Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 10th August, 2026
Uploaded on: 13th August, 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC011763132016
+
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
DR SP PARASHAR
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Rajiv Nanda, Sr. Adv. with Mr.
Manish Kumar, Mr. Vikkey and Mr.
Loveleen Kaithwas, Advs.
versus
REGISTRAR COOPERATIVE SOCIETIES
AND ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Rachita Garg. Adv. for R-1.
Ms. Manika Tripathy SC for DDA,
Mr. Aman Kumar, Adv. for DDA.
Mr. S. K. .Sharma, Adv for R-2
Society.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE VIKAS MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
Prathiba M. Singh, J.
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present writ petition has been filed by Dr. S.P. Parashar, wife of
Dr. C. D. Parashar, seeking the following reliefs:“a) Issue appropriate writ and directions quashing
setting aside the impugned order dated 18.11.2010,
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
passed by Ld Financial commissioner Delhi, in Case No
322/2001-CA.
b) Issue appropriate writ and directions to hold, that
cancellation of membership of Respondent no. 3 by
order dated 19-11-2001, was illegal and bad.
c) Pass any other order or orders or writs or directions
which are necessary in the facts of the case and
d) Allow the present Petition with costs.”
Factual Background
3.
The background of this case is that sometime in 1995 the Respondent
No. 3 - Dr Jitender Rai had applied for the membership of Suraksha Sadhan
CGHS Limited, also known as Krishna Apartments, (hereinafter “the
Society”). At the initial stage, Dr. Jitender Rai was given a share certificate
dated 10th November 1995, bearing serial number SS/024, and thereafter Flat
No. 210 in the Society was allotted to him on 3 rd April 1999.
4.
After the allotment, Dr. Jitender Rai was issued a Show Cause Notice
by the Registrar of Cooperative Societies (hereinafter “RCS”) on 19th
November 1999. The allegation in the said notice was that the allotment to
Dr. Jitender Rai was liable to be cancelled under Rule 25 of the Delhi Cooperative Rules, 1973 (hereinafter “DCS Rules, 1973”), on the ground that the
spouse of Dr Jitender Rai already owned a property in Delhi bearing A-1/35,
Panchshilla Enclave, New Delhi.
5.
The said show cause notice was replied to by Dr. Jitender Rai and the
stand taken by him was that he had not incurred any disqualification as his
wife had obtained the said property in Panchshilla Enclave, in her own right
and with her own funds, as she was working as a nursing officer with the
Director General Health Services, Govt. of India. On the other hand, Dr.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
Jitender Rai himself had enrolled as a member of the Society in his own right
and had paid all the dues to the Society from his own funds. Thus, the stand
of Dr. Jitender Rai was that the property of his wife at Panchshilla was not a
benami property and was a property purchased by his wife from her own
earnings. In support thereof, certain documents were also submitted by Dr.
Jitender Rai.
6.
The RCS, however, vide order dated 19th November, 2001, cancelled
the membership of Dr. Jitender Rai on various grounds. The said order of the
RCS was challenged before the Financial Commissioner. Initially, the
Financial Commissioner had stayed the impugned order of the RCS on 22 nd
January, 2002. However, the Society appears to have written a letter dated 21 st
January, 2002 to the DDA informing the DDA of the order of RCS dated 19th
November, 2001 cancelling the membership of Dr. Jitender Rai. Pursuant
thereto, the DDA had cancelled the allotment of flat to Dr. Jitender Rai on
11th April, 2002. This cancellation was, however, not in the knowledge of the
Petitioner or Dr. Jitender Rai at the relevant point in time.
7.
During the pendency of the appeal before the Financial Commissioner,
Dr. Jitender Rai sold the subject flat in the Society to Dr. C.D. Parashar who
in turn sold it to his wife - Dr. S.P. Parashar i.e., the Petitioner herein. The
documents which were executed in favour of the Petitioner were General
Power of Attorney, Special Power of Attorney, Will, and an Agreement to
Sell. It is stated that the Petitioner was not aware of the letter issued by the
Society to the DDA, at the time when the flat was purchased.
8.
The appeal was finally decided by the Financial Commissioner almost
8 years later and vide order dated 18th November, 2010, the Financial
Commissioner upheld the order passed by the RCS cancelling the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
membership of Dr. Jitender Rai.
9.
Thereafter, certain execution proceedings were filed by the Society
seeking to give effect to the cancellation of membership. In the said execution
proceedings, summons were issued to the Petitioner who then acquired
knowledge of the DDA cancelling the membership of Dr. Jitender Rai. The
Petitioner filed objections before the RCS opposing the execution which was
also rejected on 26th October, 2012.
10.
Further to the above, a review application was filed by the Petitioner
against the order of the RCS dismissing the Petitioner’s objections, which was
also allowed vide order dated 3rd February 2014. In the said review order, the
RCS came to the conclusion that there was no proof on record to show that
Dr. Jitender Rai was owning the flat in Panchshilla Enclave as benami in the
name of his wife. In the review order dated 3rd February 2014, the RCS
observed as under:“23. I have carefully read the aforesaid judgments and
the order dt. 19.11.2001 passed by the Registrar. All the
aforesaid judgment clearly lay down that the
disqualification under Rule 25 of DCS Rules, 1973 shall
be applicable only in those cases where the member has
some immovable property out of his/her funds only. It is
clear from the reading of those judgments of the high
Court that the same were squarely applicable in the case
of Dr. Jitender Rai as there was no allegation or proof
on record to show that Dr. Jitender Rai was owning
that flat in Panchshila Enclave benami in the name of
his wife or had contributed to the purchase of the said
flat. In fact the wife of Dr. Jitender Rai was admittedly
working and had her own source of Income/funds
through which she had purchased the said Flat in her
name, thus, there was no valid reason or material on
record against the member/Dr. Jitender Rai to indicate
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
that they had incurred any disqualification us/ 25 of
DCS rules, 1973.
24. That the objector has argued that since the orders
dt. 19.11.2001 and 18.10.2010 passed by the Registrar
as well as financial Commissioner ceasing the
membership of the Original member Dr. Jitender Rai
were contrary to the settled law laid down in the above
mentioned judgments of the Hon'ble High Court (one of
the judgment of Alimuddin was also upheld by Hon’ble
Supreme Court by dismissing SLP filed against that
judgment) the same are per incuriam and as such not
valid and binding and are liable to be ignored. The
objector has filed the judgment of SC to show that if an
order is passed in ignorance of some law or settled
precedents of superior court the same is called per
incuriam and is not of binding effect.
25. After considering all the submissions and
documents on records that I am of the considered view
that the orders dt. 19.11.2001 and dt. 18.102.10 (sic)
passed by the Registrar as well as Financial
Commissioner ceasing the membership of the original
member Dr. Jitender Rai cannot be legally executed as
the same said orders are contrary to the law laid down
by the Hon'ble High Court and thus per Incuriam to
the said binding judgments. Such Court cannot be
executed against the objector who is a bonafide
purchaser against consideration without any
knowledge of any previous proceedings.
26. The present application for execution of the said per
incuriam orders is misconceived and is liable to be
rejected. I accordingly dismiss the application for
application for execution filed by DH/Society.”
11.
Thus, the execution proceedings filed by the Society were dismissed.
The Society assailed the said order by filing a writ petition before this Court
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
being Writ Petition (Civil) 3087/2014. In the said writ petition, the RCS had
filed an affidavit dated 23rd February 2015.
12.
The said writ petition filed by the Society was finally decided on 21 st
September, 2016 in which the Court observed that the Petitioner could not
challenge the Financial Commissioner’s order in the execution proceedings.
The observations of the Court are set out below:“10. The judgment in the case of Dhurandhar Prasad
Singh (supra) does not support the submissions made by
the learned counsel for Dr. (Mrs.) S.P. Parashar.
Rather, it would show that the Supreme Court had
observed that an executing court can allow objections
under Section 47 of the Code as to executability of the
decree if the decree is found to be void ab initio or a
nullity. A decree can become inexecutable for the reason
that the decree was passed in ignorance of such a
provision of a law or the law was subsequently
promulgated making a decree inexecutable after its
passing. The aforesaid observations do not lay down a
ratio that a decision passed on merits would be held to
be inexecutable because as per the executing court the
decision was incorrect and contrary to law. The word
“inexecutable” referred to in paragraph 23 in the case
of Dhurandhar Prasad Singh (supra) would mean and
refer to a decree passed by a court which is non est or a
nullity on account of the fact that such a decree could
not have been passed for want of subject matter
jurisdiction. This can happen when the decision is in
ignorance of a provision of law by a forum or a court
lacking jurisdiction. Subsequent legislation may also
render a decree inexecutable. The Financial
Commissioner admittedly had jurisdiction to decide the
appeal filed by Dr. Jitender Rai under Section 76 of the
Act. The jurisdiction was invoked by Dr. Jitender Rai,
himself. A wrong or erroneous decision is not non est or
a decision without jurisdiction. The plea of Dr. (Mrs.)
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
S.P. Parashar is completely fallacious and contrary to
law and, therefore, has to be rejected. To this extent,
the observations and findings made in the order dated
3rd February, 2014 are set aside and deleted. The
Assistant Registrar (South) as an executing court will
proceed in accordance with law.
11. Dr. (Mrs.) S.P. Parashar has filed objections to the
execution of the decree. She has right to press her
objections as per the provisions of the law and the
applicable Act/Rules. Dr. (Mrs.) S.P. Parashar can
claim her rights in an individual capacity, predicated as
purchaser under the purported Agreement to sell dated
15th June, 2006 and also on the basis that she is in
occupation of the flat in question. Questions of bona
fides etc. may arise and if required, would be decided.
We would not like to go into and examine the said
aspects. The objections, if any, by Dr. (Mrs.) S.P.
Parashar will be confined to the aforesaid and cannot
pertain to the merits or correctness of the orders of the
Registrar, Cooperative Societies and the Financial
Commissioner. The order dated 18th November, 2010
passed by the Financial Commissioner cannot be
challenged or questioned by Dr. (Mrs.) S.P. Parashar
in the executing proceedings.
12. The writ petition is allowed in the aforesaid terms.
We clarify that the observations made above, would not
in any manner affect the challenge made to the order
dated 18th November, 2010 by Dr. (Mrs.) S.P.
Parashar in W.P.(C) No.6435/2016. We observe that
the ambit and scope of W.P. (C) 6435/2016 is
different.”
13.
As is evident from the above, the ld. Division Bench of this Court
clarified that the challenge to the order dated 18th November, 2010 of the
Financial Commissioner in the present petition would not be affected by the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
findings in the above order passed in W.P.(C) 3087/2014.
14.
Coming back to the present petition vide order dated 21st September,
2016 i.e., on the same day when the W.P.(C) 3087/2014 was disposed of, the
Division Bench had also directed that no coercive steps shall be taken for
recovery of physical possession subject to an undertaking in the following
terms:
“W.P.(C) 6435/2016
Issue notice returnable on 30th November, 2016.
Counter affidavit will be filed by the Registrar,
Cooperative Societies within four weeks. Rejoinder, if
any, will be filed within four weeks thereafter.
C.M.No.26381/2016
Having heard learned counsel for the petitioner, it is
directed that no coercive steps for recovery of physical
possession of the property in question would be taken
till the next date of hearing.
Dr. S.P. Parashar, however, will file an affidavit giving
undertaking to the Court that she will not alienate,
transfer or enter into any agreement to sell with third
parties in respect of the property in question till the
disposal of the present application. If the property is
already given on rent, name of the tenant and the rent
being received will be indicated and stated. The said
affidavit/undertaking will be filed within two weeks from
today. In case. Dr. S.P. Parashar wants to enter into a
fresh tenancy agreement, the same will be done after
taking permission of the Court. We clarify that no third
party rights would be created or accepted during the
pendency of the present writ
petition.
File of W.P.(C) No. 3087/2014 will tagged with the
present writ petition.
Relist the application on 30th November, 2016.”
15.
Presently, in this writ petition, the following aspects deserve to be
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
considered:i)
Whether the Petitioner is disqualified from allotment of the flat
due to the cancellation of the membership of Dr. Jitender Rai?
ii)
Whether the Petitioner is entitled to an NOC from the Society for
allotment of the flat in her favour?
Submissions of the parties
16.
Mr. Nanda, ld. Sr. Counsel and Mr. Sharma, ld. Counsel have made
their submissions for the Petitioner and the Society, respectively.
17.
The submission of Mr. Nanda, ld. Sr. Counsel is that the initial
disqualification against Dr. Jitender Rai is itself not attracted inasmuch as the
wife of Dr. Rai had her own source of income and had purchased the
Panchshilla Enclave property in her own right. He has taken the Court through
certain documents which form part of proceedings before the Financial
Commissioner wherein Mrs. Raj Kumari Sood, wife of Dr. Jitender Rai, had
sought permission from the Income Tax Department to purchase the property
in Panchshilla Enclave. Secondly, the documents would also show that a Reconveyance deed was executed in favour of Mrs. Raj Kumar Sood in respect
of land at A-1/35 Panchshila and according to him, these documents would
show clearly that she had entered into the transaction in her own right having
her own independent income.
18.
The second submission is that when the matter was pending before the
Financial Commissioner, the Financial Commissioner had granted a stay
against the RCS order on 22nd January, 2022. However, strangely, one day
before the stay order is granted, the Society claims to have written to the DDA
for cancellation of membership of Dr. Jitender Rai - pursuant to which the
DDA had cancelled the membership.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
19.
It is submitted that the transaction entered into between the Petitioner
and Dr. Jitender Rai was fully protected, as a stay order was operating against
the RCS order and while the said stay order was operating, the membership
could not have been cancelled. Further, it is submitted that the documents
executed in favour of the Petitioner are valid and legal documents inasmuch
as the requirement of a registered agreement to sell or registered sale deed as
per the judgment of the Supreme Court in Suraj Lamp & Industries (P) Ltd.
v. State of Haryana, (2009) 7 SCC 363, would apply only prospectively and
could not apply to a transaction which had taken place prior to rendering of
the said judgment.
20.
The transaction between the Petitioner’s husband and Dr. Jitender Rai,
thus, could not be declared as a bad transaction. Further, reliance is placed
upon the decision in Alimuddin vs. Registrar Co-operative Societies and
Ors., 63 (1996) Delhi Law Times 655 (DB) to argue that the Division Bench
of this Court had made it extremely clear that the disqualification is not
attracted if the property is held bonafidely in the name of the spouse.
21.
Finally, relying on Bardrinath vs. State of Tamil Nadu, AIR 2000 SC
3243 it is argued that since the cancellation of allotment to Dr. Jitender Rai
by the DDA was due to the letter written by the Society to the DDA, relying
upon the order passed by the RCS, which order is still under challenge in this
case, the consequential act of cancellation by the DDA also deserves to be set
aside.
22.
Mr. Nanda, ld. Sr. Counsel also relies upon two documents, one is a
letter issued by the Administrator of the Society - Shri. I.C. Gulati, on 30th
November, 2010, wherein it had been clearly stated that the dues raised
against the Petitioner were duly cleared by her. The second document relied
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
upon by the Petitioner is a certificate issued by the Society dated 8th
December, 2006 wherein the Society had communicated the no objection for
conversion from lease hold to free hold of the said property.
23.
Mr. Sharma, ld. Counsel, on the other hand, appearing for the Society
submits that the document issued by the Administrator dated 30 th November,
2010 is accepted by the Society though the same does not constitute a No
Objection Certificate. Insofar as the certificate dated 8 th December, 2026 is
concerned, Mr. Sharma, ld. Counsel challenges the genuineness and validity
of the said document, as according to him, the signatories on behalf of the
Society in the said document/certificate were not the office bearers at the
relevant point in time i.e., on 8th December, 2006. It is submitted that at the
relevant time the actual office bearers of the Society were: (i) Dr. D. K. Bhola
(President), (ii) Mr. Dinesh Kumar (Hony. Secretary), and (iii) Late Mr. K.R.
Joshi (Treasurer). This is evident from the fact that the said office bearers
were the ones who had signed the balance sheet of the Society for the year
2006-07.
24.
Thus, it is his submission that the second document does not confer any
rights upon the Petitioner. Mr. Sharma, ld. Counsel also submits that insofar
as the decision of this Court in Alimuddin (supra) is concerned, the said
judgment would not apply as it did not deal with properties which are
transferred through a General Power of Attorney/ Special Power of Attorney.
Finally, it is urged that the Petitioner who is depending upon a forged
document ought not to be granted any relief.
25.
Ms. Tripathi, ld. Standing Counsel appearing for the DDA submits that
the DDA’s action of cancelling the allotment of subject flat to Dr. Jitender Rai
was only on the basis of the letter written by the Society on 21 st January, 2002
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
which was seeking to give effect to the RCS order dated 19th November, 2001.
It is submitted by her that the subsequent order of stay granted by the Financial
Commissioner was not in the knowledge of the DDA at the relevant time
when the allotment was cancelled.
Analysis and Findings
26.
Heard. The Court has considered the matter. The main issue in this case,
which has led to so much complication for the last almost 30 years, is whether
the membership of Respondent No. 3 - Dr. Jitender Rai is valid or not and
whether he has suffered any disqualification under Rule 25(1)(c)(i) of the
DCS Rules, 1973 owing to his wife owning a property in Delhi.
27.
Rule 25 of the DCS Rules, 1973 which is at the core of the issue in this
matter is extracted below:
“25.
Disqualification
of
Membership
1. No person shall be eligible for admission as a member
of a co-operative society if he…
(a) has applied to be adjudicated an insolvent or is an
undischarged insolvent; or
(b) has been sentenced for any offence other than an
offence of a political character or an offence not
involving moral turpitude and dishonesty and a period
of five years has not elapsed from the date of expiry of
the sentence:
(c) in the case of membership of a housing society:(i) he owns a residential house or a plot of land for the
construction of a residential house in any of the
approved or un-approved colonies or other localities in
the Union Territory of Delhi, in his own name or in the
name of his spouse or any of his dependent children,
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
on leasehold or freehold basis provided that
disqualification as laid down in sub-rule (1) (c) (i) shall
not be applicable in case of persons who are only cosharers of joint ancestral properties in congested
localities (slum areas) whose share is less than 66.72 sq.
metres
(80
sq.
yards)
of
land:
(ii) he deals in purchase or sale of immovable properties
either as principal or as agent in the Union Territory of
Delhi; or
(iii) he or his spouse or any of his dependent children is
a member of any other housing society except otherwise
permitted by the Registrar.
2. Notwithstanding anything contained in the rules or
the bye-laws of the co-operative society, if a member
becomes, or has already become, subject to any
disqualification specified in sub-rule (1), he shall be
deemed to have ceased to be a member from the date
when
the
disqualifications
were
incurred.
3. A member who ceases to be a member of a cooperative society under sub-rule (2), shall not be
entitled to exercise rights of memberships or incur
liability as member with effect from the date referred to
in sub-rule (2) but as from the date he becomes a
creditor of the co-operative society in respect of the
amount due to him on account of paid up share capital,
deposit, cost of land deposited or any other amount paid
by him to the co-operative society as its member. As
from the date of his ceasing to be a member or the
society under sub-rule (2), the amount standing to his
credit shall be paid to him by the co-operative society
within 3 months and when the co-operative society is
already under liquidation, the amount due to him will be
credited as a debt due to a third party from the cooperative society.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
4. If any question as to whether a member has incurred
any of the disqualification referred to in sub-rule (1)
arises, it shall be referred to the Registrar for decision.
His decision shall be final and binding on all concerned.
The power of the Registrar under this rule shall not be
delegated to any other person appointed to assist the
Registrar.”
28.
The above Rule 25(1)(c) has been interpreted by the ld. Division Bench
of this Court in Alimuddin (supra) wherein the Court, after considering the
earlier decisions, has clearly held as under:“5. The learned Counsel for the petitioner has rightly
pointed out that the views of the Registrar and the Lt.
Governor cannot be sustained in the light of at least
three decisions of this Court interpreting the provisions
of Rule, 25(1)(c) and 25(3). These decisions are: O.P.
Sethi v. Lt. Governor, 45 (1991) DLT 426, Navjeevan
Cooperative House Building Society Ltd. v. Delhi Cooperative Tribunal, CWP 3150/85 decided on 10.7.87
and Shri Sita Ram Jain v. Registrar of Co-operative
Societies, CWP 3203/92 decided on 15.11.1995. The
decision in Navjeevan Co-operative House Building
Society Ltd. is the first in point of time and has been
followed in the later two decisions. In that case, a
learned Judge of this Court has held:
“The provisions of Rule 25 in so far as they
disqualify persons from being members of the Cooperative society need to be strictly construed and
unless any person is clearly covered by the
terminologies which are used to disqualify, no
disqualification should attach to such a person.”
“The clear intend of this rule is, therefore, that
those who hold properties “Benami” either in their
wife's name or in the name of their dependent
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
children, were not intended to be permitted to
become a member of the Cooperative House
Building Society.”
6. In O.P. Sethi's case (supra), the Division Bench
has held:
“Rule 25(1)(c) is attracted in those cases where the
properties are held Benami…. the said rule cannot
apply in the cases where properties are acquired by
transmission/devolution.”
7. The view taken by this Court has been that to
attract the applicability of Rule 25(1) (c) (i), the member
of the Society must own a residential house or a plot of
land for the construction of a house in his own name or
in the name of his spouse or a dependent child. The
phrase “in the name of” has been interpreted to mean
the ownership must be of the member though it may
stand Benami in the name of the wife or a child.
8. It was submitted by the learned Counsel for the
Society that interpretation placed by this Court is too
narrow an interpretation and is not in consonance with
continuance of the underlying objective of the provision.
It is difficult to appreciate his contention. The
interpretation placed by this Court was so placed in the
year 1987 and has held the field till now. If the rule
framing authority be of the opinion that the language of
the rule as interpreted by this Court was not serving the
object sought to be achieved, then it was for the
authority to have amended the rule so as to bring it in
conformity with the object sought to be achieved. We see
no reason to take a view different from what has been
taken on three occasions by this Court.”
29.
As can be seen from the above, the rationale of Rule 25(1)(c) of the
DCS Rules, 1973 is to prevent a member of a Co-operative Society to own
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
another property Benami in their own name, or their spouse, or their
dependent children. The provision does not debar genuine ownership of a
property by a spouse in his/her own right through their own funds.
30.
It is noted that this decision in Alimuddin (supra) has been upheld by
the Supreme Court vide order dated 3rd April 1998 passed in SLP (Civil) No.
2886/1997 titled Registrar Co-operative Societies & Anr. v. Alimuddin &
Anr..
31.
Further, two co-ordinate benches of this Court have also reiterated the
legal position in Alimuddin (supra). In Jagdish Chander v. Lt. Governor &
Ors., 2009 (112) DRJ 229 the Court has observed as under:“7. In the background of aforesaid facts, we are
required to consider as to whether the petitioner
incurred the disqualification set out in Rule 25(1)(c)(i)
of aforesaid Rules. Before us it was argued that the
disqualification relates to the member owning a
residential house or plot of land in Delhi "in his own
name" or "in the name of his spouse or any of his
dependent children". It was contended that the
ownership of property by the spouse did not mean that
the member would incur a disqualification. Fortunately,
for us, this provision has already been interpreted by
prior Division Benches of this Court. We need to only
refer to the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in
Alimuddin v. The Registrar Co-operative Societies, 63
(1996) DLT 655 (DB). In that decision, the Division
Bench had also considered earlier decisions of this
Court including the Division Bench decision in O.P.
Sethi v. Lt. Governor, 45 (1991) DLT 426. After
considering the said decision, the Division Bench
observed that the view taken by this Court has been that,
to attract the applicability of Rule 25(1)(c)(i), the
member of the society must own a residential house or
a plot of land for the construction of a house in his own
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
name or in the name of his spouse or a dependent child.
The Court further observed that the phrase "in the name
of" has been interpreted to mean the ownership must be
of the member though it may stand benami in the name
of the wife or a child. The Division Bench in Alimuddin's
case observed as under:"We see no reason to take a view different from
what has been taken on three occasions by this
Court."
8. It is, therefore, clear that the present case is covered
by the decision in Alimuddin's case. The property at
Shastri Nagar, even if it is assumed that it is owned by
the petitioner's wife, is owned by her in her own name.
It is not as if the property at Shastri Nagar is actually
owned by the petitioner, though it stands benami in the
name of his wife Smt. Sunita Rani. We may also note that
this is on the assumption that the property is owned by
Smt. Sunita Rani when, in fact, there is no document of
title to establish that the property is actually owned by
her. What she has admitted is only possession of the
property taken on lease. It is well settled that revenue
records and municipal records with regard to mutation
do not confer any title and are not documents of title. To
this extent, the Financial Commissioner has completely
gone wrong in considering that because the petitioner's
wife Smt. Sunita Rani paid house tax and her name was
shown in the municipal records, she was the owner of
the property. There is no conveyance deed and
document of title to establish that Smt. Sunit Rani was,
in fact, the owner of the property.
9. Be that as it may, even if Smt. Sunita Rani was the
owner of the property she would be regarded as being
the owner in her own right and in her own name.
Therefore, it is neither being contended nor it can be
imagined that the property at Shastri Nagar was that of
the petitioner though kept benami in the name of Smt.
Sunita Rani. That being the position, the decision in
Alimuddin’s case clearly covers the present case also.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
32.
The petitioner did not incur any disqualification under
Rule 25(1)(c)(i) of the said Rules as alleged. As a result
of which, he continues to be a member of the society. He
will retain his ranking as per the original seniority list.
The allotment shall be made according to the said
seniority. The writ petition stands allowed to the
aforesaid extent. Parties are left to bear their own
costs.”
Similarly, in W.P.(C) 6843/2024 titled Panna Lal Kapoor Since
Deceased through Legal Representative Parveen Kapoor versus Registrar
for Public Societies and Ors., the same issue was again considered, wherein
the Court held that the disqualification in the said case would also not be
attracted both on the ground that the wife of the member had held the property
in her own name and that the share of the said land was also covered by the
exception.
33.
Coming to the present case, Dr. Jitender Rai's wife, Mrs. Raj Kumar
Sood, was working as a nursing officer with the Director General Health
Services, Govt. of India which is evident from various documents which have
been placed on the record. Being a government servant herself and having
also informed, at the relevant point of time, to the Income Tax Department in
respect of a loan taken by her for acquiring the property, it cannot be said that
Dr. Rai was owning this property in Panchshilla as Benami in the name of his
wife. Dr. Rai’s wife was duly entitled to purchase the property in her own
name from her own sources and upon doing so, no disqualification can be
attracted by Dr. Rai in terms of the interpretation given to Rule 25(1)(c)(i) in
several decisions.
34.
The Financial Commissioner's order dated 18th November, 2010 is,
thus, not sustainable in as much as the Financial Commissioner rejected the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
argument that Mrs. Raj Kumar Sood had bought the property at Panchshilla
Enclave through her own funds and is not dependent on Dr. Rai, on the ground
that the word ‘dependent’ only qualifies children and not the wife. However,
the Financial Commissioner has completely ignored the settled legal position
as discussed above. Thus, the Financial Commissioner's order upholding the
RCS’s order dated 19th November, 2001 deserves to be set aside.
35.
Now coming to the issue whether the two documents, on which the
Petitioner has relied in support of its case, have been issued by the Society or
not. It is not disputed that for some period, the Society appears to have been
under the supervision and management of an administrator - Shri I.C. Gulati.
The said administrator had signed a certificate dated 30th November, 2010
wherein it is clearly certified as under:“This is to certify that based on the record in the office
of the Society and after examining all the original
relevant record/File of Sh. Jitendra Rai S/O Late Sh.
Hakim Rai available in the office of the Society that Flat
bearing No. 210 was allotted to the Sh. Jitendra Raj vide
dated 3rd April 1999 who was holding 21 shares (484504) as per his share certificate serial No. SS/024 dated
10.11.1995.
Later on Sh. Jitendra Rai transferred his Flat bearing
No. 210 in the Society to Dr. C.D.Parasher S/O Late
Sh. Puran Mal R/O, 6-104, Kaushlya Park, Hauz Khas
New
Delhi-110016
through
a
registered
deed/GPA/SPA in the office of sub Registrar-V vide
dated 25.11.2003 with registration No. 10339 in book
No. 4, Vol. No. 2034.
Dr. C.D. Parasher sold the flat under reference vide
dated 15.6.2006 through "Agreement for sale and GPA
to Dr. Surya Prabha Parasher R/O Y-64, Hauz Khas
New Delhi-110016. Society was demanding from the
GPA holder (see letter dated 18.12.2009 etc.) Rs.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
3,13,658/- which she did not pay due to mismanagement/financial irregularitie (sic) etc. in the
society. Now she has written to the undersigned vide
dated 6.8.2010, expressing her willingness to clear the
outstanding issues/dues if any.
Sh. John Mackly examined once again all the relevant
original record of Dr. C.D. Parasher and Dr. Surya
Prabha Parasher and prepared a detailed statement of
account regarding outstanding dues against Flat No.
210.
Sh. John Mackly prepared the detailed statement of
accounts amounting Rs. 2,94,837/- (Tow lacs ninety
four thousands eight hundred and thirty seven only) and
subsequently the GPA holder was communicated to
clear all the dues by 10th Of Sept. 2010. The GPA holder
cleared all the dues as per receipt No. 9831 dated
5.9.2010 and receipt No. 9869 dated 9.9.2010 vide
cheque No.750711 and 672820 amounting Rs. 84,837/and 2,10,000/- respectively drawn an Punjab National
Bank, Mehrauli road New Delhi-110016.”
36.
A perusal of the above certificate would show that the total amount of
Rs. 2,94,837/- towards the outstanding dues were paid and cleared by the
Petitioner, though she had initially objected to the same. Thus, insofar as
clearing of dues is concerned, the Administrator has clearly certified the
clearing of dues by the Petitioner.
37.
Insofar as the document dated 8th December, 2006 is concerned, it is
unclear as to what is the origin of this letter. The stand of the Petitioner is that
the same was filed by the Petitioner in the W.P.(C) 3087/2014 filed by the
Society. It is also not clear as to the identity of the persons who have signed
the said letter as there are no names mentioned except certain signatures.
However, since the Society is disputing the said letter dated 8 th December,
2006, this Court would not venture into deciding whether the said certificate
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
is valid or forged.
38.
Going by the Administrator's letter/certificate itself it is clear that the
dues which were outstanding at the relevant point in time have been cleared
by the Petitioner. The Petitioner's possession of the subject flat has also been
protected by this Court by an interim order passed way back in 2016 i.e., on
21st September, 2016.
39.
Since then the Petitioner has been in possession of the subject flat in
the Society. Today, the President and the Secretary of the Society are present
and there is no submission to the effect that there are any outstanding dues
qua the Petitioner. The Petitioner is stated to be paying all the dues as on date.
40.
Accordingly, in the overall fact and circumstances, once the
disqualification is not attracted qua Dr. Jitender Rai who had initially owned
the subject flat, and the outstanding dues have already been paid, there can be
no good reason for the Society to hold back the no objection certificate for
allotment to the Petitioner.
41.
The cancellation of allotment of the subject flat to Dr. Jitender Rai by
the DDA now remains the outstanding issue. Clearly, the DDA cancelled the
membership at the time when the order of the RCS was stayed by the Financial
Commissioner. Thus, when there was a stay operating in favour of the
Petitioner, the DDA knowingly or unknowingly ought not to have cancelled
the allotment. Moreover, considering that the very basis of the said decision
of DDA i.e., being the order of RCS is held now to be unsustainable by this
Court, the consequential order of the DDA would also have no effect.
42.
Under these circumstances, the cancellation of the allotment to Dr.
Jintender Rai deserves to be set aside as there is no disqualification which has
been attracted in this case as per the settled legal precedents. There are no
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
dues outstanding of the Petitioner to be paid to the Society.
43.
Therefore, the impugned orders passed by the RCS dated 19th
November, 2001 and by the Financial Commissioner dated 18th November,
2010, as also the order of DDA dated 11th April, 2002 are set aside.
44.
The Society is now directed to issue a No Objection Certificate in
favour of the Petitioner and forward the same to the RCS within a period of
two weeks from today. The RCS, upon receiving the no objection certificate,
shall recommend to the DDA for issuing the document of allotment in favour
of the Petitioner within four weeks thereafter.
45.
The DDA shall issue the letter of allotment within four weeks
thereafter. The Petitioner is also free to apply for conversion from lease hold
to free hold as and when the DDA’s portal for conversion becomes active
again, and upon payment of applicable charges, in terms of the conversion
policy, the conversion shall be effected in favour of the Petitioner.
46.
The present petition is allowed and disposed of in the above terms.
Pending applications, if any, are also disposed of.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
VIKAS MAHAJAN
JUDGE
AUGUST 10, 2026/MR/msh
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:19:00
W.P.(C) 6435/2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review