Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010080222024
2026:UHC:6277-DB
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition Service Bench No. 292 of 2024
23 July, 2026
Dr. Neelam Arya
--Petitioner
Versus
Uttarakhand Public Service Commission & another
--Respondents
With
Writ Petition Service Bench No.319 of 2024
Dr. Suman Lata Pal
--Petitioner
Versus
Uttarakhand Public Service Commission & another
--Respondents
---------------------------------------------------------------------Presence:Mr. Imraj Singh Rautela, learned counsel for the petitioners.
Mr. S.S. Chaudhary, learned Standing Counsel for the State.
Mr. Ashish Joshi, learned counsel for the respondent no.2Commission.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Coram : Hon’ble Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J.
Hon’ble Pankaj Purohit, J.
Hon’ble Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J. (Oral)
Since common questions of law and facts are
involved in both these writ petitions, they are being heard
together
and
decided
by
this
common
judgment.
However, for the sake of brevity, facts of WPSB No.292 of
2024 alone are being considered.
2.
Petitioner belongs to Scheduled Caste Category. Her
candidature for appointment as Assistant Professor
(Chemistry) was rejected by Uttarakhand Public Service
Commission (hereinafter referred to as “Commission”)
UKHC010080222024
2026:UHC:6277-DB
only on the ground that her Ph.D. Degree is in
Agricultural Chemicals, while the post for which she
applied is Assistant Professor (Chemistry). It is not in
dispute
that
petitioner
possesses
M.Sc.
Degree
in
needed
appointment
as
Chemistry.
3.
The
Assistant
qualifications
Professor
in
for
Government
Degree/Post-
Graduate Colleges, as mentioned in the advertisement
issued by respondent no.1 on 04.12.2021 are almost
similar to the one prescribed by UGC Regulations on
Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of Teachers and
Other Academic Staff in Universities, 2018, notified on
18.07.2018, with the difference that as per UGC
Regulations, every candidate has to secure minimum
55% marks in Master’s Degree, while advertisement
issued by respondent no.1 provides that candidates
belonging to SC/ST/OBC/persons with disabilities would
be eligible if they have scored 50% or more marks in
Master’s Degree Programme.
4.
Qualifications needed for the post of Assistant
Professor, as mentioned in the advertisement, are as
follows:“4. “kSf{kd ,ao vf/kekuh vgZrk;sa%&
4(1)¼1½ “kSf{kd vgZrk;sa %&
I. For the Disciplines of Arts, Commerce, Humanities,
Education, Law, Social Sciences, Sciences, Languages,
Library Science, Physical Education, and Journalism & Mass
Communication.
Eligibility (A or B):
A. (i) A Master’s degree with 55% (50% in case of SC/ST/OBC
(non-creamy layer)/Person with Disabilities) marks (or an
equivalent grade in a point-scale wherever the grading system
is followed) in a concerned/relevant/allied subject from an
Indian University, or an equivalent degree from an accredited
foreign university.
(ii) Besides fulfilling the above qualifications, the candidate
UKHC010080222024
2026:UHC:6277-DB
must have cleared the National Eligibility Test (NET)
conducted by the UGC or the CSIR, or a similar test accredited
by the UGC, like SLET/SET or who are or have been awarded
a Ph. D. Degree in accordance with the University Grants
Commission (Minimum Standards and Procedure for Award of
M.Phil./Ph.D. Degree) Regulations, 2009 or 2016 and their
amendments from time to time as the case may be exempted
from NET/SLET/SET:”
5.
According to petitioner, she applied for the post of
Assistant Professor (Chemistry) in response to the
advertisement and she was shortlisted for interview by
respondent No. 1 by giving due credit to her Ph.D degree.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner points out that
the candidates were shortlisted based on their API
(Academic
Performance
Indicator)
score
and
only
shortlisted candidates were called for interview and no
written examination was held. Petitioner has challenged
order
dated
22.05.2024
passed
by
Secretary,
Uttarakhand Public Service Commission whereby she
was declared ineligible for interview for the reason that
Ph.D degree possessed by her is not in the concerned
subject i.e. Chemistry.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that as
per clause 4(1)IA(i) of the advertisement, possessing
Master’s degree in concerned/relevant/allied subject with
minimum 55% marks (50% for weaker sections) is
necessary; however, candidates who possess Ph.D degree
awarded as per UGC (Minimum Standards and Procedure
for Award of M.Phill./Ph.D. Degree) Regulations, 2009 or
2016 are exempted from requirement of clearing National
Eligibility Test (NET) and NET qualification would be
necessary only for candidates who do not possess Ph.D.
degree awarded in terms of UGC Regulations 2009 or
2016.
UKHC010080222024
2026:UHC:6277-DB
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits
that
in
sub-clause
(ii)
of
Clause
4(1)IA
of
the
advertisement, there is nothing to indicate that NET or
Ph.D degree has to be in the concerned subject, and all
that is required is that a candidate should have either
cleared NET conducted by UGC/CISR or he should
possess Ph.D degree awarded in accordance with UGC
Regulations, 2009. He thus submits that when the
advertisement recognizes anyone with Ph.D degree as
eligible for appointment, then the Commission cannot
read some additional qualification in sub-clause (ii) of the
advertisement for holding petitioner to be ineligible for
appointment. He submits that Ph.D degree in the
concerned subject is not required at all as per the
advertisement.
9.
He further submits that UGC Regulations, 2018
which lay down the minimum qualification needed for
appointment as teacher in universities also, while
providing
that
Master’s
degree
has
to
be
in
the
concerned/relevant/allied subject, has not imposed any
condition regarding subject of Ph.D degree. He submits
that as per UGC Regulations 2018, Ph.D. degree should
be awarded as per UGC Regulation, 2009.
10. It is not in dispute that petitioner was awarded
Ph.D.
degree
as
per
UGC
Regulation,
2009.
The
certificate issued by G.B. Pant University of Agriculture
and Technology, Pant Nagar is enclosed as Annexure-3 to
the writ petition, which certifies that petitioner was
awarded Ph.D degree as per UGC Regulation, 2009. It is
not the case of the Commission that M.Sc degree in
UKHC010080222024
2026:UHC:6277-DB
Chemistry possessed by petitioner does not meet the
requirement of advertisement. The only ground taken for
rejecting her candidature is that her Ph.D degree is not in
the concerned subject.
11. The
stand taken by learned counsel for the
Commission is that Ph.D degree possessed by petitioner
was in a different subject, therefore, the question of
equivalence of Ph.D in Agricultural Chemicals with Ph.D
in Chemistry subject was referred to Director, Higher
Education; Director in his letter dated 25.07.2022 opined
that curriculum of Agricultural Chemicals and Chemistry
subject is different, therefore, petitioner was declared
ineligible for the post of Assistant Professor (Chemistry).
12. We do not approve of the manner in which
petitioner’s claim for employment under the State was
dealt with by the Commission. A plain reading of relevant
clause of the advertisement dealing with academic
qualifications
candidate
indicates
to
that
possess
it
is
necessary for
Master’s
degree
a
in
concerned/relevant/allied subject; however, for Ph.D
degree there is no such requirement and the only
requirement is that it should be awarded as per UGC
Regulations, 2009 or 2016.
13. State Government has adopted UGC Regulations for
appointment of teachers in Government Colleges. As per
UGC Regulation 2018, anyone with Ph.D degree awarded
as per UGC Regulations is eligible if he/she meets the
condition
of
having
Master’s
degree
in
concerned/relevant/allied subject with 55% marks. The
advertisement issued by respondent No. 1 and also the
UKHC010080222024
2026:UHC:6277-DB
UGC Regulation, 2018 are absolutely silent regarding
subject of Ph.D degree. When UGC Regulation, 2018 is
silent regarding subject of Ph.D degree and so is the
advertisement
issued
by
respondent
No.
1,
then
Commission cannot read some additional condition of
eligibility in sub-clause (ii) of Clause 4(1)IA of the
advertisement for holding petitioner as ineligible.
14. Since there was no ambiguity in the advertisement
regarding academic qualification, as such, the reference
made by respondent No. 1 to Director, Higher Education
on the question of eligibility of the petitioner was totally
uncalled for. Such reference could have been made if
there was a doubt regarding Master’s degree possessed
by petitioner and its equivalence with the qualification
needed for appointment to the post of Assistant Professor
(Chemistry). Whether Director Higher Education can be
treated as expert to answer the query raised by the
Commission is a debatable issue which is left open to be
decided in a appropriate case.
15. As
per
settled
principles
governing
public
employment, eligibility conditions must be read strictly
as advertised, and neither the State nor the selecting
body can change conditions of eligibility after initiation of
selection process. A fortiori, State or the Commission
cannot
misinterpret
the
eligibility
conditions
as
mentioned in the advertisement to deny a fair right of
consideration to a qualified candidate. An applicant who
meets the notified eligibility criteria, cannot be denied the
right to be considered for appointment under the State
on the whims of the selecting body.
UKHC010080222024
2026:UHC:6277-DB
16. State Public Service Commission is a specialized
body entrusted with the task of holding fair selection for
State services. It is the responsibility of the Commission
to ensure that equality of opportunity is given to
candidates and selection for appointment is made purely
on merit and no one is denied the right to be considered
for appointment if he meets the eligibility conditions.
17. The
Commission,
therefore,
cannot
alter
core
eligibility conditions midway through an active selection
process, as it violates the constitutional guarantee of
equal opportunity. Fairness in action demands that
recruitment terms and essential qualifications must be
read by selecting bodies literally, and they cannot be
stretched or rewritten to unjustly include or exclude
candidates.
18. In the present case, Commission has rewritten the
condition
of
eligibility
by
reading
requirement
of
‘concerned/relevant/allied subject’ even in respect of
Ph.D degree, while the advertisement is silent on that
aspect. Subject is relevant regarding Master’s degree
only. This has resulted in denial of valuable right to be
considered for public employment to the petitioner.
19. Pursuant to order passed by Co-ordinate Bench on
06.11.2025,
issue
of
equivalence
of
qualification
possessed by petitioner with the qualification needed was
referred to Equivalence Committee constituted by State
Government. Report of Equivalence Committee is on
record as annexure-3 to the supplementary counter
affidavit
dated
Commission.
13.03.2026
Equivalence
filed
on
Committee
behalf
of
the
examined
the
UKHC010080222024
2026:UHC:6277-DB
matter in detail and declared that petitioner meets the
conditions of eligibility for appointment as Assistant
Professor (Chemistry).
20. We are pained by the manner in which petitioner
was denied permission to participate in the selection
process by misreading the conditions of eligibility.
21. In view of the above discussion, we hold that
rejection of petitioner’s candidature for appointment to
the position of Assistant Professor (Chemistry) is patently
illegal. Both the writ petitions are allowed with cost of Rs.
1 lakh each, payable to the petitioners within four weeks.
Respondent No. 1 is directed to undo the injustice caused
to
petitioners
appointment
by
assessing
against
left
over
their
suitability
vacancies
and
for
to
recommend their name to the State Government, if found
suitable.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
(Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J.)
23.07.2026
AK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review