃಢಪSಸುವ ಎn.ಎn.ಎo.(.ಅಥ,ಾ ಅದ ೆf ತತEJಾನ,ಾದ ಇತ?ೆ
ಾಖIೆ ಪತ ,
2.
SL ಮತು2 q.r.SL ಪ Jಾಣ ಪತ ೆtuನ
ಾ ಹFDೆ ಪ Jಾಣ ಪತ ಗIೇ ಾದರು ಇದ<=.
3.
ೇಹ ಾಡ FDೆ ಪ Jಾಣ ಪತ (q ಎv ()rIಾ= ಶಸUt7ತEರು:ಸ3Wಯ ,ೈದ ರು ಸಜFw
ೆ ೕe -1.
4.
ನಡDೆ ಪ Jಾಣ ಪತ - ಸ3Wೕಯ ಇಬxರು ಗಣ ವ 72ಗWಂದ.
ಅಭ NFಗಳO ಈ ೆಳ ೆಕಂಡ yೂೕಷzೆ ಪತ ವನು/ ಸ<=ಸ>ೇಕು. (ರೂ.20.00 ರ 0ಾYbಂc ಪತ ದ<=)
1)
ಾನು ಸ ಾF& 0ೇ,ೆಯ<= @ಾರತದ ಸಂ
ಾನ ೆf ಬದ{ ಾLದು ಾ Jಾ+ಕ ಾL ಾಗೂ
Q|ೆ}~ಂದ ೆಲಸ JಾಡುDೆ2ೕ ೆ.
2)
ನನ ೆ ಮದು,ೆ4ಾLಲ=: ನನ ೆ ಈ ಾಗIೇ ಮದು,ೆ4ಾLರುತ2 ೆ. ಒಬx&Lಂತ ೆtuನ rೕವಂತ
ಪ ;ಪ / ಇರುವT ಲ=.
3)
ನನ/ ಈ ಹು ೆಯು DಾDಾf<ಕ,ಾLದು, 4ಾವT ೇ ಸಂದಭFದ<= ಪZವF@ಾ ಸೂಚ ೆ~ಲ= ೆ
Dೆ ೆದು ಾಕಬಹು ೆಂಬ ಪರ 2 ೆ ಒಳಪಟುY ೆಲಸ ೆf ಾಜ?ಾಗಲು ಒq•ರುDೆ2ೕ ೆ.
4)
ಾನು 4ಾವT ೇ ತರಹದ ಇತ ಥF,ಾದ: ಇತ ಥF,ಾಗದ 7 €ನo hಕದHಯ<=
@ಾL4ಾLರುವT ಲ= ಮತು2 ಬ•ಷf&(ದ ಸಂಘ ಸಂ0ೆ3ಗಳ<= ಸದಸ ಾLರುವT ಲ=.
ಸ•/Q ೇFಶಕರು,
( `E, ಬ9ಾ:&.)”
The petitioner then seeks permission of two months to join duties,
gets relieved from the institution at Andhra Pradesh in terms of the
following relieving order and then reports for duty at the Institute
on 01-02-2008:
“Alluri Sitarama Raju Academy of Medical Sciences
Eluru-534 004
“OFFICE OF THE DEAN
31ST January 2008
E/261/2008
RELIEVING ORDER
Sub: Dr. N.Usha Rani, Assistant Professor, Obst.& Gynae
Department, E.No.849 relieving from services –
Reg.
Ref: Resignation letter dated 05-01-2008 of Dr. N.Usha
Rani.
-With reference to the above, Dr. N.Usha Rani, Assistant
Professor, Department of Obst. & Gynae, who has joined the
institution on 26-06-2006, has worked from 26-06-2006 to
31-01-2008.
He/she has been relieved of his/her duties and from the
institution w.e.f. 31-01-2008 A.N.
Sd/Prof. M.Rama Krishna
Dean
To
Dr. N.Usha Rani.”
These facts are not in dispute. By the time the petitioner joined the
Institute as Assistant Professor, the 4th respondent had already
joined the 2nd respondent/Institute as Assistant Professor on
03-07-2007. The petitioner then gets promoted as Associate
Professor with effect from 06-08-2012. This promotion of the
petitioner was challenged by the 4th, respondent in Writ Petition
No.76753 of 2013.
In the said writ petition, respondent No.4
sought the following prayer:
“WHEREFORE, it is prayed that this Hon’ble Court be
pleased to issue –
i)
Writ of certiorari or any other order or direction quashing
the impugned Official Memorandum/Order dated 06-082012
passed
by
the
Respondent
No.2
in
No.VIMS/Est.II/179/2012-13 insofar as promoting the
Respondent No.4 to the post of Associate Professor of
OBG Department as per Annexure-Q.
ii)
Writ of mandamus or any other order or direction,
directing the respondents to give promotion to the
petitioner to the post of Associate Professor in the
Department of OBG with effect from 04-07-2012 with all
consequential benefits and to extend AICTE pay scale to
the petitioner as per the Order dated 16-12-2011 passed
by
the
Respondent
No.1
by
considering
the
Representations dated 06-08-2012 and 19-02-2013
submitted by the petitioner as per Annexures H & W
respectively.
iii)
Writ of mandamus or any other order or direction,
directing the Respondents No.2 and 3 to publish the
seniority list of Assistant Professors and Associate
Professors of OBG Department and to assign the proper
seniority ranking to the petitioner and Respondent No.4
by taking into consideration of the date of Appointment
Order and joining of the duty.
iv)
Issue any other appropriate writ or order or direction
which deems fit to grant by this Hon’ble Court in the facts
and circumstances of the case.”
The claim of the 4th respondent was that she was already working
as Assistant Professor by the time the petitioner joined the
Institute, as the 4th respondent was appointed on 03-07-2007 by a
walk-in interview/direct recruitment notification of 28-06-2007.
The learned single by his order dated 19-04-2018 disposes of the
said petition. The rights of the parties are determined in the order
passed by the learned single Judge. It is, therefore, necessary to
paraphrase the said order to the subject order. The learned Judge
holds as follows:
“….
….
….
20. Some of the undisputed facts are the date of
appointment and date of reporting for duty by the petitioner and
the 4th respondent respectively.
21. In the course of hearing the counsel for the Institute
has placed on record the copy of the proceedings of the 24th
Finance Committee Meeting held on 12.05.2011 at 11:00 am
held in the chambers of the Principal Secretary to Govt. Medical
Education, Vidhana Soudha, Bengaluru and one of the subjects
particularly subject No.4 reads as under:“SUBJECT-4:
PROCEEDINGS
OF
THE
REVIEW
COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 18.4.2011 (Book
let enclosed)
RESOLUTION:
The
Finance
Committee
approved
the
proceedings of the Review Committee except of Super
specialty departments where in both the Associate
Professors of Plastic Surgery & Paediatric Surgery have
not completed requisite teaching experience as per MCI
norms as Associate Professor for promotion as
Professors.”
22. From a plain reading of the above, it is apparent that
the Finance Committee has approved the decision of the review
committee to fill up the vacant posts of Associate Professors
with the exception of candidates proposed for the said post in
the Dept. of Plastic Surgery and Paediatric Surgery. Thereafter,
the said resolution of the finance committee has been placed
before the Governing Council and the Governing Council in its
35th Meeting held on 24.05.2012 in the chambers of Minster for
Medical Education, Vidhana Soudha, Bengaluru has considered
the same and approved the proposal. The same has been listed
as subject No.5 and the Governing Council has by its resolution
dated 24.05.2012 approved the resolution in its entirety.
23. In the light of these two documents the contention
that the promotion accorded to the 4th respondent is contrary
to the regulations and byelaws of the institute requires to be
rejected and is accordingly rejected. The further contention that
the resolution of finance committee has no relevance is a
misconception and fallacious. The simple reason being that
approval of posts and budgets is in the domain of the finance
committee and financial propriety would require the concurrence
of the finance committee. Hence, no illegality arises on account
of the finance committee reviewing the proposal of the review
committee to accord promotions. As required under the
regulations the byelaws the proposal of the review committee
has been approved by the Governing Council, albeit in a slightly
different manner than as canvassed by the petitioner. The same
is a mere procedural aspect and cannot be termed as a material
irregularity vitiating the very promotion itself.
24. Even otherwise, the writ petition with regard to the
quashing of the promotion has to be rejected as the petitioner
was admittedly not qualified to be appointed as an Associate
Professor as it is her admitted case that she had not
accumulated 5 years teaching experience as an Assistant
Professor.
25. It is contended by the learned counsel for Institute
that the writ petition does not survive in the light of the fact
that the petitioner has also been promoted on 15.07.2013. In
view of the said assertion and the finding rendered above with
regard to the legality and validity of the process adopted to
accord promotion to the 4th respondent, the prayer sought for
at (i) & (ii) do not survive. The only other relief that remains
consideration by this court is with regard to publication of
seniority list with particular reference to the petitioner and the
4th respondent by calculating seniority from the date of
appointment order and joining of duty only.
26. It is not in dispute that as on the date of filing
of the writ petition both petitioner and the 4th respondent
were duly qualified to be promoted to the post of
Associate Professor. This court has perused the rules and
regulations and byelaws of the Institute and chapter-I of
Annexure-2 of the Pay Recruitment, Conditions of
Services and Misc. Provisions Rules, 1995 reads as
follows:“1. SENIORITY:
The Director shall prepare and publish
a Seniority list of the staff of the Institute
both
intra
and
inter-departmental
in
accordance with the provisions of the
Seniority rules of the State Government or
such rules to be framed by the Governing
Council from time to time.” (underlining by
this court).
27. From a reading of the above, it is apparent that
the institute which is of a recent origin (1995) has under
the rules vested certain amount of discretionary powers
with the Governing Council to frame rules with regard to
fixation of seniority and in the absence thereof, place
reliance on the seniority rules as framed by the State
Govt. This is complimented by the provisions of
regulation 21 and if the above provisions are read in
conjunction with regulations 20 and 16 it appears that
certain latitude is vested in the competent authority to
draw up conditions of service in the matter of
appointment. The only qualification to the said latitude
being that it ought to be in consonance with the rules
framed by the Governing Council and in its absence, rules
framed by the State Govt.
28. It is not in doubt that the 4th respondent had
put in only 3 years 2 months service as an Assistant
Professor in the institute as on the date of consideration
of her candidature for promotion. That apart, she had
also put in 1 year 7 months service as an Associate
Professor in a private medical college and it is the adding
of this 1 year 7 months period to the service rendered in
the institute which is seriously objected to by the
petitioner. It is not in dispute that the minimum
qualification stipulated by the Medical Council of India is
that a candidate who is to be appointed as a
Reader/Associate Professor is required to render 5 years’
service as an Asst. Professor in a recognised medical
college. This stipulation is as per the MCI (Minimum
Qualifications for Teachers in Medication Institution
Regulations) 1998 in the table-1 appended to the
regulation is also stipulated in the recommendations of
the Medical Council of India. At this juncture, it is
relevant to state that the parties have placed before the
court truncated copies of the rules and regulations.
29. In the light of the above discussions, the only
fact in dispute is whether the service rendered by the 4th
respondent in a private medical college would enure to
the benefit of the 4th respondent for the purpose of
calculating the length of service for according promotion
to the next higher post? The said issue requires to be
addressed by the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 as the
determination of the seniority of the petitioner and the
4th respondent cannot be done in isolation and would
necessarily impact the other candidates also. Further, the
fact remains that the guidelines and parameters adopted
or followed by the respondent Nos.2 and 3 while
according promotions is also not laid bare before this
court either by the petitioner or the contesting
respondents. Hence, this court is of the considered
opinion that the writ petition could be disposed off by
rejecting the prayers at serial (i) and (ii) and with a
further direction to the respondent Nos.2 and 3 to redo
the seniority list as indicated herein below. Accordingly,
the prayer at serial (i) is rejected and the second prayer
with regard to mandamus to the respondents to accord
promotion to the petitioner is rendered infructuous.
In view of the above discussion, the writ petition is
disposed off by directing the respondents 2 & 3 to re-do
and publish the seniority list of Assistant Professors &
Associate Professors of the Department of OBG more
particularly with reference to the inter-se seniority of the
petitioner and the 4th respondent and while doing so the
2nd respondent shall determine the following points:1.
Whether the 3rd respondent is entitled to rely on the
Medical Council of India (Minimum Qualifications
for Teachers in Medical Institutions) Regulations
1998, in the matter of according promotions?
2.
Whether the VIMS, Bellary, Rules and Regulations,
1995 and its Bye-Laws permit incorporation of the
provisions of the MCI (Minimum Qualifications for
Teachers in Medical Institutions) Regulations 1998?
3.
Whether the MCI regulations or the State Govt.
rules provide for taking into consideration the
services rendered outside the institute for the
purpose of calculating the seniority.
4.
Whether the similar restriction clauses as contained
in Annexure-X are imposed while appointing the 4th
respondent.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
The learned single Judge holds that the only fact in dispute was
whether the service rendered by the present petitioner in a private
Medical College would enure to her benefit for the purpose of
calculating the length of service for according promotion to the next
higher post. Directions were issued by the learned single Judge for
drawing up of the inter se seniority as well.
The directions so
issued were not complied with.
9. The 4th respondent invokes the contempt jurisdiction and
during the subsistence of the contempt, the Institute publishes a
provisional seniority list of Assistant and Associate Professors of the
OBG Department. The contempt petition CCC 100088 of 2019
comes to be closed by the following order:
“….
….
….
5. It is apparent that the respondent-accused has notified
the provisional and final seniority lists subsequent to the order
passed by the writ Court said to be in compliance with the
directions issued in the writ petition. In view of the seniority lists
published as aforesaid, keeping in mind the points enumerated
by the writ Court, proceeding with the contempt petition is not
warranted. If the complainant is aggrieved by the seniority list
now published, he is at liberty to assail the same, if so advised.
6. Accordingly, contempt proceedings are dropped with
liberty to the complainant to assail the provisional seniority list
dated 11.11.2019 and final list dated 29.11.2019 published by
the respondent-accused if so advised.”
Liberty was reserved in the parties to assail the provisional seniority
list and the final seniority list notified on 29-11-2019.
Challenge
was not raised immediately. A notification comes to be issued on
09-02-2022 drawing the seniority list of faculty members working
as Associate Professors in the Institute. In the Department of OBG
in which the petitioner and the 4th respondent were working the
seniority list as on 01-01-2022 was as follows:
“Vijayanagar Institute of Medical Sciences, Bellary
Final Seniority of Associate Professors as on 1-01-2022
OBG
Dr. Usha Rani N
Dr. Shaila N
Dr. Ramaraju H.E
Dr. Shivakumar H.C.
Dr.K.N.M.Asha Rani
16-03-1977
05-12-1977
01-06-1977
13-11-1978
25-06-1966
01.02.2008
03-07-2007
12-07-2007
19-05-2008
06-12-2010
06-08-2012
15-07-2013
21-05-2016
23-05-2016
23-05-2016
A circular then comes to be issued by the State Government on
26-07-2022 for granting time bound promotion to teaching and
non-teaching staff who were eligible to be considered for promotion
to higher cadre. The circular reads as follows:
“ಸುDೊ2ೕIೆ
ಷಯ :
`E ಸಂ0ೆ3ಯ<= 7=Qಕo /
ಪ ೋನ/
ಾw 7=Qಕo
ಮತು2 ಪ ೋನ/
@ಾಗಗಳ<= ಾಲಬದ{
ೆ ಅಹF&ರುವ @ೋಧಕ ವಗFದವರು
`E ಸಂ0ೆ3 >ೈIಾ /ಎw. ಎಂ ( /ವೃಂದ ಮತು2 ೇಮ ಾ
ಅನು0ಾರ
ಾಖIೆಗಳನು/ ಸ<=ಸುವ ಕು&ತು.
Hೕಲfಂಡ
ಷಯ ೆf ಸಂಬಂ (ದಂDೆ
`E ಸಂ0ೆ3ಯ ಎIಾ=
@ಾಗದ ಮುಖ ಸ3ರು ತಮk
@ಾಗಗಳ<= - ಕತFವ QವF•ಸು 2ರುವ @ೋಧಕ (ಬxಂ ಯವರು ಸಹ
ಾ ಧ ಪಕರ ಹು ೆ~ಂದ
ಾ ಾ ಪಕರ ಹು ೆ ೆ / ಸ ಾಯಕ ಾ ಾ ಪಕರ ಹು ೆ~ಂದ ಸಹ ಾ ಾ ಪಕರ ಹು ೆ ೆ ಮತು2. ಸ ಾF&
ಆ ೇಶದ ಪ ಾರ ಾಲಬದ ಪ ೋನ/
ವೃಂದ ಮತು2
ೇಮ ಾ
ೆ ಅಹF&ರುವ ,ೈದ ರ ಾಖIೆಗಳನು/
ಅನು0ಾರ ಸಂಬಂಧಪಟY
ಾಖIೆಗಳನು/ 15
ಸ<=ಸಲು ಸೂt( ೆ. Qಗ ತ ಅವ ‰ಳ ೆ ಪ ೋನ/
ಇದ<= ಪ ೋನ/
ನಗ9ೆˆ ಳ ಾL ದೃSೕಕ&(
ೆ ಸಂಬಂ (ದಂDೆ
ೆ ಪ&ಗ+ಸIಾಗುವT ಲ=,ೆಂದು ಸೂt( ೆ.
`E ಸಂ0ೆ3 >ೈIಾ /
ಾಖIೆಗಳನು/ ಸ<=ಸ ೆ
ಸ•/Q ೆFಶಕರು
`E ಬ9ಾ:&”
The petitioner claims that she should be promoted as Professor over
and above the 4th respondent on the score that she has completed
10 years as on 05-08-2022.
This representation goes unheeded.
The petitioner then approaches this Court again in Writ Petition
105744 of 2022. The prayer sought in the said petition is as
follows:
“This Writ Petition is filed under Articles 226 and 227 of
the constitution of India, praying to Issue a writ of
mandamus or any other writ order or direction directing
the respondents 1 to 3 herein to forthwith finalize the
petitioners promotion claim to the grade of Professor in
OBG Department in respondent No.2 Institute and to
issue necessary orders thereon.”
It comes to be disposed of by the following order:
“….
….
….
3. The petitioner, who was appointed as Assistant
Professor in the second respondent - Institute was subsequently
promoted to the post of Associate Professor. It is the case of the
petitioner that she has been working as Associate Professor with
effect from 06.08.2012. The second respondent - Institute has
issued a Circular dated 26.07.2022, vide Annexure-J calling for
applications from the eligible candidates to fill up the post of
Professor that had fallen vacant in various departments. In
response to the same, the petitioner appears to have filed her
application on 01.07.2022. On the ground that the said
application is not yet considered, the petitioner is before this
Court.
4. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits
that the claim of the petitioner is pending consideration before
the competent authority for promotion to the post of Professor
from 01.07.2022 onwards and therefore, she has approached
this Court seeking for appropriate direction.
5. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent - Institute submits that the process of considering
the petitioner's application along with similar applications filed
by respondent No.4 and other eligible candidates, are still under
process and the committee constituted for considering the said
applications has met on several occasions and has now sought
for clarification from the second respondent - Institute and
awaiting the said clarification, the decision is not yet taken. He
submits that there is no delay on the part of the committee in
considering the applications and the applications are being
considered.
6. Be that as it may be, without expressing any opinion
on the merits of the case, since the applications of the petitioner
as well as the other candidates including of the fourth
respondent are pending consideration for promotion to the post
of Professor since the month of July-2022 onwards, it is
needless to state that the committee constituted for the purpose
of considering the said applications will pass appropriate orders
as expeditiously as possible in accordance with law. Accordingly,
the writ petition is disposed off.”
The coordinate Bench did not express any opinion on its merits, but
the applications of the petitioner as well as other candidates
including the 4th respondent, consideration of which was pending,
were directed to be considered and appropriate orders were
directed to be passed.
10. Then comes the Official Memorandum dated 24-01-2024
granting promotion to the petitioner. The order of promotion reads
as follows:
“As per the approval obtained in the Proceedings cited
under reference (1 to 4) the following Teaching staff working in
Vijayanagar institute of Medical Sciences, Ballari has been
promoted on 08-01-2024 to the higher post as shown against
their name and until further orders.
SL.
NO.
Name of the Teaching
staff & Department
Dr. Usharani N
Department of OBG
Present
Designation,
Department &
pay scale
Associate
Professor
in
OBG. ₹374006700+
AGP
9000 (7th pay
₹1,31,400
to
2,17,100)
Promotional posts
& Pay scale
Professor of OBG
₹3740067000+AGP10,000
(7th pay ₹1,44,200
to 2,19,200)
Note:
1)
2)
Concerned should get relieved from the present post and
report to the higher post within 15 days.
Failing which, their promotions will be withdrawn without
further notice.
Concerned shall affix the self-attested latest passports
size photograph of an individual in case of unmarried and
self-attested latest passport size photographs of family
members in case of married.”
The promotion is granted with effect from 08-01-2024. This is now
what is under challenge. The claim of the petitioner is on the
strength of a Government order dated 16-12-2011. The said
Government order insofar as it is germane reads as follows:
“ಸ ಾFರದ ಆ ೇಶ ಸಂAೆ :ಅಕುಕ 4 ಎಂಎಂ(2010 >ೆಂಗಳˆರು
ಾಂಕ : 16.12.2011
,ೈದ 7ೕಯ jŠಣ ಇIಾAೆಯ ,ಾ q2ಯ<= ಬರುವ ಸ ಾF& 0ಾ)ಯತ2 ,ೈದ 7ೕಯ ಾIೇಜುಗಳO ಸ ಾF&
0ಾ)ಯತ2 ದಂತ 8ಾನ ಾIೇಜುಗಳO ಮತು2 0ಾ)ತ2 ,ೈದ 7ೕಯ ಸಂ0ೆ3ಗ9ಾದ j ೕ ಜಯ ೇವ ಹೃ ೊ ೕಗ
ಸಂ0ೆ3, 7^ಾ)~ 0ಾkರಕ ಗಂ
ಸಂ0ೆ3, ಇಂ ?ಾ ಾಂ
ಸಂ0ೆ3, ಎn.S.ಎn X.Œ ಸಂCೆ•ೕದ ಾ
ಾರ,ಾಡ ಈ ಸಂ0ೆ3ಗಳ<=ನ
0ೇ,ೆಯ<=
ಮಕfಳ ಆ?ೋಗ ಸಂ0ೆ3, ೆ‹ೊ ೕ-ಯು?ಾಲr
ೇಂದ ಮತು2 ?ಾrೕŽ
ಾಂ
ಎ ೆ ?ೋLಗಳ ಸಂ0ೆ3,
ೆಳಕಂಡ @ೋಧಕ ವಗFದ& ೆ ಮತು2 ಸದ& ಸಂ0ೆ3ಗಳ<= ಸ ಾF&
ಮುಂದುವ&ಯು 2ರುವ
@ೋಧಕ
ವಗFದವ& ೆ
ನಂಕ
01.04.2011
&ಂದ
ಅನ)ಯ,ಾಗುವಂDೆ 2006 ರ ಅ•ಲ @ಾರತ Dಾಂ ಕ jŠಣ ಪ&ಷ 2ನ (AICTE) ಪ&ಷ•ತ ,ೇತನ
Cೆ ೕ+ಗಳನು/ ಈ ೆಳಕಂಡಂDೆ ಸ2&( ಆ ೇj( ೆ.
ಕಮ
ವೃಂದ ಪದ ಾಮ
ಈಗ
ಸಂAೆ
ಬರುವ
ನೂತನ Cೆ ೕ+
Cೆ ೕ+
,ೇತನ Cೆ ೕ+
ೊಸ ,ೇತನ Cೆ ೕ+
>ಾ ಂe ರೂ
ಅ ಾ^ೆ€‘
ೆ ೕe ,ೇತನ
ರೂ
8000-13500
15600-39100
2.
graduate
Master
Degree)
ಸ ಾಯಕ ಾ ಾ ಪಕರು
1200018300
15600-39100
3.
ಸಹ ಾ ಾ ಪಕರು
1640020000
37400-67000
4.
ಾ ಾ ಪಕರು,Q ೆFಶಕರು
ಮತು2
37400-67000
10000
Sೕw
ಮತು2
1840022400
1.
ಉಪ ಾ ಸಕರು ºÁUÀÆ (ೕQಯd
?ೆ(^ೆಂa
ಮತು2
ಟೂ ಟd
(with
ಪಮF ೆಂa
Q ೇFಶಕರು
ಾ ಂಶು ಾಲರು
post
ಷರತು2 ಮತು2 Qಬಂಧ ೆಗಳO
1) ,ೇತನ Qಗ ೕಕರಣ ಸೂತ :
6 ೇ
ೇಂದ ,ೇತನ ಆ‰ೕಗವT j–ಾರಸುEJಾS
Qಗ ೕಕರಣ
ಸೂತ ವನು/
@ೋಧಕವಗFದವರ
ೇಂದ ಸ ಾFರವT ಒq• ೊಂSರುವ ,ೇತನ
,ೇತನವನು/
ಪ&ಷ•ತ
,ೇತನ
Cೆ ೕ+ಯ<=
Qಗ ೕಕರಣ ಾfL ಅನುಬಂಧ-1 &ಂದ 4 ರವ& ೆ ಇರುವಂDೆ ಅಳವS( ೊಳ:ತಕfದು.
11) ಾಲಬದ{ ಪ ೋನ/ (TBP)
ಅ) ಸ ಾಯಕ ಾ ಾ ಪಕರು :ಅ ೇ ಹು ೆಯ<= 5 ವಷFಗಳ 0ೇ,ೆ ಸ<=( ಎಂ.(.ಐ JಾಘFಸೂtಯ<=
ಸಹ ಾ ಾ ಪಕರ ಹು ೆ ೆ ಪ ೋನ/
ೆ Qಗ ಪS(ರುವ ಎIಾ= ಷರತು2 ಮತು2 CೈŠ+ಕ ಅಹFDೆಗಳನು/
ೊಂ ದ<= ಬS2 Qೕಡಲು Aಾ< ಹು ೆ ಲಭ ಲ= ದ?ೆ ಅವ& ೆ ಸಹ
Cೆ ೕ+ಯನು/ QೕಡIಾಗುವTದು. ಆದ?ೆ ಅವರು ಸ ಾಯಕ
ಾ ಾ ಪಕರ ಹು ೆಯ ,ೇತನ
ಾ ಾ ಪಕರ ಹು ೆಯ<=˜ೕ ಮುಂದುವ&ದು
ಾಯFQವF•ಸತಕfದು
ಆ) ಸಹ
ಾ ಾ ಪಕರು ಆ ೇ ಹು ೆಯ<= 10ವಷFಗಳ 0ೇ,ೆ ಸ<=( ಎಂ.(.ಎ JಾಗFಸೂtಯ<=
ಾ ಾ ಪಕ ಹು ೆ ೆ ಪ ೋನ/
ೆ Qಗ ಪS(ರುವ ಎIಾ= ಷರತು2 ಮತು2 CೈŠ+ಕಹFDೆಗಳನು/
ೊಂ ದ<= ಬS2 Qೕಡಲು Aಾ< ಹು ೆ ಳಭ ಲ= ದ<= ಅವ& ೆ ಾ ಾ ಪಕರ ಹು ೆ ೆ ಅನ)ಯ,ಾಗುವ
CೈŠ+ಕ
ೆ ೕe ,ೇತನ (AGP ) ವನು/ QೕಡIಾಗುವTದು. ಆದ?ೆ ಅವರು ಸಹ
ಾ ಾ ಪಕರ
ಹು ೆಯ<=˜ೕ ಮುಂದುವ&ದು ಾಯF QವF•(ರತಕfದು.
ಇ)
ಾಂಕ 19.05.2007 ರ ಸ ಾF& ಆ ೇಶ ಸಂAೆ :ಅಕುಕ 2007 ಎಂಎಂ( 2006ರ<= QೕSರುವ
ಅವೃ 2 ಭDೆ ಯ (Non Practicing Allowance ) ಐtuಕ,ಾL ಮುಂದುವ?ೆಯತಕfದು ಮತು2 ಸದ&
ಆ ೇಶದ<= ಮಂಜೂ?ಾLರುವ ಇDೆ 0ೌಲಭ ಗಳO
ಾಂಕ 01.04.2011&ಂದ ರ ಾLರತ2 ೆ.
iii) ,ಾšFಕ ,ೇತನ ಬS2:
ಪ
,ಾšFಕ ,ೇತನ ಬS2ಯ ದರವT pay band ಮತು2 AGP ನ<= ಪ^ೆಯುವ ಒಟುY ಮೂಲ ,ೇತನದ Cೇ
3 ೆf ಸಮ ಾLರತಕfದು
iv) ಭDೆ ಗಳO
ಮ ೆ >ಾS ೆ ಭDೆ ಮತು2 ನಗರ ಪ& ಾರ ಭDೆ 0ೇ&ದಂDೆ ಎIಾ= ಇತ?ೆ ಭDೆ ಗಳO ?ಾಜ ಸ ಾF&
ೌಕರ& ೆ Qೕಡು 2ರುವ ದರಗಳ<=
ಾಂಕ 01.04.2011 &ಂದ ಲಭ ,ಾಗತಕfದು.
v) ತುXY ಭDೆ
ಪ&ಷ•ತ
ಐ ( X ಇ ,ೇತನ Cೆ ೕ+ಯ<=
ಾಂಕ 01.04.2011 &ಂದ ಮೂಲ ,ೇತನ Cೇ 51 ರಷುY
ಮತು2 01.07.2011 &ಂದ Cೇ 58 ರಷುY ತುXY ಭDೆ ೆ ಅಹF&ರುDಾ2?ೆ.
vi) ವ‰ೕ Qವೃ 2 ವಯಸುE
ಇತ?ೆ ?ಾಜ ಸ ಾF& ೌಕರ& ೆ ಅನ)~ಸುವಂDೆ ವ‰ೕ Qವೃ 2 ವಯಸುE 60 ವಷF ೆf
ಮುಂದುವ?ೆಯತಕfದು
vii) ›ಾ& ೊWಸುವ
ಾಂಕ:
ಪ&ಷ•ತ ಎಐ(Xಇ ,ೇತನ Cೆ ೕ+ಗಳನು/
ಾಂಕ 01.04.2011 &ಂದ ಸ2&ಸIಾಗುವTದು
ಈ ಆ ೇಶವನು/ ಆNFಕ ಇIಾAೆಯ ಅನ ಕೃತ Xಪ•+ ಸಂAೆ : ಆಇ 16 ಎn ಆd q 2011
ಾಂಕ 05.03.2011 ಮತು2 ಸಂAೆ : ಆಇ 519
ೇ 2/2011
ಾಂಕ 07.12.2011ರ<= QೕSರುವ
ಸಹಮ Hೕ?ೆ ೆ ೊರSಸIಾL ೆ.
ಕ ಾFಟಕ ?ಾಜ ಾಲರ ಆ ೇCಾನು0ಾರ
ಮತು2 ಅವರ ೆಸ&ನ<=
ಸ•/(ಎ. ೆ.@ೈರಪ•)
ಸ ಾFರದ ಅ ೕನ ಾಯFದjF-2
ಆ?ೋಗ ಮತು2ಕುಟುಂಬ ಕIಾ ಣ ಇIಾAೆ
(,ೈದ 7ೕಯ jŠಣ)”
The Government order would indicate that persons who are eligible
to be promoted to the next higher cadre and if the vacancy is not
subsisting, they must be granted time bound promotion till the
vacancy would arise. The petitioner claims that she has to be
granted promotion from a date anterior to the actual date of
promotion i.e., with effect from 16-10-2023.
The petitioner’s
representation is yet to be considered. Therefore, a mandamus is
sought to consider the said representation for grant of seniority or
removing the remark in the seniority list dated 10-02-2023 of
Associate Professor and settle the position of seniority between the
petitioner and respondent No.4.
11. It is ununderstandable as to how the Institute has not yet
settled the seniority between the two and even now a remark is
available in the seniority list that the seniority in the cadre of
Associate Professor between the two is pending consideration.
Therefore, it becomes necessary to consider the case of the
petitioner, strictly in consonance with the Government Orders dated
16-12-2011 as modified on 12-02-2013, determine the seniority,
draw up an appropriate seniority list and regulate the promotion
and consequential seniority in the cadre of Professor, taking note of
the judgment rendered by the learned single Judge of this Court,
which has admittedly become final.
12. For the aforesaid reasons, the following: ORDER
(i)
Writ Petition is partly allowed.
(ii)
Mandamus issues to respondent Nos.2 & 3/Institute
to consider the claim of the petitioner in consonance
with two Government orders dated 16-12-2011 as
modified on 12-02-2013 and consider the date of
promotion with effect from 06-08-2022, as sought in
the representations and grant all consequential
benefits that would flow from such consideration.
(iii)
While considering the claim of the petitioner, the
observations of the learned single Judge in the
judgment quoted supra shall be borne in mind.
(iv)
The Institute shall endeavour to settle the dispute
and not drive the petitioner or the fourth respondent
back to the doors of this Court with the same cause
of action.
(v)
The aforesaid action shall be complied with within
four months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.
SD/-
(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE
bkp
CT:MJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review